Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography

CLAUDE MONET - VOLUME 1, 1883-1889

XII Alfonso

Symphonic Prog

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

XII Alfonso Claude Monet - Volume 1, 1883-1889 album cover
2.82 | 32 ratings | 4 reviews | 16% 5 stars

Good, but non-essential

Write a review

from partners
Studio Album, released in 2002

Songs / Tracks Listing

1. Chemin dans les Falaises (3:48)
2. Je vous écrivais (3:55)
3. Giverny (4:03)
4. Un Jardin qui ne ressemble à rien (3:12)
5. Des saisons sur les toiles (2:28)
6. L'échappée Belle (4:37)
7. Conflits (3:01)
8. Les beaux jours de Giverny (3:08)
9. La Fanfare rouge (3:13)
10. Le Fantôme de l'Ile aux Orties (4:13)
11. Les Cathédrales Immergées (5:07)
12. L'oeil Cannibale (1:39)
13. Antibes (4:34)
14. Les Arcanes de l'air Bleu (6:36)
15. Errances (3:39)
16. L'Âme de l'hiver (7:00)

Total Time: 64:29

Line-up / Musicians

- Laure Oltra / lyrics
- François Claerhout / piano, keyboards, percussions, acoustic guitar, drums sampling
- Philippe Claerhout / electric guitar, acoustic guitar, electro-acoustic guitar, bass guitar, Syrian Oud, Vietnamese lute, harmonicas, keyboards, percussions
- Michael Geyre / piano, keyboards, Hammond organ, accordions, percussions
- Thierry Moreno / backing vocals, whistle, percussions

Thanks to ProgLucky for the addition
Edit this entry

Buy XII ALFONSO Claude Monet - Volume 1, 1883-1889 Music

XII ALFONSO Claude Monet - Volume 1, 1883-1889 ratings distribution

(32 ratings)
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(16%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(22%)
Good, but non-essential (44%)
Collectors/fans only (19%)
Poor. Only for completionists (0%)

XII ALFONSO Claude Monet - Volume 1, 1883-1889 reviews

Showing all collaborators reviews and last reviews preview | Show all reviews/ratings

Collaborators/Experts Reviews

Review by Finnforest
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR Honorary Collaborator
3 stars "Claude Monet volume 1" is an album of beautiful music which seeks to tell the story of Monet's life and work, volume 1 covering the years 1883-1889. It features an absolutely amazing 50 page booklet which painstaking details each piece of music on the album; providing lyrics, reprints of his paintings from these years, detailed texts describing the paintings, notes about his personal life, notes from his diary, and passages from letters to friends and family. I think it's my first CD booklet that actually has a bibliography in the back! If you are a fan of Monet you will need to get these CDs before they go out of print. It's a history lesson to be sure.

The music itself is a sweeping and ambitious symphonic work. Lush sounds are courtesy of an army of instruments: many electric and acoustic guitars, E.Bow, Syrian Oud, Vietnamese Lute, Harmonicas, many Keyboards, Pianos, Glocks, Gongs, various Percussion, Harp, Bamboo Flutes, Whistles, and several vocalists. About 14 musicians take part in the recording, give or take. It is a pastoral album but one that can veer from the peaceful to the playful, from the (almost) rocking to the near-techno. It has many enjoyable moments throughout, the quieter piano and acoustic guitar sections being my favorites. However compositionally this album is all over the map and you need to be willing to love meandering. I feel it could use significant tightening especially in the ridiculously out of place techno keyboard sections that really seem out of place given the storyline. You have a very professional, often beautiful album of moments but without much in the way of musical coherence, amazing given the amount of work dedicated to the lyrical storyline and booklet. A very mixed bag.

If you like mellow, pastoral, relaxing prog and you have an interest in Claude Monet, this release is your dream come true. If you don't care about Monet but like mellow prog you should still enjoy this quite a bit. If you are neither of the above then proceed with caution here. 5/10

Review by ZowieZiggy
2 stars So far, this French band was unable to catch my attention with their first two albums. Let's see if this "Claude Monnet Volume I" is going to be different.

In a way, it is. Different I mean. The music is intimate, peaceful and almost all instrumental (even if there are attempts to vocals, or better to spoken words). Some Hackett, as usual, ("L'oeil Cannibale") or even Oldfield feeling can be distinguished ("Giverny").

At (many) times some accordion is featured, and I can't say that I am overwhelmed by the sound of this instrument. It conveys an old fashioned sound that is not my cup of tea ("Un Jardin Qui Nous Ressemble ", "L'Échappée Belle" and a couple more). The use of this instrument is probably meant to project us in the period of Monet (the French painter who is the artist that has inspired this work).

The track "Conflits" is dark and hesitates between classical and eclectic music. It is quite special indeed. The "chanson française style" combined with classical piano of "Les Beaux Jours De Giverny" also offers little prog feel. The pastoral and moving "La Fantôme De L'île Aux Orties" is breaking the overall mood nicely. It is my favourite track on this album. The last couple of songs are truly in the symphonic jazz vein.

If you like the combination of folk ("Les Cathédrales Immergées"), classical and eclectic music, with a jazzy touch this album might deserve your listening. But my rating is two stars for this work. I am not convinced with their musical style which is hard to categorize.

Review by apps79
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR Honorary Collaborator
2 stars For many years Francois Claerhout had shown interest in the life and the works of impressionist painter Claude Monet.With a main goal to complete a whole book for his career he started writing down a few new songs, while his brother Philippe accompanied him on guitar.Soon they were found with so much material it could fill a triple-disc edition.The period between 1883 and 1889 was covered by XII Alfonso in the 2002 album ''Claude Monet vol. 1: 1883-1889'', released in 2002 on Musea.The quartet of Claerhout brothers, keyboardist Michael Geyre and Thierry Moreno was helped again by a long list of musicians, Laure Oltra on lyrics, Ian Bairnson (Kate Bush, The Alan Parsons Project) on guitar, French-Portuguese singer Bevido and even actress/actor Catherine Alcover and Claude Aufaure.

A trully impressive concept and a rich artistic package (52-page booklet illustrated by two young artists from Bordeaux, Guiral Claire and Philippe Poirier) is unfortunately supported by a no more than mediocre album, which undoubtfully serves the needs of covering Monet's life, but ending up to be only good for background music.Any symphonic moves are completely sidelined and the album sounds like a mix of Spoken Word, New Age and Prog Folk, styles with which XII Alfonso were already familiar with, but this time the final result is far from impressive.Too many lyrical passages and a very mellow atmosphere with folky and light Classical underlines, mainly performed on piano, is not the best content for a work with such an impressive background.The music is heavily relying on acoustic guitars, accordion and piano with occasional dashes of flutes and keyboards, there are even some Chamber Music arrangements and MIKE OLDFIELD-like soundscapes in here, but the flow just isn't there and the dynamics are much needed than ever, despite some good cinematic atmospheres.16 tracks as a result and only a few of them are above average, some intense symphonic electronics and a sporadic grandieur between acoustic and Film Score-like orchestrations are signs that the band was capable of producing something more intense and atmospheric.Because the rest of the album is too soft, often resembling to French Chanson or Acoustic Folk, lacking the nerve to become trully competetive, albeit some careful arrangements.

Dissapointing album.Great concept behind, but musically too smooth and calm, propably working better as a Soundtrack than a Prog Rock album.So I would recommend this mostly to anyone in love with Film Score Music.Prog Rock fans will be merely left unsatisfied.

Latest members reviews

4 stars This is the third studio offering from French proggers XII Alfonso. It's the first CD that I heard by the band, having previously been exposed to them via a snippet of a track downloaded from Ian Bairnson's (ex Alan Parsons guitarist and session man extraordinaire) website. The disc purported ... (read more)

Report this review (#38649) | Posted by Norm Cash | Wednesday, July 6, 2005 | Review Permanlink

Post a review of XII ALFONSO "Claude Monet - Volume 1, 1883-1889"

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.