Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography

HOLGER CZUKAY

Krautrock • Germany


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Holger Czukay picture
Holger Czukay biography
Holger Czukay (born Schüring) - 24 March 1938, Free City of Danzig (now Gdańsk, Poland) - 5 September 2017

Czukay studied under Karlheinz Stockhausen from 1963 to 1966 and co-founded the influential rock group CAN in 1968. Czukay played bass guitar and performed most of the recording and engineering for the group. Czukay recorded some important early ambient / progressive electronic albums, and is important for his utilization of shortwave radio sounds, sampling... He released his first solo album "Canaxis" in 1968. It marks a new step in the development of experimental electronic music & "ethno" rock, notably by the use of "sampling" and a traditional Vietnam voice. After his departure from Can in 1977, Czukay participated to many collaborations with jah wobble, the edge, eurythmics, david sylvian, conny plank, eno, phew... For krautrockers the most memorable albums with guests are "RastakrautPasta" & "Materia" (with Moebius and Plank). In 1979 Czukay published his project "movies", described as a good following of what he has done with Can (including a large use of different keyboards for hilarous, complex & extravagant songs). In 1981, he recorded "On the way to the peak of normal", an eclectic experimental rock album made of a spontaneous session involving the musicians of S.Y.P.H. (Uwe Jahnke, Ulli Putsch, Jürgen Wolter, Harry Rag) and two radios. These albums have been produced at Conny Plank's studio. During the mid- eighties until today numerous albums have been published for Virgin, notably "Rome remains Rome" , "Radio Wave Surfer", "Flux + Mutability" . One of his classic; "Moving pictures" (an album of virtual film music; timeless and organic) was reissued a few years ago on SPV. Czukay has recently recorded "Luna" which provides a floating, "ambient" and unconventional experience with the help of a wide variety of electronic process and patterns.

HOLGER CZUKAY forum topics / tours, shows & news


HOLGER CZUKAY forum topics Create a topic now
HOLGER CZUKAY tours, shows & news Post an entries now

HOLGER CZUKAY Videos (YouTube and more)


Showing only random 3 | Search and add more videos to HOLGER CZUKAY

Buy HOLGER CZUKAY Music


On The Way To The Peak Of NormalOn The Way To The Peak Of Normal
Groenland 2015
$11.94
$15.77 (used)
Full CircleFull Circle
Astralwerks 1992
$4.84 (used)
Movie!Movie!
Groenland 2016
$10.28
$12.38 (used)
Der Osten Ist RotDer Osten Ist Rot
Groenland 2018
$10.94
$10.00 (used)

More places to buy HOLGER CZUKAY music online Buy HOLGER CZUKAY & Prog Rock Digital Music online:

HOLGER CZUKAY discography


Ordered by release date | Showing ratings (top albums) | Help Progarchives.com to complete the discography and add albums

HOLGER CZUKAY top albums (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

3.89 | 50 ratings
Holger Czukay & Rolf Dammers: Canaxis 5
1969
3.77 | 45 ratings
Movies
1979
3.94 | 36 ratings
On The Way To The Peak Of Normal
1981
3.88 | 20 ratings
Holger Czukay w/ Jah Wobble & Jaki Liebezeit: ‎Full Circle
1982
3.08 | 9 ratings
Der Osten Ist Rot
1984
3.13 | 17 ratings
Rome Remains Rome
1987
3.46 | 10 ratings
Radio Wave Surfer
1991
3.88 | 13 ratings
Moving Pictures
1993
3.55 | 10 ratings
Good Morning Story
1999
3.03 | 13 ratings
La Luna
2000
3.04 | 6 ratings
Linear City
2001
4.09 | 2 ratings
Czukay & U-She: Time And Tide
2001
3.24 | 8 ratings
Czukay & U-She: The New Millennium
2003
3.31 | 4 ratings
Czukay & Ursa Major: 21st Century
2007
3.00 | 1 ratings
Eleven Years Innerspace
2015

