Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography


Gandalf's Fist


From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Gandalf's Fist From a Point of Existence album cover
3.69 | 79 ratings | 6 reviews | 15% 5 stars

Excellent addition to any
prog rock music collection

Write a review

from partners
Studio Album, released in 2012

Songs / Tracks Listing

1. The Tale of William Small (2:25)
2. From a Point of Existence (Parts I-V) (16:34) :
- Part I: Obscuration (0:00-3:50)
- Part II: Ascension (3:50-5:40)
- Part III: Purgatory (5:40-8:53)
- Part IV: The Fall (8:53-14:13)
- Part V: Otherworld (14:13-16:34)
3. Gathering of the Clouds (9:18)
4. There and Back Again (5:29)
5. Crestfallen (6:43)
6. Monolith (6:00)
7. From a Point of Existence (Parts VI-X) (13:32) :
- Part VI: Singularity (0:00-3:18)
- Part VII: Isaiah 38:18 (3:18-5:11)
- Part VIII: Mooncode (5:11-7:27)
- Part IX: Contemplations (7:27-11:35)
- Part X: The Page Turns (11:35-13:32)

Total Time 60:01

Line-up / Musicians

- Luke Severn / lead vocals
- Dean Marsh / lead vocals, guitars, keyboards, synth, percussion, composer

- Aisling Marsh / backing vocals (5)

Releases information

Artwork: Aisling Marsh

CDr self-released (2012, UK)

Thanks to mogol for the addition
and to projeKct for the last updates
Edit this entry

Buy GANDALF'S FIST From a Point of Existence Music

GANDALF'S FIST From a Point of Existence ratings distribution

(79 ratings)
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(15%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(50%)
Good, but non-essential (31%)
Collectors/fans only (3%)
Poor. Only for completionists (1%)

GANDALF'S FIST From a Point of Existence reviews

Showing all collaborators reviews and last reviews preview | Show all reviews/ratings

Collaborators/Experts Reviews

Review by tszirmay
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR Honorary Collaborator
3 stars "From a Point of Existence" delves even deeper into the classic prog concept album theme that made our genre so polarizing, exalting some, exasperating others. I particularly enjoyed Gandalf's Fist's previous "Road to Darkness" and its "Wizard of Oz" imagery, a delectable album of wholly entertaining music, worthy of many immediate returns (the ones that make it to the automobile audio system, as I do have 6 speakers in my new Civic) . This is an evolution of sorts, denser, less obvious Floydian aromas abound, inserting old- school prog moves (see Gryphon, Deep Purple, Tull, The Doors, Gentle Giant, Ant Phillips etc..) but unqualifiedly exalting in a myriad of ways, with a few head scratches to keep one on edge.

Pastoral beginnings as the acoustic guitar takes the spotlight, surrounded by leafy adornments, introduce the story of William Small, a personage that will meander through the storyline, unabated. Ice cream maker by trade and lost soul by psychedelic standards, the tale weave its merry path, through a byzantine labyrinth of moods, styles and musical expression. The title track is a 16 minute+ mini-epic that takes hold right away and never lets go. The tracks are drenched in deep atmosphere featuring breezy singing from a fastidious voice in Luke Severn, with burnished instrumental enhancements ranging from the fragile to the frenetic. Dean Marsh is unafraid to keep the pot boiling, severing the existing tight parameters of Neo-prog with heavy space contours, in way like a milder Hawkwind, veering into distant realms and back to the comfort zone, seemingly at will. So was "Obscuration" and "Ascencion", so the aptly named "Purgatory" rages into meatier rock contours, rowdy mellotron and tactile synths howling behind the riffing guitars. This is no angelic realm, so unconditional is the pounding. On the next subsection, "The Fall" the melancholia is chaotic, almost paranoid and definitely lysergic, like a heavy- prog "Yellow Submarine" with balls. This will take a few sittings to absorb, a little bit too harsh for my lately romantic moods but great music, without a doubt.

"Gathering Clouds" is perhaps closer to the Road of Darkness sessions, sounding almost like a compliment to the sparkling "The Council of Anderson", it being the highlight track of their young career, in my opinion. But the tone is heavier, brasher and nastier, as if the band wanted a harder sound. Mind you, a gathering of clouds can often be an ominous affair, so they are sticking to their guns. There is a slight hint of 'Locomotive Breath' in the verses, sounding very early 70s and mind-numbing the listener into some form of submission. A clear guitar solo swerves into sudden hysteria, bluesy and rabid, flexible yet linear, finishing off hot and bothered (the way a darn prog solo should be!).

