Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Horslips - Dancehall Sweethearts CD (album) cover

DANCEHALL SWEETHEARTS

Horslips

Prog Folk


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
4 stars Album number three from Ireland's greatest band is 'Dancehall Sweethearts'. The songs on the album are loosely based on the life of itinirent, blind harper Turlough O' Carolan , who collected and wrote many of ireland's most popular indigenous melodies. The album title and sleeve were partially in jest as the record company at the time was somewhat less than enthusiastic about promoting an album based on the life of a blind harper and also the horslips' previous two albums had very dark album artwork.

The songs on this album are no joke however. adding a little bit more rock edge and taking out a little of the traditional irish influence that fuelled the band's earlier albums, 'Dancehall Sweethearts' is still a truly excellent album. The production is up to a very high standard and opening track 'Night-Town Boy' is a cracking introduction to the album. The mix is excellent with the central guitar riff blending well with keyboards,mandolin and the unusual inclusion of saxophones. This song is a statement of intent for the album and contrasts wonderfully with what follows it. 'The Blind Can't Lead The Blind' is of a much slower pace in the same vein to some extend with 'Furniture' from the bands debut album 'Happy To Meet,Sorry To Part'. Both of the opening two songs feature excellent fiddle work from Charles O' Connor who shows his versatility in the contrasting moods of the two solos.

Other highlights of this album include 'Stars' which features excellent keyboard work from Jim Lockhart with his part in the chorus in the song sounding somewhat similar to Ray Manzarek's work in The Doors' "Hyacynth House", a compliment. The Concept of Turlough O Carolan's life is continued in the sublime "Blindman" which has a potent vocal performance from Charles O' Connor. Similar compliments must be paid also to "Mad Pat" which is magnificent. The prog content is kept high on tracks such as "We Bring The Summewr With Us' ; surely the most progressive treatment of Irish music ever with Jim Lockhart's keyboards making Wakeman-esque noises and Charles O' Connor joining in on concertina also.

Throughout Johnny Fean's guitar work is immense and as always superb. Fean is, in my opinion, the single most underrated guitarist to ever come out of Ireland. My claim is backed up by sterling guitar solos all across the album and Fean impresses greatly on the band's drastic reinterpretation of the standard 'King Of The Fairies' which features a simply scorching guitar solo which is wonderfully punctuated. fean also shows his versatility by supplying this track with tenor banjo also.

Eamonn Carr plays drums the way they should be played as always and is masterfully accompanied in the rhythm section by Barry Devlin whose round,solid basslines provide the foundation for Fean and O' Connor's excellent solo exploits. this rhythm section is as capable as any ever and in many, many cases are better. Carr supplies the lyrics, which proves that he is much more than your average drummer and Devlin equally raises his stock by lending his vocals to several tracks on the album.

The only issues that i have with this album is that it is certainly not a step forward in the way the 'The Tain' was from 'Happy To Meet,Sorry To part". The Trad. infuence has been diluted significantly on this album despite the fact that many of the melodies from the album's songs were sourced from old traditional tunes. Whilst certainly a step below 'The Tain', 'Dancehall Sweethearts" is an essential purchase for all fans of the Horslips and is a must have for all fans of Celtic rock. Horslips' third album serves as a powerful reminder of the mighty and great force the band were at the height of their powers.