HOLGER CZUKAY Live Albums (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

5.00 | 3 ratings
Clash (with Dr. Walker)
1997

HOLGER CZUKAY Videos (DVD, Blu-ray, VHS etc)

HOLGER CZUKAY Boxset & Compilations (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

2.29 | 5 ratings
Rome Remains Rome And Excerpts From Der Osten Ist Rot
1987

HOLGER CZUKAY Official Singles, EPs, Fan Club & Promo (CD, EP/LP, MC, Digital Media Download)

4.00 | 1 ratings
Biomutanten /as Les Vampyettes)
1980

HOLGER CZUKAY Reviews


Showing last 10 reviews only
 Holger Czukay & Rolf Dammers: Canaxis 5 by CZUKAY, HOLGER album cover Studio Album, 1969
3.89 | 50 ratings

BUY
Holger Czukay & Rolf Dammers: Canaxis 5
Holger Czukay Krautrock

Review by Neu!mann
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Holger Czukay's first LP outside the CAN stable was a groundbreaking effort, years ahead of its time in how it juxtaposed pre-existing music from widely different cultures. But that doesn't necessarily make it a classic, and today the album should be approached as a primitive experiment with far-reaching implications.

Sampling wasn't anything new in 1969, but Czukay was fusing a lot more than just music here. It's all about the unexpected context, hearing contrasting sounds in unlikely settings: in this case field-recordings from the Cham people of southern Vietnam and Cambodia, lifted off a 1965 Folkways Label record and combined with a heavily-treated loop of a melodic phrase from a lament by 13th century troubadour Adam de la Halle...or is it a 16th century requiem by Pierre de la Rue?

Both have been cited as possible sources, but either way it was an act of political daring in 1969 to pair Vietnamese folk music with what sounds like a liturgical funeral hymn, just as the Indochinese war was nearing its zenith. The album's title track, in its original form called "Shook Eyes Ammunition" (Shook-Eye pronounced Czukay), was an even more provocative side-long vinyl essay, again with Southeast Asian music cues but this time blended with edgier, ambient Krautrock drones and electronics.

Czukay of course had long been fascinated with exotic radio waves, and his apprenticeship under Karlheinz Stockhausen weighed heavily on the Canaxis sessions. Co-producer Rolf Dammers, also a student of Stockhausen, was given a share of authorship despite being credited only with "general support". But despite later speculation (in "The Can Book", by Pascal Bussy) that Czukay was the neophyte and Dammers the more experienced master, in retrospect the album was Czukay's baby, and like any new parent his doting attention was tireless: he even snuck into the Stockhausen studio after hours to perform a final mix.

In any test-run of a new recording technique the bugs have to be considered a part of the creative process, and listeners today need to allow for some age-related wrinkles. The flower from this seed would take a full decade to bloom, on albums like "On the Way to the Peak of Normal" and "Movies". But don't compare those later, playful efforts to this more embryonic artifact. He may have been a novice, but in 1969 Can's resident mad scientist had already learned how to approach sound editing and assembly as performance.

Consumer Alert! The CD bonus track "Mellow Out" (not available on every re-issue) doesn't fit with the album's avant-garde spirit, but for CAN archeologists it's a real discovery: Holger Czukay's first live performance, from a 1960 radio broadcast. It's little more than negligible filler, very much in the light jazz vernacular of its day. But the tune is a useful datum point from which to measure Czukay's musical evolution in the years ahead.

 Movies by CZUKAY, HOLGER album cover Studio Album, 1979
3.77 | 45 ratings

BUY
Movies
Holger Czukay Krautrock

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

3 stars Holger Czukay the CAN bassist has released a lot of solo albums over the years, this happens to be the third one I've reviewed and my least favourite by far of those three. Loved his "Canaxis 5" release from the late 60's and to a lesser extent "Full Circle" from 1982 but this particular album goes places I do not like. Lots of humour and of course sampling. Everyone from CAN but their vocalist is involved on one track here while Jaki Liebezeit does play drums and congas throughout. Holger thanks John Foxx of ULTRAVOX for pushing him to finish this album when he wanted to give up. This was released in 1979.

Up first is "Cool In The Pool" a poppy and humerous tune that I cannot hardly stand(haha). Catchy but lame especially the vocals of Holger and the lyrics. Oh my! Lots of silliness late. So yes this is getting off on the wrong foot big time. "Oh Lord Give Us More Money" has all the CAN guys helping out but Damo. Sadly Holger's vocals really disappoint. Lots of repetitive beats, synths and guitars. It kicks in loudly after 3 minutes with vocals almost shouting the words. Samples before 4 1/2 minutes go on for some time then more vocals. We get an extended instrumental section late.

"Persian Love" actually does work sounding very much like a Persian love song with male and female vocals. It's kind of cool actually and my favourite from the album. "Hollywood Symphony" is the longest tune at 15 1/2 minutes but I'm not convinced. We get vocals in a strange soundscape and synths give us this orchestral vibe. Suddenly before 2 1/2 minutes we get random snippets of Hollywood movies. This is all over the place though and I'm just not into it at all.

So I would recommend "Canaxix 5" and "Full Circle" to anyone wanting to check out Holger's solo stuff but for my tastes this was a disappointment. 3 stars.

 La Luna by CZUKAY, HOLGER album cover Studio Album, 2000
3.03 | 13 ratings

BUY
La Luna
Holger Czukay Krautrock

Review by Neu!mann
Prog Reviewer

3 stars First, a personal note: like many fans I prefer the music of CAN's mischievous short-wave radio painter when he's in a more lighthearted mood, composing Odes to Perfume or Persian Love songs. But there's something oddly hypnotic about this minimalist curiosity: an unbroken 47-minute "Electric Night Ceremony" recorded live at Holger's Lab on May 17, 1996 (and yes, I checked: there was a full moon over Cologne that night).

Don't expect the soothing environmental ambience of a Brian Eno album, however. Czukay's tone poem was built around a sinister mechanical pulse not far removed from the dystopian rhythms enslaving all those subterranean workers in Fritz Lang's 1927 film classic "Metropolis". He then goes to creative lengths to put a human touch on his automaton bleepfest, adding ephemeral layers of pirated radio signals, odd percussion accents, random vocal interruptions and so forth.

As usual Czukay is playing the studio like a musical instrument, and was apparently so mesmerized by the effort that he forgot his trusted French Horn. There isn't much room here for comic relief, but when High Priestess U-She (real name Ursula Kloss; Holger's muse since the end of the last millennium) approaches the electronic altar and starts muttering about "the Mother of the Universe", it's hard not to imagine Holger's tongue lodged firmly in his cheek.

There's actually a lot happening over the album's uncut three-quarter hour length, at a level of perception audible only with both ears wedged between the speakers. For better or worse, this is one of those experiments that needs your full attention to appreciate, but is best enjoyed when only half-heard as background radiation.

 Biomutanten /as Les Vampyettes) by CZUKAY, HOLGER album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 1980
4.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Biomutanten /as Les Vampyettes)
Holger Czukay Krautrock

Review by Lewian

— First review of this album —
4 stars This is a collaboration of Holger Czukay with the famous German producer Conny Planck. Both of these tracks haven't appeared on any regular album, so this single is well worth having on its own, and because it has fairly recently been re-released by Herbert Grönemeyer's Grönland Records, it should be easy to get it.

This was recorded after Holger's monumental "Movies" solo project after leaving Can. The music is fascinating; produced in 1980 there's a certain minimalist experimental new wave spin to it. Holger at the time apparently said something like he wanted to start a "horror with comfort" singles series with this, although the rest of the series didn't materialize. In any case the horror theme is very dominant. Biomutanten is about somebody being attacked by mutant monsters. There's a manipulated deep slow horror voice speaking on both tracks, both of which are carried by slow monotonous rhythmic bass and sound motifs. As usual for Holger Czukay (and Conny Planck is a congenial partner in this), the music takes its appeal from the sound alchemy woven into the horror atmosphere, which, different from "Movies" is not pieced together from short wave radio recordings but rather consists of a wealth of subtle electronoc noises, amply fitting the horror theme.

I'd have wished that more prog artists would've been able to connect with the changes of the musical landscape of the early eighties in the way in which Holger and Conny do it here; they produce something (at the time) genuinely new, having progressed away from excessive jams and other characteristics of the seventies, but the elements that they use from the new era are of an experimental leftfield nature, industrial sounds and a straight decluttered structure as a basis for creating an uneasy threatening atmosphere, rather than trying to please a record company by going commercial and easily consumable. This is fun stuff, worth 3.5 stars for the listening experience, rounded to 4 for its uniqueness.

 Eleven Years Innerspace by CZUKAY, HOLGER album cover Studio Album, 2015
3.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Eleven Years Innerspace
Holger Czukay Krautrock

Review by Lewian

— First review of this album —
3 stars New music from Holger Czukay at last! Or is it? Unfortunately neither the label nor Holger himself have cared about giving the fan much useful information about this. When was it done? Who apart from Holger himself was involved in it? We don't know and the cover (which looks like it took no more than 10 minutes to make) won't tell.

I was in doubt about whether I should classify this as compilation/boxset or as regular release; I'm not totally sure about the definitions either. These are remixes of existing material. The remixes themselves are mostly pretty innovative. They, or at least some of them, may have been done pretty recently, in which case I arguably should have classified this as regular studio album. The title suggest that they were done over 11 years but which? 2004-2014? It's a mystery. But it's material that in this state you haven't heard yet elsewhere.

Two of the six remixes are pretty close to what is already available. Secret of my Life is based on Rhythms of a Secret Life from Moving Pictures, and My Can Axis is based on material from Canaxis 5, and both of these vary the original material little. They seem like compressed miniature versions of the original tracks.

The other four tracks have much more of an existence independently of the original material that went into them, and are much more interesting. On "In-Between" and "A Maiden's Dream" sampled classical music features quite prominently (orchestral on In-Between, a string quartet on A Maiden's Dream). This is coupled with some sound experiments and snippets from previous work. The marriage between these elements doesn't work 100% without frictions but makes for a fascinating experience. We can nicely speculate about the meaning of this collage; in what sense are Holger's sounds a comment on the classical material? Is it an echo from the past, or is it rather the thing to survive in a darker future in which it still has the power to shape the then contemporary noises?

"My Can Revolt" uses material from Can, which means that we listen to a fast pulsating instrumental by Schmidt/Liebezeit/Karoli with some Suzuki voice appearing in the second half. I believe that this has been pieced together in a quite new way, possibly with some added guitar or other trickery. It is pretty intense and the fastest and loudest thing on this album. Can fans will probably like this. I remember that Holger did something like this when I saw him in the Roundhouse in 2009.

"Breathtaking" reminds me of the "21st Century" album, it is rather free form, meditative and fairly slow, with some dreamy U-She vocals.

Overall the listener gets quite a bit of interesting and fascinating new material, so this is certainly a worthwhile acquisition. The album is somewhat uneven though, and as I have Canaxis 5 and Moving Pictures already, I don't get much from the two tracks that are made of those albums (if you don't have Canaxis 5 and Moving Pictures, get them before this one, they are truly great). The remaining four tracks may well be worth four or even five stars if they stand the test of time (I'm not going to wait 20 years before I review this), but still currently I give the album 3 stars, with annoyance about the lack of information perhaps playing a role here.

 Clash (with Dr. Walker) by CZUKAY, HOLGER album cover Live, 1997
5.00 | 3 ratings

BUY
Clash (with Dr. Walker)
Holger Czukay Krautrock

Review by Lewian

5 stars This is an absolutely unique monster of an album and whoever is up for something truly innovative and progressive should at least give it a listen. Trouble is, it has some heavy techno influences which probably aren't particularly popular in these quarters.

Clash is recorded live but contains only new and fresh material. Holger Czukay once said about it that the live collaboration with Dr. Walker brought him back some of the original excitement and spontaneity of playing with Can. Much of the album appears to be improvised or developed spontaneously. It is a double CD giving us about 140 minutes of music in nine tracks. The main principle of the music is the combination of Dr. Walker's techno rhythms with Holger mixing in a rich variety of sampled sounds with the addition of some electronic sounds produced on the spot. This seems simple and straight enough but actually the devil comes out of the detail; Holger unleashes layer upon layer of nervous, meditative, groovy, fast, slow, human, artificial, sophisticated, trivial, spacey, earthly, western, eastern, northern and southern attacks on the listener's ears from his sound archives put together over many decades from radio stations and other sources from all over the world. Now this seems no longer that simple and straight, but the reader may expect it to be somewhat random and disconnected. Let me assure you, it is not. What you get here is a viable and complete new world pieced together of parts of the old one making for a surprisingly consistent experience produced by the two musicians' talent to combine the samples and the rhythms in a very organic manner, always providing a leading thread (sometimes it's the rhythm, sometimes one of the more expansive sampled and remixed soundscapes). Particularly, the teamwork between the two is amazing with Holger all the time adding depth to the rhythms and taking it on and Dr. Walker showing a good sense for the dynamics and mutations required by Holger's constructions.

The samples and the way Holger is manipulating and combining them produce a unique experience with many nuances to discover at any moment. It is as if secret layers of the human existence shine through what is perceived on the surface, similar to the multilayered technique that some modern painters use, combining selected manifestations of life with their own comments.

The rhythm stops and changes its character at times, at other times it has a rather subtle appearance and seems almost deconstructed, but often it flows very confidently but thanks to the omnipresent sound metamorphoses never too monotonously; and occasionally it becomes a mighty stream that tears everything with it.

This is probably not for everyone, but I rate it as an an outright spectacular experience.

 Czukay & Ursa Major: 21st Century by CZUKAY, HOLGER album cover Studio Album, 2007
3.31 | 4 ratings

BUY
Czukay & Ursa Major: 21st Century
Holger Czukay Krautrock

Review by Lewian

3 stars Ursa Major is the singer U-She, here collaborating with Hokger Czukay for the third time (plus some contributions to other Czukay releases, namely Linear City and Clash). The last one was called "New Millenium" and this one is now "21st Century"; you'd be surprised that such creative personalities as Czukay & U-She come up with two album titles like these in a row. This is supposed to be music for the new millenium/century, yes, we got that. Compared to "Time and Tide" and "New Millenium", "21st Century" is the most consistent album, or one could also say the least diverse. I think they tried to concentrate more on what they do best; there are hardly any attempts to write conventional songs here, and rhythms are lighter than on New Millenium and less like techno-beats. The new songs give Holger's sound experiments quite some space and U-She works much with repetitions of fairly simple mini-tunes, at times reminding me of Damo Suzuki's improvisations. The sound is dominated by digital keyboards, drum computers and samples and has some meditative free flowing feel to it. Don't expect much enlightenment from the lyrics... "Every day is a new day, you shouldn't try to run away"... well, well. It shouldn't hurt too much, I guess. To be honest, I could do without most of U-She's contributions here. The music is rich and attractive as ever; Czukay's creativity and musicality quite obviously hasn't run out of steam just yet. Unfortunately it's now 2015 and I think he hasn't released anything new in the meantime. I saw him live at the Roundhouse in 2009 and much what he did there was originally mixed and partly created just for the gig, and boy was it good - I guess he's still sitting on quite some interesting unreleased material. He is well over 70 now and I'm a bit worried that his website hasn't been updated since 2011, but apparently he still has his hands in some re-issues of remixed Can and Czukay-material from the 70s and 80s, so I'd still hope for some new music to be released at some point.