"There and Back Again" just does not do it for me, never a fan of overtly American-style pop balladry. But others do enjoy this. So be it but the Lynyrd Skynyrd dual axe blowout leaves me ill at ease. Not their style and it does not firt seamlessly into the mix. "Crestfallen" booms along like some fiery Exocet missile, nowhere nearly as gigantic and symphonic as the Anathema song of the same name but settles in compellingly into some danger zones. Good but not as great as I was hoping "Monolith" as the name implies keep the mood salty and sweltering, wallowing in a thundering surge of psychedelia, becoming the best of the last three tracks by a mile, with a comfortable repetitive riff that marches along obediently. My favorite track here.

The title track part 2 continues where the first left off, heavy machinery barreling down the prog highway, a 13 minute + stretch of that restates the original craziness but the style is not that far removed from more metal acts and that's what bothers me. It's just not my cup of tea, so I won't even criticize it, wholly unwarranted on my behalf.

Nice cover work. .

I definitely prefer "Road to Darkness" only because I have listened to it so many times, knowing it almost by heart and adoring it so. This heavier offering stays the course and is a pleasant addition to the previous masterpiece but I doubt very much it can ever hope to surpass it.

I guess it may need a few more spins......

3.5 wee Liam Chromosomes

Review by Second Life Syndrome
3 stars As a huge Lord of the Rings fan, I was hoping to find a gem in the band Gandalf's Fist. However, after hearing their latest, I come away unimpressed. To be sure, it has everything I want: great guitar lines, interesting lyrics, etc. etc. However, there is something that isn't quite right.

The first problem is the vocalist. The vox aren't bad at all, but the overall mix of the album leaves much to be desired. The powerful guitars drown out everything, especially the lightweight vocals. I feel that this is less a result of a lack of skill and more of a result of having a vocalist that isn't quite ready to be standing up with the big boys. His voice is okay, but needs work.

I also found the compositions to be rather dull. They aren't very imaginative, and are usually rather straightforward. Even the multi-part From a Point of Existence is pretty dull and never gives me anything to anticipate. Then, of course, there is the track "Monolith" that is completely different with an interesting groove that keeps your attention. This is probably the strongest track here. This album isn't bad or revolting, but it sure is safe and rather unremarkable. There are a couple glimmers of good ideas here, and it's worth a listen. Just, don't get your expectations too high.

Latest members reviews

4 stars Weirdly named Gandalf's Fist is classified here on PA as neo-prog. The style usually associated with neo is the radio-friendly marriage of Pink Floydian atmospherics and Genesis theatricality. This is not that. I guess I could characterize the sound of this album is a kind of a melodic, but gloo ... (read more)

Report this review (#1006869) | Posted by Progrussia | Saturday, July 27, 2013 | Review Permanlink

4 stars Having thoroughly enjoying the previous release by this obscure act, I found myself once again reunited with Gandalf's Fist by a chance when listening to the a covermount CD from 'Prog' magazine which featured 'The gathering of the clouds' from this release. I recently received the album from t ... (read more)

Report this review (#993097) | Posted by MattinsonG74 | Sunday, July 7, 2013 | Review Permanlink

4 stars I did not like the previous "Gandalf's Fist" album much at all. Immediately I find this album to be more upbeat than the previous one (thank goodness). I really enjoy the sound of "From a Point of Existence I - V" Some "Iron Maidenish" sounding lead guitar work to spice things up (it's obvious ... (read more)

Report this review (#992528) | Posted by sukmytoe | Saturday, July 6, 2013 | Review Permanlink

5 stars Great. Balls. Of. Fire. What an absolutely cracking album. Whilst members of the progarchive community may recognise that Gandalf's Fist has hastily became one of my top 2 favourite bands, I should make a quick note that this album surpasses all expectations I had for the little Cumbrian duo and ... (read more)

Report this review (#841770) | Posted by Dr Ball | Sunday, October 21, 2012 | Review Permanlink

Post a review of GANDALF'S FIST "From a Point of Existence"

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.