Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Trion - Pilgrim CD (album) cover

PILGRIM

Trion

Symphonic Prog


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
erik neuteboom
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars In 2003 the Dutch trio Trion (an abbreviation of the words trio and Mellotron) released their debut CD entitled Tortoise, a wonderful symphonic prog album layered with beautiful Mellotron samples. It was received very well by the press and progrock fans and soon Colossus (Finnish Progressvie Rock Society) invited Trion to contribute to the 2-CD The Spaghetti Epic (featuring progrock bands from all over the world). Trion was OK and delivered the epic Frank. This composition can be found on this new CD (in a re-arranged version) while originally Trion was only founded to make one album!

Listening to Pilgrim I notice a huge progress in comparison with their first effort, way more dynamic and alternating, also due to the more varied vintage keyboard sound. That variety is very present in the first song Pilgrim: a violin-Mellotron intro, a piece with Fender Rhodes piano and a sensitive guitar solo, a compelling rhythm with Hammond organ runs and propulsive guiar riffs, a mid- tempo with fluent synthesizer flights and a final part with first fragile Grand piano/Mellotron and then organ, Mellotron and slide guitar, wonderful! In the other tracks the atmospheres range from dreamy to compelling with echoes from Seventies Camel, Genesis and Focus. Especially the interplay between organ and Mellotron with the electric guitar is beautiful and moving, like in Silence of the Universe, Giant Man, The Deep Ocean and Out There Somewhere. In between we hear interludes with warm play on classical - and acoustic guitar like in How We Used To Go (solo piece) and Reveal The Mystery (wonderful interplay between organ and Mellotron). Also worth to listen to are the tracks The Book (majestic church organ sound aling slide guitar and Mellotron) and the mellow A Dream (warm sound of the Grand piano and fragile acoustic guitar). But the absolute highlight is the final composition Frank: it begins with twanging 12-string guitar (like early Genesis) and violin-Mellotron, then lots of shifting moods (with moving guitar, beautiful Mellotron), a captivating duel between fiery guitar and fluent synthesizer runs and a compelling grand finale delivering a long and moving guitar solo, supported by mellow organ and strong drums, this is Progheaven!

What a wonderful album, I am glad Trion decided not to remain an one-shot-band!

Report this review (#143735)
Posted Thursday, October 11, 2007 | Review Permalink
5 stars Wou!!!

If you are a lover of seventies sound, the mellotron, the slide guitar, yuo must hear this masterpiece.

A complete work full of rick sinphonic instrumental melodies por those progarchives friends of Camel music.

Sorry but my english is very limited por all I can to say you about this great and wonferful album of Trion.

Five Stars.

Report this review (#157867)
Posted Sunday, January 6, 2008 | Review Permalink
Tarcisio Moura
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars When I heard Trion had released a second CD I was a bit suspicious. Tortoise was supposed to be an one offshot side project by members of Flamborough Head and Odyssice. That first release was excellent but it seemed to me it could not go further from that. Well, I was wrong. Pilgrim is quite a big step forward. So much it got me completely off guard. Those guys are in their prime both as songwriters and players.

Edo Spanninga keyboards are even more varied than before, using a vast array of old-but-gold analogic sounds like the Hammong Organ, Fender Rhodes piano, mini-moogs and, of course, mellotrons. Eddie Mulder´s guitar playing is another highlight thorughout the CD: he is an acomplished player of both the electric and the acoustic guitars. Sometimes his style bearing the trademarks of such great ones like Andy Latimer, Steve Hackett and Jan Akkerman. Menno Boomsma is also a precise and creative drummer.

The music on the album is that kind of instrumental progressive music that has the rare quality of mixing simple structures and melodies to fine craft and intricated arrangements. The result is both complex and accessible, captivating and challeging. One fo those rare albums you hear with the same pleasure from start to finich (ever rarer in a 76 minute long CD!).

Highlights? Yes! Giant Mn with its killer guitar solo and a wonderful mellotron sound that sends shivers down the spine everty time I hear it. The Silence Of The Universe (great Hammond Organ runs and good use of acoustic and eletric guitars sounds). And then, of course, there is Frank. Frank is a 22:57 prog epic that was born a classic. It has nods to early Genesis, Focus, Yes and Camel with many shifting moods, tempo changes and a grand finale that would make any of those great bands proud of. I never heard the original version of this song,but this one might be the definitve one! I´m really glad it was included as a bonus track!

This is one of the best prog albums of 2007 and certainly one of the top five instrumental prog albums of all time. A classic. Highly recommended!

