Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
The Beatles - Abbey Road CD (album) cover

ABBEY ROAD

The Beatles

Proto-Prog


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
5 stars Since the beatles have been added here I REALLY HAVE TO make a review of their albums! I don't know how many will like this but... anyway, Abbey Road: Abbey Road is their best album with Revolver, tracks 9-16 just blows me away everytime, it's just amazing! Golden Slumbers, Carry That Weight, She Came In Through The Bathroom window. Damn how great songs! Also including one of the most beautiful songs ever created: Here Comes The Sun and also hit Come Together and also the funny Maxwell's Silver Hammer, which tells a little tale about a serialkillerboy, who murders his girlfriend, his teacher and a judge. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED ALBUM!
Report this review (#69422)
Posted Wednesday, February 15, 2006 | Review Permalink
erik neuteboom
PROG REVIEWER
3 stars Many times I have tried to get into the music from The Beatles but apart from a bunch of good songs, I cannot listen to an album for the whole running time, The Beatles simply fail to get me as a listener involved. This highly acclaimed album features many good songs but to me these compositions sound as a progressive blend of pop and rock. I dare not to ignore their huge influence in the history of pop and rock music but I often have the idea that the music by The Beatles has an enormous emotional importance to many people who grew up with that wonderful time in The Sixties when Chuck Berry, Elvis Presley, The Beatles and The Rolling Stones became 'biggies' who turned simply 3 minute pop songs into more adventurous, rock-oriented music. The Beatles are for them the link between musical excitement and emotion. Well, it sounds a bit cynical but for me (I am from 1960) Status Quo, Uriah Heep, Black Sabbath and Deep Purple were the bands that let me escape from the irritating, empty pop chart songs. If I compare the songs from this famous and pivotal The Beatles album to the aforementioned bands, I prefer these bands above The Beatles. In my opinion The Beatles are a very overrated band and for sure no more progressive than The Doors, a very underrated band on this site, in terms of progressive rock elements!
Report this review (#69425)
Posted Wednesday, February 15, 2006 | Review Permalink
vladimir.leks
5 stars I have not reviewed any album since perhaps more than one year. I have done it with all the albums I wanted, others which I proposed to be included in PA (such as Dezo Ursiny for example) were ignored. But now I see Abbey road here, great news, so I must do a review again. This is the very very very top album of rock music. From the beginning till the end, it flows like a river of wise, funny, inteligent, brilliant music. Each song is unique. This album is with no hesitation the progressive pearl of pearls. I like Yes, Rush, Genesis, VDGG, but to be honest, Abbey road is No.1. The side one is a collection of great songs, every one unforgetable, all members contributed with their best. The side two is a fluent suite of magic music. The songs involved here are not enormously known hits, but they display clearly a musicality which can be compared to the peaks of the classical music. You will not find here decadence, vulgarity, superficiality, servility, all the marks of post-modern nowadays like-to-be-art efforts. Abbey road is a proof that rock music can be a real art. Fortunately, a lot of real art works followed after that album, either inspired by beatles or not. nevertheless, with this album Beatles grown to the all-time-classics. The love you take is equal to the love you make.
Report this review (#69457)
Posted Wednesday, February 15, 2006 | Review Permalink
mmfloyd@gmail
5 stars My favorite album!!

I wonder sometimes if this band could carry on in this carrier to make more stuffs like that. You could hear symphonic and emotional songs ('Sometimes') and vaudeville art rock gems with synthezisers and nice pianos ('Maxwell's Silver Hammer'). There was excellent rock songs with a heavier side like the bluesy 'Oh, Darling!' and the exceptional SABBATH-like 'I Want You (She´s So Heavy)' with an incredible heavy riff- master peaking on a massive chaos in the end of the 7 minute piece. It´s hard to think that you´re hearing a Beatles album. Very prog and haunting. They never sounded so dark and sinister. And then you have nice and catchy pop-songs ('Here Comes the Sun') and dark melodies a capella ('Because') before the great sequence of songs that make this record a HUGE classic. Beginning with a beautiful piano in 'You Never Give Me Your Money' to the final climax with 'The End', the band enters a truly progressive suite with complex arrangements, unexpected melodies and intricate passages to another pieces. The final sequence 'Golden Slumbers', 'Carry That Weight' and 'The End' reprises initial melodies and choruses to make a grand finale with a short but breathtaking Harrison solo and a great symphonic piece. What an album!!

This album is progressive enough to appear here, being THE BEATLES after all a POP- ROCK BAND and NOT a progressive one. But they made wonderful things that still surprieses me untill today if we consider all they could do in the studio. It could be proto-prog, art-rock or symphonic. Anyways... Get this album in your collection being you a prog fan or not!!

Report this review (#69472)
Posted Wednesday, February 15, 2006 | Review Permalink
Tony Fisher
PROG REVIEWER
2 stars Most of this album is pretty forgettable; The Beatles simply do not offer enough musical interest in their songs or their playing to sustain my attention for a whole album or even album side since I was brought up on more sophisticated songs from bands like Strawbs and Genesis, who develop ideas more. Yes, there are some innovations but the songs just aren't that good and the playing is fairly basic, the odd Harrison solo excepted. However, there is one glorious exception to this mediocrity: Here Comes The Sun is one of the great songs of all time and shows that, whilst Lennon and McCartney get all the plaudits, it was George Harrison who wrote most of their best songs. This album is definitely not a masterpiece in any way and The Beatles are terribly overrated generally. Even Here Comes The Sun can't lift it above 2*.
Report this review (#69519)
Posted Wednesday, February 15, 2006 | Review Permalink
cadets/hernan
5 stars Wow first review. I was pleasantly suprised to see The Beatles being added to this website because I think they are proto prog. But to the review. This is a very concise, cohesive, and consistant album. Those are the three Cs I look for in an album. Abby Road is an innovative classic and a masterpeice in music. The songs are excellent and very diverse. You get a song about a cerial killer who kills people with a hammer and a song about a man named Mr. Mustard a song about an octopus's garden and many more. Side two is especially amazing. The suit is perfect although I wish Polythene Pam was a bit longer. Not a single song is weak on this album except maybe the 30 second her magisty in the end. The highlights of abby road are Come together, Here comes the sun, I want you, because, and all of side two. A true masterpeice. One does wonder what could be accomplished after this album if The Beatles stayed together. The musicianship is also very noteworthy. Though not the best drummer Ringo does do well and drums very effectively. Heck, he even sings well in Octopus Garden. John sings his lungs out in I Want You. Paul sings great in Oh Darling and plays bass great as usual. Last but not least George Harrison. He is an excellent guitarist. Listen to I Want You and Here Comes The Sun. You gotta love that. Happy listening. Over all 4.7 stars. tony
Report this review (#69525)
Posted Wednesday, February 15, 2006 | Review Permalink
Zitro
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars One of the best albums ever made in the 60s!! The Beatles, as we all know, is one of the most influential rock bands to ever come from England. Even if the primitive technology of the 60s stands in their way, they have managed a timeless album superior than many well-known progressive rock albums of the next decade. The members are no virtuosos, but they used all their songwriting talents to create this. The first side is a wonderful set of short songs. The second half has a wonderful ballad and a collection of short songs masterfully connected.

Come Together starts the album with a bang! This unusual blues/rocker is way ahead of its time. It has a unique ascending bass riff, as well as two melodic guitar solos and rocking vocals and rhythm. Something is a very different successful track: it is a symphonic ballad with gorgeous melodies. This band is so good at composing melodies! This is their peak, so expect them at their best. Maxwell's Silver Hammer is a cute innocent sounding children song, but if you read the lyrics, it's about a kid killing a friend, a teacher, and a judge in the choruses. Basically, he is a serial killer. It features synthesizers and piano and are effecting in creating the ironic tone. Oh Darling is a bluesy song with some interesting screaming coming from the band.

Octopuses Garden is a fun children song with very catchy melodies and backing vocals. It ends with a great guitar solo. But this is not the song I want to hear. I await eagerly for the powerful and progressive hard rock of I Want You (She's so Heavy):

Everything about this song is perfect. This is the perfect Beatles song, really! The immortal and mindblowing hard rock guitar riff, while repetitive, leaves me waiting for more! The song has sing-along blues verses, organ & bass call and response riffs before the chorus, and the proggy repetitive choruses and coda. Trust me, it is not only a riff. It has moog synthesizers, hammond organ virtuosity, bass guitar improvisations , and hypnotic (yet simple) drumming. The song unexpectedly ends in silence.

Here Comes the Sun is an energetic ballad with amazing choruses featuring catchy vocal lines and analogue synthesizers (ahead of its time).

And now ... The Epic! Acapella singing introduces it. It has very psychedelic lyrics and tone. A great start of the epic. You Never Give me Your Money is a pop/rock section with very memorable melodies and changes of tempos. This song has more changes than some 10+ minute songs! Sun King has singing in some foreign language (Latin?) but it sounds really good. Mean Mr Mustard is an up-tempo rocker that ends too quickly. Not the best part of the epic, but enjoyable. Polythene Pam sounds very much like music from Led Zeppelin III, great!. Bathroom Window is another good song but is no match for Golden Slumbers' melodic genius and the anthemic "Carry That Weight" The end has a drum solo that is pretty pathetic, but the guitar solo coming before it may be the best guitar solo I have heard from The Beatles. Her majesty influenced the "hidden track" feature found in modern prog rock.

Highlights: I Want You, Here Comes the Sun, the Epic Let Downs: Maxwell Silver Hammer and Octopuses Garden.

My Grade : A

Report this review (#69526)
Posted Wednesday, February 15, 2006 | Review Permalink
Cygnus X-2
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
5 stars Words cannot describe the massive amount of creativity and effort The Beatles put in their swan song record Abbey Road. Recorded after Let it Be and released before it, this is truly final Beatles record. The creative juices were flowing and the songs kept churning, and this would become the Beatles finest outing on record. John sneers and soars vocally and along with McCartney creates some superb compositions (although Come Together is a "lift" of a Chuck Berry song). Paul sings staggeringly and creates rich and melodic bass runs even while singing his heart out. George is at his creative peak, with an overly emotional piece and a cheery acoustic number. And finally, Ringo has his moment of glory with his country-esque Octopus's garden.

Opening with the John Lennon piece Come Together, the song was meant to be a propoganda piece so people would vote for Timothy Leary for a Congress or Senate campaign. This song is often criticized for being a "lift" of the Chuck Berry song You Can't Catch Me. None the less, it's one of the great Beatles songs. Something is the first of two George Harrison songs on the album. This song became a huge hit for the band. It featured great augmentation of an orchestra by George Martin, and some great bass runs by McCartney, as well as a tasteful guitar solo from Harrison. One of the best songs in the Beatles catalogue. Maxwell's Silver Hammer is a McCartney track about a serial killer named Maxwell Edison. It features some great moog textures during the pre-chorus breakdown and is one of the more humorous Beatles songs available.

Oh! Darling is one song that John resented in the fact that Paul didn't let him sing it. A pretty standard 12/8 ballad number, but it features one of Paul McCartney's best vocal works in his career. Octopus's Garden is the second Ringo Starr composition to make it on a Beatles record (the first being Don't Pass Me By on the White Album, and although he helped write the bridge of What Goes On, he wasn't given a solo credit until Don't Pass Me By). It has a country beat to it and some nice guitar frills from George Harrison. One of the more experimental Beatles tracks, I Want You (She's So Heavy) is an overly overdubbed guitar powerhouse with some brilliant leads from Harrison. It goes through many time changes and towards the end, as the hisses and moans of moog synths fill the speakers, it all ends abrubtly.

Here Comes the Sun, another classic George Harrison track, is a simple acoustic track written around variations of the d chord. It features a great 3/8 breakdown as well as some uplifting moog during the chorus. The final song before the medleys is Because, the main riff inspired by John wanting Yoko to play the Moonlight Sonata backwards. This song features what I read to be 9 tracks of vocal (3 from John, 3 from Paul, and 3 from George) and is more about the music than the lyrics. You Never Give Me Your Money begins the medley to end all medleys. A very piano based intro leads into a great shift into a more rocky section, then into some great unison guitar runs from the band until gently cascading into silence with the mantra " 1234567/All good children go to heaven". Sun King is a very atmospheric piece which features some great harmonies, and some nice italian lyrics towards the end, it segues into...

Mean Mr. Mustard is a short little ditty with a very catchy riff, it leads right into Polythene Pam, which has a nice solo from Harrison; which then leads into She Came into the Bathroom Window, a bluesy number that has some great guitar frills from Harrison. It leads into Golden Slumbers, which features one of Paul's most emotional and heartfelt vocal performances on record. It leads into Carry that Weight, which has some great harmony vocals and a great reprisal of the You Never Give Me Your Money theme. It all is summed up with the stellar conclusion, The End, which has some great guitar runs from Harrison, and very fun drum solo (the only one on record) from Ringo. It all gets summed up in two phrases according to Paul McCartney "And in the end, the love you take/ is equal to the love you make". And the end is near. But then a little surprise awaits you. Her Majesty is a little ditty that seems to have fit in between Mean Mr. Mustard and Polythene Pam, a bit of a throw away but none the less enjoyable.

Overall, I know I've written a lot about this album (I think this is my longest review ever), but I just can't help but say that this album is a masterpiece by and by. There are no weak tracks, and there are no sore spots. Utterly magnificent. Essential to any music collection. 5/5.

Report this review (#69532)
Posted Wednesday, February 15, 2006 | Review Permalink
Prog-jester
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars My fav from them I was involved in Beatles because of my father - I guess every person in USSR loved "Bitly" as if they were our native band.And they were.Surely my father likes early albums - he was 13-15,when he experienced them ,and as you know the first love is for the whole love.My first fav songs were "I'm only Sleeping" and "Yellow Submarine",but when I've heard " Octopus Garden"...I was 6 or so.I was completely astonished.When I was 7 I loved "Because" - I've been crying because of this song,it is really genius.When I was 12,I loved Nirvana,but my favouritest songs were "I want you" and "Come Together". I adore Beatles,and I like this album from them most.It is better than Sergeant in many aspects,it is mature work,and I'd recommend it to every prog fan.Just listen to it,you won't regret
Report this review (#70449)
Posted Saturday, February 25, 2006 | Review Permalink
ffilipes@hotm
5 stars Listening to this work of art, I wonder what would became The Beatles if they have continued through the seventies. The roots of progressive are all here: complex compositions, perfect execution, extensive use of keyboards, and an "epic". Abbey Road, produced with the assistance of Alan Parsons is almost a progressive album in his own right. Pure, solid and full of virtuosism, this record is lovely! The Beatles were, indeed, the pioneers of progressive rock.
Report this review (#70643)
Posted Monday, February 27, 2006 | Review Permalink
5 stars Abbey Road in a way is an album by Lennon, McCartney, Harrison and Starr rather than the Beatles (if you know what I mean) but despite that it is a far more homogeneous work than the double White Album that preceded it. It also showed the Beatles were no less creative at the end of their career than when they first burst onto the scene.

The mood of the album is fairly heavy overall as would be expected released in the Autumn of 1969. However it is beautifully put together and produced and above all contains some of their finest songs as well as the inspired medley of tracks that make up much of side 2.

For me this album vies with Revolver as their best and is a true masterpiece of rock.

Report this review (#71382)
Posted Tuesday, March 7, 2006 | Review Permalink
5 stars Well, I started listening to the beatles in 2004. Before that, I wasn't interested in their music, 'cos I thought they only had this poppy love songs from the 60's. I got this one as a christmass present in 2004, and I thoght it was a cool album. In 2005, there was a time in which I, for some reason, stopped listening to the Beatles. I found this CD last Sunday, and started listening to it. After just 1 listen, I didn't think it was a cool album anymore......no, it was not JUST cool......it was a MASTERPIECE!!! Ok. The album starts with "Come together": A hippie song, really cool, with vocals by John, a really popular track, one of my favourites. "Something": A ballad by George, very good guitars, piano and orchestra. Another all-time Beatle hit. "Maxwell's silver hammer": It's a quite funny song, which tells the story of a serial killer, who kills everyone with his "Silver hammer". Good piano, bass and synths (which gives the song this Prog sound), as well as the vocals by Paul. "Oh, Darling": A bluessy song, sung by Paul, with nice guitars, blues-like piano and bass, good rythm on drums by Ringo, and the vocals are really rockin'. "Octopus's Garden": An entretaining song by Ringo (one of the very few he wrote in the beatles). He does the lead vocals, and the others do the backing ones. There's a part in which you can hear the sound of water moving, and the blowing of bubbles through a straw, with sythesized vocals, which gives you the sensation that they're singing under-water. This is when George knocks out a nice guitar solo. I want you (She's so heavy): Probably my favourite on this album! It's a progressive rock/blues, featuring the same repeated lyrics, divided into two sections. First, there is one part in which John sings, in a soft bluessy way:"I want you...so bad.....it's drivin' me mad."Then you can hear a section of strange guitar & hammond organ chords, a short bass solo(2 times, I think) and there comes the 2nd section: "She's so....(Hammond solo-really cool. Then, with hard rocking voice, everyone goes:) HEAVYYYYYYYYYYYYYEAH!!!!!!!!". After they repeat the whole thing a couple of times, they go:"She's so......", and without even saying "Heavy", the song reaches it's peak, with an instrumental part, with the most rocking guitars, bass, drums and the coolest hammond organ!!!!!Oh, pretty long description, isn't it? well, by the way, this is one of the Beatle's longest tracks(It lasts almost 8 minutes). "Here comes the sun": a song by George, another hit, played with acustic guitar, mostly. The middle section, has a moog synth solo, which sounds really progressive. "Because": A soft track played with sitar and guitar, with nice chorus by Paul, John & George. "You never give me your money": A song sung by Paul, with piano.It starts quite soft, but it ends up being quite rock n' roll. It's a cool song. And now.....the most interesting part......THE MEDLEY: tracks 10-16 are played as a medley. "Sun King" opens it. It's a quite soft song sung by John and Paul. It's quite weird.Then, you can hear the drums and.... ...."Mean Mr Mustard": A song sung by John, with nice rythm, good guitrs and, bass. Well, I can't say much 'cos it only lasts like 1 minute!...then you can hear three chords, which happen to be the beginning of... "Polythene Pam": Another cool rockin' song sung by John. Then, Paul sings.... ...."She came in through the bathroom window": Another cool short rock song. "Golden Slumbers": Is a piano ballad by Paul with sublime orchestra. When 1 minute and 30 seconds pass.... "Carry that weight", which features the same theme of " You never give me your money".And, finally... "The End" of the medley, which features solos by all the members of the band.....Really cool. 15 seconds of silence.....and Paul comes with the acustic guitar and sings: Her Majesty's a pretty nice girl, but she doesn't have a lot to say Her Majesty's a pretty nice girl but she changes from day to day

I want to tell her that I love her a lot But I gotta get a bellyful of wine Her Majesty's a pretty nice girl Someday I'm going to make her mine, oh yeh, someday I'm going to make her mine. This album is the best Beatle alubum I've got so far(I've gotta get Sgt. Pepper) If you haven't got it, get it! but, first, do yourself a favour and listen to "I want you (She's so heavy)". You can do it in this site.

Report this review (#72956)
Posted Friday, March 24, 2006 | Review Permalink
5 stars Upon their final studio album (although not the last to be released), The Beatles bow out on top; "Abbey Road" is a brilliant ride showcasing a band (who were largely at odds with each other at the time) at a total creative peak. Well, 1965-1970 was one large creative peak, but consider this the peak of the peak.

"Abbey Road" is stylistically diverse, like we'd come to expect. There's anthematic hard rock ("Come Together"), silly children's songs ("Octopuses Garden"), old timey soul ("Oh Darling", possibly Paul's best vocal ever), lighthearted pop ("Maxwell's Silver Hammer", which is so bouncy and fun you won't notice how dark the lyrics are!), druggy dirges ("I Want You (She's So Heavy)"), and more.

"You Never Give Me Your Money" is a mini-suite ala "Happiness Is a Warm Gun", but it's Paul, so it's not nearly as dark. Helluva tune, though. As is "Because", a glorious juxtaposition between a dark, minor key melody and heart wrenchingly beautiful vocal harmonies. George Harrison also pens two of his best songs: "Here Comes the Sun" is, appropriately, an uplifting, sunny pop song. And "Something" is only the greatest love ballad ever.

Side 2 meshes all these song fragments (unfinished ideas, likely) into one amazing song cycle. "Sun King" is gorgeous; it floats admidst the rich, lush harmonies. "Mean Mr. Mustard" is a catchy rocker; "Polythene Pam" is part surf-rock, part punk (punk? in 1969?). "She Came In Through the Bathroom Window" is a soulful rocker, followed by the brief but magnificent piano ballad "Golden Slumbers". What a gorgeous song. "The End" is, well the end. It's fun, upbeat, it has a cool drum solo.

Report this review (#72963)
Posted Friday, March 24, 2006 | Review Permalink
Menswear
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars Aw man, the end of an era.

Just a dribbin' shame it as to end in a fight. Oh well, still we have this. After hearing the amazing Abbey Road, we can agree on the strategy of the Beatles: they were aiming for progressive material. Althought very pop, this album is still the firm intention of exploring much more ground since the White Album.

Ringo gave us his best track ever, Harrison litteraly lifted and animated the album with amazing songs and Moog effects, Paul was Paul and Lennon was sporting a superb red beard. Everything was there to create years of progressive madness. Man, talk about saving the best for last. *Sigh*

This album wouldn't be complete without the magnificent suite starting with Sun King and closing with The End. Oh so many good evenings related to those songs...

No Beatles collection'd be complete without Abbey Road, it would be insanity. If you don't have it, well shame shame. Just go buy it tomorrow and don't speak about it.

Report this review (#73705)
Posted Friday, March 31, 2006 | Review Permalink
Guillermo
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars Some of the albums released by The Beatles are very linked to happy memories of my chidlhood because my late father bought some of their albums in the late sixties. Maybe some of my reviews for these albums are boring for some readers, but I`m sorry... these albums were the "soundtrack" of some of these memories.

During the last weeks I listened again to some very old singles, all released in the sixties and early seventies. Great music which was played in the Radio then, and were bought by my father. Songs like "Eloise" (Barry Ryan, 1968), "A Whiter Shade of Pale" (Procol Harum, 1968), "I`m So Glad" (Deep Purple, 1968), etc. The sixties was, musically speaking, IMO, a great decade. The Beatles closed, IMO, that decade with the release of this great album in September 1969. The Beatles said goodbye at the right time, with a very good album. Recorded after the "Let It Be" sessions, it sems like they wanted to say goodbye with a better album, and they achieved it. George, Ringo and Paul started recording this album in early July 1969, without John for several days, because John had suffered a car crash with Yoko, but he later joined the other three Beatles in the studio.

The songs:

"Come Together": a very good song about a "simultaneous orgasm".

"Something": one of the best songs that George Harrison composed and recorded with The Beatles. Paul said that it was the best song that George composed during his time with The Beatles. John didn`t participate, but agreed to release this song as a single, the only song comoosed by Harrison which wa released as a n"A" side.

"Maxwell`s Silver Hammer": a "funny" song with "dark sense of humour" about a serial killer, composed by Paul. John hated this song!

"Oh! Darling": an intense "heavy-ballad" composed and sung by Paul, with heavy piano played by John.

"Octopus`s Garden": a good and funny song composed and sung by Ringo.