Report this review (#34098)
Posted Sunday, February 27, 2005 | Review Permalink
Tony Fisher
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars The third album from the greatest band ever to emerge from Ireland (or just about anywhere else for that matter) is a much more loosely conceptual collection than its predecessor, being based on the ramblings of blind Irish harper O'Carolan. There's much more of a rock feel than before and some of the traditional folk element is gone, but the recording quality is superb - the instruments stand out clearly and with excellent dynamics. Nighttown Boy kicks off with a punchy guitar riff, saxophones and some excellent fiddle work. The Blind Can't Lead the Blind has some complex backing vocals and We Bring the Summer With Us is a novel style for the band as it is essentially a huge synth and organ piece a la Wakeman. On side 2, Mad Pat and Blindman are excellent songs but King of the Fairies is a masterpiece - you just have to get up and jig. Charles O'Connors fiddle, Jim Lockharts's keyboards and Johnny Fean's guitar swop solos; Fean is one of the all time greats. But the crowning glory is the poignant The Best Years of Our Lives, a lament for a musician long dead which could be almost autobiographical. The album cover shows them looking utterly worn out after incessant touring and the lines "they took me how they found me and the whisky nearly drowned me" suggests that they too may have had a hard time! Eamonn Carr provides the lyrics and, since he was originally a poet, they are always classy. The only thing that stops it getting 5 stars is that it isn't quite as good as its predecessor, the Tain. But it's still damn good and would get 4 and a half if it were possible.
Report this review (#34099)
Posted Saturday, March 26, 2005 | Review Permalink
obiter
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars thugamar fein an samhradh linn has a haunting melody which has never left me. To hear it in We Bring the summer with us was moving.

there is a stangre raw beauty to this album which transcends The Tain and stands in stark contrast to the polished feel of the seminal Bookk of Celtic Invasions.

As I've said before this is neither Planxty nor the Bothy Band but the Horslips filled an enormous void in irish music. this was 1974 there may have been mayhem on the streets in the north but: Thin Lizzy had already brought out Vagabonds and Nightlife; Rory Gallagher was touring; the nadir of politically sentimal folk would not been reached for a good few years (Moving Hearts).

Dancehall Sweethearts was an irish answer to Jethro Tull. Steeped in folk but breaking away from the shackles of traditional and introducing a 70s rock feel.

An essential for any folky prog types.

Report this review (#120470)
Posted Tuesday, May 1, 2007 | Review Permalink
kenethlevine
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Prog-Folk Team
3 stars With "Dancehall Sweethearts", Horslips toned down the celtic element...the tracks were still virtually all if not all traditional in origin, but dressed up for the late 20th century to such an extent that for most of the disk they could pass for any quality band of that era from any corner of the Anglophone world.

This "dumbing down" worked wonders about half the time, such as in "Stars", "We Bring the Summer with Us", and especially the bluesy prog of "Mad Pat", which sounds eerily like early Genesis in its quieter moments. Then of course there is the fairly recognizable corker "King of the fairies", oft covered but rarely with this much panache and amplification, and the brief lovely ballad "The Best Years of my Life". OK, so they can't completely de-celtify any more than they can be de-mystified. One's DNA doesn't lie, and Horslips are an honest bunch. However, the less said about the clumsiness of some of the other material, particularly the opening 2 numbers, the better.

A discussion of the best material from this band rarely includes this uneven third album and, while it won't be the sweetheart of your collection, it has enough highlights to be worth an occasional tick on your dance card.

Report this review (#194183)
Posted Wednesday, December 17, 2008 | Review Permalink
Queen By-Tor
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
4 stars Leaving the Celtic a touch in the dust, but still picking up where they left off.

Horslips is a fascinating band, whether they're writing grand concept albums that piece together multiple songs to create a cycle that any prog fan will find to be on the same level as skill as the progressive megalodons, or they'll be creating a more modest concept that works around ''full-songs'' that are just as easy to enjoy. While this is definitely something that not every band can pull off, Horslips does it with such grace that you just never mind what they're doing, so long as they're doing it with those smooth Celtic melodies, their endless pools of inspiration or their somewhat quirky sense of humor.

