Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography


Pat Metheny

Jazz Rock/Fusion

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Pat Metheny Orchestrion album cover
3.87 | 88 ratings | 8 reviews | 18% 5 stars

Excellent addition to any
prog rock music collection

Write a review

from partners
Studio Album, released in 2010

Songs / Tracks Listing

1. Orchestrion (15:52)
2. Entry Point (10:28)
3. Expansion (8:37)
4. Soul Search (9:20)
5. Spirit of the Air (7:44)

Total Time 52:01

Line-up / Musicians

- Pat Metheny / guitars and Orchestrionics (*), arranger & producer

(*) Custom-built set that includes keyboard, pianos, marimba, vibraphone, Orchestra bells, basses, guitarbots, percussion, cymbals, drums, blown bottles & other acoustic mechanical instruments.

Releases information

Artwork: Barbara De Wilde with Henry Leutwyler (photo)

CD Nonesuch - 516668-2 (2010, US)

Thanks to snobb for the addition
and to Quinino for the last updates
Edit this entry

Buy PAT METHENY Orchestrion Music

PAT METHENY Orchestrion ratings distribution

(88 ratings)
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(18%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(46%)
Good, but non-essential (31%)
Collectors/fans only (3%)
Poor. Only for completionists (1%)

PAT METHENY Orchestrion reviews

Showing all collaborators reviews and last reviews preview | Show all reviews/ratings

Collaborators/Experts Reviews

Review by snobb
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR Honorary Collaborator
4 stars I am listening now very fresh Pat Metheny album, released just a week ago. And I am expecting something special. Not because I think Pat is very experimental musician in the sense of music - during few decades I learned he is great soft guitar player, often on smooth jazz border.

The reason is this new his album is "real" solo album, where Pat plays all instruments himself. And there are many of them - all acoustic (but his guitar). But most interesting moment is that the album is not recorded as product of many overlays, pre-recorded different instruments sounds, mixed in one just in studio. No, this one is recorded using all the studio as instrument ( not very innovative idea, by the way). Pat uses "Orchestrionics" - a method of developing ensemble-oriented music using acoustic and acoustoelectric musical instruments that are mechanically controlled in a variety of ways, using solenoids and pneumatics. On top of these layers of acoustic sound, he adds electric guitar playing as an improvised component. And even more - starting from today Pat plays all this music live on big European live tour!

But speaking about all this attractions, let return back to music. Even if the way it was produced is not very usual, most important is a final product. And there are less unexpected things I can mention. In fact , all five compositions are competent contemporary jazz, soft, melodic, tasteful, with excellent electric Pat guitar on the top. But as usual very safe. Intelligent and pleasant listening. One of strong Pat's works. But no way revolution. I believe that Pat is very intrigued by the way he is playing his new music, and it will be really interesting to see/hear him playing live using all this devices. But in fact musical result is more or less similar to his previous works. Just another good album for quality contemporary jazz lovers.

Review by Gooner
4 stars This is definitely a solo album where Pat Metheny plays everything on it from keyboards to percussion and guitar.. Basically, references point to Chicago's Tortoise(without the dub...think TnT), Mike Oldfield's Orchestral period(Incantations), Pierre Moerlin's Gong and Wes Montgomery. Jazzy and orchestral in scope. Fans of Pierre Moerlin's Gong during the period of _Time Is The Key_ and _ Leave It Open_ would find this very appealing. No stellar tracks, really, Everything is solid. A little Zappaesque in parts. This could be Pat Metheny's AMAROK, but don't expect any toothbrushes. It harkens back to his period of '78 to '82 on ECM. (Pat Metheny Group, As Falls Wichita, Offramp). No synth-guitar(as far as I can tell). Recommended.
Review by Marty McFly
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR Honorary Collaborator
4 stars My first album by Pat so I cannot compare, however this album seems like obvious choice for me. Because as someone not so used to listen Jazz, being not revolutionary enough is actually big advantage for me. Being easy to listen and still offer a lot of interesting sounds, even not necessarily complex can be good.

If new means contemporary then yes, this may be advocate, representative album of modern Jazz. Not Prog at all costs, but Jazz for sure. And when compared to some normal "jazzy" tunes that just uses skeletal pattern of what Jazz is, then this is if not progressive then at least Prog.

The fact the Pat Metheny plays all instruments alone is remarkable, one would easily say that this is real life (5-6 members) band. Nostalgia element is also prominent here and it adds to my liking of this.

4(+), not so sure about Prog here (I've leave it be to Prog or Jazz experts), but very likable album that will find its fans.

Review by BrufordFreak
COLLABORATOR Honorary Collaborator
5 stars When this album came out in 2010, I think that the explanatory and illustrative YouTube videos must not have been available yet because NOBODY who has reviewed this album seems to understand the process by which this music was created (not even you, Slava G). Based on the principles behind the player piano and the follow-up phenomenon known as the "orchestrion", every single sound, instrument, note, chord, etc. on this album is played by instruments set up in a single room and ALL ARE PLAYING AT THE SAME TIME according to Pat's guitar and foot pedal links and programmed commands--and its done through mechanical methods, not MIDI or computer programs: that is, pneumatics, solenoids, pulleys and levers! Pat is, in fact, wearing (and playing) THE ROOM just as a circus act's one-man band might have done one hundred years ago, only with literally thousands of instruments connected to his manual and pedular ministrations (and with the advantage of electrical connections)! The effort to design a song much less performa and record must have been nothing short of gargantuan. Think of the roadies and sound engineers having to transport and set up the "room" on stages around the world when Pat toured for this album! I STRONGLY urge you to watch any and all of Pat's videos to gain some appreciation for the effort (and genius) that went into the making of this music (and the room!)

While I agree that there are very few groundbreaking sounds, melodies, or songs coming out of Pat's "experiment"--it still sounds like Pat Metheny and no other--I am so torn as to how to rate this album due to the sheer awe and respect I hold for this man's unbound creativity. "Genius" hardly seems to give him his due. He is a Wile E. Coyote of music: a "Super Genius"!

I'm going to call this "essential" for the sake of its ground-breaking means to delivering complex, multi-layered jazz music despite it's "smoothness" or familiarity. Plus, I invite you: any of you, to try to play along with Pat and his guitar. It's not as easy as it sounds; it's just that he's also a genius of melody-making (and a genius at making sounds that sound easy to make).

Review by Conor Fynes
4 stars 'Orchestrion' - Pet Metheny (8/10)

Through my experience with Paul Metheny, I may not have loved everything I have heard from him, but I have come to really respect him as a brilliant fusion guitarist. When I don't care for something of his, it is usually a matter of it being too smooth for my tastes, and I tend to get a bit bored despite the dynamic musicianship throughout each album. It is the albums that seek to be more than mere mood music that I've found I care about the most; 'The Way Up' is the chief example of this, through its dynamic and diverse approach. Happily, I find Metheny's 2010 offering 'Orchestrion' to be an album that has enough going on for it to jump out of the background. As skilled a composer as he is a guitarist, 'Orchestrion' proves Pat Metheny is still at the height of his game.

As the title may suggest, this is more than the quartet or trio style of jazz that some might be used to. While the piano, clean guitar tone and mellow drums are all staples here, the arrangements are fairly complex here. Enter the title track 'Orchestrion', a piece which features rapidfire guitar and xylophone harmonies that are much in the sound of Frank Zappa. The xylophone is never a leading instrument for any of the work on 'Orhcestrion', but it instead serves as being a great way to add depth to the already good sound Metheny has crafted here. The complexity here aside, there is not enough here to entail an orchestra, which I may have thought was the case for this album.

The performances here are admirable, especially in the complex lead arrangements. Metheny performs everything heard on 'Orchestrion', and it is very clear to any listening that he's a brilliant multi-instrumentalist. The cornerstone of the music is certainly the guitar, of which Metheny uses a clean guitar sound quite typical of jazz. Much to an ironic effect however, the guitars are one of my less favourite aspects of the sound here. Certainly as talented a soloist as any other guitarist in jazz fusion, it does feel after a few minutes into the album that Metheny is merely noodling around with the lead. This is all done extremely well, but the sheer amount of album time spent showcasing his guitar talents feels as if it hinders the composition of the work, which is otherwise excellent.

Pat Metheny's work is usually decided based on the writing of the music, rather than the strength of the performance, which is always top notch. While not the best album I have heard the man churn out, there is certainly the clear evidence of careful writing here, especially when Metheny takes out some unexpected instruments out like the tambla drums and incorporates it into the mix. That being said, there are not as many hooks or dynamics as I may have liked to see here.

'Orchestrion' may not show Metheny's vision at its strongest, but it is certainly one of the better things the man has come out with. A complex, somewhat mellow but consistently entertaining album, 'Orchestrion' is an excellent album for intelligent relaxation.

Review by Sean Trane
3 stars Based on a XIXth C instrument (or should we say a battery of instruments) the present album is the culmination of Metheny's fascination with this gizmo, and this solo album is a bit of his holy grail. Indeed, between pianos, marimbas, vibes, tuned percussions, guitars ad all kinds of self-made gizmos (including two bottle blowers), the principle is to have only one operator handling all of them at the same time in only one take. A rather impressive performance in itself, not totally devoid of technical interest, but if the music being performed is average, then the value of the experiment is almost pointless. And to be honest, besides the prowess of playing everything by Metheny himself on the album (I mean this is the truest meaning of a solo album, since he's the only one appearing in here), there isn't that much interest, because sonically-speaking Orchestrion doesn't sound any different than most of his other albums, beit the group or other solo ventures of his. In a way this kind of venture is more of an engineerial feat than an artistic one, because on has to actually build the whole gizmo, if not from scratch, at least in linking the instruments via a series of electrical relays to allow the solo operator to command all sonic tools concerned.

Ok, if you're a fan of Metheny's music, there isn't much doubt that you'll enjoy the present, since it's more or less the latest little brother in his overall oeuvre. But this writer hasn't really been a fan for quite a while, and the charm doesn't work much, if at all. Actually another small technical prowess is to develop the typical snoozy ECM sound on another label, and this is Nonesuch-ally achieved. Soooo, let's give it half a star for the pictures and explanations in the booklet (though they could've been better), but giving it more than an average three star would also be unfair, because the sonic contents are nowhere as groundbreaking as the technique it used. And most important, there are no hints of those horrible Synclaviers that were one of Pat's trademark for so many years? An honest release, but nothing that will revolutionize the jazz world, despite the impressive technology developed for it

Latest members reviews

4 stars What can I say? I was a little cautious about the fact that Pat Metheny plays on all the instruments in this album, but it seems to have worked out just fine. The musicianship on average is competent at the very least, the drums being probably the least remarkable - which is fully compensate ... (read more)

Report this review (#805359) | Posted by Argonaught | Thursday, August 16, 2012 | Review Permanlink

3 stars Exceptionally well played, but missing surprises. Pat Metheny´s solo album Orchestrion evokes mixed feelings. On the one hand the concept of orchestrion as an instrument really supports and explains the way many instruments and musical arrangements on the album are played - for example percussio ... (read more)

Report this review (#279966) | Posted by Oliverum | Friday, April 30, 2010 | Review Permanlink

Post a review of PAT METHENY "Orchestrion"

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.