Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography


Brian Auger

Jazz Rock/Fusion

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Brian Auger Definitely What (with The Trinity) album cover
2.33 | 20 ratings | 2 reviews | 0% 5 stars

Write a review

from partners
Studio Album, released in 1968

Songs / Tracks Listing

1. Day in the Life
2. George Bruno Money
3. Far Horizon
4. John Brown's Body
5. Red Beans and Rice
6. Bumpin' on Sunset
7. If You Live
8. Definitely What
9. What You Gonna Do?
10. Red Beans And Rice (Part 1) - (CD bonus track)
11. Red Beans And Rice (Part 2) - (CD bonus track)

Line-up / Musicians

-Brian Auger/ vocals, keyboards
-Dave Ambrose/ bass guitar
-Clive Thacker/ drums, percussion

Additional personnel:
-Gary Boyle /guitar
-Ray Swinfield/ flute

Releases information

LP Earmark (1968)
CD One Way (1994)

Thanks to alucard for the addition
and to snobb for the last updates
Edit this entry

Buy BRIAN AUGER Definitely What (with The Trinity) Music

More places to buy BRIAN AUGER music online

BRIAN AUGER Definitely What (with The Trinity) ratings distribution

(20 ratings)
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(0%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(35%)
Good, but non-essential (30%)
Collectors/fans only (30%)
Poor. Only for completionists (5%)

BRIAN AUGER Definitely What (with The Trinity) reviews

Showing all collaborators reviews and last reviews preview | Show all reviews/ratings

Collaborators/Experts Reviews

Review by Chicapah
1 stars As "Auge" himself says in the liner notes, he was "shocked from a warm horse trough of rancid risotto one afternoon by the news that the King of Marmalade had commissioned me to make a solo LP" that "lies along a straight line drawn between pop and jazz and aims at the fusion of both elements," something "the group has been trying to do for the past two years." Unfortunately, that informative quote turns out to be the most creative thing about the LP as their lofty aspirations proved to be more admirable than the final product, "Definitely What!"

Their bold but overly contemporary rendering of The Beatles' "A Day in the Life" starts things off. Somehow they manage to take any and all excitement out of the song by making it all sound too "groovy" and "swingin' London" hip. The strings and brass they employ throughout are suitably dynamic (thanks in no small part to the engineering skills of a young Eddie Offord) but it's so dated that you half expect Austin Powers to show up and exclaim "Yeah, baby!" Auger's "George Bruno Money" is nothing more than a corny, nostalgic big band number he dedicated to his "long-time mate and fellow tea-drinker," Zoot Money. Maybe some executive thought this could be a hit with the older generation or something but it doesn't fit here. "Far Horizon" follows and it's a bit of modern jazz that Brian wrote during "one of the bad periods that one inevitably encounters" and, alas, it sounds that way. Auger's limited voice is terribly off-key and the playing is uninspired. But it's a Grammy winner in comparison to the God- awful "John Brown's Body" that sounds like a throwaway, drunk-in-the-studio track that somehow found itself back onto the master. Embarrassing is the most flattering adjective I can attach to it.

"Red Beans and Rice" is a spirited cover of a Booker T and the MG's instrumental where the group redeems themselves somewhat from the previous disastrous cut. "Auge" turns in a decent organ solo, drummer Clive Thacker and bassist Dave Ambrose lay down an extremely tight and flowing rhythm track and it's the only tune that I would deem worthy of repeated listens. The feeling I get from this song is that somebody at Auger's label had the bright but misguided idea of turning Brian into the British version of America's master of the jazz organ, Jimmy Smith, and gave the producers carte blanche to do just that. Close, but no cigar. Their take on Wes Montgomery's "Bumpin' on Sunset" is next and I like the piece although Auger would produce a much better version with his Oblivion Express ensemble several years down the road. "If You Live" is a cocktail bar-worthy blues/jazz ditty by Mose Allison where Brian provides a fair piano ride. The album-ending "Definitely What" instrumental is as close as things come to even approaching prog but it fails miserably to be entertaining. As Auger explains in the liner notes, it was developed from "the idea of trying to play the organ as a conga drum one night when my drummer Clive was missing somewhere in a cloud of smoke." That revealing quip should tell you all you need to know about this jumbled mess of unrelated solos and noodlings.

I encourage all fans of jazz rock/fusion to explore the catalogue of Brian Auger's fine musical offerings but you should avoid this one like the plague unless you are a completionist because this ain't prog at all. In fact, it's not even a passable contemporary jazz record. Within the year the group would bring in the incomparable Julie Driscoll and record the vastly superior "Streetnoise" LP so I consider this no more than an unwise but valuable learning experience in his otherwise illustrious career. 1.4 stars.

Review by Sean Trane
3 stars Without their diva Jools, The Trinity was often written away by the pop press, but rockers knew better and this album is their first without her, and provides a good start, but it doesn't match their awesome follow- up Befour, which to be fair should be called a The Quartety, since the brilliant guitarist Gary Boyle will join them. With a usual-for-then artwork, DF is as usual a good dose of covers and its load of original songs and this was a typical product of Gomelsky (Yardbirds and many more) and one of the last of the Brit R'nB wave

The album is like most other Trinity albums, loaded with brass arrangements that Auger, Ambrose and Thacker are now so used to. Overall I'd say that most of the covers would sound a bit like a made-for- supermarket music if it weren't for Ogre's huge "Aurgan" and his tempestuous interventions. Indeed covers of Beatles' Day In Life, If You Live (a straight blues) or JB's Body (the standard track) might sound a bit odd and even lame for an uncompromising proghead. But Red Beans is a dynamite rendition; and Wes Montgomery's Bumping On Sunset is fantastic (will be reworked much later in Oblivion Express) version with excellent but discreet string arrangements.

Among the originals is an Ogre tribute for fellow organist Zoot Money (GB in the title), a slow-building brass-studded Far Horizon with a brilliant Hammond interlude, and the wild lengthy title track. Starting on whistles, than an Ambrose bass solo segueing into flute (guest Swinfield) itself leading into a Thacker drum solo and finally a Auger Hammond augeran solo. The Cd comes with a very lively What you Gonna Do, which doesn't have the same production sound, but diersn't deface the album, partly because it's bloody good.

A correct album, but not standing up to comparison to its successor Befour, DF should wait until you're sure you want more of Trinity works, and while bound to disappoint a little, DF still has its share of good moments.

Latest members reviews

No review or rating for the moment | Submit a review

Post a review of BRIAN AUGER "Definitely What (with The Trinity)"

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.