Genesis Self-Titled - 1983 - artistic or commercial ??? Same as asking the question 'to be or not to be ??'
This release isn't half bad, nor is it an exceptional expression of early 80's Progressive music. What our
Symphonic friends have displayed here is the fact that they can keep up with the demands of the music
bizz and contemporary trends by sacrificing inspiration over aspiration. Collins and Co. seem to be
catering for their newly established Pop-Rock fan-base (of which there were many to compliment their
sales demographics), rather than pleasing ' ye olde faithfuls' (of which there were few by this
stage ... the cash-cow would've turned into a bull....) Sure it's something of a winner on the charts, with mega-
hits 'That's All', 'Illegal Alien' and 'Mama', of which only the semi-lengthy 'Mama' has any vague link to
their past, with the slow build-up and haunting Keyboard work that is truly (Tony) Banksian. The track is
actually a quality piece of music - quite the cut above most radio oriented drek at the time. Collins really
puts on a chillingly powerful vocal, some of his best singing ever IMO. 'That's All' is a focused and simple
tune, which, at least, features an organ sounding synth solo followed by a guitar solo. Pure Pop, but not a
tune one is likely to forget, thanks to the highly melodic and catchy nature of the piece. 'Illegal Alien' has
Phil putting on the accent of someone of Mexican decent, quite a daggy idea, to be honest. A slightly
ethereal interlude is all the interest the song can muster. Elsewhere, most Proggers respect the 'Home By
The Sea' suite, with its instrumental consideration and unusual lyric subject - apparently about
ghosts - Collins letting loose on his Electric Drum-Kit, crunching guitars and Fretless Bass from Mike
Rutherford, and varied, atmospheric Keys from Banks. A definate high-point of the album. Three 'take-it-
or-leave-it' tracks in 'Taking It All Too Hard' (almost M.O.R. Collins solo material), 'Just A Job To Do' (pure
commercial Pop music) and Silver Rainbow (a somewhat unusual track which I just don't appreciate) and
the album closer 'It's Gonna Get Better', which again puts Banks in the fore-front with his tasteful
Keyboard work and features some cleverly arranged rhythms. I must admit that this is one of the first
Genesis albums I heard back in '86, courtesy of my sister, and it bought to my attention the existence of their vast back-
catalogue, therefore I feel a generous score of 3 is justly deserved, good, but far from an essential
purchase....... what ?? ....... of course Nursery Cryme is better !!!
Tom Ozric |3/5 |
MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).