"I Want You (She`s so Heavy)": a heavy Proto-Prog song with has several guitars recorded by John and George, with a bit of Moog noises added at the end of the song.

"Here Comes the Sun": another great song composed by Harrison, also recorded without John. It also includes a bit of Moog playing.

"Because": a song composed by John, with great vocal harmonies by John, George and Paul.

"You Never Give Me Your Money": a song about Apple Corps` finantial problems.

"Sun King": orignally titled "Here Comes the Sun-King", composed by John, but he changed the title to avoid confusion with George`s song.

"Mean Mr. Mustard" and "Polythene Pam": both songs composed by John, about two weird characters.

"She Came in Through the Bathroom Window": another good song composed by Paul, it also was recorded by Joe Cocker for one of his albums (which also included "Something").

"Golden Slumbers": composed by Paul, and recorded by Paul (piano and vocals), George (bass) and Ringo (drums), linked to "Carry that weight", also composed by Paul, and also recorded by Paul, George and Ringo, including backing vocals by Ringo too.

"The End": also composed by Paul, and recorded with guitar solos by Paul, George and John. It closes the album very well.

"Her Majesty": an irreverent song composed by Paul, and originally included in the album as a "hidden track" only listed in the L.P. label.

This album was bought by my father in late 1969 or maybe until 1970, because he liked "Here Comes the Sun". He also bought it again in 1979, in a "Picture Disc" limited edition release. He even bought the C.D. in the late `80s.

Report this review (#78949)
Posted Sunday, May 21, 2006 | Review Permalink
5 stars In "The White album" I couldn´t give 5 stars because it wasn´t a progressive record. Here Abbey road deseves this honor. I prefer The Beatles to Abbey Road, but, In a progressive point of view, this record is better.I Want you it´s maybe one of the first dark and heavy progressive records. The Second side is just the work of a genius, in this case, the work of 4 genius plus George Martin, The song You never give me your money make a musical concept until The End. Listen all the progs that sail here! This record improved Sgt Pepper and made Progressive Music accesible.The Beatles gave the first brick in Progressive Music, no doubt. Well Done Lads!
Report this review (#80265)
Posted Saturday, June 3, 2006 | Review Permalink
Chicapah
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars After struggling to record the sub-par and rough-edged "Let it Be" the Beatles realized that it would not be a fitting or appropriate testimony to their glorious legacy and made amends with George Martin to help them create another great LP. The result is an album that is topped only by "Sgt. Peppers" and equalled only by "Revolver" and "Rubber Soul." Starting with the brilliant mood of the surreal "Come Together," they set the music world on its ear once again. The only things that keep this from being their best effort are the silly "Maxwell" and "Octopus' Garden" which are way too whimsical to appeal to me over the long haul. They are brilliantly produced and recorded but they just don't belong alongside the other magnificent compositions that surround them. Starting with "I want you (she's so heavy)" the Fab Four created their most progressive music ever. (I hear shades of this musical refrain as Dream Theater fades out of "Scenes from a Memory"). Harrison's "Here comes the sun" is a delight in its simplicity. The medley of songs that close out the album fit together so well that it defies description. If there was a Grammy for multiple-song editing it would be named for Mr. Martin and his engineering crew just because of this effort. It has no reason to flow so well but somehow it just works like a charm. Every song is great and lasts just long enough to make an indelible impression. Nothing else in rock music history even comes close to it. In retrospect this was, indeed, "The End" of a miraculous era in music and the tunes they gave us througout their career have stood the test of time as if they were carved from granite. The cover pictured them walking out of our lives but they will never leave our hearts and our memories. What a great way to exit stage left! Bravo!
Report this review (#84303)
Posted Thursday, July 20, 2006 | Review Permalink
5 stars The Beatles last album they recorded and their album which was the closest to being prog. A real masterpiece. For one final time, the Beatles went into the studio and recorded one of their finest albums. The second side was especially influential to what prog would become.

The Good: "Here comes the Sun" showed George Harrison was up there with Lennon/McCartney in the songwriting department. The suite on the second side was one of McCartney's best ideas.

The Bad: "I Want You (She's so Heavy)" Iis a song I could never get into.

The Ugly: "Octopus's Garden" shows Ringo just didn't know how to write music to save his life. And his pathetic drum solo on "The End" makes me wonder how bad Pete Best must have been for them to get rid of him for Ringo.

But overall this is a masterpiece of progressive music and set the stage for the great progressive music which would come in the 70's.

Report this review (#84554)
Posted Saturday, July 22, 2006 | Review Permalink
5 stars George Martin was a genious. He was the 5th Beatles. Every musician in this group was also a genious. That's why Abbey Road is so inspired, terrific ! You must have it in your collection. I Want You (She's So Heavy) lasts for more than 7:40 minutes ! Everything is great on this effort except some minor pieces. Listen to it and you'll understand what I mean by "terrific", promised!
Report this review (#85730)
Posted Friday, August 4, 2006 | Review Permalink
Chris S
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
4 stars I think that as one progresses through the Beatle albums in terms of reviews it gets harder because musically in terms of technical ability I would not put any of them really " Up There". But as a unit and a songwriting collective force I doubt there have been few others who could compare as favourably as Harrison/Lennon and Macca.

' Abbey Road' is an excellent piece of work from beginning to end. Some specific highlights would be " Come Together ", " Octopus's Garden", " Golden Slumbers' and the fragile and beautiful ' Here Comes The Sun". Great work from a band who can be noted for being pioneers in the creation of epic progressive sounds.Four stars.

Report this review (#87353)
Posted Tuesday, August 15, 2006 | Review Permalink
4 stars Wow. Where do I begin? The Beatles recorded Abbey Road as their last album. However, Let It Be was cancelled due to the rage within the band, and the how they all separated more and more (But it was released in 1971 however.). So instead came Abbey Road, where they assured George Martin that things would be better. And boy, were they ever!

The album opens up with Come Together. A very bluesy song with heavy bass. One of the best songs they ever did in my opinion. The vocals are incredibly fitting and the organ solo in the middle displays which virtuosity the members had on their instruments (Well, Ringo can be debated lol). Then comes a nice guitar solo while the songs volume slowly goes down.

Then comes the beautiful ballad Something, written by George. The song itself is perhaps the second best song George ever wrote and is definitely way beyond any of the White Albums 'filler' ballads.

Now is probably one of the albums less good songs. However, that doesn't mean it's bad. It's sort of like a childrens song. But listen to the lyrics. Not too much ''Children'' about it anymore eh? It's about a serial killer. Quite amusing :)

Then comes a song we all recognize. Oh Darling. It's a very good song, with a lovely vocal performance delivered to us by Sir Paul McCartney. And while the song isn't any of the albums strong ones, it's a fun song to just put on and listen to.

And now for Ringo's best song; Octopus's Garden. This song is very nice actually, with very up-beat drums, lovely guitar tone and beautiful vocal harmonies. The singing could be better, but the only time it's noticable is the first time Ringo sings ''Garden'' where he hits the note terribly wrong.

And now for the most progressive song The Beatles were to write. At 7 minutes long; I Want You (She's So Heavy) starts out with a dark, nightmare-ish riff and then comes the real gem; the verse. Hypnotic drumming with absolutely stunning guitar and vocal work. Then comes the intro riff again, followed by an incredible guitar solo section with complicated drums (For Ringo that is) and then comes the verse again, and then comes that riff again. That scary riff, which now colaborates with moog to make a windy, foggy night effect. And it does just that. The song ends in the middle of a note. This was what John wanted, since he wanted the listener to realize that they had been carried away by nothing more than a simple composition. And didn't we? ;)

After this comes the Medley. Said by many to be the best songs in a row ever. And here's why:

Now comes Harrisons best known song ever; Here Comes The Sun. With such stunning, beautiful guitar, there's really no question about it. Great vocals, backed up by cool drumming makes for a very outstanding song. The outro is especially amazing.

And then the albums worst song. This is the reason I gave it four stars instead of five. It's called Because. It starts with a boring riff, followed by vocal harmonies that have been duplicated 3 times 3. So that's 9 voices. Sure, nice addition. But after some singing, the song goes on for what seems to be forever due to the fact that they don't sing words anymore. It's just ''aaaaaah''s and ''ooooooh''s.

You Never Give Me Your Money is a great song, with several sections. It has a rather jazzy intro piano, then comes a more Rock 'n' Roll verse followed by intermissions, solos and such. Brilliant.

Sun King is another filler, but it's a nice addition to the medley and has beautiful vocal work. In the end there is nonsense language that means nothing. I guess it's just one more of John's crazy ideas.

Mean Mr. Mustard is an upbeat rocker that's again, a nice addition and brings a little mood to the whole thing. The song has no outstanding sections but it's nice, and is followed directly by...

Polythene Pam which is an awesome song. Unfortunately, it is very short. However, this song defines the term short but sweet. The guitar is awesome, the vocals remind me of early Led Zeppelin. The song leads over into...

She Came In Through The Bathroom Window. This song really didn't catch my attention, and can get boring at times. But it's quite a good song overall.

Golden Slumbers is the beginning of the three songs that marked The End and left fans weeping. It's a beautiful song, quite sad but involves awesome drumming that sets the mood very good. It then quickly changes into...

Carry That Weight which is a very good song. In the middle is a little reprise from You Never Give Me Your Money, and then it changes to the normal song again. And then comes the final song...

The End. What a finish. It's upbeat, it's rocky, it's awesome. First there are some screeching vocals, followed by Ringo's only drum solo ever recorded. It's not a technical drum solo, but it's something. Then comes a choir with distorted guitars singing ''Love You''. This is where the golden part comes in; John, George and Paul take turns in playing solos. Sort of a duel if you may, however, a friendly one ;) Paul's simple, free form solos with higher pitched notes and tone, George's bluesy, hard sounding solos and John's heavily chordal based solos make for a final song that blows me away every time. Suddenly, it all stops to leave place for a beautiful piano riff followed by these very words; that people say was the meaning of The Beatles message: ''And in the end, the love you take is equal to the love you make''. Then, some final notes and chords, and then it all ends. Or does it? Not really...

Her Majesty is a 22 second song followed 14 seconds after The End. It's actually quite beuatiful, and could've joined Here Comes The Sun would it have been longer. But unfortunately it isn't. Oh well.

What a brilliant way to end The Beatles career.

Thank you for taking time and patience to read this review!

Report this review (#87740)
Posted Sunday, August 20, 2006 | Review Permalink
5 stars This is the last album of the greatest band of all time, and what a finish it is. After several unsatisfying albums (of the Beatles' standards), they shook the world with "Abbey Road". Even though "Abbey Road" was released before "Let It Be", it was recorded afterwards.

Come Together: There are a lot of classics on this album. This is the first. A very chill- out song; it has a bluesy feel to it. It's a nice Lennon-track, and it's a fine opener.

Something: This song is amazingly beautiful. Nice string arrangement and a great guitar- solo. This is probably Harrison's finest moment ever.

Maxwell's Silver Hammer: A fun little tune by McCartney about a serial-killer. It features synthesizers and percussion.

Oh! Darling: McCartney's best vocal performance ever. PERIOD. This is an amazing song, and probably Beatles' ultimate rocker.

Octopus's Garden: The traditional Ringo track featured on each album. A very charming song with nice vocal harmonies. Unfortunatley: The weakest track on the album...

(From this point ahead, the record is flawless. It's really a great experience)

I Want You (She's So Heavy): This is one of my favorite Lennon songs. An epic and pretty proggy song. The chorus sends shivers down my spine each time. Very nice guitar-solo.

(By this point in Harrison's career, he really started to shine. And it's pretty evident in the next song)

Here Comes the Sun: A very melodic song with nice acoustic guitar. It features string arrangements and synthesizer.

Because: It brings tears down my eyes. This is one of my favorite songs of all time. You could safely say, that this song is Queen's biggest inspiration. It features stunning melancholy vocals: A choir...

Now we get to the good part... I usually describe this next piece as simply: "The Abbey Road Suite". It's a 16-minute song compiled of 8 unfinished Lennon/McCartney songs. It is arguably Beatles's finest moment. The song start with the beautiful "You Never Give Me Your Money and continues with such classics as "Sun King", "She Came In Through The Bathroom Window", "Golden Slumbers" and "The End". This song should be experienced by anyone interested in good music. Ít's a great end to the Beatles' career.

This record shares the space as the best Beatles album with Sgt. Pepper, thus securing it as one of the finest albums of all time. Plus: It features the boys at their musically best. It's highlights are "Something", "I Want You (She's So Heavy)", "Because" and (of course!) the Abbey Road suite.

Report this review (#88456)
Posted Tuesday, August 29, 2006 | Review Permalink
3 stars The Beatles' influence on the music scene in general is above note-worthy, and this album (among many others) led to the creation of progressive rock. This is not only one of the most emotional albums, but one of the most interesting and generally fun albums. A lot of the songs carry meaning, which is not common with Beatles (for me, personally), but still is not perfect. Simplicity, and the lack of anything that jumps out screaming I'm special, I'm fresh, I'm new!. Many will argue and disagree with me, but this is my view.
Report this review (#94495)
Posted Saturday, October 14, 2006 | Review Permalink
5 stars oh, what a way to end such an amazing and important career as the Beatles had. I believe that at least half the plant would use "the Beatles" as the answer to "who is the best band ever known?" It really doesn't matter if the Beatles are your favorite band our not(actually their not my favorite band for instance) what they accomplished in their short career, and the the way they changed the music as we know it - is a thing that should not ever be touch, is a perfect being of a band.

"Abbey Road", is the last album ever record by the band, and it's truly shows the band in their most forced and focused state ever displayed by them. The album holds many famous pearls such as "come together" and "octopus garden", but in it hides magnificent pieces such as: "I want you", "Maxwell silver hammer", "because" - and Harrisons songs, whom in this album shows they he should never be under-rated near to Paul and john. such perfections as: "Here comes the sun", and "Something" - two songs who are close to my heart as to other millions of Beatles fans.

and finally there's the music apos that starts with "sun king", until "the end" - who perfectly sums up the essence of the Beatles:

"And in the end, the love you take equals to the love you make"

5/5

Report this review (#95148)
Posted Thursday, October 19, 2006 | Review Permalink
Ivan_Melgar_M
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
5 stars When THE BEATLES were added to Prog Archives I was one of the members who objected their inclusion, not because of the quality of the music but because I never considered them one of the most influential bands in the development of the genre called Progressive Rock and also being that most of their career (Until Sergeant Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band) they were not even remotely related with Prog.

But if I had to choose one album that justifies their inclusion in Prog Archives it would be the excellent and versatile "Abbey Road", a real masterpiece by the fabulous four that was clearly one step before all popular bands from the era.

The balance between songs is simply outstanding and the impeccable production helps a lot, side one is excellent but side two is almost perfect, almost an epic consisting of several short tracks linked perfectly one with the other.

"Abbey Road" starts absolutely strong with the legendary "Come Together" an almost Hard Rock track with intelligent lyrics and a great sound, breathtaking from start to end but the strength of this rack is more evident because of the contrast with the beautiful and calmed "Something" (Despite a good dose of drama), this guys really knew how to calm the mood when it was necessary.

"Maxwell Silver Hammer" it's a silly but funny little track acts as a relief after the dramatic first two tracks and allows us to appreciate more the bluesy "Oh Darling" another good track with strong piano sections and powerful vocals, would have been much better without the cheesy "oohs" by Paul Mc'Cartney that break the mood. (This shouts were OK for their early stuff but not for a serious album).

"Octopus's Garden" is one of the few songs by Ringo Star, I believe QUEEN used this simple but interesting track as inspiration for some of their songs as "Seaside Rendezvous", many people hate it but I really like it specially for the good backing vocal work.

"I Want You (She's so Heavy)" is a complete and evident product of the late 60's, the organ work takes us to the center of Psychedelia with it's druggy atmosphere and the guitar work is simply delightful and the Moog is outstanding and of course the beautiful Hammond Organ, probably the only 100% Progressive track THE BEATLES ever released, and what a masterpiece.

"Here Comes the Sun" is by far my favorite Harrison track and perfectly located to open side two, I always heard people saying it's a simple ballad, something with what I strongly disagree, the changes are subtle but brilliant, the chorus perfect and the synths are brilliant, never understood why some progheads seem dislike a good melody, a high point.

But the best is at the final part, the next tracks linked perfectly one with the other create one of the first real epics that starts with the excellent "Because", absolutely dramatic and based mostly in the strong vocals with dark mood and ends with the breathtaking "The End"..no not forgetting "Her Majesty" but well this could had easily be avoided..

If it was only for "Abbey Road" I would had never opposed to the inclusion of THE BEATLES in Prog Archives because this one is a real Prog masterpiece that deserves no less than 5 solid stars.

Don't expect another similar review by me about another BEATLES album because I always believed "Abbey Road" is their peak and by far, not even "Sergeant Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band" comes remotely close.

Report this review (#100294)
Posted Saturday, November 25, 2006 | Review Permalink
Mellotron Storm
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars It's really an honour to review a BEATLES record, and this was the last studio album they recorded. It's interesting that as prog was being birthed in the late sixties THE BEATLES had already had an illustrious career that was ending in 1969 with this record. For many BEATLES fans this is their favourite one of the lot, and certainly the album cover is famous.

The first song "Come Together" was a song I never really liked. Even when AEROSMITH covered this song in the late seventies I still didn't like it a whole lot, even though I was a big AEROSMITH fan back then. "Something" is one of the greatest ballads I have ever heard ! I must confess that George Harrison has always been my favourite BEATLE. The best for me on this record is "Here Comes the Sun" followed by this song "Something", both George Harrison songs. As a matter of fact the closest BEATLES paraphernalia I ever owned was a George Harrison t- shirt when I was in my teens. "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" was a fun song who's lyrics reminds me of the old English nursery rhymes. "Oh ! Darling" is Paul McCartney all the way. "Octopus's Garden" is a Ringo sung and written song that is quite good. "I Want You (she's heavy)" is dark and heavy.

"Here Comes The Sun" was written at a time when THE BEATLES seemed to have these endless meetings to discuss business, and sign forms and cheques etc. with their management and accountants etc. Anyway George decided to skip one of the meetings he was supposed to go to with the rest of the band, and he drove out to the country to a farm on a sunny day and wrote this song with his guitar in hand. Just listen to the lyrics and the melody that is full of light and evokes happiness. "Because" is dark, while "You Never Give Me Your Money" has a beautiful piano intro and the guitar is good later in the song as well. "Sun King" is reserved, while the next three song blend into each other like a medley of songs. All three are uplifting and fun tunes.The next three as well blend together forming another medley, as the album ends with a less than 20 second song.

This is one of my top three favourite BEATLES albums and a must-have people.

Report this review (#106930)
Posted Tuesday, January 9, 2007 | Review Permalink
5 stars In my opinion, probably the best Beatles album ever made, with the possible exception of Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, close tie there! It is an absolute masterpiece as far as The Beatles go, and there is not a hint of the lingering annoying pop songs that usually accompany their best songs on albums. No, only good songs here (still pop, but good), and not just good, but great wonderful songs that stick in your head for years.

The album was supposed to be a return to the olden days of Beatles greatness, without the arguments that accompanied the album productions before it. It is tightly prepared, and it shows. The two sides of the album represent the two tastes of John Lennon and Paul McCartney. Side one appeals to Lennon, and it is a collection of short, catchy and wonderful songs. Side two for McCartney consists of songs making one long ballad, all in all, the two album halves are very different.

"Come Together" provides a good starting point to get the album rolling, it is fast-paced, up beat and one of those songs that just makes you want to have a good time. A misunderstood hippie (weren't they all) provides good backdrop to set up an interesting song that will have you humming along despite yourself.

"Something" is the silly romanticist pop side of The Beatles-or so you think, but the song has good music to it as well. The distinctive guitar is very entertaining. Though it tends to air on the dramatic side, this song is great in its own right. And besides, sometimes dramatic romantic songs are just what one needs!

"Maxwell's Silver Hammer" is perhaps the most catchy, happy song about murder you will ever run across. It goes right up there with Roundabout on my list of songs that just make me pleasantly happy. This is the song that, at least for me, got stuck in my head for weeks the moment I heard it. A fun lighthearted track that almost comically hides the dark lyrics, thus making them not dark at all.

"Octopus's Garden" was written by Ringo Starr. Not by any stretch the best song on the album, but a well-done little song with amazing backup vocals. Same goes for the next track: "I Want You (She's So Heavy)", good, not the best, but takes away absolutely nothing from the album by bring there, so it is a good addition to add more of The Beatles wonderful music to be enjoyed.

"Here Comes the Sun" is one amazing song The Beatles did, it has great guitar, drums, and especially vocals, up-beat and happy, the keyboard in it keeps it from becoming repetitive, and it becomes one of the best additions to the album.

The next part of the album form a clear McCartney-like epic. Starting with "Because", it ends eight songs later with the appropriately named track "The End". An epic to be remembered as one The Beatles crowning achievements, and rounds of this album at a comfortable five stars.

The last track is "Her Majesty" is only 28 seconds long, but a surprisingly good 28 seconds, not that it really matters much, but it is probably the best 28 second song in the universe, in my opinion. As soon as I find another one to compete with it, I'll tell you.

The Beatles really showed there best in this album, making it their best work, and one of the best and most influential works rock history has ever seen.

Report this review (#108604)
Posted Tuesday, January 23, 2007 | Review Permalink
4 stars 4.5 stars for this album. Between 4 and 5, I go with four beacause it's not a perfect album.

I've never been a big Beatles fan, but this is one album everyone has to hear at least once in a liletime. It's not perfect, as there are weaker points like Maxwell's Silver Hammer, Oh! Darling and You Never Give Me Your Money. I think the best part is the ''medley'' between Sun Kind and The End. It flows so well between two tracks, I didn't even realised they were separate songs the first time I listened to the album. A five star rating might be too much. Maybe a hardcore Beatles fan would have another opinion, but I see it that way.

Report this review (#119915)
Posted Thursday, April 26, 2007 | Review Permalink
5 stars I didn't use to like the Beatles.

It's true. I really disliked them, especially their so-called "masterpiece" Sgt.Pepper, and i thought that everybody who did were simply brainwashed. I always had a soft spot in my heart for "Octopus' garden" though, and because of that i once desided that i should give Abbey Road a try. So one day when i was at my sister's, we took out the album and played a few songs, her trying to explain to me why the Beatles WRE as good as everybody said, me trying to resist the temptation to dig in on the music. I failed. Miserably. By the time it had come to "The End" i had completely given up pretending that "Okay, maybe that one was good, but the next is probably not", and just told her that i needed to listen to the album again, as soon as possible. So an hour or so later, i lay down on the floor, alone in the apartment, and let the Beatles speak to me through her stereo, and as i lay there i had what some refer to as a "moment". I felt the true essence of music filling me for 49 minutes straight, telling me that everything i had ever felt was wrong, and that this is the way i need to live my life from now on. It sounds stupid, and of course i'm exaggerating, but it IS true that, after listening to Abbey Road (twice, and then digging upp sgt. pepper the same day and listening to it 3 times in a row) that day, my whole perspective on what music is changed. Before Abbey Road i was all about ELP and Genesis, and all music which could be considered "simpler" than that, i did not consider worth listening to. Abbey Road made me appreciate music, it opened my eyes, and no music did ever sound the same afterwards.

Now i know that it was only a matter if time before i dropped my silly notion of what i considered "music", and what was important, and i know that if the Beatles hadn't been there, it might as well have been any other good cd in my sister's collection, but i also remember the intensity of the outro of "i want you", how the notes fell on my head like soft raindrops a hot summer day when "here comes the sun" started playing directly after, and the whole section from "you never give my your money" through the end struck me as absolute musical genius, each new section turning my stomach in anticipation while my heart screams "never stop!"

Abbey Road is the album where the Beatles took every good element from their past and distil them into their absolute masterpiece, their swansong. And since i even like the goofy numbers (maxwell's silver hammer, octopus' garden), it's all good to me! Some may consider it an uneven album, and while i can understand that, to me it's gold from start to finish, and the majority of my favourite Beatles moments are found in here as well (when the piano comes in in "the end", "here comes the sun", the "carry that weight/you never give me your money" medley...) The most "Prog" of the Beatles' albums as well, and with more triple vocal harmonies than you could ever need (but it's all good). It is varied, stylistically, and doesn't have that "plastic" studio feel that Sgt.Pepper sometimes does.

No matter if it fits the site's agenda or not, there is no way i can give this seminal album anything less than masterpiece rating. So that's exactly what i'm going to do.

Report this review (#126267)
Posted Monday, June 18, 2007 | Review Permalink
5 stars This album is the begning of a journey for me. It was the first album I heard in its entirety that wasn't inteded for a children's audience. Abbey Road is the start of my lifetime obsession with music. Despite what others may think, I still think Abbey Road is one of the greatest albums ever made, even after all the others I've heard over the years. I'm not sure weather I like this or Sgt. Pepper's more, but it's a masterpeice. Even on first listen I loved everything exept "Because", which has grown on me over the years.

Weather it be quirky pop (Octopus's Garden), Heavier rock (I Want You (She's So Heavy)), or the B side medley, everything is done outstandingly. The playing is better than the singing, not all that common for The Beatles. Come Together is a nice funky exercise. Somthing is my favorite Beatles song, what beautiful lyrics from George Harrison. Maxwell's Silver Hammer is a nice catchy tune, funny concidering what the song actualy is about. Oh Darling and Octopus's Garden are more nice pop songs, followed by the Rocking I Want You (She's so Heavy). This song has amazing guitar and bass.

Continuing onto the second half of the record, we have the famous Here Comes The Sun, a nice, lighter track. Because is kind of weird, mabey the most progish thing here (Abbey Road is not really one of the albums that got the Beatles put on this site). Once those to finish, we get the great medly. Wow. What an amzing exit for a band. This was just a bunch of ufinished songs for the most part, but are fine in this format. Not bad for a band about to impload. This album is an absolute essential in any collection.

Report this review (#127188)
Posted Saturday, June 30, 2007 | Review Permalink
Hercules
PROG REVIEWER
2 stars When I cleared 2-300 albums out of my own collection last year to make way for a large collection I inherited, this was one of the first to go along with the other Beatles albums. I grew up with The Beatles and Beatlemania and never got seduced by it, and even though I bought all their albums to try I didn't play them more than once or twice as there was nothing to grab my interest - no great epics, few decent solos and dull melodies. I get the impression that they were experimenting to find out what they did best and they didn't get it right very much even by this, their final album. The musicianship is basic and several songs are deplorably bad (the cheesy Octopuses' Garden being the absolute pits). Come Together and Here Comes The Sun redeem it a bit, just enough to save it from the ultimate degradation. And my final comment - how does such a mainstream pop album ever get on a progressive site?
Report this review (#130049)
Posted Tuesday, July 24, 2007 | Review Permalink
Finnforest
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
3 stars Strung-together leftovers from Let It Be do not equal genius

The Beatles swan song is holy to some who consider it their finest hour. I respectfully disagree with my esteemed colleagues. While the production here is better than the original Let it Be, the songs are mostly leftovers from those sessions (for those unaware, LiB was recorded before Abbey Road, even though it was released after it) and by this time our lads were phoning it in and looking ahead to their solo careers. I am a Beatle fan and Abbey Road is the one I play the least. Let it Be features far better material than Abbey Road.

"Come Together" is a real Lennon yawner that just bores me to tears. The two Harrison hits on this album are admittedly wonderful and it's these songs that keep Abbey Road from being a 2 star album. George finally beats both Paul and John in song quality on an album and it's not even close. "I want you" is a good song but Lennon would do much better soon on Plastic Ono Band. The majority of the rest of the songs range from completely dreadful to mediocre, the worst being Maxwell, Octopus, Mr. Mustard, and Poly Pam. On the latter Lennon sounds positively contemptuous on his "yeah yeah yeah" bit, like he couldn't wait to get out the door.

It is true that Abbey Road has a really nice sheen to it, a certain whole feeling imparted by the connected tracks and the high quality production. It sounds good but it's empty calories music. Look at the meat of the songwriting and it's frightfully thin, again, except for Harrison. The other stuff has very little soul, little grit, little of the Lennon/McCartney spark and passion. I'm supposed to care about Maxwell and Poly Pam after being treated to things like Across the Universe, Two of Us, I've Got a Feeling, and Long & Winding Road? People often mistake side 2 as some kind of genius moment akin to great progressive rock, as if simply stringing together some mediocre bits that were lying around makes a profound musical statement. I've never understood this line of thinking.

They manage to concoct a very nice ending sequence of "Golden Slumbers/Carry that Weight/The End" which literally saves the day and puts a period at the end of the Beatles career, though ending with Let It Be would have been far superior. We could now look forward to decades of (often) subpar material from our lads solo careers after a few good albums like Plastic Ono Band, All Things Must Pass, and Band on the Run.

Abbey Road is without question the most over-rated Beatle album (yes I'm using the dreaded O-word for this occasion) and the last one I'd suggest to young Beatle fans. Start at the beginning and work your way forward chronologically through the brilliant career of these legends. The very best albums are the debut, Rubber Soul, Magical Mystery Tour, and Let it Be (get the Naked version.)

Report this review (#134816)
Posted Saturday, August 25, 2007 | Review Permalink
Seyo
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
5 stars Along with "Revolver" this is perhaps the best BEATLES album. And I am talking in terms of experiment, studio wizardry, avant- gardistic approach, groundbreaking and progressive expansion of the sound, composition and musical ideas.

Apart from obvious hit-start with "Come Together", Harrison and Starr provided their arguably best compositions penned for the group - "Something", "Octopus's Garden" and "Here Comes the Sun". Lennon/McCartney duo on the other hand made their way through the first side via strange and disturbing "Maxwell Silver Hammer" and 7-minutes minimalistic improvisation of "I Want You".

The whole of Side B is devised as a semi-suite of 10 short pieces tied together in what sounds like a magnificent pop-symphony, with the main theme from "You Never Give Me Your Money" repeating in the closing parts of "Carry That Weight". Something that would be brought to perfection by GENESIS in the following decade... "Abbey Road" is very important album for progressive rock style and a masterpiece of THE BEATLES in its own right.

PERSONAL RATING: 4,5/5

P.A. RATING: 5/5

Report this review (#140535)
Posted Tuesday, September 25, 2007 | Review Permalink
5 stars This is a prime example of what progressive pop rock should be from I Want You to the hidden track Her Majesty. The first side is basically pop rock with the double sided smash of Something/ Come Together being the standouts. The Progressive side starts with the avant hard rock blues of I Want You She's Heavy with the unexpected ending. Here Comes the Sun has mixed meters in the middle section with an early use of synthesizer. Because is a classical influenced song with one of there best vocal harmonies.

You Never Can Give Me Your Money basically starts medley one the song is a 4 part song a prog feature, with many guitar tones and great vocal harmonies, then the Sun King fades in sounding a lot like Pink Floyd. After She Comes through The Bathroom Window starts medley two with the Symphonic rock of Golden Slumbers then combining it with hard rock in Carry That Weight and The End. The final track is a hidden track another strong prog feature in Her Majesty the song ends abruptly like side one and I don't know if a rock album before this ended two sides this way.

Report this review (#141505)
Posted Tuesday, October 2, 2007 | Review Permalink
4 stars 1. Come Together::::::::::was written as the campaign song for Timothy Leary while he was running for Govener of California, real mellow.
2. Something::::::::::::Written by George Harrison for his wife, the one that Eric Clapton stole from him, beautiful ballad, great string arragement, fantastic vocals and guitar. Soft drums from Ringo and smooth bass from McCartney.
3. Maxwell's Silver Hammer:::::::::::::Werid tune telling a story of a murderer who uses a silver hammer as the murder weapon. Sung by Paul and features the Minimoog synthesizer.
4. Oh Darling::::::::::Sung By Lennon, sounds kinda like a 50's doo-woop love song mixed with modern rock. The bass is fluent and stong and carries this song. Lennon narates the song while shouting "When you told me."
5. Octopus's Garden::::::::::::Sung by Ringo. The weakest song on the album. Though it has nice backing vocals, and effects.
6. I Want You::::::::::::::::::::Quite possible the heaviest song The Beatles ever did besides Helter Skelter. The best song on the album. Jazzy drums paint the background, while the lead guitar imitates Lennon's voice, the rhythm guitar: distorted and lould. An organ fills in the gap and the bass provides the heart beat of the song. The end of the song gets staticy and then just cuts off.
7. Here Comes The Sun:::::::::Another Harrison song. Beautiful song that has a nature overtone: Acoustic and soft filled in by the minimoog.
8. Because::::::::::::::::::::::::Another weak song in my honest opinion. The focal point is the harmony vocals and keyboards.
9. You Never Give Me Your Money::::::::::::: Soft piano driven. At 1:10 into the song, the song takes a drastic change, leading to a more guitar driven and vocal harmony driven end.

The rest of the songs all form one large song, blending into each other, which many claim to be the highlight of the album. My favorite part of the suite is Golden Slumbers, which has beautiful vocals. I know that the Beatles had pretty much broken up during this time, even though the Beatles didn't purposly record this album (it was pasted together from outtakes from the Get Back sessions, which was released as Let It Be) it is still often regarded as one of the Beatles best albums ever released.

Report this review (#155051)
Posted Monday, December 10, 2007 | Review Permalink
ZowieZiggy
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars The band had almost finished "Let It Be" (under difficult circumstances) when Paul suggested to Martin to start another album, more in the spirit of a band's album like they were used to do in their early days. This idea was well received and the Fab Four started the sessions for "Abbey Road".

The band will come up with some of their finest songs. Especially George. "Something" is one of the very best Fab Four song. One could say that it is the most McCartney ones of his creation. An enormous melody, an emotional guitar solo (but "While My Guitar. was already a hint of this). It is my fave of this album.

It was released as a single (which I purchased in 1971) with "Come Together". Another great and famous Lennon song. It will be the first Nr. 1 hit from George. It was initially meant for Joe Cocker who will perform an incredible cover of "With A Little Help For My Friend" at Woodstock.

The first weak moment is for sure "Maxwell's Silver Hammer". Just press next and listen to "Oh Darling". It is an excellent song from Paul even if he had some problems with his voice at the time. John has even said that :" He could have done a better job, but since Paul wrote it, he should be on the leading vocals".

"Octopus Garden" is the second song written by Ringo in the Fab Four history. It is also one of my fave from Ringo when he was in charge of the lead vocals.

The closing number of side one "I Want You (She's So Heavy)" is my second preferred track from this album. And so it was some thirty four years ago when I discovered it. It is a dual song with two separate parts. It is their second longest composition (after "Revolution 9") and features an hypnotic and heavy guitar riff with an abrupt finale which was desired by John. The band developped a long and vibrant instrumental section, which was not the standard for the band.

The contrast with "Here Comes The Sun" is enormous, especially when you listen to the CD version since it just comes straight after. I already made this type of comment for "Rubber Soul" when "Michele" finished side one and "What Goes On" started side two.

It is another of the very good George composition. He wrote it while being at his friend Eric Clapton's house. He just grab an acoustic guitar, walked in the garden, thought of the never ending English winter and wrote this great song. Sounds so easy... Lennon did not participate in the recording.

In terms of melody "Because" is probably the most beautiful one from this album (on par with "Something"). John was really at his best while writing it. The song features interesting synthesizers work as well.

IMO, it ends the most interesting part of this album. The next eight songs are some sort of "suite" of which "Sun King" is very soft and melodic. But there is little consistency in this work. They are really eight different short songs.

The McCartney parts being very pleasant ("You Never Give me your Money "and "Golden Slumbers"). On the "Carry That Weight" chorus, the four members are signing (which was not often the case).

During "The End" each member will perform a short solo (even Ringo for fifteen seconds! ). It is a song with lots of theme change which should have closed this album instead of the ridiculously short "Her Majesty" The shortest track ever recorded by the Fab Four (twenty-two seconds.).

It is the Fab Four album in which McCartney was the less involved. Probably becuase he was thinking of something else...

"Abbey road" is very good and will peak at the first spot of the UK charts for seventeen weeks. Four months!

Four stars.

Report this review (#155592)
Posted Sunday, December 16, 2007 | Review Permalink
Gatot
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
4 stars The artwork of this album has been so legendary that some people always refer to it whenever the cross the road. In fact in some of the social activities with my friends - especially those who knew this album we always mention "Let's do Abbey Road!" referring to crossing the road when went out together for lunch, for example. This cover has also inspired the artwork of modern band Red Hot Chili Pepper. Actually, the artwork is so mundane and nothing so special. It's probably the music that made the artwork very popular. This album contains all excellent tracks and nothing is "just good" as far as music composition. All of the songs are truly excellent. The opening track "Come Together" (4:20) is an excellent rocker with great ambient and groove. It has a powerful nuance resulting from a combination of bass guitar work and guitar plus drums. It flows beautifully with "Something" (3:02) which has some blues flavor in the music. This song is so legendary and it was one of my favorites during my childhood.

The next track "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" (3:27) is a pop rock outfit that suits beautifully after "Something" and it connects naturally to another bluesy pop "Oh Darling" (3:26). "Octopus's Garden" (2:51) opens a great welcome of a song with great riffs "I Want You (She's So Heavy)" (7:47) which has very strong orientation towards rock music. "Here Comes The Sun" (3:05) gives a musical break. All the remaining songs are excellent, including: "Because" (2:45) - which has good vocal harmonies, "You Never Give Me Your Money" (4:02), "She Came In Through The Bathroom Window" (1:57), "Golden Slumbers" (1:31) - "Carry That Weight" (1:36).

It's odd if we love classic rock music but do not have a copy of this legendary and truly excellent album. All songs are masterpiece and memorable.

Peace on earth and mercy mild - GW

Report this review (#157000)
Posted Saturday, December 29, 2007 | Review Permalink
Atavachron
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
5 stars Despite the growth apart they were experiencing and bizarre legends that haunt this release, it shows a band at the height of their powers, modern but firmly rooted in the rock experience that came before them. Producer George Martin evidently wanted the boys to make a proper record after the brilliant but cobbled-together White Album and fun jams of the Get Back sessions, and the tracks on Abbey Road were a reasonable extension of the former. Plans to do a nearly-full side of continuous, interconnected songs that was envisioned for Pepper's but shelved (a decision long-lamented by Ringo) had finally come to fruition, and the whole feeling of the album is, ironically, charged with positivism and gleaming with electrical energy.

Starting the record with typical Beatles class is 'Come Together', John making no allusions about his increasing concern for all of us, the people pulling us apart and what needs to happen despite his rock star status, but George Harrison calms things with the delicate 'Something'. Paul is up next with two; the altogether strange fairytale of Maxwell and his magical mallet cracks even him up and is in a very 'Honey Pie' vein, and his early work with Little Richard comes screaming out in 'Oh! Darling'. 'Octopus's Garden' could best be described as a children's song, but it's 'I Want You (She's So Heavy)' that is really the shining moment on the first half, an astonishing piece even for the Fab Four with size, drive and undeniable power. It is one of their finest moments, clearly influential on all serious rock musicians to this very day and though sung by John, it sounds like a true group effort here. Harrison's flourishing talents as composer are heard on 'Here Comes the Sun', fortifying and hopeful for the future. The song is taken from material he and Eric Clapton were playing with, Harrison recalls: "Here Comes The Sun was written at the time when Apple was getting like school, where we had to go and be businessmen: 'Sign this' and 'sign that'. Anyway, it seems as if winter in England goes on forever, by the time spring comes you really deserve it. So one day I decided I was going to sag off Apple and I went over to Eric Clapton's house. The relief of not having to go see all those dopey accountants was wonderful, and I walked around the garden with one of Eric's acoustic guitars and wrote Here Comes The Sun".

That pretty much says it all about this period and it becomes clear that personal differences weren't the only things pulling them apart. But you'd never know it, 'Because' being one of the most beautiful group vocal performances in history (the voice tracks sans music is a must hear for fans), perfectly recorded synthesizers still sounding as fresh as ever and 'You Never Give Me Your Money' is hilarious, Paul's blues piano and tragically hip lyrics leading. Brian Wilson's extraordinary influence is heard on John's sultry and romantic 'Sun King', followed by his 'Mr. Mustard' and sister song 'Polythene Pam'. McCartney pretty much closes out the show with 'She Came in Through the Bathroom Window', throat-lumping and sublimely arranged 'Golden Slumbers', sage 'Carry That Weight', their farewell to the world with 'The End' and final, funny and wonderfully absurd 'Her Majesty'.

Though Let it Be was released a year later, this was indeed goodbye. It is a flawless testament to four young guys with good souls and a gift for rock 'n roll the world is unlikely to see again, and it was an inestimable evolutionary moment for rock.

Report this review (#158782)
Posted Wednesday, January 16, 2008 | Review Permalink
3 stars Not my favorite Beatles album at all, even if there is a lot of great songs here : Something, Here Comes The Sun, Come Together, You Never Give Me Your Money and all that medley which comes after this last song I quote...

Abbey Road is the Beatles's most best-selling album (for an album, not a compilation), but not the most revered album. You must admit that the magic which was on Sgt. Pepper, Magical Mystery Tour and Revolver (and even on the White Album on a certain way, but I think it's another kind of magic) is gone here. The Beatles were almost dead when this release came out, and the last to come, Let It Be, was a confirmation to this statement.

Some good moments, so, but some horrible stuff too : Maxwell's Silver Hammer is a mess, Octopus's Garden too (what the f**k anyway with Ringo's songs ?), I want you (She's so heavy) is good but too long and repetitive (look out ! a guitar riff Pink Floyd will take for their In The Flesh ? song, in the album The Wall !), Oh ! Darling is a bore...

Abbey Road is a good album. Just a good one.

Report this review (#162847)
Posted Thursday, February 28, 2008 | Review Permalink
4 stars This is an absolutely delightful album. It doesn't have the absolute strength of songs that some Beatles albums have, but it is a real pleasure to listen to it, and also includes a fair bit of (proto) Proginess.

'Come Together' mixes psychedelia and tinges of hard rock to become a great hippy anthem. 'Soemthing' contrasts the high energy of the previous track by focusing on soft, beautiful melodies. 'Maxwell's Silver Hammer' is an amusing song about a... silver hammer! 'Oh Darling' is an average Beatles song (which is to say very good). 'Octopus's Garden' is a great, underated song courtesy of Ringo who is normally the memeber I respect least. 'I Want You (She's So Heavy)' is a masterpiece. The end is a brilliant repetitive riff, and I can hear the influence it must have had on bands such as diverse as System of a Down and Dream Theater. 'Here Comes the Sun' is another average song. 'Beacause' recalls the beauty of 'Something'. Then begins the epic medley:

'You Never Give Me Your Money' is a great song, and the longest section of the medley, being the socond longest song on this album. It's very good, and a highlight of the epic. 'Sun King', 'Mean Mr. Mustard', 'Polythene Pam' and 'She Came In Through The Bathroom Window' all continue in the same vein, introducing a series of interesting characters. 'Golden Slumbers' is a beautiful lullaby style piece. 'Carry That Weight' is another highlight including a reprise of 'You Never Give Me Your Money'. 'The End' closes the epic in a surprisingly proggy two minutes which is some of my favourite material by the Fab Four. Then there is another track on the end called 'Her Majesty' which is interesting, if not unecessary.

This album is pretty essential, and I like all of it, and love most of it. It isn't quite a masterpiece as there are a few uninteresting moments, especially in the first half. Very well deserving of four stars.

Report this review (#164228)
Posted Tuesday, March 18, 2008 | Review Permalink
TRoTZ
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars Much can be said about the Beatles, and I unquestionably I'm in the group who consider them one of the most overrated rock bands of all time. Even though, despite much of what they play had already been experimented before, in opposite of much of what is said about them, I have to admit certain works are evolved by a particularly sublime aura. This is the case. The album flow in a continuum, containing some precious moments like Something or Here Comes the Sun which elicit a genuinely appealing feeling, some more experimental tracks, other more rocking ones, all blended perfectly in a well done production. Regarding this matter, sound effects are scattered all over the album giving a special presence to the work, and inspiring perhaps the magnanimous Dark Side of the Moon years later. Lyrics and message are as well pretty decent - In the end, the love you take is equal to the love you make. Together with the pretentious and self-indulgent St. Peppers Lonely Hearts Club, this is probably the best Beatles has made and a classic of the history of rock music.
Report this review (#165427)
Posted Monday, March 31, 2008 | Review Permalink
5 stars I believe this album to be the start of progressive rock. I've never heard a band evolve the way The Beatles did. Remmember when they were still singing Roll Over Beethoven (very decent track too)? This album shows depth, and much more musicianship than ever before. So here are some reasons for my everlasting love for this album.

Come Together. Well...a timeless classic. Eventhough you can find this on the cheapest Beatles Greatest Hits, it still bashes the old idea of what I thought of Paul and John. Deny it if you want: this is one of the best basslines in Rock Music. I also love Harrison's wining guitar in the end (it's amazing how it compliments John Lennon's voice. 10/10

Something. Maybe this is the only track that reminds me of their later work, because it's still a very basic pop song. However, Abbey Road would not be what it is without this track. It does have a middle part which I love, that doesn't have a lot to do with the rest of the song. 8/10

Maxwell's Silver Hammer. I cannot imagine what my childhood would've been without this song. I remmember my dad taking me to school, and us too rocking all the way. Such a silly, but unbelievebly AMAZING song. The rythm, THE LYRICS...such a happy but dark song, about this psycho-kid, killing away with a hammer. That idea alone is enough for me haha. 10/10

Random note: one of the things which make this a beautiful prog album is how the songs unite almost as one SINGLE big song. One of the best examples are Something with Maxwell's Silver Hammer, or Because with You Never Give Me Your Money. Just beautiful...

