Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography


Beat Circus

Prog Folk

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Beat Circus Boy From Black Mountain album cover
3.90 | 11 ratings | 2 reviews | 0% 5 stars

Write a review

from partners
Studio Album, released in 2009

Songs / Tracks Listing

1. The February Train (4:16)
2. The Life You Save May be Your Own (2:59)
3. Boy From Black Mountain (5:47)
4. Clouds Moving In (1:25)
5. Petrified Man (3:43)
6. As I Lay Dying (4:13)
7. Saturn Song (3:26)
8. The Course of the River (1:45)
9. The Quick and the Dead (5:00)
10. The Sound and the Fury (4:11)
11. Judgment Day (3:55)
12. Nantahala (3:47)
13. Lullabye for Alexander (1:58)

Total Time 46:25

Line-up / Musicians

- Brian Carpenter / vocals, harmonica, accordion, piano, trumpet, tambourine, harmonium
- Paran Amirinazari / violin, backing vocals
- Jordan Voelker / viola, backing vocals
- Paul Dilley / upright bass, acoustic guitar
- Andrew Stern / electric guitar, tenor banjo
- Doug LaRosa / trombone
- Ron Caswell / tuba
- Gavin McCarthy / drums
- Larkin Grimm / vocals
- Ellen Santaniello / voice
- Julia Kent / cello
- Bill Cole/ Chinese Suona

Releases information


Thanks to Evolutionary_Sleeper for the addition
Edit this entry

Buy BEAT CIRCUS Boy From Black Mountain Music

More places to buy BEAT CIRCUS music online

BEAT CIRCUS Boy From Black Mountain ratings distribution

(11 ratings)
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(0%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(64%)
Good, but non-essential (27%)
Collectors/fans only (9%)
Poor. Only for completionists (0%)

BEAT CIRCUS Boy From Black Mountain reviews

Showing all collaborators reviews and last reviews preview | Show all reviews/ratings

Collaborators/Experts Reviews

Review by JLocke
4 stars From the very first time I heard this album, I loved it. Now, I'm not much for Country music, but the mixture of southern elements with the Avant-Garde Rock stylings make for some of the most entertaining music I've heard this year. Too bad last year (the year it was released) I missed out on this little gem. I think in terms of creativity and eclecticism, Beat Circus is surely near the top right now. This album contains everything from symphonic strings and bluegrass banjo to hard rocking guitars and tubas.

''The February Train'' is an absolutely gorgeous opener, featuring Carpenter's unique and spine-tingling voice singing a lovely melody, accompanied by an incredibly string section. Altogether, it makes for a wonderful way to begin the album.

''The Life You Save May be Your Own'' is the first Country song on the record, full of traditional melodies and harmonica. Not a bad track, but it's sounds half-finished, and almost serves as a precursor to a much stronger song, ''Petrified Man'', that will come later on.

''Boy From Black Mountain''. The title track is also the longest one, and it is a very good ballad, full of soaring strings and choir vocals. It's one of the many high points on the record, and certainly cannot be missed. It almost sounds like it was composed for a film.

''Clouds Moving In'' is one of the weakest tracks, is too short to really go anywhere. It basically consists of jumping, bubbly violins, and could serve as a decent intro to something bigger, but just when you think it's going to move into a new direction, it ends. In my opinion, a song that doesn't even need to be there, and it drags the complete album experience down a little.

''Petrified Man'' is the first song from this album that I heard, and it is still one of my favorite Beat Circus tunes. It sounds very similar to track number two, but is clearly a development of the theme, and a very enjoyable listen, if you ask me. Again, a very southern-y song, but much better than your typical country fare.

''As I Lay Dying''. Probably the funniest track, full of goofy, over-the-top vocal styles and musical patters. At the same time, very exciting and just a lot of fun. Make particular note of the high-pitched hooting and hollering in the style of a traditional hoedown flanking the tubas and trombones of a big band.

''Saturn Song'' is among the more unconventional tracks, and this tradition will continue for most of the remainder of the album. It opens up with some funky banjo and ends with classical violins.

''The Course of the River'' continues that classical vibe, with cellos and violins starting things off on a very stylish note. Soon enough, though, harmonica and electric guitar join in as well as upright bass for a very nice meeting of the styles. This track isn't very long and is instrumental. Unlike the''CLouds Moving In'' track, however, it isn't filler. I really enjoy it.

''The Quick and the Dead''. The deep, gravelly vocal stylings of Carpenter mirroring the wailing, frantic strings is the brightest spot in this track for me. Of course the other instruments serve their purposes as well. In fact, ANY moment on the record in which Carpenter brings his voice down to a britone low, it makes my day. The man is a masterful singer, and seems to have an indefinite monopoly on the amount of range or theatrical flourishes he can hold. Around the 2:30 mark is enough reason alone to hear this song.

''The Sound and the Fury''. When I said things were going to continue in the unconventional direction, I wasn't kidding. This is a song that starts off with string-accompanied female vocals. No lyrics, just wordless melody. I'm assuming the voice belongs to Ellen Santaniello. Not long after this has begun, things switch into a very different mode, and it sounds like a Henry Cow song. After a little more craziness, the best part of the song happens. An off-beat bass line serves as the star instrument for awhile, as we hear distant chanting of children in the background. It's unnerving, and possibly a little disturbing. I absolutely adore it. Some more strings and wordless singing come in one final time before the reprise of the distant, monotone chanting. The song ends on a very dark, unsettling note. Get ready, because more darker edged music is just around the corner.

''Nantahala'' is by far my favorite song on the entire album. It's astoundingly brilliant. It begins with what sounds like pre-recorded violin , which then builds into many violins, and they are all playing the same, relentless string of notes with fury and angst. Once the radio speaker effect leaves and you can hear the sound of the strings in all their clear, open brilliance, the best part of the album comes in. Around thirty seconds in to the track, a pumping, heavy, relentless electric guitar lead breaks in, and it continues to build and built over the course of the song until every ounce of open air is swallowed up in its wake. The ever-going violins underneath the distorted star instrument makes for a very delicious dichotomy, and while this is undoubtedly my most prized moment of the album, it is also arguably the most 'prog' moment on the record. Everything about this track just shines, and when the song is over much too soon, I often find myself having to hit the 'back' button and listen to it again. 'Brilliant' is the only word that describes this.

''Lullaby for Alexander''. After a long silence (most likely giving the listener a chance to process all the frantic weirdness that has ensued, and catch their breath), the final track comes in as softly and gently as it possibly can, easing the listener into the final musical movement that serves as a the bright light at the end of the dark (and incredibly eclectic) tunnel that is Boy From Black Mountain. I don't really know the last time I fell this instantly in love with an album without needing a lot of time for it to grow on me. This one just instantly clicked. I don't know if it was the quirky, heavily southern-tinged Avant-Garde approach, the beauty and unconventional composition or perhaps it's just meant to remain a mystery, but something about this album in particular spoke to me instantly, and I've been in love with it ever since.

For me, this is hands-down one of the best surprises I've had in a long time. I think anybody who has even a little bit of an open mind will enjoy the hell out of Boy From Black Mountain, and so I am giving this a solid 4. One pointless track (in my opinion) keeps it as a whole from reaching the heights that other albums have for me, and the sudden steer into the darkness during the album's second half might make for a slightly unbalanced listen for some, but weak or uninspired this is certainly not. One of the coolest new bands I have discovered in recent years, Beat Circus has hit it out of the park with this release.

Very happy listening.

Review by ClemofNazareth
4 stars Following two decent albums that nonetheless sound at times like samplers, Brian Carpenter and the Beat Circus sound finally congeal into something both cohesive and eminently memorable. 'Boy From Black Mountain' reveals Carpenter's A-League game, both completing his "Weird American Gothic" trilogy and announcing the arrival of a serious contender for the next great American music icon.

The previous albums 'Dreamland' and 'Ringleader's Revolt' primarily tackled subjects of fairly obscure United States history as well as absurd vignettes centered around themes of circuses, vaudeville and a time when Americans were as na´ve as they were brash and indefatigably optimistic and blithe about their harsh but promising existence. This time around the subject matter is a bit darker, but every bit as energetic and uncompromising.

Carpenter took his young autistic son as inspiration for much of this material, and his compassionate yet stalwart sense of love and survival come through poignantly on the gorgeous title track and on "Saturn Song" ("boy from Saturn, he doesn't deal too well with crowds?").

Elsewhere he spins the hard yarn of a watermelon-farming family ("The Life You Save May be your Own"); a docile coal miner ("Petrified Man"); and a brash country kid turned gunslinger facing down his brother's murderer ("The Quick and the Dead"), all set to steam- train chugging rhythms with a musical heartbeat befitting the millions who toiled to create their nation.

Carpenter surrounds himself with a remarkable cast of stellar musicians, most notably the flawless violinist Paran Amirinazari, violist Jordan Voelker and Girls Guns and Glory string bassist Paul Dilley. Andrew Stern of Boston trio Fat Little Bastard delivers on guitar and banjo, while Doug LaRosa (trombone), Ron Caswell (tuba) and Gavin McCarthy (drums) anchor the delightful collage of sounds. Carpenter himself does most of the singing when he's not blasting his trumpet or playing harmonica, harmonium accordion and piano. To a man and woman each member delivers with superb professionalism and passion. The octet shows their chops most concisely on the four instrumental tracks, particularly the closing "Lullaby for Alexander". Former Rasputina cellist Julia Kent, folk-chanteuse Larkin Grimm and former Zorgina vocalist Ellen Santaniello also make guest appearances.

I could go on for quite a while about each track on this album, but would have to preface that exercise with a spoiler alert, and frankly any fan of genuine Americana music deserves to experience the album for themselves. I can't quite bring myself to tag this one a masterpiece, but it sure as hell is about as close as you can get and who know, maybe time will prove me wrong. Four out of five stars and very enthusiastically recommended. Try Beat Circus on for size, you won't regret the trip.


Latest members reviews

No review or rating for the moment | Submit a review

Post a review of BEAT CIRCUS "Boy From Black Mountain"

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.