Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Giant Squid - Cenotes CD (album) cover

CENOTES

Giant Squid

Experimental/Post Metal


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
4 stars Giant Squid - Cenotes

This was my first experience with Giant Squid. Besides the fact that they had a Cello player, and this was metal, I did not know what to expect. ? It was a nice surprise right from the first note.

This is a sort of prog. doom metal, with a thick Metal sound, but with a lot of input from other genres. The Cello plays a very vital role in the mix, very present all the time. The Guitar and the Cello duels are amazingly beautiful. And the vocals are very varied, from heavy rock styles too folk'ish vocals.

Stylish there are elements from Asian/Middel East music, and elements of classic inspired music mixed into the Metal power poundings.

Sometimes the tempo is fast sometimes almost frantic, at other times its very slow. The album is shots and compact, but that is not a bad thing. Quality prevails quantity.

A strog 4 stars, and for those who like their music to be this hard, I bet it could easy be a 5 star. This is metal, and you have to be into metal, to like it. If you do not like metal at all, the chance you will love this one is next to none.

Report this review (#795385)
Posted Friday, July 27, 2012 | Review Permalink
5 stars CENOTE - A deep natural well or sinkhole formed by the collapse of surface limestone which exposes the ground water underneath.

The title of Giant Squid's monstrous EP very much fits the suffocating onslaught of the music trapped within. On "Cenotes" the band strays from the variety of instrument and personnel experimentation of their previous effort, "The Ichthyologist", to a simplified version of what the four core members are capable of on their own. It does not disappoint. Each track, save for Figura Serpentinata, travels from the realm of heartfelt melody to an ocean of crushing riffs without altering the song structure. Predictable crescendos perhaps, but nonetheless exhilarating. If you can't bang your head to this album you simply have no pulse.

To be fair to the band I will also annoyingly complain that this album is an EP, not a full length LP as it is labeled on this site, and therefore excused for it's play time of only 35 minutes. And to quote one of the band members, it is "the mother(expletive) Voltron of EPs". Yes, yes it is. The guitar/cello interplay is sublime, backed by a punishing rhythm section and very much complimented by the male/female vocal blending which can be absolutely haunting at times.

Tongue Stones- Heavy, epic and formidable way to start the album with plenty of highs and lows. A lengthy song which begins softly, then gives birth to devastation and refuses to quit. Mating Scars- Similar in vein to it's predecessor: A long track with a beautiful intro that naturally dives into the deep end, comes back up for air and sinks again. Stunning vocals and nice tribal-esque breakdowns in this one. Snakehead- An upbeat Squid song with a funky middle-eastern feel that completely rocks, for lack of a better term. You'll find yourself waiting and waiting for the heavy riffs to take over, completely immersed by the time they do. Figura Serpentinata- Sort of a quickie for this band. Fast paced and relatively short, but captivating enough to leave a whet palate. Personally I am never ready for this song to end. Cenotes- I find the album's closer to be a reverse of formula for Giant Squid, starting fast and heavy and eventually morphing into a trailing trance-worthy fade to black. An exquisite outro to say the least.

Most music lovers will, at some point, discover a lesser known act whose lack of widespread popularity boggles the mind. For me, Giant Squid is that band. Granted, part of me enjoys the diamond in the rough obscurity, but I can say with pure honesty that I simply do not understand how, on a songwriting level, they have not made bigger waves in the gigantic metal community. They offer the perfect blend of complexity and simplicity without losing any hook. The artistic integrity of their music is, in my opinion, unchallengeable. As an LP this would get 4 stars, based on length and length alone, but this is an EP, and I've heard few EPs more deserving of 5 stars.

5 emphatic stars for Cenotes, only because there are no more to give.

Report this review (#795481)
Posted Friday, July 27, 2012 | Review Permalink
DangHeck
PROG REVIEWER
3 stars Aside from its obvious "Eastern" onlooking (successfully), somewhat reminiscent of TOOL, in beefy grandeur and in vocal style (from the get-go). The strings and the standard/traditional Rock instrumentation really interlock well together. It's very cohesive sonically. Bravo! The aforementioned Eastern influences and, as mentioned on their blog, Gypsy style moments give it a sort of (perhaps accidental) psychedelic feeling (not quite Raga Rock). It's very familiar (in a good way).

As good as it is (for the genre--if this isn't telling enough), I have to say, given the post-metal nature/slant of the album, it only does so much for me and I have no intention of listening further. [If I can try to explain it, most Progressive music is dynamic not only vertically, but also horizontally. It gives and it gives and it gives, and ideally it works out most everything possible from what the artist has at their creative disposal. Post-rock/-metal only moves in a vertical direction, mostly in its standardized loud-soft dynamic, and provides little in the way of compositional interest (in my language, that horizontal movement).]

If you are into this sort of thing, it's certainly worth checking out. It's definitely a different (worthwhile) approach to the medium.

Report this review (#2606068)
Posted Thursday, October 21, 2021 | Review Permalink

GIANT SQUID Cenotes ratings only


chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of GIANT SQUID Cenotes


You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.