Report this review (#158582)
Posted Monday, January 14, 2008 | Review Permalink
tszirmay
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
5 stars As I stated in my previous review of Trion's debut "Tortoise", I was in a state of advanced trepidation while waiting for this sophomore contribution. The first album was an exemplary mellotron orgy, loaded with bristle melodies, sensational soloing by guitarist Eddie Mulder and winks at Camel, KC, Ant Phillips and Focus. Because of incredible feed-back from both fans and media, the Dutchmen decided to turn their one- shot deal into a sequel offering "Pilgrim", without any attempt to not progress into deeper adventure: the mighty 'trons are still present of course but Edo Spanninga has wisely added some organ, piano and even synthesizer to his arsenal. Eddie continues to double on bass but he really gets to showcase his incredible talent (not always apparent with day-band Flamborough Head) with some well crafted signature solos. Odyssice's talented Memmo Boosma is steady as a dyke, keeping it all together. This remains an all- instrumental affair of the highest caliber, with a multitude of ingenious workouts that have more substance than endless noodling, suggesting deep felt emotions that need no lyrics or vocalist. Had this been in vinyl LP form, we would have a double album as this monster is 76 minutes in length. So how to these Hollanders set sail? With an opening title track that seizes the casual listener by the melodic jugular, a 7 minute + ride that is certainly mellow (no crunch here!) but fully loaded with passionate evocations of the Jemetrion saga (first broached with the debut), a story with no singing (similar to Xang, who have deep lyrics and momentous storylines but no vocals). There is no point in describing each track as they are all luscious affairs, my fellow colleagues have done a splendid job throwing light on the magnificent moments. Suffice to say that this is a huge melodic banquet that has everything a progfan needs to get his jollies: stupendous mellotron expressions, fascinating guitar solo sorties and a rich variety of acoustic and electric adornments. Without a doubt the epic monster "Frank" is a typical example (or recap) of the creative genius expressed in the grooves, full of alternating contrasts, shifting moods and unpredictable surprises. An unmitigated instrumental masterstroke. After all, we PA reviewers can't be wrong, we do have taste ! Also very cool : the debut had a Roger Dean style artwork while here we are in an overt Hipgnosis mood, very reminiscent of Yes' Going For the One . 5 Try-ons
Report this review (#180389)
Posted Wednesday, August 20, 2008 | Review Permalink
Mellotron Storm
PROG REVIEWER
3 stars TRION are from The Netherlands and they are a trio with Menno coming from ODYSSICE while Eddie and Edo are from FLAMBOROUGH HEAD.Their band name comes from the fact they are a trio and also that they use mellotron. It's interesting though that they've chosen to use sampled mellotron instead of the real thing. I like this better than the debut. It's very pleasant sounding with lots of acoustic guitar, light drums and keyboards (organ, piano).

"Pilgrim" opens with mellotron as drums and organ join in. Guitar after 2 minutes comes in soaring.The tempo picks up 3 1/2 minutes in. Some nice guitar before 5 minutes as well. Piano follows with mellotron only as it settles down. "Silence Of The Universe" takes a while to get going then the guitar starts to soar with a beat and organ.Synths after 3 minutes. "Walk On Land" has this slow repetitive rhythm that starts to pick up then we get acoustic guitar only after 2 minutes as contrasts continue. "How We Used To Go" features acoustic guitar melodies throughout.

"The Magnificent Forest" has more life to it as a full sound kicks in right away.Synths lead a minute in. It settels back 2 1/2 minutes in and mellotron comes in after 3 minutes. "Reveal The Mystery" opens with gentle guitar and mellotron then it picks up quickly with drums and organ as contrasts continue."Giant Man" is one of my favourites. A beat with bass and mellotron leads early then the guitar comes to the fore. Back to that earlier sound as the contrasts continue,. "The Book" opens with mellow sounds that pulsate. Organ and drums kick in then guitar before 2 1/2 minutes. "Blue Shadows" opens with acoustic guitar melodies as the mellotron rolls in. "A Dream" is mostly piano and mellotron while "The Deep Ocean" opens with an almost haunting mood and acoustic guitar. It comes to life with organ and electric guitar then settles back as contrasts continue.

A relaxed and enjoyable instrumental album. 3.5 stars.