Dancehall Sweethearts is a potentially dangerous album to follow up the deadly serious The Tain with, and is one that hard core proggers may put off buying thanks to the cover art alone. Fear not, for this is easily one of the band's best albums. It follows a loose concept, and it has plenty of songs on it to enforce the Celtic rule, and while that may not be as prominent this time around, it's still around to a high degree. It can be quickly said that all of the best songs on the albums are the ones that feel the Celtic love, but the others are quite good too - it just so happens that the best songs on this album are the best among all of Horslips catalog, so the others can get quite overshadowed. Still, the disc works on the whole - and was actually probably the best thing they could have followed up their sophomore with (even though something like The Book Of Invasions is closer in kin) since it shows another side of the band's songwriting prowess that would be heavily used on later albums, albeit less successfully.

Take three parts rock and one part pure folk and you get what amount to the most impressive of opuses in the album's best songs. The opening tune is a perfect example of things to come with its ringing riff and catchy development. Nighttown Boys may not hit you over the head with its more subtle elements right off the bat, but you'll likely be hearing them the second or third time around, and when you do you'll understand what makes this band such a good fit for our inclusive little club. Another standout on the first side is the stunning Sunburst which makes the best use of the grandiose side of things with its horns and female backups creating a much larger Horslips than we're used to, but it makes for a nice break, Horslips never being the kind of chaps to bore you with one thing for too long.

The second half is home to some very amazing tunes. First on the dock is Mad Pat, a progressive epic contained in the short span of 6-minutes that manages to bring to life everything the band does well. Perfect melodies, catchy segments that manage to stay successfully ''un-poppy'' while still being accessible and impressive instrumental sections that any pretentious prog master would be proud of. The instrumental The King Of Fairies is another quite impressive moment, despite its criminally short length of around 3-minutes, and llike instrumentals done by the band before it (The Silver Spear for instance), it's brought to life by as many Celtic instruments that you can possibly think of, while still diluting the folk side of things with a good dose of rock adrenaline shot right into the arm.

While this review may have fixated on a few songs over the rest there's no doubt that even after repeated listens you'll do the same. The rest of the songs on the album are also impressive and well worth the listen in their own rights, it's just that the shining moments of the disc shine so brightly that they are just very hard to best. Overall the disc is going to get a 4 out of 5 - while it may not be a masterpiece it certainly comes close. This album is recommended to anyone who has the chance to get it, and to all appreciators of the band or simple Celtic rock - seek out this album! You won't be disappointed.

Report this review (#211287)
Posted Tuesday, April 14, 2009 | Review Permalink
SouthSideoftheSky
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Symphonic Team
3 stars The king of the fairies

Following after the excellent conceptual album The Tain, Dancehall Sweethearts is almost necessarily a bit less interesting. However, there is much to enjoy here too. The present album may not be held together by a concept, but it is a fairly coherent album with mostly good moments some of which are even as strong as the previous album. There is a slight change of musical direction towards the "commercial" which can be noticed on a few of the songs. The difference in the music is, however, not at all as apparent as the difference between the cover art pictures - from a dark picture of a hand in armour ready for war (The Tain) to a rather sleazy picture of the members of the band (Dancehall Sweethearts). Indeed, even the album title itself is badly chosen; Dancehall Sweethearts!? I don't know who's who in the band, but the man to the very left in the cover picture looks very much like Graham Chapman of the Monty Python group!

But don't be fooled into thinking that this change is that radical, this is still for the most part very much Prog Folk with a very Irish sound. There are still clearly many progressive aspects to Horslips' sound and approach even some which were not there before, like a stronger presence of different keyboard instruments. The latter are most obvious on the short instrumental We Bring The Summer With Us, which is a great little interlude. There are also some brass instruments that might be an acquired taste, but for the most part they fit in.

The Rock 'N' Roll opener Nighttown Boy is a bit of a disappointment and it initially scarred me away somewhat from this album. But one should really hold out and listen further into the album to find the better songs which I did. Despite Lonely Hearts, which is back to the straightforward Rock 'N' Roll style of Nighttown Boy, the second half of the album is by far the better half and more interesting one with very strong numbers such as Mad Pat and King Of The Fairies. But also the first half has its highlights.

