Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography



Post Rock/Math rock

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Swans Leaving Meaning album cover
3.86 | 18 ratings | 1 reviews | 17% 5 stars

Write a review

Buy SWANS Music
from partners
Studio Album, released in 2019

Songs / Tracks Listing

CD1 (45:58)
1. Hums (2:00)
2. Annaline (5:17)
3. Hanging Man (10:48)
4. Amnesia (5:49)
5. Leaving Meaning (11:21)
6. Sunfucker (10:43)

CD2 (47:12)
7. Cathedrals of Heaven (7:49)
8. The Nub (12:01)
9. It's Coming It's Real (7:42)
10. Some New Things (7:09) - not on LP
11. What Is This? (6:05)
12. My Phantom Limb (6:26)

Total Time 93:14

Line-up / Musicians

- Michael Gira / vocals, guitar, producer
- Kristof Hahn / guitar, backing vocals
- Yoyo Röhm / electric & acoustic basses, keyboards, piano, synth, backing vocals
- Larry Mullins / drums, vibraphone, percussion, Mellotron, synth, keyboards, backing vocals

- Jennifer Gira / lead (6) & backing vocals
- Baby Dee / lead vocals (8)
- Mika Bajinski / backing vocals
- Marie-Claire Schlameus / backing vocals
- Anna von Hausswolff / backing vocals (4,6,9)
- Maria von Hausswolff / backing vocals (4,6,9)
- Fay Christen / backing vocals (8)
- Ida Albertie Michels / backing vocals (8)
- Norman Westberg / guitar
- Ben Frost / guitar, synthesizer, sounds
- Paul Wallfisch / piano
- Thor Harris / trumpet, clarinet, bells, vibraphone, percussion, sounds
- Jeremy Barnes / accordion
- Cassis Staudt / accordion, harmonium
- Phil Puleo / hammer dulcimer (4)
- Heather Trost / violin, viola
- Christopher Pravdica / bass guitar, sound effects
- Dana Schechter / bass (10)
The Necks
- Chris Abrahams / piano & organ (5,8)
- Lloyd Swanton / double bass (5,8)
- Tony Buck / drums (5,8,10)

Releases information

Artwork: Michael Gira

CDx2 Young God Records ‎- YG63 (2019, US)

LPx2 Young God Records ‎- YG63 (2019, US) With less one track (#10)

Thanks to Rrattlesnake for the addition
and to Quinino for the last updates
Edit this entry

Buy SWANS Leaving Meaning Music

More places to buy SWANS music online

SWANS Leaving Meaning ratings distribution

(18 ratings)
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(17%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(50%)
Good, but non-essential (22%)
Collectors/fans only (11%)
Poor. Only for completionists (0%)

SWANS Leaving Meaning reviews

Showing all collaborators reviews and last reviews preview | Show all reviews/ratings

Collaborators/Experts Reviews

Review by Lewian
4 stars On Bandcamp, Michael Gira writes that "I dissolved the line up of musicians that constituted Swans from 2010-2017. Swans is now comprised of a revolving cast of musicians, selected for both their musical and personal character, chosen according to what I intuit best suits the atmosphere in which I'd like to see the songs I've written presented. In collaboration with me, the musicians, through their personality, skill and taste, contribute greatly to the arrangement of the material." There are well known names such as Ben Frost, Anna von Hauswolff, the Necks, and actually every single official band member who played on the previous Glowing Man album among the collaborators. This sounds like another new approach for this band, who went through many different phases in their long existence, although their last three albums were a rather homogeneous trilogy.

Yet, leaving meaning clearly bears the hallmark of Swans' most characteristic feature at least in recent years, namely the shamanic approach using monotonous rhythms and conjuring meditative vocals that slowly build up to trance-like ecstatic states, speaking to deep ancient layers of our conscious and subconscious existence.

There is in fact also change. The approach on leaving meaning is less openly aggressive and heavy, somewhat slower and cleaner, and dominated by acoustic instruments. I was pondering whether to say "more relaxed" here; more relaxed than Seer/To Be Kind/Glowing Man it is, but the atmosphere is still tense and dark and many of the songs are still relentless and won't let the listener's attention go for one second; despite Swans' strong use of post rock elements like the straight rhythms, the slow build ups, and the absence of traditional song structures, this isn't music to relax and calm down, it is still tense and captivating. The songs here are no longer than 12 minutes (on the previous three albums they had some more than half hour tracks), but somehow many of these still have the same kind of "eternal" feel - surely they haven't started to rush through things.

The somewhat calmer approach leaves space for a rich yet subtle mostly acoustic sound spectrum (Hums, Annaline, The Nub). The Hanging Man, leaving meaning, and Sun[%*!#]er sound much closer to Seer-trilogy Swans (with which I'm absolutely fine actually, this trilogy is the highlight of the 2010s for me), but more acoustic, making for a more meditative atmosphere, which creates its own unique and convincing version of the shamanic trance mood evoked by Swans' music.

The first eight tracks of leaving meaning are a straight five stars masterpiece hands down. Unfortunately I have more difficulty connecting with the last four tracks. I respect that after more than one hour of extremely captivating music Gira doesn't call it a day but gives us something even different, at least hinting at more traditional "songs", or rather, in "Some New Things" (of all titles) at a clearer reprise of the more electric sound of the Seer trilogy that is otherwise absent here, but in shorter format. This is OK as an experiment, but to me these tracks come over as quite a bit more shallow than the first eight; some loose tentative messing around contrasting the pure magic that we got before, but then not really far enough from the earlier material to show anything like a proper new direction. This shouldn't of course stop you from buying and appreciating the album, but it makes me eventually go for just 4.3 stars here. Probably I'd have appreciated more to get track 1-8 as another 100% iconic release and the remaining four as a stand-alone EP.

This is the fifth release of Swans in the 2010s, and that's a lot of music; except the first one, which was a bit of a warm up. all of them have two CDs worth of material. It is also the fifth very strong release, cementing their rank as the best band of the decade, with some distance, in my view. Up to The Nub the album is total music, a spellbinding and deeply moving piece of shaman magic. Then there are some additions that I currently suspect of being rather forgettable, but anyway, feel the magic!

Latest members reviews

No review or rating for the moment | Submit a review

Post a review of SWANS "Leaving Meaning"

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.