Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Submarine Silence - Journey Through Mine CD (album) cover


Submarine Silence

Rock Progressivo Italiano

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
Rock Progressivo Italiano Team
4 stars Italian symphonic group Submarine Silence, whose core line-up is comprised of guitarist David Cremoni and keyboardist/multi-instrumentalist Cristiano Roversi of Moongarden, find themselves in an interesting position for their third album, 2017's `Journey Through Mine'. The oddly titled disc combines the two worlds of the previous couple of SS albums, their fully instrumental self-titled debut from seventeen years ago (and a much-loved minor modern symphonic classic it's often considered) and the difficult to love vocal-driven `There's Something Very Strange In Her Little Room' from 2013, by offering a balance of both approaches together, with highly consistent results this time around that often lift to real greatness - vintage prog fans are in for a treat!

Submarine Silence are unashamedly influenced by the early-mid Seventies era of Genesis, but thankfully most of the time they are more a case of `inspired by' as opposed to blatantly recycling themes and motifs of that legendary English group (although little moments still pop up here and there like that, so you might need to be a little forgiving!), and they are similar in approach to international acts like the Agents of Mercy and Willowglass, and Italian groups such as The Watch (or even PFM's `Chocolate KIngs' era) that continue in the classic Genesis style. About half the pieces on `Journey...' have English lyric vocals delivered by a raspy and deeply hoarse new singer in Guillermo Gonzales, but thankfully he never tries to ape Peter Gabriel, if anything he reminds a little of Johan Hansson from the Swedish act Twin Age, another Genesis-like group, and while he will likely still prove divisive with listeners, he's a marked improvement on the singer on the previous disc `Something Very Strange...' that frequently distracted from some colourful musical backings.

Opening instrumental `The Astrographic Temple' is all dizzying synth spirals, whirring Moog sprints, Mellotron-lifted fancy, loopy electronic programming, crisply nimble electric guitar runs and punchy drums (courtesy of Emilio Pizzocoli, returning from the debut), sounding not unlike another modern group Trion. `Black Light Back' is full of pretty and dramatic atmosphere, built around haunting Mellotron choirs, sparkling twelve-string acoustic chimes in unison with weeping ethereal electric guitar strains, and Guillermo delivers a curiously charismatic and charmingly accented vocal (and a lovely highlight is the proper grand piano instead of keyboard emulation in the intro, a difference that is instantly noticeable and should be thoroughly appreciated by listeners!). `Swirling Contour' reminds of numerous 80/90's Neo-Prog bands like Grey Lady Down with its overexcited and energetic vocals, and Genesis-flavoured instrumental `Canova's Gypsoteque' swoons with all the regal organ, aching Steve Hackett-like guitar strains and haunting Mellotron choirs beloved of that band.

The twelve minute title-track `Journey Through Mine' is overloaded with heroic instrumental passages, heavy rumbling bass playing and a theatrically tortured lead vocal, but parts of it could come a little too close to branding Submarine Silence with a dreaded `clone band' tag in the way it borrows similar themes and sounds from Genesis' `Unquiet Slumbers/Quiet Earth/Afterglow' medley off their `Wind and Wuthering' LP - still sounds wonderful and proves very effective though! Gloriously romantic Andy Latimer-esque guitar reaches full of longing burn throughout soloing-heavy instrumental `Five Lands Nightwind' that will be adored by Camel fans, and `Butterflies' is a class act to close on, starting as a delicate piano ballad backing Guillermo's tenderly reflective words and voice as sweet guitar ruminations and inspiring Mellotron choirs raise everything to the heavens in a dreamily hazy finale.

Despite the fact that it doesn't do much in the way of anything new, some vocals can be a little trying and the disc does have a slightly stuffy and boxy production (although it's a welcome antidote to the over-polished lifelessly pristine sound of many modern works), `Journey Through Mine' has an authenticity to its vintage sounds, a warmth in its use of old equipment and an unending pride in the proudly grandiose symphonic prog sounds of old that plenty of vintage prog fans cherish. Submarine Silence are to be commended for stepping up in quality again here, and their latest album, that frequently unveils a very special magic, is highly deserving of more attention.

Four stars.

Report this review (#2054178)
Posted Thursday, November 8, 2018 | Review Permalink
4 stars The pure symphonic rock and the country of Italy have been a strong marriage for decades. Symfo with many keys, a lot of bombast and a lot of emotion always works well in this beautiful country. It was also the country where Genesis first achieved success at the time. They gave the lead and bands like PFM, Banco and Le Orme continued to build on the foundation of rock progressivo. There are now countless sympho bands in Italy and you can see that they are working hard to keep the traditional Italian symphoprog. Cristiano Roversi is also a man who stands for good and traditional symphonic rock. We know him mainly from his band Moongarden, but also from his long collaboration with John Wetton.

Journey Through Mine is the title of the third album under the name Submarine Silence , placing itself as an evolutionary step of the excellent There's Something Very Strange In Her Little Room (2013). The hands of Roversi (all keyboards and bass) and of the faithful and talented guitarist David Cremoni are now an indisputable trademark, which pours punctually with every listening. With the help of Emilio Pizzocoli on drums and the voice of Guillermo Gonzales, Submarine Silence stage another musical journey between old and new emotions, between consolidated reminiscences of symphonic prog and more current and stimulating insights. Fairytale sounds, the courage for sudden and modern inserts, the interesting/fantastic vocals from Gonzales, drumming that is always calibrated and perfectly functional to the performance of the songs ... from a technical- qualitative point of view, even if you want, it is complicated to find any flaws in this album. The seven pieces in the lineup offer a continuous cascade of sensations, alternating flowing instrumentals with sung passages of equal and genuine intensity. There is cohesion but at the same time variety and I believe this is the best interpretation and there are, it should be reiterated, the massive and exciting scores of the keyboards by Cristiano Roversi and the arabesques of the guitars by David Cremoni.

Of course, it remains beyond doubt that the evocative and dreamy soul of the two once again addresses the music towards emotional and vibrant coordinates; the three instrumental passages in this regard are a perfect example, suspended between dynamic and suggestive atmospheres where there is ample space for tight segments (The Astrographic Temple), episodes in which the romantic / epic vein prevails (Canova's Gypsoteque), and finally others in which all this manages to rise exponentially on an emotional level and where the growing and irrepressible phrasing between piano, keyboards and guitars leaves you breathless (Five Lands Nightwind).

On the front of the songs that include sung parts there is the good eclecticism of Guillermo Gonzales, able to pass through idyllic moments of rare intensity (Black Light Back), very marked rhythmic accents (Swirling Contour), references and involving flavors belonging to to another season of progressive (the title track), touching episodes in which the pathos reaches its peak (Butterflies).

There is not much left to add but an applause to all the members of the Submarine Silence. A must-have album, Journey Through Mine won't disappoint.

Report this review (#2601754)
Posted Tuesday, October 12, 2021 | Review Permalink

SUBMARINE SILENCE Journey Through Mine ratings only

chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of SUBMARINE SILENCE Journey Through Mine

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.