Overall, I think that Horslips is an underrated group and Dancehall Sweethearts is, despite some lesser moments, one of their best albums. I would, however, strongly recommend starting with The Tain and Book Of Invasions which are the band's finest efforts. But for those who like those albums, the present album is a very worthy addition.

Recommended, but not the best place to start

Report this review (#265770)
Posted Friday, February 12, 2010 | Review Permalink
3 stars The band members exhibit maximum sleaze on the cover of this album, so all you ladies beware of these uptown boys! Overall, the album is good. There is no unifying theme, so each track stands as its own. Popular appeal seems to have been a consideration, especially concerning the song Stars with it punchy beat, and fist-raising sing-along lyrics. Just the thing you would expect to hear in a modern dancehall. At the same time, there is more than enough true Celtic rock to keep the listener's attention. One of the serous criticisms I have is for the muddy sound, but that might be because of the version I have - an out-of-print Outlet version my wife bought for me used, oddly, for Valentine's Day. The album opens with Nighttown Boy, a mid-tempo grungy affair - literally. The song is decent, but I find it weak, and it sets a tone that belies the remainder of the set.

This is vintage Horslips, though, and it rocks as only they can. Throughout, John Fean's guitar, Charles O'Connor's fiddle, and Jim Lockhart's organ are played very well. In fact, Lockhart's sound is one of the best I know of - it has such a rich and mellow tone. To that, Barry Devlin and Eamon Carr provide a fine rhythm section - holding the bottom and the beat where necessary while taking center stage occasionally for dramatic effect. The uncredited choir on The Blind Can't Lead the Blind adds an extra dimension to the sound, as does the uncredited horn section on Sunburst. My favorite part of the album is a three song sequence in the middle comprising We Bring the Summer With Us, the instrumental King of the Fairies, and Mad Pat. This is where the real Horslips magic comes into play, and the band sounds great. The album ends on a melancholy tone with the simple The Best Years of My Life, a reflective song that ends abruptly. Clearly, this was planned, and fits the subject of the song, but I've never really liked it when a band does that - I prefer some sort of resolution both musically and thematically, and this just left me hanging there waiting for something more.

There are a couple more songs I have not mentioned here, nor do I feel the need to do so. Suffice it to say I find this a good Horslips album, mostly outstanding but with a few disappointing characteristics. It won't win any new converts, but for the Horslips fan, it is a good effort.

Report this review (#281130)
Posted Sunday, May 9, 2010 | Review Permalink
4 stars Why did I took it so long to review a Horslips album? Its the band I was praying to hear when all I did was celtic reserches and that kind of stuff.

Begning with Dancehall Sweethearts is something interesting: its their more "pop" album, full of catchy refrains and riffs. But its right there I believe that hides the magic, just as Jethro Tull deliver every influence of them in rock scenario, so Horslips did it in Dancehall Sweethearts. "Nighttown Boy", "The Blind Can't Lead the Blind", "Stars", are the startes exaclty in this vein. The next track, "We Bring the Summer With Us", is absolutely gorgeous as its the oposition of the above. The movement is different, its folk music played intirely with electric instruments and a heavy keyboard and then were back to the heavy riff and catchy chorus with "Sunburst" (one of the best tracks). The Ireland of classical instruments such as the fiddle appear with the great "King of the Fairies". "Lonely Hearts" is kind of a repetition of terms and could be put it out of the album, but as it goes in the same mood and the closing track "The Best Years of My Life" take you straight to a pub, nothing is loss actually.

The great works of this remarkably Irish band was still to come (and they were certainly "resting" from the ambitious "The Tain"), but Dancehall Sweethearts can easily be among your collection.

Report this review (#926461)
Posted Friday, March 8, 2013 | Review Permalink

HORSLIPS Dancehall Sweethearts ratings only


chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of HORSLIPS Dancehall Sweethearts


You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.