In any case, it's easier to get into 21st Century than into the two predecessors, but it's not as diverse and not just as surprising as those (at least not if you know them already when getting to this one), so it's three stars this time.

 Czukay & U-She: The New Millennium by CZUKAY, HOLGER album cover Studio Album, 2003
3.24 | 8 ratings

BUY
Czukay & U-She: The New Millennium
Holger Czukay Krautrock

Review by Lewian

4 stars For me this is the best one out of the three collaborations of Holger Czukay and U-She. It is the least meditative, though, with some fast techno beats and some dazzling cascades of notes that you wouldn't normally expect from a grey-haired veteran like Czukay... actually you wouldn't expect them from anybody, so adventurous and fresh is this. Some of this has dancefloor qualities, although you'd need a pretty unusual crowd there for this to work. In any case, this may be Holger's most physical music.

There are still some of Holger's trademark slow and deep soundscapes in this, but usually they come with some nervous electric rhythm. U-She's singing is fine in most places here; in "Cinderella" and "Supernova" both her and Holger's voice can be heard, making for a fascinating contrast (actually I think these are my favourite occurrences of Holger's voice in all his work - he sounds like a true sorcerer here). These are my two favourites. A number of songs are longer than what you find on "Time and Tide" and "21st Century", and this suits the album well. There is more development and ideas are played out with more patience.

In some respects this is quite accessible, particularly through some of the rhythms and digital riffs that carry some of the songs. On the other hand, those who'd like to have traditional drums, bass, guitars or even traditional song structures should stay away.

Interestingly, the title song "New Millenium" was tried out as a single and I saw Holger and U-She performing this on mainstream German TV (Harald Schmidt Show). Something is not quite right with this song, though. Although the melody (particularly the main keyboard motif) is nice and could work well in principle, the song has by far the worst sound on the album with some very cheesy synthesizer chords, and U-She, uncharacteristically, seems to have some difficulties synchronizing properly with the syndrums, which Holger may have played manually and which are perhaps even on purpose pedestrian and imprecise (or precisely subverting what they should have been for a normal listener; totally opposed to most of the rest of the album, which is very sharp). For me this is the song I like the least; funny that they put some effort into selling this of them all to the general public. It actually may be just one more example of Holger's strange humour, from which there is no hiding in his work generally, but if you just want to immerse yourself in the music from beginning to end, this is something of an annoyance.

Anyway, if you're not scared off by the lack of good old natural instruments, check this out!

 Good Morning Story by CZUKAY, HOLGER album cover Studio Album, 1999
3.55 | 10 ratings

BUY
Good Morning Story
Holger Czukay Krautrock

Review by Lewian

5 stars Holger Czukay has a number of ridiculously deep albums that by pure sound alchemy touch me in ways that other music hardly ever achieves. Good Morning Story is one of these. Its centre piece is certainly the 20 minutes of Mirage, which is a slow and somewhat minimalist sound collage based on a single drone sound, which is however breathing, moving and changing all the time, enrichened by all kinds of samples and very tastefully engineered sounds evoking all kinds of emotions from pain and fear to jumping around playfully. However, the sometimes ethnic nature of the samples and the somewhat distant sound of most of them makes this more of a globe- or even universe-spanning than a personal experience. One could see connections to Tangerine Dream's unique and legendary Zeit here, but Holger's world of sounds, well informed by the technical possibilities of the 1990s, is more human and warm, at the same time keeping the same level of experimental boldness. Newer issues of the album follow Mirage by a 10 minutes remix, which is stunning, don't miss it! The deep sound world of Mirage here is put together with wild rhythms and grooves, a very worthy re-interpretation of the epic just heard.