Report this review (#405235)
Posted Tuesday, February 22, 2011 | Review Permalink
BrufordFreak
COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
2 stars An album filled with melodically pleasing music of exceedingly syrupy and simplistic pop/New Age sounding constructs, this would not even warrant my consideration or attention were it not for the presence (on my acquisition) of the wonderful bonus song, "Frank (new version)." Don't get me wrong, the album is a very pleasant listen, all songs are engaging and likable, but the lack of complexity, lack of intricacy, lack of unpredictability, all make for a highly uninteresting album. I want something with meat in it--something that makes me take notice, step back, and say "wow!" This has none of that. But listen to Frank.
Report this review (#459436)
Posted Sunday, June 12, 2011 | Review Permalink
4 stars Sorry friends for the long dissertation on the bonus tracks!

"Pilgrim" is the second album of Dutch prog band Trion. It is totally instrumental and consists of eleven tracks and two bonus tracks.

I've never been a great lover of so-called "bonus tracks". I do not like re-releases on CD, including bonus tracks added to the songs that historically make up the album, especially when the albums in question are those of the classical era (the seventies) of progressive rock. Few years ago I recommended a friend (who did not know very much the prog rock genre) to buy the CD "Close To The Edge" to get an idea of the amazing music of Yes. Imagine my surprise when I had to explain that the songs were not seven but three, and the album ended with "Siberian Khatru". The CD reissue (I am not sure but I think it was the 2008 remastered edition) in fact, contained seven songs including "America" and other excerpts from studio rehearsals.

This kind of commercial operations completely distort the meaning of the message that the progressive music has spread in recent decades. In the context of rock music, progressive rock has always been regarded as the maximum expression of art. The intention of the bands of the 70s was to promote a true art form through rock music. Assuming that an object of art ought not to be modified by others, how you can reprint a CD by adding more songs than the original ones? it is like adding a few poppies and daisies to Van Gogh's "Sunflowers"! For this reason, when I do a review, I prefer to completely ignore the bonus tracks and I just express an opinion on the album considering only the songs in the very first issue.

Here, however, I must make an exception.

The heart of this album is in fact represented by a bonus track: the long instrumental epic Frank. Probably, as the band explains in the liner notes of the album, if it were not for the positive reviews of Frank, this album would not have been achieved, at least in a short time. Frank is a 22-minutes epic inspired by the eponymous character of Sergio Leone's movie "Once Upon A Time In The West", played by Henry Fonda. The song was recorded for a Musea / Colossus project who wanted to include it in the album "The Spaghetti Epic" (which I already did a review on this site). I do not know why the band decided to publish it as a bonus track and not in the ordinary list of songs, perhaps for contractual reasons with Musea / Colossus. The version included in "Pilgrim" is slightly different, surely better than the version of "The Spaghetti Epic" (a short section characterized by a larger footprint rock, that has nothing to do with the rest of the epic, was cut in the middle of the track). The song is really amazing, totally instrumental, and inspired by the 70s band (especially Camel and Genesis) with intelligent use of various keyboards (church organ, mellotron, sinth) and delicate acoustic guitar arpeggios. In the first part of the song dominates the solemnity of a church organ: then, after few minutes, the same organ chords are played again in a magical piano solo. The second half of the epic sees a great guitar playing. Excellent solos evoke typically western themes. In particular, the last amazing guitar solo gives me a lot of chills: if you love prog and also like the typical music of "Spaghetti Western" movies you'll appreciate very much this fantastic great finale.

The other songs are not at the same level of Frank. Listening to the album, the most obvious flaw that you feel is the sensation of being in front of a lot of musical ideas not fully executed: for this reason some songs, especially The Book, The Deep Ocean and A Dream are a bit inconclusive . Another negative aspect that characterizes "Pilgrim" is a little monotony, and perhaps the excessive duration. The atmosphere is, more or less, almost always the same, often characterized by slow rhythms and a classical pastoral calm (in the context of contemporary prog, Andrew Marshall, aka Willowglass, makes music in a very similar way). It also does not help the lack of a singer: the presence of vocals would certainly mitigate this monotony.

Despite some negative aspects the level of the tracks is generally quite good. Walk On Land and The Magnificent Forest for example, are very beautiful, with many parts reminiscent of Camel and magical mellotron and guitar parts. Pilgrim, Giant Man, How We Used To Go and Blue Shadows are other interesting songs.

Definitely, "Pilgrim" is a good album, if you love the symphonic genre, and the magical mellotron atmospheres. The quality of the sublime epic Frank allows to obtain one more star.

So, four stars and a final rating of 7/10.

Best song: Frank

Report this review (#758575)
Posted Friday, May 25, 2012 | Review Permalink

TRION Pilgrim ratings only


chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of TRION Pilgrim


You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.