Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography


Amon Düül II


From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Amon Düül II Bee As Such [Aka: Düülirium] album cover
2.79 | 18 ratings | 5 reviews | 6% 5 stars

Write a review

from partners
Studio Album, released in 2010

Songs / Tracks Listing

1. Mambo La Libertad / On The Highway (8:34)
2. Du Kommst Ins Heim (9:22)
3. Stil Standing / Standing In The Shadow (8:15)
4. Psychedelic Suite: Back To The Rules / Walking To The Park (26:02)

Total time 52:13

Line-up / Musicians

- Renate Knaup / vocals
- John Weinzierl / guitars, synth, vocals, producer
- Chris Karrer / guitar, violin, sax, oud, vocals
- Lothar Meid / bass, vocals
- Danny Fichelscher / drums
- Jan Kahlert / percussion, vocals

- Gerard Carbonell / bass (unconfirmed)

Releases information

Artwork: Henry Stag (2014)

MP3 download from band's site (2010, Germany) Originally entitled "Bee As Such", no artwork

LP Purple Pyramid - CLP 1804 (2014, US) Renamed "Düülirium"

CD Purple Pyramid - CLP 1808 (2014, US) Renamed "Düülirium"

Thanks to fluiddruid for the addition
and to Quinino for the last updates
Edit this entry

Buy AMON DÜÜL II Bee As Such [Aka: Düülirium] Music

More places to buy AMON DÜÜL II music online

AMON DÜÜL II Bee As Such [Aka: Düülirium] ratings distribution

(18 ratings)
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(6%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(17%)
Good, but non-essential (39%)
Collectors/fans only (22%)
Poor. Only for completionists (17%)

AMON DÜÜL II Bee As Such [Aka: Düülirium] reviews

Showing all collaborators reviews and last reviews preview | Show all reviews/ratings

Collaborators/Experts Reviews

Review by Guldbamsen
3 stars Black hole night nurse

Wow - just WOW!! How is it even possible for an album made by one of Krautrock's finest to be this neglected - completely overlooked? This has got to be one of the best kept secrets inside the world of progressive music. Sure, the fact that Bee as Such only is available as a download off of the band's website, and that it hasn't even received a proper art work as of yet - and baby we're talking 2012 now - it has been 3 years for crying out loud!!! -Maybe just maybe that has something to do with the remarkable obscurity surrounding the release, but whatever the reasons may be, and whatever the intentions behind all of this hush hush - keep it on the down low big boy, it certainly doesn't complement the music found within. From this Danes' perspective, it is a crying shame.

The purpose of the album, back in April of 2009 when Renate Knaup, John Weinzierl, Lothar Meid, Chris Karrer, Danny Fichelscher, Jan Kahler and Gerard Carbonell entered the Dreamscape studios, was to remove themselves from the past and the Krautrock that had formed them - focusing entirely on making music for the new millennium. That may all very well have been their intentions, but the fact of the matter is that with an all-star cast like that - including some inspiring and psychedelic twin guitar serenades like fiery phoenixes, we were never going to get anything less than a solid and highly esoteric Krautrock album - Amon Düül ll style!

Renate sounds as witchy and foreboding as ever - reminding me of some ancient sea nymph luring men of the big blue oceans out on long strenuous ordeals just to wind up in the embrace of this poisonous female. John Weinzierl's playing is just like I remember it to be - high and mighty - constantly playing around with a loose notion of what he wants - relying on the instrument itself to make up the rest of the story as the music slowly unfolds and reveals its deepest and darkest secrets. Multi-instrumentalist Chris Karrer still sports an undying love of quirky instillations, and the way he approaches any given instrument is a thing of beauty. Come violins come saxophone - he is truly your man - AND he plays a mean guitar as well. Then we've got Lothar Meid who sits in the middle of the proceedings like a big fat Buddha - relegating warm and fuzzy blasts off his unique bass. He is a building block in himself. In short: Every band member is in top form, and whether the aforementioned idea of making music for the millennium ignited something special or these old warhorses just clicked and made music untethered and in the spirit of the moment - or it indeed was a combination of the both, still remains to be revealed, but the outcome sure is thrilling and rocking.

Comprised of 4 tracks one could be led into thinking that Bee as Such is but a brief exercise in music, but with a closing cut lasting some 26 wonderful minutes - you'd be wrong. It lasts nearly an hour. Every tune leading up to this monster of a closer take different routes - wandering freely around in pelting rock gymnastics, pseudo folk aspirations and teutonic gulps of towering Krautrock. If anything, I think this album has everything to do with the past. Albums such as Yeti and Tanz der Lemminge are timeless. They don't fit into boxes - and they certainly aren't ancient artefacts that speak about a once lost generation of musicians that dared to go outside of the confines of modern music. NO - it is infinitely more than that! It was and still is about the music and what it achieves in that fleeting moment, when it reaches your ears. It can literally become the whole world - speak for the whole world - and in sentences you understand with body and mind - only fuller and more intensely. Bee as Such has fragments of this. It dares to be something that is as modern and hip as a bicycle, but that doesn't change its usage and the way we are able to cherish it. I ride my bike every day, I'll have you know!

