Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography



Experimental/Post Metal

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Grayceon This Grand Show album cover
3.96 | 17 ratings | 2 reviews | 29% 5 stars

Write a review

from partners
Studio Album, released in 2008

Songs / Tracks Listing

1. It Begins, and So It Ends (4:58)
2. Still The Desert (11:30)
3. Sleep (21:15)
4. Love Is (a dream) (13:27)
5. This Grand Show is Eternal (5:25)

Line-up / Musicians

- Max Doyle / guitar, vocals
- Zack Farwell / Drums
- Jackie Perez Gratz / electric cello, vocals

Releases information

Vendlus Records, Vend035

Thanks to avestin for the addition
Edit this entry

Buy GRAYCEON This Grand Show Music

More places to buy GRAYCEON music online

GRAYCEON This Grand Show ratings distribution

(17 ratings)
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(29%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(35%)
Good, but non-essential (29%)
Collectors/fans only (6%)
Poor. Only for completionists (0%)

GRAYCEON This Grand Show reviews

Showing all collaborators reviews and last reviews preview | Show all reviews/ratings

Collaborators/Experts Reviews

Review by avestin
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR Honorary Collaborator
4 stars Promotional album received from XO Press, on behalf of Vendlus Records and Grayceon

A continuation

Grayceon's s/t album was one of my favourite releases of 2007; an album I got addicted to, drowned in, in love with. With its captivating sound, the Grayceon trio with their cello-guitar-drums made a deep impact, not only on me but on a wide audience as evidenced by the numerous positive reviews they've received. It is therefore not surprising that this, their second effort, released in 2008 is one of the year's most anticipated albums, not only by myself. They face a difficult task in this aspect; following up on what to is a stellar first release and a fabulous album in itself. Where would they go from here? Do they even need to go somewhere? Is repetition enough? Or do they need to evolve progress and offer us something new not heard on the first album? I personally was curious to see how they chose to go, and was trying to keep an open mind in that regard.

What do we get? The way I hear and see it, this is an album that continues in the lines of the first one, proceeds several steps beyond that one and delivers a tighter sounding band. It might not offer much new comparing to what we heard, but there are some novel ideas thrown in there (at various points in the songs Still The Desert and Sleep for instance). But as a whole, it will sound almost familiar; not the tunes, obviously, but the atmosphere, the sounds, the interplay of the guitar and electric cello, the melancholy of the music, the crushing riffs and the thundering drums.

I felt "at home" right away with the It Beings, And So It Ends, the opening track of the album. It sounds familiar in a heart warming way, as if you've reunite with a loved one that was gone for a long time. In fact it sounds as if it starts from the middle of a track in a way, as if they were interrupted at the end of the previous album (which is correct in a way, since it ended in a fade out). The hesitant-like notes of the guitar and the cello enveloping it re-introduce us to the band's sound, to that typical gloomy mood they produce, one which I personally adore. From this quiet, calm opening, the band builds up, in their now usual style, a fascinating musical tapestry made up of interchanging tempos and varying levels of aggression, interplay of the guitar and cello and dominant drum playing. Though it is the shortest track on the album, it is a dense and packed piece covering several emotional grounds.

It goes on and links with the second song, Still The Desert, without interference, which after a short intro, present the first vocals on the album, performed by Jackie and Max with their contrasting vocals, which mirrors the relationship between their instruments. While the music, or rather the sound and frame of mind, seem familiar, there is still the captivating element here that was present in their previous album; a sound that when I hear, I can't seem to want to let it go. As they progress and build up their song, making changes to their speed and direction and then resuming the original theme of the song, I can't help but be a prisoner to their music, gulping in every drop of note they're willing to give. Even though it is still a minimalistic lineup, being a trio, their sound, when one is willing to be submerged in it, is still grand and epic. They add some new touches with some faster sections in the longer songs, a background screaming (barely noticeable though) by Jackie (in Still The Desert) and an overall sense of trying to achieve a larger impact and effect on the listener this time.

