Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Mostly Autumn - Graveyard Star CD (album) cover


Mostly Autumn


Prog Folk

4.14 | 129 ratings

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

5 stars UK melodic prog rock band, Mostly Autumn, release a powerful and evocative new album, documenting their experience of the pandemic over the last year or so. It has all the ingredients of a classic Mostly Autumn album, but soaked with the raw emotion of personal loss, despair and finally hope for the future.

Mostly Autumn are a band not averse to showing their emotions on their sleeves when it comes to the subject matter of their albums. Dressed in Voices (2014) had the dark concept of a killer forced to witness the full weight of all he is taking away from his victim and 2019's White Rainbow was shaped by the death of former member Liam Davison. So, it is maybe not too surprising that the COVID 19 pandemic and the effect that has had on everyone, is the linking concept behind their post-lockdown album, Graveyard Star.

As Bryan Josh says in the liner notes: The album is:

"A real-time documentation of living through 2020/21 and a strong reflection of how we were feeling as this time passed. Although very personal to us. I can only imagine many of you can strongly relate to this journey."

As a result, you get all the elements you would expect from a Mostly Autumn album; angelic vocals from Olivia Sparnenn-Josh, consistently strong guitar work from Bryan Josh and a stable line-up of musicians seamlessly blending elements of melodic rock, prog rock with Celtic folk overtones. However, add a deep lyrical content and a diverse range of compositional styles, and you have one of the most impressive releases in the band's 26-year history.

The opening epic, Graveyard Star, begins atmospherically with Iain Jennings' keyboards and intimate and haunting vocals from Bryan and Olivia before violin and flute appear and then Henry Roger's drum picks up the strident beat prior to some great ensemble playing by the band. This is a song of loss, even if it dates from January 2020 before the first lockdown. Lyrics of mortality and loss dominate, with Olivia's yearning vocals emotionally charging lines such as "Goodbye sun from another sun", "I was the lamp beside your head, I was the diamond in your head" and "A spark in heaven's crowd" amongst others, while Bryan's darker vocals complement the mood. Discordant electric guitar then shifts to a gentle acoustic guitar-led interlude with poignant violin accompaniment from guest artist Chris Leslie (from Fairport Convention), before an expressive guitar solo soars above the heaviness and tiredness of the background tempo. A final rally fails to lift the sadness. It is clear that this journey into the dark has only just begun.

There are Floydian elements to Bryan's weary vocals on The Plague Bell as he states, "It's a long way home tonight" and the image of death as a "white rag ghost" stepping on board the ship, takes us back to the first lockdown in March 2020. It is effectively the introduction to Skin of Mankind - where Olivia's dramatic vocals are joined by a deep guitar riff echoing a Western theme or an Enrico Morricone soundtrack, with a trotting rhythm from Henry's drums and Andy Smith's bass. The spritely, folky violin is strikingly at odds with the dark lyrics of a changing world and the need to now isolate to survive.

Shadows starts acoustically, but soon develops into a driving, mid-tempo rock song. We are well into isolation at home by now (April 2020) and Bryan's vocals and lead guitar over Chris Johnson's rhythm guitar emphasise the monotonous routine of it all. "Shadows cut the grain of the thunder and the rain." The Harder That You Hurt continues the struggle against it all. Olivia's gentle vocals emphasise the weariness, "The stronger you are, the weaker you feel" is countered by "Counting days till we are back on the road again." The band build up the power in typical Mostly Autumn fashion from a sleepy Knopfler-style guitar pattern to full-blown ensemble instrumentation.

Written in May 2020, Razor Blade is another very personal track on the album. Dedicated to Val and Tracey, it starts with Olivia's melancholic vocals over strummed acoustic guitar, as the lyrics hint at wanting to be away from it all. "Take me off the razor's edge" - get out me out in the air and space and away from the darkness and the loss. Nice piano from Iain heralds another build-up, with keyboards taking flight and Bryan's and Olivia's contrasting vocals intertwine heartbreakingly. This Endless War continue the theme of loss and the need for support in those dark times to continue to fight and is a stunning slow burner of a track. Olivia wrote the lyrics and they resonate throughout "I would have been the answer to your call, You'll always be the answer to my call. I'd chase the wolves right from your door, I'd bring you home from this. Endless war..." The music is initially sad and pensive, with gentle piano before the full band come in. Bryan's closing solo is the best on the album for me and Olivia's passionate vocals at the end are scorching!