Oh Darling. Simply my favorite love song of all time. But this is not just a love song...it's so full of McCartney's energy (the when you told me bit is just mindblowing, accompanied by those amazing keyboards). It really makes me feel like the guy's begging for mercy, something I really enjoy, maybe because I've lived it. This track is just a big part of my life, and it has saved me in obscure times. 10/10

Octopus's Garden Probably the most inocent part of the album. This, however, in my opinion at least, is the best song Ringo ever wrote.Eventhough it's naive and out-of-the-blue, it gives so much contrast to the rest of the album. The backing vocals are mellow and very enjoyable, as well as Harrison's guitar-playing. The backing vocals actually give a very sea-like effect to the song. And it's just so happy!! 9/10

I Want You (She's So Heavy) Just perfect. PERFECT. Talk about guitar-voice synchronization!!! Absolutely amazing breaks, where you can listen to that oh so beautiful bassline. Harrison's style changed completely, beginning to get a bit messier. The She's So... part is so unexpected, it barely lets me stand up straight. And that middle-solo is so compatible, immitating what the voice had already done: so new, so bluesy, so PROG. For me, this song tops anything else The Beatles ever did. 10/10

Here Comes the Sun. One of the strongest possitive vibes I've felt through music. It's always seemed to me this song was writen after a heavy rain (maybe that's because I've heard it a lot after it rains, and not just in a literal way). It is a reminder of hope, and beauty in general. It kills me when these guys's voices come together. Even though it's not a very prog song compared to the ones beside it (I Want You and Because), it is also a contrast climax in the album, and an all-time classic. 9/10

Because. A stoner song...yes, I know. I don't care, though. For me, it's difficult to get better than this. Just an attempt to understand the global picture, I think. Voices melt together perfectly, which is my favorite aspect of this song. However, one can always distinguish between them. Another fantastic example of guitar-voice synchronization, which is definately one of the strong features of this album. 10/10

You Never Give Me Your Money. Because has just ended, and suddenly this incredible piano line kicks in with unspeakable dexterity. McCartney's mellow voice runs through the verse, when it suddenly takes a whole different style in the middle-bridge (a style competely new to him, in my opinion. And here comes the prog ingredient, when the song takes another twist, and one realizes there is actually a track inside the track, if you know what I mean. Harrison's middle solo gives passage to something else, and no...the song is not yet over. When McCartney starts with One sweet dream.., the rythm has changed, the essence has changed, a completely different thing. And hey, talk about amazing lyrics. What else can one ask for??? 10/10

Sun King. Are we in India or WHAT?! A very very mellow song, perfect for stoners. I have played this track (bass) and only by doing this, I realized how beautiful it really was. Again, a mindblowing bassline, perfectly joining a smooth guitar, and suddenly, voices melt again, somehow returning to a Here Comes the Sun motive, and finally...is that Italian? Surprise after surprise. I cannot competely express how much I love this track, but these are definately some of my reasons. And there are more surprises coming...far from over. 10/10

Mean Mr. Mustard, Polythene Pam Another perfect track. Simply amazing how it comes together with Sun King. Very catchy rythm and lyrics, about a very every-day story. For me, this track and Polythene Pam are a single song, eventhough they are different in style. But again, here can one find the beginning of prog: these guys are working on concepts, not just random and isolated tracks. The story actually continues in the next track, Polythene Pam, which is full of energy, and in a competely different direction, ending with an amazing guitar solo. 10/10

She Came In Through the Bathroom Window Blending prefectly with Polythene Pam, this track starts with McCartney's voice, and off they go again. The chorus is my favorite part, because it's partially written in the minor scale, giving amazing contrast to the song. Both verses are moody and catchy, and then blend into the amazing line Did Anybody Tell Her? 10/10

Golden Slumbers Probably the best song of the album. Eventhough I don't like Rock accompanied by orchestras, they did a great job on this track. McCartney's voice in the middle part is...I had never heard a voice so powerful, so full of emotion. One can feel everything through those few lines. It also blends perfectly with the songs beside it, with a great piano intro, which gives way to these wonderful lyrics. 10/10

Carry That Weight Complimenting Golden Slumbers, this is a more playful song, but it never loses its integrity and ballance. I never believed McCartney could master this amazing style, but this song comes to show it (Oh yeah, all right...now you're gonna be in my dreams)This is followedby an unexpected and brief drum solo that comes rushing in. In this song, one can find another prog aspect, which is going back to a previous motive, in this case the one in You Never Give Me Your Money, but now immitated by brass instruments. 10/10

The End. The beginning of this song is much like the one on Golden Slumbers, with some piano chords before the voices melt again, showing for the first time, the exit. For me, the most beautiful part is Harrison's amazing guitar (especially how it gives way to the last song). 10/10

Her Magesty. I think I've never heard such a bizarre ending to an album. Maybe I haven't listened to enough music, but this is weird. The most unexpected thing happens. A very funny guitar line joins MCCartney in a very very very mellow and joyful song, which only last a couple of seconds, leaving us with some sort of mystery. I have never understood it, but this somehow makes it a great ending. 8/10

I am sorry I have used the words incredible, mindblowing, amazing, etc etc so much, but in this case in particular, they are simply unavoidable. If you want to know how rockers started thinking differently, go back and listen to this incredibleamazingmindblowing album. I promise you won't regret it. If I could give more stars to this album, I definately would.

Report this review (#179100)
Posted Thursday, August 7, 2008 | Review Permalink
4 stars I borrowed this record from my dad, because I really hadn't heard much of the Beatles music. I was sure that the Beatles were just a good band from the 60s that got a bit too much airplay. Then I heard this album and I was impressed. If you listen to this album, you may start to appreciate the Beatles' musicianship.

Come Together is a great groovy little track. It's a catchy tune and it's a great opener for the rest of the album.

The next track, Something is a beautiful ballad-type track. About halfway through the song, the chords and the harmonies get a bit adventurous, making this not just a pretty song, but a fun pretty song.

Maxwell's Silver Hammer is an upbeat little ditty. It's a fun catchy little track. The lyrics are surprisingly disturbing for such a fun song, though they're not bad enough to make someone avoid this song.

Oh Darling and Octopus' Garden continue in the same fun/catchy songs vein, the former being a cheezy love song (and a good cheezy love song at that) and the latter being a fun nonsense type song.

I want you (She's so heavy) is one of the coolest tracks on the album. It is rather heavy and dark for a Beatles song, and it contains some great organ jamming and some sweet electric guitar riffs.

Here comes the Sun is fantastic. The chords and the harmonies are just perfect, and it's one of the most beautiful songs you will ever hear from the 60s era.

Because is an odd track. It's got some great melodies, but it's got a mysterious psychadelic type vibe. It's not fantastic, but it's a good song.

After this, the songs start to play out like a suite, with different themes appearing and re-appearing through the songs. You never give me your money is pretty at first, and after a couple of minutes it turns fun and bouncy.

Sun King is a simple acoustic type song, repeating lyrics from Here comes the sun and ending the song in Italian beautifully.

Now this is where things start to get fun. Mean Mr. Mustard is a short song about the bum on the street. After a minute, it flows into the next track, Polythene Pam, where the tempo picks up, and the band sings about Mr. Mustard's sister, who is so good looking but she looks like a man. Things keep picking up until finally it goes smoothly into She came in through the bathroom window, a good love song. After this everything drops out. You may be wondering why they would drop out the tracks after things started getting exciting. Well it picks up again.

Golden slumbers starts off slow enough, with some quiet piano. It continues the same way, until it adds some drums and segues into Carry that weight. Suddenly, the music and melody from You never give me your money appears. They just about wrap up the 'suite' when suddenly the tempo picks up quickly and it goes into The End, starting of with some cool drums. Everyone starts jamming out in the song behind a repeated, Love you in the background. It finally drops out, finishing with a grand and beautiful ending.

Her Majesty was originally going to be after Mean Mr. Mustard, but it works out for a nice little ditty for about 20 seconds. Not much to say about it.

What can I say. There are some great, fun songs at the beginning of the album, and the way the later half of the album goes together, it can make the listener very excited to hear it. I would reccomend this one to fans of both pop and prog alike.

Report this review (#180639)
Posted Saturday, August 23, 2008 | Review Permalink
J-Man
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars If you were to listen to Meet The Beatles, and then listen to this, you wouldn't even know it was the same band. The Beatles started out as a typical 60's rock group, and then made the first prog album ever. It has complexity, unique arrangements, diversity, and longer songs. Sound like prog to you? This abum is a masterpeice like no other. Sure other DT, Yes, and Genesis albums are better, but none hold their place in rock history like Abbey Road. It starts out with a great rocker, Come Together, and just gets better from there. Later in the album comes a very heavy and proggy 8-minute track followed by the lighthearted ballad, Here Comes The Sun. Next comes the Phsycadelic Because, and then the album really begins. A 16-minute epic that defined prog as we know it. It starts out with beautiful piano chords with Paul singing, and then the rest of the band comes in. This idea is later reprised in Golden Slumbers and Carry That Weight, with elaborate arrangements. Then comes the grand finale to The Beatles, The End. The band goes back and forth with 2-bar guitar solos, and let me tell you: IT ROCKS!! Then the piano comes in and, using one of the greatest lines in rock music, And in the end, the love you take is equal to the love you make. I love The Beatles, and this album entirely sums up why: A high recommendation those who still think The Beatles are like The Rolling Stones.
Report this review (#190190)
Posted Saturday, November 22, 2008 | Review Permalink
ProgShine
COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
5 stars 01. Come Together Come Together is one of the most famous riffs in the world of rock (the riff in question is the riff from bass of Paul), the song was kind of an anthem for John and he played throughout his solo career. The sound of the Beatles is unique and all tones are almost impossible to recreate. Has a guitar work invoked in the bottom of the music that is very difficult to hear and the vocal support of Paul were perfect. And what about the chorus? One of the most thrilling and exciting things. Question? You have a band? So enjoy this music and play on your shows you'll see is true, I can attest. It has a keyboard solo from already short of an amendment on guitar. The drums of Ringo I love. Have that timbre 'tuneless' he's one that few talk about but it should be more respected.

02. Something George does not write with the same speed of Lennon and McCartney, but when did ... God, when he did it... Such a pearl of the world songbook already re-recorded thousands of times. And special attention to the great Paul McCartney in one of the most sensational lines already written down for bass. And of course we have the hand of the 5th Beatle George Martin with beautiful orquestrations and a shy keyboard in background. The guitar break? Good solo is the more melodic that has news, regret the whole body to tell you the truth. Save George wherever you are, the more quiet of Fab Four, never got into scandals, his only fault was being too religious and believe in the wrong people (read Indian Gurus and alikes).

03. Maxwell's Silver Hammer What is this? Simple! Paul! He is one of the greatest composers who have already stepped on the planet. One of the most expensive musical of the music world. Paul song that tells a story super cool and crazy about a student who put the hammer on the head of a bunch of people (laughter), he is as brilliant? Who would imagine a demented lyrics with a melody that beautiful? Ah! And do not forget the lines of synthesizer (in 69? Yep!) And sensational guitar lines from George!

04. Oh! Darling To complement what I said up there we have the top 3 McCartney. Excellent bass (Something), excellent composer (Maxwell's Silver Hammer) and a awsome vocalist (Oh! Darling). How can someone sing so very different as if he had not doing anything much? Saw this guy! The 'ballad' has composed more emotional! Pay attention to small details (aka the whole disk).

05. Octopus's Garden Ringo's song, quiet unusual in the Beatles! Octopus's Garden is a country half way rock song with a weird chorus and modulation of tone for solo. The guitars vary and George was sensational. The voice of John and Paul too!. The voice of Ringo is the perfect for this song, he does not have what we call 'voice for singing' but in none of the songs he sang with the Beatles in any of them I have some kind of complaint.

06. I Want You (She's So Heavy) MY GOD! WHAT WOULD IT? This is BEATLES? Are you sure? These are common questions of who hears I Want You for the first time. Only this song has affected half of prog musicians on the planet (and I say the King Criimson for sure). John sings incessantly while the same phrase in almost all the music accompanies the guitar in perfect tune. And the chorus is one of the most sensational things of the world, we could be listening to this music even if she had some 30 minutes (which was delicious). The guitar break is another pearl, started with the melody of the song. And do not forget the hidden Hammonds entire range. Voice more than perfect (hey, we're talking about Beatles here, perfection is redundant). She's So ...... Heaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaavyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy !!!!!!! UAU!

07. Here Comes The Sun Well, here we started the 2nd part of the album, in fact I'm sure that this track should have been in Side 1 of the lp as all the rest is composed of small beads all linked, probably was not included in part 1 for lack of time, and many great songs! Like I said above George is a great composer, at Here Comes The Sun this does not change at all. All we know this song. The beginning of the guitar is beautiful, something genius. Fantastic melody. Great band! I love these guys.

08. Because Here we begin what should be a single track (one day I will put all together just to have the taste, laughter). The guitar and keyboard sounds that begin very well together. And the voice? All singing together in perfect vocalization. It is difficult for me to write about it because most of the time I'm singing along (laughs).

09. You Never Give Me Your Money This piano is divine, most of the melodies of Paul and the bass from the beginning? UAU! Until no more emotional power. And for diversifying the chorus is full of Honky Tonk, a kind of sallon sound. The drums of Ringo is that splendid party! A lullaby in the end only makes the most sensational thing. Great guitars at the end.

10. Sun King One step further and arrived in Sun King (which originally was called Here Comes The Sun-King, but John changed the the name, this way it is not equal to the music of George that opens the side 2). The most sensational of the band (besides the weather and the guitar 'Hawaiian') are the vocals in Spanish, very cool to hear the Beatles singing in Spanish. And again Paul hit the bass.

11. Mean Mr. Mustard Another great track! A half-moon tambourine is a percussion in the background while the band sends one of his most sensational stories about fictional characters (or not!), The effect that Paul was put in the bass is sensational.

12. Polythene Pam Polythene Pam comes in, which in itself is a continuation very cool, has a nice guitar in the background and the basic voice of John was spectacular, and was the guitar solo of course.

13. She Came In Through The Bathroom Window A hell of a melody, a guitar and a wonderful bunch of vocals in the background. Aside from the excellent chorus, and melancholy.

14. Golden Slumbers Is just fantastic! What George (Martin) did with the orchestra here haven't a price (give a look on the disc 'Love' he has launched with collages of sounds of the Beatles and will understand why the guy is genius), and once again shows that Paul is one of the best vocalists of the rock world (in my opinion the best, going to the Freddie Mercury, which is one of Great for me).

15. Carry That Weight Indeed these last 3 tracks are one. Carry That Weight have a small orchestra and a solo guitar, is perfect. Outside the piano course! Chorus is one of those for you to sing along! Want something better?

16. The End Ask for a drummer doing a solo! What does it do? Fill in with tons, snares, etc, not Ringo! Make a super simple and beautiful line. Aside from that solo are then recorded two batteries! While everybody sings' Love You 'at the bottom there George recorded one of his best solos. Well-Blues Rock. To finish the melody which is most exciting news in musical history.

17. Her Majesty Question! A sticker may be the greatest thing you ever heard? Answer! If was The Beatles of course!

Source: www.progshine.com

Report this review (#205912)
Posted Tuesday, March 10, 2009 | Review Permalink
Conor Fynes
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars 'The Beatles' - Abbey Road (8/10)

Generally considered to be the 'end' of the Beatles' saga, 'Abbey Road' is certainly not a dissapointing finish. It has all of the elements (especially the final 'epic' medley) that gives a feeling of wrapping up something collosal. The Beatles had a strong sense that their band was in it's dying hour, and they certainly went out with a bang.

I wouldn't say that 'Abbey Road' is the best album by the Beatles, but it's definately up there. I personally prefer their mid-era work (Revolver) if I'm going to take out an album to listen to. 'Abbey Road' is certainly the most grandiose, epic work by them though. The 'medley' that consists of almost half of the albums tracks could be considered as a mini-epic of sorts. Even though it doesn't clock in overall at an 'epic' length, it still works magic, and all of the different musical ideas getting bombarded upon the listener one after the other makes the medley feel alot longer than it really is.

There are lots of complex orchestrations here, and quirky musical ideas that makes for a really interesting trip. It's hard to believe that this is the same Beatles who only a few years back was being called a 'boyband.' This is very mature music, and you can hear the experience of age in each of the band member's playing.

A four star rating is awarded in terms of comparison, really. The only two real 'masterpieces' I would say the Beatles did were 'Revolver' and 'Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band.' Those were done at the start of progressive music, and therefore were alot more groundbreaking. While this is excellent, and every Beatles fan should own this, I simply didn't get the same groundbreaking feeling listening to this one. It's excellent, though.

Report this review (#207704)
Posted Wednesday, March 18, 2009 | Review Permalink
5 stars It was November of 1978, and, while an undergraduate at the University of Notre Dame, I had the opportunity to attend an interesting lecture entitled "Avoiding the Hazards of Terminal Adulthood" given by Dr. Timothy Leary. Delivered from the stage of Washington Hall replete with the music of Pink Floyd and the assistance of his grandson, nephew, or some other young relative, Dr. Leary made his presentation. A day or so later, while waiting for my flight home at the South Bend airport for Thanksgiving, I encountered Dr. Leary, also on his way out of town. Not able to resist, I greeted the celebrity, shaking his hand, and exclaiming, "The Moody Blues were wrong; you're not dead!" Dr. Leary responded, "Nice suit." Ah, yes, innocence and experience . . . .

Of course, and rightfully so, Dr. Leary had more time for others. For our present purposes, this would be John Lennon and the Beatles. Abbey Road might just be the album in which the dialectic of innocence and experience reaches as tentative a synthesis as can be achieved in space and time.

And what a synthesis it is. To use the cliche, John, Paul, George, and Ringo were certainly at "full steam ahead!" With the support of George Martin, the Fab Four produced an album that showcases their songwriting abilities and the consummate collective effort that would result. In "Come Together" and "Something," McCartney delivers masterful bass lines in support. In "Octopus's Garden," there's Lennon with his apt backing vocals. In "Because," we encounter a great unity of voices.

Yes, a supposed earlier California Gubernatorial campaign of Dr. Leary led to the title "Come Together." But, for me, images of a dying Brian Epstein fill this song complete with not-so-veiled references to the great ocean of human sexuality. Then, there's "You Never Give Me Your Money." Perhaps, this is a bit of a stretch, but Paul's reference to "funny paper" makes me think of once and future financial crises. "I Want You (She's So Heavy)" is the instrumental showcase of the album, partially indicating a future direction for the band. Fittingly, Harrison's "Here Comes the Sun" follows the lugubrious conclusion to "I Want You." Around 1974, one of my best friends pressed me about, in his view Keith Emerson's excessive use of synthesizers, saying, "The Beatles didn't need them." I replied, "listen to Abbey Road once again." It, synthesis, is all here.

It is only right that we focus, finally, on "The End." Just how aware were the Four Lads from Liverpool that Abbey Road would be just that for them? We can only speculate. However, I do know that, as pointed out by others, Harrison, McCartney, and Lennon traded "licks" in the song's guitar solo and Ringo gave us a rare drum solo. And, then, there's the ostensibly obvious, yet truly ethical statement, "And, in the end, the love you take is equal to the love you make . . . ." Once we journey through "the nuts and bolts of life," we come to recognize that synthesis can only emerge through endurance. Abbey Road leaves many of the false answers of desire behind, achieving rare singularity.

Yes, Dr. Leary, adulthood need not be terminal.

Report this review (#211718)
Posted Sunday, April 19, 2009 | Review Permalink
Evolver
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Crossover & JR/F/Canterbury Teams
4 stars I'm not a Beatles fan, and I heard almost every song they recorded so many times that I would rather not ever hear them again, but I do enjoy this album.

Does it have some prog leanings? Soitenly, as a late great comedian would say. But it also has some spectacular songs. Come Together, Something, Oh! Darling, and Here Comes The Sun are fantastic pop tunes, and the production of them always brings a smile to my ears. Even Maxwell's Silver Hammer, while silly, is finely produced. And the group of songs that filled most of side 2 of the LP version, what more can be said.

But the gem here is I Want You (She's So Heavy). This to me is the best song the Beatles ever produced.

Report this review (#212154)
Posted Wednesday, April 22, 2009 | Review Permalink
Sinusoid
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars I've never been totally in awe of any of the Beatles works, so my rating for this is quite unusual for me. I feel that of all of the Beatles albums I've heard so far, ABBEY ROAD is the only one that has a ''timeless'' quality to it without sounding like a cluster of awkward filler tunes. A good batch of their best songs are right here.

''Here Comes the Sun'' is pure gold; an acoustic pop song with many progressive quirks, it really highlights Harrisons' songwriting skills that usually go unnoticed. If you take ''Octopus's Garden'' and ''Maxwell's Silver Hammer'' for what they're worth (goofy pop songs), neither aren't too bad. The mini-suite at the end sounds pretty corny for a while (''Mean Mr. Mustard'' for instance), but getting to ''The End'' and its guitar solos is worth it. The atmosphere of ''Sun King'', the synth in ''Because'' and the heavy jamming of ''I Want You'' should keep the progsters coming back.

The two hits at the beginning are a tad overplayed, especially ''Something'' which despite it being a Harrison piece, the song really sounds flat. ''Oh! Darling'' is an awful slow rocker that has no business here. Despite its flaws, ABBEY ROAD is a Beatles album worthy for a prog collection and maybe even a spin or two here and there.

Report this review (#214619)
Posted Saturday, May 9, 2009 | Review Permalink
UMUR
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
4 stars "Abbey Road" is the 11th full-length studio album by UK rock act The Beatles. The album was released through Apple Records in September 1969 in the UK and in October 1969 in the US. This is actually the last full-length studio album recorded by the band as "Let It Be (1970)" was for the most part recorded before the recording sessions for "Abbey Road", although it was released after. The "Get Back" sessions in January 1969 (which would later become most of the "Let It Be" album) were disastrous as the band members at that point had a hard time working together and it was only after the band had agreed with long-time producer George Martin that they would do "Abbey Road" his way that they would begin sessions for that album. At this point the "Get Back" sessions were shelved.

The psychadelic tinged pop/rock that had dominated the last couple of releases by the band, were not as prevalent on "Abbey Road" which instead features lots of hard rock and blues rock leanings. The focus on experimenting with sound productions is not that dominant on "Abbey Road" either and the album overall comes off as a bit more simple and "to the point" than it´s direct predecessors. It´s not necessarily a minus though as The Beatles were still able to produce well-crafted memorable melodies and intricate vocal and song arrangements.

Tracks like "Come Together", "Something", "I Want You (She´s So Heavy)", and "The Abbey Road Medley" on Side 2 of the original LP (several short tracks that seque into each other) are among the highlights on the album but there´s nothing here that´s sub par. It´s a quality release through and through. Even the quite silly Ringo Starr led "Octopus's Garden" is bearable and one of the better Beatles tracks where he sings.

The sound production, is pleasant, organic, and professional. The great mix provides room for Paul McCartney´s bass lines which I find particularly enjoyable on this album but also George Harrison´s lead guitar work is of high quality and prospers greatly from the great quality sound production.

One of the things I mostly enjoy about "Abbey Road" is that the band seems to be enjoying themselves (which stands in stark contrast to the fact that the band were close to disintegrating at this point). Their passion for the music really shines through. I find "Abbey Road" to be a very accomplished album and one of the most important albums in The Beatles discography. Just short of a 5 star rating, but a 4.5 star (90%) ratings is well deserved.

Report this review (#225628)
Posted Friday, July 10, 2009 | Review Permalink
AtomicCrimsonRush
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
4 stars Take a trip down ABBEY ROAD - watch your step!

The last great album from The Beatles before it all went pear shaped (as opposed to Apple). The album cover may well be the most famous location in music history. The Abbey Road crossing has become a pilgrimage for fans worldwide. The eerie 'Paul is dead' fable is strong in the iconic imagery, Paul in bare feet, out of step, a weird number plate and a cigarette ? all point to his death, don't they? The music is another matter.

The album begins brilliantly with the masterful 'Come Together', perhaps the best on the album. The nonsensical lyrics sum up the shakey era it was created 'got to be a joker he just do what he please'.