This is not the past, the present or the future, but it is some sort of hybrid of the three. It is Krautrock - and a damn fine example of it too. My only plea is that they release this little chameleon as a tangible entity. Something I can hold and lick - and something I can stare at, whenever I dream myself away on those German starry night skies with dark and sombre blues and blacks engulfing me, as if a black hole picked me up in its arms and cradled me to the gentle bobbing of Amon Düül ll.

Review by Rivertree
3 stars Don't know how it comes that they announce this album to be the first one since 28 years? Since 'Vortex' yes, but 'Nada Moonshine' from 1995 seems to be a valuable band album too methinks. Okay, never mind, probably they disregard it for personal reasons. Recorded in April 2009 at the Dreamscape Studios in Munich this one consists of four recordings, where the first three seem to be excerpts from way more extended sessions apparently. Originally it was planned to release this stuff on vinyl and CD too, but 'til today even the official cover art is missing, notified to be Falk Rogner's task on their official website.

One can argue if this is typical kraut rock as such, and their current style is not very close to what they've created in the 1970's. Though it's surely original and experimental, provided with some glowing avantgarde appeal. This predominantly due to the weird, unusual multilingual vocals and recitatives performed by Chris Karrer and Renate Knaup-Krötenschwanz. While the instrumental skills are still proper, this truely is amounting to the sensation here. The opening garagey Mambo La Libertad cannot catch me really, the following German menace Du Kommst Ins Heim shows Karrer playing his violin in a clean manner, a very ambitious song I must say, and you are faced with some improvised vocal acrobatics which are simply ... provoking? ... amazing?

For me it's the Psychedelic Suite which attracts attention basically, improvisation is the name of the game - and this comes closer to what I associate with Amon Düül 2. I mean the initial crawling behaviour decorated with violin and wonderful psychedelic guitars which are nicely swirling around. Renate alternates between German and English language, very expressive, I can smell the spirit. Somewhere in between this even sounds like they are losing control completely. What a blame though, aren't they experienced musicians? So what, all happens with intent, you know.

Currently only available per download from their website 'Bee As Such' is a very special attempt, not for everyone's taste - as for that they simply remain true to their principles. It only remains for me to add that the production is professionally recorded, technically flawless. And yes ... they still can stand on the stage! If you are looking for something really off the beaten path, check this out - 3.5 stars.

Review by Neu!mann
2 stars Comeback albums aren't normally as haphazard as this belated effort by one of Krautrock's essential forefathers: recorded in 2009; offered as a digital download under the name "Bee as Such" in 2010; and four years later finally given a legitimate CD release, with a better title and actual sleeve art...everything except a credible performance, sadly.

In truth the music by itself is fine, and doesn't show a trace of anachronism. All of it was clearly improvised in the studio, but in a more groovy modern fashion than the embryonic freakouts of "Phallus Dei" et al. A cheap comparison could be made to the valedictory CAN album "Rite Time" (1989), a likewise late-in-the-day reunion with a similar (but more successful) vibe, also curiously delayed in post-production.

Maybe the new Düül album should have been considered as a strictly instrumental project. The musical rapport was still there, and surprisingly vital after so many years away. But the vocals by old comrades Renate Knaup and Chris Karrer are - to put it delicately - a calamity: hoarse, abrasive, and fatally off-key.

Krautrock has always been full of eccentric singers able to exploit their amateur lack of training (think of Can's Malcolm Mooney). But there's a big difference between non-professional and plain bad, and that line was emphatically crossed here. I'm reminded of Timothy Leary's cringe-worthy performance on the notorious ASH RA TEMPEL train wreck "Seven Up", something no sane listener ever needs to hear a second time.

The fingernails-on-chalkboard effect reaches its nadir throughout the 26-minute "Back to the Rules/Walking in the Park" (aka "Psychedelic Suite", on the "Bee as Such" version). Here, the attempts at improvising a freeform vocal accompaniment to an already exploratory jam stand out like a mangled (i.e. more than simply sore) thumb.

Needless to say, the new album is no "Yeti"...despite some abominable moments. It's reassuring to know the old-timers still have a pulse, but this session wasn't worth the long wait. Better late than never? Don't be too sure...

Review by Mellotron Storm
3 stars It's pretty awesome that this band is still making music after all of these years. And the fact that that Krautrock spirit is still alive and well in their music only adds to my admiration for this legendary band. They released this as a digital download only back in 2009 and called "Bee As Such" then it got a physical release in 2014 and they called it "Duulirium" after the title of a bonus track on a "Wolf City" re-issue. Renate and Chris share the vocal duties often on the same track while I would also mention the many intricate sounds found on this recording.