Sleep, the longest song here at over 20 minutes may be the equivalent of Ride from their first album, starting in the same delicate way, gently offering the topic of the song; however it is, unlike Ride, more coherent, more structured and clearly presented. It is a powerful song, soon escalating its raw energy level and speed and one can start imagining what a ride this can be, being such a long track. Indeed Sleep is not a representative name for this song. About a third of the song in, they do a nice fade out and introduce a new section, opening without the drums, with the Max on the guitar providing the basis for Jackie to experiment a bit with her electric cello. A psychedelic segment, where Sleep seems a more appropriate title for (but boring it is not, unless you dislike such texture building), it even reminds me of Pink Floyd's middle segments in Echoes and Atom Heart Mother where the bands creates bizarre and unearthly sounds. The band resumes the main theme about 6 minutes later, first quietly and then burst out (still slowly though), heavy, thumping sludgy-like with Jackie singing "Don't close your eyes, don't go to sleep", and later on they pick on a more rhythmic pace, as if trying to prevent the listener from falling asleep by making more "noise". One particular thing that caught me in their first album was the magnificent melodies and vocal lines. This is also present here and the most notable example for me is in the song, Love Is (A Dream), where their voices are digitally morphed as they sing the wonderful chorus line.

The album ends with a quite upbeat, bouncy and fast song, the title track, This Grand Show Is Eternal. Clocking at a bit more than 5 minutes, this relatively short song, like the opener, gathers inside a pack of energy and several ideas inside a limited frame and is the most intense song in here.

This album seems to focus as much on creating haunting textures as it is on evoking emotions through the use of catchy and beautiful melodies. In this aspect, it is another step forward from the previous album, going more in the direction of harnessing the power of their instruments combined to create a new fused sound of this lineup of three.

Like the first album, this album, much like a good wine, needs to time to breathe in the open, to be listened to several times and to get absorbed in your hearing buds. For those who know the band, it will be quicker to do so. If you're new to the band, I suggest starting with their wonderful 2007 s/t effort, released on Vendlus Records and then move on to this one. If you know and loved that first album, don't hesitate and get this! Bottom line - Grayceon delivers another stunning album.

Review by Negoba
4 stars Tasty but Strangely Spiced Post-Metalish Stew - Chamber Metal?

Those who seem to be in the know have said that Grayceon is not post-metal, but the band's music is certainly based in the atmospheric sludgy sound of that genre. However, they add some unique elements that I've heard virtually nowhere else. Jackie Perez Gratz' addition of cello and clean female vocals give Grayceon a quite unique sound. She had also contributed to the band Giant Squid, whose album I had liked and led me to THIS GRAND SHOW. As it turns out, I actually like the Grayceon album better than the Squid disc. The combination of Perez and Max Doyle's vocals is both more interesting and easier on the ears than GS's System of a Down styled singing. In addition, the cello's intrinsic role in the music just adds, well, a nice spice to the stew, perhaps hinting at maudlin of the Well.

Like Toby Driver's projects, there is something essentially beautiful about Grayceon's sound despite its melancholic drag. And while the band has a great signature sound, varies their tempos, and shows us a number of looks in their lead elements, they just don't have the bag of tricks that Driver does. No track really stands out or grabs you by the collar and demands attention. In that way, it allies itself with post-metal or even post-rock as background mood music rather than art metal that requires close attention to detail. But this is deceptive, for the additional textures make this music better than any post-metal I've ever listened to.

In fact, this is a little bit of a difficult review, as Grayceon's sound is very hard to put your finger on. But it's good. I keep coming back to it to listen again. More than Indukti (another band in this category that uses strings) as Grayceon's compositions are much better. More than Giant Squid which is just grating enough to get old before the album is over. More than Pelican. More than Isis. I suppose it comes down to the sophistication of the compositions. At this moment, I listen through the epic "Sleep" and realize how meticulously this music has been constructed. It is now that the term Chamber Metal comes into my mind.

Fans of Kayo Dot and Maudlin of the Well are almost certain to enjoy this album, though it is clearly more accessible than either of those projects. Still, this is very ambitious music that actually accomplished what so many other bands attempt and don't quite accomplish in my opinion. If there was just that sense of awe or true transcendence, this would be a masterpiece.

Latest members reviews

No review or rating for the moment | Submit a review

Post a review of GRAYCEON "This Grand Show"

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.