Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography


Framus 5

Eclectic Prog

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Framus 5 Mesto Er album cover
3.69 | 37 ratings | 3 reviews | 22% 5 stars

Excellent addition to any
prog rock music collection

Write a review

Buy FRAMUS 5 Music
from partners
Studio Album, released in 1971

Songs / Tracks Listing

1. Město ER (19:07)
2. Tys kámen (4:24)
3. Pláču (3:31)
4. Kapela (2:56)
5. Noc je můj den (4:57)
6. Perceptua (3:40)

Line-up / Musicians

Michal Prokop (vocals, guitar)
Ivan Trnka (piano)
Ladislav Eliás (bass)
Lubos Andrst (guitar)
Petr Klárfeld (drums)

Releases information

LP Supraphone 1 13 1069

Thanks to clarke2001 for the addition
Edit this entry

Buy FRAMUS 5 Mesto Er Music

FRAMUS 5 Mesto Er ratings distribution

(37 ratings)
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(22%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(46%)
Good, but non-essential (22%)
Collectors/fans only (5%)
Poor. Only for completionists (5%)

FRAMUS 5 Mesto Er reviews

Showing all collaborators reviews and last reviews preview | Show all reviews/ratings

Collaborators/Experts Reviews

Review by Marty McFly
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR Honorary Collaborator
5 stars If you're OK with brass orchestra (which helped them to distinct themselves from other bands at the time) combined with top notch Prog music + some jazzy elements (in form of soft electric guitar and sudden slowing down of pace) elements, you will love this record. I wasn't able to write this review for a long time. Too difficult music to capture its essence in words, but I'll have to try sooner or later. Not it's later.

There basically aren't traces of blues anymore. I'm also not sure to compare it with something known in "western" world, it's unique. As with most of Czech albums (ahem, when they weren't doing covers of otherwise un-accessible songs from UK/US bands). When trying to find flaws here, some non progressive elements, I'm almost unable to do so, as there is not much flaws to find.

This album is divided into side-long epic and then 5 shorter tracks + 2 bonuses. Title track Město ER (City ER) is story of crisis about being lonely in a big, desolate city in some kind of utopian/dystopian society. It's lyrical hell, because it's actually interpretation of poems by respected Czech poet Josef Kainar. Musically, it shows one of the best epics ever coming from Czechoslovakia, full of drum, keyboards, guitar solos, having weird, melancholic atmosphere and it's far from being empty track full of nothing. Don't expect repetition, this is highly original work. Whispered parts of lyrics, shouted ones, haunting keyboards (at times), solid drumming backing, very qualite guitar by Lubo? Andr?ť, even Psychedelic elements to be found here.

The rest of album isn't as good. How could it be in the shadow of this. But they're not dull, even not as good, they are trying to fight for their place on the sun

5(-), almost.

Review by apps79
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR Honorary Collaborator
3 stars Not very well-known among Prog fans, Framus Five was definitely a legend of rock music within the Czechoslovakian borders.Formed in Praha in 1963, they were led by singer/guitarist Michal Prokop, keyboardist Ivan Trnka and bassist Ladislav Elias (he joined the band in 1967) during their early phase.Originally the band relied much on its reinforced horn section and their 1969 debut ''Blues in soul'' was exactly what its title suggested, an amalgam of Blues, Rock and Soul influences.By 1970 with newcomers guitarist Lubos Andrst and drummer Karel Jahn their style shifted towards more intricate paths.The album ''Mesto ER'', released in 1971 on Supraphon, featured several guest and previous members on drums and bass.

The whole story regarding this album is centered around the impressive attempt on the 19-min. title-track, which sounds a lot like MODRY EFEKT, drawing influences from Classical Music, Jazz, Psychedelic Rock and Soul.A great piece with excellent singing by Prokop and many different instrumental segments with romantic, dramatic and dark tendencies, evolving from orchestral movements to powerful, Soul-inspired horn parts and some sort of psychedelic overtones and containing some great organ washes and piano lines next to some dominant work on trumpets and strings.This piece has aged quite well despite its psychedelic lines, there are even some moments of intense Kraut-like jamming in here and a couple of moments with ethereal flute work, while the connections between the variations is trully convincing with the star of Andrst shining through his unmistakable guitar moves.Beautiful piece of art.The flipside of the original vinyl is not that convincing, it's standard Psychedelic/Jazz/Horn Rock, again Andrst's work on guitar is great with both psychedelic and jazzy inspirations, while Prokop's voice is always expressive and tireless.These numbers contain also Orchestral Pop textures, slight Folk influences and evident Soul and Blues touches, executed in accesible structures with split dynamic and mellow passages.Good tracks, but far from the musical concept of the album's centerpiece.

The band dissolved the same year only to return in 1978 with Prokop as the only original member, releasing four standard Rock albums, until a second demise occured in 1990.In 2000 a third reunion took place and Framus Five continued their career via studio and live performances.

Good document of early-70's East-European Psych/Prog.A great vocalist, a flexible sound and some unmet atmospheres of sheer beauty await every listener of obscure Prog throughout the album's title-cut.Recommended.

Review by GruvanDahlman
3 stars The progression of music behind the Iron curtain is baffling and impressive. Despite oppression and hardship talented people managed to not only imitate but enhance and develop their own brand of progressive rock. While they must have been influenced by what took place in the West there is most certainly a very unique tone in east European prog that is not to be found anywhere else. One of my favorite bands of all time is Modry Efekt, a group that managed to develop and progress at an immense rate in just a decade or so. Framus 5 is Czech aswell and besides Poland the Czechozlovakia (as it was known) is the country that I find produced the finest brand of prog in the eastern parts of Europe. Why that is I don't know.

"Mesto ER" is an album of great interest but holds some lacklustre moments aswell. The majestic title track is one impressive track that goes on for almost 20 minutes. The opening, brooding organ is great and sets the stage for a musical experience quite enjoyable. Musically I hear echoes of the excursions made by Modry Efekt circa the "Nova synteza" album, that is jazz rock with horns. I love that kind of music, big band prog as it might be labelled. This is a great, epic piece of music that needs to be heard. I think it is very dense and foreboding. The rest of the tracks are, unfortunately, quite lacklustre and dwells in the territory of blues. It is not surprising that they do include these blues elements as they, like so many other bands, started out in that way. I like blues very much but I fear it has no real place here.

So, in conclusion one might say that the title track is an amazing example of east European prog but the other tracks lack the progressive and enthralling elements required to amuse me. Still, this is an album worth having on the basis of the title track, since it is a fine example of progressive jazz rock. Though the title track is worth four stars, the album as a whole gets three out of five.

Latest members reviews

No review or rating for the moment | Submit a review

Post a review of FRAMUS 5 "Mesto Er"

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.