Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography


The Minstrel's Ghost

Crossover Prog

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

The Minstrel's Ghost Jack: A Different Tale album cover
2.25 | 13 ratings | 2 reviews | 8% 5 stars

Write a review

from partners
Studio Album, released in 2019

Songs / Tracks Listing

1. Alone (2:52)
2. Born (5:18)
3. Growing Pains (4:16)
4. A New Day (4:17)
5. New Scars (4:27)
6. Goodbye (4:32)
7. Darkness Falls (5:06)
8. It Begins (4:50)
9. The News (3:13)
10. Saucy Jacky (4:08)
11. What Have I Done? (4:49)
12. Reflections (5:46)

Total Time 53:34

Line-up / Musicians

- Blake Carpenter / Keyboards, Rhythm Guitar, Lead Vocals (3-5,8,10-12), Harmony Vocals
- Jartse Tuominen / Lead Guitar
- Tony James Martin / Bass Guitar, Lead Vocals (9), Harmony Vocals (3-6,9, 11)
- Mark Troup / Drums, Lead Vocals (2), Harmony Vocals (3-6,8,9,11)

Releases information

Label: Melodic Revolution Records
Format: Digital
April 5, 2019

Thanks to mbzr48 for the addition
Edit this entry

Buy THE MINSTREL'S GHOST Jack: A Different Tale Music

THE MINSTREL'S GHOST Jack: A Different Tale ratings distribution

(13 ratings)
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(8%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(23%)
Good, but non-essential (31%)
Collectors/fans only (38%)
Poor. Only for completionists (0%)

THE MINSTREL'S GHOST Jack: A Different Tale reviews

Showing all collaborators reviews and last reviews preview | Show all reviews/ratings

Collaborators/Experts Reviews

Review by TCat
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin
2 stars "The Minstrel's Ghost" is a Crossover Prog band from the US, that was formed in 2011 by multi-instrumentalist Blake Carpenter. Since 2011, he has released 3 albums. The album "Jack: A Different Tale" is the 3rd album and was released in April of 2019. Blake performs on keyboards, rhythm guitar, and does most of the lead vocals. Other musicians on this album include Jartse Tuominen on lead guitar; Tony James Martin on bass and lead and background vocals; and Mark Troupe on drums and lead and background vocals.

The album is made up of 12 tracks that stay between 3 and 6 minutes each. The album has a run times of over 53 minutes. The album tells the story in song about a boy growing up around dark influences that lead to murder and finally suicide.

"Alone" is an introductory track led mostly by guitar and a moderate rhythm. The sound is a definite David Gilmour style. "Born" features the first vocals on the album, but the lead vocals are done by Mike Troupe on this track. The music is slow and atmospheric, mostly led by a piano and the thoughtful, sad vocals. The band comes in half way through the track. "Growing Pains" keeps the tempo moderate, but the guitar at the beginning is brighter. Carpenter's vocals are introduced here and are a bit tinny and they sound like there is some processing done to his vocal tone. This track has a nice, driving bass line. There is a synth solo followed by a guitar solo here. "A New Day" is definitely more upbeat, but Carpenter's vocals are a little better on this track, but they still have that strange tinny sound that can be a little annoying. The music to this point is pretty straightforward and accessible, but could use some challenging elements.

As the album continues, "New Scars" continues with an upbeat sound, but the vocals eem to worsen here. He tends to have a Peter Gabriel sound, or least attempts to, except that his tone is off enough to be noticeable, and slightly off key. The track itself is not at all interesting. Things slow down for "Goodbye" as the album turns to a dark tone. Subdued synts back up a slow guitar solo until the piano comes in with more vocals, which still haven't improved. "Darkness Falls" is an atmospheric instrumental led by guitar. This same sound continues in "It Begins" except with bad vocals.

"The News" features lead vocals from Troy James Martin, but his vocals aren't much better and the interest in the music continues to wane as it is all quite straightforward and light on the progressive side, with the usual guitar solo stuck in there. Things don't get any better as the album goes on, in fact it even gets embarrassingly bad at times.

The music just stays quite uninteresting without any real ear-catching material and the story behind the concept is not that great. I can't really come up with any real positives on this album, except for maybe some of the guitar solos, but the music is very predictable, the vocals are mostly unemotional and off key. This is one that can be avoided.

Review by kev rowland
2 stars This is the first album from The Minstrel's Ghost since 2012 and is also planned to be the final release from the band as leader Blake Carpenter has decided it is time to move on. Blake provides some of the lead vocals, plus rhythm guitar and keyboards, and is again joined by Tony James Martin (bass, lead vocals). Jartse Tuominen has joined to provide lead guitar (which was provided by the much-missed Colin Tench on the last album), and drums this time are by Mark Troup (who also provides lead and harmony vocals). There is something missing from this album, as there is no real spark or vitality. There is nothing inherently awful about it, but it feels as if it is just meandering along waiting for an idea. It certainly doesn't sound as if it is the third release by a band, and if I had been just given this without any information I would have expected it to have been a debut release by an unsigned band, as opposed to something on the mighty MRR.

Yes, it is a dark tale, but there are too many times when it feels contrived and false, as if there was no real heart and soul, no emotional connection with what was being performed. It is an album which I have to say didn't improve with repeated playing, and is one I can't imagine I will ever be returning to.

Latest members reviews

No review or rating for the moment | Submit a review

Post a review of THE MINSTREL'S GHOST "Jack: A Different Tale"

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.