Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography


For Absent Friends


From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

For Absent Friends FAF Out of HAL album cover
2.16 | 11 ratings | 3 reviews | 9% 5 stars

Write a review

from partners
Live, released in 1995

Songs / Tracks Listing

1. Downtown (edited version) (3:34)
2. Into Love (acoustic) (3:37)
3. Memories (acoustic) (3:35)
4. The Fight (acoustic) (3:35)
5. Dreamer (acoustic) (3:34)
6. Looking for Love (unreleased demo track) (3:04)
7. Someone Like You (live) (5:57)
8. Downtown (live) (5:04)
9. Running Scared (live) (4:25)
10. The Bad, the Fat & the Ugly (live) (4:21)
11. Attitude (live) (7:24)

Total Time 48:10

Line-up / Musicians

- Alex Toonen / vocals
- Edwin Roes / guitars
- Rene Bacchus / bass
- Peter de Jong / keyboards
- Ed Wernke / drums

Releases information

CD-SI music-SI3061-2-Nld-1995

Thanks to ProgLucky for the addition
and to projeKct for the last updates
Edit this entry


FOR ABSENT FRIENDS FAF Out of HAL ratings distribution

(11 ratings)
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(9%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(36%)
Good, but non-essential (27%)
Collectors/fans only (0%)
Poor. Only for completionists (27%)


Showing all collaborators reviews and last reviews preview | Show all reviews/ratings

Collaborators/Experts Reviews

Review by The Prognaut
4 stars Right before getting my hands on to "FAF Out of HAL", the nearest approach I had had towards the band was "Running in Circles", that in my appreciation was convincingly sounding fresh and different from what was considered as "neo progressive" those days. Discovering FOR ABSENT FRIENDS was a pleasant experience to me from the very beginning, making me realize there will always be enough room inside the mainstream progger you can be for the musically unexpected and the meaningful simplicities. As a matter of fact, this is the most suitable FOR ABSENT FRIENDS' album to be turned into the bookmark in the middle of their prominent career since it's got several views from different angles and every possible determinations. I also consider this production the most liable point of departure for newly FAF fans to start from due the exigencies they may come up with when discovering a brand new band (specially one from the demonized "neo prog" genre), and a surprising "eyebrow-rising" occasion for recurrent fans.

The band located in the harbour area in Rotterdam, decided to include both edited and recorded live versions of "Downtown" (taken from the album "Running in Circles") in here to find the appropriate contrast and a direct response from the audiences. As the rest of the album, this song's got a symbolic function. It brings together all the work put into the realization of the first studio version to the last live one recorded the 22nd of January, 1994 at the former terminal of the Holland America Line (HAL), where this album certainly had its appropriate premiere. Personally, out of all the possible versions of "Downtown", the recorded live is the one I enjoy listening to the most. The voice impact evoked by Alex TOONEN (A.T. for the pals), when interacting with the crowd is simply amazing, an that enlightens this meaningful song to an almost seductive approach. Somehow, Edwin ROES manages to wail off his guitar strangely accurate from the studio version, giving the song all the punch and freshness a live recording needs.

"Into Love" is the first of the four acoustic versions included in "FAF Out of HAL". There's a 12 strings guitar execution that deserves complete attention, and overall, entire admiration. The percussions added up to soften the upbeat arrangements, is quite great. The mushiness of the lyrics is pretty much evidenced here, and by the time you get yourself caught in "Memories" (where a soft, playful piano, comes in between a peaceful guitar and a single-beat drum set), you'll be already used to it. "The Fight" emanates beautiful folkloric passages throughout a relaxed guitar, well written, moving lyrics, and that provocative type of mood every romancing song has got.

"Dreamer" and "Looking for Love" (a previously unreleased demo-track), pretty much flow down the same narrative stream, concerting a marked dialogue between this chamber-music-like piano and a simple, unspectacular guitar (not to diminish the work, but to prove that even with little instrumentation, something memorable could come out of it).

The second half of this album, which is the one that contains the live versions; is indescribably amazing. "Someone Like You" far beyond been exquisitely written, with its due bittersweet touch; it displays such eeriness and emotion that even with the descriptive drum performing by Ed WERNKE, appears unbelievably convincing and practical. "Running Scared" proudly displays the sourness sustained by FAF, and by this point of the album, no matter the lyrics, you will completely be drawn to the band's magnetism. Simple, fast and helplessly. Just like that.

What's left of the album, represented on "The Bald, The Fat & The Ugly" and "Attitude"; is completely unidirectional. The pure essence of FAF flows completely through those tracks, we can perceive the magic and the skills each one of the musicians have individually. That's what FAF is made of. An excellent album that will open up your mind, taking you to unconventional neo progressive places, despite the vivid IQ and PENDRAGON influence this Dutch band has got. Remarkable latter half of the nineties production.

Review by hdfisch
1 stars Even listening to them live (on record) this band could not convince me, that it's an essential one in this sub-genre. The quality of the music is thousand of miles away from that of the leading ones in NeoProg like MARILLION, IQ, PENDRAGON or ARENA. I can't rate it higher than with 1 star, sorry!!
Review by ZowieZiggy
1 stars This " FAF" album is not really great. But none of their albums were so far.

This one holds one short unreleased song (Looking for Love). Like most of these (unreleased I mean), it should have been better to remain so. It's mellow popish and poor. Sounds as a demo track and it's absolutely of no value.

One of the best moments (there won't be many) is the edited version of "Downtown", but it's just a commercial trick I guess. Original version was better and is also featured in onther version further on.

This Dutch band had released two albums prior to this one. I don't think it was useful to get some sort of a compilation work with such a short repertoire. This album is a combination of acoustic and live numbers actually.

I never have liked the "unplugged" exercise and this one is no exception. "Memories" is slightly better thanks to some drumming and piano backings but all these songs aren't benefiting anything from being converted to acoustic. A bit duller I guess. The palm going to "The Fight" but "Dreamer" is almost on par. Dreadful.

The only section that is bearable is the live one. One song from their first album and four from their latest release "Running In Circles" which was not a jewel to say the least. Two pleasant numbers here and that's it. Two prog-pop songs which a pleasant melody and a catchy chorus. An attempt to sound as the genuine "Marillion" but let's be honest, "FAF" is far to be as creative as them. Just easy listening music.

The second one is my fave from this release : "Running Scared" is rocking OK and the upbeat tempo is very much welcome but this is not an interesting album. Far from the brilliance of so many other Dutch bands. But the audience is reacting very well during the live songs. I can't say the same about my impression.

One star.

Latest members reviews

No review or rating for the moment | Submit a review

Post a review of FOR ABSENT FRIENDS "FAF Out of HAL"

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.