Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Scarlet Thread - Valheista Kaunein CD (album) cover


Scarlet Thread

Prog Folk

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
4 stars The Most Beautiful of Lies

That is the title roughly translated to english. The album cover and the name of the band and the thing that it is listed as a folk prog group gives me some expectations concerning the music. And yes there are moments of folkish mood when the band play low and either the violin or one of the guest flautists play nice folk melodies. But the overall feeling of the music is more straight forward guitar rock.

I can imagine atleast two Finnish influences for the band: Piirpauke and Tasavallan Presidentti. Piirpauke for the melodies and President for the rough rock sound. The combination is quite interesting. It takes a while to recognise the talents behind the little bit restless sound. At first I was dissapointed and thought that it sounded like a bunch of youngsters playing in the garage. The more you listen to the album the more you get acquainted with the atmosphere and start hearing the individuals from the whole. Also in my opinion the songs get better towards the end... There is no singing and I think that it is very refreshing. Firstly there are not so many such bands around and secondly it is difficult to find a talented singer. So many otherwise good groups get lame as the singer starts singing.

I would say that this would make a good addition to a somebodys prog collection, mine anyway.

Report this review (#99123)
Posted Thursday, November 16, 2006 | Review Permalink
Prog Folk Researcher
4 stars It occurred to me when I opened the package this album came in that Musea Records must do an awful lot of their business via mail order. Of all their CDs that I have, I don’t believe I bought any of them at a brick-and-mortar unless it was a used record at a head shop or old book store. Not that this has anything to do with this CD, it just struck me that you would have thought by now the label would have moved to all digipacks, at least for their imported stuff. The jewel case this came in only had a very minor crack from the shipping, but this seems like an archaic way to transport a CD all the way from France to the midwestern US. And by the way, I think the drummer pictured on the inside artwork has his fly open. Anyway, I digress as usual. On to the music.

The first track on this Finnish folk band’s latest album gives the impression of being more like neo-prog music than folk. And to a certain extent that’s probably true. I sometimes wonder if any band with a violin and a flute is automatically considered folk. Hardly. Everyone knows you have to throw in a lute to make it a real prog folk band, and an electric hurdy-gurdy to qualify as a neo-prog folk act. These guys don’t cut the mustard on either count. In fact the opening track “Tahtijen Taistelu” sounds more like the opening salvo of a Nightwish album than anything remotely folk-related. One other note – this is an all-instrumental album, although I actually was on my second spin of it before I actually noticed this. These tracks were recorded in 2004 but only released in 2006 after the band signed a deal with Musea. According to the band’s web site they now have a female vocalist and have rewritten several of these tracks to include vocals, so if you have a chance to see them live I suppose you’ll get a taste of that.

But the following title track settles down considerably, and violinist Erja Lahtinen is excellent on violin along with flautists Juha Sutela and Essi Suikkanen, who add to the folk feeling even though their instruments are mostly buried behind the twin guitar attack of Jani Timoniemi and Sami Hiltunen. “Vaeltava” is similar except that here the violin is even more prevalent and there is a tasty blues-inspired guitar solo that dominates the middle portion of the track.

“Juma Lanpilkkakirves” actually shows a little jazz/fusion influence in the arrangement, and I wonder if some of this was improvised in the studio. Lahtinen’s violin work reminds me of former Kansas violinist Robby Steinhardt on this track and on “Aatoksia Kivusta”. There is heavier guitar work here than on most prog folk albums, and that probably lends to the comparison. In fact, the closing track “Kunnes Kuolema Meit Erottaa” is very much in the vein of the mellower Masque-era Kansas music (minus Steve Walsh’s vocals of course), and “Haarasilta” is a tune I could see the original Kansas performing on stage without any trouble whatsoever.

“Levoton Sielu” is the most interesting track because of the way it melds a neo sort of guitar riff with meandering violin parts and the heaviest bass lines on the album. This track gives the feeling of being on a mystical journey of some sort with danger lurking all about, rough terrain to traverse, and of wooden ships in a nearby harbor. Very nice.

I didn’t really take to these guys much the first couple of times I listened to this album, but it has definitely grown on me with each spin. I’m looking forward to their next release and will almost surely be adding them to my ‘must buy’ list in the future. Four stars and well recommended not only to prog folk fans, but to neo-proggers as well.


Report this review (#157018)
Posted Saturday, December 29, 2007 | Review Permalink
Mellotron Storm
4 stars I got a big surprise when I first listened to this album because I was expecting a Prog-Folk album from this Finnish band and what I was hearing was this powerful and dynamic music, nothing like Folk at all. Well it turns out that after their Folky debut, the bands leader and guitarist Jani Timoniemi made wholesale changes in the band's lineup (he's the only one left from the debut) and changed the style of music while he was at it. He added a second guitarist, and the violin plays a key role. 2 guest flute players help out too.

"Tahtojen Taistelu" has a good heavy sound to it with violin arriving around a minute. It settles down before 2 1/2 minutes then picks back up after 3 minutes with violin. "Valheista Kaunein" is more laid back with violin and drums standing out. This sounds so good. Guitar comes to the fore before 2 minutes. Flute and violin follow then it picks up more with guitar leading. Nice. "Vaeltava" is laid back with violin to start. It kicks in before a minute with guitar and violin out front. It settles after 2 1/2 minutes. Check out the intricate guitar a minute later. Then it kicks back in.

"Jumelanpilkkakirves" is fairly heavy with flute over top. How good is this ! It settles beautifully as contrasts continue. The guitar rips it up after 3 1/2 minutes. "Valon Lahettrais" is led by drums, violin and flute early. Guitar takes the spotlight 4 minutes in. "Aatoksia Kivusta" is heavy and uptempo before settling with violin. Flute leads after 2 1/2 minutes. "Haarasilta" is a violin led track and the closest thing to Folk on here. "Levoton Sielu" opens with guitar as drums join in. A calm with flute before 3 minutes. Violin joins in as well. It kicks back in and the guitar is lighting it up late. "Kunnes Kulema Meidat Erottaal" is mid- paced with violin leading the way. A nice solid sound here. It turns spacey before 5 minutes to end it.

This has just been a pleasure to listen to this past week. Highly recommended instrumental music.

Report this review (#284845)
Posted Friday, June 4, 2010 | Review Permalink

SCARLET THREAD Valheista Kaunein ratings only

chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of SCARLET THREAD Valheista Kaunein

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives