Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography


Post Rock/Math rock • New Zealand

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

The Dark Third picture
The Dark Third biography
Founded in Auckland, New Zealand in 2013

Atmospheric art rock collective based in Auckland, New Zealand formed in 2013; current lineup consists of Daniel Hay on vocals and piano, Luiz Paganelli on guitar, Denys Matveev on bass guitar, Alika Wells on saxophone and Tim Doyle on drums. Guitarist Tommy Leigh and bassist Christan Pianta were part of the recording of Even As the Light Grows, but departed before its release.

(Bio by Quinino - courtesy of octopus-4)

See also: HERE

THE DARK THIRD Videos (YouTube and more)

Showing only random 3 | Search and add more videos to THE DARK THIRD


THE DARK THIRD discography

Ordered by release date | Showing ratings (top albums) | Help to complete the discography and add albums

THE DARK THIRD top albums (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

3.85 | 4 ratings
Even as the Light Grows

THE DARK THIRD Live Albums (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

THE DARK THIRD Videos (DVD, Blu-ray, VHS etc)

THE DARK THIRD Boxset & Compilations (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

THE DARK THIRD Official Singles, EPs, Fan Club & Promo (CD, EP/LP, MC, Digital Media Download)

0.00 | 0 ratings
4.00 | 1 ratings
A Problem for Another Time / Healing Knives


Showing last 10 reviews only
 A Problem for Another Time / Healing Knives by DARK THIRD, THE album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2020
4.00 | 1 ratings

A Problem for Another Time / Healing Knives
The Dark Third Post Rock/Math rock

Review by nick_h_nz
Collaborator Prog Metal / Heavy Prog Team

— First review of this album —
4 stars [Originally published at The Progressive Aspect]

2020 has been a strange one for music. Release dates have been moved back, and back some more. Gigs to celebrate those releases have happened months afterwards, or not at all. And there has been an extraordinary amount of older material released or reworked. While a lot of people are aware that bands and artists are often not able to play live, I think they expect them to spend the time when not gigging recording new material. What this doesn't take into account is that if there is no money coming in from performing, there is no money for recording either. (The trickle down means that studios and producers, etc. are also suffering, but their plight is less visible.) It's no wonder, then, that musicians are digging into their back catalogue.

One such release is the recent single from The Dark Third ? billed as a double A-side companion to their album, Even As the Light Grows. That album came out in 2018, so I guess were it not for the strange times we find ourselves in, we might not have heard these two songs at all ? and that would be a great shame, as they are both interesting and enjoyable. There is still promise of new The Dark Third material, but in the meantime these two unexpected songs more than suffice.

With a name like The Dark Third, the first thing to come to mind for many will be Pure Reason Revolution, and although there is some of that modern prog sound in the music of The Dark Third, they are far from the first comparisons I would make. Rather, I am reminded more of bands such as Anathema or Alcest, or fellow Kiwis Mice on Stilts. I also find The Dark Third's sound quite reminiscent of Sunny Day Real Estate, and also that band's brief reign as The Fire Theft. On their Bandcamp page, The Dark Third recommends Mice on Stilts and Astronoid, and describes both as being big inspirations for their music. I've not actually heard any Astronoid, so I may have to rectify that, but obviously I agree with Mice on Stilts. The band's other recommendation is Kayo Dot, and though I'd not considered that, and though they are not described as being an inspiration, I can definitely hear some of that collective in The Dark Third, too.

I have always thought that the artwork for Even As the Light Grows is a great depiction of the band's sound. It's immense, jagged and icy, and has many peaks. The Dark Third excel in atmospheric soundscapes, often full of aggression, and with rich crescendos. As for immense, the two longest tracks on the album (both over ten minutes) certainly fit that bill. Despite coming from the North Island of New Zealand, the cover art evokes to me the Southern Alps of the South Island, the snowy peaks of which featured memorably in the Lord of the Rings films. That epic feel fits much of The Dark Third's music ? even in their shorter pieces.

But let's not dwell on the past, so much as the new songs (which actually come from that same past). The first track, A Problem for Another Time, begins with some absolutely gorgeous guitar, and a nifty bass undertone. Thea Doyle's drums, as ever, are a delight. I loved her drums on Even As the Light Grows, and I love them here, too. I get the impression that The Dark Third is whoever Daniel Hay happens to have with him at any one time, but I do hope that whatever comes next from the band does include Thea. This song is perhaps the most emo (in the original Sunny Day Real Estate vein, rather than what that term has come to mean in more recent years) I have heard from The Dark Third. It's an absolute blast.

At almost twice the length of A Problem for Another Time, Healing Knives has plenty of time to impress, and that it does. The second half is infinitely better than the first, and it just blows me away every time it hits. And it hits with a lot of force! Initially I thought I preferred Problem to Knives. It is certainly more immediate, and more immediately appealing. But Knives definitely has a way of sinking into the skin, and cuts deep. It is now easily my favourite of the two. Just, Wow! The saxophone and violin, performed by Alika Wells and Grace McKenzie, provided some delightful accents to the main collective on Even As the Light Grows, which I thought I might miss on this year's release, but I can safely say my worries were unfounded. There's more than enough going on with just the four musicians on these two tracks to need further ornamentation.

The two songs were written around the time of the album, but recorded afterward. I think I can see why they were not recorded for the album, but that doesn't mean they are lesser songs. I'm not sure that they would really have fitted within the overall sound of Even As the Light Grows, but they are just as impressive in their own right. It is definitely fitting to call this release a companion piece, then. And, two years on, hopefully these two songs might bring renewed interest in an album that could easily have been overlooked two years ago. In fact, I'm going to go back and listen to it myself now, and I can highly recommend you do so, too! As good as these two songs are, and as great as a companion piece to Even As the Light Grows as this release is, the album in all its glory is hard to beat. Check out the opening epic, The Dreams of Lesser Men, and see if it doesn't suck you in?.

 Even as the Light Grows by DARK THIRD, THE album cover Studio Album, 2018
3.85 | 4 ratings

Even as the Light Grows
The Dark Third Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Steve Conrad

4 stars Mournful, Wistful Meditations

Death, Desperation, Light, Sabotage

This debut release from New Zealand-based post-rock collective quintet (on this release anyhow) The Dark Third drills down mournfully, deeply, into dark caverns, suffocating bleakness, overwhelming seas of despair. Only very occasionally is the light shining, and it's never clear if the love so dearly needed and so strongly sought, is real or fantasy or...?

A Blend of Washes of Sound and Silence

We hear walls of chaos, crashing chords, brooding piano, wistful and dreamy vocals sometimes chanting sometimes singing dirges.

We traverse wide and various emotional terrains with few breaks for hope or transcendence. Whatever light does penetrate into these terrains can be readily sabotaged and ruined. There appears to be no safe harbor.

The Dreams of Lesser Men

The lengthiest and most developed track opens the album with a crash, that gives way to gentle guitar and piano. It builds with chiming guitar lines and dreamy vocals speaking of sleep, dreams, longing, doubting, and ultimately death.

The music builds slowly, changes in subtle shifts of feel and tempo. There is mournful elegance as the claustrophobic sense of being trapped develops. Then, lush piano chords in slow cadence brings in heavy guitar in slow and deliberate sequence.

These Things Are Not Inherent

Portentous piano with skittery, nervous drumming beneath leads to chanting vocals singing dirges. The protagonist is trapped, longing for release, yet terrified of it.

The bittersweet, push/pull, trust/doubt dichotomies propel the track back to piano lines, leading to heavy guitar pounding. Wait- is that a sliver of light? Of hope? Maybe, but it is easily undermined.

The rumbling, rasping bass guitar leads into the next track.


I'm told there is a Samual Butler novel by this name- "nowhere" spelled backwards (with a couple letters rearranged).

Here we get moody, dark, chiming guitar chords leading to changes in tempo, growing, becoming harder-driving post-rock. It becomes intense, and the lyrics emphasize the bursts of light, of hope, of belonging, of home.

It grows in passion and intensity, then begins to subside, and a single held note ushers in...

The Regressor

Dark, moody, drugged/dreamy vocals open the track that give way to single guitar and vocals. Drums tapping nervously enter and clean, picked guitar chords. Vocals are deliberate, using octaves, singing of the overwhelming sea, frayed rope, drowning souls, submerging/suffocating, rising to the surface only to submerge again...

Heavy band play leads to the most extended instrumental section using powerful guitar chords and droning lead lines. The percussive and heavy piano lines add definition and depth. Drums are busy and the repetitive riffs build into a wall of chaos and spooky sounds that reminded me of a nightmare death or birth canal experience.


The closing track gives way to what sounds like down-tuned, somber solo acoustic guitar and vocals.

There MIGHT be hope, a new resolve as day breaks. There MIGHT be freshness and courage and a sense of purpose and resolve...

Punchy guitar chords enter, only to subside to echoes, and distorted guitar feedback slowly fading...into silence.

In Conclusion

This is a strong example of post-rock with some other influences that become apparent. It's never terribly hurried, rarely showy, always building and changing and developing.

Just be prepared for a lot of mournful, wistful, desperation along the path.

For me, this is a four star release.

Thanks to octopus-4 for the artist addition. and to Quinino for the last updates

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.