Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Moonchild Trio - The Crucible CD (album) cover

THE CRUCIBLE

Moonchild Trio

RIO/Avant-Prog


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
3 stars The fourth of the Moonchild trio (Mike Patton, Trevor Dunn, Joey Baron) shows us that Zorn will continue to experiment and augment the basic line-up. This time we have John Zorn participating as a full member on alto-sax as usual, and Marc Ribot stoping by to lay down guitar on "9x9".

The basic formula remains the same: Joey Baron lays down his amazing, tasteful, complex drum work, Trevor Dunn plays heavily distorted, rhythmic base-lines, which serve as the foundation for most of the songs, and Mike Patton imitates the psychiatric ward with his vocals. Zorn's sax work really shines here. As always when he plays I can't listen to anything else. I enjoy what he's done here more than on the previous album, because while he played almost exclusively in the high resgister on Six Litanies, much of the just emulating Patton's vocals, here we see more of a full repitoire from him. A great dynamic that really fits in perfectly with the music.

Given the description and what you know of John Zorn, you would think this must be pretty avant-garde, obtuse stuff right? What makes this album work so well is that most of the time that assumption is dead wrong. When this album is at its best it's sickeningly catchy. Despite the complexity and the manic vocal and saxophone screaming, this comes off as a fun, mindless, summertime rock album in its feel. Joey Baron in particular performs with incredible groove.

While a majority of the album is as I described, it also has a much different side. Six Litanies was the "creepy" album, and The Crucible seems like it was meant to be the "evil" album. Some tracks really slow down the tempo, are heavier and darker, and feature Patton "singing" passages from the necronomicon of Lovecraft lore. The music certainly achieves its goal of being evil, but I think the album drags in these places. If Zorn continued with the funner side of things this would be a five star album in my mind.

"9x9" is a different track entirely. It features a "Black Dog"-esque guitar riff which the other performes build around. A nice Led Zeppelin tribute and a fine track.

I hope more people check this out as it didn't recieve the attention Six Litanies did. It has some slow points, but when the album moves it's truely great.

Report this review (#257538)
Posted Wednesday, December 23, 2009 | Review Permalink
TCat
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin
4 stars "The Crucible" is John ZORN's MOONCHILD TRIO's fourth album. For those that don't know, this band was formed to some of ZORN's avant garde music, and this album is, as are the others, a combination of improvised jazz, doom metal, modern- classical music and power chord rock. Quite a quirky combination. Along with that, you get the vocal antics of Mike Patton (Faith No More, Tomahawk, Mr. Bungle, etc.) who provides his crazy vocals and also scary readings from dark tomes, Trevor Dunn's heavy bass (Mr. Bungle, Secret Chiefs 3), and avant garde drummer Joey Baron who has worked with Zorn quite often. John Zorn actually becomes part of the band on this album with his alto sax, and Marc Ribot also joins in on the track "9x9".

Right away, "Almadel" shocks you into paying attention as it stars out with Patton screaming at full high-pitched volume, the chunky bass comes in and soon Zorn's sax starts to squeal. It's not too long before the music morphs into a more melodic style that quickly veers off in to maniacal territory and back to melody again. Zorn carries the whole thing along with Patton as they determine the level of craziness to sanity moving from each with the greatest of ease. It's as wild as one would expect. How Patton doesn't blow his voice out is beyond me. His vocals are unbelievable going from wordless squealing and noise to growling recitations. After 5 minutes, the bass finally gets to shine through and the melodic singing returns as it follows Zorn's sax almost note for note. "Shapeshifting" (3:20) begins right away with a catchy bass and drum riff, and Patton begins to carry on, soon tearing all catchiness away and shredding it all to pieces with screaming sax and yelling, but with dark heavy bass and chaotic drums. Ha! For a minute you thought you were going to get into the groove here but everyone sees to it that we won't tolerate dancing here. Patton soon turns into a screaming wild cat and then a cannibalistic chanter.

"Maleficia" begins with a rumbling bass and airy effects probably brought to you by Patton. The music stays dark and forboding, yet quiet until just before 2 minutes before the sax and bass erupt into chaos and then fall back into dark rumblings again. As it goes on, the sax takes over with avant garde style screeching and screaming while the background continues to rumble along, the sax stopping only to let Patton incorporate Gollum-like vocals. "9x9" is definitely quite a bit different as Ribot's guitar adds a more rock-like riff with his guitar controlling things from going entirely off the rails. Of course, Patton sees to it that this not a typical rock song, but Ribot does his best to keep control of the situation. It's a nice (somewhat) change of pace after the chaotic craziness of the rest of the album. This is the closest thing to being commercial, but I doubt you'll ever hear anything like this on the radio anyway as it is hard to sing along with Patton (follow the bouncing ball everyone).

For the most part, the album then returns to the wild antics of before, but expect surprises like the melodic jazz section in "Hobgoblin" or the infectious bass in "Witchfinder". The music is mostly the wild crazy improvisational sound that you have been experiencing so far, but it's more than just noise. Its excellent musicianship and composition, melding together music styles that you wouldn't expect to be melded together.

The album is dedicated to Anonin Artaud, Edgard Varese, and Aleister Crowley. With a dedication like that, you should expect what you are hearing, but if this is your first experience with Moonchild Trio, you won't be ready anyway. But just listen to the layers of talent here, its quite amazing, and very, very unsettling.

Report this review (#2246425)
Posted Monday, August 26, 2019 | Review Permalink

MOONCHILD TRIO The Crucible ratings only


chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of MOONCHILD TRIO The Crucible


You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.