Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography


Soul Secret

Progressive Metal

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Soul Secret 4 album cover
3.23 | 14 ratings | 2 reviews | 36% 5 stars

Write a review

from partners
Studio Album, released in 2015

Songs / Tracks Listing

1. On The Ledge (8:36)
2. Our Horizon (7:01)
3. K (5:43)
4. As I Close My Eyes (2:01)
5. Traces On The Seaside (4:48)
6. Turning The Back Page (6:51)
7. Silence (5:21)
8. In A Frame (3:48)
9. My Lighthouse (6:36)
10. Downfall (5:06)
11. The White Stairs (16:44)

Total Time 72:58

Line-up / Musicians

- Lino Di Pietrantonio / vocals
- Antonio Vittozzi / guitars
- Luca Di Gennaro / keyboards
- Claudio Casaburi / bass
- Antonio Mocerino / drums

Releases information

Label : GoldenCore Records
Release Date : April 10, 2015


Thanks to MoonshineO for the addition
and to NotAProghead for the last updates
Edit this entry


More places to buy SOUL SECRET music online

SOUL SECRET 4 ratings distribution

(14 ratings)
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(36%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(29%)
Good, but non-essential (21%)
Collectors/fans only (14%)
Poor. Only for completionists (0%)

SOUL SECRET 4 reviews

Showing all collaborators reviews and last reviews preview | Show all reviews/ratings

Collaborators/Experts Reviews

Review by Second Life Syndrome
3 stars Another album---another vocalist. I feel badly for bands that just cannot seem to retain a lead vocalist. Italy's Soul Secret started out with a guest singer, progressed to Fabio Manda's amazing voice on their sophomore album, and now have turned to Lino Di Pietrantonio to lead them. This choice, much like the album, is a solid one, though flawed in some ways.

Soul Secret's third album is called "4", and, yes, that is confusing as hell. It represents a slight change in sound for Soul Secret, due not only to the change of singer, but also to the maturity of these guys as musicians. Indeed, I hear stylistic changes across the board. Soul Secret, if you are not familiar, are definitely a progressive metal band in the vein of Dream Theater, though I'm sure that's a shadow they don't want. Either way, though, it is the truth, as they rely on strong guitars from Antonio Vittozzi, sizzling keys from Luca Di Gennaro, foundational bass from Claudio Casaburi, and the ever present structure of Antonio Mocerino's drums.

Their styles have changed somewhat, though. I am a huge fan of their previous album "Closer to Daylight", and the band as a whole has moved on from shorter, more structured tracks to longer and more varied concepts. This is both good and bad, as you won't really find much to sing along to here, but you will certainly find incredible instrumentals to admire (something Soul Secret has always done well). In fact, it seems like each and every track has a noteworthy instrumental, and some, like "Traces on the Seaside", "On the Ledge", and "Our Horizon", have multiple sections that are incredibly sublime. This is partially due to the new sounds for this band, especially Luca's wonderful keys. He has moved on from the standard atmospherics so often found in prog metal to new heights of solos, even leading the music many times. Needless to say, I'm very impressed with the large range of key tones used, too. Besides this, I sense a change for Mocerino's drums, too, as he has opted for a more delicate touch than his blast beating past. In addition, Vittozzi's guitars seem much more deliberate and inspired in composition.

Thus far, we have a great third album called "4" that features some notable changes in sound. This is where my slight issues with the album appear. First of all, I do feel that it is a bit long. At 72+ minutes long, I feel like some of the incredible effectiveness of the first half of the album wears off by the end. Indeed, I feel like they realize it, too, as most of the really amazing rhythms are found in the first half. This is not to say that the latter half is bad. It's actually great, especially songs like the instrumental "Silence" or the addictive ending to "My Lighthouse". Heck, "Downfall" might be my favorite song on the album! The first few tracks, however, just gel so well that you barely notice the time pass.

My other issue with this album is the Dream Theater sound. This is primarily because of Lino's vocal performance. Indeed, I think the band actively tries to avoid the DT sound by including plenty of small oddities, like harsh vox, crazy synth, and a notable lack of overpowering guitar. Lino's voice, however, sounds SO much like Labrie's vox on "Images & Words". This isn't a bad thing, as I don't think Labrie has ever sounded better. Lino does avoid the pretentious wailing (thank God), but there are definitely a few times where I could have imagined that I was listening to DT.

Overall, though, this is another solid album from Soul Secret, and they really show their instrumental chops. Indeed, the ending epic "The White Stairs" opens with a fantastic groove that always makes me stop everything else I'm doing. For progressive metal fans, then, I don't think there has been a better offering so far this year. Be sure to get your hands on this album!

Review by b_olariu
3 stars 3.5 stars really

Soul Secret from Italy is to me a very strong prog metal band with a decade career so far and three albums released so far, but with all that they are quite unkown in prog metal circles and is a damn shame because they offer a very solid, well written type of prog metal. The third album is from this year 2015 named simply 4 (strange name to me) and far less pretentious as on previous two releases. Another album another vocalist, this time we have the unkown, at least for me - Lino Di Pietrantonio. Did he integrated well in Soul Secret sound, yes, of course, his type of voice is fiting like glove on hand here, he has a clear tone and his job is well done . So, another worthy one of this italian band, for sure among my fav prog metal bands from recent years. What we have here, is good well performed type of prog metal, lacking in originality but the musicianship is more thn ok most of the time,. If the overall sound is keeping the same formula as on previous two albums, elaborated arrangements, twisted passages, lots of changes in tempo, the perfect example is the opening - On The Ledge - for sure one of the most intresting pieces the band ever composed, and probably on my top 3 pieces from this yea, absolutly great from guitars of Antonio Vittozzi to the spectacular keyboards parts of Luca Di Gennaro (no wonder he will apear on new Subsignal album) - this tune simply kick ass, the best of the album, at least for me. On the opposite is the track named K who is by far the worst piece band ever done, I don't like here in this context the growling vocals provided by a guest , simply totaly unintresting tune and forgetable at best. Another hihlights ar the instrumental one Silence and few more. All in all quite good release, maybe not their best from all 3, but close enough. I like a lot this band and I'm with an eye on their career since the beggining. 3.5 stars, fans of the genre take a listen worth it.

Latest members reviews

No review or rating for the moment | Submit a review

Post a review of SOUL SECRET "4"

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.