Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Pink Floyd - Inside Pink Floyd Volume 2 - A Critical Review 1975 - 1996 CD (album) cover


Pink Floyd

Psychedelic/Space Rock

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
3 stars Second leg of DVD to overview the career of this mythical band. It ranges from "Whish You Were Here" to "The Division Bell" in terms of studio albums and ends on "PULSE". The version I have is the European version. Apparently it lasts for almost double the time than the Sout American version and also holds a bonus live track played by "Mostly Autumn" ("Comfortably Numb").

The same recipe has been used for this second part: three members from "Mostly Autumn" Heather Findley and Bryan Josh are giving their point of view about the music, while Ian Jennings provides a technical angle.

WYWH is accurately covered with a deep analysis of two of their most emotional songs ever written: SOYCD and WYWH. The live footage is again taken from a concert in Venice in 1989. The chapter about "Animals" is quite reductive, and half of it highlights the cover. A bit short, I'm afraid.

It is indicated how Roger starts to get control over the band; which will lead to "The Wall". No original footage of course but pictures again from their Venice concert (there are only poor quality images of one of their Earl's Court concert, as far as I have seen). Good overview and explanations about "Comfortably Numb" from Bryan Josh.

The elements of discord started to appear during the recording of the album and this will lead to the sacking of Richard Wright. A good chunk is also dedicated to the movie and the stress is put on Geldof's performance and the great complementarities of the animations and the music.

The disaster of "The Final Cut" (musically), the little input from David, the absence of Rick (a founding member) is shortly discussed. Some short Gilmour interview about the fact that most of the songs featured on TFC were not good enough to appear on "The Wall" and he saw no reasons to have them back again on another album. TFC was a Roger affair and no more.

To provide some balance, the sequence about "AMLOR" shows a short footage of Roger who mentioned that there were little chances that the band would be ever together again. The review of the album is probably too positive but the interesting part covers the live show and how this tour was considered and put in place. A total Gilmour affair.

"The Division Bell" since it is the last Floyd album (to date?) is the occasion to make the conclusions about this great band and how they have impacted the music industry for about thirty years.

As the first part (covering the years 67 through 74) this DVD is a decent attempt to describe Floyd's work. There are much less interviews from the band members on this second part (only two) but tensions were so high during this period than it is understandable.

Anyway, a good tool for newbies, more than for devoted fans. Three stars.

Report this review (#250774)
Posted Sunday, November 15, 2009 | Review Permalink
2 stars BEWARE! ?. Of unsprupulous others who make DVD documentaries with 'INDEPENDENT EDITORIAL CONTROL'. They contain the same old clips seen in legitimate 'docos' interspersed with 'nobody' talkiing heads and cover bands playing floyd numbers because the makers of these DVD's have no legal access to actual pink floyd material.

These DVD's overlap dramatically, using the same material over and over, mostly Syd era stuff, even when the title of the DVD refers to later albums or periods, the same Syd era stuff is trotted out to fill space.

If you must buy any of these DVDs then buy one of the more 'general' ones that covers the whole history and then STOP there. Look for the 2 disk releases ? they are the better ones, or the Inside Pink Floyd volumes 1&2.

AVOID those titles as individual album reviews in particular as these are generally the worst. These DVD;s contain nothing new for the Floyd aficionado. Especially avoid the 4 disk sets as these contain the sam amount as the 2 disk sets, simply spread out on to 4 shorter disks.

You have been warned! Don't waste your money

Report this review (#575256)
Posted Friday, November 25, 2011 | Review Permalink
1 stars My wife Savitri gave me as a birthday present this DVD and its companion. I love her so much but she failed miserabily. It sucks very hard. The reviews are not better than the ones you can find in Amazon or Allmusic, only becoming worst by the unnecessary comments by then-Mostly Autumn's members. They gave 4-stars (out of five) to AMLoR! I'm on Gimour's side of the fight but that is ridiculous.

Honestly, an interview with some of the best reviewers of PA would be a far more insightful thing. Run like hell from this [email protected] that is worst than the first part.

Report this review (#861894)
Posted Sunday, November 18, 2012 | Review Permalink

PINK FLOYD Inside Pink Floyd Volume 2 - A Critical Review 1975 - 1996 ratings only

chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of PINK FLOYD Inside Pink Floyd Volume 2 - A Critical Review 1975 - 1996

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives