Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Roy Harper - Flat Baroque And Berserk CD (album) cover

FLAT BAROQUE AND BERSERK

Roy Harper

Prog Folk


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
Sean Trane
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Prog Folk
4 stars Third stunning album in a row for Roy Harper, this one goingas the title says bonkers. With Harper dressed as if he was in his coffin, this also Roy's first for the EMI-subsidiary label Harvest and it was producer by Floyd alumni Peter Jenner. Backed up by the three musicians from The Nice, you'd have a hard time to think of this album as folk album, but

Actually the album's general tone is fairly singular folk rock and not necessarily easy to cope with, as Harper is particularly nasal, on top of his usual antics, but most progheads should love the lengthy I Hate The White Man, a poignant thought-provoking song in these Western European empires disappearing days. That track and its similarly-built little brother How Does It Feel are the A-side highlights, the rest being as described at the top of the paragraph.

The flipside start with a slew of shorter tracks resembling the same description in the previous paragraph, before hitting the druggy psych-folk-rock of Tiddler's Ground and later, the fun Hell's Angels, a ditty about the pack's delicious lifestyle, including intimate details.

Certainly not as immediate as Stormcock or Lifemask, FB&B is surely not an easy album and it won't give itself on the first few listens, but it shouldn't put up desperate resistance either. Try the following two or the preceding FJO.

Report this review (#170299)
Posted Friday, May 9, 2008 | Review Permalink
Chris S
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
3 stars A very welcome follow up to Folkjokeopus. Flat Baroque and Beserk is IMO a solid album all round abley backed by The Nice. Tighter arrangements marked the beginning of the 70's decade for Roy Harper that he was being taken more and more seriously. Standout songs are ' Don't You Grieve', the politically sensitive ' I hate the White man' and ' Hell's Angels'. Protest songs were never in short supply from Roy Harper, he sang the the poignant ' South Africa' back in 1973 and was clearly one of the early musical prog pioneers against racism. Three and a half stars.
Report this review (#176031)
Posted Thursday, July 3, 2008 | Review Permalink
4 stars Folk, straight up with a prog chaser.

That's the best way I can describe Flat Baroque and Berserk to someone that's never heard it. There's little folk prog on this album and nothing terribly complicated, but that was the point. FBaB was Harper claiming a solid stake in the folk music world before it's appeal was forever lost to time. Unlike his British contemporaries who took acoustic folk into the world of jazz, blues, middle eastern, Indian, Moroccan and pseudo Elizabethan influences, traditional English folk, along with a 1001 alternate guitar tunings, Harper wears his American folk influences on his sleeve and owes more to Woody Guthrie and Bob Dylan in both song structure and lyrical styles at times.

The lead off track Don't You Grieve is a goof on the lyrics to the Guthrie folk tune Sally Don't You Grieve, but with Roy consoling good old Judas Iscariot, as it was he that had to do the dirty work in order to achieve salvation for mankind. I'm sure that this song is a nod to Nikos Kazantzakis too.

I Hate The White Man is Harper at his socially political best as he lambasts the effects of past white colonization on much of the under developed world and also to Harper's long standing grudge with the apartheid policies that were in place at that time in South Africa. The tune is catchy, but it's over the top in a way that the late Phil Ochs would hit injustices square on the head with very little nuance, but it sounds as sincere as anything ever written and sung by Ochs.

Feeling All the Saturday and Good Bye are poems from Harper's head placed into air with catchy acoustic strums and a vocal delivery that now sounds assured and steady as Harper has dropped the near falsetto that marred sections of Folkjokeopus, the fantastic sprawling epic that was released just one year earlier.

Where we get to the highlights of this album starts with the sublime and ethereal Another Day, which has more gentle acoustic strumming by Roy, but with a magnificent string score by David Bedford that places the listener squarely in the reminiscing and extremely moving frame of mind of Harper, as he recants an old flame that has come to him with the regret that she never had one of his children. Another Day is nothing less than a standard barer for the nascent 'singer songwriter' genre that would soon emerge with the likes for James Taylor and Cat Stevens. Both of whom would shorty go on to produce songs to match Another Day in emotional content, but never bettering it. It is simply one of Harper's finest recorded achievements.

East Of the Sun and Tom Tiddler's Ground both owe a heavy debt to Dylan lyrically as they are both suggestive and metaphorical, but with great accompaniment by harmonica and recorder, respectively, and are also album highlights.

Song Of The Ages sounds just like what it's title implies. It's a beautiful ballad with a harp accompaniment that's played in unison to Roy's gentle guitar lead notes and arpeggios. As with all songs on the album, Harper's vocals are another instrument that accompanies the songs.

The brief Francesca is a thank you from Harper to a free loving woman who has left him, and the subtext of love free of entanglement and guilt is prevalent in many of the songs on Flat Baroque and Berserk, as it seems that the English people were still trying to shake off the well engrained decades old Victorian morals that permeated that era.

Just incase the average rock listener has had an overdose of folk, Harper teams up with The Nice and performs a seven minute bombastic ode to living by one's own rules inside of society on album closer Hell's Angels. Partly filler, the song does rock out with Harper even playing some very good electric guitar in an enthusiastic take that must have been as fun as it sounds. Clappy's to Keith Emerson and company for not disappointing and helping to end the album with a great prog tune.

Flat Baroque and Berserk, if not a high watermark for Harper, is certainly the anchor where his former recorded work led to and where all his future efforts were launched from, including the heralded Stromcock album which followed one year later. While not technically a progressive rock album, I give FBaB the highest possible score that can be awarded to a non prog album, 4 stars.

Report this review (#1471693)
Posted Thursday, October 1, 2015 | Review Permalink
4 stars Although somewhat overshadowed by the magisterial Stormcock, which followed in 1971, Flat Baroque And Berserk is nonetheless an extremely impressive innings from the old cricketer.

Harper's fourth album, and certainly his most consistent up to that point, it was also his first release on what turned out to be a decade long and extremely fruitful association with the EMI Harvest label.

A largely solo acoustic guitar set (a harp accompaniment here, a small string ensemble there) Baroque is packed with strong songs and contains a number of bona fide classics in the Harper canon - the elegiac Another Day, the vitriolic I Hate The White Man.

White Man aside, the prevailing mood is reflective and introspective. There are short and sweet homages to former lovers and to Harper's brother Davey. Harper's best songs sound as though they demanded to be written and, in these sparse arrangements, the songs and his passionate delivery cut straight to the heart.

Baroque rounds off with the raucous Hell's Angels, which does rather shatter the carefully created contemplative mood, but it's a funky enough psychedelically tinged number and Roy, playing electric guitar and backed by the Nice no less, sounds like he's having a great time.

This record is as fresh as the day it was recorded. Roy Harper has written many excellent songs throughout his long career but, in retrospect, the 70s does seem like a golden era for him, producing a steady stream of ageless albums. This was the first of them.

Report this review (#2651696)
Posted Sunday, December 12, 2021 | Review Permalink

ROY HARPER Flat Baroque And Berserk ratings only


chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of ROY HARPER Flat Baroque And Berserk


You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.