Spirit of Mankind takes us to January 2021 and the second lockdown, and that feeling of frustration and sadness as we returned to isolation and the closing of the borders. "We're on the ropes again" and the days filled with "the best of us" and "the worst of us". There is a pulsating beat, epic keyboards and some well-pitched electric and acoustic guitar runs, and possibly the most catchy refrain on the album - hinting that there is light at the end of the tunnel and the promise of "a phoenix rising through these flames."

All of the sudden we are in July 2021 and Back In These Arms signals the change from the dark to the light as the final lockdown ends. The subdued keyboards open up into a dynamic slab of anthematic group playing, with optimistic, joyous and defiant lyrics chanted out as life begins to return to normal. "I can hold my mother!", "Yes we cry so hard cause it feels so good". Andy's bass pushes the song towards the end, with proggy keyboards from Iain adding to the lighter tone along with pipes and whistles from returning guest musician, Troy Donockley (Nightwish). This optimistic mood continues with the beautiful Freedom to Fly. Largely piano-led over Olivia's wistful tones - the sense of a new beginning is clear to hear and is an enlivening change of tempo.

Chris Johnson's song The Diamond is also a refreshing change, with his acoustic guitar driving the song through as it builds up and his soft vocals, joined by those of Angela Gordon, produce a wonderfully ethereal and hypnotic soundscape. I was interested in how it fitted into the whole concept (Bryan alluded to a link to the diamond in the title track), and Chris gave me a very revealing explanation:

"It was about being in lockdown and feeling an intense longing to go the beautiful places in the world. For me that's mountains and I imagined them still stood there, the nature unaffected by the pandemic. I wondered if you could compress all the hurt and sadness we were feeling. Compress it down and down until it was just a hard stone and throw it into the beauty of a deep mountain lake to get rid of it. But then, we need the sadness. It's part of us and we wouldn't be the complex things we are without it, so the song explores this kind of separation. The idea of wanting to get rid of a part of yourself, and then really missing it when it's gone. I feel we have all changed from who we were before the pandemic, and maybe we're searching to feel whole again."

Turn Around Slowly is the epic conclusion to the album and really brings all of the strands of the concept together, with repeated themes and lyrics. Starting with gentle musical passages, the first half has a poignancy as the lyrics look back on the long journey we have all took. "The Lady" is a fitting reference and tribute to the work of Dame Sarah Gilbert and the Oxford vaccination team and whilst the tone is optimistic, Bryan's vocals make us remember to "sweep up the roses that bent in the Sun". Another epic guitar solo takes us into full prog rock mode but then there are alternating changes in tempo prior to a defiant reprise of Skin of Mankind, over powerful riffing. Bryan's lyrics now have a combative tone, as he is talking to the virus and saying your time is now up! Troy's pipes add a Celtic edge, with his low vocals building up the drama before Olivia reprises Graveyard Star and another quality guitar solo concludes the album as the band hit top gear. This track will be a real highlight when played live and links the whole album concept in true prog rock fashion.


The 2000 who brought the limited edition of the album as a pre-order with the bonus disc, have another 9 strong tracks to enjoy - many of which would have fitted on the first disc if space allowed, or if the double album option had been pursued. The Show Is On is an exuberant celebration of a return to live music, and Into The Valley of Death Rode The Six Hundred is a proggy Iain Jennings instrumental. Check In Your Eyes is typical, driving Mostly Autumn, whilst Side Effect is a gentle, piano-led Chris Johnson ballad. Swallows is a moving and expressive composition about a woman following the return to swifts and swallows in spring (another reference to the departed Tracey) with a poignancy added by some beautiful violin playing before an epic conclusion; definitely one to see live in the future, perhaps? Heading For the Mountains is an acoustic folk/country number by Bryan and Mountain Highway is another flowing Iain Jennings penned instrumental. This House (dedicated to Val) starts off almost C&W-like and is a bitter-sweet reflection of loss, but with an uplifting spirit at its heart and a moving, epic conclusion.

GRAVEYARD STAR is another great album release by Mostly Autumn and adds to the consistent run of quality recent albums. Its topical concept about lockdown and the pandemic is deeply personal but never feels forced. It hits immediately, but also grows with repeated plays. As a result, the deep lyrics gradually speak stronger to the listener themselves, as well as documenting what Bryan, Olivia and the band went through themselves. Their prog-infused melodic rock with soaring guitars and evocative vocals is as engaging as ever.

In all honesty, if you have not succumbed to the band's charms on recent albums, the new album is unlikely to change your view. However, existing fans are going to lap up this impressive and mature release and I would urge those less familiar with Mostly Autumn's work to give Graveyard Star a good listen or two and reflect on the journey we have all travelled in recent years.


Squonk19 | 5/5 |


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Share this MOSTLY AUTUMN review

Social review comments () BETA

Review related links

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.