We have some other highlights on side one such as 'Octopuse's Garden', a childish romp into aquatic excess, and the brilliant 'She's So Heavy'. The guitar work on this track is sublime and features one of the best lead solos from the group. Lennon's vocals are full of angst and it has many time shifts and metrical signatures. The end goes on repetitively and very metal like in a sense and then it ends so abruptly it's a shock. Check out the version by metal warlords, Coroner!

However, the real joy is on side two. It begins with 'Here comes the sun', such a great melody and I adore 'Because' with its overlayered vocal harmonies, but the real treasure, as far as progressive territory, is the multi movement suite of the last few tracks. They all blend one into another seamlessly and are really like one lengthy track rather than a series of short tracks less than 2 minutes each. None of them feel complete and seem to be parts of unfinished songs, which in reality they were. 'Polythene Pam' is memorable and 'She came in through the bathroom window' has a wonderful guitar motif in the verses and 'carry that weight' blends into the finale 'the end'. In fact it was the end for the Beatles, at least the end of their greatness. A flawed album certainly but still worthy of any musicologists collection.

Report this review (#228550)
Posted Sunday, July 26, 2009 | Review Permalink
Marty McFly
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
5 stars 5(+), which brings here strange situation. One of few times I feel comfortable enough to give rating before, not after review. When somebody thinks, that this is useless album and is full of forgettable songs, I can oppose him and say that every one of them is masterpiece, probably the most memorable album I know. Come Together with it's opposite side of mood for Something makes pretty nice pair. Together. Crazy and madness bringing (but funny, so funny) Maxwell's Silver Hammer (bang bang) and classic rock Oh! Darling. You can say that they're little bit pop, but I'll reply that they overcomes borders of pop rock and dwells into something bigger, better and more mature. This is their dusk, after this album is just twilight. But after this song came playful Octopus's Garden.

For example these album sales. They and Elvis Presley made it so far. And both were pioneers, but while Elvis is legend in quite different style (my grandma likes listening his songs), The Beatles (my father likes listening their songs) are prog. Why ? Because all these things they created, or helped to create, or used in a way that caught audience. Why not The Monkees guys ? I suppose we all know the answer. Never mind, this I Want You is great instrumental song. Yes, there are lyrics, but as I once learned (hey father, we can listen to Abbey Road and I got all lyrics, except I Want You, I once said to him. He replied that for this song, lyrics are not needed. That I will understand. And I do), but they just express his desire. So raw and emotional song, without cheap emotional style. And consider how long this song is, so many in it. For me, it became some kind of legend, same as with the rest of album.

Both accessible (for normal people) and masterpiece (for prog lovers, who will see behind perfect rock and find perfect prog). This is something which not much albums accomplished before. Interesting part is ending of this song (still (She's So Heavy) I'm talking about), where you can think at one point that it's about to end, but timer shows still tens of seconds to the end. And when the song is over, it doesn't seem like end, more like as it want to continue, but that couldn't happen. I see it as scream of heart-broken man, who's love is rejecting him, but he's trying over and over again to reach for her. And this fake end is when he's losing hope for reaching her feelings, but then he tries it again. And finally, loses. At least I see it like this. Then happy Here Comes the Sun and better average, but overall hated by me Because and Sun King. But track-to-track ratings is not only thing from which I have final rating. And after all, I'm already decided, I'm just justifying it.

There is also second side, but a lot of words were already written. And after all, everyone writes about 2nd epic, I'll just take some time. I mean, I'm not obliged to write about every track here. All I can say now is that if first side is 5(-) - 5(+), second one is 5(+) without doubts. You're looking on masterpiece man, from legendary cover art (beaten only by Sgt. Pepper), to last tricky song.

Report this review (#239717)
Posted Thursday, September 17, 2009 | Review Permalink
3 stars The Beatles were before my time and undoubtedly I do not appreciate them as much as I would have had I heard them when their music was new. I have had to wade back from my musical birthing grounds in the early 80's through countless songs undoubtedly influenced by or stemming from a musical inheritance from the work of The Beatles. To remain true to my subjective perspective, I cannot provide the best testimony to their value and influence.

Come Together - Groovy cool song; heavy sound but laid back. I imagine the lyrics were considered "totally far out man" at the time. They are still inventive and poetic. With lyrics that balance sense with non-sense you can achieve an unconscious impact that can make it harder to separate lyrics from music.

Something - Sultry keyboards and guitar and strings all melt together as they swell the sentimental passion. Beautifully expressive guitar solo. Poignant song that dilutes its sadness with hope.

Maxwell's Silver Hammer - Back to the march step rhythm section of The Beatles earlier work; nursery rhyme lyrics and light-hearted music barely conceal the successive acts of violence making what is psycho a bit of crazy fun.

Oh! Darling - 50s sound; Paul McCartney pleads desperately to good effect with his lover.

Octopus's Garden - Part two of "Yellow Submarine"? This song caught my attention as a child. Guitar accents sound right for this underwater adventure.

I Want You (She's So Heavy) - The sound here is reminiscent of "Come Together". One reason I suspect that I don't like this song as much as I would like is that I am not a blues fan. Another is that try as they might, The Beatles are not a blues band. I have meager amounts of the blues to compare it to but it does not compare favorably. Still they try admirably. Also, this must be one of the Beatles' longest songs and for that reason also I wished I appreciated it more. What was an appetite for the coda on "Sgt. Pepper..." and "Magical Mystery Tour" has found its way deeper into the song bringing you to the progressive, instrument-oriented music not just once but twice. This song has a psychedelic strain with a slightly disturbing wind sound that evokes a strange, alien atmosphere and then leaves you startled and gasping for breath at the song's abrupt end. For me these are positive elements that don't make up for other elements in a song that I'm sure many will consider much more favorably than I do.

Here Comes the Sun - Although this song's lighter than air openning is a stark contrast with its predecessor it moves towards a similar instrument-oriented progressive passage; this time in more favorable terms. The guitar provides the elegant path through which this song strolls. Again what would have been an interesting coda is brought in in the midst of the song and again at the end. This same song form is used frequently by bands with superior instrumental abilities to great effect. The Beatles ability to bring us into the high of "the jam" however is tragically limited. This song and its predecessor point the way to a great many great progressive rock song.

Because - Slow chant comes off slightly comic with its 60s mysticism, but poised as it is just before the Medley it is full of presentiment as well as sounding like a conclusion to what preceeded it.

Medley

You Never Give Me Your Money - This medley frames the songs ahead just as "Sgt. Pepper..." with its openning track and reprise framed that album. There is a note of sadness under the light-hearted lyrics. The various moods and melodies in this song also give it an overture-like, mini-medley feel preceeding the series of much shorter songs which follow. Moreso than any of the other songs in "The Medley", this song could stand alone. As the song fades we gradually discern night-time crickets and the next song starts right up...

Sun King - ...as a kind of brother song to "Because" with its slow pace and 60s mysticism. Hot summer day slow tribute to the sun I presume. There is a strange tension between a joyous appreciation and a lazy tempo, a tension which resolves somewhat with the latin verses at the end. Spills out into...

Mean Mr. Mustard - ...a much shorter song that also picks up the tempo. We have the familiar Beatles march style rhythm with the just as typical catchy tune. One verse ends and...

Polythene Pam - ...one more notch up on the tempo and on the energy brings us to the next song. Complex drums, cryptic lyrics, rock guitar solo rests languidly on the rhythm section and drops us into...

She Came In Through The Bathroom Window - ...the next song which has us in the bathroom relaxing the energy a bit. The rhythm kicks back a notch and the guitar and the vocals have a vigorous back and forth. Golden Slumbers - After the first significant gap between songs since the medley began, sweet strings and gentle piano surge with passion and quieten again. Two times we breathe in and out and then into...

Carry That Weight - ...a triumphant anthem. Horns come in to shout joy in a short progressive chorus. Then the reprise of "You Never Give Me Your Money" comes in as if somehow we never left it so many melodies ago.

The End - Sudden transition to a rock n roll mini-melody with an slightly understated drum solo. One of the harder guitar solos for The Beatles is found here. Another sudden transition brings up down a notch and back up for the final orchestral climax.

Her Majesty - Couldn't leave on a serious foot; hidden track although not too far down the groove, an outrageous poke at nobility.

(3 stars) I rate the medley ("You Never Give Me Your Money" through "The End") as a single song with 5 stars. The other songs on the album just don't add up to enough for me to justify a higher overall rating. I'm sure that this has a lot to do with the fact that the elements of these songs I've heard first elsewhere and performed in ways I prefer. Had I heard it first from The Beatles, my rating would have been higher. I've chosen to rate the albums from my own subjective view. This certainly will rub many people the wrong way but I think it is more honest. Undoubtedly my favorite music will receive a great many ratings knocks from the majority that don't appreciate it.

I heartily recommend "The Medley" to progressive rock fans for its outstanding collection of catchy tune ideas strung together in a highly effective way. Although I am not as turned on by "I Want You (She's So Heavy)" and "Octopus's Garden" as I would like to be, those songs along with "Here Comes The Sun" may also appeal to the progressive rock fan. As The Beatles bow out of the recording studio as a band an era of music has just been inspired that is where I find my heart and soul: progressive rock.

Report this review (#240245)
Posted Saturday, September 19, 2009 | Review Permalink
5 stars Some people think the Beatles should not be included on this site. It is not surprising considering that their early rockabilly/skiffle-influenced pop music is very far from what you normally mean by progressive rock. On the other hand they went through a metamorphosis that is so astonishing it is hard to believe that it took only a couple of years.

In my opinion Abbey Road is the musical, if not commercial, peak of their career, and side two of the original LP is, with the exception of Here Comes the Sun (which is a great song), an early example of a symphonic rock suite. It is not just a collection of songs, but an extended piece of music that feels very integrated. If the Beatles themselves thought that they just got rid of a lot of ideas for songs at the same time, well, fine, it just adds to their greatness.

The first side of the LP is more uneven, with the nonsensical Maxwell's Silver Hammer (creapy subject, though!) and Ringo's Octopus's Garden (I love them both!). The masterpiece is, of course, John's I Want You (She's So Heavy).

I've listened to the Beatles since I was a kid in the sixties, and Abbey Road is the record I return to most often, even more than Sgt Pepper.

Report this review (#247336)
Posted Friday, October 30, 2009 | Review Permalink
4 stars Golden slumbers fill your eyes..

Abbey Road, the last studio album of the great Beatles, might be the cornerstone of rock music in general. Easily the best album of the sixties, this album has probably influenced all the rock bands of the 70s. What was it that made it possible to the Beatles to create this magnificient masterpiece? A mix of 4 talented musicians, singers and songwriters and a mix of creativity and consistency in the songs.

This album might also be the most accessible album for newer generations. There are rockers like Octopus Garden and Come Together that sound to me more accessible even though they have a strong 60s feel. There isn't really a single bad track on this album. The real gems on this album to me are "I Want You (She's So Heavy)" with its psychedelic organ fills and vocals, "Oh! Darling" and "Golden Slumbers" where McCartney shows his crazy vocal skills, "Here Comes The Sun" the Harrison masterpiece, and the before mentioned "Octopus Garden".

Report this review (#262384)
Posted Monday, January 25, 2010 | Review Permalink
Negoba
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars The Grand Finale to the Greatest Band of All Time

ABBEY ROAD was the final album recorded by the Beatles, who hold the title of biggest rock band of all time and have been variously ascribed every superlative the English language holds. After the disastrous LET IT BE sessions, Paul immediately suggested the band get back together with "Fifth Beatle" George Martin, and record an album together as they had earlier in their career. The result was the perfect conclusion to the band's great career, an album with monster hits, experimentation, and great production. The album utilizes numerous elements that became staples of the Prog Rock style, placing ABBEY ROAD as probably the most important proto-prog album out there.

The album contains a huge variety of material that may seem scattered, but in fact effectively recaps the band's entire career. The bluesy "Oh Darling," perhaps better than any song on record, captures how the young band must have sounded (full of testosterone and hunger) in the basements doing covers of American songs. Harmony vocals are essential in many of the songs, with "Because" having some of the most lush of the Beatles' catalog. Ringo gets a light-hearted turn on "Octopus' Garden," which he actually wrote, and Paul gets one of his "granny tunes" (Lennon's term) on the album with "Maxwell's Silver Hammer." While this was a weaker song compared to much of the disc, it is an essential part of the Beatles style and deserved a place on this coda.

At the same time, the album also looks very much forward. George Harrison's most famous songs of his career appear here in "Something" and "Here Comes the Sun." Lennon leads off the album with the singular "Come Together" which might have been rather ordinary without the minimalist combination of Ringo's drumming, Paul's rolling bass line, and Billy Preston's keys. Lennon also lends a progressive wink on the extended "I Want You (She's So Heavy)" with its juxtaposition of styles and quite intense timbred sounds courtesy of guitar and Moog.

The second side contains the somewhat controversial medley. In fact the entire side forms a continued whole, and its suite-like construction became a recurrent element in prog to this day. Without a doubt, the piece has a pasted together feeling, and several of the transitions are extremely abrupt. Some were unfinished from previous records, but more importantly, some of the ideas may not have sustained an entire song. As they are, they are the coda to the coda, a final flourish recapping not only the album, but the career of the greatest rock band there may ever be.

ABBEY ROAD is a masterpiece of rock, prog, music, and art in general created during the memory of those currently living.

Report this review (#263207)
Posted Thursday, January 28, 2010 | Review Permalink
friso
PROG REVIEWER
2 stars The Beatles - Abbey Road (1969)

The perfect record...

I really love Sgt. Peppers, I like the old beatles songs and I'm still trying to get a vinyl of the White album and Rubber Soul. This album however was a big letdown!

The production of the album is very good and the sound is clean but OK. The songs however are very very boring! There are only two tracks I can enjoy, Come Together (of which the intro was recycled) and the great Hear Comes the Sun. All other tracks are boring or even painfull. I know this oppinion might be very provocotive for some members of our society, but it's just my opinion. I just miss the excitement of Sgt. Pepper's or the catchy tracks of other Beatles albums, or even the experiments with recording and rare instruments. All gone.

It's truly amazing how this album became one of the best selling and rated albums of the Beatless. My guess it's because it has a lot of easy popsongs. If you like popsongs this might still be a good album for you, but if you're in search for progressive music you'd better skip on this one because you'll only find intelligent and atmospheric songwriting on Here Comes the Sun. Two stars. Way to much filler.

Report this review (#276749)
Posted Wednesday, April 7, 2010 | Review Permalink
Peter
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
5 stars If, like me, you prefer your Beatles bearded and barefoot, then ABBEY ROAD is likely your favourite from the Fab Foursome. Sure, SGT. PEPPER'S was more influential, and THE BEATLES (AKA "The White Album") has twice the tune-age, but this one is just plain flawless, with some of the best, most polished material The Beatles and producer George Martin ever committed to tape.

As you may know, the Beatles' albums were re-mastered and re-packaged recently, and the results were great. Now is the time to start, complete or even replace your collection of CDs from the biggest band ever. As with the entirety of The Beatles catalog, ABBEY ROAD is much better than before thanks to the re-master. The sound sparkles, and is more clearly defined -- you can hear individual instruments and nuances you may have been completely unaware of before. The packaging is also a class act: the fragile old plastic jewel box is gone, replaced by durable, esthetically-pleasing and environmentally friendlier cardboard. There are loads of great photos, historical notes, recording notes and a mini documentary on the making of the album, to further sweeten the deal. The documentary can be played on your computer, and features video and more photos, plus audio commentary from the Fabs themselves. Gear! Does it get any better than this? Well, yes: I can't speak for your country, but around these parts the re-masters are selling for nearly ten dollars less than previous inferior editions. I often wondered why Beatles CDs needed to be so expensive (typically around $25 Canadian, compared to average CD costs of 18 to 20 dollars). Now here they are, sounding and looking better than ever, for just 15 bucks a pop. Thank you, universe!

Of course, as I indicated above, ABBEY ROAD may just well be the finest of The Beatles' long-haired classics. Some of the biggest and best hits are here, including Lennon's ultra-cool album opener "Come Together," Harrison's beautiful and romantic "Something" and his uplifting "Here Comes the Sun," McCartney's cheerfully dark "Maxwell's Silver Hammer," and Ringo's wistful, escapist kiddy favourite "Octopus's Garden." The Liverpool Lads were in top form here, and working very well together as a band. The mood was good, and the result was the career high note that should have been the last release (if it all had to end as it soon did -- leaving a then ten year-old me in tears of disbelief at the news). McCartney's "You Never Give Me Your Money" may not have made the old blue 67- 70 hits compilation, but man, it's an absolute gem, and the melancholy longing for lost innocence in the line "Once there was a way to get back homeward, once there was a way to get back home" now moves me more than ever. Finally, and best of all, the seamless song-cycle that forms the album's second half is, simply, stupendous. On the mini-doc, Sir Paul tells us that as he and John entered the iconic studio, they had "lots and lots of bits of things-- and we hit upon the idea of medlying them all, which gave the second side... a kind of operatic structure." Paul, Ringo and your humble reviewer are in agreement; quoth Ringo: "one of the finest pieces we put together."

ABBEY ROAD is a rock masterpiece, and no less than a landmark of 20th-Century popular music and culture. It's a timeless album to live, love, and revisit again and again. Remember, folks: "and in the end, the love you take is equal to the love you make." Hear, hear!

Report this review (#278954)
Posted Thursday, April 22, 2010 | Review Permalink
5 stars While I rarely consider the Beatles a progressive band (despite their huge influence on the genre), Abbey Road is the one album where I always second guess myself. The songwriting is absolutely incredible--the blend of '60s pop (a weak spot of mine) and more complex songwriting results in a highly accessible album with a lot of surprises for those inclined to listen more closely. The big highlight track is "I Want You (She's So Heavy)," an eight minute epic that leaves you emotionally drained at its sudden end. The five-measure 6/8 melody is sublime, and it's easy to lose yourself in it. "Here Comes the Sun," while seemingly nothing more than a pleasant pop rock piece, betrays a bit of complexity in its shifting rhythms through the middle buildup and turns an otherwise okay piece into a great one. The medley of songs on the second side (which I treat as a single piece) is also beautifully done. A sixteen-minute menagerie of wonderful tunes which each have their own great aspects. If nothing else, Abbey Road is the essential Beatles album for any progressive fan.
Report this review (#287247)
Posted Friday, June 18, 2010 | Review Permalink
Rune2000
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
5 stars For those who have been following my recent review streak might have already guessed my opinion on Abbey Road, but why would I have it any other way? Besides, what better way is there to celebrate my 500th review than by exploring this gem of a release?

After a solid streak of studio albums the Beatles finally stuck gold with the release of Abbey Road. Unfortunately the journey leading up to this point has been straining on the quartet, meaning that this turned out to be their final group effort. It's almost impossible not to experience the feeling of sadness when listening to this this album, but they say that if you plan to go out, make sure to do it on a high note. I honestly can't think of a better example of such occurrence.

After the exhausting The White Album-sessions followed by the even more nerve wrecking preparations for the Get Back performance, that was meant to revive the band's enthusiasm but instead did more damage than good, the Beatles had all the odds against them. Although, if we've learned anything about this band then it's the fact that they always worked best under pressure. According to the later interviews conducted with both Paul McCartney and George Harrison both members claimed that they knew that this particular recording session was going to be their final group effort. Whether this is actually true or not is entirely debatable, still the fact that this great album exist only adds to the already well established legacy left by the Beatles.

It's as if everyone in the band decided to chip in and do their best no matter the consequences. George Harrison had finally completed his songwriting maturity cycle and even surpassed Lennon/McCartney with Something and Here Comes The Sun. Ringo Starr also managed to chip in one his better offerings with Octopus's Garden, co-written by Harrison, this is easily the most enjoyable track Starr composed while being in the band. Of course Paul McCartney and John Lennon did their best to maintain their songwriting quality all the way to the end. Among the notable performances related to prog I Want You (She's So Heavy) is easily the most prog-related composition with Billy Preston playing the h#ll out of the Hammond organ towards the end while the abrupt ending is pure genius!

Still, the highlight of this album comes towards the end with the Abbey Road Medley that occupies most of side two. Since I've heard different opinions as to which songs are considered a part of this medley let me clarify by saying that I'm talking about Because and onwards. This medley was suppository composed out of incomplete song ideas from Lennon/McCartney but it's difficult to hear it considering how well each section fits in with the rest of the medley. Paul McCartney's outro section, beginning with She Came In Through The Bathroom Window is easily the highpoint of this album for me just for the sheer joy I get from hearing these masterful song hooks.

The final offering from the Beatles showed the band finally achieving their well deserved prog related credentials and it's a masterpiece well worth exploring! I can understand everyone who prefers the more cheerful side of the band on Revolver or Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band but those albums never sounded like complete self sufficient masterpieces to me. Abbey Road, on the other hand, has that special feeling plus a bunch of amazing stand-out moments attached to it. Essential for all fans of creative music!

***** star songs: Come Together (4:20) Something (3:02) Here Comes The Sun (3:05) Because (2:45) You Never Give Me Your Money (4:02) Mean Mr Mustard (1:06) Polythene Pam (1:12) She Came In Through The Bathroom Window (1:57) Golden Slumbers (1:31) Carry That Weight (1:36) The End (2:19) (Her Majesty) (0:23)

**** star songs: Maxwell's Silver Hammer (3:27) Oh Darling (3:26) I Want You (She's So Heavy) (7:47) Octopus's Garden (2:51) Sun King (2:26)

Report this review (#292596)
Posted Thursday, July 29, 2010 | Review Permalink
octopus-4
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
RIO/Avant/Zeuhl,Neo & Post/Math Teams
5 stars I'm surprised to see 2 and also 3 stars reviews of what I consider an absolute masterpiece. This is one of the first albums on which each songs fades into the following like in many acclaimed progressive albums to come in the following years (The Wall and Misplaced Childhood just to mention some...) and this is the same year of the King Crimson's debut that many people consider as the first progressive album of the history.

Abbey Road is pop, some of the songs are famous hits, but this adds value to an album that can be enjoyed like a suite and has many elements that can easily be called "progressive".

"Come Together" is a great opener and one of the most famous Beatles' songs. Some pop mellow songs are interludes to pop-rock moments. Many of the songs of this album have had excellent covers during the years, since Joe Cocker's version of She's coming through the bathroom window" to the medley played by Transatlantic on Live In Europe.

Songs like Polythene Pam, Here Comes The Sun, and of course Octopus's Garden (look at my nickname) are evergereen classics.

This is the 199th review of this album so there's no much that I can say that hasn't already been said. For me it's one of the most important albums ever and is the only one Beatles album that I sometimes enjoy still today.

I can't find the 6-stars checkbox, so it's only 5.

Report this review (#299945)
Posted Tuesday, September 21, 2010 | Review Permalink
zravkapt
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
4 stars As a rule, I refuse to give 5 stars to any album in Proto or Related. If this was a plain vanilla rock site, this would get 5 stars from me. I think Revolver has better songs but Abbey Road is far more consistent. And there's Moog here. You can't go wrong with Moog(even something like Switched-On Bach is nice).

"Come Together" has some of Lennon's best lyrics("Got to be good looking cuz he's so hard to see"). "Octopus's Garden" is the best song Ringo wrote while a Beatle. Abbey Road also has some of his best drumming. "I Want You(She's So Heavy)" is one of the greatest songs ever. Period. "Here Comes The Sun" is the best song George did while a Beatle. His guitar tone on this album is fabulous. Before this was recorded Harrison released one of the first electronic albums, Electronic Sounds. You can hate this band all you want but you'll never convince anyone that they were not influential.

The so-called Long Medley("You Never Give Me Your Money" to "The End") is fantastic and a precursor to the beloved epics of prog. "You Never Give Me Your Money" is possibly my favourite Beatles song. It's like 4 or 5 songs in one. "Mean Mr. Mustard" has great fuzz- bass. "Golden Slumbers" has the best vocals McCartney ever did with the group. "The End" is great proto-prog; it has drumming in stereo and George, Paul and John trade guitar solos. Sweet. "Her Majesty" was removed from the medley(it was originally between "Mustard" and "Polythene Pam"). It's a throwaway the band didn't want on the album.

"Because" was always one of my favourites here. John, Paul and George recorded their vocals three times each, so you are literally listening to nine Beatles singing. The instrumentation is just superb with an electric guitar arpeggio(Lennon), electric harpsichord(George Martin) and Moog(Harrison). This was the last song the three ever recorded together. Now let's talk Moog. Paul plays it on "Maxwell's Silver Hammer"(the happiest song about murder); George plays it on "Here Comes The Sun"; and John plays it on "I Want You"(the noisy part at the end).

The first time many people heard a synthesizer for the first time was on this album. But the Beatles were no pioneers in this department; The Monkees, The Byrds and Simon & Garfunkel had already used Moog. It's strange that a band as big as the Beatles was only using 8-track to record this album. Obscure(at the time) American artists like Zappa and The Grateful Dead were using 16-track in 1969. British studios were behind their American counterparts until the early 1970s.

Not much else to say really. Great album. Great Proto-Prog. 5 star effort but 4 stars for PA.

Report this review (#306281)
Posted Saturday, October 23, 2010 | Review Permalink
5 stars To me.. this is the first Prog album ever. With prog, we usually mean in the world related to pop/rock music, not Classical pieces etc. Therefore Abbey Road lead the way. Not Sergant Pepper. Abbey Road fooled you that you were hearing pop music. So well conceived and not showing off in any way, just a perfect piece of music. I can't downgrade the rating from 5 because of a weak moment here and there. She's so heavy is worth 10 on it's own! My favourite Beatles album for sure. It still has not been surpassed in my mind. Possibly my favourite album by anyone.
Report this review (#320808)
Posted Monday, November 15, 2010 | Review Permalink
5 stars The Beatles' final studio album was a perfectly timeless work. Although the fab four weren't functioning as a unit at the time, the album was tightly constructed with some amazing tracks.

The opener is a Lennon classic "Come Together" which showed he was still a mean stomping rocker at heart. John's "I Want You" also has a killer hard rock riff . Variety shows with McCartney leaning more towards pop whimsy on "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" which is good stuff but a little insubstantial compared to "Oh Darling" which is excellent and more of the style I like. Paul also brings back some of his Little Richard moans. Ringo's "Octopus's Garden" is a real charmer and a great kids number too. I can't say I've heard songs with such a lyrical nature anywhere else!

Harrison's songwriting had become exceptional by this point. He steals the show with the delicate "Something" and the utterly beautiful "Here Comes The Sun". The second half is the most legendary of all. It's a sustained suite concieved mostly by Paul and it ties a string of ditties that wouldn't have stood on their own, but tied together they combine to make perhaps some of the finest music ever made. I could rave about all of the tracks here but I won't. "GoldenSlumbers/Carry that Weight/The End" contain a Ringo drum solo and the only one the group released on a studio album. The masterstroke "Her Majesty" is where McCartney comes back when you think it's all over with a brief simple ditty that deflates the group's career on just the right note. Abbey Road is surely among one of the greatest records of all time. A music collection somehow wouldn't be the same without this. It's pure class. 5 stars.

Report this review (#406731)
Posted Wednesday, February 23, 2011 | Review Permalink
5 stars My personal favorite album of any genre, Abbey Road is the definitive record. It's a Beatles record, it's got a medley, and it's quite proggy. And, it is 100x better than Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band.

Come Together (10/10): Excellent opener to an excellent album. Hard bass riff, strange lyrics, and a shuffling groove make this one of the Beatles' best album openers.

Something (10+/10): Maybe the greatest song ever written, Something also has a sweeping Baroque-style instrumentation with an excellent string background. Excellently produced, very well-written track.

Maxwell's Silver Hammer (8/10): This is a very good song with a happy melody but sad lyrics. Just not one of my favorites.

Oh! Darling (9.5/10): Excellent passionate song by Paul McCartney, and good, bluesy time signature. Just thought that the vocals were a bit over the top.

Octopus's Garden (9/10): Undoubtedly, Ringo's best work! Amazing guitar from Harrison, and seaside background vocals make this a classic Beatles song! But, it just isn't one of my favorites.

I Want You (She's So Heavy) (10+/10): This is a prog website, and this is a prog song. From the opening, slow guitar riff, to the long instrumental passage at the end with amazing keyboards from Mr. Billy Preston, this is the proggiest thing the Beatles ever recorded! And it's an underrated gem!

Here Comes the Sun (10+/10): My second favorite George Harrison song, Here Comes the Sun, like Something, is an excellent ballad with some Baroque instrumentation in the background. And this song is also a fine folksy break after the "Heavy" song

Because (10/10); Hauntingly beautiful, with a keyboard riff reminiscent of Beethoven's Moonlight Sonata.

You Never Give Me Your Money/Sun King/Mean Mr. Mustard/Polythene Pam/She Came in Through the Bathroom Window (10+/10): Excellent first part of the ever-so-famous ending medley of Abbey Road. Every part of it is seamless with the other, so I couldn't review them separately. These, together, make up the heart of the album.

Golden Slumbers/Carry That Weight/ The End (10+/10): Wow! What an epic way to end a career! The (almost) closing medley is my very favorite song by the Beatles. An excellent way to cap off a career. But wait......

Her Majesty (9/10): I give it a 9 only for being so short! God why didn't they make this longer! I love this song!

With barely anything below a 10, though this may not be thought of as a prog album, it is a must-have for music fans, and even non-music fans! You can not deny Beatlemania!

Report this review (#438037)
Posted Saturday, April 23, 2011 | Review Permalink
baz91
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars Abbey Road, what an album. After seeming distant from each other on the last few albums, to the point where some of the tracks had become solo works, it's really heartwarming to hear the band on this album, sounding as close as they ever did! With this album, we don't hear the psychedelic or eclectic noodling that made the other albums stand out. Instead, The Beatles take us back to basics, and just play extremely good rock music.

I never really liked Come Together as the opening to this album. It seems like quite a dark song, for an album that is mainly very bright. It's quite a cool track, but I have actually heard better covers!

When compared to any of The Beatles' love songs from their earlier period, Something shows you just how much this group had moved on. This is a deeply moving track with really sweet lyrics.

Maxwell's Silver Hammer is a deeply twisted track! The bouncy melody seems like just the wrong theme tune for the brutal, yet comic, murders that are outlined in the lyrics, but instead I think this song comes out just right. I really like the fun lyrics, although I've never understood the Maxwell character. Not the best song on the album musically, but a fun little track nonetheless.

Oh! Darling is best known for Paul's soulful singing. He really pours emotion into those lyrics, making this a very difficult song to cover! Fantastic song.

The reason Ringo has never been taken seriously is because of songs like Octopus's Garden. You get the feeling that he probably didn't take himself that seriously either, because he actually wrote this! It's a fun melodic track, but this is another children's song! Thematically, it's extremely close to Yellow Submarine, but this track is an improvement. It's an important song, and it's definitely well remembered, but I really wish Ringo could have concocted something more fulfilling.

Talking of fulfilling, next up is I Want You (She's So Heavy), which remains my favourite Beatles track. Structurally, it's a very simple track, and with all three verses having exactly the same lyrics. However, this track has some of the best music around. At 7:47, this is the longest proper Beatles song (discounting Revolution 9 which is ...). I particularly like the jazzy instrumental verse section, with brilliant drumming, and a great subtle guitar solo. However, this is nothing compared to the jawdropping 3:10 coda, played entirely in 6/8 with one of the greatest chord progressions ever. The chords repeating in this way set a prog rock standard, and there are countless songs that finish in such a way! To name a few, Yes's Starship Trooper, Uriah Heep's July Morning and Steve Hackett's Shadow of the Hierophant. In fact, Dream Theater made a much more direct tribute in their song Pull Me Under which finishes in the same abrupt way as this track. Bursting with prog, this is undeniably The Beatles' most epic track.

Here Comes The Sun opens the second side, and what a beautiful track this is. This is a song for all the proggies, as the 'Sun, Sun, Sun, here it comes' section has many odd time signatures built into it.

I've always found Because to be incredibly creepy. This song borrows the 6/8 theme from I Want You but turns it into a 4/4 theme. The lyrics are really deep, and possibly pretentious, but I won't judge them.

The next 8 tracks form a 16 minute piece of music commonly known as the Abbey Road Suite. I recently joined these tracks together on my computer for two reasons. Firstly, I'm a prog fan and in my world, longer generally means better. Secondly, if I didn't, then I'd barely every give tracks like Sun King a listen. The medley starts with You Never Give Me Your Money which is a great standalone song. It's quite progressive in nature too, as there are several parts to the song. Sun King is quite dull, and towards the end gets a bit silly, with nonsense lyrics made to resemble Spanish. The next couple of songs, Mean Mr. Mustard and Polythene Pam have a rough unfinished feel to them, and I've never been a particular fan of either. She Came In Through The Bathroom Window is an improvement with good lyrics, and more structured writing. The music temporarily stops before Golden Slumbers begins. This is a beautiful section with lovely lyrics, and mature instrumentation. Carry That Weight is an anthemic track which brings back a theme from the beginning of the medley, making this feel more like a prog epic. The End has always been my favourite part of the medley. There is a brilliant drum solo from Ringo, followed by a wonderful guitar solo which is actually played by all three guitarists. Some brilliant 'words of wisdom' help bring this epic, and indeed The Beatles, to a close.

However, there's a surprise 'encore'! Her Majesty is actually an out-take from the medley, which was originally placed between Mean Mr. Mustard and Polythene Pam, before Paul had it edited out as he felt it was out of place. It accidentally got stuck on the end of the album, and as a result, does not appear on the vinyl sleeve, making it one of the first 'bonus tracks'. I do agree with Paul's decision, and, in fact, it's quite sweet that you just get to hear a little bit more of The Beatles before they were really gone. Very much like an encore indeed.

Abbey Road is one of the most iconic and well known albums of all time. It's one of my favourite Beatles albums and deserves to be in everyone's music library. I feel quite sad reviewing this album, as Abbey Road marked the end of a musical legacy that has transcended time. The Beatles are objectively one of the best bands in the history of rock music, and I don't think there's any band that could come close to being as musically ingenious and well-recognised as them. With some brilliant pop tunes, some very progressive songwriting, and an amazing 16-minute faux-epic medley, this album deserves no less than the perfect five-star rating.

Report this review (#439498)
Posted Tuesday, April 26, 2011 | Review Permalink
Warthur
PROG REVIEWER
3 stars A dignified but not exceptional exit for a band that knew in its heart of hearts that its time was up, Abbey Road is a far better way to remember the Beatles than the patchwork monster that is Let It Be (even though it has its own weird patchwork of ideas that don't really sit together properly in the form of the side 2 medley). With numbers like Come Together, the joyful Octopus's Garden (possibly Ringo's best songwriting contribution to a Beatles album) and the sublime Something (again, one of George's best tracks) and so on the album in some respects represents a preview of the directions many of the Fab Four's solo careers would go.

It's not altogether perfect, of course - She's So Heavy's outro goes on for too long without introducing any real variation beyond the gently increasing white noise, whilst Maxwell's Silver Hammer is an unfunny joke track - Lennon dismissed it as more of McCartney's "granny music", and I can't say I disagree on that point. But let's face it: by 1969, the situation of the band had deteriorated to the point where it would be futile to expect perfection, and perhaps we should be glad it's as good as it is.

Report this review (#454923)
Posted Monday, May 30, 2011 | Review Permalink
5 stars Rating: 10/10

The Beatles revolutionized music industry after releasing "Revolver" and "Sgt. Pepper", but they had never sounded so creative, challenging, inspired, genial as on "Abbey road".

Besides all the avant-garde merits the band accomplished in a short period of time, they manage to release their most carefully produced recording: a set of impeccable songs recorded extremely fussy and also flawless registered.

They were maturing in giant steps from one work to another and, though "Let it be" was their last release, "Abbey road" was actually the last time they joint their skills together into a recording studio.

Despite the fact they weren't recording together in the same room -at this point their human relationship was definitely broken-, the music didn't suffer even a bit of that.

Lennon was fully inspired as he shows us his most challenging side on "Come together", featuring one of the most glorious bass lines ever; then he finishes the 1st part of the album with the mind-blowing masterpiece "I want you (she's so heavy)", perhaps Lennon's best song ever with The Beatles -unfortunately mostly overpassed- in which the band crosses another thick line: Lennon takes a step forward the fury and potency of Mc Cartney's heavy metal seed "Helter skelter" and adds his usual psychedelic visions giving birth the first perfect commune between heavy metal and progressive rock into an almost 8 minutes suite: unbelievable.

Mc Cartney shows his wonderful changes of mood: he goes from silly on "Maxwell's silver hammer" and its delightfully rhythm, to shameless confessional man on "Oh! darling".

And Harrison is overwhelming and writes one of the greatest ballads ever, the emotive "Something"

Although the term "concept album" couldn't be fully applied as on "Sgt. Pepper", it would be totally wrong to dismiss it completely; on side 1 we find individual songs, but on almost the entire side 2 each one of the pieces are not only related but attached in-between them.

And if the 1st part shows great achievements and potential, the 2nd knocks you out, leaving you speechless.

Harrison shines once again with the folk jewel piece "Here comes the sun".

Mc Cartney is now angry and tells-off against music business on "You never give me your money" -title speaks for itself-.

Lennon comes from his incredible dense but genial "I want you" and takes a 180 degrees spin on the beautiful and heavenly "Because", another masterpiece.

And at this point if you're about to fall, they hit you with a killer punch up with a colorful and innovate collage of stunning songwriting short pieces that actually have a high value individually, but all together manage to form an incredible and crushing finale -Mc Cartney closes it all with the now evocative phrase: "...And in the end, the love you take is equal to the love you make..."-

"Abbey road" is the best The Beatles made in their entire career.

You can't choose a superior figure here -as on other albums-.

Lennon is more creative, eloquent and inspired than ever.

Mc Cartney is unafraid of showing every different artistic aspect and genial compositions as never before (oh my God, I almost forgot: please do yourself a favor and check -besides "The end"- "She came in through the bathroom window" and "Golden slumbers"... you'll have to thank me then...).

And, as never before happened on any other Beatles' release, many critics and part of the audience pointed Harrison as the stand out songwriter on this one because of those 2 precious pieces "Something" and "Here comes the sun".

That's why this is the best Beatles work ever; simply because this is Beatles at their best.

Report this review (#458529)
Posted Thursday, June 9, 2011 | Review Permalink
3 stars The album with THAT album cover. One of the bigger cultural icons of the last 100 years.

It seems like the band was in disintegration at that time with George and Ringo dropping in and out of the band. In particular George which had left the band and had to be talked back again. It is therefore ironic that one of his and The Beatles best ever songs is the star of this album. Something is a brilliant song by all standards. In my humble views, far better than the other great Beatles love song; Yesterday. Another one of George's songs; Here Comes The Sun is also great. Ringo's Octopus's Garden is also great.

...... The rest of the album is not particular good and this album really disappoints me. There is a lot of studio experiments here which would be adopted by the prog rock movement to great effect. But the songs are not good.

So three brilliant to superb songs and the rest is not so great. A three stars album in short.

3 stars

Report this review (#574759)
Posted Friday, November 25, 2011 | Review Permalink
Matti
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars The Beatles has never been among my very dearest bands but I enjoy their later albums. This is their finest in my opinion. (What an awkward situation it would be if I didn't like this, when it comes to the rating! Maybe my five stars do have some sort of extra for Absolute Classic Album By The Absolute Classic Band in Rock History, because after all I don't listen to this - or The Beatles in general - too often in my life. But yes, five stars it shall be.)

If the group was about to disband, it really don't show in the music. It's so full of cheerful energy. Well, John Lennon's (darker?) contribution is maybe smaller than usual; I have understood this album is very much Paul McCartney's child - and without his uncompromising working attitude the album possibly would have never been finished. Why on earth his solo output seems so much less impressive then? The Beatles must have been a playground for great individuals challenging each other. Also "the black horse" George Harrison brought his best known compositions here, lush love song 'Something', which has been covered by dozens of artists, and bright 'Here Comes The Sun'.

The first side includes also the deliciously ironic 'Come Together', fantastically over-the-top, tongue-in-cheek 'Oh Darling' with Paul's best vocals ever, and magnificent 'I Want You (She's So Heavy)'. One could consider two hilarious Ringo Starr numbers ('Maxwell's Silver Hammer' and 'Octopus's Garden') as weaker links of the great album, but they give their share to the overall charm.

The second side is a seamless suite of songs (too bad it doesn't have a name, only separate track titles), and especially by many progheads often considered their finest moment. There are a couple of rougher parts I usually skip, but they too are crucial to the artistic whole. The first part, 'Because', is fantastic (I'm really running out of superlatives!) slow and mystic-feeling song with lovely harpsichord sound and vocal harmonies. I remember it once being used, to a great effect, in a TV document about fractals. The next song, 'You Never Give Me Your Money', has beautiful melancholic melody that's genuinely repeated near the end of the suite. 'Golden Slumbers' is so heartachingly beautiful McCartney ballad that it's probably self-mockery. Even with some less enjoyable sections this suite is amazing and hasn't dated at all. A masterpiece album, no question about it. Also the superb level of production is very rare for its time.

Report this review (#593751)
Posted Wednesday, December 21, 2011 | Review Permalink
thehallway
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars Amazing; the best Beatles album and a triumph in 20th century pop music. It seems that 1969 was a peak in British and American music, and that certainly applies to George Harrison, who on this record delivered two of the greatest pop songs ever written. Paul was prolific as ever in his creation of mega-catchy melodies and innovative genre-blending, while John continued to write increasingly complex music (touching on progressive rock), and Ringo proves he can also write a decent song. Enhancing the fab four and helping defuse their explosive arguments, keyboard extrordinaire Billy Preston, who mingles in soulful jazz electric piano and pure rock organ. Add to that a plethora of super-producers (including the formidable organiser of sound Alan Parsons, and proven master of instrument clarity Ken Scott) all under the masterful eye of George Martin himself, and you can see exactly how and why the greatest and most innovative band to walk the Earth managed to go out on an unequaled high.

'Come Together' is smoky, funky jam rock with great singing and playing from everybody. 'Something' has beautiful chords, simply effective lyrics and is expertly arranged. Both reached number one, at a time when that meant something. 'Maxwell's Silver Hammer' is one of Paul's whimsical pieces of "granny music", made wonderful by the lyrics, contagious melody, and great interludes on the then- new Moog synthesizer. 'Oh! Darling' is nothing new, in fact it harks back to Fifties 6/8 swamp pop, yet it's sheer style and passionate singing makes it one of my absolute favourite Beatles songs. Then we have Ringo's 'Octopus's Garden', which is lovely enough to listen to that you forget about the grammatical error in the title. Closing an overwhelming first side is the rather epic 'I Want You (She's So Heavy)', which sees John Lennon influenced by the latest blues rock guitar styles. Preston makes this track even better. The time signature alternates to an incredibly dark, foreboding passage that never ends (until it is cut off without mercy by an engineer).

The second half of Abbey Road wows me even more, starting with 'Here Comes The Sun', surely the song where George overtakes Paul as the best writer of melodies in the band. 'Because' is a haunting, philosophical masterpiece from John, where thick, three-part harmonies are laid over harpsichord and guitar arpeggios. Then, it is the suite; the indicator that The Beatles would have been a prog band in the Seventies if they'd not split up. 'You Never Give Me Your Money' is another of the band's great group pieces, without a chorus or a verse, rather a linear journey across many moods and times. It flows via nature sounds into the Fleetwood Mac inspired 'Sun King'. More lush vocals create a Mediterranean feel, and Lennon's chords are as original as they get. Things naturally segue into 'Mean Mr Mustard' and 'Polythene Pam', a pair of rock songs that are just good fun. 'She Came In Through The Bathroom Window' has a great beat to it, and a brief pause signals the finale of the album, consisting of 'Golden Slumbers', a beautiful vocal piece, 'Carry That Weight', which climactically reprises the start of the suite, and then, 'The End'. This song features solos from all four members of the band, and concludes with one of the best couplets ever. There is a misplaced 26 seconds of folk in 'Her Majesty', just to outline that this was a band that never took itself too seriously, even in the end (uh, the very, very end).

Everybody should hear Abbey Road. It has the most consistently high quality songwriting of any Beatles album, the crispest sound, the best playing and solos, and feels more like a piece of art than a 'collection of tunes'. I love it, and I will listen to it as long as I live.

Report this review (#600479)
Posted Saturday, December 31, 2011 | Review Permalink
5 stars This is the masterpiece of the Fab Four, along with Revolver and Sgt. Pepper

Everything is great about this album. The songwriting, the performances, the harmonies. Even Ringo. His drumming is at it's finest. This was their last call after writing the majority of Let It Be. And what a great last call this is. From the bluesy tracks (Come Together, I Want You (She's So Heavy), Oh! Darling) to Harrison's gems (Something, Here Comes The Sun) and the Medley. I mean, what not to like about this album full of quality music.

The biggest band ever have changed and their discography is so varied. Now they say goodbye, not like the Stones who kept going with bad albums again and again (I mean, they were bad anyway.) The Beatles is not just a band, they are the biggest cultural event that happened in the history of music. And their discography shows it well. Full of great albums. Even the early ones. Pop at it's finest. But this album will stand the test of time forever, not like the early albums. A cultural masterpiece.

***** songs: Come Together, Something, I Want You (She's So Heavy), Here Comes The Sun, Because, You Never Give Me Your Money, Sun King, She Came In Through The Bathroom Window, Golden Slumbers, The End **** songs: Maxwell's Silver Hammer, Oh! Darling, Mean Mr. Mustard, Polythene Pam, Carry That Weight, Her Majesty *** songs: Octopus's Garden

Report this review (#609696)
Posted Saturday, January 14, 2012 | Review Permalink
3 stars First of all, is there any prog on "Abbey Road'? No, but I don't care. Non-prog albums don't get added to receive low ratings. Secondly, I personally found this record to be quite problematic musically. There are, however, quite a slew of tracks that I like. 'Come Together' is the best pop-rock track I found on the album because it really benefits from the vocal delivery and the guitar work. 'Because' is a nearly-cathartic track that made a strong impression on me through the vocal delivery. At this point I just want to curse this band. My other favorite tracks are either childish ditties ('Maxwell's Silver Hammer', 'Octopus' Garden') or tight rockers ('Polythene Pam', 'The End'). Don't miss out on 'The End', which features one of George Harrison's best rock guitar moments that became instantly popular with me when I was in high school. Also, some of you might enjoy the album version of George's 'Something', although I would highly recommend the "under-produced" version, the first version of the song that I have heard and which demonstrates Harrison the Acoustic Rocker at his best.

Now let's discuss other popular tracks on the record. I like 'I Want You (She's So Heavy)' for the organ work and the riff, but then the band threatens to go on and on and on, picking up noise as if the boys were trying to create a sense of drama. The riff isn't convincing enough to be dramatic, and neither is the noise. I feel very immune to this kind of "drama". 'Here Comes the Sun' is too simple and happy for me, and it has a very limited set of powerful musical ideas. As for the side two medley, well, I'm not into medleys. I do not support the whole idea of musical incoherence, of stitching together different tracks or musical bits and treating it as a whole.

Allow me to add that there is a hidden track on the album, 'Her Majesty', which I personally found quite spooky with the sudden change of keys that sound a bit microtonal to each other.

Ratings/comments (if you have to ask):

1. 'Come Together' - ***** ; 2. 'Something' - ** ; 3. 'Maxwell's Silver Hammer' - **** ; 4. 'Oh! Darling' - *** ; 5. 'Octopus' Garden' - **** ; 6. 'I Want You (She's So Heavy)' - ** ; 7. 'Here Comes the Sun' - * ; 8. 'Because' - ***** ; 9. 'You Never Give Me Your Money' - ** ; 10. 'Sun King' - *** ; 11. 'Mean Mr. Mustard' - ** ; 12. 'Polythene Pam' - *** ; 13. 'She Came in Through the Bathroom Window' - * ; 14. 'Golden Slumbers' - **** ; 15. 'Carry That Weight' - *** ; 16. 'The End' - **** ; 17. 'Her Majesty' - ** ;

Stamp: "Try it yourself" (as in "I think it's worse than lots of people say it is.")

Report this review (#614005)
Posted Friday, January 20, 2012 | Review Permalink
5 stars This album has already been reviewed on this site over 400 times so my opinion doesn't make much difference in it's rating, but what the heck...ABBEY ROAD, of course, is one of the "classic" must-have albums by the Beatles and does have some progressive tendencies similar to SGT PEPPERS LONELY HEARTS CLUB BAND. There are no real weak moments except possibly Octopus Garden which I have never liked. In fact, Ringo's tunes have never done anything for me. And the 2nd half of ABBEY ROAD contains a wonderful musical journey from "Here Comes the Sun" all the way through to "The End". A true masterpiece of rock if not Progressive rock. There is no way I can not give it 5 stars. I would never forgive myself! Along with Revolver, my favorite Beatles album.
Report this review (#639351)
Posted Thursday, February 23, 2012 | Review Permalink
5 stars I view Abbey Road as the last true Beatles Album. Not just because it was it recorded last, but it has a sense of finality to it. Consequently, this is my favorite album from the band. It is possible this is also their most progressive album. They explore interesting soundscapes in many songs, and continue to experiment with different instruments and sounds.

There is still a pretty eclectic variety song-wise. You have your classic light rock tunes in 'Come Together,' 'Oh! Darling,' and 'Octopus' Garden,'

Any pop on this album is far removed from the trite they recorded in their early days. 'Maxwell's Silver Hammer' 'Here Comes the Sun,' and the ballad 'Something' are all pop, but have a slight artsy quality to them that much of their earlier stuff clearly didn't.

However, the highlights for me are 'She's So Heavy' and the entire 'Abbey Road Medley.' The heaviness and mood on the former is unlike anything they've ever done, while the Medley is simply a plethora of top notch songs in a row.

How fitting the last words on 'The End' are "The love you take is equal to the love you take, a dogma that has been in there songs since the beginning. This is simply the band's best, and is a testament to the uncanny musical transformation they have undergone in a short six years.

9/10

Report this review (#771414)
Posted Friday, June 15, 2012 | Review Permalink
5 stars The Beatles was for me, like for many others an eye opener to all other music. It was their easy, lovely melodies and their new inventions that was what I liked. With a delicious blend of styles and influences they made unforgettable music.

Abbey Road has all those ingredients. It has contrubutions from all members. Ringo's Octopus's garden is a fine and melancolic song with happy thoughts. George's contributions is perhaps the sweetest and most beautiful on the album, the greatest hits. Beside of this the album has heavier parts lik rough Come together, strong Oh! Darling and the psychedelic yelling of I want you.

The biggest experience of this record is the long Abbey Road medley. Lately I listened for the first time without breaks between the diffrerent parts, it was totaly awsome. All these short songs with different lyrics and atmosphere is so progressive together. They should have made one song of it insteed to make it even more proggy.

My favourite piece is Golden slumbers, a powerfull anthem of lyrical brilliance. Her Majesty is in my opinion the less interesting track. I can't give Abbey Road less than five stars, honestly all albums from Revolver to Let it be is worth the same (by not Yellow Submarine).

The music's complecity is what makes progressive rock so interesting - but it can also be too much of it. Beatles was not a progressive rock band, their songs was too short and radiodesigned but still their music was progressive. No song sounds like another and their playing learned me much about music.

Report this review (#886302)
Posted Wednesday, January 2, 2013 | Review Permalink
5 stars My all-time favorite Beatle album. This album has a number of progressive features to it, especially side two. Side two is known as the medley, as nine or so songs are melded together to represent a whole. Most of the songs in this medley were written around the time of the White Album, with a few from the Get Back sessions and some from their current time of Abbey Road. This extended piece is definattely proto-prog as they use an extended sequence with a recurring theme (a part of You Never Give Me Your Money is reprised in Carry That Weight). This idea was taken by many of the coming prog artists at that time and incorporated into their music. Without the Beatles experimentation with sequencing of songs (i.e. the medley), prog would have stuck to the short song format.
Report this review (#901788)
Posted Tuesday, January 29, 2013 | Review Permalink
BrufordFreak
COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
4 stars Abbey Road was certainly a change in direction for The Beatles. I heard it the day it was released to record stores in the United States. Over and over. My best friend's nineteen year old brother had just bought it and played it non-stop the entire day while I was there. He kept coming out of his room saying things like, "Are you hearing this?" "Isn't this amazing?" I was hearing and feeling an album very different from the heavily-played-at-home-by-my-mother Sgt. Pepper and Magical Mystery Tour--both of which I loved. I wasn't disliking what I was hearing, I just wasn't sure of how I felt. Ambiguous. The feelings the album was evoking in me were ones of simplicity, peace, patience, determination, ennui, clarity, steady pacing, and spacing. None of these were feelings that I had typically associated with Beatles songs or albums. So, needless to say, it took me a while to digest and appreciate Abbey Road. Plus, I was distracted for a while by the album's added fuel to the raging fire around the "Paul is dead" rumors. (I had friends who were quite fanatical about all of the "evidence" in the albums, covers and literature. On this one Paul's bare feet on the album cover picture were sure signs that he was the cadaver, Ringo, in black, the undertaker, John, in white, the minister/priest, George, in jeans, the lay representative--stuff like that!) When my brother brought home the album all we ever really heard was Side One. The radio was playing "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" a lot (which I always thought was a silly song-- more like a medieaval nursery rhyme). The music was at times too heavy for my delicate tastes ("Come Together" and "She's So Heavy") and because of my language disability, the lyrics were non-objects to me. (I do not hear lyrics; that is, I am unable to make sense of spoken or sung words--unless I read them repeatedly along with listening to the song. I am too distracted by the music. To me, singing is merely another instrument added to the tapestry of the fabric.) Plus, some of the songs shifted radically or went on longer than the two-to-three minutes to which I was accustomed. (I was a young, unworldly 11 years old.) To this day, the impression left on me by Abbey Road is one of ennui; I could really care less if it were ever made or if I ever hear it (or it's songs) again. (Though "Octopus's Garden" and "Here Comes the Sun" were fun for my child-raising/parenting experience.) As to a more cerebral, intellectual perspective on the value to the album to the future of music and to the inception of "prog," I do believe it added to the world's views as to what directions were possible for musical exploration. Is it the most influential Proto-prog album of all-time? I do no think so. Not by a long shot. Don Ellis Orchestra Live at Monterey, Revolver, Sgt. Pepper, Days of Future Passed, several Frank Zappa albums, Are You Experienced?, and even Magical Mystery Tour all rate higher than Abbey Road for me.

Report this review (#910978)
Posted Thursday, February 7, 2013 | Review Permalink
4 stars This album represents the point in the Beatles career where they transition completely from making interesting guitar pop songs into being a mediocre classic rock band. Whereas Sgt. Peppers is hindered by having a streak of poor songwriting, especially towards the middle, the poor quality on Abbey Road feels deliberate. Whether its the kind of boring, bluesy background guitar that was in style at the turn of the decade (She Came in Through the Bathroom Window, I Want You) the inclusion of shameless granny music (Oh Darling, Maxwell's Silver Hammer), or the lazy, incomplete songwriting of the medley, all of the flaws in the album are fixable but left in place as some sort of stylistic choice. And on the subject of the medley, I realized why I like Pink Flag, which has similar song lengths, and not it. Simply, the songs on Pink Flag stand on their own. I can listen to and enjoy Straight Line when it comes on shuffle, even though it's only 45 seconds long.
Report this review (#930057)
Posted Thursday, March 14, 2013 | Review Permalink
5 stars Obviously such an iconic album, and influential to the future of music after the psychedelic 60s, as well as progressive rock. "Abbey Road" is perhaps The Beatles at their greatest in terms of songwriting, although perhaps tires a little throughout, with side 1 being the hits - making you overloaded with these pop rock songs, and side 2 a fantastically sequenced yet outstretched medley containing reprises from previous songs. While this album is packed with all of these 3-minute wonders, it feels a bit forceful and over-indulgent in certain places and not quite consistent in its sound, which to me was sort of patched up by repeated instruments (the fuzz guitar on "I Want You" and "Because"). The worst part of the whole album in my opinion is the clean guitar sound that doesn't fit a few songs. Anyway, that's practically all that's bad with "Abbey Road", so here's the good stuff!

"Come Together": a great blues rock opener, with some awesome little hooks and melodies. A bit of psychedelic flavour is chucked into the mix, and overall gives you a great impression on the rest of the album's signature sound. Leaves enough space for you to breath though, as it could be so easily overloaded with bluesy guitar licks. As I've said, I would have liked a little more grit in the guitar solo, but otherwise awesome and undoubtedly a classic. "Something" is so beautiful in so many ways. The lyrics are so dreamy and fitting coming out of a heavier song, with great instrumentation and chord progressions and a structure just adventurous enough to keep you interested but not take you out of that wispy trance. Some great keyboards/mellotrons in there too, giving it that proto-progressive vibe, plus the bridge which is often forgotten. Very consistent and possibly the best song on the album. A masterclass in pop rock ballads.

"Maxwell's Silver Hammer" is a classic plodding McCartney pop song, that strangely has a divide of people who love it and hate it. I kinda like it :P not as good as some of the stuff on Sgt. Pepper, and John's harmonies seem a little bitty to me, but still great. The lyrics tell quite a strange story for the mood of the melody and the chords behind it, making it all the more eerily charming like every good psychedelic pop song should be. Love Ringo's anvil in it though, and the guitars add a brilliant bite to it. "Oh Darling" is another favourite of mine, right up there with "Something", and begins on such a sumptuous augmented chord, and then rolls into a swinging compound time, showing the other side of Paul, and his interpretation on the blues. Probably at his best here, and improved with John's aah's behind him. Paul hits some incredible notes, and displays so much soul, it makes the whole thing irresistible and builds to such an indescribable climax. Another classic.

"Octopus's Garden" is Ringo's time to shine on here, and is very basic in terms of melodies and chords, so not quite up there with the other tracks. It displays more of a camaraderie feel, as it did with "Little Help From My Friends", but this isn't quite as overwhelming to say the least (probably as Ringo didn't write the latter). A lavish guitar intro (and outro), and overall very warming coming out of the heartbreak of "Oh Darling" and entering "I Want You". Some intriguing arpeggios here, and so desirable when the wall of sound dissipates, and the vocals and guitar sing in unison. So solid, and a great couple of chords (i.e. the E7b9). Not much more to say, but a brilliant blues number. Again, not quite up there with the other tracks, but still gets a 5-star rating. I do like the ending, but maybe like cut half a minute off, or put half a minute on. I always kind of get hesitant when playing along, and thinking it should have ending, then just getting back into the swing of things. Anyway, still great when listening to it :P

"Here Comes The Sun". Excellent start to Side 2, as things were just beginning to slip. Another great piece of songwriting by George, and I'm loving the 7th fret capo on the guitar (sorry for all you non-guitarists about going on about this). The lyrics aren't meaningful, and the chords aren't eccentric and fascinating, it's just an absorbing song that fills you with a true happiness that you have to find a little bit. Better than all these crappy modern "sunshine" songs. Anyway, some nice harmonies and time signatures all make this another exceptional song in the Beatles catalogue. "Because" is a bit too dreary coming out of this and doesn't really go anywhere. I always feel that you'd have to be on drugs to appreciate this song, and therefore isn't accessible enough, especially on a pop rock record. Not essential to the album in my opinion, and although there are some thought-provoking lyrics, chords, harmonies, and various musical devices, it doesn't strike a chord with me particularly.

"You Never Give Me Your Money" is so wonderfully narcissistic like lots of Beatles songs, and holds that sort of unexpected charm. So basic and played down, with Paul and the piano blending right together and creating a wholesome atmosphere. A great start to the medley as the final upbeat rock section (already reprising "Here Comes The Sun") slides into silence as the appearance of the "Sun King". Again a bit too psychedelic, and sounds like one of George's raga songs arranged for guitars instead of sitars and tables or something. Still enchanting and hypnotic when the harmonies kick in and stun the music. The French lyrics are a nice touch - no idea what they mean though... "Mean Mr. Mustard" is possibly the highlight of the medley. So simple and easy to enjoy, with some awesome random lyrics with great time signatures and then going straight into "Polythene Pam" with John taking over the vocals, and singing some funnier lyrics. Just heaven at this point, and so fast moving - not like "Because" at all.

"She Came In Through The Bathroom Window" segues straight out, and still keeps you gripped with some strangely jolly guitar chords and lyrics that tell quite a vivid story, and you still get those classic Beatles harmonies. The medley calms down here, and enters the soothing "Golden Slumbers", with "once there was a way" and such a lush orchestra backing from that repetitive piano section. Some reassuring, gentle lyrics interrupted by an overpowering middle section before retreating to the hopeful mood. "Carry That Weight" is too harsh coming out of this, but probably the best they could have done looking at the songs on there. Too dull and shouty with the orchestration behind and the plodding guitars behind. Doesn't fit, but the "You Never Give Me Your Money" reprise is pretty terrific. Like they've just remembered another problem in life. Still very celebratory though, and unfortunately stopped prematurely by that chorus again.

"The End" is such one of the best songs on the album, hidden away at the back. Also, a great way to fool people into missing "Her Majesty" after a few seconds of silence, but I'll get to that. "The End" is such a tremendous rock song, and so definite and mature. Love Ringo's drumming here too, plus the 3 guitars from Paul, John, and George, showing off their signature styles. It all seems to "come together" here, and you can't help but have a massive smile. The piano interruption is so perfect, and has some truly magnificent chord progressions to see it out. "Her Majesty" then adds a little icing in the top of the cake. Such a glorious few seconds more to bask in that acoustic dreaminess, and listen to Paul for just a little longer after the all too predictable symphonic ending. To me, it sounds like Led Zeppelin's "Hey Hey What Can I Do", which I feel they wrote along a similar story because it's almost too short and sweet. Anyway, a splendid hidden track (quite absurd they thought they could keep it that way with such an enormous fan base) and of course a fabulous conclusion to the album and the leaders of the 60s and its soundtrack just before the world of music grew out of the psychedelic culture.

A(+): Even with so many sales, it still remains underrated and a part of Britain's heritage, even a small piece of history.

Come Together: ***** Something: ***** Maxwell's Silver Hammer: ***** Oh! Darling: ***** Octopus's Garden: ***** I Want You (She's So Heavy): ***** Here Comes The Sun: ***** Because: **** You Never Give Me Your Money: **** Sun King: **** Mean Mr. Mustard: **** Polythene Pam: **** She Came In Through The Bathroom Window: **** Golden Slumbers: **** Carry That Weight: *** The End: ***** Her Majesty: *****

Report this review (#984641)
Posted Sunday, June 23, 2013 | Review Permalink
5 stars My favourite Beatles album. This was their swan song even though Let It Be was released after it. A concise collection of enjoyable songs.

"Come Together", "Maxwell's Silver Hammer", "I Want You (She's So Heavy)", and "Here Comes The Sun" alone show the diversity of The Beatles. The medley that takes up most of side 2 is one of the best moments of their career. A burst of energy from a band that was near the breaking point, the side 2 medley is a musical brainstorm that never fails to put a smile on your face.

Abbey Road is my Beatles choice along with Rubber Soul and The Beatles (White Album). Recommended.

Report this review (#1089147)
Posted Thursday, December 12, 2013 | Review Permalink
patrickq
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars Abbey Road is one of the best Beatles albums, and that says something.

The weakest track on the album is "Oh! Darling," and I think that says something, too: while it's by no means a great song, each of the other sixteen* is better. My only other criticism is that nearly eight minutes, "I Want You (She's So Heavy)" is a bit long. I do appreciate the need for the song to be longer than the usual track, by the way; I think in particular that the three-minute coda gets a little monotonous. But overall, the songwriting here is excellent. In fact, among all Beatles LPs, Abbey Road represents the best balance among the group's songwriters. Although Paul McCartney doesn't have a standout track, his contributions to the Side Two medley are pretty good - - especially "You Never Give Me Your Money," "Golden Slumbers," and "Carry That Weight." Ringo Starr's contribution, "Octopus's Garden" is delightful, and John Lennon turns in both "Because" and "Come Together," the latter being one of his best Beatles songs. The real star, though, is George Harrison, as his best two songs, "Something" and "Here Comes the Sun," are both here.

While few bands have produced a song as incredible as "Here Comes the Sun," "Something" is in another league. Among Beatles songs, "Something" is only equaled by "Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da," "She Loves You," "I Saw Her Standing There," and "Eleanor Rigby," and is surpassed only by "Penny Lane." Of course, to be fair to Lennon and McCartney, Harrison learned from the best. Every compositional aspect of "Something" is fantastic, from the way the verse-chorus melody builds and resolves to the contrast the bridge provides to the incredible guitar solo. And the hopeful but ambivalent the lyrics ("you're asking me, 'will our love grow?' / I don't know; I don't know") are on a par with the writing of Lennon or McCartney.

In addition to the compositions, the instrumental and vocal performances (and in particular the choral performances on "Because" and "Sun King") are superb. As the group's bass guitarist, McCartney outdoes himself, so to speak, on "I Want You (She's So Heavy);" surprisingly, the appropriately conventional bass line on "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" is played by Harrison, the lead guitarist. In turn, McCartney, Lennon, and Harrison play successive guitar solos on "The End," the song which also features a drum solo by Starr.

While I still consider Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band to be the Beatles' best LP, Abbey Road and Revolver are also strong contenders. It's particularly remarkable that the band produced Abbey Road after two relatively weak albums (The Beatles and Let it Be, the latter finalized and released after Abbey Road).

====

*counting each track on the 2009 CD as a separate song.

Report this review (#2264288)
Posted Saturday, September 28, 2019 | Review Permalink
jamesbaldwin
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars Abbey Road has a first side of songs that characterize the styles of their authors: two remarkable Lennon rock- blues; two by McCartney, a pop song (the usual Macca song that takes the Beatles out of rock and in light music for families and children) and a remarkable rock and roll; a Harrison melodic classic and a tasty Ringo country. A second side follows where almost all the songs are mixed together, to form a suite that anticipates those of progressive rock (Colosseum's Valentyne Suite will be released shortly after). Both sides are very thick and, in particular, the second side of Abbey Road is the most innovative and certainly the best of all the second sides of the Beatles albums (average 8.00) since in this case there is no , as happened in practice in each previous album, no drop in quality: the compositions intended for facade B are not "minor", compared to those of side A - however, it may also be that the three central segments, by Lennon, if developed into real songs, they would have given rise to minor pieces. Slow, atmospheric love songs are missing from the album, there is not the usual honeyed retro song by McCartney, on the other hand there is a sweet and vocal song by Lennon. Abbey Road, as well as Let It Be, printed later but recorded earlier, marks a return of the Beatles to rock, after the psychedelic hangover of 1966-67, in which McCartney mainly recorded vaudeville and retro songs of every possible musical genre, with orchestral arrangements more than rock, and Harrison raga songs with Indian arrangement.

Abbey Road is a rock album with a much smoother sound than the White Album, but also much more 70s, and in fact the synthesizers appear, the only case in the Beatles discography. In this album, Lennon signs two little Beatlesian rock songs, which place the Beatles on the same level as the rock-blues bands of the time (Rolling Stones, Cream), and two very original melodic and atmospheric songs; Harrison writes his two most famous songs: a melodic classic, and a folk classic; McCartney does not write any of his true classics (but the weakest song on the album) but, in reality, he places on the second side two piano songs, with a beautiful intro, which then evolve into two mini rock suites that constitute the avant-garde peak of the album. The disc opens with Come Together, which for bass and drums constitutes a unicum in the Beatles discography. It is a very refined rockblues ballad, with dark and sensual atmospheres which brings the Beatles towards much more "heavy" music than pop music. On an instrumental level, it is excellent, each Beatles gives its best in the arrangement: bass, drums, solo guitar, singing.

Something is a much lighter song that however delights for the melody, and for the bridge, fantastic, one of the most evocative crescendo of the Beatles, which unfortunately has the defect of not being repeated a second time. Frank Sinatra will make it his own, dilate it and, of course, he will be able to emphasize bridge and repeat it. Something remains a small masterpiece, which could have been a great masterpiece with an extra bridge and greater pathos in singing. Maxwell Silver Hammer opens the Macca songs on the first side. It is a vaudeville goliardic pop, at a slow medium rhythm, which lowers the quality of the disc but which, at least, enjoys a good musical arrangement, suitable for a rock complex, with synths in the foreground, which does not make it appear a song too dated or for children. Oh Darling is a doo-woop song and you don't understand if it is a parodic, caricatural piece or just an emphaticpiece: in any case it's a great song, however retro. It is a rock and roll to listen to at full volume, where Paul stirs the listener between singing and bass. Great work also on drums and guitar. The song alternates the melodious voice with a hoarse voice, scraped up to the throat, which fills the refrain with an emphasis on the limit of excessive.

Ringo arrives (helped by Harrison in the composition) with his pop-country: an excellent solo of Fender guitar by Harrison with a clear sound, a beautiful singing, an excellent arrangement with noises of bubbles in the instrumental part. It is his second (and last) song for the Beatles, and fills the first side with freshness. In closing, I Want You - She's So Heavy, is a long, heavy, gloomy and obsessive song, which makes the most of its minimal text. Not loved by Beatles fans (because it's too rock and gloomy), on the contrary it is one of their absolute masterpieces. The depth and intensity that Lennon knows how to touch with his voice and the hypnotic guitar tour that goes on for 7 minutes is unsustainable for lovers of the cheerful and carefree Beatles of two minutes. The first side ends like this, with I Want You being cut (the recording tape ends, and the Beatles decide to leave this ending). As for the quality of the songs, and the refinement of the instrumental arrangements we are at very high levels (average above 8), however in terms of sequence, smoothness and sonic innovations, the first side of Sgt Pepper (and also of White Album) are superior to it.

1) Come Together 8,5 ; 2) Something 8+; 3) Maxwell Silver Hammer 6,5/7; 4) Oh Darling 8+; 5) Octopus's Garden 7,5; 6) I want you ' She's So Heavy 9;

The second side opens with a large melodic folk piece by Harrison. Just the phrasing of guitar and singing to delight, in this very simple song. In the middle, a one-sentence bridge repeated 5 times, with crescendo of synthesizers, then returning to the initial melody. A song that remains in mind. Follows Because, voices and synthesizers, a very beautiful melody reminiscent of Beethoven's Moonlight, dreamy choruses, an atmospheric song that lacks development. Here is finally McCartney, with You Never Give Me Your Money, a song little known to most but which represents one of his artistic peaks. Written as a response to Lennon's Happiness Is a Warm Gun, which was a condensation of changes in rhythm and melody, You Never ... is a minisuite, with a beautiful piano start, melodic, to then become a boogie, then return melodic and end with a country atmosphere at night, with the sound of crickets, which is mixed with the medley of three pieces of Lennon's songs. First there is the atmospheric instrumental of Sun King, very nice, it looks like a soundtrack, then the romantic voices arrive but soon transmute into the mocking goliardic of an Italian-Spanish language that it is not known where it could go to save unless the piece arrives by Mean Mr. Mustard (one minute), with a fast pace, which unfortunately ends too early in the guitars of Polithene Pam (a minute and a half), in which the sound of the voice seems distant and the excited rhythm has no time to unfold in something more accomplished. All in all these three pieces of Lennon are interlocutors, and they surprise, amaze with their changes in sound and rhythm but do not give time to be appreciated.

Polythene Pam results in a continuum of guitars in a better developed Macca song (two minutes), a good almost complete guitar rockblues piece (Joe Cocker will make a great cover), She Came In Through The Bathroom Window, which closes too quickly. Overall, so far this medley, made up of a real song by Paul (You Never ...), three pieces by John, and an almost song by Paul, after an excellent start suffers from an incomplete fusion of music and sound in its various passages : the pieces appear superimposed a little too quickly on each other (it would have helped if Lennon's had lasted longer), and before and after Mean Mr. Mustard there are no connecting phrases, however the sequence holds up well and the piece of Mr. Mustard serves to give a change of gear.

After She Came Trhogh The Bathroom Window there is a pause, a part of the medley finishes and another decidedly more compact begins, with Golden Slumbers, which has a great effect: it opens with a melodious and romantic piano line, it becomes serious in the vocal crescendo of Macca, who forgets that he is singing a lullaby, returns melodious with a beautiful background of strings, of a somewhat expressive romanticism, and then explodes in the chorus of Carry That Weight, which is halfway between the goliardic and the epic; then it takes refuge in a reprise with trumpets, beautiful, of You Never Give Me ... The choir of Carry That Way returns and then changes its pitch and rhythm to flow into the instrumental that sees first Ringo then the three Beatles grapple with a solo (always very simple compared to the jams of the rockblues complexes of the time). The three guitarists are called and respond to each other with the same number of guitar phrases per head. The solo of the three guitarists is a very genuine and amused solo, which reflects the Beatles' behavior in the studio: they were having fun, like in the old days. Ringo, on the other hand, did not perform a real solo, because he refused but his teammates fooled him: they removed the guitars from the mix channels and so almost only Ringo's drums remain, which perform a really simple and elementary rhythm, so much so that many criticized Ringo for this rudimentary solo: but he didn't know he was doing it! He was not doing any solo! Closes the percussive piano on which Paul sings the maxim of The End ("And in the end the love you take is equal to the love you make"). It was supposed to be the end of the album but McCartney couldn't resist and inserted the acoustic piece by Her Majesty, which was a piece excluded from the previous medley.

7) Here Comes the Sun 8; 8) Because 7,5; 9) You Never Give Me Your Money 8,5; 10) Sun King/Mean Mr Mustard/ Polithene Pam 7+/7,5/7+/ 7,5; 11) She Came Through the Bathroom Window 7,5/8 ; 12) Golden Slumbers/Carry That Way/ The End 8,5/9/8+/ 8,5/9; 13) Her Majesty.

Overall, it is the most adult Beatles album, which leaves little space for cheerful and carefree songs, vaudeville, exuberance (even the rhythms are decidedly medium, not high), with retro arrangements: it is an album completely played by a rock complex (and it is the most refined musically, the Beatles show that they are also great instrumentalists), with the addition of orchestration to make some melodic moments memorable. Like Sgt Pepper, Abbey Road is a well-kept album, which is developed according to a precise idea (both albums have a song that is resumed, to sign a concluded circle, which for Abbey Road is valid only for the second side), however divided in two distinct parts; compared to Sgt Pepper does not have that festive and flowing and varied beginning, sometimes with pyrotechnic sounds and arrangements, which is maintained for most of Pepper, on the other hand Abbey Road is more reflective, homogeneous, deep; psychedelia is replaced by a greater romanticism alternating with blues gloom. Like Let It Be, it is less heterogeneous than the albums ranging from 1966 (Revolver) to 1968 (White Album), more compact, without Indian or retro or orchestral sounds but, compared to Let It Be, Abbey Road is finished with extreme precision and coordination in the studio between the various Beatles and George Martin (while Let It Be is recorded live, only to undergo posthumous orchestrations); moreover, it has better pieces.

Abbey Road, although not the album that has most affected in the history of the Beatles (and pop music), and although it is not the most innovative album in terms of sounds and arrangement (the palm of these peaks is up to Sgt Pepper), on the whole their greatest masterpiece, as the best rock album, containing the most mature and valuable songs, and as played with the best instrumental skill, and with the same care of Pepper's arrangements; and where Pepper is one of the first albums concept (however broadly speaking), Abbey Road is one of the first albums with suites that anticipate those of progressive. It is a masterpiece of composition and arrangement, with high quality songs, without any significant drop in tone, summa of the Beatles' styles but with an eye to represent it with contemporary rock sounds, without falling into light music, and with a second side that wants be experimental for the long sequence of pieces of tracks mixed together, the original and seminal solution of progressive.

Medium quality of the songs: 8,02: Rating: 9,5/10; Five stars.

Report this review (#2378030)
Posted Thursday, May 7, 2020 | Review Permalink
DamoXt7942
FORUM & SITE ADMIN GROUP
Avant/Cross/Neo/Post Teams
5 stars According to the recording dates or so, "Abbey Road" released in September 1969 could be thought as the 'last' album by The BEATLES. Contrary to the very last album "Let It Be" set with lots of masterpieces, this album features less 'smash hits' than the following one but possibly the four talented musicians especially Paul would perfectly concentrate the overall production. Curiously it's said the producer Giant George MARTIN might have barely influenced nor touched the creation, but in "Abbey Road" George's "Inquiry spirits" and "Creativity" should live vivaciously. In addition, every single track has not only "originality" but also "homage" for the rock vanguards like Chuck BERRY or Buddy HOLLY.

Listen and we can find that the first track "Come Together" by John involves a massive homage for Chuck's "You Can't Catch Me" (later John covered and released in his album "Rock 'n' Roll"). Needless to say "Come Together" has also his innovative interpretation for Black Music and deeply heavy texture though. Such a powerful soundscape can be heard in the last track on SIde A "I Want You (She's So Heavy)" that is so simple in melody lines but at the same time possesses crazy heavy and challenging atmosphere. In Paul's "Oh! Darling" we can touch his heavy- metallic but delightful preference in those days, in the same vein of "Why Don't We Do It In The Road" in the White Album. No complication nor distortion is here. Sounds like he would have created, played and sung this song as he wanted to do. Speaking of 'as he wanted to do', Ringo's "Octopus Garden" is quirky catchy for this album but very enjoyable to feel plenty of sound effects and easygoing vibes. "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" is quite unique and sarcastic stuff, flooded with splatter bloody hellish but mysteriously cheerful hints.

"Something" and "Here Comes The Sun" by George HARRISON are splendid masterpieces. His deep religious vision or outlook is pretty intriguing. These stuffs are seasoned with such a meaningful flavour but produced to incredibly brilliant, acceptable gems. Makes sense George's "My Sweet Load" won the first prize on Billboard Hot 100 ahead of other Beatle guys. On the other hand "Because" by John reflects his world vision in a peaceful manner. His lyrics are not complex but definitely are thoughtful and energetic enough to ring our bells again and again.

The Side B created by the quartet and produced almost by Paul McCARTNEY is kinda magnificent rock opera itself. Regardless of such a bad group condition as we know well, they completed the excellent suite placed on the top of the rock mountain. "You Never Give Me Your Money" is very suitable to open the theatre curtain with a colourful melodic / rhythmic pattern. Wondering what Paul said with the words 'funny papers' not money but we could easily imagine he would have found no substantial The BEATLES' existence value like 'funny papers'. Sounds at least for me like that John's "Sun King" might take on the role to respect George's vision. Calm, religious, dramatic "Sun King", and stable, sincere but slightly weird "Mean Mr. Mustard" calling for rolling stones all over the world, and the following uptempo, attractive and cynical one "Polythene Pam" are John's massive intention and attitude for missing the beatle spirits, that were featured tragically by Paul.

On the contrary, from "She Came In Through The Bathroom Window" until "The End ~ Her Majesty" Paul would tell the 'last' words which should be great fit for their epilogue. Guess Paul might sing his concerns about a mysterious beautiful lady who has stolen the spirit, on this track. Drenched with sad, lonesome flavour ... who knows if they would have a bright future or not. But he tried to dig something energetic and hopeful out in the next stage "Golden Slumber" with powerful voices. Sleeping tight but do not give up his dreams, he should have said via this stuff. "Carry That Weight" featuring the highlight of "You Never Give Me Your Money" is kind of an adrenaline rush just before the finale. Everybody might get optimistic at this moment. And "The End" sounds exaggerating, pessimistic, but dreamy, that must be suitable for the end. The 20 second silence is like their, and our 'empty life' but do not throw our rock spirits out. Because he left small messages for us to keep our mind eternally in "Her Majesty" a tiny short song.

Yes they give such an enthusiastic passage towards the fantastic future.

Report this review (#2531777)
Posted Saturday, April 3, 2021 | Review Permalink
3 stars Abbey Road is the last album the Beatles would ever record, despite being released before "Let it Be". It has one of the most iconic images ever as the cover, but the music...

It's ok. It's certainly not prog (but the medley gets close), but that's not to say it's bad.

Lennon's contribution's to the album - outside of the medley - were "Come Together" (which had some lyrics copied of Chuck Berry's "You Can't Catch Me"), "I Want You (She's So Heavy)", coming in at 8 minutes and only a couple more words, and the last track before the medley "Because", which is a very simplistic song. Overall, only one song, that being "Come Together", I really enjoy, although I do enjoy some of the vocal harmonies that are in "Beacuase", although it ends up coming of as boring and weird, and the medley after it. And "I Want You" is a long, repetitive mess, and for eight minutes, the lyrical, and musical content is really missing, in place of it, useless repetition.

Harrison's contributions to the album are "Something", and one of the Beatles most recognisable songs "Here Comes the Sun". "Something" features what I'd say is McCartney's best bassline, ever, and one of the greatest love songs ever (for me, it's only beaten by the Beach Boys "God Only Knows"). And "Here Comes the Sun" is a wonderful way to begin side 2, and a beautifully calming and relaxing track.

Ringo Starr makes his second ever composition (and last) for the Beatles, in his one contribution to the album "Octopus's Garden", and a much better one than his previous "Don't Pass Me By".

Paul's contributions - apart from the medley - are "Oh! Darling" and the comical "Maxwell's Silver Hammer", the former of which provides some of Paul's best vocal work.

Finally, the medley. It opens with "You Never Give Me Your Money", a somber tune, that quickly turns into rock n' roll, once a minute rolls around, and is the most complete song in the medley (although it somewhat feels like two). "Sun King", once again features the three part vocals from "Because", but this time, a slightly less strange sounding melody. "Mean Mr. Mustard" and "Polythene Pam" are both rock n' roll songs written by Lennon, the former being slower, and less interesting, and the latter being stronger, and deserving a fully finished track, which unfortunatley would never happen. The last songs are all McCartney songs, "Golden Slumber" being a song based of a 17th century poem, with powerful orchestration, and "Carry That Weight" reprises some parts of "You Never Give You My Money". "The End" is ok, somewhat depressing, but also beautiful in its own unique way. And finally, "Her Majesty" is a beautiful short song to end the album, after 20 seconds of silence.

Overall, the best part of "Abbey Road" is it's cover. Other than that, it's a fairly forgettable album, with the strange medley being the most notable part musically, along with the first two tracks being number ones, and "Here Comes The Sun" becoming their most popular song.

Report this review (#2590934)
Posted Tuesday, August 31, 2021 | Review Permalink
3 stars The big one, Abbey Road. The tenular rock album (I don't know if I'm using that word correctly). I like it a lot, it's a good album. But it ain't experimental enough, not nearly as much as The Beatles [White Album]. Which is kind of a bummer considering what they did with that one, oh well. Here I feel like McCartney got his grubby hands too much on the production. It sounds too much like him, it's too milky and not as grounded and Earth as The Beatles [White Album]. And I like the later The Beatles [White Album] sound a lot better. And sorry if I [%*!#] up some of the wording. As you can tell by the title, this is my second time writing this review, and I am soooooooooooo [%*!#]ing tired.

Come Together is iconic, really one of the most recognizable songs ever. The bassline is funky, the solo is solid. Its mellowness and lyric content work well together. Although I don't think it's the best choice for the opening track. I think Because would've been a better choice.

Something is a sweet loving song, it should be right up my alley, but it just doesn't hit the nerve with me the same way it has with so many other people. Musically it rides the coattails of Come Together with its mellowness. But then the bridge comes along and all of these different ideas come together (pun intended), and it just doesn't work. The dynamics are all weird.

Maxwell's Silver Hammer is awesome. It is very overproduced though. What should be a very fitting album track tried to stretch and over-reach its boundaries. It tried way too hard to become a single when it just never could considering what it's about. None of this stops it from being an amazing track though. It's a very bouncy track. It's all made to be very playful. Because of this no matter how many times I listened to this album this one always makes me a bit uneasy. Just the concept and how lightly it's being treated rubs me the way. The anvil and Moog are so eerie and hang over the track so well. It all feels like a well-done creepypasta in song form.

Oh! Darling is the only track on this album that feels like a throwaway. It's boring, it does nothing interesting. If John sang the vocals he would've been able to make something (pun intended) out of it. But I guess Paul was hellbent on having ripe filler in this album.

Octopus's Garden is an incredible song. Everything is so fine-tuned, it feels perfect without feeling overproduced. The bassline moves everything along nicely, the guitar is frosty, and the piano is playful. The guitar solo is perfect for setting up the song's environment. This is the perfect song for a voice like Ringo has, it's so warm and sing- alongable (?). The lyrics are the best, from the music I've heard, about finding warmth and comfort from the world with sounding existential and chilling.

I Want You is for now my favorite Beatles song. The lyrics themselves don't say much. You have to get most of the context and meaning of what this is by the composition. My interpretation of it is that our protagonist loves this girl very deeply. In the first half of the song the instrumentation between the lyrics are telling us that rather than longing for this girl because of the features she has, or her nice personality, he's longing for her because he needs her as a piece to fix himself. It's an incredibly heavy song the lyrics are meant as they are verbatim, but they're definitely not meant lightly. The line "she's so heavy" means basically that she's important. Which again, doesn't sound like much, but everything around it highlights and bolds it, tries to make you understand. The last line of the song cuts it off at "She's so-" before the outro. The booming proto-metal outro in place of the word "heavy" jams the theme of the song SO far down our throats that it creates this existential whirlpool. The song doesn't even give you the satisfaction of knowing it ends, it just cuts off. This gave us no context of how the story ended, any change or end to what was going on would've implied something.

Here Comes the sun is a nice warm landing from the cold atmosphere of I Want You. It's their most popular song, which I can see why it's optimistic and comforting. My only problem with it is that it's dreadfully boring. Nothing is engaging about it. It's too white. The sound is weirdly isolated despite trying to sound comforting. And if I wanted a comforting and warm song, Octopus's Garden is already here.

Because is a nice separation between everything else in this album and The Long One. It's soft and thoughtful. It's very ghostly. I love the loving nature of the lyrics, they feel very honest and appreciative.

The Long One is the big centerpiece of the album. A bunch of odds and sods fit together to be somewhat coherent. It works for the most part. But I could honestly live without Sun King through Golden Slumbers. Aside from good spirits, those tracks don't offer much. I'd prefer they made a proto-prog epic out of You Never Give Me Your Money, Carry That Weight, and The End.

You Never Give Me Your Money starts The Long One with a nice track about mistrust and their managers (I think). I prefer to think of it as a bunch of off-lines scotch taped together creating some sediment about love or whatever. And it works. Probably not the way most people listen to this track, but I like it more this way, so that's that I guess.

Sun King has affected me in the following ways: it's booooooorrrring. I don't care if you can speak Spanish, get on with it. They even got crickets in this track, they know what they're doing, PUTTING ME TO SLEEP!!!

Mean Mr. Mustard is a bit of a bop I guess, I thank it for introducing me to Mr. Mustard himself. It's a bit too McCartney.

Polythene Pam is much the same case. Pam sounds hot, thanks for telling me about her. The music here is more interesting, it's more power poppy, it's cool. I like that it doesn't overstay its welcome.

She Came In Through The Bathroom Window is much like You Never Give Me Your Money. A collection of pretty cool lines. It doesn't hit me the same way that song did though. The music's dynamics are pretty cool, but nothing to write home about.

Golden Slumbers is a very emotionally driven song. It doesn't mean anything to me in particular. But the lines are powerful, and its sort runtime doesn't force me to think about it that much.

Carry That Weight is amazing. The opening line talks to you directly, telling you to think about whatever awful thing it is that you've done in your life, and to think about them enough to where you never do them again. The horns are triumphant and bring everything home.

The End is just that, the end of the Beatles. It has amazing energy and musicianship that makes you appreciate the Beatles. The final lines "And in the end, the love you take, is equal to the love you make" isn't masterful wordplay or writing, but it's the Beatles and what they stood for, you really couldn't have any better ending to a career than that.

Report this review (#2882342)
Posted Tuesday, February 14, 2023 | Review Permalink
5 stars Review #64!

'Abbey Road' has a place in my heart that if I lost would be forever empty. When I was first finding my musical tastes (not my family's), I reached for The Beatles. I bought almost all of their LSD-era albums on CD, and I still have them all. I fell in love with all of them apart from maybe their self-titled one (don't murder me, please). But since the first listen, 'Abbey Road' had become my God. I deemed it my favorite album for three years. Now it's 'The Dark Side of the Moon', but that's beside the point. What an album! Every song, even if most of them are just glorified filler tracks, is musically and lyrically amazing, from one-minute ditties like 'Mean Mr. Mustard' to the proto-hard-rock 'I Want You(She's So Heavy)'. The album starts with 'Come Together', which needs no introduction. Funky, rocky, groovy, psychedelic. A great track. Next is 'Something', a soft, lush love song that is, naturally, Frank Sinatra's favorite Beatles song. This track (I can't call it that, that name is diminishing) is beautiful and is easily one of the best love songs ever written. It also holds one of the best George Harrison guitar solos ever. 'Maxwell's Silver Hammer' used to be my favorite Beatles song. I love this song! It is so fun and childish, besides the subject matter. Every little nuance benefits the music in the best ways possible, from the steel clanking to the 'woah-oh-woah-oh!' close to the end of the song. Next is 'Oh Darling', a bluesy little track that showcases Paul's vocals perfectly. From the soft main melody to his gritty shouting in the chorus, he shows all types of his singing, and it adds so much spice to the song. 'Octopus's Garden' was written and sung by Ringo Starr (makes sense), and has a goofy childish feel that I compare to 'Yellow Submarine'. This song fails to be fun and serotonin-producing. 'I Want You(She's So Heavy)' is so funky and bluesy. It is my favorite song on this album. It is also the second-longest Beatles song behind 'Revolution 9'. I love the use of a Fender Rhodes. 'Here Comes The Sun' I find to be overplayed and overstated in its beauty, but is still a great track. 'Because' is a kind of dark, beautiful love (what I think is love) song with a sad mood to it. I have always liked this song and is one of my favorites from this album. I love the Fender Rhodes in this track. 'You Never Give Me Your Money' is a nice song about conflicted love (?). Four minutes of pure bliss. The opening 'Sun King is a kind of foreshadowing to 'Get Back'. Then it turns into this pretty harmony that is like a reprise of 'Here Comes The Sun'. This melts into 'Mean Mr. Mustard', which begins the string of one-minute tracks to come. This song is kind of goofy, and I love the lyrics. 'Polythene Pam' is the next one-minuter, and is doubly fun compared to its predecessor. 'She Came In Through The Bathroom Window' is funky and bluesy, like a lot of the other songs on this album. I love this song so much! It is very springy and catchy. It melts into 'Golden SLumbers', easily one of the most beautiful ever written, despite the length. The strings meld beautifully with the bass and drums and vocals and guitar and everything. 'Carry That Weight' is the perfect follow-up. It is so powerful and fun. It holds a reprise of 'You Never Give Me Your Money'. 'The End' is the ending track to this album (not!). It is an okay song, but nothing special. It is pretty fun. After some silence, the hidden 'Her Majesty' plays. This is the shortest studio Beatles song. I have memorized all the lyrics (quite an easy feat). I love this song for a reason I do not know. Short songs just have such a fun atmosphere to them. All together now (pun intended), I love this album. I recommend it to anyone. Anyone! 'Abbey Road' is a wonderful album, for anyone.

Anyone!

Report this review (#2901917)
Posted Sunday, March 26, 2023 | Review Permalink
4 stars This crown jewel is in my TOP 3 Beatles albums and no doubt a favourite one among many classic rock fans. Sounding as a cliche for the Fab Four but they all have reached an astonishing amount of maturity and proved they were still able to be in the leading pack though not being the leader any longer. Lennon did, despite his diminishing interest in the band, provide two passionate numbers - the hard-rocking "Come together" and the jam-like "She's so heavy". The chord sequence in the latter one is powerful. The addition of hammond organ adds a bit of jazzy atmosphere.

McCartney has the strongest and most dominant presence. "Maxwell's silver hammer" is far from the strongest cuts on the album, yet it features moog and a likeable guitar solo. "Oh darling" was underrated by me as I found it a pastiche but later I started the appreciate the incredibly powerful and wide-ranged McCartney's vocal that even Lennon must have been jealous of. McCartney's first two contributions are rather conventional but he compensates it later on the second album's side which is more adventurous, a nice studio work and slightly interesting instrumental coda.

Harrison is an equal contributor with two legendary "Something" and "Here comes the sun", with the first one being one of the best late 60's ballads. Let's highlight Harrison's guitar work be it heavier guitar on "Come together", "She's so heavy" or the wonderful solo on "Something".

"Because" has great vocal harmonies, Beatles still proving they had some top vocals despite cutting down on the number of harmonies after 1966.

Starr is showing improved and updated drumming with a great feeling, hear "Something", "Come together" or "She's so heavy". He come with a number that I consider most mature during his time with the band "Octopus's garden" with the heavy band support.

Abbey Road album has not been matched by any of the solo Beatle output and remains a fascinating legacy of classic rock.

Report this review (#2972753)
Posted Saturday, December 9, 2023 | Review Permalink

THE BEATLES Abbey Road ratings only


chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of THE BEATLES Abbey Road


You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.