"On The Highway(Mambo Le Liberta)" features sparse sounds throughout and I really like the tone of the guitar. Vocals join in sounding rough like Captain Beefheart. Renate joins in vocally around 2 1/2 minutes. There's a little more intensity after 6 1/2 minutes with the guitar and vocals in particular but the song never does really breakout. "Du Kommst Ins Heim" opens with Renate's vocal melodies along with a beat, violin and some experimental sounds. Lots of intricate and sparse sounds then we get some silly and strange vocals before 5 1/2 minutes. "Standing In The Shadow" starts out with percussion, bass and odd sounds before the male vocals arrive a minute in. Renate starts singing after 2 minutes as the song becomes catchy. Male vocals too as they trade off and also sing together.

"Back To The Rules/ Walk To The Park" is the 26 minute closer and the only reason I'm not giving this a higher rating. For such a long song this does little for me. This is very sparse with percussion to start as faint vocal melodies arrive around 2 minutes in. Renate starts to sing in a relaxed manner. The song seems to come to life 7 minutes in and violin joins in around 9 minutes. More vocals join in at 10 1/2 minutes then there is silence before those sparse sounds return. A catchy beat with guitar and vocals arrives after 12 minutes. Vocal melodies and guitar 17 1/2 minutes in as it continues to be sparse sounding until around the 20 minute mark when fast paced spoken male vocals kick in with guitar, bass and drums. Some nice guitar late.

While this was better than I thought it would be I can't rate this higher than 3 stars.

Review by Lewian
3 stars I have for long toyed around with the idea of reviewing this. There are some good reviews around already that give you an impression of the ambiguity one can feel when listening to this, and ultimately I can see how one can love or hate this, but most seem to go in the middle of the rating range for its obvious qualities and drawbacks.

On the positive side, this is a very fresh, creative, and original album. Much of it is improvised. The last track is probably a fully free improvisation whereas the first three have some composition but are performed in a very free way. This is not nostalgic in the least, it has its very own character that uses some modern elements and sounds while at the same time pointing to the free and somewhat naive nature of the earliest material of the band; it is also dominated by traditional electric guitar, bass and drums, if with some electronic additions. My two favourite tracks are the second and third one. "Du kommst ins Heim" means "You go to the care home" in a way that this could be said in an authoritative manner to an elderly person who has lost their marbles. The musicians were in their early sixties at the time when this was recorded, and I hope still in good shape, still I like them taking on this topic at advanced age, with some allusion to the fact that Amon Düül II have always been crazy and wild and were at the very least in the early days misunderstood and sniffed at by mainstream culture. This (and the whole album) is a clearly a statement that they don't plan to become civilised ever, and that there have been and will be voices telling them "Du kommst ins Heim" at any time of their career and surely still (or again) at old age. The music on this one is quite structureless and mostly improvised, very well fitting the theme of the track, with some crazy word play by Renate, who comes over on this album as even more crazy and witchy than ever, and Chris, who sticks to his well known smoky anti-singing. (Stay away from the album if you need beautiful voices and melodic in-tune singing - this is all about expression of moods and mostly probably better understood as artfully spoken text than singing!)

"Standing in the Shaddow" is what most resembles a rock song on the album with a very solid rhythmic spine, and traditional Amon Düülish bass and guitar. The beginning is composed, but it later devolves into another improvisation. It comes with some fun electronic noises adding to the rhythm that work very well. The first track "On the Highway" is something of a hymn to the freedom of expression and against narrow views, with which they were apparently confronted a lot. It's the track I like least on the album, because it is let down by very static drumming (there is some pretty good and some outright annoying drumming on this album - not sure why obviously existing ability was underused here) and it is quite repetitive - actually they are repetitive all over the place, which makes sense in an improvisation and can come with its own appeal - just on this track I don't think what they are repeating is that worthwhile.

The album ends with a 26 minutes improvisation Back to the Rules/Walking in the Park, which has its highs and lows. It starts off in a very subtle manner and has some nice free experimentation. It is pretty dynamic and varied; on the negative side I think that they devote some more time and repetition to less interesting parts, and some other parts would have deserved more focus.

It is half refreshing and half annoying to hear such a supposedly naive and direct approach of seasoned and experienced musicians. There are times when I totally love this, but at some other time I think "try harder"... devoting some more time and elaboration to this album could have improved a number of parts of the album, although they would probably have thought that it could have destroyed the spontaneous character of the album.

It takes some guts to come out with an album like this, and surely they always had them. Ultimately I'm happy that we have this. 11 years after this was recorded there is no sign of maybe another album coming (they were playing live as late as 2018 though), and if this will be their last album, they will have finished their discography with something unique and fresh. Fine by me. If I devote myself properly to listening and I'm in the right mood, I love it (or let's say most of it), but the provocatively amateurish character of some of this can annoy me at times. 3.4 stars.

Latest members reviews

No review or rating for the moment | Submit a review

Post a review of AMON DÜÜL II "Bee As Such [Aka: Düülirium]"

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.