What was originally the first side of the album is made up by shorter songs. There's the relaxed and fun Invisible Man sung (or rather told) by Holger and Sheldon Ancel with some dreamy female voice by Holger's later wife U-She thrown in. This has a pretty unique twilight atmosphere. Then there are two tracks, Good Morning Story and Dancing in Wild Circles, that are based on sampled Can's genius rhythm from Vitamin C (Ege Bamyasi), which is one of the grooviest pieces in music history. Good Morning Story is the more relaxed piece, Dancing in Wild Circles uses some seemingly tribal rhythmic voices and is generally far more buzzing. Personally I can hear Jaki's legendary drums from Vitamin C day and night, Holger can remix and add to this as much as he wants and I will love it, although of course creativity credit here goes partly to the original. Surely both tracks here have a proper and strong life on their own. World of the Universe is a mostly instrumental piece with some spoken words by Holger that reminds me of parts of Hollywood Symphony from "Movies". This sounds rather dark and subdued and there's not that much sampling here, or only very strongly in the background. Instead we get some of Holger's original guitar playing and sound design. Very atmospheric. Atlantis is probably the weakest thing on the album. It's dominated by cheap sounding rhythm computer beats many of which seem to be randomly chosen, put together to create rather straight "ungroovy" rhythms, and then there are some more twilight atmospherical sounds. This certainly takes some getting used to, but on the positive side it's a pretty unique experiment and surely has enough complexity and unpredictability to keep the interest alive. That then is followed by Mirage, already described. I'm surprised that Good Morning Story is currently rated lower than the previous effort Moving Pictures. Moving Picture is certainly not bad, but Good Morning Story is in my view much richer and has the superior sound, it sounds absolutely amazing. After some not so strong work in the second half of the eighties and early nineties, in my view Good Morning Story is among his true genius pieces.

 Der Osten Ist Rot by CZUKAY, HOLGER album cover Studio Album, 1984
3.08 | 9 ratings

BUY
Der Osten Ist Rot
Holger Czukay Krautrock

Review by Lewian

3 stars You've got to have the last track "Traeum mal wieder"! It's ABSOLUTELY essential! For me at least this is one of the best things ever recorded. It conveys the deep meditative impression better than any other music I know that when you really listen to your own body and mind, the whole world is a part of you and you are not as an individual separated from the world. Some of the used sounds speak to the deepest layers of my soul. But it's not "new age"; you'll come across more edgy parts of the world and of yourself here as well. It also opens a new direction for Holger to go on many of his later releases (although not the next one Rome remains Rome). Really, get this! Actually there are possibilities to get this track other than buying "Der Osten ist Rot"; it's also on the CD made up of the best of this album and "Rome", and Holger has lately offered a remix of it on vinyl on his website ("Dream Again"), which doesn't do any harm to the qualities of the original. Not sure whether this is still on sale.

The complaint I have about the remainder of this album is that apart from "Traeum mal wieder", it mostly sounds like toying around with ideas without really elaborating them, and some jokes. "Traeum mal wieder" is very serious, deep music, whereas everything else is rather "fun", and much more lightweight on the musical side.

It isn't all bad though. The title track is a nice experiment deconstructing the Chinese national anthem (I believe), "Das Massenmedium" ("mass media make stupid, stupid, stupid") is a joke but musically tasteful and good to listen to, and "Michy" works fairly well as an improvised minimalist experiment. Otherwise there is more stuff based on field and radio recordings and voices, some strange Holger humour, and some toy melodies. I guess that Holger tried to make "Photo Song" kind of commercial, but his musical brain is much too twisted to get such a thing done, so Photo Song is rather a somewhat skewed children's melody with some charm but hardly any commercial appeal. Again, it qualifies as "fun" but not as serious music. Of course Holger doesn't take himself all too seriously, so you can't really blame him for this, but as a music lover, you'd probably prefer to get 40 minutes of the top quality he is able to deliver than 7 1/2 minutes of stunning music and >30 minutes of toying around, even though you gotta give to him that there is quite some variety and creativity here and as a Czukay fan I still would have wanted to have the >30 minutes of experiments and jokes, had he decided to publish a "100% quality music" album at the time.

Thanks to Philippe Blache for the artist addition. and to Quinino for the last updates

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives