EMERSON LAKE & PALMER

Though the sound of Emerson decreased a little while being in ELP (when he was in The Nice was more agressive), the sound of the band was and is always incredible, and this record prove it, their first and with a great stuff... Listen Take a Pebble (is not King Crimson is ELP), The best singing of Greg Lake is all here. Recommended

A rip-roaring great start! "The Barbarian" just makes you sit up and take notice, as do "Tank" and "The Three Fates"! Normally I can't stand a lot of Greg Lakes sappy tunes but "Take A Pebble" is a screaming exception (just needed a liittle editing though).

Could've done without "Lucky Man" though.

As far as I am concerned this one is the most honest and the least bombastic of their records and therefore my personal fave. Such a good album to start with that even ELP started with this one also .

Take A Pebble is fantastic and so are Tank And Barbarian . It is hard to fault those three guys for having left their respective groups - Lake's choice to leave Crimson was disputable but valid and The Nice was a spent force and Atomic Rooster would go on to better things.

Actually , if you can believe it my least fave is Lucky Man as it is relatively out of line with the rest of the album and that long Moog solo does not do much for me.

If you are discovering ELP , this would be the perfect album for an intro and work through their discography chronologically untill..... you feel like it!

Lucky men

A bold statement for a first album, but given the supergroup tag instantly applied to ELP, this was perhaps to be expected.

I love ELP's music, but almost every album includes a track or tracks I don't get. This album is no exception. There are six tracks in all, three on each side of the LP. "The Barbarian" is a great instrumental introduction, pacey, and accessible. "Take a Pebble" is a soft acoustic track with Greg Lake in fine vocal form,, and playing some wonderful acoustic guitar. The track includes a lengthy middle section which drifts into jazz piano, before returning to the main theme for the conclusion. While I have grown to love this track, I've always felt that an edited version without the piano section could sound better. Incidentally, the opening chords are actually played by Keith Emerson who is strumming his piano strings.

"Knife edge" is reminiscent of Atomic Rooster's "Tomorrow night", the closest thing to a single on the album. "The three fates" is for me the Achilles heel of the album. It is a vehicle for displaying Emerson's keyboard prowess, but leaves me completely cold.

"Tank" is a powerful instrumental, but in retrospect the showpiece drum solo was indulgent, and at best far too long. "Tank" and the last track "Lucky man" both featured a unique sound at the time from Emerson's moog synthesiser. It's hard to explain now, just how different the synth solos on these two tracks sounded when the album was released. Even today they send shivers up my spine.

By all accounts, "Lucky man" was a late addition to the album, and did not take long to record. The version of the Synthesiser solo included was the first take. Ironic then that this is arguably the best track on the album.

I have no hesitation in highly recommending the album, but feel free to skip through the odd track (or drum solo!).

Well it's a stunning debut album, characterized by some unforgettable tracks as well as tepid or annoying episodes in the same time..."Lucky Man" as a ballad was a famous hit single, but it's totally out of contest, in comparison for example to the splendid "The Barbarian" or the Fugue inside "Knife Edge" ...instead the mini-suite "Three Fates" is a controversial idea by EMERSON alone and it's not always inspiring from the point of view of its composition, even though his skill is excellent as usual!! Recommended, despite of being essential in some circumstances only..."Tank" is another example of PALMER's great skill, but once again the composition is quite "cold" and academic as well!!

Probably the most important Progressive Rock album ever!!! November 26, 2003 Some would probably suggest that "Days of Future Passed" by The Moody Blues is the first true progressive album. True, it was innovative. Classical, yet mixed with rock. But, that doesn't quite define "Progressive". I think the first progressive rock concept LP has to be "In the Court of the Crimson King", by King Crimson. And I'm sure other countries had their "prog" concept bands beginning around 1969. But what makes Emerson, Lake, and Palmer's debut LP so important is that the three members came from other experimental rock projects. Three individuals, and three individually powerful performers. Three people who could entertain an audience doing a solo performance, not necessarily needing the others to help enhance their performance. Yes, three commanding forces in their own spotlights on the stage before the world to see. Before ELP, the only bands that we knew all the band members by name were really only The Beatles and maybe The Rolling Stones. ELP was the first band to really give us all pre-conceived expectations of what they can do. The first SuperGroup! Who would have thought that all that "ego" could work together without competing with each other, or get in each others way? This first album by ELP was either going to be a super success, or sudden death for the Prog genre! This was an album that sounded like nothing else out there. It was definitely the one first album to shape the future of many Progressive Rock bands throughout the early to mid Seventies. It was the one album that other experimental Prog bands measured their concepts and goals to. The one album all Progressive Rock lovers praised, and, still to this day, cherish. Often imitated, but never equaled by any measure. ELP's first album is what defines what progressive rock truly is. ELP's follow-up albums were unique as well. New ideas always came to ELP. But, new progressive bands were growing all around and were competing with ELP with the concept that they created. And eventually, ELP was just lost in the wash of other Prog bands during that era. But, loyalty always goes to the first, of course. The innovator must never be overlooked. Although other famous Prog bands followed, such as Strawbs, Yes, Pink Floyd, Triumvirat, The Moody Blues, and many others, but Emerson, Lake, and Palmer is the most famous, and most recognized Progressive Rock band in history.

This is their first album. Progressive rock. The songs are rather varied and do not have the same style. The keyboards on "The Barbarian" have the typical TRIUMVIRAT sound. There is also on it electric guitar which I consider rather bland. ELP is not a band to listen for the electric guitar.

Take a pebble is one of the best ELP songs: catchy piano, excellent lead vocals, loud and complex bass, subtle drums parts, the song can be mellow and progressive. "Knife "Edge" has a fully distorted organ sound through keyboards solo. The piano on "Three Fates" is absolutely outstanding: Keith EMERSON is a virtuoso, that's obvious. "Tank" is an instrumental track full of fast bass, drums and keyboards. Unique. There is the mellow pop "Lucky Man" with simple acoustic guitar.

This is an outstanding debut by one of the best prog rock bands of all time. The only question that comes to mind is: What is Licky man doing here? Its a little out of place and messes up the flow of the cd! Otherwise, this is a must buy record! Amazing!

One of the first rides into progressive music, and what a ride!!!! a very complex and emotive record, every piece of music is a masterpiece, the fresh ideas of the early 70's. Hear it is to love it, and loving it is to undestand it, pieces like TANK and THE THREE FATES shows the impressive technique and emotion they as a band had at that time, a must

Gosh.What a music.I'm listening to it now anod I'm impressed. I love jazz and there is so much of it on ELP first album. There is also a bit of King Crimson, especially in vocal part. And this progressive elaboration and lenght. For me it's a obligatory piece for every prog rocker...It's a pity 70s are gone forever.

ELP get up and running with 'The Barbarian' as Carl Palmer ably demonstrates why he won so many drum polls. Then follows the majestic 'Take A Pebble' which has become one of the high points of ELP's music.Keith Emerson's piano work is exceptional ,well beyond the normal boundaries of 'popular music' while Greg Lake sings in his typical laid back style.Perfect. My least favourite track on the album 'Knife Edge' makes good use of Lake's deep baritone but I find the structure flawed and it lacks the usual fluidity I associate with ELP.'Three Fates' is a chance for Emerson to demonstrate his considerable skills and show off he does. Amazing piano and church organ! 'Tank' is very much a chance for Palmer to indulge his love of all things Buddy Rich and Emerson gets to have some fun as well.'Lucky Man' finishes the album on a highpoint with Emerson's powerfull moog solo. Overall this is a solid debut album that falls only marginally short of being a masterpeice.

Dark and mysterious, Emerson Lake & Palmer's debut album is one of the better albums that came out in 1970. Mostly because of Palmer's impressive drumming and Emerson's fantastic keyboard's. Kick's off with "The barbarian", with an agressive gutar opening that sounds like something King Crimson could have done on that time. It's a very good song, although i don't listen to it as much as the other songs. "Take a Pebble" is a long, but very rewarding song by Greg Lake. It's one of the best songs on the album. "Knife Edge" is a very cool song with very cool vocals. Then "The Three Fates" comes. It's probably my favourite song on the album because im a huge fan of Emerson's piano skills. "Tank" features a great drum-solo by Palmer, but uforenately the rest of the song is not much to brag off. "Lucky man" is easily the worst song on the album. It's just stupid and pointless. Anyway, ELP kick's ass with this album, but "Tarkus" is even better! Recommended!

The band who did a surgery in my heart and brain, the band i knew the progressive wolrd. Starting with the ultra fast, energetic and one of my favourites elp songs/versions, "the barbarian", followed by the half acoustic masterpiece "take a pebble", the splendid "knife edge" has a riff that even my mother likes, "the three fates" are organ solos, "tank" is ok, and "lucky man" is the classic greg lake repertoire, a song he did when he was 13, ill try in the next life...

Emerson Lake & Palmer has a lot to say in their first record. 3 very young lads with a speciality each. But one in common: make enough noise to make you believe the're 5. This album stands out in a satisfying way: there's NO signs of fatigue in ANY tracks. No 'Are you ready Eddy?' or 'Crystal Bitches' (stupid name...).

The Barbarian really gives the impression of a drooling bearded viking chasing you around with a rusty axe having the idea of bringing home your limbs as a trophy. One heck of a chase. There's a lot more of acoustic piano on this one; Keith giving his best shot on many tracks like Three Fates and Knife- Edge. Lake is charming us again with a beautiful gift in Take a Pebble. Relaxing, floating, country-style interlude and sets place for a lot of mental travelling, thanks to Greg's clear and magnificent voice. It's like a new King Crimson song in the old 1969 way.

Don't expect grandiose extravangance like Brain Salad Surgery but also no signs of by-products a la Tarkus, making this record the only one like that in their repertoire.

It's more serious, aggressive and challenging and yet, very less entertaining.

Essential - but I wouldn't recommend it...

Although there is much evidence of creativity, an approach full of inspired drama and a wide range of great ideas, there are altogether too many flaws in this album for me to give it the full masterpiece status - which, to be fair, it practically begs for! That in itself is mainly why I do not give it the coveted award - generally the trio try too hard to impress, and not enough to write music of distinction.

"The Barbarian" features Greg using a fuzz box which sounds very much like one I bought many, many moons ago - and was ancient then! Great, retro fuzzy sound, and intriguingly panned across the stereo, but somewhat ponderous.

Keith then demonstrates how to play the organ with boxing gloves... I only jest slightly, for amongst the deliberate dischords, there is evidence of clumsy fingers and slightly poor timekeeping that makes a trained keyboard player such as myself balk somewhat. That said, there is much inventive keyboard work in this track, much of which reminds me of some of the early twentieth century French composers - and fine stuff it is too... except that it's a bit directionless and doesn't really gel into anything much.

It's only when Greg swings the bass back into action with a bit more volulme applied that we are reminded that this track is entitled "The Barbarian". Palmer, of course, keeps things ticking away nicely with sensitive drumming crammed full of suble technical goodies and punctuation - although, on the whole, unremarkable, except for that gong!

On the whole then, an opening designed to grab the listener's attention that does not really sustain it despite the increase in intensity, because of the lack of direction and the keyboard "fluffs".

Moving on to "Take a Pebble", which apparently starts with Keith dragging a plectrum across the strings of a piano. Ineffectually for the opening, he changes to a more delicate motif, then steps around to the proper playing area of the instrument and produces wonderful rippling music of a sublime quality. In the meantime, Greg rolls out some fat root notes and Palmer produces fine, sensitive percussion... and then there are the vocals. I am not keen on this particular style of singing - and even less keen on the lyrics - so will leave it there before I upset the ELP fan base!

Around the 3 minute mark, we get more piano ideas based around the rippling motifs - and, mysteriously, more of the piano string scraping, before an ultra-quiet acoustic guitar led section in a different key. This inexplicably builds to a hand-clap accompanied climax before subsiding again - presumably the idea here is to build a series of "movements", but a little continuity would be nice! Keith has the idea when he re-introduces the rippling piano, but stylistically develops it. One or two fluffs don't mar this section, which drives onwards, maintaining the French style I observed earlier. Palmer picks up a nice jazz rhythm, and Lake wanders coolly around the bass and the music develops naturally and easily for a while, but wanders a little here and there into uncertain territory. There is something of the King Crimson lurking in here - if only I could put my finger on it...

"Knife Edge" is a bit of a mystery to me still - I like the crunchy riffing, and the quiet - loud - quiet - loud construction should resonate with anyone into Nirvana style grunge. Keith shows again why he should take those boxing gloves off, producing solo lines with more fluff than the average rabbit. The direction gets almost completely lost about midway, attempting to draw from Bach, but fortunately it's all pulled back together in a somewhat cacaphonous fashion full of technical tid-bits, and dramatically stirring in many ways - but a little too short of melody for me.

The Three Fates section starts off with Keith donning heavy duty boxing gloves for his duties on the Royal Festival Hall organ, playing pretty much what he likes, with virtually no direction - believe me, I've played church organs, and know only too well the temptation to just pull out all the stops, stomp on the really low pedals and the swell and see what drops out - it all sounds very impressive, so you temper it with some softer noises in between. It only impresses me if someone can produce great music that way - listen to Saint-Seans organ concerto to see what I mean.

Clotho is the youngest of the Three fates - the spinner and daughter of the night (OK, technically one of the oldest godesses in Greek mythology, and daughter of Zeus and Themis, but I digress). I would have expected less Bombast and more "dark", less showing off and more tempered, yet slightly out of control spinning in the music.

However, the piano section that follows is full of Scriabin-like drama tempered with Debussy-esque soft chords and shows that Keith can find his way round a keyboard with both hands - very convincingly. He's also well played (as in the sense of well-read) - hark! Is that Beethoven I hear? After another burst of organ, we get a deliciously dischordant piano riff that builds up with bass and drums into a mesmerising section full of minimalist devices a la Steve Reich, and a peculiar rattlesnake noise coming from Palmer's direction - if only the rest of the album were at this kind of quality!

Lachesis is the apportioner, decider of life duration for mortals, and Atropos the inevitable cuts the thread at the end of your existence so it's more difficult to have a preconceived idea for the music - but this works. Maybe I haven't heard the section beginnings and ends correctly, as this suite is well blended, but no matter - the first goddess is the only one I have issues with (musically...!).

"Tank" features a drum solo. For us non-drummers it's OK on the first couple of listens, but gives me nothing lasting except a desire to skip past this bit every time I listen to this album - which is a trifle unfair on Palmer, as it is an excellent solo. I'm not sure what they were thinking when they wrote the section after the drum solo, as it is stodgy and generally horrible - especially that ridiculous shrieking... Sorry. I have nothing nice to say about this section.

"Lucky Man" rounds off the album with a nice acoustic intro and more of those dodgy lyrics - although we can more easily take these as tongue-in-cheek. A standard kind of verse-singalong chorus structure makes a real contrast from the more progressive music which makes up the rest of the album - replete with FM rock guitar solo, it has to be noted! Pleasant enough, although the keyboard solo at the end is an odd touch... still, proves we have a geniune prog album on our hands - even if it's not a masterpiece!

Worthy addition to your prog collection, but don't expect magic.

This is almost a required album to have. The instrumentals are rich, deep, complex and plentiful. What more do you want from a prog album? The Barbarian has some awesome drumming on it accompanied by very good music. You can almost feel the horses of the Mongols strafeing by you as you dodge their merciless blades. Well named song and proof from the start they are able to effectively paint a picture with music. "The Three Muses" is an excellent composition and shows off the keyboard playing skills this group has. Particularly, "Atropos" the piano trio. It is one of the heaviest piano songs I have heard, being very masculine and jagged. Lucky Man was always one of my favorite songs on the radio. The term 'lucky man' is first used in the song as a statement of envy but later as the 'lucky man' is called to war and is killed the statement, 'lucky man', morphs to sarcasam. You will find as you listen to their albums that in a few ways they are kind of morose. Which in my opinion is delightful and refreshing. Screw "Peace dude" how about saying "People are dying for a pointless cause, fell happy now?" it's a little more direct and snags upon the ugly truth of conflict a little better in my opinion. This is a great song on a great album. I would have given it 4.5 stars.

An impressive first album from this trio, demonstrating a confidence and maturity that is, on reflection, not surprising given the previous experience of the band members. Listening to this album in the early 1970s it was not difficult to believe this band was destined to go far.

'The Barbarian' is the trio's heavy interpretation of Bartók's "Allegro Barbaro", which is itself sombre and 'barbaric' in feel. Emerson's piano and synthesizer playing really brings out the almost demonic feel of the piece, and Palmer's skill is also evident almost from the first bar. Quite an ambitious opener for a first album - the band clearly wanted to start with a bang.

'Take A Pebble' starts with piano and the strumming of piano strings, and bass, introducing the rich timbre of Lake's voice, which is pleasing. He does not sing for long before the piece turns instrumental, with some very good piano and percussion from Emerson and Palmer. The instrumental then continues with acoustic guitar that, oddly (at least to me), sounds more like something one would hear in the Appalachians than from a progressive rock band. It's certainly very laid-back and pleasing, but I'm not sure this section of acoustic guitar fits particularly well into the piece as a whole. Then Emerson comes back in with piano - again very good - and the piece feels as if it's back on track. Palmer jumps in a bit later and the piece almost starts to feel like barroom jazz. There's a pause in the track and the piano then returns to reintroduce Lake's singing for a short while to complete the twelve-and-a-half minute track.

'Knife-Edge' is the trio's interpretation of the first movement (Allegretto, Allegro, Maestoso) of Janáček's Sinfonietta for orchestra, Opus 60, but with the addition of Lake's singing. As with 'The Barbarian', this interpretation of a classical piece also works well. Emerson's keyboard sounds like a church organ, albeit a very funky one. This track is also heavy in places, but a real 'foot-tapper' (or should that be 'head banger'?), and the lyrics are manic and dark. Again I've got to say that Palmer's drumming is noticeably very good.

'The Three Fates' (the goddesses Clotho, Lachesis and Atropos from Greek mythology) starts with 'Clotho': Emerson playing the Royal Festival Hall's organ, which is such an impressive, deep, ecclesiastical sounding organ with rich reverberation. Then piano replaces the organ for 'Lachesis' - very classically inspired piano - that is very pleasing indeed if, like me, you are a big fan of the piano. Part of this sounds a little Rachmaninov-like when Emerson speeds up (not that I'm comparing Emerson to the great Rachmaninov). 'Atropos' is a piano trio in which Palmer backs Emerson with some good and varied percussion. Again there is a slight jazzy feel to this. Actually, it also makes me think of some of the music in West Side Story, so perhaps it has a hint of the Latin to it.

And then comes my favourite track of the album, 'Tank'. The clavichord-sounding synthesizer (or maybe it's a real clavichord or harpsichord?) sounds excellent, and the track fairly scuttles along until Palmer gives a two-minute solo that again shows this drummer's skill. And when the solo ends with the synthesized swishing from speaker to speaker and the marching, fat synthesizer with pounding drumbeat and high-pitched synthesizer dancing over the top almost like a flute, it's the absolute business. You could easily picture a formidable army marching relentlessly forward to this.

The last track, 'Lucky Man', is a ballad by Lake with acoustic guitar leading and ironic lyrics. Although the song has a simple structure and the lyrics might be considered slightly pretentious, the tune and chorus are pleasing, and this is something to which I find myself humming or whistling along. Emerson's Moog synthesizer 'pyrotechnics' come in towards the end and the piece ends with just that and Palmer's drums.

Well, what more can be said? The album is not a masterpiece although it is certainly a showcase for the playing skills of Emerson and Palmer, although less of a chance for Lake to shine than on their later albums. Emerson always borrowed heavily, and here a third of the tracks are the band's interpretations of pieces by classical composers. If you listen to the original pieces you'll see that the interpretations are actually quite close to the originals (and you'll also hear how good the originals are!), but at least the band has given them a good twist. To me, though, 'Tank' is the best track on this album (and much better than the version on "Works, Volume 1", but that's another story). Nevertheless, all of the tracks are good, and all three musicians produced an album that I still listen to some thirty years later, which says something.

Excellent album ELP debut consists of important suites as "the barbarian" and "Take to pebble" and the great madness in "tank" and its commercial exito but "lucky man" that sometimes I think that I get to leave this progressive line very similar to consideraria "Triumvirat" not it a copy but but they are contemporaneos well.

A landmark in rock music as a listening experince. It is a shame that the band, at least on the early issues, claimed credit for composing music written by other people. The Barbarian is in fact Allegro Barbaro by Bartok, and Knife Edge is the Sinfonietta by Janacek. That said the Barbarian is a fantastically exciting piece of rock music.

Take a pebble shows Lake singing at his best and Emerson playing the piano with the subtlest of touches. Knife Edge is a great example of Lake's "mean and nasty" edgy vocal style.

The Three Fates are something really different, especially the third one, made famous as a jingle by Alan Freeman. Tank swings along brilliantly towards Palmer's drum solo, his definitive studio work. Lucky Man is very popular with everyone and much easier to listen to than the rest of the pieces on the album.

This album was never surpassed by ELP, in terms of pure music that grabs you by the ears and transports you to another place.

I consider this album so brilliant that i got it on vynil to try to inspire myself with the original sound. Consider this, every song in it can perfectly match with any collectioin of 80´s and 90´s songs, specially "take a pebble", i can listen this subtly peaceful song after Dream Theater and still go on my life!

What an excellent debut for this pioneer of prog rock supergroups! The talents of Emerson, Lake & Palmer are fluidly combined with their enthusiasm for this new project they were undertaking. Emerson basically continued to explore into his diverse musical interests (jazz, classical, rock, psychedelia) while assuming a prominent leading role; Lake felt much comfortable with the new band's melodic drive, while keeping a hard edge in a large amount of his bass parts; and Palmer, who was already a young veteran in the rock-blues scene, had and took the chance to expand his artistic vision and develop it with a clear disposition for pomposity. ELP's eponymous debut album was also one of the first ones to feature the Moog stuff in a rock context, a synthesizer that Emerson has already begun to experiment with during his last days with his Nice partners. Every single piece contained in this repertoire is great; as a whole, the selection showcases varied ambiences that result from the threesome's different individual interests converging into a unique, solid offering. The only minus point is a certain lack of cohesiveness in the repertoire, as a whole: there is no chaos here, and the listener can tell that the band members have a clear direction set in their minds, but I feel that the inner consistency is not totally achieved. This factor will soon be resolved properly in some of their following albums, which are absolute prog classics, indeed. Anyway, let's take a quick look at the repertoire itself. 'The Barbarian' starts with a wicked bass guitar riff by Lake, as a herald that briefly announces the storm of Hammond chord progressions delivered by Emerson: during the Dixieland-oriented interlude and the reprise of the initial motif, the trio sounds very tight and confident. 'Take a Pebble' shows a gentler side of ELP's music. Having been conceived as an acoustic ballad by Lake, Emerson takes it to a more sophisticated level, flirting with free jazz and Gershwin, while Palmer sustains his partners' performances with both sensibility and delicate precision. This song lasts 12 minutes, and it's definitely quite pretentious, but it's not overwhelming in its pretentiousness, mainly because the sense of reflectiveness that remains consistent from beginning to end helps the trio build a complicity with the listener: Emerson's piano passages that meander like a flowing stream, and Lake's country-inspired acoustic guitar solo are relevant for this matter. Then comes 'Knife Edge', a track that is quite paradigmatic of the ELP most habitual power-trio sound: aggressiveness and exquisiteness, both fused into one sonic source. 'The Three Fates' is a showcase for Emerson's virtuosity and passion: it displays its successive motifs on pipe organ, grand piano, and a Latin jazz oriented piano trio that closes down the track with a rough explosion. The exhibition of power and pomposity doesn't end, since 'Tank' serves as a vehicle for Palmer's exhibitionism: the jazz section and the bluesy section are intertwined by an effective solo (which includes some of Palmer's signature double gong banging). Thought less articulated than the previous tour-de-force, this one is much catchier, indeed. And then, as a closure, the unexpected hit single - 'Lucky Man'. Penned a few years ago by a teenager Lake who by then only dreamt about becoming a rock star, this is basically an acoustic ballad with a simple structure, with a conventional country-based electric guitar solo in the middle. But it is Palmer's precise drumming, Lake's occasional multi-layered vocal harmonies, and last but not least, Emerson's outstanding Moog solo in the final section, that take this track to a higher level. The sober beauty of the original idea is enhanced in a most superb manner: a great closure, indeed. As I stated before, the fact that the repertoire in itself is not entirely cohesive, keeps this record from deserving the perfect rating, but it comes close: and more importantly, it is a prelude of better things to come in the following three years.

What a great debut! Emerson is not just a great keyboard virtuoso but also a knowledgeable composer. His skill in harmony and theme developement is undeniable. Also remarkable are his smooth transitions between composed and jazzier improvised parts. This is just the essence of prog rock - breaking style barriers in an artful way! The skill of the other two members is debatable. I think Lake is a decent vocalist and bass player. The problem with most people seems to be Palmer. He may not be the most accurate drummer but he has the chops that fit the music well. ELP's debut album is very diverse with a lot of dynamics.

The first track "Barbarian" is a reference to a energetic work by the classical composer Bela Bartok. If you want to like ELP you have to like classical music. It's so much presented in their style.

"Take a Pebble" is one of the best prog songs with piano. It's more lyrical in mood. The band finds expression in interplay and Lake's voice is very captivating. Lakes acoustic guitar solo isn't the same class as Howe for example but it adds to the dynamics with it's quiet tone. As a pianist I find Emerson's piano parts outstanding! The playing is virtuosic but unpretentious and concentrated in creating an atmosphere. I wish ELP had gone more in this direction.

"Knife Edge" is a good proof that a band without a guitarist can really rock. The riffs are quite heavy. Suprisingly the song is based on Janacek's Sinfonietta. But what's happening in the middle? A Bach's suite quotation. An intertaining move. Great Hammond playing here. The only bad thing is that their quotations on this album aren't credited.

"The Three Fates" is the Emerson's instrumental showcase. These sophisticated and complex compositions lean towards classical music and display high lelvel of musicianship. At first this three-part composition may sound self-indulgent and bombastic but I think it is not the case. It's just an elaborate piece of music. It focuses my attention up to the end.

"Tank" is the only weak track. The intro and the end didn't really grab me and the drum solo in the middle is a bore. Too much of plain bombast for me.

"Lucky Man" was a hit single but it's by no means cheezy. ELP lacked back vocals and Lake was dubbed to get the vocal harmonies. Lake's lyrics are about absurdity of war. A nice ballad with a folky melody and a Moog solo at the end.

This is maybe my favorite ELP album. It's more consistent and has less sheer bombast than their later stuff. It's a good starting place and it deserves 5 stars. As I said before, you have to like classical keyboard music from baroque to 20th century to fully appreciate ELP. This elements are not only in their classical qutations but also in their original style. There are also some jazzy moments. If you regard prominent keyboards and don't mind the lack of guitar you should try this album!

This one is for Karnevil 9, i hope he reads it. After some ELP bashing and being told not to listen to them by my friends i thought i would see what all the fuss was about. I only know about this bands sound and career from things i have read on this site, so i wasn't completely sure what to expect.

I certainly didn't expect that lush distorted droning sound to kick off the album, that is really nice. There is some strong drum work here but i think it is ruined by some very over dramatic piano work, but i managed to sit through it, once the piano bit is over there is a lush roar that sounds likea dragon waking up and then some more distortion which sounds kinda heavy and evil! Definetly a good start, i am actually impressed by "The Barbarian". The bass and drum work is very well done!

The vocals on "Take a Pebble" are pretty nice, somehow it sounds like a very unique sound that ELP have created very nicely here, and Greg Lake uses a different vocal style to King Crimson which is good because it is the start of a brand new sound and prog direction for each member, quite a big leap for a debut album, they have definetly kissed their previous bands goodbye! The piano work is a lot softer here, with some nice acoustics, which i prefer. I can't remember the last time i heard clapping and whistling in prog, how random, but it's here! The soft sound seems to lack direction, going through different acoustic and piano areas before it settles into a beautiful piano section. The thundering bass kicks in and all sounds good. This track can stretch on quite a bit, but i say, so far so good! There is a nice piano climax just before the 11 minute mark that leads back into some vocals, bringing this track to a brilliant close. The vocals are powerful and full of passion and emotion.

"Knife Edge" has some really strong bass and keyboard work, perhaps a sound that i prefer. It can get quite frantic and then flow into more steady parts. The vocals work really well once again. The musicianship here is definetly strong and powerful, sometimes it can be scarily overdone, i prefer them in their less pretentious areas.

The first three songs are excellent, but "Three Fates", the track that a very popular forum member is named after, let me down. This track is nothing but Keith Emerson making love to his keyboards for nearly 8 minutes. Sure he has talent but he is just showing off here, and it becomes boring. I managed to sit through this though, it gets interesting when the organ comes in but then it leads back into the same old drizzle. There is a really annoying sound, like someone is winding up a clock which quickly gets repetitive and irritating. I would suggest listening to this one or two times, if it still doesn't do anything for you then the skip button is all you need!

"Tank" doesn't do it for me either, another let down, this is just some mindless drum work, followed by some uninterting tag ons from the rest of the band. ELP really overdo it here. "Lucky Man" definetly redeems this album with some nice vocals and acoustic work, yet it has a stupid ending which sounds like you are being chased by an ambulance or something!

ELP are definetly talented as well as unique and original. Sometimes they can really overdo it and dont know when to calm down but at the end of the day this is definetly some strong, good and interesting work. Still, i can see why a lot of people make fun out of them! Overall, their are 4 really good pieces on this album, yet it is let down big time by "Three Fates" and "Tank". I think this album just scrapes 4 stars.

Take A Pebble is an emerald in the sea... This album is fantastic, I'm sure about it. The voice of Lake, the piano of Emerson and the rythms of Palmer made an album simply great, I think it's hard to criticate these songs, made of glass and diamonds... I think it's good to start exploring ELP world. Maybe not a masterpiece, but necessary.

This is a great debut album by any standard, but these guys were already experienced so its not such a surprise really! The difference that Lake and Palmer make to Emerson makes the sound streets ahead of anything that the Nice did. The opener, Barbarian, starts procedings and is a quasi classical piece with a jazzy interlude. Take a pebble is a beautiful song with an extended piano section. Knife Edge is a good enough tune, but I've tired of it a little now. Side 2 opens with The Three Fates which is basically another Emerson workout, followed by Tank when its Palmers turn. I love Tank, always did, and I love the drum solo, from then on the drums were the instrument for me. Tank fails for me when the music returns after the solo, its a bit weak and weedy! Luck Man brings up the rear and its as fine a Lake song there is, complete with debut Moog solo at the end, which I guess is a spine tingle moment for most ELP fans.

To start with, I feel this is really one of the first real workings of a moog. The classical intertwining really gave a lot of bands influence. including YES.

To sum a few things up, The different tracks are all wonderful.

Lucky Man-would be a lot nicer if it wasn't the only thing played on the radio for the most part by them...

The one that I would really like to touch on is-----TANK

TANK- Is On Broadway-with the demented wind that swirls around time square added in... Listen to the two of them one than next. Kinda like an apacolyptic New York. the drum solo was probably the only place on the album for it to be placed for any possable functioning. The second half...Is the basis for Tarkus, and Abbadon's Bolero... The Mythology of the Manticore.. Head of a Lion, body of a dog, hair of a porcupine, and a tale of a scorpion. It was to hunt man by mesmerizing him with the combined sound of a flute and a horn. the later half deffenitly resembles this with its boelero march...

If there is sheet music out there for this I would love to find it...

Emerson, Lake & Palmer began their album career with this album. It begins and ends great. You get all the classic ELP elements tossed together and made into a mix that cannot be replicated. The album opens with The Barbarian, and it has easily one of the greatest intoductions I have ever heard, the distorted bass gives a great intro into truly one of the best Instrumentals in Progressive Rock. What you also get with this album is Keith Emerson playing his over zealous, incredibly intricate organ lines, making the feeling that he plays with Boxing Gloves. The next track, Take a Pebble, has all the elements of progressive gold, intricate bass, clever and catchy piano, intuitive and subtle drumming, and a great acoustic break. Knife Edge also carries on the same greatness that Take a Pebble has, great overall playing. The Three Fates is a Keith Emerson Keyboard solo that takes form in three types, Organ, Grand Piano, and what he calls a "Piano Trio". Tank is a Carl Palmer drum solo that is in the same vein as "Moby Dick" by Led Zeppelin and "Toad" by Cream. It begins with the entire group playing intricate lines, then the drums take the forefront and Carl Palmer shows everybody why he is considered one of the best drummers around. The album closer is often considered one of the best ELP songs around. Lucky Man has very tasteful guitar, and some very well written lyrics. The only gripe I have with it is Keith Emerson's solos, they just don't fit with the acoustics. And Carl Palmer's drumming is a little sloppy when he comes out of the drum fills. Overall, this album is a great debut. I recommend it highly.

What a debut! This is a really strong showing. The talent of all the members really is shown here. Palmer's drumming (esp. on Tank) is maddening. Emerson's playing is, as always, spectacular. Also, Lake has one of the best voices in all of music. The songs are all coherent and go well together. Personnal favorites include The Barbarian, Knife's Edge, and the aforementioned Tank. Knife's Edge is particularly great. Such passion is used in Greg's singing, and the bands performance. Truely a great piece of music. There are, however, a few moments that keep this album from being five stars. For example, The Three Fates. Parts of this song are dull and unexciting. Also, the second "part" of Take A Pebble. I find this to be uninspiered, and it drags the song down. Despite these moments, this is really a solid album. Less pretenous than the rest of catelogue and not to be overlooked.

In the mid-Seventies it took a while before I started to appreciate the sumptuous progrock from ELP. It's also totally different from the music from Genesis that I appreciated in the Seventies. But gradually I got into the virtuosic progrock and Keith Emerson, the 'Jimi Hendrix of the progressive rock', became one of my progrock heroes. His keyboardplay is so impressive, on this album I like the church-organ sound, the sparkling piano-runs, the fat Moog sound, what a stunning sound and what a sensation it must have been to hear this music in those days! The interplay between the three musicians is breathtaking ("Take a pebble" and "Knife edge" are timeless masterpieces) although Carl Palmer is not my favorite drummer, a matter of taste. Very special was the mellow song "Lucky man" because of the melancholic climate, the warm vocals from Greg Lake and the spectacular finale, based upon a perfectly build-up Moog synthesizer solo, even inventor Bob Moog was highly impressed! ESSENTIAL!!

This is a true masterpiece debut album! I like the more aggressive and artistic symphonic material which this band managed to create, but sadly many of their albums don't reach their full potential they could have managed to do. Luckily their fist album does it. The opener "The Barbarian" has quite cool fuzz bass on it, and it's a transition of BELA BARTÓK's piece. The following "Take A Pebble" is one of the most perfect progressive ballads. It's long, full of acoustic musical solo scores, which drift pleasantly from an idea to another like a summer day's dream. "Knife-Edge" brings back the violent moods with raw sounds, good riffs and fine rhythms. Two next numbers are solo scores, "The Three Fates" is for Keith and "Tank" for Carl. The drum solo is a difficult task, and this isn't very exiting, but OK performance still. "Lucky Man" is then Greg's composition, an acoustic ballad with weird synthesizers. As a total, these tracks create a real classic album!

The style is principality semi-officially with the works of The Nice, Procol Harum or Moody established Blues and definitively at the end of the 60 and beginnings of the 70 by bands like King Crimson, Jethro Tull, Yes or ELP, that made debut with this disc, one of most popular of the terceto. In "The Barbarian", they mix of dynamic way shining and hard rock with the "Barbaro Allegro" of the Hungarian composer Bela Bartok. Initiated the piece with one fuzz to guitar the development is a main vehicle for the abilities in the organ and the piano of Keith Emerson, also emphasizing the sinewy work in the battery of Palmer. "Take to Pebble" is an extensive and melodic composition of Greg Lake, that demonstrates that it has an excellent voice. Ductile song of varied tempos, rich in atmósferica creation, contains calmed passages of acoustic guitar, with even some wink to country-folk, and anxious pianos of tendencies jazz. "Knife Edge" is a subject hard progressive rock with some tempo which they could fit in the disc debut of Black Sabbath (published the same year) and influences classic of the "Sinfonietta" of Leos Janacek. "Three Fates", piece divided in three parts, "Clothos", "Lachesis" and "Athropos", it seems to fuse the rock, with Miklos Rosza and Johann Sebastian Bach, with Emerson demonstrating that an expert in the keyboards is everything and that if he goes of expert he can arrive to become instrumental onanista and to end up boring like in this occasion. "Tank", an also somewhat indulgente subject, is outstanding by the use of the sintetizadores (all a newness at the moment with the use given by Emerson in the compositions of the group) and the single one of battery of Carl Palmer, great an instrumentalist one infravalued enough who demonstrates that he could compete with anyone in the cleaning rods. The most commercial song of the album, very indebted of the time at which it was recorded, is the one that closes the same one, "Lucky Man". ELP forget complexities and compose a most beautiful acoustic ballad of medieval nature that exhibits the remarkable melódica capacity of Lake, precious vocal harmonies and a single one of Moog on the part of Emerson that caused enough impact at its moment. A sometimes shining disc, other pomposo and autocomplaciente, but significant of the style and the time at which it was recorded. That yes, the people who only feed themselves on hardcore, punk, metal, hip hop or teen pop, better than she does not approach nor of distant spot his sound. To go to the biography of Emerson, Lake & Palmer

It is hard to say something new after so many reviews. This is good debut of the power prog trio, with highlights including "Take a Pebble", "Lucky Man" and "Barbarian". It still sounds fresh when listening today because the excesses of Keith Emerson are minimal here and Greg Lake is in full condition after leaving KING CRIMSON. Recommended even to those who don't like ELP.

Incredible album which I would have tagged as a five-star masterpiece if it wasn't for one track. The album starts off with "The Barbarian", a dark and brooding piece of instrumental rock that kicks off the disc with gusto. Track two, "Take A Pebble" to me is their "Moonchild". A song that starts off very nicely with Greg Lake's beautiful voice and acoustic guitar but drifts into nothingness before returning to the beginning. Being the longest track on the album, it's just streched out for no reason, (did we really need to hear hand clapping?). Ahh, but the next track, "Knife-Edge" is classic ELP. Heavy organ and bass and singing from Greg from the netherworld. It rocks! A perfect prog song to blast from your car speakers with the windows down. How about that synthesizer bridge two minutes in. Awesome! A bonafide classic 5 minute prog song. "The Three Fates" is a showcase for Keith starting with the organ in part one, then the piano (I enjoy his piano work more than his organ), then the band joins in for part three. "Tank" is an excellent instrumental which showcases Palmer's drum playing. Very nice. Finally, the hit "Lucky Man" which includes, if you ask me, the most famous Moog solo/fade out in rock history. I'm not the biggest ELP fan, but you must admit after listening to this album that it's a fantastic first album with their best still to come. 3.75/4 stars

I think that there are a lot of people who recommend "Tarkus" and "Brain Salad Surgery" for the highest masterpiece as for ELP. However, their 1st albums "Emerson,Lake and Palmer" are great boards. I love "Take A Pebble" and "Lucky Man". This expression of feelings music is extraordinary and wonderful.

Emerson, Lake & Palmer were progressive rock's first 'super group', and their first album historically is a must have for prog rock fans. Musically, its merit is a bit more dubious. This album is enjoyable, but really just sets the table for ELP's much better works over the next three years. EMERSON LAKE & PALMER is mostly instrumental, and showcases Keith Emerson's brilliant keyboards playing. This is very much a heavy Organ and Drums affair, even flirting with hard rock, but Greg Lake manages to add enough soft touches to save this from being solely a Hammond Organ album. The album was an instant success, hitting number #4 in the UK and #18 in America (quite a feat, riding on the successful single Lucky Man).

The album opens with an ominous tone, with "The Barbarian". This song features mainly the distorted (fuzzbox) organ of Emerson with some good drumming and excellent Bass lines from Lake. This piece is an (initially uncredited) adaptation of a composition by Romanian composer Bartok, and is an ambitious opening for the group. It is a very good dark instrumental in which each member shines and they really lay out their vision for the band. The next track is somewhat weaker. "Take a Pebble" starts off with rippling piano chords by Emerson and delicate percussion setting a soft but surreal mood. Greg Lake's voice enters the track, with typical pretentious ELP lyrical nonsense. It sounds good though. After the vocals we get some more piano, which is very good, but after this the piece deteriorates rapidly. This is ELP's first real 'Suite', and they have not yet mastered transitions between sections, so this piece comes of as rather disjointed, awkward and clumsy. It alternates between jazz piano from Emerson, too bizarre acoustic guitar and hand clapping. This goes on for a bit, and the music just kind of wonders with no real direction (reminiscent of KC another reviewer pointed out). It eventually closes out with the initial vocal melody full of typical ELP bombast. This is a very weak track in need of serious editing, and was utilized much better in the form of a medley with other more acoustic ballads. Luckily the next track an ELP classic, "Knife Edge", which adapts Janacek's Sinfonietta for Orchestra, Opus 60. This piece is similar to "The Barbarian", but is much more successful, featuring great vocals and decent lyrics from Lake. The piece even has a Fugue for piano in the middle, a real highlight. The repetition of the organ melody is excellent, coming directly after Lake's vocals. The next track is the worst, in my opinion, on the album. "three Fates" is really nothing more than a pure showcase for Emerson on piano and church organ. This piece technically is excellent but is completely devoid of emotion, and comes off as a rather good demonstration of talent, but not compositional skill. It plods along, but never picks up steam. The album closes strongly with two excellent tracks. "Tank" serves as Carl Palmer's showcases, and features on of the few drum solos on a studio album that works, and does not come off as overly indulgent. This is also the first real appearance of Keith Emerson's famed Moog work, which would have a much more prominent role in later albums. It sounds a bit dated now, but must have been spectacular in 1970. The album ends with the Lake ballad, "Lucky Man", a song Greg Lake wrote when he was 12. The song was included as filler, and surprisingly became ELP's first hit. It received decent airplay in the US. It is similar to much of Lake's other acoustic work, and features an excellent Moog solo by Emerson, taken in one take. The lyrics are some of the best Lake has written, telling the story of a warrior who lives an excellent life, and then dies. The story comes off as rather silly here, but is excecuted quite well, and makes a fitting end to the album.

While ELP's 1970 debut is weaker than some of their other material, it is an incredibly brave, progressive and successful debut album, showcasing the collective talents of each member, who really were the cream of the crop. This album is highly recommended for historical significance to prog. It is also recommended to those who want the grit and talent of ELP without dealing with an abundance of synthesizers and pretension. 4 STARS.

In my opinion, ELP's the only flawless album and the only five-star album. And a great masterpiece of progressive rock! Hard to believe in it since this is the opening album. "ELP" is much more impressive than any other opening album by any other famous band. I think YES and BANCO also had great openers too (titled, just like "ELP", after the names of the bands) but ELP's opener sounds mature. You don't get the feeling that the musicians are trying new ground or ony learning to play. Every track is memorable, every musician's performance is exemplary. Lake's voice of this period is one of the most beatiful voices in prog. Emerson is a virtuoso of composing, feeling and technique (ins't it he who is regarded the main composer for ELP?). Palmer is a fantastic , very technical drummer.

When I just bought "ELP" I immediately fell for 'Take a Pebble' and 'Lucky Man'. When Lake sings "Then watch the ripples ... " I get a goose skin. In fact, the effect is close to that produced by the four famous notes from 'Shine On You Crazy Diamond'. Now, after a few months of listening to the album, I also like the first track, 'The Barbarian', very much. I am sure no matter what your tastes are, you should include "ELP" in hundred best prog albums of all time!

A masterpiece. Words can't describe the perfection in this piece of art. Absolutely the greatest prog rock album ever. Many ELP fans pick Brain Salad Surgery over this but there's just something about this album that draws me in. A lot of prog fans don't like Lucky Man but as a Classic Rock fan I like it fine. I do understand them not wanting it on the album it was a little strange, but I liked it. I don't think anyone can ever top ELP in their debut album. One of the things about this album is it's their first. Words are not enough for this album.

4.5 Stars

The first and their best album. Here it sounds fresh and very progressive while the following albums, it sounds like more of the same (except the groundbreaking Tarkus). Keith Emerson is easily one of the best keyboardists ever to exist, Greg Lake is a great singer/bass player and can play some mean guitar, and Carl Drummer is one of the best Drummers to exist. The problem with the band is that they are not good songwriters at all.

BARBARIAN (9/10) kicks off the album with a very good start .. it is a very hard rocker dominated by brilliant hammond organ playing all over the song, it is followed by TAKE A PEBBLE (8.5/10) which starts with one of the most gorgeous vocal performances ever, and is followed by a good ELP jam. KNIFE EDGE (8.5/10) is an ELP classic, and it contains a songwriting style that reminds me of Black Dog (Zeppelin) .. all musicians shine here. The next song is "THREE FATES" (8/10) which is a good showcase of Emerson's talents, then CArl Palmer shows his talents in TANK (8.5/10) which is an ELP jam with old synths and a drum solo. The album ends with easily the best song of the album LUCKY MAN (9/10) which is a perfect pop song with one of the most exciting moog solos to ever appear on a record. It is also the first moog solo to ever appear on a record, making this song legendary.

I highly recommend this album for anyone, yet it is no masterpiece.

My Grade : A/B

A debut album from one of legendary progressive rock heroes. Greg Lake who was previously a bass player and singer for another legendary band King Crimson finally accepted Keith Emerson (ex The Nice) to form a new band. These two gentlemen met in San Francisco backstage at a show featuring both The Nice and King Crimson. During that meeting they did a lot of talking and followed-up their ideas when they came back to England. [1]. The early formation of ELP happened at the same time when King Crimson's recording of second album "In The Wake of Poseidon" at the Wessex Studios. When ELP finally got into gear, Lake did not return to Wessex Studios which left one track - the ballad "Cadence and Cascade" - without a vocal. For this Fripp contacted Gordon Haskell, hisl old schoolfriend who had no particular liking of Crimson's music but for a session fee of £50 was happy to come to Wessex and sing. [2]. Indeed, King Crimson's leader and guitarist Robert Fripp never considered Greg Lake as bass player. He's wrong as we know that Lake plays excellent bass guitar with ELP.

Carl Palmer became a member of The Crazy World of Arthur Brown at the peak of their popularity. Returning from an 18-month American tour, Carl and Crazy World organist Vincent Crane split to form Atomic Rooster. Musically akin to The Nice, Atomic Rooster was Palmer's first real success as a band founder, and it took some persuading from Greg to convince 20-year-old Carl to leave the band and cement the ELP lineup in 1970. And . JRENG! Finally, what would later be a famous band was formed! And their debut album Emerson Lake and Palmer took the music industry by the storm.

This album features six tracks including a song adapted from Bela Bartok's "Allegro Barbaro" (The Barbarian) and another song adapted from Janacek's "Sinfonletta" (Knife- Edge). The album starts off with a distorted music which brings Keith Emerson's dazzling organ / synthesizer combined with dynamic drum by Carl and bass by Greg. It continues to Greg's nice ballad "Take A Pebble" which features great piano work by Keith and melodic vocal line by Greg - reminiscent his style with King Crimson's "Epitaph". What comes after is a kind like improvisation music blending Keith rapid-fire piano work, Greg inventive bass playing and Carl drumming (mostly with high hats and toms). The long interlude part explores the piano solo nicely. "Knife-Edge" - which later became an ELP staple - continues with accentuated voice line, dynamic bass line combined with organ and drum.

"The Three Fates" that contains three parts starts with a long sustain and multi layer organ solo with some classical music influence (Royal Festival Hall Organ). It continues with piano solo, broken down into two parts. This track is explorative in nature, written by Keith Emerson. "Tank" is another legendary track ELP has ever produced; containing Carl Palmer's excellent drum solo. The album concludes with a simple ballad written by Greg Lake "Lucky Man".

It's a promising debut album that proved to be the hallmark of ELP's subsequent follow- ups" "Tarkus", "Pictures At An Exhibition", "Trilogy", "Brain Salad Surgery". It's a must for any prog music lover. Keep on proggin' ..!

Peace on earth and mercy mild - GW

References: [1]. "The Return of The Manticore" ELP box set sleeve [2]. "In The Court of King Crimson", Sid Smith, Helter Skelter Publishing, 2003.

A monstrous achievement, so far above anything Emerson did with the Nice it can't come as anything but a revelation. The dated psychedelic predilections and silly joke songs of the Nice were long gone. Moog synthesizer was in and, for 1970, this must have sounded very fresh and modern. This was not the first rock album to use a Moog, but it was probably the first one to really integrate it as a rock & roll instrument, as opposed to a mere sound effect or gimmick. The fire it brings to "Knife-Edge" and "Tank" is undeniable, and the textures on "Lucky Man" are, of course, the stuff of legend.

But the Moog is not over-used. Emerson is still all about the Hammond, and applies what he learned in the Nice to stunning effect on "The Barbarian" and the aforementioned "Knife-Edge". He gets the opportunity to lavish some absolutely heavenly piano work on Lake's feature-length ballad "Take A Pebble".

Most of the album sounds as though it could have been recorded live; the exception being "The Three Fates", which opens with a pipe organ solo and closes with Emerson playing three pianos at once, thanks to the magic of multi-track recording. There's even some Hohner Clavinet on "Tank". In all, this is practically an aural reference book for prog-rock keyboard players.

Easily the peak of Emerson's career as a keyboardist and ELP's as a group simultaneously. For once in their life, the mating of rock and the classics seemed like a vital thing, rather than the campy kitsch it became on ensuing attempts. I think song selection (pieces by Bartók and Janacek) has a lot to do with that. Choosing pieces that work well as rock songs as opposed to, "Recognize this piece? Ha ha, aren't we clever!"

The most underrated ELP album for me, and also the best. Plays to all of the band's strengths and none of its weaknesses (I'll be kind this time and turn a blind eye to the drum solo in "Tank"). They'd never be so consistently inspired again.

This is one that grows on you, I think. Although none of the songs are actually bad, there are some mildly boring parts in some of them.

The albums starts off with the Barbarian, a heavy prog instrumental and rousing opener featuring heavy bass/guitar and some dissonant sounding hammond from Emerson. From the sounds the band makes you actually see in your head a barbarian running around doing barbarian type things. It rocks for about a minute and a half, then goes into some cool piano for a while, until it roars back into the original theme and ends on a frantic sounding note. All in all, an awesome song

Take a Pebble is great when there is singing, and some of the instrumental breaks are good, like the first piano one and the acoustic guitar one, but after a while it can get a little boring. This song is pretty good.

Knife Edge is another rocking song to feature the hammond, and it features one great melody, although it is more of a typical rock type melody, although ELP makes it work for them. Also, the rocking ending with Lake singing over the hammond is spinetingling-ly good. This song is great.

Three Fates is one of those long mostly keyboard only instrumentals. While being slightly boring, it has some cool ideas in it. The church organ beginning is cool, and the first piano part is also neat. The second piano part is alright too, but this song can get a little boring because it drags on a while too long. Although it does show Mr. Emerson's awesome skills, being an alright song.

Tank is another instrumental, which features some alright music at the beginning, although it isn't too memorable, then a rather boring drum solo (even though it does showcase Mr. Palmer's talents to a great extent), but the music after the drum solo is awesome. Some great synth lines and riffing.

Lucky Man is a great emotional closing track. Very melodic, mostly acoustic, with absolutely splendid vocals from Mr. Lake, a nifty electric guitar solo, and one great great Moog solo to finish it. I love the fat sound these things produce. An awesome song.

So all in all, while it is not a perfect masterpiece, I'd say this is essential. The Barbarian, Lucky Man, and Knife Edge are all awesome songs, Take a pebble is pretty good, and Tank and Three Fates have some prog-defining moments in them, so 4.5 stars, rounded up to 5.

A piano-driven affair, Emerson incorporates jazz and classical influences into a veritable feast of improvisation.

The Barbarian evokes echoes of Guaraldi while disseminating Bartok. Just Take a Pebble combines strummed piano strings, Lake's evocative lyrics and vocals, avid percussion and even a hoedown into a singularly beautiful composition. But your progressive feast has only begun!

Read Bradbury's Pillar of Fire as you balance on the Knife-Edge. Soon your Three Fates will lead you down a Lake-less path of organ bombast; as you continue watch out for the improvisational extrapolations the Pebble cast earlier - but mind the vibraslap and honky-tonk, they're rabid. Have fun driving in your Tank as you view the wasteland Tarkus will wreak all too soon. And if you're wondering who the Lucky Man is, you need look nor further: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=08R4m-TMXyI

It's a perfect album: The Barabarian is very good and the harmony of this is very complicated. Take a Pebble is a very very nice song, it's poetic. Knife-Edge has a very good harmony, i like this The three fates is a keyboards suite very nice. Emerson is the best at the Keyboards Tank is a very nice percussion track. Palmer is fantastic! And Lucky Man is a ballade very nice. Talk of a man very rich wich dead in war and the bills not save he.

(I'm Italian. I speak a very bad English!)

This is not just the must have ELP album, it it the must have prog rock album of all time. The ideas are fresh, the instrumentation appropriate and refreshingly sparse ( not overloaded like in many prog bands (Yes/Genesis/Floyd)). This lets the classical roots of the music shine through without being overbearing, and when given a rock feel the transition is appropriate to the feel of the piece. There are moments on Tarkus and Pictures at an Exhibition which approach this, but this album goes to places other ELP albums dont achive. To sum up - compelling and appropriate.

For many ELP fans, this debut album is their favorite. Its strong point is the piano playing, especially on Take a Pebble. The middle section of highlights a little guitar piece they seems to suggest a guy in the woods finding a guitar. I am sure Rush picked that up for 2112. The Barbarian is a fun piece because of its quoting of Bartok's allegro con barbaro. When his widow found out they had used it, she sued the band. Emo should have kept to ripping off Russian composers who were in the public domain thanks to communism. I like the way the opening bombastic guitar faze creates this silly caricature of an armadillo-like creature; it would have been great for the second album Tarkus. Then this texture dies down and the Bartok that creeps in. There are no words because everybody's tongue was stuck in their respective cheeks.

The album is really like works Vol Nul in the sense that you have one side of the album that is Emerson, Lake and Palmer and a second side that highlights the three players individually. The Three Fates highlights Emerson's piano playing in a pseudo- Messian rip off with some Debussy thrown in for good measure. it's very pretentious and fun. Tank is a fun piece as far as drum solos go. They used to play this on the radio once in a while; imagine that. Carl Palmer is one of the great Brit drummers of the last sixties early seventies. (What happened to all the great drumming.) Then of course we have Lucky Man, penned when Lake was twelve, he reworked it for the album because they needed one piece to fill it out. It's probably Lake's only song that has a chorus and it still gets airplay; imagine that. Lake kept the first take of the moog because he liked the portimento in the opening. Now Emerson says he's expected to play this solo for verbatim.

Overall, the album is an impresssive debut. It shows the distinct personalities of the members that ultimately led to the band's demise. Luckily, they were able to work well together and integrate their individuality to produce some great albums and pieces of the 1970s. Its emphasis on the piano and jazz improvisation are its best moments; but they were often the best moments in ELP.

I love ELP, nevertheless I think this is their only really perfect album. As much as I love the others (at least those up to "Welcome Back My Friends..."), to be honest I have to admit there's always something missing, unlike, for instance, in albums such as "Wish You Were Here" or "In the Court of the Crimson King". However, this is not the case of ELP's eponymous debut: a bold, bombastic, in-your-face statement of intent, a prog masterpiece the band have been able to better in all their chequered career.

When the record originally came out, its two sides were divided between 'group' efforts on the first and tracks showcasing the individual prowess of the three band members on the second. ELP took up the same idea in their 1977 "Works vol.1" double album, only much less successfully. Everything begins in style with one of my all-time favourite instrumental tracks, the magnificent "The Barbarian", a reworking of Bela Bartok's "Allegro Barbaro", an extremely heavy triumphal march driven by Palmer's drumming and Emerson's Hammond, complete with booming gong to signal the end of the quieter section and the reprise of the main theme. After that, things couldn't get more different with Lake's haunting, wistful ballad "Take a Pebble", undoubtedly one of his best vocal performances, with lovely piano and acoustic guitar in the middle section. "Knife Edge" is a rockier song that draws again upon a piece of classical music (this time it's Janacek's "Sinfonietta"), featuring beautiful Hammond work by Emerson and menacing, almost snarling vocals by Lake.

The second side sees Emerson's three-part tour de force, "The Three Fates", where he plays a real organ in the majestic "Clotho", before laying into his piano for "Lachesis" and "Atropos". Palmer's showcase, the intricate and heavily percussive "Tank", follows, and Lake's Top Ten ballad "Lucky Man" (which, as everybody now knows, he wrote at 12) brings the album to a close. Though I've never been particularly fond of this song, I cannot deny its attractiveness, enhanced by Emerson's Moog solo a the end. However, as Lake's ballads go, I very much prefer "From the Beginning" and especially the much- maligned "Still...You Turn Me On". I agree that ELP may not be to everyone's taste, but I also think no self-respecting progger's record collection could be considered complete without at least this one album. As to myself, this is definitely one of my Top Ten favourites in any kind of genre.

This album, like the others is one of ELP's masterpieces. In this disc ELP highlight much of their technique but it has melody and above all soul [spirit], something that not all Prog groups have.

For those who are being introduced to the prog genre, I recommend getting your hands on a copy of this album. The fusion of jazz and classical influences, coupled with heavy melodic ornamentation adds for a treat. I particularly enjoyed the extended piano soloing in The Barbarian, and The Three Fates.

Clearly ELP is still in its infancy here; their debut is full of much bombast but lots of filler. "The Barbarian" and "Knife-Edge" -- both being great examples of ELP's souped-up-classical style -- are the highlights of the first side. Look out for live versions of the later -- Emerson peppers his solos pleasingly with lots of fleeting classical references. In these two, ELP are making a direct statement of intent; the pieces are short and to the point and, thus, work well. On the second side, "Tank" has some really memorable moments -- the beginning and end constitute the archetypal ELP synth driven instrumental extravaganza -- but it is a pity the song is really just a frame for an overly-long and unnecessary drum solo. And then there are the two "epics" of the album. The better of them is "Take a Pebble", with a haunting main theme based on a chord progression Lake supposedly picked up back in his Crimson days. But the piece does not deserve its 12 minutes; Lake's guitar solo is particularly boring and irksome, and its up to Emo to save the day with his nimble piano work before an unnecessarily long restatement of the main theme. "The Three Fates" opens with a brilliant organ line, but quickly becomes boring. The 'piano trio' (which is just a solo piano unfolding over two layers of really simple and repetitive piano lines) stretches out far too long. And what of "Lucky Man" ? Very simple in structure and arrangement, a straightforward lyric, and a memorable melody. The best of Lake's ballads and perhaps, for all its quaint folksiness, the best track on the album. Emo's synthesiser solo at the end is timeless and revolutionary, and introduced so many new listeners to the instrument's untapped power. This album's place in rock history is enshrined for that reason alone. But because it's the first does not make it the best. Listen to Tarkus or especially Trilogy first.

the first adventure of one of the most representitives and well-knowns prog groups. three guys with an exhuberant talent of playing and composition... keith emerson from the nice, greg lake from the mythic group king crimson, and carl palmer, a young drummer that played with arhur brown and aomic rooster. the band was oriented to the classical genre, with some jazzy moments aported by palmer. 1.the barbarian (10/10) it's a really powerful opening track. wild, violent and schizoid. 2.take a pebble (10/10) contrasting with the previous track, it's a soft and nice song, full of beautifuls melodies of piano that takes you to other world, and with an inspirated greg lake singing better than ever. 3.knife edge (10/10) to complete a perfect a side. in the same vein of the barbarian. here emerson returns with that schizoid keyboards and greg lake playing the bass with the same anger of the crimson days. 4.the three fates (9/10) it starts with a church organ, that envolves you into the song, then, in the second movent, the church organ is changed by the piano, and in the third movement, carl and greg appears to give a powerful end to the song. 5.tank (7/10) the song starts cool, late, carl release a drum solo that bores me a little (is a great drum solo, but i hate the drum solos). and in the last 2 minutes, greg and keith returns again to complete a good song. 6.lucky man (7/10) it's just a nice ballad, but the style of the song is really different to the rest of the album. and it's not a good song to close an album... anyway, the final keith solo saves the song, and make it acceptable.

rate 53/60

pd: excuse my english.

This entry album has already indicated direction which will be firmly held by ELP on majority of their releases. Compositions written by Emerson will show heavy classical influence and his arrangements of classical parts undisputed keyboard virtuosity;on the other hand, Lake's material will be musicaly easier, melodicaly more receptive and attract listener's attention with lyrics, which will be his exclusive contribution to all ELP work.My favourites frrom this album are 'Take A Pebble' and 'Lucky Man' ;the former offering likable acoustic sound and suggestive Lake singing, the latter almost a 'hit' due to frequent airplays at the time of this album release. Solid start, but most valuable ELP material was to come.

Man, we are talking about a album and a band that opened a new era in progressive rock music! "The Barbarian", for me, was composed in influence of russian music (Mussorgsky) - the influence that we saw clearly in "Pictures in Exhibition", years later. In this album, ELP made experiments that helped them find an original style! I love this album!

4.3

With a lot of piano, this album makes for a marvellous debut revolving around the bands founder, Keith Emerson. Track one, 'The Barbarian', is not one of my favourites, being really quite dark and almost noisy in parts. 'Take a Pebble' is one of the best tracks on the album, starting eerie strokes of the piano strings and trilling swoops of the keyboard over the sound of Lake's vocals. This develops into a brilliant track. 'Knife Edge' is another of my favourites, with almost catchy vocals. Great use of keyboards and drums and effective tempo change. 'Tank' is not to my taste, as it appears that everything other than the skilful drum solo was added afterwards. This filler sounds silly and is definitely the lowest point of the album in my opinion. 'Luck Man' is a very enjoyable listen with good lyrics, but is generally musically uneventful. (I do like, however, the strange synthesiser noises.)

Overall this is a very good album with some jazzy and classical fringes and earned a welcomed position in my collection

Good Album. Better than I expected, as a forme ELP hater. The Barbarian opens the album as probably my favorite ELP song, Emerson shines. Take a pebble has pretty bad lyrics IMO, but again Emerson shines and the instrumental parts are very well done. Take a pebble is my least favorite track but is still pretty good.

I'm not going to go into details on all the songs, but Greg Lake's best track is the ending of the album "Lucky Man" which is the most popular early ELP track. This album ends very well.

Overall I'd say this album is an Excellent addition to any prog music collection, great to play every now and then and a must for keyboard enthusiasts. I really enjoy this album but I doubt it's a masterpiece of prog, but I definitely recommend to 70s prog fans. A great start for ELP.

93/100

The first E.L.&P. album must have been a breath of fresh air when it was first released.

The album has obvious elements of classical music but these are here taken a step further than The Nice (perhaps due to the superior technical abilities of Lake and Palmer compared to Emerson's erstwhile partners in his previous band?) and blend very well with the dark tinges reminiscent of Black Sabbath and other early 70's hard rock bands, namely the opener 'The Barbarian' which contains a brilliant distortion effect on Lake's bass and a wild organ riff by Emerson.

Emerson shows off his virtuosity on the keyboards majestically, as in 'Take a Pebble' which is a beautiful song played by Emerson with exquisitely delicate touch...despite falling later into hippie-singalong-by-the-camp-fire routine. All three musicians work cohesively and give their best on the extended instrumental 'The Three Fates'.

'Knife Edge' is another outstanding song as is the latter part of 'Tank', this being mainly a drum solo, with some syncopated parts by the rhythm section and an overdriven moog part by Emerson.

I have always held mixed views on the ballad 'Lucky Man' and still cannot make up my mind whether I like it or not; it has, however, a crisp sounding acoustic and nice clean electric guitar solo by Lake towards the conclusion.

The production is good as well and the re-mastered version on cd is a couple of steps better.

It is a more than worthy addition to any progressive rock collection.

I first listened to this album in 1981. An older cousin lent me this album then, and also other albums like ELP`s "Brain Salad Surgery" and others.

Maybe the band was still trying to create their own identity in sound in this album, but there are very good songs like "The Barbarian", "Take a Peeble" (with a very good piano), "Knife Edge" (with a great "Baroque music" organ arrangement), "Three Fates" (with the use of a church organ) and "Lucky Man" (maybe the most known song of this album). The music in this album is maybe less interesting than "Tarkus", "Trilogy" and "Brain Salad Surgery", but it was a very good start for this band, IMO.

This is one of the most influental and essential prog albums that you will ever run across. Period. Possibly ELP's best work ever, this album encompassed the energy and drive and technicial ability they had in the early years.

The Barbarian - ELP's best hard rock/classical fusion peice. This song has a power and energy that reflected this young trio in their early years. Keiths organ tone is perfect!

Take A Pebble - Beautiful despite its inconsistencys. The acoustic guitar part, although not bad, it seems very out of place but I geuss this is ELP we are talking about. Gregs singing is awesome in this one, not to mention Keiths incredible piano playing. Carl Palmer adds some tasteful percussion.

Knife Edge - A very good prog rock song with a very nicely done (bach?) interlude. Decent soloing, very good singing and such.

Three Fates - Very good showcase of keiths talents

Tank - a little bit of Greg showing who is boss of the skins

Lucky Man - Ok so its not so progressive, but its a classic. I never would have gotten into prog if it werent for this song. Definatly better then most proggers give credit for. I'm still kinda wondering about the solo...I know the story behind it, still, how does it fit the song?

In all...KILLER ALBUM...A MUST HAVE

The self-titled debut album of prog's neo-classical Symph-Prog trio gives a good taste of what's to come for this monumental band. They found their footing fairly quickly for a band whose members are all freshly picked from the finest Proto-Prog bands of the late- sixties and early seventies. Here, you can see ELP starting to develop the album format that would win and lose them some in the years to come. You've got your classical adaptation (Bartok's "The Barbarian"), you've got your Lake ballad (the unsought after radio hit "Lucky Man"), you've got your concert favorite-to-be ("Take a Pebble"), you've got a couple of short but memorable tracks ("Knife Edge" and "Tank") and you've got your Emerson ego-trip ("The Three Fates"). The only thing missing appears to be the worthless "comedy" number. But we can live without that.

The album is more laid back than the better recognized "Tarkus" or especially "Brain Salad Surgery". Emerson plays some blistering solos here, but the pace of the album as a whole seems to be quite a lot slower than the aforementioned albums, or even than "Trilogy". This impression may be partially because of the centerpiece track "Take a Pebble", which is bookended by two lyrical ballad-like bits featuring Greg's beautiful voice over the sound of Keith strumming a piano. In between, there's an acoustic guitar and nature sounds bit, followed by some of Keith's most sensitive piano playing. Yes folks, he could be subtle when he wanted to, he just chose not to be most of the time.

"Take a Pebble" is one of three numbers on the album meant to showcase the individual songwriting talents of each of the three members. Pebble was written entirely by Lake. "The Three Fates" was written entirely by Emerson. This is a composition in three parts: one for pipe organ, one for piano, and the last for three pianos. All three are thoroughly engaging and showcase Emerson's writing style very accurately, as well as his incredible instrumental prowess. Mr. Palmer lends a helping hand or two (and a couple of sticks) to part three.

In return for this, Emerson assists Carl in composing his feature number, "Tank", as composition was never his strong point. Unless, of course, he's composing (improvising?) a drum solo! A Palmer drum solo is always a red carpet event, and this one's no exception. It fits nicely in with Keith's intro and outro.

There's a funny story behind the album's introductory track "The Barbarian". This story is also the reason I bought the album used on vinyl. Early editions of the album had this track credited to Keith Emerson, when it was actually composed by Bela Bartok for solo piano and arranged for rock band by Keith Emerson. The song itself opens the album (and the band's career) with a bang. Emo's characteristic synths and Hammond dominate, setting the stage for the next five releases.

Knife-Edge is a cool rocker with some great vocals from Greg Lake. A great way to end Side One. Side Two ends with a similar kick in the pants, with the ballad "Lucky Man". It's great that this was the track to become a hit for ELP, much as it doesn't represent their sound. The reason being that the track's finale makes very pronounced use of the Moog Synthesizer shortly after its development. This introduced the general public to a new and exciting sound that would become one of prog's defining traits, and would be used in several other styles to boot. In conclusion, "Emerson Lake and Palmer" is an excellent debut from a monumental trio. It is great all the way through, although "The Three Fates" can get a bit dull at times. Not that it's bad, its just that there are lots of other Emerson features I enjoy more. And "Take a Pebble" more than makes up for it. The other tracks are also solid moments in ELP history. A more than satisfactory piece of prog from all angles.

Well, here we have the debut album from another quintessential band in progressive rock. For my taste it is also the best one of their catalogue, because, while most of its followers contained one or two major flaws, this one stands like a gem in brute. This record as well contains some of the most stunning piano passages I've ever listened. Honestly

The opening track, "The Barbarian", contains most of the ingredients characteristic to this album and to this band in general (except Greg Lake's vocals, missing here), those being Keith Emerson's amazing organ passages and piano extravanganzas, signs of a true master, Carl Palmer's agressive drumming (he has become one of favourite drummers, along with Phil Collins) and finally Greg Lake's subtle guitar work.

"Take a Pebble" is probably one of my favourite epic pieces of all time. It is sweet, melodic enchanting and again, the piano passages here can make anyone melt.

"Knife edge" is a rocker reminiscent of early days of rock' n ' roll, in which Greg Lake's bass and guitar sections interleave elegantly with Keith Emerson organ to obtain a pretty strong track.

"The Three Fates" makes Keith Emerson the true protagonist this time, with the organ at the beginning (like he would do in countless times to start many ELP songs) giving this song a classical atmosphere, followed by another superb set of fast and excellent piano loops which drive your mind to pure delirium.

In "Tank", the star role moves now to Greg Lake and Carl Palmer, the first one with his guitars and the latter with a strong drum playing, creating a stunning classic rock performance.

And finally, in the last track, Greg Lake is the star again, but this time showing us his skills as a vocalist, and I would dare to say that this song contains one of his best vocal performances, not to mention it is a beautiful and delicious song.

So, like I mentioned before this is their best balanced record, with no apparent flaws, which makes an essencial piece in any progressive rock collection. Highly recommended.

This is the weakest of the four essential ELP albums (trilogy, tarkus, and BSS being the other three). The Barbarian is one of the best tracks on the album and is a great album opener. It is pretty heavy for an ELP song and features more distorted guitar than most ELP songs. It is instumental and goes from a heavy rock section to a piano interlude that builds up to an explosion where the guitar re-enters in terrifying fashion. Great stuff. Basically the other good songs, to me, are Knife-edge and Lucky Man; and of course everyone has heard the latter song about a million times on any classic rock station. Lucky Man, even though a good song, is not representative of what ELP are all about. Now, onto the bad parts. Take a Pebble never really gets going, and is just so slow, especially in the middle section. This song sounds nothing like ELP's other work and sounds like they were still trying to find their signature sound; this definitely was not it. Also, the lyrics to this song kill me, in a bad way ("disturbing the waters... of our lives"). Last, and definitely least are two instrumentals that are uneven and boring. The Three Fates doesn't turn into something exciting until the last section and even then it is nothing special. Tank sounds strange, I can't really explain it exactly, but again I think that ELP were still trying to find their sound and this was yet another failed attempt.

In conclusion, the three shortest songs on the album are the best ones in my opinion and that makes up only about fifteen minutes of the album. The other three tracks are slow, boring, and do not sound like anything from their other definitive albums. In my opinion, this is an o.k. start for a "supergroup." I would say that it is definitely not an essential album; I would download The Barbarian, Knife-Edge, and Lucky Man and call it a day.

The band Emerson, Lake and Palmer are arguably the first ever prog super group, comprising of members from already established British progressive groups. Keith Emerson was from The Nice, Greg Lake of King Crimson and Carl Palmer of Atomic Rooster, these three musicians joined together to create Emerson, Lake and Palmer, or simply ELP. The guys decided to name the band after each member's last names as they were all well-known musicians and this would grant the band immediate recognition. Luckily, something good came out of this supergroup in their debut album" Emerson, Lake and Palme"r which was the first in a string of successful albums. " Lucky Man" in particular was very successful and ELP gained a foothold so to speak on the musical public.

The album opener "The Barbarian" is quite a heavy song as far as this band goes, entirely instrumental and almost completely dominated by Keith Emerson's moogs and other Synthesizers. Parts of said song are very swift and display great virtuosity from all members, but especially from Carl Palmer whose percussion is a driving force in this number. Following "The Barbarian" is "Take A Pebble" which originated as a poem and then as a blues tune written initially by Greg Lake. The song was taken and literally stretched out to around 12 minutes, in which Emerson and Greg Lake play solo on the piano and guitar respectively. When the "pebbles drop" a fast pace instrumental section beings which then leads into an ending much like the beginning of the piece.

The calm brought on by "Take a Pebble" is completely thrown out the window with the next track, "Knife-Edge. ""Knife Edge" is quite a loud song with heavy keyboard, percussion and bass guitar lines. The lyricism of "Knife-Edge" is very catchy and the bass guitar echoing in the back round complements the vocals very well. The addition of instrumental interludes between vocal sections gives the song a, kind of repetitious feel. The band was taken to court over a keyboard section "borrowed" from a 20th centaury composer's song. Luckily the dispute was solved out of court and royalties were payed to the composer's family. Next is "The Three Fates", a song completely dominated by Keith Emerson.until the last two or so minutes when the whole band comes out with all guns firing.

Next is another instrumental called "Tan"k which begins immediately with swift percussion from Palmer and thrumming bass guitar, which is soon joined by Emerson playing the main tune over the top. Carl Palmer's percussion solo in the middle of the song leads to another violent fusion of synthesizers, bass and percussion which in tern ends the song. Finally we come to "Lucky Man", which is probably ELP's most famous song. It's basically about a rich, lucky man who goes to war and dies. Acoustic guitar makes up the general feel of the song, with an electric guitar solo in the middle. The good-stuff comes towards the end of the song when Emerson plays probably the most memorable moog-solo in all prog. Great stuff.

1.The Barbarian (4/5) 2.Take a Pebble (4/5) 3.Knife-Edge (4/5) 4.The Three Fates (3.5/5) 5.Tank (3/5) 6.Lucky Man (5/5) Total = 23.5 divided by 6 = 3.916 = 4 stars Excellent addition to any prog music collection

ELP may not everyone's cup of tea, and many people dislike ELP with a bloody passion, but this album is one which everyone can enjoy along with 'Brain Salad Surgery.' This is real classic progressive rock, it doesn't come more genuine than this my friends. I'd recommend this album to everyone who enjoys classic 70's symphonic prog and fans of Yes, Genesis and to a lesser extent King Crimson should enjoy this album among the band's others.

Even arriving a little later than King Crimson, Genesis, Yes, Jethro Tull and others to the progressive scene, EL&P is doubtlessly one of the "Giants". Well, their members were all in a way or another involved with prog-rock and the likes for some time then when the trio appeared. They are also called the first prog super-group exactly due to the previous musical contacts and experiences of Keith EMERSON, Greg LAKE and Carl PALMER. Uh, too many epithets for a bunch of three men and what about the music?

EL&P were a very popular band in early 70s (not only for prog, but for the entire rock genre) who saw their prestige diminish since then except for some resurgent appearances, material re-issues and compilation releases. Unlike other 1st class bands which settled their record material on their own compositions, EL&P rotated around old erudite authors giving their opus new clothes and approaches. Yes, they produced their own stuff too, but the entire atmosphere sounded clearly imbedded in the classics. In a span of few years, the scheme aged just when prog-rock was suffering its adulthood pains and the general audience was aiming to less contemplative and qualified genres, led by label managers and media promoters, not counting the excesses and pretentiousness of prog spearheads (EL&P amidst them) that initially amused/amazed the public only to leave a boring feeling as long as time goes by.

Band self-titled first studio album is a fair effort, although unbalanced, with orchestral-like extravaganzas dwelling together with simple chord arrangements and with classical based songs joined by virtuoso keyboard exhibitions opposing soft and cool ballads. General production is half-way mainly if compared with band's output in years to come. The ever-present sensation is that for their first party together, members brought their own home-made liquors.

"The barbarian", the opening track, is a powerful beginning, reminding King Crimson's openings in their two first albums, being the great difference the absence of a singing segment, which could be even more noticed since the singer is the same either for Crimson and EL&P, the notorious Greg Lake. The song is credited for the triad but in fact is based on a Bartok piece named Allegro Barbaro and it sounds like an introducing card of band's philosophy.

"Take a pebble" has all the progressive spices we all pleasantly admire and consequently grabs the honor of being the best album's track. Lake's voice is superb, Emerson's piano solo and accompaniment is glorious and Palmer does rightly his work here. After the smooth balladesque intro we hear a very bucolic and sometimes psychedelic guitar passage mixed with folk backings that gives room to the mentioned piano part broken only by drums and bass tunes, the effect is magnificent, a great prime mover of the prog-rock style. Song closure returns to the ballad part with a slightly different touch which is very convenient.

"Knife edge", a song based on a Janacek composition, starts nervous and almost frenzy bearing the typical troika keyboards-drums-bass playing that should be a kind of band's signature. The following track, "The three fates" has a disturbing organ sounding a bit non-sense. Piano part is much more appreciable even resembling the previous track. The song leaps in quality when the band acts like a real combo. "Tank" has a rehearsal atmosphere which may have sounded fair when played live, however the final result is poor bordering asleep state.

Final track, "Lucky man" is probably the most commercial feature in band's career. While the song is hearable and agreeable, it breaches totally album's nature and its inclusion was initially rejected - what an irony! The now famous and recognized moog ending was improvised and player Keith Emerson wasn't satisfied, although he probably changed his mind when the coins erupted in his wallet.

As a first effort by EL&P, we should say that the this album is above average with prospects for higher flights (and that was the perspective back in 1970). Splendid "Take a pebble" track responds for the rating increases from good to essential. Total: 4.

A TOTALLY EXCELLANT ALBUM After Greg Lakes departure from King Crimson, Greg Lake linked himself to another genious, ex Nice leader keyboardist Keith Emerson Carl Palmer a extremly incredible drummer from atomic rooster

Greg Lakes amazing lyrics INCREDIBLE BASS PLAY! and angelic voice ARE NOT EQUALED ANYWERE

hard edged instrumentals drenched in hard rock marching rudiments and classical music

an exquisite hybrid of music forms and precision playing

a true classic

yours truly a pleasant symmetry

4.4

Oh yes. The long awaited debut of the super-group Emerson, Lake & Palmer was titled after nothing more but the bands own name. And of course, this would mark the beginning of what we know would be the most popular prog band of the seventies, taking Genesis, and even Yes with storm. This album lets you understand why they were so big.

''The Barbarian'' rips up the album, starting out with a heavy distorted bass tone brought to us by Greg Lake. It doesn't take long for Carl Palmer to band the snare drum and lay a beat. And of course, we soon have Keith Emerson fiddling with the organ keys. The Barbarian is chaotic and Keith Emerson goes a bit nuts on the keyboard. Carl Palmer's drumming is very technical, and hills fills are outstanding. Keith is of course, great on the organ and lays down some great and chaotic organ lines every now and then. Soon that distorted bass tone is heard again, followed by acoustic piano while Palmer plays a fast line on the drums. This section is more of a happy section. Strange chords are played, and of course as we know, Emerson plays them 10 times faster than other people would. Great virtuosity is displayed here, both by Palmer and Emerson. Lake keeps the bass going strong throughout. The chaos soon erupts however, with Keith delivering the distonal chords to us. A heavy gong smash by Carl gets the chaos going again. Loud distorted bass tones are heard, and that creepy organ hops in again. The first section is repeated here, and the fills by Carl are even faster now than before. Pure chaos erupts soon after that, with Carl playing like a madman and Keith playing whatever fits into the key the song is in. The song ends abruptly.

''Take A Pebble'' is if I may, the best song on this album. The intro consists of Keith Emerson dragging a plectrum over piano strings, and I admit, it does sound pretty weird, and unfitting. However it doesn't take long for Carl to give us some soothing ride cymbals, and soon Lake joins on the bass. After that, we are blessed with Greg Lake's beautiful vocals, so soft and mellow. The piano here is great, while Greg sings emotional vocals to us. The chorus is perfect, however after the chorus more dragging a pic across piano strings pops in. But don't worry, Greg soon takes control again. The vocals are again just superb. Keith delivers fills on the piano that makes the verse even more emotional. A new chorus comes to us. Soon, beatiful piano is played by Emerson, and I don't know why, but this section is Emerson's best one on the entire album to me. This could easily be in the opening of some fancy movie, and everything flows so perfectly. Not one single note that screws up. After a while, the piano slowly stops. This leaves place for a quiet acoustic section. This is Lake's most beautiful guitar work ever to me. Gently playing the notes at high frets, he plays the chords every now and then. Simply gorgeous, and the emotion put into the work here; you can really hear and feel it. After some gentle strumming and notes picked in a beautiful way, the song evolves to Keith and Carl clapping their hands (keepin the beat I suppose) while Greg plays the chords. Pretty cool section, with some whistling and talking heard. The clapping turns into an applause, and more beautiful guitar work is gracing our ears. Soon Greg plays very fast, displaying what an underrated guitarist he really was. After the last soothing guitar note, Emerson's crazily beautiful piano is brought to us. Played at a fast speed, he makes the music feel really alive. Such a soothing section this is. It's something you can just sit back and relax to and say ''Damn. That is some crazy piano skills''. More hyper speed notes are given to us, however now Keith focuses more on the chords, and the fast fills which he somehow doesn't mess up. Carl soon joins with ride cymbal and the snare, with the fills getting heavier, and so does Keith's piano playing. After one hell of a ride, Greg comes in with the bass. This is the climax of the song, with all three members giving their best. Carl doesn't overplay here, which I enjoy. Neither does Greg (Which is great, since the group was accused of being people with nothing but gigantic ego's. More on that later) Keith delivers the last hyper fast piano playing, and the main theme of the song comes back to us. Heavy tom-tom playing by Carl is followed by Greg's once again soothing vocals. So clean and beautiful, you just can't dislike it. After the last gorgeous chorus the song ends at 12 minutes in length. One hell of a ride ey?

''Knife Edge'' is another chaotic song. Kicking right into gear, it opens up with heavy drumming and a loud Hammond organ by Keith. The bass is soon the only thing heard. Greg soon sings strange vocals, with the drumming being jazzy. After the first verse, Keith improvises around the notes that cover the key the song is in, and the result is bloody brilliant! Another verse pops in in, with Greg's voice being reverbed, and after that, another organ section is brought up. Carl delivers heavy fills here, and a bridge joins shortly thereafter. Vocals being shouted here, pretty great section. A fast drum fill leads into more organ driven sections here, and they just have such an awesome sound. Marching-like drumming is played while Keith goes mad on the organ. Great virtuosity here. After that a strange section comes into play, sounding medeival and displays some cool drumming by Carl. Another bridge comes in, this one being longer than the previous one. More organ driven sections arive. The song ends in an awesome way; the tape of the record slowing down and down until stopping completely. It sounds really wicked.

''The Three Fates'' is the reason this album got 4 stars instead of five. The song starts out with an annoying melody played on a church organ. Keith is really just having fun here, and the result is pure boredom to the listener. However, after that, a pretty cool section comes with very fast organ playing. Unfortunately, more of those opening organ notes are played thereafter, and just leads me wanting to skip the track. However, since this is a review I must go through the whole song. But oh yes! More of that cool intermission is played, and some heavy organ chords are brought to us. Soon the only really good part of the song kicks into play, Lathesis. Hyper-speed piano is brought to us with cool chords and notes of course, and somehow this section reminds me of that of Take A Pebble. But unfortunately it doesn't take long for Emerson to get ahead of himself and he starts playing random notes sounding like absolute bull****. However, at 03.13 perhaps the most beautiful section on the entire album is played. Sad chords are played with fast, clean fills by Emerson. Just so beautiful that it's barely true! But again, Emerson starts playing random crap again and just ruins the whole thing. But it gets a bit better after that, but then turns into a sloppy soup of random notes again. The song kind of continues like that throughout until the next section, Atropos. This is the... worst section on the entire album. It's more of the random crap, but now there are THREE PIANOS! Not only that, but Keith drags out on it for 2 bloody minutes, which seem like an hour and 30 minutes. It gets very boring very quickly, and you're thanking God when the song finally ends at 07.43.

''Tank'' is the albums way of showcasing Carl Palmer's skills. Starting out with jazzy drumming and heavy bass, this evolves into some synthesizer playing by Keith. Very cool section, pretty funky overall. A new section comes up after that, with a more ''happy'' feel to it than the last one. Carl keeps the drumming very steady throughout. Great synth playing by Keith here. Kudos to him. Then you get a kind if synth-drum-synth-drum section. Keith plays his line on the synth, followed by hyper-fast fills by Carl. This is played for a while, and it's the coolest section in the song. Soon a crazy fast drum solo is delivered, with super speed snare drum playing and heavy tom playing is delivered to us. This sounds like something Neil Peart would play, only with more emotion. A more 'march' like section comes in, however this is followed by more fast snare drumming and some cool hi-hat work too. Incredible snare work with heavy bass drumming is played after this, and it's the coolest section of the drum solo. Some gong playing is done, and then Carl goes mad on the cymbals, and the bass drum as well. More of that cool section comes, and then more mad cymbal playing and then some snare drum playing with cool effects on it. At 04.12 the song goes back to normal with the jazzy sections, however Carl's drumming is not nearly as technical now as it was in the beginning of the song (A bit of a dissappointment when you think about it). The song carries on with some crazy synth playing by Keith, while settling down at 06.51. Pretty cool song.

''Lucky Man'' is the albums closer. It's pretty beautiful and features what would become Greg Lake's trademark acoustic guitar work. A very cool first verse is followed by the songs widely known chorus with the line ''Ooh, what a lucky man he was.'' Another beautiful verse is brought, with Greg's emotional vocals sung. Another great chorus comes in after that, and leads to the pretty awesome guitar solo. Although it's nothing technical, it's just great. Some ''ahh''s by Greg leads into the third verse (Where the lyrics are extra interesting) and after that comes another chorus. This leads into the absolutely awesome Moog synthesizer solo in the end. Effing awesome I tell you! So this solo of course ends the song at 04.36.

This album is a fine work of music, indeed and by all means, if you want to buy any Emerson, Lake & Palmer album then this is a good way to see what they're like. However, this album is hard to get into at first. But later it will grow on you.

Its very hard now to appreciate just how powerfully different this record was at release. Following after the Nice's last records was always going to be a difficult feat for any band, but ELP managed to compleatly over shadow the early-prog Nice and defined a whole musical movement with the record. Not the first prog rock LP by any means but certainly one of the first hugely successful prog releases. " The Barbarian" starts the whole show and demonstrates the great power of ELP's music. "Take A Pebble" is a pretty good song and we are treated to some great Piano playing, this track is firmly in the Jazz tradition and could perhaps have been produced by the Nice, However the Nice never had a lead vocalist that could really match the rest of the skills on offer, so getting Lake (who most certainly can sing) was a great move. If anything the track now seems a little on the long side but remains a choice cut. "Knife-Edge" is a real ELP rocker and features some typical Lake apocalyptic Lyrics, maybe a little like Peter Seinfeld's but infinitely more focused and less pretentious. "The Three Fates" is divided in three parts Clotho features a real church organ and maybe this experiment doesnt quite come off although as with all Emerson, keyboard work it is very hard to fault in technical terms. Lachesis is a nice contrast and is my favorite section of this track "Atropos" is a tripled piano and makes the whole work unperformable live as a result. In all the three fates is not the strongest cut on the record and makes uncomfortable listening. "Tank" is an excellent track despite being little more than a drum solo, Palmer is of course a true master of his instrument and even if few other drummers could pull off such a track Carl Palmer certainly can, were the band come back in remains a shining example of ELP at its thundering best. "Lucky Man" is a typical Lake song and is by one of his better efforts. It features some nice use of the Moog synthesizer. On reflection side two is somewhat weaker than side one but this still remains an excellent debut release and forms parts of the classic period of ELP for many many people they could do no wrong. Some people claim that ELP's music has no emotion but I don't feel that is incorrect. The Music is full of references to urban life and the very real fears of people at the start of the 70's. The apolitical lyrics (of lake ) fit perfectly with this very powerful music. The Nice had been a great if flawed band, the biggest problem being the lack of a vocalist of the same high standard as the rest of the band. Greg Lake's voice alone would have improved matters. The inclusion of one of the most (if not the most) talented drummers of a generation ensured that ELP on paper at least should have been something very special this LP demonstrates that indeed ELP were a super group in every sense, producing stunning music that has never been surpassed for pure power. This record has a few flaws but is a must have for anyone interested in Progressive rock music.

Emerson, Lake and Palmer's debut is by far their best effort. This album brings me to my career as a musician. After Wishbone Ash's first album (my favourite album of all time), this one was as a Big Bang from nothingness. I am clearly not objective, but I think this album gives to music real classical prog at highest level (Thank you mr.Emerson for NICE piece of music, too).

Power rock trios like Cream, J. Hendrix Experience, Grand Funk Railroad and so on, gave as an idea, that a man doesn't need too many musicians to make great music. ELP takes it one more step farther. They gave us a flash of perfection.

One by one,

Greg Lake was one of the greatest singers in prog (as King Crimson fans hugely agree) and he is still one of my favourite voices in music. Well, he is a good bass guitar player, too.

Keith Emerson - hm, what to say and stay original? One word will be enough - the BEST.

Carl Palmer is awsome drummer (one of my first idols) and in his age on this album I have no doubt to call him a Master drummer.

Songs are all great, I personally like most Knife-edge (as a citizen of ex-Czechoslovakia) and Take a pebble. Great work, one of the best top ten albums af all time not only in prog.

3.5 stars.

This is, by far, their most even album far as I've heard.

People seem to be afraid to spin this baby, at the threat of getting killed by Emerson's dissonant marathon... But there's not really that much to fear about; yes, there's still dissonance, but it's digestable. A fault that many people find in this band is the lack of guitar. Lake fortunately fixes the problem, even if he doesn't do any "Steve Howe" or "Steve Hillage" (whichever suits better), he gets the job done effectively in both electric and acoustic. The guitar is still not omnipresent though.

"The Barbarian" starts the album with a faithful reworking of Bartok's "Allegro Barbaro", even if it differs in format, substantially is the same feel.

"Take A Pebble" is a Lake's composition, and it has Emerson trying to jazz things up, as the verse-chorus-solo fades, we're brought to a southern folksy passage with claps, and then Emerson sets the mark again for a jazz improvisation. After all that, we get back to the main theme. Although it might seem a bit stretched at first, it grows on you. I liked it on first listen.

I really didn't care for "Knife Edge"; I find it cheesy in arrangements, and even if I haven't heard Janacek's piece, I don't think he'll be too happy to hear this. The song's melody is strong nonetheless.

"The Three Fates" is for me the best opus on this album. It's mostly a showcase for Emerson alone, although the rest of the band enters at some point. The suite sets off with haunting organ chords that fits more in "Atropos" than in "Clotho" (past and present, respectively), but it doesn't matter. Lachesis is a grand piano segment very much in the vein of a true classical pianist, and yet it really evokes at some point a "warp to the future" (ironically enough). "Atropos" welcomes the entire trio to the piece and Palmer's beat is amazing here.

"Tank" might be seen as a continuation of "The Three Fates" in which Lake employs vibrato in the bass notes at the beginning.

"Lucky Man" is the pop song of the album. Terribly spoiled by the Moog solo in the middle, which by now sounds awfully dated.

All in all, I still think that this album is an excellent addition to every progressive far, even if brought down by 0.5 stars.

SO ELP ME GOD...

...but this, not Tarkus, not Trilogy, not Brain Salad Surgery, is the best Emerson, Lake, and Palmer (ELP from now on) album. Now, I know that a lot of people (myself included) generally detest the use of the definitive best in a situation like this. But consider this: On Tarkus, there is the excellent, amazing, incredible title suite. And then there's a bunch of filler. On Trilogy, there are a couple good songs (the Endless Enigma, Trilogy, Abaddon's Bolero) and about as much filler. On Brain Salad Surgery, there is the Karn Evil 9 epic and, you guessed it, filler (though the filler on BSS is less than on the other two). Well, I've had it with the filler. Why don't we just sit down to this lovely eponymous debut album and have a ball without having to deal with FILLER!!!!!!! Huh, why not? ELP has one album without any filler from their prime era, and this is it. Thus, I would say that this is a flat out BETTER album than any of those three. What is a matter of personal taste is that I also happen to prefer the songs on this album to the songs on other ELP albums.

For those who don't know, Emerson, Lake, and Palmer is a three piece band consisting of, surprise of all surprises, Keith Emerson, Greg Lake, and Carl Palmer, and is arguably prog's best supergroup. Greg Lake, of course, comes from King Crimson, lending his voice and his bass talents to the album. Carl Palmer comes from Atomic Rooster, bringing with him some wonderful and invigorating drumming. And Keith Emerson, arguably the star of the band, comes from The Nice, and, in ELP, establishes himself as one of the best keyboardists around. This is their debut album, and it is their best, probably in large part because their oversized egos haven't started clashing yet. Now, on to the album itself.

There is a heavy classical influence on this album, perhaps more so than on any other ELP album. Tank and the Barbarian are covers of classical pieces, and then, I believe, The Three Fates is a classical piece composed by Emerson himself (but you should know that I'm not quite sure about this). Keyboards dominate every aspect of this album to the extent that there's even a moog solo on Lucky Man. It isn't a concept album (ELP didn't do those), but the lyrics, when they appear, are excellent, as are the vocals (courtesy of Lake). This album really shines, and as far as I'm concerned, is the real reason why ELP is one of the prog greats, not any of their other albums. In fact, even with all the hype about Brain Salad Surgery's (admittedly awesome) cover, I think "The Dove Album's" cover is much better. It is true, ELP's debut cover is their best, and one of my favorites. But enough about the cover, music isn't for looking at, it's for listening to. So, here's a bit of what you can expect from each song on this wonderful album.

The album opens with The Barbarian, ELP's wonderful take on a classical music piece. It begins with some heavily distorted guitar which gives way to Palmer's fast drums and Emerson's amazing keyboard skills. This is a fast-paced ride that showcases both the genius of ELP and the composing skills of the old greats that greatly influenced progressive rock before rock of any kind even existed. This piece really grabs you and pulls you into the album, especially when you have Lake, Palmer, and Emerson all going at once (starting with about 1:30 left), getting faster and pacer, more and more energetic, and creating a wonderful mood that gets you ready for more great music.

And ELP delivers that great music straight to your ears. The next song, Take a Pebble, is an absolutely beautiful cross between a ballad and an epic. It showcases Lake's considerable vocal and lyrical talents, as well as the ability of Emerson to create moods out of nothing on his keyboards. Lake's vocals that get us started, on top of Emerson's lovely keyboards and Palmer's fitting drums, are simply heavenly. Palmer's drumming here at the beginning does not wow you, he gets his chance to do that later in the album. Here, he lets Lake and Emerson have the show mostly to themselves, and I, for one, feel that this was a very good decision on his part. Now, there are parts of this song where he does really grab you, but mostly this is Emerson and Lake combining to create great music. After the section with vocals that got us started, there is a lovely middle section entirely dominated by Emerson. I will warn you that it is slow the first few times, but once you get used to it, it's very good (except for the short bit with the cheesy clapping, but that goes away quickly). There is a very classical feel to the keyboards in the middle here, and as I've said, they are very good. The song then returns to the heavenly vocals of Lake for a rousing finale that takes this mini-epic ballad to a wonderful close. While I will give credit where credit is due and say that Tarkus is a much better song than this, I will also point out that I enjoy this song more than Karn Evil 9 or any of the longer songs on Trilogy.

Knife Edge is a more typical rock song, though with a definite ELP feel. The lyrics are excellent, as are the vocals. The bass takes a lead role here, followed by drums. This song has the least Emerson input, which, as the quality of this song shows, is not a bad thing. And, in the short instrumental bursts, Emerson gives it his all. This is one of the "weak"-est songs on this album without a single weak song. Everything comes together to create the type of song that needed more representation on later ELP albums rather than the filler they gave us. It's a relatively short track, but engaging throughout, and I must say I love it. A lot.

Next comes my favorite on the album, essentially a solo song by Emerson that features three parts, each with him playing a different keyboard related instrument. All three parts are very classical pieces, and all are great. Clotho, the first part, features some excellent organ work. It consists of a loud theme, which is repeated a few times, and then he gets into fast and wonderful playing on piano (Lachesis) that is heaven on the ears. I didn't like this track at first, but now that I've realized just how good Emerson is (and now that keyboards and their relatives are my favorite instrument family), this track simply feels magical. Around 5 minutes in, some drums come in, and I think this marks the beginning of the piano trio (Atropos), which is my favorite part, energetic and frenetic, showing just how good piano can be. On this note, the song comes to an end, easily my favorite song on the album, and perhaps my favorite ELP song off any album (competing with Tarkus). When considering what rating to give this album, this song was the breaking point, the sheer brilliance of it convinced me that the album deserved five stars.

Tank comes next, and having just come from reviewing Yes' Fragile, Five Percent For Nothing from that album is fresh in my mind. Well, the opening of this song (released earlier) is very similar to the entire theme of Five Percent for Nothing, but this song then goes somewhere with it. It is another classical cover, this time without the distorted guitar. It is my least favorite on the album, but it is still good. Palmer's drum solo is the highlight here. The ending, which starts immediately after the drum solo, is also awesome. Overall, Tank doesn't completely tank, but it's nothing to write home about either.

The album comes to an excellent close, however, with Lucky Man. Lucky Man is a witty little song that is more pop than prog, but it is some highly intelligent pop, especially the lyrics. Basically, the song is about a man who has everything (thus he is lucky). Well, he goes off to war and becomes a hero, but misfortune besets him, and he dies, yet, "oooh, what a Lucky Man he was" (no, I was not actively trying to see how many articles I could fit into that sentence). This song is simply enchanting, and despite what at least one reviewer has said about the moog solo being dated, it is still incredible. This is a beautiful and catchy little ditty that closes this excellent album in style.

This album is simply a masterpiece, one of the defining moments of progressive rock, more so than any of their later albums. As I have written in several of my recent reviews, I've recently undergone a spiritual rediscovering of classic progressive rock, catching several great albums (including three masterpieces) that I somehow had not grasped the full power of before. And this is one of those three masterpieces. You cannot go wrong here.

5 STARS - ESSENTIAL: A MASTERPIECE OF PROGRESSIVE MUSIC!

In this review, I swear that I have told the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so ELP me God...

Maybe the most "normal" of the ELP "elite" records.

Take that comment as you wish. Some will praise this record for maybe being the most sane, others will complain because it wasn't pompous enough. For me this has a very significant connection to King Crimson's first work primarily because of Lake's presence during the time period (released in back to back years).

This album was surprisingly heavy, to me anyways. It's also got plenty of moments of virtuosity, which although might not be thought as such by some of today's elite, but certainly was for its time. The biggest problem I have with the record is a lack of balance and lack of identity. I hear ELP catering to many different audiences, as if to attract more listeners, but no definitive sound throughout. While such decisions may have helped them reach a broader audience, I am of the opinion that they are wasted and dull tracks which only serve to hurt the impact the record might otherwise have.

For example, the rhyming lyrics in The Knife is pain to listen to, it's just awful poetry; maybe Ian Anderson could have helped them with some snazzy lines. I would say Three Fates is the best listen here, along with Barbarian. ELP certainly was one of the most experimental of early prog bands, and an extremely innovative band. This is a nice little start, and would be the best place to begin for those more accustomed to the other "big" symphonic prog acts.

A very good debut.. not surprising, as all three members had previously been involved in other progjects before. Carl came from Atomic Rooster, Keith from The Nice, and Greg from King Crimson.

The sound here is alot more dynamic and heavy than what came later, with dominating tunes like "The Barbarian" and "Knifes Edge". Keith shows his piano talent on the drawn-out "Take a Pebble" and Carl is shown as an exceptional drummer on "Tank". Greg has his solo moment also, in the softer "Lucky Man" which contains the magical Moog solo.

Production quality is decent, the best reissue available as far as I'm concerned is the Japanese K2 24 bit remaster. Makes the recording shine, sounds like it was recorded last year.

Developing sound still, this album definitely shows you what they were capable of, and foreshadowed the greatness to follow.

The Barbarian really starts things off nicely. The malevolent and dark keyboard, complimented by violent fuzz bass and aggressive drums, really sets a mood here. I find this track to be very accessible. Even my cousin, who is a "gangstah rap" fan enjoyed this track when he first heard it. After the aggressive introduction, the song fades a bit to a piano section, emphasized by Carl Palmer's brushes on the snare drum. It later picks up again, and ends on a high note. A very well written opening track to a fantastic debut album.

This album tends to jump from keyboard heavy, amazingly talented instrumentals right to softer, sensitive (acoustic, often) songs. The latter, written and sung by Greg Lake, do well to balance with ELP's more violent nature. But even during these fast-paced, exciting outings, the band does well not to over-do everything, and still rely heavily on their fantastic writing skills, as opposed to depending altogether on their musicianship. It was these more passive songs that won ELP the majority of their air-play, even though the band clearly eschews commercial success. The most popular of these songs is held within this album: Lucky Man. But do well not to overlook the other song of Lake's here: Take a Pebble. Flowing from one musical environment to another, this track is certainly different from its more radio-friendly brethren, as it is still very experimental and atmospheric in nature.

And let us not overlook the piano opus of The Three Fates (reference to Greek Mythology). I found this track to take a few tries before I enjoyed it to its full extent. The piano section in the middle (surnamed Lachesis) is very beautiful and almost surreal.

As we all know, ELP is one of the most technically gifted packs of musicians. Tank is an opportunity for Carl Palmer to show off his skills, as The Three Fates was for Keith Emerson. Does he ever! This drum solo is actually one of my favourites ever recorded.

This is a debut album full of many many great ideas, and executed with elegance and originality. All the musicians are very gifted and put their talents to good use. Excellent work, E, L, and P.

I was in my very early 20s when this album came out in 1970. But I was in no way, shape or form able at that time to fully appreciate the brilliance of the revolutionary music of Emerson, Lake and Palmer. (I dare say I wasn't alone among my peers in my immaturity, though.) I'm not telling you that I didn't become an instant fan or that I didn't enjoy it. On the contrary. It's just that I probably lifted the needle over the very best parts a hundred times in order to get to the "heavier" stuff that the headbanger in me craved. It's only in the many decades since then that I have come to understand just how amazing and timeless this album is. First things first, however. I have to point out the fact that the painting on the cover by Nic Dartnell is one of the all-time classics. But you already knew that.

"The Barbarian" is a perfect four and a half minute introduction to ELP. They throw everything at you including a fuzz bass and a very intense, snarling organ from Keith Emerson. His piano interlude midway through is exhilarating and soon you know you are in the presence of a truly gifted keyboard virtuoso. "Take a Pebble" is one of those songs I would jump over in my youth but I was only cheating myself by doing that. Greg Lake's distinctive voice starts things off singing a nice melody with simple lyrics about how each individual act can have a rippling effect on one's entire life. Emerson's piano takes over and literally takes your breath away. Then comes a folksy acoustic guitar segment from Lake that is gentle and spacious, ending with handclaps and whistles as if they were sitting around a campfire. Next you get another dose of wonderful piano alongside Carl Palmer's jazzy drums before Lake finishes the song with another poignant vocal. "Knife Edge" more than satisfies the hard rock monster in us all with its hard, piercing organ and gutsy vocal over some very strong drums. And the cool meltdown ending is just what the doctor ordered. There's no excuse for my years of skipping over the apex of the album, "The Three Fates." What was I thinking? Just testosterone-fueled impatience, I guess. The enormous sound of the Royal Festival Hall Organ is magnificent and the piece, "Clotho," would be right at home in a gladiator movie soundtrack. And I mean that in a good way, too. It is epic in scope. Emerson next treats you to "Lachesis," a truly outstanding solo piano composition and performance that blew away 99.9% of the keyboard players in rock at that time. It is nothing short of awesome. After a brief return to the cathedral organ the drums enter and Palmer and Emerson go into the stirring 7/8 time "Atropos" that would impress even the great Gershwin. It's fantastic. "Tank" is probably the least remarkable track here but that's only because of the obligatory (at that time) drum solo contained within. Even then the clavinet at the beginning and the Moog noodlings at the end are intriguing. All this being said about the album, if it wasn't for Lake's ironic anti-war anthem "Lucky Man" it's debatable as to whether the group would have attained the huge success that was to come. This song got them noticed. It's a very catchy ditty to begin with and Greg's unique voice is a definite plus but it was Emerson's Moog rising like a phoenix toward the latter part of the tune that made everybody reach over and crank up the volume on their radio. It wasn't the first time the public had heard this new instrument but it was the first time it was the STAR OF THE SHOW and even the most conservative listener couldn't get enough of it.

The high fidelity of the sound is surprising until you notice that the engineer was none other than Eddie Offord (who would go on to produce most of Yes' finest albums). In particular, the piano sounds so crisp and clear it's like it's in the room with you. So, if you haven't procured a copy of this cornerstone of progressive rock by now, do yourself a favor and add it to your collection. It is unquestionably one of the greatest debut albums ever and the music is still as fresh and relevant today as it was when it first appeared on the record shelves. Just don't be like me and skip over the best parts.

Aggressive and technically stunning music from Symphonic Prog(ressive Rock)'s first "super trio".

I. "The Barbarian": Wow. Emerson, Lake & Palmer's debut is a cacophany of angry, classically inspired treble-heavy bass guitar, hammond organ, and more-than-proficient percussion. The feeling of desparation, violence, and even hatred is enshrined in a perfect rock arrangement of Bartok's "Allegro Barbaro" (1911). Although ELP choose not to attribute their classical influences on the album, it really does not matter when such powerful playing is involved. As a homage to the earlier composers who they built on, the middle piano section here is amazing! It is a whirlwind of chords, arpeggios, runs, and things that many others in Symphonic Prog cannot match. After the stunning piano section, Hammond organ and bass guitar come back with the ridiculous drums to create a perfect conclusion.

II. "Take a Pebble": An example of true progressive rock; never staying in one spot, the melodies reveal themselves in bass guitar, clavinet, piano, and acoustic guitar. In particular: piano runs, along with the light drumming, work to create a calm jazz feel. Lake's vocals are some of the more ergonomic in Prog: they are not raspy, nasal, or abrasive. His singing is always calm and beautiful, but again the keyboards are the central focus for melody and expression. Lake's bass playing is worth mentioning, as it is quite prominent in the mix (muted, as well, so it sounds very nice)! The piano eventually fades out and an acoustic guitar takes over, sounding like a lazy summer day on the water (Lake's playing is very nice!). Piano then takes over for guitar, and this time there is no bass, no percussion, or singing; there is simple classical piano playing. Emerson plays masterfully, and the fame this has won over the years is well deserved. Eventually the piece ends, not too soon and not too late, when the opening motif is repeated and concluded following a jazz-ey jam.

III. "Knife Edge": A load of powerful prog introduces this bass-guitar heavy piece, a rearranged, modernised "Sinfonietta" (Janáček, 1926). The desparation of "The Barbarian" is again introduced, but there is an entirely new song; no repetition or boring smiliarities. Hammond organ shines strong from Emerson, along with what sounds like several drummers (but always only the amazing Palmer). I absolutely love the bridge theme, taken from a Suite written by Bach but played on organ instead of piano, which is that suite's usual medium. This is one of my favourite warlike pieces with classical overtones that I have heard from ELP, and deserves recognition! Amazing drums, powerful bass, and virtuoistic playing of the Hammond organ.

IV. "The Three Fates": Emerson jumps on to the Royal Festival Hall Organ for a stint of Gothic Impressionism... it is a frightening and grandiose solo organ rendition. The keyboardist's virtuosity borders on that of Rubinstein's technique and Horowitz's emotion once the piano solo evolves after two minutes of music. Not essentially of the Baroque, Classical, or Romantic schools, the piano parts are trumped up forms of post-Impressionist early 20th century playing. The strongest influence appears to be Rachmaninov, that greatest of Russian pianists, but there is a certain proto-classical sound which has strange dissonance in it. It is hard to describe this piece, and that is a very good attribute to have; it is mysterious and seems to tell a story. The lovely Organ arrives again after the length piano segment, with percussion heralding an apocalyptic piano trio. Emerson is in his highest form here, utilizing so many scales, rhythm changes, and effects as to boggle the mind. Whatever bizarre jazz, classical, and folk ideas were flying about in the keyboardist's head as he composed this music, they work very well in practice and leave the listener in a daze of awe.

V. "Tank": Obviously a showing of Palmer's amazing percussive value as a musician. Emerson adds in some psychedelic-sounding clavinet, and Lake's bass playing is smooth and liquidy. As seen above, the classical/jazz influences shine out to a large degree, giving the music its own unique feel. What is truly amazing about the piece is that although it is a showcase for drums, the clavinet and organ still manage to stay equal with the rhythm section.Toward the end of the percussion solo, the producers even added a phasing to the drums to give a synthesized feel. Eventually, bass guitar and moog synthesizer are introduced to give the final review and end this utterly creative bit of Symphonic Prog. Emerson's tweaking of the Moog is an early showcase of what he'd be doing later in true flying colour.

VI. "Lucky Man": The stringent pop-oriented tune that reached its arms up the UK and American charts is quite good. Acoustic, and at times very wide bass guitar give a texture to Lake's harmonized and echoed singing. The guitarist even plays a rare (albiet short and sweet) guitar solo, adding more variation to the piece. Lake's lyrics are not revolutionary philosophical rantings, but they are intruiging in their nice simplicity. When the chorus falls again, sounds of that ominous Moog begin to drift into the piece, heralding one of that instrument's first uses in Prog. Emerson introduces an almost celtic feel of quick successive ups and downs which are intensely anthemic and infectious. That monophonic beauty shows itself for the first time, introduced by the masters of classical-influenced rock.

This review did not view Emerson, Lake & Palmer as amazing musicians until this album entered the fray. Every piece is beautifully composed, played, and expressed; there are hardly any set backs. No one instrument is lacking, and no instrument is overplayed to the extent of irritation and boredom. This is a true classical of Symphonic Progressive Rock, and should be sought by a new listener to this genre. 5/5!

For the record I love ELP. I can still remember going to see them play live in 1972 at the Long Beach arena in Southern California knowing nothing of their music except Lucky Man. I came out of there stunned. Being a piano player I was completely blown away that Keith Emerson had replaced the guitar with his keyboards as the main focus of the music. So of course I went out the next day (or maybe it was the next time I had money. Fuzzy memory there. Well it was the 70's) and purchased all three ELP studio releases.

I listed to them over and over. I still pull out this occasionally anfd I still listen to the whole albuim when I do. To me that is a mark of a classic. What strikes me first is the willingness of the group having such a great singer is producing so many instrumental songs. The Barbarian, Tank, Three Fates and the middle section of Take a Pebble make up for way more than half the album. Starting with t he Barbarian the band is stating to you this is no acoustic guitar singer album. They smash you in the face with an almost metal like violence. Then they turn 180 degrees to the acoustic Take A pebble with it's brilliant vocal and romantic piano lines, then turn back to the thunder with Knife Edge. The Three Fates show off Keith's side as a classical composer moving through three movements with varying intensity and instrumentation. Tank finds us in awe of Carl Palmer's drumming prowess until they leave us with Lucky Man kind of swaying pub song you might sing while drinking with your friends.

Great album on progs earliest examples by three excellent musicians. It was one of my earliest introduction to what would become a long line of great keyboard players. 5 stars.

ELP. Three letters which evokes all the extravaganza and exhuberence you can think of. They have been categorized as pompous, pretentious, bombastic. What is for sure is that those three guys are very gifted. Each of them playing his intrument (s) very well. To decide to not include a guitar player in their line-up in those days was rather bold.

The opener "The Barbarian" is a true ELP song. Every aspect of their personality is represented here. It is a kaleidoscope of what ELP will produce durin the decades to come. One of my all time fave. Powerful, violent and bombastic. This is how I love ELP. This trio is extremely powerful, delivering incredible sounds thanks to each one's virtuosity.

"Take A Pebble" is a showcase for Lake and Emerson. I quite like Lake's very smooth tone of voice; quiet, discreet, almost tranquil. His bass play in the first part of the song is really impressive. The song will evolve into a classic piece during which he will play a very subtle acoustic guitar piece. It is a very slow part, almost silent. Emerson will take up around the middle of the song, as if each has to have the lead on his own.

This will probably affect the cohesion of the band sometimes (cf. Works). Each member playing his part to shine. I do not know if it was a compromise between them or just a fact that arose between them. The last section of the song, is quite jazzy and sounds more as an improvisation. Some nice drumming work as well during this part. IMO, this number lacks in cohesion : no real leading strand.

"Knife Edge" is a difficult number, its dark mood reminds me of KC. It is a powerful track, like the opener. We are far from the subtility of "Take A Pebble". This track clearly announces "Tarkus". It also has all the typical ingredients of a classic ELP track. The trio is sensational : to combine such pieceful (almost religious) music with the heaviest one without transition is a remarkable tour de force. Keith is hitting his keys like a savage. Really good.

The pompous side of the band is clearly illustrated in the intro of "The Three Fates" : sounds like the entry of the gladiators in the arena. Could have been the sountrack of a peplum of the sixties (Wakeman will also sound like that from time to time). These three movements are purely there to push Keith on the front line. This track is a bit annoying. It is again a real band track during the last third of it. Great percussion work again from Carl.

"Tank" is, during the intro sounds more like a combination from the band. It confirms their maestria as a band but inevitably since he was somewhat discreet so far, this number will be the opportunity for Carl to be on the foreground. Great drumming (with a short solo) from one of the greatest rock drummer (all times, all genres).

ELP were short of one song to make a decent lenghty album. So, they were still missing one number. Lake will come with a very old number he wrote while he was twelve (if I remember correctly). It will lead to this very nice little piece of music. The lightest on this album, and even if Lake is of course the frontman here, the band is wonderful in its complementarity. I like that song very much (even after such a long time).

This is a very good debut album for the band. Of course these musicians have already played with big names before so it is not really their debut. What frustrates me on this album, but this is an ELP trademark, is the habit from the E, the L and the P to play each one's part as being more important as the performance of the whole. At least it sounds like this to my ears. Having said this, this album gets all the ELP quintessence. There are no weak numbers, it displays already what the band will produce later on and is, IMO, one of the best they will produce.

Four stars.

ELP were once one of the best prog bands, then they started make some piece too much pretentious and not so good as the four albums.So this is the most equilibrated album of our career,with Emerson not so much intrusive as in other LP's (particularly BSS, very good but even so much Emerson addicted...)...To me is the best album with Trilogy. Take a Pebble is the jewel of this album, maybe the best song ever written by ELP...

this is my favorite elp album, though I don't have trilogy. I do however have tarkus and brain salad to compare with and this one beats them both for me. There's no filler here people, only pure elp greatnes! The barbarian has an excellent hook; a distorted bass riff followed by some 'whole tone' keyboarding which I love. The rest of the song is a fast pased, piano driven classical 'runalong' (you feel like you're running while listening to this one!) Take a pebble has a beautiful intro with piano string strumming. It gives the song an original feel, quite appropriately so. Knife edge is a classic elp favorite with some cool echo effects in the intro theme. It's a perfect example of the trademark elp sound. The three fates is over-the-top awsome! This one starts of with an epic pipe organ intro that soon leads into a whir of piano soloing which eventually leads to a strange jazzy piano jam which is completely awesome! That one is probably my favorite. Next is tank which has some really cool bass work in the beggining segment and an awesome drum solo, which is not too long in my opinion. It is essential to the piece in that it gives a militaristic feel to the song, causing you to imagine a tarkus-like tank rolling by. The solo is followed by some futuristic soloing on the synth. To conclude the album comes lucky man, the acoustic hit. This is the most widely known elp song period! People who don't even know elp like this one, but that's not to say it's out of character for elp. It's all there, just a lot more subtle. An excellent song with excellent vocals. I finally understand the strange synth soloing at the end of the piece; it's the last song on the album. The solo serves as an 'synth bookend' for the album. Elp would not have left you hanging with an acoustic passage. they're elp for heaven sake! The album was destined to end with that strange, seemingly out of place solo. (only seeming out of place when the song is separated from the album) I have to give this one 5/5 because it's the best of elp. The progresiveness is definitely there, and so is the musicianship. Each piece fits nicely and keeps you well interested. A prog masterpiece! Get this one and you'll be a lucky man! (or woman of course!) yep, purplepiper gives it a 5!

A great album from a band would arguably go on to define the genre, and is probably one of their best. I consider ELP to be the drunken frat-boys of progressive rock, since many of their later albums feature ecclectic (and overrated) songs which are neither very progressive or exciting; however, "ELP" is short and sweet, showcasing the band's legitimate talent with a classy set of songs that are a perfect example of the early '70's progressive sound.

The heavy opening of the instrumental "Barbarian" starts things off great, while the soft textures and smoothness of Lake's vocals in "Take a Pebble" really demonstrate the band's range. "ELP" is heavy on instrumentals, but since each member of the trio is outstanding at what they do that isn't necessarily a bad thing. Highly recommended to the very few people reading this who don't already have it!

Songwriting: 4 Instrumental Performances: 4 Lyrics/Vocals: 4 Style/Emotion/Replay: 4

Although i have more interest in albums like Trilogy or Brian salad surgery, this one was a big start for one of the giants of prog rock. At that point, they had only performed at the Isle & Wight festival, so people were all waiting to see what the band could do.

"The barbarian" makes you take notice of what kind of material the band is using and what you are going to get from them. "Take a pebble" and "Knife-edge" are the two best tracks on the album. "Lucky man" was the last minute song and is what put the band on the map as composers, although it is not my favorite song. "Tank" is a good song and it's interesting to have a drum solo, maybe it's too long but a great addition to the album which introduced the real capacities of Carl Palmer. "The three fates" is good, but i could have gone through the album without it.

I recommand this album to people who knows the band. Though it is really good, i don't think it's a good start for new fans.

ELP's debut is, for many, their best and it stands as one fo the finest debuts in prog. Prog rock's first supergroup wasted no time placing themselves at the top of the burgeoning heap, and they would go on to become more popular that Genesis and Yes in the early years. The members brought with them mastery of their respective instruments and would make some defining records. Keith Emerson is the only man who could ever outplay Rick Wakeman. Lake brings his wonderful voice as his incredible bass skill, as well as high competence with a guitar. The stand out, however, is Carl Palmer, who plays the most technical drumming that had ever been heard at that point.

"The Barbarian" opens the album with heavy bass and organ from Lake and Emerson before mellowing out for a bit with piano, then coming back fiercer than ever. It's one of the more enjoyable ELP instrumentals, and it sets teh stage for the high musicianship of the album, especially Carl. "Take a Pebble" features Keith messing with the strings of a piano before playing liek a normal person (if you can call his phenomenal skill "normal"). Lake's voice is incredible, as is his bass. Emerson has some great improv in this song. "Knife Edge" is the best song of the album, and it obliterates the tranquility of the last song with crushing heaviness clearly influenced by Lake's stint with Mr. Fripp. This song is really the best glance into what ELP would sound like on the next few albums. Songs like this show how well these guys could gel, and it's a shame that so many of their arrangements serve only one member at a time.

For example, "The Three Fates" lets Keith show off and "Tank" is Carl's drum solo. They are both very good, especially Tank, but it kills the togetherness by having essentailly two solos back to back. "Lucky Man" is the pop tune for the album. It's the only ELP pop tune I enjoy; later ballads would lack energy or even decent lyrics.

Overall, this is ELP at their rawest. They act like aband, not three separate stars. The next three albums would show ELP conquering the progressive world, until ego and greed got the best of them and they released failure after dismal failure. This remains the only ELP album without filler, and prog fans must have it.

Grade: A-

This debut album shows you a very human side of ELP, but it also shows where they were apt to go wrong. The human side is prevalent in the 12-minute-plus 'Take a Pebble'. This tune has simple lyrics and an attractive melody, but it's especially notable for its extended piano improvisation. Emerson may not be in the same league as Bill Evans, Keith Jarrett or similar virtuosi, but he is fun to listen to, and the interplay with his fellow musicians runs smoothly. I can't think of any other prog pianists who could have pulled off this sort of thing back in the early seventies - certainly not Rick Wakeman, Tony Banks or John Evan. (Perhaps the pianist from Renaissance? I must admit I don't really know that band...)

"ELP going wrong" finally emerges in 'Lucky Man', which would have been a lovely ballad if it had been sung by someone who had true FEELING in his voice (love the moog solo though) and in 'Knife Edge', which is ruined by Lake's clever-clever lyrics. But 'Knife Edge' also proves that Emerson was prog's unmatched Hammond organ hero! I didn't discover ELP until 1975, but back in 1970 this album must have raised great hopes.

Rating: two stars and a half.

This is my favorite ELP album. The fellas in the band were simply playing the music that they liked without the big egos they would later develop, but also with a touch of naivety. The albums opens up with Greg Lake's distorted bass sound, in a similar style as "21st Century Schizoid Man" from King Crimson's first album, but with the addition of Emerson's present piano and hammond organ instead of Fripp's guitar. We hear a potent band but if the whole album was in this style it would quickly get boring. Luckily that's not the case! "Take a Pebble" exemplifies Lake's strong ability to also play guitar, but other than that it's a gorgeous and subdued, something you wouldn't expect from ELP. The middle section is excellent as well with Emerson quoting classical works over a modal riff. "Knife's Edge" is a catchier rock song with more baroque soloing from Emerson. "The Three Fates" is altoghether a more ambitious work and forshadows their more elaborate albums that are seen as masterpieces. We hear a pompous church organ resembling medieval music with the parallel fourths. Emerson takes us on a trip through different sounds in his arsenal. "Tank" is Carl Palmer's showcase but it has a good theme as well. Is there anyone who doesn't know the last track? I've always liked hearing it on classic rock stations myself. This is a great introduction to the band, and essential to any prog rock collection!

The debut album by the famous band.

The barbarian Starting with a loud, distorted bass and heavy Hammond sound, the track then gets into a jzzier mood with Emerson playing a jazzy piano solo, before it returns to the openiong theme again. Nice, but not awesome. 3.5 stars

Take a pebble The track starts off with an atmospheric piano (again jazzy sounding), and soon Lake starts singing in his balladeering manner, which is good and also reminiscent of his work with King Crimson. Then Emerson plays a lovely piano solo, supported by marvelous bass playing from Lake. In the next part, a faster acoustic guitar passage follows, reminiscent of Steve Howe´s acoustic workouts (although less technical). Then another great piano solo by Emerson follows, and later Lake and Palmer join him, and the track becomes increasingly jazzy. The track concludes with the melancholic vocal part again. 5 stars

Knife-edge A rocker driven by Hammond organ and Lake´s vocals, which basically repeat the melody line in verses. Palmer´s drumming is especially great on this one. Emerson also plays a typical solo, which turns later into a Bach - like workout and the track gets the opening part again. 5 stars

The three fates A pointles instrumental. Starts off interestingly with a church like Hammond organ , but later the track develops again into a jazzy piano workout, but this time without much to say. 1.5 stars

Tank Great rhytm section on this one and also solid keyboard playing from Emerson. His organ solo has even a recognizable melody to it. However, I am not that much into the drum solo, even if Lake is one of the best drummers in prog or rock in general. At least it´s short. But Emerson´s moog solo is awful. 0.5 stars

Lucky man A fine, poppy ballad with a nice electric guitar solo from Lake. Still, the moog solo by Emerson it just the same as on the previous track. Starts off nicely, but then gets awful. 4.5 stars

Overal: 3 STARS

GOOD? BUT NON-ESSENTIAL

Any normal new band can afford the luxury of making a good even when not great album but ELP not, they were the first Prog Supergroup, with members who came from great bands as The Nice, Arthur Brown and nothing less than King Crimson, so people should expect not only a solid but a mature album and they partially achieve the goal, even when it's evident we're not before one of their masterpieces.

The album is very good, saying the contrary would be a lie and unfair, but it's far from being even close to the status of masterpiece. Some tracks are almost perfect but others too simple for them, most are well elaborate but as a whole it's a bit uneven, so without more subjective comments, lets check the songs.

"The Barbarian" is an adaptation of "Allegro Barbaro" by the Romanian composer Bela Bartok, quite an ambitious task, but IMHO they fail, at the beginning you don't know if they remain in the Psychedelic era or trying to make some Classical oriented Hard Rock, then they step closer to Jazz and Neo Classical. If I had to say something positive, the drumming by Carl Palmer is quite impressive but nothing else, yes Keith is very skilled but it seems like not able to find a defined style, loud and frantic, but lost in the middle of nowhere.

"Take a Pebble is a solid improvement, Keith starts scratching the chords of the piano and immediately joins the wonderful voice of Carl Palmer sounding better than ever, absolutely impressive and strong, the piano background is incredibly beautiful, then the instrumental section gets even better, Keith proves how good he is in the piano and Carl makes a perfect subtle jazzy drumming, simply love this track.

"Knife Edge" is another adaptation, in this case from Sinfonietta by Janacek, the result is amazing this time, Greg's incredible voice helps a lot and they can really Rock while making radical changes, then the instrumental section is Prog at it's best and the organ solo gives me goosebumps, another excellent track that never bores.

"The Three Fates" simply leaves me cold, seems like Keith lost his path between Rachmaninoff and Debussy and could never find it, it's a pity that the only epic and the best chance they have to demonstrate what they are able is practically wasted, not bad but they were able of much more.

"Tank" starts solid with Keith making his synth sound as a clavichord, the rhythm section works perfectly with Lake at it's best, but the two minute solo by Carl Palmer is way too much, it may be great in a concert to give the rest of the band time to take a breath and get an ovation, but in a studio album is a waste of time, yes we know Palmer is top notch, but this is not the way to prove it, playing perfectly with the rest of the band is better.

After the boring solo, the closing section is also brilliant, Lake is again perfect with the bass and Keith knows what to do when he puts his hands on a Moog, now Palmer does a great job, if there was a way to eliminate the drum solo would be a perfect song, sadly that's not possible so we get a good one and not more.

The album ends with the naïve "Lucky Man", yes I know people will say that Greg wrote this song when he was 11 or 12 years old, what is pretty impressive, but he was 23 and Keith three years older when released, so by this moment it was not a so impressive achievement.

But being honest, the singing is perfect and every album requires a single and a chance for the audience in the concerts to sing along, so "Lucky Man" fulfills it's mission and it's pleasant, at the end the Moog performance by Emerson makes the track much better than the usual acoustic versions sung by the author lately.

Now it's time to rate the album, not a masterpiece so 5 stars is out of the table, but now comes the problem, I'm not sure if it's an excellent addition for any Prog Collection and obviously is not essential from my point of view, but it's more than just good.

This is one of the cases in which I wish there was half stars to rate it with 3.5, but being impossible, will have to go with 3 very solid and a bit unfair stars.

There was a time when keyboard players got no respect. The music press was all Hendrix and Clapton and Page and Beck. And you know who that hot chick in the front row went back to the motel room with; it wasn't the keyboard player. Well, Keith Emerson set out to change all of that.

The opening shot was the first Emerson Lake and Palmer album (sorry, the Nice stuff, while admirable, doesn't count).

The intention is clear right from the beginning: we're a power trio and we don't need no stinkin' guitar player! The Barbarian (never mind that it was an uncredited ripoff of Bartok) is absolutely brutal hard rock. Lake and Palmer -- no strangers to strange bands -- are more than up to challenge. Take a Pebble shows a softer, more contemplative and even experimental side -- I don't think anyone had played a piano zither-style before. Then comes Knife-Edge, which is more flat-out, take-no-prisoners hard rock. Emerson and the band are shoving it down your throat.

With these three songs Emerson forever changed what would be expected of a rock keyboard player. It was no longer enough to be some competent mellotron player (e.g., Moody Blues), or organ power chord purveyor (e.g., Jon Lord of Deep Purple). No, you had best bring some chops to the table if you wanted to be counted among the best.

What was side two of the LP is a bit of a disappointment. The Three Fates hints at where ELP would eventually end up, and Tank is the obligatory drum bit. But Lucky Man is a great vehicle for Lake, and at the end Emerson lays a little moogie-woogie on the king of rock and roll.

The last half of this one runs out of gas, so I'll only give it a 4. However, do not underestimate the importance of this album: proof that a band with no lead guitarist could play devastating hard rock.

This should be the definitive review on ELP's first effort. Some people dodn't understand why the boys included that drum solo in the song "Tank." In my opinion, it is one of the best solos I have ever heard. Also, it has been questioned why "Lucky Man" was included. I will also explain the reasoning behind that move.

This has to be one of the best dubut albums that I have ever heard. This music speaks! It is a visual journey into the future of pure music! The musicianship is immaculate. The singing is well done. This album has no flaws and you wish there was more to listen to when it is over.

The adventure starts with "The Barbarian." This song entices the ear with the mezmerising organ playing of Keith Emerson. His God given talent is seen at once. This guy just outplays any guitarist of that period, hands down! "The Barbarian" is a visual composition that tells a story through the medium of instrumental music. The listener can see a picture of a midevil hunter stalking his prey. Then story teller Emerson plays a middle section that gives the impression of the poor victim trying to get away from the hunter's wrath. For me, this contributes to the suspense of the tune. It is essential to the song. Emerson's playing is riviting and intense! As the song closes, the barbarian finally gets his enemy and bashes him to death. Carl Palmer does a superb job on the drums as he gives life to the end of the song. The listener can see the barbarian mercilessly beat his hapless victim and at the very end he gives his prey a couple more licks for good measure. Simply a facinating song to experience!

Next comes the classically driven "Take a Pebble." Emerson shines again, as continuous melody floods the ear from those beautiful fingers! He just compliments Greg Lakes lyrics. Lake has a strong, distinct voice, that is highly pleasing to the ear. The verse is like a call and answer session between Emerson and Lake. Greg's singing is powerful and evokes graphic images. He sings the first line and Keith pours out beautiful, moody, and fitting replies on his piano. Pure pleasure to hear!

After the second verse, Emerson takes us on a musical journey into the unknown. It is classical music that speaks with every touch of the keyboard. Just when one might think the song is done, Greg Lake begins some wonderful acoustic guitar playing. The reverb effect arouses images(for me, at least) of being out in a wooded meadow by a cool pool of water on a quiet summer's day. Greg does an extraordinary job of giving the listener the impression that he just picks the guitar up and plucks a note here and there. It then progresses to an almost bluegrass-like tune where and audience of 5 or 6 are rhythmically clapping to Greg's "improvised" playing. As the playing winds down, the audience claps as if the song is over. As the last clap is heard, Lake again plays a note here and there. Then he throws in a little classical stuff, showing his well rounded ability on the guitar. As the last harmonic note fades into the distance, Emerson begins to lead the band in a classical jam session that is musically speaking with every beat. As the final verse is sung, Emerson ends the piece with a retarded flurry of meloncoly notes. A real monster of a song!

Next is the dark and forboding "Knife Edge." Lake's lyrics on this one are striking. Again, the music is intense and disciplined. No wasted notes in this one. The bridge is a show case for Emerson's soloing technique. Very well crafted.

On side two "The Three Fates" begins with an overwelming pipe organ piece. It put me to mind of a madman playing the organ in an old horror movie. In contrast, the next part finds Keith playing some of the most beautiful classical music I have ever heard, on the piano. I don't care what anyone says; I can here a little Gershwyn in his style. At any rate, Emerson returns to the organ and again plays the scary. Afterwards the song progresses to multi-layered keyboards with band support. This song is essential for the music lover.

Speaking of essential; the next song "Tank" show cases Carl Palmer's drum pounding abilities. This is a must have for anyone contemplating a career as a drummer! This is pure visual imagery at it's finest! I have never heard anyone come close to a solo like his even in this day of humming bird like flurries.

It starts off with the band playing some animated melodic fare. It is very intricate stuff! Then Carl takes over. This solo had to be an act of God on his behalf! Carl makes the drums sound like a tank firing shells at the enemy. After this he gets the sound of mortar fire in the fast lane. He throws in some traditional drumming as well. Then to top it off, Carl uses the cymbals to emmulate the sound of distant explosions. It is awesome in effectiveness! At the end the band plays a victory march with the moog sounding like a flute player going wild with extreme happiness. It sounds like a celebration on wheels, no less! Like I said before, I have never heard anything like this to this day!

The finale to the album is "Lucky Man." Back in the early days of prog, Bands like ELP, Yes, and others wanted to induce the general public to listen to their music by giving them something easier to take. So they most generally put at least one pop tune on their albums. No doubt the record execs were pressuring the bands to use the top 40 as a springboard. Anyway Greg Lake is the featured artist here. This song blends the acoustic guitar with the electric, as well as the computer renderings of the moog synth. The tune is tastefully done with highly satisfying results. It almost sounds like something out of the 16th century. Palmer's playing is poised, polished, and proper. It really enhances the rest of the song. The theme deals with a sarcastic look at glorifying war. Lake is in top form as far as the lyrics and music go. He is also an excellent bass player.

For the above reasons, I can give this album no less than five stars. It is a killer effort! I just wish that this review would find its way into ELP's hands. I think they would get a kick out of it too.

The birth of EMERSON,LAKE AND PALMER (simply E.L.P.) came true,when Keith Emerson of ''The Nice'' met Greg Lake of ''King Crimson'' at a concert,where the two bands shared the same stage.The two men had complementary opinions on musical direction and recruiting Calm Palmer of ''Atomic Rooster'' behind the drum kit,they formed E.L.P. amd moved on to record their eponymous debut in 1970.A high-class work,''Emerson,Lake and Palmer'' is a great combination of KING CRIMSON's smooth yet amazingly-arranged prog rock with THE NICE's classical approach.The sensitive vocals of Greg Lake are excellent,while Emerson fills the instrumental space with awesome suite-like organ themes,sometimes mellow sometimes bombastic.The powerful drumming of Palmer is fantastic,while I recognize some slight jazz influences in their music.''Emerson,Lake and Palmer'' is a beautiful start of a magical journey for E.L.P. in the progressive rock planet!

An irrelevant debut.

No, it's not the album that is irrelevant. The fact that it's a debut doesn't mean much. It could also be someone's last album, the only album or randomly generated sounds by some aliens, appearing on the Earth in 1970 by a coincidence. It's so unique. Where did these guys came from? Well, we know the story: THE NICE; ARTHUR BROWN; KING CRIMSON, but...where did the ideas originated? Obviously, Keith had a main role here. As a performer and as a composer. Now I know, not all the material is originally Emerson's, but back then I wasn't familiar with Bartók or Janáček. They were not credited, and I heard they had some problems because of that...and as a sidenote, Greg was absolutely unaware of that musical "borrowings". I won't comment legal and moral issues - however ELP popularised a contemporary classical music to a wider audience (remember, this was recorded in 1970, when sympho rock was POPular). The album consists of six songs; six different ideas. Hmm, that sounds stupid. Of course they have to be different ideas if they are different songs...but what I'm trying to say is....they were new, fresh band. The direction that band should follow was not clear yet - so they were lost in different paths, different concepts...different ideas. In a word, they lacked focus. From that point of view, this is so typical debut. Of course, what makes a difference is the music. There is no bad song here, they're just all too different. Okay, now we are crossing that tiny line from concept (or lack thereof) to the substance...and here we are, grinded, mutilated by piano keys, stabbed by a church organ, while arpeggios are bleeding and drums are enfilading us.

It's that powerful, and more. In the most furious moments (personally, my favourite moment from the album) we have a piano trio, with perverse chord progressions, evil rattlesnake percussion and 7/4 time measure that is vivisection of all things related to madness. On the weakest side, we have poppy folk balladry - which is not bad at all, with its clever usage of text (I dare say ironical). ELP were always touching the subject of battles, wars, madness...and that story started here. In "Tank" (sic!) we have detailed picture of a tank and his driver: scared little man, reluctant to go, drives a tank and slowly enters the battlefield as his madness is growing. Great clavinet and bass melodies here are making so plastic, tactile, humid picture of his brain. Drum solo is not a show-off for Mr. Palmer; it's a middle of the battlefield, showing as machine guns, cannons and enfilades. The final of the song utilises heavy layers of synths: madness is here. The tank proceeds, but not intact. Blood-red are the eyes of the driver. The tank is advancing and crushing everything in front of him without mercy. Those high-pitched synth solo, don't they sound like weepings and screams? The story has no conclusion, since it's faded. The destiny is to be imagined. The closing song is explicitly criticising the aforementioned topic, plus with the music, the solo at the very end...isn't that the sound of bullet hitting the body? All these pictures will be developed further on, on the albums to come (please see my reviews), but the big idea started here. The debut is inconsistent, innocent, at the moments naïve. The song themselves are filled with monstrosity. Young, raging brains struggling to explode in all possible directions. How could I dislike it?

Before many of the well known prog bands of the classic period had started to roll, these guys formed prog's most loved and hated supergroup.

Keith Emerson and Greg Lake met while playing the same gig with their respective bands. They decided they would do well together and recruited Carl Palmer. What resulted is an album of many strengths.

As was his way in The Nice, Keith arranged piano and orchestral works for rock. On ELP's debut, he transformed pieces by 20th century composers Bela Bartok and Leos Janacek into prog works. Bartok's Allegro Barbaro was dressed up into The Barbarian and Janacek's Sinfonietta became their song Knife Edge, in which Keith also inserts Bach in the middle. ELP also added lyrics to this, and interesting ones too!

Take a Pebble and Lucky Man are quite frequently referred to as Greg Lake Ballads. Well, Take a Pebble is absolutely fabulous and is probably Lake's best composition. It utilizes a lot of nice piano and guitar work, as well as Keith plucking the piano strings. Lucky Man is a nice song that Lake apparently wrote as a child. The moog solo is the best part. I've read that Keith improvised the solo and that they kept the first take. He said he felt it wasn't his best as he has and could've done much better. I agree with this but it is still good.

The other two are instrumentals. The Three Fates features Keith and if anyone ever needed proof of his ability (let's just pretend), this is all they would need. Tank is more or less Carl's song. I say this because he is most prominent. He even has a two minute drum solo. Keith also makes his presence known in the song with many great, flashy runs and synth parts.

Not many bands can get off to as great a start as ELP did. Perhaps it was their experience in previous bands that allowed them to do this. This is their most solid effort. There are no weaknesses. They do a fine job in composition/arrangement and still show their virtuosity in every track. ELP is my favorite ELP album and feel it is essential to every prog collection, like them or not.

Review 1, 1970, Emerson, Lake and Palmer

This self-titled debut is, in my opinion, the progressive supergroup's best. Of the six tracks, only one (Emerson's 'The Three Fates') suffers from any doubtful taste, and even that has a beautiful section. This is an even more astounding accomplishment given the sheer versatility of the music produced: a great folk ballad with a moog solo that never ceases to amuse me, the essential acoustic masterpiece, the heavier Hammond-based Barbarian and Knife Edge, the drumming-dominated Tank, and the various noodlings that comprise The Three Fates. Even though ELP have produced several excellent prog albums, this is the one I'd call essential.

Barbarian introduces the trio perfectly, with a growling electric guitar, a superb heavy Hammond organ, and tasteful drumming. The music's constantly shifting, yet retains all its rawness. And suddenly, there's an acoustic section with quirky, yet delightful, piano and drumming. And somehow Emerson escalates that back to the main tune's heaviness flawlessly. And it just gets better and better towards the end. Proof that a progressive masterpiece does not need to be long.

Next we have my all-time ELP favourite, Take A Pebble. It's just three musicians on acoustic instruments working together flawlessly, with gorgeous, flowing classical-inspired piano supported by Lake's delicate bass and acoustic guitar parts, tasteful percussion, inspired use of watery sound-effects, strong vocals (most reminiscent of Epitaph) with beautiful surreal lyrics. The band shifts moods between optimism, anticipation, grandeur and surprisingly heavy, dark moods seamlessly. Emotion oozes from the piano and the vocals. There are no weak moments in all the twelve and a half minutes of beautiful music.

Third in the album we have another heavier piece, Knife Edge. This took me a little longer to acquire than the previous two songs, but the excellent bass lines, mantra-like, almost-spoken vocals, slightly darker drumming with brief drum solos, and superb build-up and entertaining keyboard riffs and parts ultimately make for a great song. I particularly like the weird churchlike instrumental section in the middle. The lyrics are solid, and work very well with the music. It ends with a slowing-down effect and sort of clicks to a stop. As progressive as Barbarian, and though it doesn't quite reach the heights of the opener, it's still a masterpiece.

The Three Fates is a little more mixed. The organ-opener Clotho hasn't really made an impression on me, but it's well worth listening to through to move onto the beautiful piano solo, Lachesis. Delicate, beautiful, tasteful, mobile, and fairly symptomatic of Emerson's piano on the album as a whole. Atropo is another entirely different kettle of fish, with a combination of the instrumentation used earlier in The Three Fates and a little percussion, if I'm not mistaken. The build-up to a final explosion sound effect is quite good, and has a bizarre dramatic atmosphere that goes down quite well. Overall, this track's not quite as good as the rest of the album, but still interesting, at times masterful, and well worth listening to.

Tank is another oddity. Bass and drumming paves the way for another flippant keyboard (Moog, I think) part, sustained by the bass and brief bursts of solo drumming leading up to a longer (though not excessive), extremely good drum solo with a real sense of direction that many solos lack. It builds up extremely well and leads into the return of the bass and the moog. Yet another great, charming prog piece.

Lucky Man rounds off the album soundly. It's in a much less progressive vein than the rest of the album, but that doesn't really matter to me. The basic melody and the bass part is good, Palmer's drumming complements it nicely, you get to hear more of Lake's voice. And finally, there's a hilarious moog part. Emerson was apparently not taking the solo entirely seriously when he played it, but it's still brilliant. Although it's really more folk than prog, I still love this song.

In conclusion, I'm giving this album one of the easiest five star ratings that I'm ever likely to give. I love it. This is ELP at their finest, with electronic and acoustic instrumentation both used to their full effect. Accessible, yet a grower. As much loved as In The Court Of The Crimson King or Selling England By The Pound. Well worth buying, and also a good introduction to the band.

Rating: Masterpiece. Five Stars.

Favourite Track: Take A Pebble.

Exclusive: Doves Cause Baldness?

It should be self evident that reviews of such pivotal progressive rock albums as this one one must be tempered by the heights/depths a band subsequently reached after their release. Had I heard this for the 1st time in 1970, I would have been quite simply 'blown away' as they say, as there had been nothing quite like it hitherto.

Preamble over, on with the music.

'The Barbarian' - although rather cheekily not credited to Bartok on the initial pressings, this remains perhaps my favourite ELP track ever. Venomous and sinewy Lake bass, snarling and attacking Hammond plus a kit assault from Palmer that stills leaves me speechless. The piano/brushes interlude in the middle comes as a welcome respite from the unremitting carnage that bookends this classical adaptation. When the track ends, you are changed forever....

'Take a Pebble' - Emerson's musical designs dwarf what is at best, a pleasant enough but rather insubstantial Lake ballad which completely outstays it's welcome. The piano playing is as ever, masterful, but given the paucity of melodic material available here with which to improvise on, Emerson runs out of ideas well before half way. The rudimentary guitar solo in the middle, replete with the atmospheric cave sounds, is mixed far too low and served only to become an area on the original vinyl record that proliferated scratches in glorious hi fidelity stereo.

'Knife Edge' - Notwithstanding another little copyright 'oversight' re the disgruntled Janacek estate, this is a belter of the first order with a fantastic organ solo that still exhilarates 37 years on. Great singing from Mr Greg but collaborating with a roadie is more than likely to result in terrible lyrics (Fraser) The band always had a terrific knack for adapting just the right classical piece to suit their own musical ends and Bach's Italian Concerto quoted here is no exception. Like most people in 1970 I too thought my record player had melted during the 'slow down' section at the end.

'Three Fates' - Wonderful playing from Emerson throughout his 'solo' contribution after a rather boggy and sludgy intro on the pipe organ (which became de rigueur for all his subsequent imitators/wannabees thereafter). Can't help but feeling that the whole is less than the sum of it's parts on this one. Lots of great ideas follow on from each other sequentially but the overall architecture creaks a bit. Greg and Carl's entire summed contribution appears to be restricted to the latin flavoured final section.

'Tank' - Probably the closest ELP got to playing jazz rock in their careers. Brilliant harpsichord and clavinet from Emerson, and fat boy turns in a tour de force on bass. Being the early 70's, this sprawling epic could not be complete without recourse to a lengthy drum solo. I have heard and been entertained by many of Carl's solos over the years but must say that this is the worst one he ever committed to tape. When the hopelessly dated phased drumming enters, it's such a relief to hear the swung ending section after the tedium that preceded it. Emerson's ominous Moog makes it's first appearance here and at the time, was an alien timbre that we were all completely bowled over by. Ground breaking stuff indeed.

'Lucky Man' - the band's only stateside hit probably gave the yanks the impression that ELP was the UK's answer to CSNY. Lake's pretty but inconsequential acoustic song certainly milks undeserving resources from Emerson and Palmer which would have been better utilised on more group material. Similarly with Take a Pebble the arrangement is far superior to the underlying musical ideas. Much has been written about Emo's famous outro Moog solo, so I won't labour the point, but according to his autobiography he states

I thought it was [&*!#], I still do...

Personally, I love it and it seduced me thereafter into a lifelong love affair with the synthesizer and Prog Rock in general. Having now read both Keith and Greg's autobiographies it seems their respective versions of events often contradicts that of the other as to how this track came into being. Both agree that the album was 3 to 4 minutes short of the industry standard 40 minute running time required by the record company. Greg therefore pitched his acoustic ballad written when he was barely in his teens to address this. Keith tried initially to contribute some organ but soon abandoned this and asked Lake to record the song on his own before retreating to the pub. When a 'refreshed' Emerson returned, he expressed admiration for how far the arrangement had developed with the addition of drums, bass, electric guitar and backing vocals. He suggested a synth solo over the fade-out using Advision's resident Moog which had lain undisturbed in the studio for a long time as everyone confirms they were afraid to touch it (including engineering guru Eddy Offord) Lake however, states that a Bob Moog prototype was only delivered to the studio the same day as the Lucky Man solo was recorded and that when Keith was asked 'what does it sound like' he replied 'I don't really know, I've never used it in a studio' This all begs the question: If the Moog features on Tank, weren't they actually closer to 11 minutes shy of the desired 40 minute running time? The reason for Keith acquiescing to leave his solo on the recording may be considerably more mundane than any offered previously i.e. the Performing Rights bean counters wouldn't have allowed them to release the song as a single byELP if Emerson didn't play on it.

To sum up:

The problems of satisfying such a disparate trio of personalities as ELP were manifest as early as this 1970 album. The inclusion of 'solo' tracks can be interpreted two ways: as an expediency to placate a record label anxious to meet the voracious demand for product before sufficient group material had been worked up or, ELP as an ego massage parlour. Coming full circle at the demise of their career on the 1977 Works album, the symmetry is complete, with each member getting a side each of a double album.

ELP made progressive rock possible with both their viability in terms of sales wedded to their brilliant musicianship. The history of popular music dictates that up till that point, the two were considered mutually exclusive.

Possibly the best debut album ever.

The musicians are of course no debutants but having each a notable background (The Nice, King Crimson, Atomic Rooster, Arthur Brown). Expectations were high when this super group was formed and they were even able to exceeded them. A masterful record from first note to last.

THE BARBARIAN: a cover version of Bartok's Allegro barbaro for solo piano and a very heavy entry for such an artful album. When listening to it a thought sprang to my mind: maybe ELP are the unknown founder of art metal - just listen to the hefty ending of the piece. Who needs Black Sabbath when you can have stuff like this one. (5/5)

TAKE A PEBBLE: the beautiful mellow counterpart to the barbarian. Beautifully executed by everybody, 12 minutes long, never getting boring. The vocal melody is superb as is Emerson on piano. (5/5)

KNIFE EDGE: takes up the mood of The Barbarian. Very heavy again, and again a cover version of a piece by a classical composer (Janacek), with lyrics from Lake. Still a concert favourite today. (5/5)

THE THREE FATES: highlights Emerson once more. Certainly the most awkward (or should I say demanding) piece on the album: Organ solo, piano solo, piano trio. Here Emerson makes no compromise to the average pop/rock consumer. But once you acquired the taste for the organ solo, you'll find The Three Fates up to par with the rest of the album. The secret, rewarding highlight, I daresay. (5/5)

TANK: a drum solo with keyboard accompaniment. The keyboard sound I find strange and a bit unpleasant (reminds me of the keyboard stuff Zappa & The Mothers did on Uncle Meat and Burnt Weeny Sandwich). Then comes the drum solo proper - and Palmer blows me away. One of the most melodic drum solos I've ever heard. So great! (4/5).

LUCKY MAN: yes, I know, no-one knows this song ;-). But did you recognise that almost all of it is a duet between Lake and Palmer (immensely beautiful drumming!) until Emerson comes in at the very end? It took me years to realize that it's just voice guitar and drums most of the time. Here the masters show us what they can do with a simple pop tune. (5/5)

5 stars, simply stated. You'll bereave yourself if you avoid this album.

I really am in turmoil to award anything less than 5 stars for this Supergroup's debut album.... From the 1st time I was turned on to ELP - (then it was Crimso, Nice, Asia, Yes, Atomic Rooster, Genesis, Floyd etc ..........) I knew this was the complexity and sound I desired for my sort of music. With this album, I loved the brutal fuzz-Bass (on the opener 'The Barbarian'), Hammond Organ/Piano play, also an early display of a Moog synthesizer, fully endorsed by its creator, Dr. Robert Moog....., and for Carl Palmer's beyond 'rock-music' approach to his drum-kit (he did display his amazing dexterity on Atomic Rooster's debut album, particularly on the track 'Decline and Fall'....), so, this record stands as an amazing amalgam of different styles of music, all rolled into one highly attractive and accessible offering on a musically hungry demanding public. Of course, this album came out well before I was born, but, I feel that these sorts of changes were quite revolutionary within music's development.....(please correct me if I'm wrong....). There's been recent evaluations on various ELP albums at this time, and I would just like to support their albums with my honest feelings toward their music. Sure, a 5 star Canterbury album means so much to me, in terms of quality.....but, ELP are totally amazing as well........I can understand why a certain amount of listeners don't dig these guys........

I can really get into this album because it simply rocks out. It's intense, bombastic, and ELP's best. Other than this album, I've never really gotten into the band. I've heard most of their stuff, but it all kind of pales in comparison to this debut. This is probably the only ELP album I'd highly recommend!

How to review and rate a perfect work , that effected your life in 55 years ?????? the year 1970 , a vintage year for masterpieces in progressive releases , and the revolution started . there was no wars in the world except the cold war ( freezed) , and the progressive rock war ( in action ) Since 1970 , i'm still asking myself about the status of Greg Lake as one of the best Vocalists , bass & guitar player , comparing between the two masterpieces , In the Court & E.L.P , What a tough job ???? Whatever was your opinion in KC or ELP , in Robert or Emerson , Simply Greg Lake was jumping all over there creativity , by performing incredibly in all tracks . So , this album of 1970 , was like a KNIFE EDGE to me , and i was a LUCKY MAN to have it , cause it was made for non BARBARIANs fans , like myself . Have Faith in my opinion and discover it , it's extremely essential ,,,,,,,,,,,,, 5 Stars .............................. ThANKs .......... Tracks Toni

I have been looking forward to making this review as it has been a very long time since I listened to this album the last time and it´s nice to come back with fresh eyes to see if it´s really as good as I rememeber it. This is ELP´s debut album. ELP consists of Keith Emerson ( The Nice) on keyboards, Greg Lake ( King Crimson) on vocals, bass, electric & acoustic guitar and Carl Palmer ( Atomic Rooster) on drums. A kind of supergroup. Both Keith Emerson and Carl Palmer are without a doubt virtuosos on their respective instruments while I have always had a hard time really appreciating Greg Lake´s efforts. He´s a good musician no doubt, but I never felt he was as brilliant as the others. Quite franky I never liked his voice much. It´s hard to explain but it never touched me but it didn´t annoy me either. It´s just there.

The music is rock inspired heavily by classical music. There are only keyboards, bass, drums and vocals in the music but Keith Emerson dominates the soundscape with his keyboards, so you don´t miss any other instrument. This is truly a power trio. The music is mostly instrumental but there are vocal parts which is of course great for the diversity. There are some really good songs on this debut album and I would mention The Barbarian, Take a Pebble, Knife-Edge and Tank as the highlights of the album while I find The Three Fates to be too much noodling and Lucky Man too commercial.

What I enjoy most about this album is the musicianship. Let me just state that it is outstanding and there are several breathtaking moments throughout the album.

The sound quality is excellent. One of the best productions from that time.

There are many positive things to say about this album and I have mentioned a few, but somehow ELP never really excited me much. Their musicianship has always been the most exciting thing about them while I always found most of their songs to be emotionless compared to other great bands from that time like Genesis, Gentle Giant and Yes. It´s about the same feeling I have always had with King Crimson even though I like them a bit more than ELP. I know this sounds very negative but this is a good album and I do like it more than it sounds like when you read the above lines. I would have rated the album 4 stars but after some second thoughts I have decided that I will rate it 3 big stars.

Emerson Lake & Palmer's eponymous debut hit the world in 1970 and started what would become a fruitful, yet at times trying relationship among these three talented musicians. Labeled as a supergroup at the time, and although unfortunate that they never got the chance to explore the incorporation of Jimi Hendrix into the group due to his unfortunate death, that supergroup label stuck with them ever since, even during their dismal return in the 1990s. It was well deserved nonetheless.

Although the talent was there, much of the material off their debut was mostly solo-related. The only song where all three received credits was on the opening track The Barbarian. Lake was responsible for both ballads, Take a Pebble and Lucky Man. The latter track was originally recorded to fill leftover space on the record at the request of the record company. It was actually penned by Lake as a teenager, not well received by either Emerson or Palmer, and featured a one-take, improvised Moog solo at the end by Emerson. It became one of the band's biggest hits and a concert favorite.

Carl Palmer is showcased on Tank where he shows off his virtuoso drumming style. The remaining tracks are Emerson's contributions. Incorporation of classical influences is easily noticeable with references to Bartók, Janáček, and Bach. In fact, many of these inspired pieces were note-for-note extractions placed inside a rock music setting, something Emerson is most noteworthy for. Original or not, it made for some interesting listening showcasing some beautifully played symphonic prog rock with many complex time signatures.

My biggest issue with ELP is that each of their albums seems to have a couple of what seem to be unnecessary tracks just thrown in like they were there to fill up the space, maybe even precursors to what we all know as bonus tracks these days. For me, they tend to be the ballads and acoustic numbers written by Lake. When you have someone pounding away on the keyboards like a madman, although sloppy at times, and follow it up with a sleepy lullaby, the unevenness is glaring. Sometimes that can be put to good effect, but not here nor in any other ELP album that features this flaw. Furthermore, just from hearing these differences in style between Lake and Emerson on their very first album clearly shows the personality conflicts that would erupt between them for many years to come.

An excellent debut with a perfect marriage of classical and complex rock, but with some flaws like the Lake filler and a question of being slightly unoriginal. Clearly very pretentious, but we all like that about ELP, don't we? Definitely a worthwhile purchase and easily worth four stars.

It's both a surprise and an impressive statement that this first album by the symphonic supergroup is their best. The complicated relations of the three members and their individual talents actually work alongside each other at one-hundred percent here, creating a focus and determination one would have wanted for all the successive albums, but sadly is found only here.

There has always been a deep schism in ELP's music, between top-class symphonic numbers and the more accessible songs, appealing to a wider audience. Heading off in your own direction, with the choice of combining these two styles, is by many considered the biggest flaw of the group. I'm often, but definitely not always, agreeing with it since it makes many of the albums feel like bags of wild ideas, without relation to each other and far from being in touch with the audience. It's an egocentric, introvert yet flamboyant style of music you often love OR hate. Stuck in a middle-ground between these camps, I find ELP's career to be an interesting mix of highs and lows. The self-titled debut is a definite high. It's definitely focused on sheer, brutal musicianship, leaving vocals and lyrics a little behind. If you find this hard to bear, be warned.

With a menacing distorted guitar, The Barbarian opens the album in classic ELP style. Aggressive, loud and forceful, with technical and jagged keys from mr. Emerson and drum power from Palmer, you know you're in for a proper tour-de-force. Interestingly, the song develops into a nervous, paranoid theme with a compulsion that reminds me of Banco Del Mutuo Soccorso's Darwin!, only to return to more violent ground and the abrupt ending.

Showcasing ELP's most prominent feature - the polarity - Take A Pebble is next. It's stunningly beautiful, sometimes reminiscent of the mellower King Crimson tunes, but with a lot more emphasis on piano. Soft-singing, Greg Lake delivers the first vocal line of this great tune. It's not sad, but reflective in nature. Mystical and enthralling, it's carried away on Emerson's delicate piano. The odd, cheerful middle-part with guitar feels very Yes-like for a while, but it's deceptive. In a matter of seconds, the piano is back, very classical-sounding this time. A real pleasure for tired ears.

Lucky Man closes this phenomenal album, being the last jigsaw in the ELP puzzle. Simple in structure, light-hearted in ideas and concept and perhaps frustratingly accessible to some, it's a quality rock song nevertheless. Acoustic guitar as a textural backdrop, with a relaxed electric solo, standard drumming and Emerson surprisingly out of the picture. He delivers a Moog solo in the end, but it's actually not that mind-boggling. A fair, but not brilliant ending.

Aggression is what prevails though, and most of the remaining songs wander off in that direction. The hard-rocking Knife Edge, a bit like something by Atomic Rooster, the chaotic and brilliant Three Fates, which I didn't like at all from the beginning, but which has evolved into an amazing display of Emerson's, but also Carl Palmer's disciplined frenzies as instrumentalists.

It is absolutely an odd collection of songs. But they all work together, sharing one important thing: impressive quality. And sometimes that's all you need. There are some jazzy parts thrown around, there is a lot of arty pretension, stunning displays of skill, drama and fire. Borderline masterpiece.

4 stars.

//LinusW

Of their first four classic albums, this self titled debut is far and away my favourite. It's almost like it was tailor-made for me. Perfect fit. It's difficult to estimate how influencial this album became, but make no mistake it became a template for many bands who followed. I could heap praise upon each one of these three guys for their individual talents and no one would argue, but I think Palmer is the one who surprised me the most on this debut with his drum skills. I mean he's only 19 years old here but playing like a passionate, seasoned veteran.

"The Barbarian" is raw and dirty to open. Check out Lake's filthy fuzz bass ! Meanwhile Emerson is ripping it up on his Hammond organ. Palmer meanwhile is simply incredible on the kit. Things change 1 1/2 minutes in as piano and drums take over. A gong sound signals a return of that fuzz bass and those nasty organ runs. Palmer is so good just firing off round after round. A knock out punch and they're just getting started. "Take A Pebble" is pastoral track with Lake's pleasant vocals as Emerson tinkles on the piano. The tempo picks up after 2 1/2 minutes with piano leading the way. A calm before 4 minutes with Lake on acoustic guitar. The tempo picks back up 5 1/2 minutes in with clapping. Back to a calm and acoustic guitar. Piano takes over 6 1/2 minutes in. Drums start to get more prominant after 9 minutes and bass joins in too. Vocals are back before 11 1/2 minutes to the end of the song.

"Knife-Edge" features sinister sounding organ, and vocals that are darker. An uptempo organ/drum melody follows. These themes are repeated. Check out the organ and drums 3 1/2 minutes in. It becomes powerful 4 minutes in with vocals and killer organ runs. "The Three fates" opens with pipe organ. It's so powerful ! Piano 2 minutes in. Yes Emerson can play ! The organ is back 4 1/2 minutes in. Piano and drums follow. Great sound before 6 minutes. An explosion ends it. Appropriate. "Tank" opens with drums and a clavinet solo from Emerson. This all sounds pretty incredible. A collage of intricate sounds fills the air. Check Palmer out 2 minutes in until after 4 minutes when the other two finally join in. Love the synths 5 minutes in to the end of the song. "Lucky Man" was written by Lake when he was around 12 years old when he was learning to play guitar. He dreamed of what it would be like to be rich. To be a lucky man. I first heard this song when I was in my teens in the mid seventies and have never grown tired of it. It's a mellow song that tells a story. Acoustic guitar, vocals and drums to open. Awesome sound before 2 minutes. Palmer is so intricate, very Bruford-like here. Of course it ends with that famous moog synthesizer solo. Emerson didn't own one at this point, but there was one in the studio belonging to MANFRED MANN's Mike Vickers. He borrowed it and the rest is history.

Rave up

Emerson Lake & Palmer's self-titled debut is one of the classic albums, not only of the band but of the whole genre of Symphonic progressive Rock. Several of the album's tracks went on to become staples of the band's live sets and have appeared on several live albums and compilation.

The album opens with the menacing The Barbarian (which, when I played it aloud today, frightened my cat so much it hid under the bed!). This is an adaptation of a piece by composer Béla Bartók. This sort of adaptation of classical music was something that was to become a trademark of the band, and music composed by Leo? Janáček and Johann Sebastian Bach is used on the track Knife-Edge.

The Three Fates is an original three part composition by Keith Emerson in a classical vein while Take A Pebble and Lucky Man are written by Greg Lake in a more folky in nature and Tank shows Carl Palmer's jazzy influence. This mixture of Classical, Folk, and Jazz within a Rock context is the life blood of the band and essential to their greatness.

The band had yet to mature fully, but they were already very good here. A very good start of a brilliant band. Highly recommended!

I've said it before, so why not again. In my opinion, Mr. Lake is one of the best singers of the prog scene. Just listen to Take a Pebble and you'll know what I mean. This album is a good debut, a lot better than the follower, greatly recommended. However, as an ELP album, the influences from everyone's old bands are apparent and come out pretty well.

The Barbarian is a good showdown of the guy's skills. For the first time listener who thought of finding about this band, it's a good opener. Though nothing much more than an influental instrumental piece, it's still pretty consistent and ongoing.

Take a Pebble has become one of my favourites. Though in the beginning it's very similar to early King Crimson. Of course because of the singer, but also for the melodies. It's a slow and moody song, a very nice combination of good piano and singing. Of course, on this song and on this album there's a lot more guitar than prehaps later on, as Greg Lake is more of a bass player than a guitarist, and Keith Emerson takes over the melodic/instrumental part of the music. After exploring the guitar, a beautiful grand piano takes over. Really a treat for the ear. Then after some musical passages you realise again what song it is with the nice lyrics and the pompous drumming of David Palmer, for a short while.

Knife Edge was to begin with one of my big favourites. It's a bit more heavy than your usual ELP, but it's got a really nice melody and a thrilling riff. The solo part for the organ is really groovy.

The next a 3 parted keyboard assembly is what I meant with Mr. Emerson taking over the musical part of the band. These are of course great listenings to a pianist, but as a jazz guitarist like me, they're just, well, virtuosity, but perhaps not all that full of greatness as a whole band construction would be. Well, Lachesis is my personal favourite, it's really melodic and nice. The piano trio later on gets a bit too confusing to sound like something you'd want to listen to the whole day through.

As a musician, I'm really thankful for them letting David Palmer play a long and nice drumsolo for Tank. Other than that, it's really not much of a song, but the music of this band seems to be a bit too much just around two persons. Ok, so frankly the solo's not that good, but at least he gets to jam it all off.

Lucky Man doesn't probably need any introduction. This song must be one of the most known ELP tracks. A nice pop-rock song, not really any prog. Well, I guess it was made for getting the album sold.

In the end, this is one of the two ELP albums that I think are the best. A nice debut indeed, and because ELP is such a huge name in the prog scene, for self-civilizing reasons, everyone should probably give this one a go at one point or another. I'm going to give this one 3 stars. 4 would have been my original plan, but in the end, it's a collection of good songs, nothing excellent really, nothing grounbreaking.

The trio of Keith Emerson, Greg Lake, and Carl Palmer, who created a few of the greatest progressive rock masterpieces imaginable, begin their adventure together weakly and rather disjointedly. It is hard for me to imagine the celebration of this album next to the reactions of horror that typically accompany Works Volume 1, particularly since what they seem to be here are three outstanding musicians who are completely apprehensive about working together. This album is a hodgepodge of classical and jazz piano music, singer-songwriter ballads, crunchy organ, and daring instrumentals.

"The Barbarian" With a distorted introduction and some grating organ, along with wild snare-slapping and dynamic bass playing, the first one-and-a-half minutes of this piece is an excellent idea of what the band will sound like on forthcoming releases. What follows that, however, is a sudden piano interlude. It takes getting used to in the overall context of the piece, but it demonstrates Emerson's ability well. After this, there is more in the vein of what came before. It is one of the band's best instrumental tracks, and certainly the best instrumental on this album.

"Take a Pebble" The opening to this one features alternating harmonious and discordant chords that makes one think of an autoharp played with only the benefit of a strumming hand. Overall, this is less like progressive rock and more like directionless meandering. The folk section that comes in later is apropos of nothing. Six-and-a-half minutes in, there is beautiful piano playing, some of Emerson's best, but again, it just seems capricious in context. Later, the band enters to make what sounded like classical piano jazzy. Lake's vocals bookend this unnecessarily long track, but just as the keyboard work up until this point has finely exhibited Emerson's ability, his singing displays what he will sound like during his finer moments with the group.

"Knife Edge" The second of three vocal tracks, this song takes what was great about the first track and what was great about the second track, namely Emerson's organ and Lake's vocals, respectively, and blends them to produce a highly enjoyable listen. The song repeats themes without becoming repetitive, paving the way for further organ work. After the middle section (an ELP highlight in and of itself), Lake returns with more energized vocals. It's unfortunate the song fizzles out in the manner it does.

"The Three Fates (Clotho/Lachesis/Atropos)" This is the point in the album where ELP begin to seem less like a ensemble, and more like a threesome of solo artists sharing studio time. Emerson has already shown how amazing he is at what he does, so why the need for an extended three-part instrumental exclusively featuring church organ, piano, and then more piano with some unwarranted drumming? While it's certainly understandable that ELP (and many artists in the early seventies) were not consciously trying to write progressive rock (the way many modern symphonic acts seem to be doing), Emerson's solo act is no more progressive rock than any classical or jazz pianist playing alone is.

"Tank" Finally Palmer gets a real opportunity to show his stuff, with a drum solo both to open the song and two minutes in. The dual clavinets and piano are all over the place for the most part during the time before this, which is sad really, because the bass line is truly one of Lake's best. It is not until Palmer's solo is finished that Emerson finally breaks out the Moog, using it both as a solo instrument and to beef up the rhythm section.

"Lucky Man" Almost an afterthought, it was this song that was largely responsible for taking ELP to the airwaves. Its chords are played on a twelve-string guitar and Lake sensitively sings the words. The improvised synthesizer solo at the end sounds out of place and can be annoying in parts. Overall, it's a good song, but nothing at all compared to what would come.

Keith Emerson (The Nice), Carl Palmer (Atomic Rooster) and Greg Lake (King Crimson) in one band. This debut by these great musicians is as good as one could expect. In some way it sounds like an improved version of The Nice with a far better vocalist and a better drummer. They copied some of the intellect and magic of King Crimson and made symphonic/eclectic prog. This trio of musicians became very influential with the key-bass-drum line-up and inspired bands like Triumvirat and Trace.

"The Barbarian" is an instrumental and the best track of the record. It's intellectual and dark. "Take a pebble" reminds me of King Crimson ballads: it's a good track with nice piano progression. It ain't no surprise that this track is written by Greg Lake. The record ends with a radio friendly track called "Lucky Man". The most tracks are mainly instrumental with long piano or keyboard solo's.

This record was essential for the development of progressive rock but is not a masterpiece IMO. A nice addition to a prog collection it is.

We all know the story of these three guys so I won't take time explaining it. In my opinion BSS is the ultimate ELP masterpiece ( and prog rock masterpiece as well) , but this album is a high point in their career.

When I think of ELP I tend to focus on the huge epics like KE9 , Tarkus or , The endless enigma but when I started paying attention to The Barbarian I realized what a great tune it was. Just 4 and a half minutes long but including every single aspect of ELP's career . OK no vocals this time , but you get: Classical influenced keyboards , versatile drumming and a fuzz bass that sounds like a roaring beast! I picture the faces of the ones who first heard this piece in 1970 , it must have been overwelming. There can't be a better way of introducing themselves in a record.

The second piece settles a huge contrast to the previous one , it's a very relaxing one with an acustic interlude by Greg Lake , also I must add that his vocals in this song are among the best he ever did. This type of songs is what made me become an ELP addict , sometimes this song reminds me of Keith Jarrett and makes me wonder why Emerson did not release a solo album in the vein of the Koln Concert , I would have bought it for sure.

Kinfe edge is a hard rock piece , much similar to the heaviest moments of the Nice and Atomic Rooster. It may sound weird on a prog rock site but the way this tune develops reminds me of Nirvana , Lake sings quiet the verse and then the song reaches a peak in intensity. If anyone has a doubt about ELP rocking or not just heard this tune.

The second side of this album is their more exprimental one , in which hints of ELP's future records will be found. The three fates is a haunting instrumental featuring a church organ first , then a percussion movement and lastly several layers of keyboards by Emerson. i picture this song to be hugely influential to japanese symph groups like Ars Nova or Gerard , again if you have any doubt as regarding this fact just check The Goddess of Darkness by Ars Nova , there is Three Fates all over it.

ELP was always about instrumental abilities. Tank features a Carl Palmer drum solo which is accompanied by Emerson's Moog. I really like the outro to this song because of Palmer's simple yet powerful drumming. As a negative aspect I have to say the production is not the best. Last tune of the album is hit single Lucky Man , which is a ballad that features very moving vocals by Lake , with the exeption of Emo's famous Moog solo at the end of it ; this song has no progressive elements around and it feels quite out of place in the album. However what would an ELP show without Lucky Man?

Outstanding debut , 4.5 stars

I am not a huge ELP fan, but this is (for my tastes) their best recording. This album's overall quality isn't compromised by weak failed-humor tracks (like Benny the Bouncer & The Sheriff) that plague every subsequent album... but there are some boring show-off noodling sections to drag it down a bit. This is their heaviest and most visceral album however, and I recommend it above all others in their discography. The Barbarian is a favorite of mine. It features very heavy distorted bass and great frenetic playing from all three members. Take A Pebble starts as a wonderfully dark and moody piece; it is only slightly marred by some boring solo-instrumental parts in the middle that make the song way too long for it's own good. It it had been kept around 5 minutes this would be one of my favorite ELP tracks. Knife Edge goes back to the aggression of the first track and almost does it better! It's a very heavy song reminiscent of King Crimson's first album with Greg Lake's agitated vocals in top form. The Three Fates is a downright boring composition in comparison to the first three. It featuring heavy church organ and solo classical piano themes. Honestly this side of ELP doesn't do much for me... i prefer the powerful ensemble pieces to such showy pointless exercises as this. The song does get more interesting near the end when the drums FINALLY kick in with an awesome brain-twisting 7/8 rhythm and some downright insane distorted piano solos. The final third of this song saves it from being a total waste of tape. Tank is great when all three members are involved but the extended drum solo is quite pointless. Sure, Carl Palmer could play circles around any other drummer at that time... but this just a boring exercise. Lucky Man saves the second side of the album from being mediocre. Everyone has already heard this song countless times on Classic Rock radio before, so no descriptions needed... i'll just say that after Knife Edge this is the highlight of their debut album.

According to my personal tastes I can only give this 3.5 stars... however, I recognize the great influence this album has had on generations of Prog bands that followed it, so I will bump it up to 4 stars simply for it's historical value and the wonderful Barbarian, Knife Edge, and Lucky Man.

From my experience,the experimentalism of true progressive rock oftenly results in beautifull masterpieces,but may also end in disorientated pieces of music,and honeslty,I don't think there are many exceptions concerning 'mainstream' prog.Experiments on studio may be incredible or complete disasters.

...Not that this debut applies to one of those two ending results,but I do find it a bit lost and somehow not as near as memorable as the albums that followed it.And incredibly overated in the site.ELP shows glimpses of power they would rather sooner than later develop,but I guess the killing flaw here is the absence of a true climax.Let's just say this album came close,but never made it.

It's clear that their debut was a chance for the band to experiment freely as they wish,as there are radical changes of mood as each new track starts,varying from pure classical form to pop flavoured acoustic ballads.The sense of experiment is shouting out loud for everyone who gives the album a listen.

If I had to pick one favourite,it would be Knife Edge.This is a hard rocking song with progressive fills all around,sang very darkly by Greg Lake.I'm very fond of this one,for it shows a rare heavyness in ELP.The song grows as the chorus comes closer,and in the last minute,a true revolution takes place,lead by a stunning Carl Palmer.

Take a Pebble is a Lake ballad,but the true spotlight here is Keith Emerson's grand piano.Lake is,as always,in a wonderfull vocal performance,but if the first and last minutes grant the song a very sad and melodic mood,the long and unnecessary mid-session gets lost halfway through.Well,this is still a very nice song.

Unfortunately there's not much more really worthy of attention.The album is consisted of long instrumentals with multiple time signatures and rich instrumentation,but it doesn't have a true character.The Barbarian is a nice opening and an agressive instrumental,but nothing more.The Three Fates may please prog fanatics,but it's a very demanding ten-minute classical suite.It's not bad at all,but I'm leaving a fair warning:it is NOT for everybody.The Tank is a boring drum solo with very poor complements.

As for Lucky Man,the big hit in the album,it is a nice pop ballad,but easily forgettable.It's quite catchy and has a great chorus,but a misplaced moog solo could have been kept out(Keith Emerson should know better than this).

A fair three stars it is.I've tried really hard to truly aprecciate the album,but the truth is Emerson,Lake and Palmer's debut is retired in my CD collection for a long time now.

Like this album needs another review, but heck with it! Emerson, Lake, and Palmer had already outdone themselves on their self-titled debut! The keyboard playing in each track is phenomenal! No wonder Keith Emerson is called the Jimi Hendrix of the Hammond organ, he's amazing! This really shows on the tracks The Barbarian and The Three Fates. On The Three Fates the organ is immediately noticeable and it only gets better after that as they go into the piano trio which is amazing! Lucky Man the hit single is an excellent track although it definitely could've done without the synth solo in the end which just doesn't seem to fit it. All the other tracks are very good and there is nothing just thrown in here which seemed to be the case of their later albums. It's a masterpiece ELP!

EDIT:

Gosh this album grows stale after awhile even with it's impressive passages. Guess it's not a masterpiece, but just an excellent piece.

The debut album from ELP is a great place to start for anyone new to the band. It combines their raw energy and tenacity with world class composition, arrangement and playing. A landmark release in progressive rock as three established musicians of the late 60's scene began four years of unparalleled music; Emerson, Lake & Palmer stands alongside Trilogy as this band's crowning achievement. Take one Greg Lake (King Crimson), one Keith Emerson (The Nice), and one Carl Palmer (Atomic Rooster), put them in a studio together, and give them free reign; the result: one of the finest classical influenced albums, with a wonderful balance of acoustic guitar, bass, flamboyant Hammond, Moog, piano, organ, clavinet, and transcendent percussion!!!

The diversity, particularly within the songs themselves, and wealth of music on this album are what make it such an intriguing listen from front to back. The songs go places, adequately allowing the trio to explore their ideas in depth and demonstrate the wide range of compositional skill, musicianship, and pure cathartic nature of the music. Whether it is the band compositions on Side 1 or the individual spotlights on Side 2, the album features a band at the height of their progressiveness. Sure there aren't any sidelong epics like 'Tarkus' or 'Karn Evil 9'- that is not the point. Listen to 'The Barbarian', 'Take a Pebble', 'Knife Edge' and even 'The Three Fates': all of these pieces are dynamic, fluctuating between gentle and delicate piano solos to foreboding and resounding organ. All the while, Carl Palmer and Greg Lake never cease to amaze with their capacity for jazz-like rhythm underneath the keyboard work. If anything, this is a Dave Brubeck in a rock setting- with extreme classical and jazz tendencies.

The album closes with a Keith Emerson Moog solo on 'Lucky Man'; one take was all that was needed to capture the climax of one of the most endearing pieces in the ELP catalogue. It demonstrates the manner in which this album was made, where inspiration and spontaneity were as integral to the sound as experimentation and composition. This is the beginning of a fruitful period that would produce some of the finest Symphonic Prog of the early 1970's. For those unsure about ELP because of the stereotypes surrounding this band, this is the album for you- modest, sincere and emotional.

Being a huge ELP fan I've always wondered why some poeple say it's the best ELP's album. I'm not saying this debut is a bad release but far from expectations. The first time I heard this record I was familiar with Trilogy, Brain Salad Surgery and Tarkus. And I'm finding those three releases much better than this album. First of all I don't think band's style was crystalized in 1970. So here we have one long and sensless piece Take A Pebble. It's just boring to me. Not enough energetic. Fortunatelly on next albums band decided to rock some more. Barbarian and Tank don't move me at all either. Album sounds pretty lame to my ears but I don't have remastered version so maybe now it's much better. Knife-Edge it's the best track on this album to me. It's a bit hard rockish song with addition of classical music. That section in the middle is simply awesome. Lucky Man is the most famous track of this debut and it's not bad really. Everyone should know this. It's some lighter part for those who prefer that softer side of ELP. Three Fates seems to be kind of loose improvisation. I guess it was the time Emerson wanted to show all his skills. Yeah I can understand that. And I'm thankful that later he worked more on his compositions. This album is a piece of music played by very tallented guys. Not necessary having ideas for songs. But playing like they were knowing what they were doing. It doesn't deserve more than 3 stars.

It is said that true ambition knows no bounds. This was perhaps the driving sentiment behind the creation of prog rock supergroup Emerson Lake & Palmer. Combining the talents of former Nice organist Keith Emerson, former King Crimson bassist/lead vocalist Greg Lake, and former Atomic Rooster drummer Carl Palmer, their ambition was to push rock music to the limits of technical virtuosity. At times the ambition paid dividends in the form of brilliant performances, such as on the Tarkus LP, but there were also times when the same ambition produced little more than pretentious bombast, such as their take on Mussorgsky's Pictures At An Exhibition. On their self-titled debut album, however, they found the good side of their ambition.

Among the highlights are "The Barbarian", an instrumental featuring the signature Hammond B3 sound of Keith Emerson as well as Greg Lake's frightening fuzz bass guitar. "Take a Pebble" features Emerson's considerable piano talents. "Three Fates" features more virtuosity from Keith Emerson including a beautiful performance on the pipe organ. "Tank features the fantastic drumming of wiz kid Carl Palmer, and the FM radio hit "Lucky Man" closes the set in a memorable way with Lake's fine vocals and Emerson's Moog exploits.

The end result of ELP's debut was a good one. Their technical prowess was still on full display, and although they may have rode the edge of self-indulgence at times, overall they turned in a set of songs which showed ELP in a flattering light. It is highly recommended for fans of progressive music, and I gladly give it 4 stars.

My face spills so gently, into your eyes, disturbing the waters, of our lives

I haven't really got my head around ELP, no matter how hard i have tried. Their debut, however, is their only album i actually sometimes listen to. Why? Because of one man. Greg Lake.

This album is full of that which makes progressive rock progressive, unfortunatley in this case it's a bad thing. Emersons skills on the keys are out of this world, but the problem is that, it doesn not always implicate good music, and same goes for Palmer. The album opens with Barbarian, that rocks out ok, but nothing really i find myself listening to often. However, the next track is that which gives the album its value, and for no other reason than Mr. Greg Lake. Just listen to the first vocal part of the second track, Lakes vocals are everything that we want them to be. Otherwise the album fails to deliver anything else than keyboard skill showboating by Mr. Emerson. The problem with ELP solos in general is that they have no direction. I wouldn't call it "mish-mosh" but something without a soul or meaning. One highlight in this album is the track Lucky man, which on record can be a little bit boring(and ruined by the moog solo), but live Greg Lake would sit with his guitar and sing his heart out to the world.

This is not a bad album, but far from 4 stars nonetheless. For me the music from ELP is mostly clueless. but this album still delivers much more than it's successors. 3 Stars.

3.5 stars really.

The first album by the first prog supergroup, as members of King Crimson, The Nice and Arthur Brown / Atomic Rooster came together to create a new type of music.

Well, not really new, since it is dominated by Emerson's neo-classical sensibilities. Pretty much a continuation of the Nice, only with a much better singer (in terms of ability, I think Palmer and Lake were pretty much on the same level as Davidson and Jackson on their respective instruments).

Many people consider this their best work. In some ways, I can agree. It's fresh, different, and pretty consistent. There are no "joke" songs, and it's actually comparatively restrained compared to their later albums. On the other hand, it seems to me that they really didn't have enough material for a complete album and threw some stuff together at the last minute to fill up the album.

The album opens with a heavy handed Bartok interpretation, The Barbarian. It is pretty much a statement of intent for the band, and as such works pretty well. Heavy, distorted organ, nimble bass lines, and propulsive drumming define the piece. Not a bad tune.

Take A Pebble is a Lake composition, and is by my reckoning the best song on the album. A great ascending and descending piano melody compliments Lake's fantastic vocal melody. The instrumental middle section features Lake on unaccompanied acoustic playing some lovely yet simple major key explorations (though the almost country section with the drums is more than a little corny, but it's over quickly). This is followed by an excellent jazz tinged piano solo section over a great Lake bass line with excellent drumming from Palmer. It finishes in grand fashion with a reprise of the beginning section. A great piece.

Knife edge is a driving song, containing yet more classical "borrowings", this time Janáček's Sinfonietta for orchestra, Opus 60. Lake has added lyrics to this one though, and his vocals fit very well. A very fine piece of music, and another defining piece for the band, with heavy organ, great bass playing, and precise drumming.

The Three Fates is basically 3 mostly unrelated pieces stuck together to create a longer piece. Church Organ, then piano, then Emerson soloing over a repetitive bass and drum line. Frankly, I find this song rather dull and aimless, but I suppose Emerson's playing is decent. Tank is a Palmer Drum solo, followed by another repetitive bass and drum line with soloing. Not a bad solo, but I really don't understand why bands put them on albums. Another mostly uninteresting track.

Finally, we have the song that everyone in the Western world has probably heard (over the age of 30, at least), Lucky Man. Lake wrote it when he was 12, though it is not a terrible song, despite the simple chord progressions and humorously naive lyrics (though even those are pretty good for a 12 year old). Emerson didn't want to use it, because he didn't think it represented what the band was. Of course, with his ego, he wasn't really considering what the other band members wanted, so Carl and Greg recorded the song without Keith. Later, Keith recorded a Moog "solo" over the tail end of the piece. Keith later stating that it was really more of him just playing with the Moog and not a proper solo. Nevertheless, it has become an iconic Moog solo and was one of the first times members of the public would hear this now hopelessly intertwined with prog rock instrument. The song became a hit. The band made lots of money, thanks in large part to Lakes simple song. Keith, it seems, never really accepted this or was comfortable with it. But, it allowed the band to move on to a more interesting album with a large following and plenty of money.

On the whole, I don't find this to be their best album. But the first half is excellent, and the second half, while far less interesting to me, is not terrible. So a solid 3.5, rounding up for the historical significance and my general fondness for ELP.

This self-titled debut of ELP's possibly represents the band at their most focused and most restrained...so is it any good?

My answer would be just listen to the first thing you hear, that fuzzed-out bass thing at the beginning of ''The Barbarian''. That instrumental track is an all-out assault on the ears with the pounding drums, heavy bass and piercing organ. If that's not enough, they managed to reprise the assault on ''Knife Edge'' (add in some vocals) and ''Tank'' (with an astounding clavinet part). This heavy bass-keys sound is what I enjoy most from ELP, the band and the album.

However, it isn't an ELP without even a slight degree of pretentiousness. ''The Three Fates'' is just that to the max, a chance for Keith to show how impressive he is on church organ and piano all the while not much impressing me either. Carl Palmer is also guilty by squeezing in a drum solo in the middle of ''Tank'', although that solo doesn't get on my nerves. My problem is that this is the first album to feature the ''obligatory Greg Lake sappy ballad'', one that will be copied several times throughout ELP's career to get radio play. Here, the ballad is ''Lucky Man'', and it contains some of the worst lyrics in the ELP canon. The catchy chorus saves the song though.

All three kind of get out of hand on ''Take a Pebble''. While the acoustic guitar is put to great use in the form of a country-hoedown-esque solo (I rarely have complements for ANYTHING country) and Keith lays down some great piano solos (including the very beginning of which he plucks the strings inside the piano), ultimately, it's length gives me fits as many solos go on for longer than I desire.

All fussing aside, check this out if you think excursions like ''Tarkus'' and ''Karn Evil 9'' are too much for you. Probably my personal favourite of the ELP albums I've heard so far.

Emerson Lake & Palmer burst onto the music scene back in 1971 with this incredible album. Keith Emerson had used classical pieces as the basis for his rock songs while in The Nice, but never with a band with this amount of talent. Carl Palmer's drumming and Greg Lake's bass, guitar and singing voice far surpassed their counterparts in Emerson's old band.

Right from the start of The Barbarian, with a roar from Lake's guitar, and Emerson's might Hammond organ, the listener knew he was in for a new experience. Bartok had never sounded so cool. Every song here, even the soft ballads, are classics of prog.

Take A Pebble may be ELP's most beautiful song, with Emerson's piano deftly describing the ripples created in the ocean from a tossed pebble. Knife Edge gives us a very heavy piece, based on Leos Janacek's Sinfonietta. This song would become a live favorite for the band, with Emerson throwing knives into his tortured Hammond.

The Three Fates is first an organ-heavy piece, that then turns to piano amazingness. Tank is a fusion piece, one of the few Palmer had a hand in writing. And Lucky Man, well, everyone knows that song. It still, to this day, gets plenty of radio airplay.

While this does not have ELP's best songs, it is certainly their most consistent album.

ELP roars into the prog world in a blaze of glory with this 1970 debut. Bands worldwide must have been envious of the debut that stamped authority on prog and a unique blend of symphony and rock. Every track screams to be noticed and are all bonafide classics in their own right.

The Barbarian is a fabulous complex instrumental featuring chaotic drumming and a frenetic Hammond from Emerson. What a way to introduce the band! Take A Pebble is close to my favourite prog song with beautiful lilting vocals and an amazing melody line that is unforgettable. The lyrics are simply mesmirising. I love the piano interlude and acoustic instrumental. An absolutely brilliant piece of virtuoso music from end to end. You will find it on all good ELP compilations.

Knife-Edge is a trademark ELP track and features Hammond stabs and wall to wall bass and drums. A very frenetic time signature and potent vocals. The 4 chord staccato stabs are powerful and aggressive.

The Three Fates is the lengthy majestic Emerson showpiece that grows on you on each listen. It is perhaps the only track not found on compilations as a general rule.

Tank showcases Palmers enimatble style, a drum time signature that made all other drumers sit up and take notice.

Lucky Man became ultra popular and blitzed the charts showing the softer balladic style of the band and Lake's quiet approach to music. And there you have it. A master class performance. Not the best they will do but as far as a debut goes, it would be hard to find better.

Great debut album from the first prog Supergroup. Playing just in power trio format, they 're maiking impression of full orchestra added, Album songs are very different in melodies,styles and arrangements, so you wouldn't be boring during listening. Main album sound is Emerson keyboards,for sure, but pleasantly total sound is acoustic enough ( I hate all this over- produced sympho-rock bands filling all the space not with music, but with pseudo-classic keyboard's sound).

The Barbarian is a gem, classic ELP song for years. Longest composition " Take The Pebble" contains Greg vocal ( I have nothing against it, but some people don't like his voice). Long construction contains classic piano sound mixed with jazzy drums and bass line, and I like it!

Knife Edge and The Three Fates ... demonstrate nice neo-classic piano technicue both. Again, in combination with jazzy drumming and some synth effects it give really nice result.

Tank is synth-based instrumental with characteristic sound of early seventies and long drums solos.

All album is still not as bombastic as later ELP works ( for good). Palmer's drumming is more jazzy there,and it really gives some air to total sound. "Lucky Man" is traditional ballad ( many critics hate it because of simplicity and lyrics, but I prefer this naive song against complex songs about dragons and elves so popular between pseudo sympho-proggers).

I am sure, that it is very strong debut and one of the best ELP album. Absolutely recommended to everyone interested in sympho-prog roots and one of the best bands for years.

Emerson, Lake & Palmer - Emerson, Lake & Palmer (3.77/5 stars) Original Release: November 00, 1970

Songs:

The Barbarian (3 stars) Instruments combine to evoke the image of a heavy, plodding Barbarian moving across the landscape. The quick work of the drums, however, evoked a sense of listening to the soundtrack of a silent film however. The busy-ness of the instrumentation on this instrumental tends to tire the ear and detract from the passages that creatively evoke the mood that the song aims at.

Take a Pebble (4 stars) The bass and a profound piano accompany the haunting vocals in the first part of this song. Then with a cascading rhythm layered piano takes over. In the middle of this there is a quiet section with a thoughtful acoustic guitar playing amidst the sounds of water drops. the lyrics are difficult to interpret but I suspect that what they are getting at is how the moments of our lives, successive moments in time, disturb, distort and destroy our memories causing them to fragment and to dissipate as the force of the latest experience propagates in our minds like a pebble thrown into a pool. The quiet mid point of this song might represent a moment when the knower achieves a reflective clarity regarding this relentless process and finds a place of stillness within the perpetual succession of time. Layered piano work has both a timeless cascading part and an ever changing timely part. The end of the song concludes this pleasant and disturbing journey with further descriptive words.

Knife Edge (4 stars) The menacing lyrics walk you through a mad world with a mildly hypnotic rhythm. The instrumental middle section expands the musical theme and moves briefly to a more ethereal passage. Then its back to the plodding guitar-organ of the openning hard rock theme.

the Three Fates: Clotho/Lachesis/Atropos (4 stars) Big evil organ opens the song. After a while a piano emerges. The piano playing is strong, colorful, then quiet, gentle. Then the piano swells with a rising passion like ocean waves. Emersons piano work moves through many themes and takes you in many directions with skillful ease. There are lots of interesting textures and moods painted in succession by Emerson in this instrumental. There is a good balance of variety without becoming a tedious jam session. The song ends in an explosion that dissipates just as the next song kicks in.

Tank (3 stars) In this instrumental the percussive melody paints the picture of some persistent machine moving over the landscape. A drum solo appears which seemlessly fits into the feel of the song as a whole but sounds still like a drum solo. I have a sense of a tank negotiating in its plodding yet nimble way an obstacle course of a landscape as I listen to this song. In the last half of the song a sinister rhythm of synthesizer, drums and and bass kicks in. Then a high-pitched harmonica synthesizer sound plays a strange blues. It is as if the tank has done something of consequence and now lumbers on in some new realm or mad reality. Although the song did engage my imagination it was more difficult to connect with emotionally.

Lucky Man (4 stars) the lyrics describe a man with women and wealth who performed his duty for his country and found death as ready to take him as anyone else less fortunate. The haunting chorus underscores the lyric's irony. The vocals sound Beatlesque. The song ends as a synthesizer comes in and brings an electric energy that is taunting and haunting all at once.

Album: The often dense style of Emerson, Lake & Palmer is the best asset and greatest liability. The songs on this album tend to succeed in balancing these things but not always so well. The band's style of play lends itself to themes of madness and relentless motion. The imaginative lyrics and themes seem concerned with dark spirits. The darkness in this album is akin to that of King Crimson's "In the Court of the Crimson King". Lake's vocalizations help to cut down on the density of the instrumentation. This density tends to soure me to their music over time but I have found this album one that has suffered less from than than there other albums from the 70s.

This album is an early progressive rock classic with exceptional musicianship combined with fantasy sound textures that transport you to another world and I recommend the album as a whole to prog rock fans.

MP3 recommendation:

4 Star Songs (4/5 stars) 1. Take a Pebble (4 stars) 2. Knife Edge (4 stars) 3. The Three Fates: Clotho/Lachesis/Atropos (4 stars) 4. Lucky Man (4 stars)

This is probably one of the best debut's in the history of mankind. To it's heavy keyboards, awesome basslines, and sweet drumming, this has it all. ELP managed to be the first ever progressive rock supergroup ever, everyone coming from different bands. Greg Lake is the bassist, acoustic guitarist, Keith Emerson is the keyboardist, and Carl Palmer is the drummer for the band. They make some amazing music if you are concerned.

"The Barbarian" is simply stunning. Lean and mean basslines and keyboards, and some fast drumming make this song simply beautiful. The organs are really prominate in this song, and it's a good substitute for an electric guitar, though Lake plays an acoustic in some tracks. Amazing instrumental opener. "Take a Pebble" is one of Lake's moments, where his sappy songwriting comes in, talking about love and romance, nothing that interesting. It has some nice musical moments. The vocals are amazing, of course, thanks to Lake of course, the bassline is soothing, though Lake isn't an amazing bassist, the drumming is very nice. Emerson is playing very well on this piano for the most part. "Knife Edge" gets back to rocking out, honestly. The lyrics are much better than the previous track, and the overall music moves much faster. The bassline is pretty nice and slow paced for this song, specially written and written very well for this song. The keyboards are really upbeat and get you in the groove. "The Three Fates" is a mostly keyboard/piano solo. It's stunning, to say the least, and it's one of the best things ever written. Keith Emerson really can play those things very well, it's beautiful the music that he can make on it. "Tank" has some nice rhythm section, drummings and bass pumping out really hard. After the storming intro, the keyboards enter and start to take control, as the bass and drums seem to come natural for Palmer and Lake. After that intro, the drum solo starts to kick in, and let me tell you, it's pretty good. Mezmorizing, to say the least. Though I don't think that Palmer is along the lines of, lets say, Neil Peart, but he is pretty close. "Lucky Man" is kind of weak with it's acoustic intro, but I find it a bit uplifting. The vocals of course are simply stunning, to say the least.

Though are a few parts that are definatly not amazing, they are definatly good to say the least. This is filled with prog to spare, but not as much prog as their next few albums would contain, but this is where it all began. 5 stars for the supergroup.

ELP is probably one of the most debated of all classic prog bands, praised to heaven by some, slated by others. I find myself in both camps really, often even simultaneously, one moment marvelling at their unique sound and musicianship, the next shaking my head in desperation at the pointless and emotionless drivel they churned out. Also their debut doesn't escape this ambiguity and contains both pearls of prog and annoying filler.

The first track is essential, in so far that I would include it on a 'mixed tape' sampler of prog music - supposing someone would actually ask for that. The Barbarian is rock music full of classical influences, it's big, overstated, pompous, grandiose, swirling, epic, virtuosic, it's prog! And it only needs 4.30 minutes to make its point.

Take A Pebble shows another side of ELP, more lyrical, melodious and romantic. It's the Lake side of ELP, more classic rock ballad oriented, tasteful and more subtle then Emerson's extravagance. It's the other aspect of ELP's sound that makes them an interesting listen. Take A Pebble is a beautiful piece of music; even if the middle part is a bit long-winded, (especially the piano section).

Knife Edge is another classic ELP track where all 3 forces in the band come together very successfully, the heavy organs from Emerson, the pumping bass and commanding vocals from Lake and Palmer's superb drumming.

Side B of the original album has a whole lot less to offer, at least to me, when I want to hear church organ I'll put on Bach and when it comes to piano, there's a library full of more meaningful pieces from classic composers and jazz pianists. The Three Fates is not bad by any means but it's a bridge too far for me. The last two minutes with the entire band make more sense.

Tank is the desperation moment. There are worse examples but still this is where purposeless virtuosity for its own sake takes over, the drum solo is downright tedious. However, the last 2 minutes save this one again and demonstrate what this band could achieve when they set their minds to it. A great staccato rhythm sets the pace for one of the first moog solos on a rock album, and it's a great one, both playful, smart and dramatic. Lucky Man is ELP's campfire moment, unexpectedly ending with anther big moog party.

Making consistent albums wasn't ELP's specialty and the debut suffers from their lack of consistency. Overall, I count a good 20 minutes of really great music here. The remainder is a bit average but nothing that's really poor.

EDIT: I though I liked Tarkus more but upon reviewing that one, I realised this debut is my preferred ELP release after all.

ELP exemplifies all that is good and bad about prog. There is loads of instrumental prowess, classical and jazz influences, and feeling here, but there is also a lot of overblown, pompous displays of "look how good I am". The debut isn't exactly one of my favorite ELP releases, but it's still good. It's main problem is consistency and filler- while Tarkus was an engaging journey, with not a note wasted, some of the songs here seem to be stuffed with filler, usually along the lines of Emerson shoving in a piano part wherever he can.

The Barbarian is a classically-influenced rocker, with muscle and menace- Lake's bass romps around like an angry dinosaur, as Emerson's organ flies around overhead. Around the middle, Emerson turns it into a keyboard piece (surprise, surprise), before it reverts to its original state a bit later. Take a Pebble begins with Emerson's piano and Palmer's tinkling percussion, with Lake singing over it, though the singing blurs the line between the earnest and the pretentious. After that, it dissolves into nothingness before turning into another piano part, until Lake and Palmer come back, and it ends like it began. Knife Edge is the best song here, being a powerful, aggressive rock song with more classical influences- however, the organ parts seem a tiny bit inconsistent with the overall "mood" created during the vocal parts- this isn't a big problem, because both sequences are very well-made. And then, the Three Fates; if you like long keyboard exercises, you'll love this, as Emerson flies solo for five minutes, until Palmer comes in and makes things a bit more interesting- not really bad, but not great either, and nothing really memorable here. Tank is a good instrumental, with a really nice drum solo in the middle, because we all totally needed convincing that Palmer had massive amounts of talent. And finally, ELP's best-known song, Lucky Man- once again, not bad, but nothing really mind-blowing, either- however, it's more memorable than a lot of the stuff here, the vocals are good, and there are nice guitar and Moog solos, so it's got my blessing. All in all, ELP's debut is a good start, but they're not quite there yet- though there's lots of fun to be had here, they still need to learn to cut back on useless instrumental performances in the middle of otherwise good songs. Good, but not great- three stars.

Masterpiece?

When people talk about the classic progressive rock groups, ELP is always mentioned. While I won't dispute their significance in the progressive rock world, they have never excited me as much as other classic prog bands such as Yes, Jethro Tull, King Crimson, and Genesis.

This was the third ELP album I had purchased after Trilogy and then Brain Salad Surgery. I find both of those albums moderately enjoyable (probably 3 star albums), but I did find them overrated. When I bought their debut album I was really expecting something great, but I was very disappointed. Whereas the two above mentioned albums have many redeemable qualities behind the excessive noodling, this album never really did much for me. I don't think I'll ever understand what is so great about ELP, and why I'm unable to discover it. This album certainly didn't do me any favors from that aspect, and makes me question their music even more.

For those of you who have never heard ELP, this is progressive rock (though I wouldn't nessacerily label it "symphonic" prog) with many classical influences. There are some hard rock leanings mostly because of the heavy dependence on Hammond organ. The music has a lot of weak transitions, and is focused mostly on Keith Emerson's virtuosic keyboard abilities. The skill and talent is present on all of these songs, but the memorable melodies and consistency is only present for brief visits.

THE MUSIC:

"The Barbarian"- The first starts with a distorted guitar riff, that soon turns into heavy and dark organ chords. I remember the first time I heard this I was immediately in love. Keith Emerson's talent on the organ shines right here, and Carl Palmer does an excellent job as well. Almost out of nowhere, it turns into a classically-influenced piano section. I think the song would have faired much better without it, to be honest. The transition into this section is weak, and the section itself is nothing too memorable, and seems directionless. Luckily the original section soon returns, and Keith Emerson amazes me again. The organ soloing is truly excellent. Overall, this is a mixed bag, though. It definitely has its moments, but it is lacking in consistency.

"Take A Pebble"- The first song opens up with a beautiful piano melody. The opening is really good and when Greg Lake's vocals enter it's pure magnificence. Soon a classical-sounding piano section enters. It sounds really good, even if it doesn't really fit. Soon a folky guitar section enters. This entire section (and trust me it's pretty long) doesn't fit at all, and seems almost pointless to me. It gets absolutely nowhere, even if the guitar playing is solid. When the classical piano enters again, too much of it seems like noodling for my tastes, but the musicianship is excellent. It builds well into the ending. Again, this is a very uneven song, and only about half of it is really worthwhile. This is much longer than it needs to be.

"Knife-Edge"- After the fairly boring and overly long previous track, this immediately brought my attention back. After the bombastic organ opening, it goes into a bluesy-section with just bass, drums, and Greg Lake's vocals. Much of the song builds off of these two sections, and it does it excellently. This has some great soloing from Keith Emerson. This is my favorite song from the album, and I wish more of the album would be like this.

"The Three Fates"- We all know the saying that good things never last. Well this is a perfect representation of that. After the magnificent previous track, this just strikes me as boring, pretentious, and unnecessary. The opening church organ solo is decent enough, but it does nothing for me. It goes into a piano section that is just pure noodling. Nothing more, nothing less. The church organ shortly returns and just plays the same chords over and over again. A weak transition brings us into a complex piano section with drumming. This whole song is completely pointless in my opinion, and it just seems like Keith Emerson showing off. Needless to say, it doesn't impress me.

"Tank"- This is Carl Palmer's solo spot, and he shows his chops clearly. This is a weak composition, though. The musicianship is spot-on as always, but the songwriting does nothing for me. That's usually my main problem with ELP. Their talent is undeniable, but the music is often questionable. This is another fairly useless track.

"Lucky Man"- This is often the most scolded track on the album, but I must say that it is one of my favorites from the album. Unlike most of the other songs, this actually has memorable melodies and it is consistent from beginning to end. I love the synth solo near the end especially. This is a great closing track, though I'm sure many will be quick to deny it.

Conclusion:

Emerson, Lake & Palmer is a pretty overrated album in my opinion. The musicianship is excellent, but the music often is directionless and leaves me cold. ELP's music just never interests me as much as Yes, Jethro Tull, or Genesis, and this album is no exception. I enjoy some of their later albums, but their debut is flawed in various ways. I don't consider myself an ELP fan much at all, but this is one of my least favorites from this era. If you're interested in ELP, I recommend going to their next couple albums, as I find them moderately enjoyable. This album is lacking terms in consistency and memorable moments. I know many will disagree, but I can't give this more than a 2 star rating. I don't think I'll ever understand what's so great about this album.

2 stars.

The first and the best

Emerson, Lake and Palmer got together from their three previous bands - Emerson's The Nice, Lake's King Crimson and Palmer's Atomic Rooster. They released their debut album - homonymous Emerson Lake and Palmer, to a dreat commercial success in 1970. In my opinion, this one will eventually remain their best album. The musicianship is perfect. These musicians are magicians, but regretfully their composer's skills are not of the same high quality as their musicianship. Despite that, all songs are memorable and interesting. The album is highly influenced by classical music, most notably in Take a Pebble and The Three Fates. Piano solos by brilliant Keith Emerson are exceptional moments all around the album. The voice of Greg Lake is of high quality, especially in vocal-oriented song - Knife-Edge and famous ballad Lucky Man. The opening track - The Barbarian contains darker themes as well as the third part of The Three Fates. Tank is captivating mixture between different ideas, including eastern influence and contains drum solo by Carl Palmer. It's quite experimental album, highly recommended for classical fans and quite recommended for prog fans with dynamic taste. 4 stars!

I wasn't quite as wowed by ELP's debut album as I thought I was going to be, seeing as how it is so highly regarded here at PA. The only other ELP album I (currently) have is Brain Salad Surgery. When I first purchased Brain Salad Surgery it was love at first listen. It knocked my socks off and set up sky high expectations. Brain Salad Surgery is aggressive and challenging, but importantly it is a focused effort. When I listen to the self titled album by comparison, I get the distinct impression that ELP are kinda just noodling around; which isn't necessarily a bad thing when you consider this is their first album and how else are they supposed to find their feet. It just doesn't always make for the most entertaining listening experience unfortunately. They seize on bits and pieces that are really entertaining and sort of scattered about the album.

So what is there to like about this album? For starters, I'd have to say probably Greg Lake's vocals. The only bit of trouble is that he doesn't sing quite enough for my liking. You honestly cannot speak ill of the calibre of the musicianship which ELP possesses everything has that nice perfectionist feel too it even though musically it has a jam session quality to it. The two strongest tracks on the album are, in my opinion, Knife Edge and the impossible to hate Lucky Man. Both are solid from start to finish.

This album is for people who like jazz influence and a more improvisational style or are totally taken by the ELP sound. 2 for 5.

By 1970, when Emerson, Lake and Palmer released their eponymous debut, the infant progressive rock movement was really beginning to grow, and flex its muscles. King Crimson had established an influential prog blueprint the year before with IN THE COURT OF THE CRIMSON KING, and future top-tier progressive acts Yes and Genesis were each toddling to their wee prog feet with sophomore efforts TIME AND A WORD and TRESPASS, respectively.

EMERSON, LAKE AND PALMER saw prog's most potent trio emerge fully-fleshed upon the developing scene. It's an impressive first effort, with all of the classic ELP elements in place. The band whose names would become synonymous with the genre -- for a few bright years in a positive fashion, but, during prog's 76 to 77 fall from grace, more often in a scornful manner -- had a firm musical identity, and knew their business right off the mark. Singer Greg Lake had already honed his grand, inspiring vocal style during his two-album stint with Crimson, keyboardist extraordinaire Keith Emerson had been wowing audiences with his prowess for some time with The Nice, and Carl Palmer now confirmed his burgeoning reputation as a drummer's drummer, having been the tour drummer for The Crazy World of Arthur Brown, and a founding member (and studio drummer) for Atomic Rooster. The three ELP men were no smooth-cheeked neophytes, but seasoned musicians and recording artists.

That deep pool of experience is apparent on EMERSON, LAKE AND PALMER's opening track, the instrumental "The Barbarian," which is four and a half minutes of rampaging, head-hewing, pure prog power and majesty. Emerson in particular shines here, with some church-style organ and some lightning-fast work on the piano. The second piece, the magnificent twelve-and-a-half minute, multi-part "Take a Pebble" finds Lake delivering some typically stirring vocals, while Emerson and Palmer get to stretch out and show off their flashy, jazzy chops in perfect complement to one another. Next up is "Knife Edge," another heavy number which encapsulates all of the quintessential ELP elements within its five minutes. Palmer's stellar performance on the skins and cymbals, and Emerson's mastery of the Hammond are again the highlights. "The Three Fates" is an instrumental, which takes the listener to some grandiose cathedral of prog, via Emerson's imposing pipe organ opening. Piano and drums also get a real workout here, and the high-ceilinged sound evokes the mythological motif of the title, before a literally explosive close. This, boys and girls, is the sound rock makes when it's progressing! "Tank" is another instrumental, and this initially nimble number at first belies its name. Formidable finesse is seen in Palmer's "obligatory for the early 70s" drum solo, before the slower main theme asserts itself for the closing half. Now one can readily envision the armoured killing machine of the title, lumbering along in smug, impenetrable might. Finally, the album ends with 70s FM favourite "Lucky Man." (Only the cloying "C'est la Vie," from the overblown WORKS, would ever garner ELP as much air time.) "Lucky Man" is a nice enough song, though its lyrics are somewhat school-boyish and didactic in their heavy-handed message that wealth does not bring true happiness, or even (gasp!) forestall death. Still, Lake's acoustic guitar is pretty, and dig that spacey synthesizer at the close -- far out! (Hey, it was a new sound way back then, and it impressed my shell-pink ears to no end -- even if it sounds a mite dated and corny as I listen today. Alas, fleeting innocence, I hardly knew ye! How dare I be so jaded?)

Thus, EMERSON LAKE AND PALMER was a strong debut, which played no small role in solidifying the progressive rock template. Jazzy affectations, classical pretensions, "deep" lyrics, pompous musical bombast and complexity, along with sheer "look what I can do" ace musicianship, had constructed a gilded home. A growing, worshipful audience, eager for more such heady fare, soon came calling. These days, as prog's favourite whipping boys, ELP have fallen far from the Olympian peak of slavering adulation they once occupied. Still, here one can find out how they attained such rarified heights in the first place. EMERSON LAKE AND PALMER is must for all fans, and for any comprehensive collection of early progressive rock.

This is probably the best overall effort by the then newly formed super group Emerson, Lake, and Palmer. I bought this record some time after I had gotten "Tarkus."

There are no weak tunes on this and I remember after the album had ended, I wanted to hear more. That is the mark of a good recording! It just seemed to short to end when it did. This is funny since "Take a Pebble" is over twelve and a half minutes long. The shortest song is over four minutes in length. So there is definitely some chemistry going on here.

"The Barbarian" is a great way to open the set. It engages the listener right away and doesn't let up until the last note is ended.

Then comes the time to get your breath. "Take a Pebble" is just simply beautiful to hear. Very graceful and elegant. Emerson at his best! Greg Lake sings so visually and the lyrics can make you grieve. He also does some tender and foot stomping solo guitar in the middle of this mini epic. Carl Palmer is also right there pounding away in ear pleasing tones.

"Knife Edge" is the "B" side to "Lucky Man." It is a strange and scary tune. Greg Lake definitely knows how to keep you on the edge of your seat lyric wise. He is just a great singer! Keith Emerson throws in some wonderful soloing that is original and interesting.

Speaking of interesting, "The Three Fates" is something else! Keith almost sounds like a madman on the beginning organ solo. You have got to hear it! Then he goes into some of the most beautiful piano music ever recorded by anyone. The last part is outrageous. The whole band is beating your brains out and your loving every minute! I had never heard anything like it.

"Tank" is a chance for Carl Palmer to get his licks in and boy does he do the job! This is a futuristic sound for the boys and they are on top of their game. The music itself is very visual and stunning to hear!

Last, but not least we have "Lucky Man." Very good and sarcastic. I didn't get the last verse right away, but when I did, I had to laugh. Greg is a talent. I really enjoyed the solo by Emerson at the end and I still do. The notes make it sound like you are watching the end of a great block buster epic. It is genius at work!

I consider this to be essential listening for anyone who wants to hear plain good prog. It gets 5 stars!

Boy, did THIS album ever grow on me. When I first got it, I basically liked it, but probably would have given it only a high ***. Then it grew on me some more, and comfortably settled into a **** range. Then when I thought it would go no further, I eventually found something that basically shocked me - not only had this album managed to sneak its way into my top 100 overall (for a while, anyway), it had managed to be an important reason in my upgraded opinion of ELP as a great band. Brain Salad Surgery may be the focus of ELP's fame (for better or for worse), but THIS is the album that makes them deserving of that fame.

Indeed, the first half of this album is just about PERFECT, one of the best sides of any prog album I own. "The Barbarian" is an astounding opener, an update of an old Bartok piece that takes on a life of its own here. If you're a cynic who says that Emerson's playing is merely self-indulgent tripe that cannot be easily enjoyed by a casual listener, you really need to give this track a listen or three. It took me a while to get into the rest of the album (to varying degrees, anyway), but this track sucked me in right away. The opening distorted bassline/guitarline is much moodier and "tougher" than one would stereotypically expect out of ELP, and once Emerson jumps in with his keyboards and begins driving forward theme after theme with his whole array of piano and organ tricks, any expectation of archetypical British "wussiness" on the album should fly right out the window. All three are at their very best throughout this track, managing to both demonstrate their huge talent AND make sure that the listener actually cares about what they can do with that talent, with the final result an unabashed prog classic.

The next track is no slouch either, and quite possibly even better. "Take a Pebble" is based around an absolutely gorgeous ballad courtesy of Greg, and what truly makes the song magnificent is the soaring and powerful vocal effort that Lake graces it with. Now, I appreciate Jon Anderson's vocal approach as much as anybody, but I will admit that prog tunes benefit when the vocalist is able to (almost) convince the listener that the bombastic and meaningless ravings are actually relevant and, well, emotionally move the listener. And Lake does just that; not that the lyrics are all bad ("the sadness on your shoulders like a wornout overcoat, in pockets greased and tattered hang the rags of your hopes," there's a good line), but they really need that extra oomph in order to make them work. In any case, there's also a really nice middle instrumental section. Parts are in typically bombastic classical motifs, but they really sound interesting (once again, Emerson is at his beautiful best, this time on piano), especially after we get to be enchanted with, of all things, a nice Mississippi-style acoustic ditty (which once again provides a perfect example of ELP's ability to deflate itself at needed times, at least in the early days of the band). As you might imagine, when they performed it in concert, they would stick tons of music between the bookends of the piece, often sticking several of their other tunes in the middle, but this 'miniature' seven or eight minute middle section is wonderful in and of itself.

Next up is "Knife Edge," which I once disliked for whatever reason, but I was a F-O-O-L. An adapation of a classical piece (the name and author of which escapes me at the moment), this track is a nearly perfect summary of all of ELP's talents, with almost none of the flaws (except possibly "self-indulgence," but that's just something you have to accept with ELP, and besides, nothing about this track is particularly self-indulgent). The basslines RULE, Lake's vocal delivery is aggressive and forceful in a manner that he didn't use nearly enough in the rest of the band's career (yup, I actually prefer aggressive Lake to bombastic Lake, even though the latter is just great), Emerson's playing is a perfect mix of jarring organ dissonance and blazing organ solos (ALL of which are interesting), and of course Palmer is Palmer. I tell you, when Lake blasts out his, "CAN YOU STILL KEEP YOUR BALANCE?!!" vocal near the end, it's absolute meaningless (but not imageless, make the distinction people) bombastic prog bliss for me, and when taken all together, it's little wonder that this is the track (along with "The Barbarian," heh) that I use to try to introduce people to ELP (and with a decent level of success, considering that it's ELP, heh).

Unfortunately, the majority of the second half of the album doesn't come close to matching the sheer brilliance of the first, and for many people this is what causes the rating of this to come crashing down like a ton of bricks. The first two tracks of this side, you see, comprise a lengthy (about 15 minutes) instrumental suite, consisting of a multi-part classically- influenced keyboard piece ("The Three Fates") and a drum solo ("Tank"). Upon first (and possibly second, and third) listen, these will come across as a completely self-indulgent mess, and it's possible you may want to dismiss them outright (I know I basically did). On the other hand, though, by making the three sections of "The Three Fates" distinctive from each other in both sound and mood, not to mention actually somewhat memorable (even for somebody who doesn't spend all day listening to this sort of thing), Emerson found a way to make me enjoy the piece much more than theory says I should, and as such I'm not at all offended by its inclusion on this album. As for "Tank," well, it's a drum solo, and I don't much like drum solos, so it does somewhat offend me. That said, I'm amused that the band employs one significant variation on virtually every other drum solo ever recorded, namely that the main riff of the piece is played by keyboards and not by guitar, and as far as the actual solo goes, I think that Palmer is better suited for "show-off" soloing than most others I've heard (just because of his incredible technical ability), so I don't hate it as much as I do other solos.

Fortunately for all, the album ends not on an ambivalent note (regarding my attitude towards it), but rather on an extremely strong one, courtesy of the radio hit "Lucky Man." The song does a wonderful job of reminding the listener that the foundation of the band's greatness lay not with all their instrumental pyrotechnics, but with their ability to create solid "normal" songs, with their playing abilities serving as an augmentation and not as a replacement for true inspiration and creativity. The ultimately tragic lyrics work well with the sea chanty-style melody, and while some might gripe that the ending synth solo (filled with all sorts of cool pitch-bending) is tacked on and completely inappropriate (not me, though), there can be no question that it leaves a major impression (for better or worse, depending) on the listener come album's end, and I'm all for leaving strong impressions. Besides, it functions well on a symbolic level as well, a sort of trumpet's call proclaiming the band's entrance into the pantheon of significant artists (at least for a couple of years).

In short, this is a solid 10, and without a doubt my very very favorite ELP album. It's the one that entertains me the most, and furthermore it's the one that interests me the most - after all, even if it doesn't define an entire genre like In the Court of the Crimson King does, it does represent an intriguing projection of modern-classical values onto conventional rock ideas, and that's definitely worth something in my book.

Most fans/listeners/people would agree that ELP's debut is probably one of their better releases, perhaps on a par with 'Trilogy', but not up there with 'Brain Salad Surgery'. And so I was surprised to see that on this site, it is the highest ranked album by the trio with a good forty places above their alleged magnum opus.

It almost definately has something to do with the cloud of pretentiousness that has been thrust upon the band, because this is the only release where such a quality isn't present. And while some people have obviously underated the music on later albums due to the members' egos, that's not something I believe is fair. Sure, egocentricism is a social turn-off, but in order to even have any degree of success in the music industry you must showcase yourself. People might as well make music in private if others are going to criticise their attitude.

Anyway, 'Emerson, Lake and Palmer' is a fine album regardless of such arguments, but is it deserving of its place in the middle section of our top 100? I'm not so sure. It's fequently good, but also frequently individualistic. There are plenty of moments (by which I mean, too many on side 2) where only one or two of the band members are playing. And albums such as 'Ummagumma' and 'Fragile' prove that this only works if the music has a point to it, which on both albums, it doesn't. And I'm afraid to say that it doesn't here either. 'The Three Fates' is purely a pianist's virtuoso display; fine, but the bulk of 'Take a Pebble' already proved that Emerson was a fantastic musician, not to mention being a vehicle for Lake's acoustic skills. And with 'Lucky Man' being self-confessed filler, the only neccesary song on side 2 is 'Tank', an actual song with a brief drum solo that makes it's point and leaves again. Carl Palmer knows the difference between a studio and a stage.

I have no complaints about the group tracks; later albums would show significant development but these arrangements are good evidence that ELP was a band worth forming. In fact, despite my harsh remarks, all six tracks here are decent. It's just that 'Take a Pebble' and 'Knife Edge' sum up this band's sound enough between them to make the latter songs not needed. If 'Works' was too diverse, then this is too samey.

In conclusion, this debut is a classy and dynamic album, but it had something important to say:

"Emerson, Lake and Palmer are a great band, but they've already run out of ideas"

Thankfully the impending 'Tarkus' would disprove such a claim...

I've been very patient when it comes to reviewing ELP albums. The reason for that is the fact that the first four albums strike a nostalgic chord with me that will probably effect my judgment. But after thinking about it I've decided to give it a go. I just what you all to know that you should take my ELP-reviews with a grain of salt since they're written by a fan.

ELP albums have never, in my opinion, really been group efforts. That was until I discovered Emerson, Lake & Palmer's debut album. Here, I can actually hear Greg Lake's contributions on every track while still getting my regular dosage of Keith Emerson and Carl Palmer. It's clear that the band has a bunch of clever ideas, but those ideas wouldn't all be implemented with the same greatness as on their later releases. In other words, this album gives us a great group effort but lacks the maturity.

Only the album opener The Barbarian is great enough to be comparable with the band's later work. Take A Pebble definitely comes close to greatness but falls due to the very loose middle section of the track. My recommendation is to start with Tarkus, Pictures At An Exhibition and Trilogy and later work your way to this release and maybe even Brain Salad Surgery. Although, if you ask me, you can probably skip everything that came after Trilogy all together since it's all just an ego trip between the band members.

The band's debut album is a good example of what these three individuals might have achieved if only they continued to collaborate as a band. Instead they only fell further apart from each other with each consecutive release. This, in no way, implies that they still couldn't write great music, even though it was never again the band effort that can be observed here.

***** star songs: The Barbarian (4:33)

**** star songs: Take A Pebble (12:34) Knife-Edge (5:08 The Three Fates (7:45) Tank (6:52) Lucky Man (4:36)

This is probably my fav ELP album. The Barbarian is excellent in the keyboards guitar and drums all 3 guys show off in this one and is the only song on this album where all men contribute to it. Take a Pebble is the first Greg Lake ballad on this the album but not the last or best. I like the piano work but i do think it trudges on a bit to long. Knife Edge, my favorite song off this album and the most played ELP song on my iPod i love the drive of it the anger and Lakes vocals and lyrics soar over it just rite to creates a great mood for this song. The Three Fates a very interesting song the first part is Emerson on a church organ and has a very epic feel and makes me fell im in a church hall for this part. the next part is a fantastic piano solo and the final part is my favorite part which shows the chemistry Emerson and Palmer have together on piano and drums. Tank is Carl Palmers drum solo on the album and has backing from Keith's Clavinet for a while and then jumps into this amazing and influential (on my part) drum solo which goes for about 3 mins and really shows us that Palmer can hold his own in this power trio supergroup ELP was. Lucky Man the final song and ballad from Lake one of my fav songs from ELP and is really impressive and easy to sing along too also has a remember able Moog solo from Emerson. Overall, a fantastic album that paved the road for Tarkus, Trilogy and Brain Salad Surgery.

This was, for me, a revolutionary album, very much in the vein of KING CRIMSON's Court of the Crimson King. That keyboards could be that expressive, and that dominant was totally revelatory to me. I had never before heard "rock" classical music--though with a jazzy flavor to it. Though I had not yet heard Aaron Copeland or Bach's compositions for church organ, I felt as though I were being introduced to the masters of old--Keith EMERSON provided a kind of bridge to classical music (which I would dive into whole-heartedly in the 1980s). 1. "The Barbarian" (4:33) is such an introductory bridge for me. (9/10)

2. "Take a Pebble" (12:34) has some of the most gorgeous vocal and bass melodies in all music. To think that Greg LAKE could even conceive of singing his beautiful lines over such odd musical background is still astounding to me. (10/10)

3. "Knife Edge" (5:08) is powerful for both keyboards and Greg LAKE's vocal. (Not much of a fan of the drumming here.) (8/10)

The three-part keyboard extravaganza, 4. "The Three Fates" (7:45) starts off so majestic and pompously with the awesome church organ, then goes into the amazing piano part--which, incidentally, feels as if it has three distinct personalities--before moving into the trio section. Awesome ride! (Pre-dating RENAISSANCE's comparable "Trip to the Fair" by a few years.) (10/10)

5. "Tank" (6:52). The world of electronic keyboards was so new to me, and this album had a lot to do with introducing me to the possibilities of said instruments. BTW, this song puts on display Carl PALMER's best drumming on the album. (Finally!) (9/10)

6 "Lucky Man" (4:36) is to this day probably my favorite all-time prog radio "hit" (rivalled only by FOCUS' "Hocus Pocus"). As much hate as it gets around here I find myself mystified: It is such a cool, gorgeous song with one of the greatest instrumental exits EVER! Prog's "Man of La Mancha"! (10/10)

I did not like this album--or ELP--so much when I first heard it but each and every successive listen to this album has helped to win me over and caused the band (and album) to grow in my esteem. I now feel that this eponymous debut album is one of the most important, foundational albums of all of progressive rock music. Amazing, start to finish!

Let me begin by saying that I don't like the pieces that the group plays, and I don't like the over-the-top way it's approached. Yet I have to give this 5 stars, it's essential for the very purposes of why prog archives exist at all. The musicianship is excellent too, and warrants our full attention and respect.

But I have to take issue with the biography listed here when it says that this was a new format in group lineup - you are joking. The whole concept of such a band was born in The Nice itself, which, as well attested, was born out of 1-2-3 (Clouds), who were the first Rock organ trio. So let's give ELP full credit for their achievements, but it doesn't do them any favours to embellish their claim to history with stuff that doesn't belong on their shoulders, they have enough unfair flak coming their way from the disgruntled tomato-throwers of the disc collecting world.

Let's just be glad ELP existed, for along with King Crimson and Yes, they put this show on the road. Of course it went too far, and disappeared up its own jacksy. That's the nature of improvisation and experimentation. I used to see Keith at the Speakeasy, jamming happily a la Jimmy Smith, having a whale of a time, but making music of no good purpose, like most musicians when they're allowed to jam without thought or construction - They have great fun, we watch the spectacle, but as long we don't listen to the music too closely, it's ok, just kids playing games.

The fame and success of ELP let them do just that, and they got disconnected to us. But they did a great job just the same.

After the harrowing "Brain Salad Surgery, " I was afraid to hear anything more from Emerson, Lake and Palmer.Decided hear his first album, self titled, and miha surprise he's not so bad.

Except for "Tank", all other tracks have good moments.Except for "Lucky Man ", all other tracks have tickets decepcionantes.I had high hopes for "Take a Pebble, "and they were met in the first part (the guitar solo is great), but everything went downhill with the confused and rambling piano solo that lasts until the end of música.Sinceramente, I do not like the Emerson-bodies are boring and arrogant.

Between 3 and 4 stars, I'll give you three, but who knows in the near future ...

Much of this is bravado and huffing and puffing; the compositional quality is dubious in the extreme; yet this is an essential piece of our history, next to Crimson, probably the most important band of them all. Born from the ashes of The Nice more than Crimson (despite Greg Lake's input), this was Emerson putting keyboards on the map, pushing guitarists to one side as the lead instrument, perhaps taking the cue and clue from Clouds but making so much more of it than that band ever could.

The tragedy for me is that this could have been so much more, had the excellent writing of Lake been given the prominence it should have had. Perhaps that again is the flaw in progressive rock, the writing and the music have often two different agendas, audiences being audiences, the musicians tend to win, having the loudest voice and applause, but this isn't necessarily a victory, music is the loser.

I have mixed feelings about this album and indeed about the band. But one can't justifiably deny them their importance in history. Has to be five stars.

This ELP self-titled debut album is probably the only one of their albums that I can slightly enjoy all the way though, and this is only because they haven't starting playing in the pretentious style that took over on their later releases. The playing here is fluid and the songwriting is barely existent, although it stands that I really don't like ELP's music and this review is only for review's sake.

"The Barbarian" is heavy rock inspired prog jam that is quite energetic and fun to listen to. "Take a Pebble" is the first track that I had ever heard of ELP and it serves as a terrific introduction to the band. It's a calm track that starts with Emerson strumming the strings inside of his piano, creating a very nice atmosphere that is instantly memorable and gripping. The vocals are also strong here. The song goes through various passages that seem to be loosely strung together, but manages to come off as playful rather than overly serious. "Knife-edge" is another rock inspired song with a very solid bass line and strong keyboards. This track comes across as a bit too goofy for me, and I personally never enjoyed it. Most of "The Three Fates" is a jazzy and modern classical inspired piano solo, but the other instruments later come in at the end and manage to make quite a bit of noise. This only stands out as being the only incessantly noisy track. "Tank" is a noisy and random track that most people seem to enjoy, but I also find this track to be forgettable and incessantly noisy. After all the noise, "Lucky Man" is a classic acoustic ballad that is very accessible. It still isn't a song that I enjoy, but it is beautiful and a great break from all the madness that came before it.

I recommend this to people who already know they like ELP, which I am not. In fact, I know that I don't like ELP. However, this is one of their best albums, and I recommend this as an introduction to the band.

Emerson Lake & Palmer - st (1970)

To be honest with you, listening to this album was a relief for me. I'm not that good at liking common 'masterpieces' and this ELP debut was actually quite extraordinary, especially when you place it on a time-line of progressive rock.

Keith Emerson (the Nice), Greg Lake (King Crimson) and Carl Palmer (Arthur Brown, Atomic Rooster) formed this first super-group of progressive rock. With their music they changed the way progressive rock was perceived. From now on progressive rock didn't need to be music with strange atmospheres and innovative ideas, but the extreme technicality would ad both ego and some playfulness to the mix. ELP didn't embark on the spacey atmospheric passages, but they would play fast, thick, right in your face instrumental passages without to much delays and reverb.

The recording quality & sound of this album is stunning for 1970. All instruments sound warm, clear and have a good place in the musical land-scape. Later on dozens of Italian symphonic progressive rock groups would try to get this sound again, and frankly, none ever did except for Banco (debatable topic though). Most of the time ELP has a bass, drums and two keyboards or a piano. The arrangements are exciting and bombastic, with many organ and moog sounds (with amazing bass) that would make you forget a band ever needed a guitar player. Though this album has many moments of great intelligent en technical compositions, the other big element of his album is showing of musicianship. Luckily there's also some good song-writing and I must say I even like the ending ballad 'Lucky Man'. I still think Greg Lake is one of the best vocalists of prog, though I don't like many ELP recordings.

Conclusion. This is the best ELP album for me, and it's good to know it still sounds fresh after more then forty years. Though this album features all weaknesses of the band, it is dominated by the quality of the compositions and the song-writing. After this only side one of Tarkus would be of this quality IMHO. Four stars for this one, but I can recommend it to every-one on this site.

Yeah, what a great debut album this is!!

This is my personal favorite of all the ELP albums, and in the Progressive Rock genre in general.

I remember the first time I put the record on, and "The Barbarian" just took me all by surprise and messed up my head & my senses REAL bad. I LOVED IT! "The Barbarian" is one of THE best prog rock tracks EVER, with its ripping Hammond Organ sound, sick piano parts, great drumming and ripping distorted bass. Sure, it's a cover of Bela Bartok's "Barbario", but who cares as long as it's this good?

"Take a Pebble" has got great lyrics, beautifully sung by Greg Lake. Great piano through the whole song, displaying Keith Emerson as a real virtuoso on keyboards. Love the jazzy part in the middle.

"Knife Edge" is another ELP classic that I instantly loved. VERY hard distorted Organ sound, with many different parts, again showing Keith Emerson as a real virtuoso. It's very much like a Classical symphony in some places, but also Jazzy in other places. Great drumming from Carl Palmer on this one.

"The Three Fates" is a great vehicle for Emerson for showing his chops. He was really creative here, with a Church Organ and Piano.

"Tank" is just a great Jazzy and slightly funky & psychedelic instrumental, with a great drum solo in it. I really enjoy listening to this one.

The final track "Lucky Man" is a nice little Folk-song with some dramatic lyrics. As we all know, there is a famous Moog-solo in the end, though it's maybe a little misplaced. My least favourite on the album funny enough, as it was THIS song that became their first single & signature song, at least for a while.

Overall: NO weak spots on the album. A great album as a whole, and a must have classic.

The onset of senilism and old age means I have forgotten to review this album...... before tonight.

And what can I say about the debut album from a band whose first albums + first live albums I love ? All songs on this album is legends, no less. The three musicians here had a wide variety of background, but it is fair to say that Keith Emerson put his stamp on this album. It is not as rock'n'roll as his previous band The Nice was. This album feels much more as a fusion between baroque classical music and rock. Yes, this album borrows a lot from Johan Sebastian Bach.

Take A Pebble is my favorite track here and that despite of that being a more rock than a baroque number. But all songs here are classics and only a full fiver will do for me here. 24 carat gold it is.

5 stars

Although I can't say I got on too well with their later directions, I do like ELP's debut. Not uncritically - although the performances are undeniably good, they don't reach the stratosphere, but then again they don't reach the depths of later work either. I would say, in fact, that if you want *consistency*, this is the best ELP album of them all - later albums would be much more up-and-down in terms of quality.

The album starts with some rocked-out classics in the form of The Barbarian, with a down and dirty performance that proves that this supergroup can get heavy if it wants to (though it's no Atomic Rooster). Other highlights include Take a Pebble, in which the group proves that it can bring jazz into its formula as well as classical music, and the closing Lucky Man which binds a Moog solo to a folk-rock number with surprising success.

I guess part of the reason I can't quite extend my rating to five stars is that the album feels directionless. Musically, the group are very diverse, but the consequence of that is that the tracks don't seem to flow together very well and it's hard to say what the band's identity or sound at this point really is - or even if it does have an identity at all beyond being a vehicle for the three named talents to strut their stuff. They would succeed in forging a unique sound for themselves in the title track of Tarkus... but that album, and subsequent ones, would continue to have the problem that the three musical personalities in the group just never quite gelled, resulting in all of their work having a similar lack of focus to this one. That said, even if I find their later work patchy, still *this* album turns me on. (See what I did there?) Four stars.

The debut from the first rock supergroup is a memorable one. From the opening instrumental The Barbarian to the closing ballad Lucky Man this feels like a complete listen by three guys who were determined to do things their way. Most of the songs are written by the individual members and not as a group except for Barbarian which might be the best song on the album with a memorable bass intro and great keyboards from Emerson. The Three Fates is a mention able song because it goes through so many changes and shows off Emerson and Palmer's ability. Tank, Palmer's drum solo is also fantastic and influential on me. Overall, this is one of the best debuts by any band and is worth a listen. 5 stars. Highlights: The Barbarian, Take a Pebble, Knife Edge, The Three Fates, Tank, and Lucky Man.

Reviewing albums from 1970 on a progressive rock site without mentioning Emerson Lake & Palmers debut would be beyond foolish, so here it is. Concerning 1970, I actually would consider this the most important prog album of the year. Plenty of the major forces in prog were developing their sound and even releasing some fantastic albums, but most of those bands' seminal releases would not occur until the following few years. However, ELP did not waste their time churning out one of their highest regarded works from the get-go, packaged in an album cover that comes across like The Moody Blues in an uncharacteristically morbid and bleak mood.

"The Barbarian" starts off with a mean distorted bass before the keyboards kick in and it is soon realized that this is pure keyboard driven prog rock without things like loud guitars getting in the way. Still, this does have some power and 'oomph' to it, and the song does not feel incomplete despite lacking ripping guitar solos and vocals.

"Take A Pebble" is an interesting track with its gorgeous verses and long break in the middle with a bit of a hoedown tossed in. Odd, but strangely atmospheric. "Knife-Edge" has a bit of that Atomic Rooster sound to it and actually feels like all of the performers' previous bands contributed equal levels of influence to the overall sound of the song.

"The Three Fates" is Emerson's "LOOK AT ME" song, and for what it's worth, I pretty much dig the 2nd part featuring the solo piano quite a bit. "Tank" is Palmer's stab at glory, and it starts off cool, but drum solos over a minute long on studio albums eventually bore me. There were a lot of these drum solos being pumped out on albums back then. "Lucky Man" gets slagged a bit, but Lake's contribution to this album remains one of their best known tracks, and is actually the best track on side two. Catchy chorus, friendly guitar solo, folksy vibe that was in vogue at the time. Yet there's still that wild moog attack at the tune's end that brings back the prog and keeps things interesting.

ELP have never released a brilliant album in my opinion, but as an important one, this certainly deserves lots of regards. It sort of set the bar up a bit earlier than most in for the prog scene, and remains highly influential.

I actually reckon the Nice was better than ELP, at least to listen to. I loved the classical electric take, the idiosyncratic approach. Of course, it was rough and ready, not smooth at all, not as smooth as ELP itself. Then again, it would be churlish not to say that ELP was the important step, one of THE seminal groups in Prog and certainly one of the first. I dont think this album is the best of ELP, for me, that was Tarkus, but its a statement of intent, and has a magnificence that at times transcends the lack of clarity in composition and aesthetics. I always feel uneasy with those who knock this group too easily, such an important group should not get such unsympathetic responses, especially by those who fail to understand the timeline of it all. I would personally have liked a lot more to come from the three outstanding musicians involved, but Im sure glad they put this together for the sake of us all. HAS to be five stars for importance alone.

Aside from the rather pop oriented "Lucky man" this album is restless and relentless to a degree that has rarely ever been put on record. The musicianship is top notch and Keith Emerson proves here, especially with the ingenious "lachesis" part in "the three fates", that he was probably the most virtuous keybord player ever in rock music history. Even putting the legendary Rick Wakeman to the second place. This album is so full of energy and ideas that I know only of a handful other records that could compete with it in that respect, maybe Birds of Fire being another one. In my book this is one my ten island records and the relatively low ranking on this site seems almost grotesque to me. Definitely one of the most original and technically skillful records I have heard. Top Ten material!

3.5 stars

Emerson, Lake, and Palmer's first album is definitely one of their stronger ones, and I really love some of the tracks on the album. That said, some of the songs are lacking. "Take a Pebble" has never really kept my interest. The intro is very intriguing, but the rest doesn't really have "that special ELP styling" about it. "Lucky Man" isn't good at all. The cheesy keyboard solo actually makes the song worse, as if it wasn't bad enough already. Greg, why on Earth did you think that this song was a good idea?!?!

"The Barbarian" has great bass, especially since it has that powerful fuzzy tone. The actual keyboards are a tad annoying, and don't feel (in my opinion) like they belong there. I really love "Knife- Edge", and find it to be the strongest song on the album. "The Three Fates" is also fantastic, and deserves special recognition for probably the best piano work on the album. "Tank" has a great drum solo.

I really enjoy this album, and feel like it deserves 4/5 stars just for being such a great debut. However, I can't bring myself to rate it any higher than 3.5 stars.

I must confess that I was never a big fan of ELP. Too much keyboards noodling and too little guitar, I guess. However, I cannot deny their importance for rock in general and the prog world in particular. They were truly grounbreakers that merged classical, rock and jazz into a very new kind of sound that defined the 70´s. There were groups that worked those styles before (among them Keith Emerson´s own band prior to ELP, The Nice), but not in such scale of talent and style. Emerson was right when he finished The Nice and looked for the right line up to fit his ideas. So while he and drummer Carl Palmer were technical and trained,. bassist, guitarrist and vocalist Greg Lake (from King Crimson) balanced the sound with nice acoustic songs and warm vocals. This chemistry remains unsurpassed.

I heard their debut album many years ago and I bought it again a few weeks ago. And I was astonished by how good it was. I mean, I didn´t exactly turned into a hardcore fan of them, but it is clear to anyone that their first work was a milestone in rock music when it was released in 1970. They impressed many with their instrumental virtuosity, but they also came with great songs to match, even for radio play. Several of ELP´s more celebrated stuff was introduced here: Take a Pebble, Knife Edge, Tank, Lucky Man. Besides we have other fine epics like the opener The Barbarian and the surprisingly varied suite The Three Fates (I loved the caribbean rhythms included on one of the parts, with a great percussion work done by Palmer). The CD is incredibly well balanced and nothing is really overdone here (like it surely would in years to come). Such an achievement for such young band.

It had a good production for the time and the new remasterd edition made it quite perfect.

Like King Crimson´s debut, ELP defined the coming of age of an era with its first release, a great promise that was totally fulfilled (all the future excesses included). This CD is not only a great record. It is, along Yes Close to The Edge, Genesis Foxtrot and the aforementioned Crinson´s first, the quintessential work of a new time in music, no less. A classic, essential masterpiece fo progressive rock. Five stars with honours.

The debut album of three non-debutants as this is one of the first supergroups in the prog history. Keith Emerson comes from the Nice and the first track of this album "The Barbarian" clearly demonstrates it "from the beginning". Carl Palmer is the powerful drummer from Atomic Rooster and Gre Lake is the man behind the Crimson's masterpiece 21st Century Schizoid Man.

Can you expect a masterpiece from this band?

Yes, of course.

Reviewing an album of this kind is very hard because finding something that hasn't already been said by somebody else is very uneasy and unlikely to happen.

However after the very "nice" opener, Greg Lake gifts us of his fantastic voice on "Take A Pebble". I'm one of those who think that Lake is one of the greatest singers ever. I think that his voice is the essence of how a prog vocalist should sound and this long song is for me the best of the album and one of the absolutely best songs released by ELP. It contains all the things which have made this band great: a great piano solo, the non-invasive but effective drums and a lot of ideas. Emerson harping directly on the strings of an open grandpiano while Lake plays a 12 strings guitar in an oriental performance that grows into a country-blues piece. An epic track which pays back for the whole album.

"Knife Edge"'s bass line is something that's fixed in my mind since from the 70s. Sometimes these few notes pop up to my mind unexpectedly. Emerson's keyboards has here that sound that will forever be the band's trademark, so what could I ask more to a five minutes song?

Let's switch to Side B (I have the vinyl, of course). The church organ which opens the mini suite "The Three Fates (Atropos, Clotho and Lachesis)" is pompous and dark as a church organ only can be and I think this is the track which gave to some Italian directors the idea of hiring Emerson for horror movie's soundtracks. After the initial organ part, the rest of the track is mainly based on piano as Emerson only can play it. I don't want to enter in the polemics about who's the best player between Emerson and Wakeman. I like both and they are just similar but different. This is another track that I love.

"Tank" became famous in my country because it was used as end title track of a weekly TV magazine. It started from the last minutes of the drum solo until the end, but it was the version taken from Works. Here it's still one of the most famous ELP songs and on the album is followed by the radio-friendly one: Lucky Man.

I loved that song but as all the radio-friendly things, I've got a bit tired of it during the years. What I still love of this song is the final keyboard riff that's not so much radio-friendly.

The only "bad" thing of this album is the presence of very low volume parts, specially on take A Pebble (but even the following albums will have silences and low volume moments). This is a problem when you pretend to listen to the album while driving. It requires headphones and finding the right way to listen to this album was not easy neither cheap in the early 70s.

However this is a masterpiece and I still listen to this ELP album (and not to this one only) even after 40 years.

A great debut. It might even be the most well-put-together album from the group.

Aside from the leftover cover art (which was originally made for an american rock-group called Spirit), I really dont seem to find any kind of notable flaws in this album. It opens up appropriately with "The Barbarian". An adaptation from Bela Bartok's Allegro Barbaro. Lake's distorted bass creates a solid and strong structure for the song, while Emerson's grand piano and percussive organ masterfully lead it. Palmer, in the other hand, shows his true skills in the end with a drum solo you wont forget. Three words: FAST AS HELL. This showcase of ELP's teamwork is definitely my favourite piece from the album. The second track "Take a Pebble" is a step in a different direction. This folky ballad runs for over 12 minutes, and consist of several sections. It's quite ambitious. One would even consider it the best of the bunch. It's and archetypal Greg Lake composion, and a good one at that. The third one is another modern classical adaptation, which is interesting because it sounds like any good rockin' tune from the early 70's to (only with modal hammond-organ interludes). I think it's one of the least appealing songs in the album, and that's not because it's unappealing in any level. It just is not as amazing than the two tracks before. Still, it can be enjoyed for what it's worth: A rockin' tune with modal organ interludes. If you are listening the vinyl, now it's time to switch sides. Side B opens up with "The Three Fates" (as in the greek mythology), divided in three parts, showcasing both Emerson's skill and ego. It's an amazing composion, but is it rock? No. Altough the last section "Atropos" has percussions, it should viewed as a classical composion. The fifth track "Tank" is the same thing for Palmer what "The Three Fates" is for Emerson. It starts with the whole band. A hohner clavinet is a lead instrument, which Emerson uses in a very classical manner, altough a clavinet is usually an instrument favoured in funk, blues and jazz. Emerson plays a solo first before giving the spotlight to Palmer. Around the two minute mark, it's Palmer's turn to shine. Needless to say, his solo is great, and it soon became a major part of their future performances. The last minutes of the song includes the whole band again, and it's Emerson let loose again. This time he plays much more bluesier solo with the moog synthesizer until the song fades. The sixth and the final track "Lucky Man" is a song which i hear has received mixed opinions. Why? I think it's a great piece, and i even love the "notorious" ending of it. Just because ELP made a radio-oriented song does not make it bad. I dont know, decide for yourselves.

Comparing this to the other "classic" studio albums by the band, I truly consider it best in a whole. I will say though, that the band's best composions (Tarkus, Karn Evil 9, The Endless Enigma) are all in the other albums. But then again, none of those albums would be made with the same level of seriousness like this one. For this matter, Emerson Lake & Palmer should be cherished just as much as the other classics.

This review refers to the recently released three disc deluxe edition and the question is: is it worth the double dip of buying it when you already have the original? I would say definitely yes.

The 5.1 mix alone is a revelation. You can hear things you were not too sure were there and hear them very clearly. It's not a gimmicky mix, there is not much in the way of surround effects with instruments flying around the room ala Brain Salad Surgery DVD Audio. The focus is more on dimensioning and ambience with a result that is quite stunning. Greg's multi-layered vocals just fills the room expecially on Take A Pepple and Lucky Man. Keith's Hammond almost sounds as if he were playing two of them with the high- ends coming out of the rears and the mid and low-ends out of the fronts. Carl's drums are pretty much spread evenly across the fronts with some going to the rears occasionally particulary the gongs and tympanis.

Now for the new stereo re-mixes and the extra tracks. While disc one includes the original LP, discs 2 & 3 carries the new mixes and the 5.1 surround mix (disc 3 DVD Audio). It's somewhat a mixed bag of goodies. The new stereo mixes really don't provide much of anything new except on Knife Edge where the tape manipulations on the original are gone. I'm talking about the speed up on Keith's organ just before the final verse kicks in and the slow down at the end. What you do get at the end of Knife Edge is an extended improv with Keith tweedling around on his Hammond which is interesting. Also included is an unreleased loose instrumental titled Rave Up that eventually evolved into Mass on Tarkus which is pretty good and shows that can really jam on the fly when they want to.

Other extras included are a cut of Promenade later used for Pictures At An Exhibition. Carl's studio drum solo that's a little different than the one we're familiar with. And there are various alternate takes on other songs including Greg doing Lucky Man solo. Keep in mind that because of the lack of the multi-track masters, Tank and the opening church organ segment on Three Fates are not included on these remixes either stereo or 5.1. Which is a disappointment for me, I would've loved to hear Carl's drums phasing at the end of his solo in 5.1 surround.

All in all, I would say it's worth an extra purchase for this title especially if you got a surround system.

5 stars for the title 5 stars for this edition 'nuff said

Emerson, Lake and Palmer's eponymously named first album was a harbinger of things to come. From the opening notes of The Barbarian we know that we are facing something more than the sum of their parts - it's not the Nice, It's not King Crimson, it's not Atomic Rooster. Moving to the second track we get the ethereal Take A Pebble, which comes in like a light breeze blows through several changes and exits on a whisper, a great song.

Following that we are taken to the Knife Edge, a rollicking piece that is as sharp as anything ELP has ever done. The Three Fates come on the start of side two of the LP and it is one of my least favorite tracks by ELP.

Tank is an interesting cut as its power folls over you like thunder and showcases Palmer's percussive skills. Lucky Man, which closes the album proper was their first single, and it received quite a lot of airplay, even now on AOR or Classic Rock stations. Asigniture Lake tune.

The 2012 remastered edition features Rave Up and a Drum Solo not found on the original and they are wuite interesting, too. But the original album is something that is a must for prog collectors as it showcases what is to come from these Progressive Rock Giants.

The eponymous debut is the album that started the legacy of the first prog rock super-group. Surely with this much talent the instrumentation should be impeccably sharp. But this is where the problem lies. Much of this album relies on excessive noodling and showmanship.

The perfect example of this is on songs like 'Take a Pebble' and 'Tank.' The former is kind of messy and doesn't really go anywhere, while the latter also has some noodling, especially in the drum solo.

Three Fates' exhibits a similar problem, while 'Lucky Man' is just a throwaway track they added at the last minute.

'The Barbarian' and 'Knife Edge' show what the band is capable of when they concentrate and write a shorter, more concise song. The result is a complex, yet interesting and fun song.

Overall, despite the problems this album has with over-zealous instrumentation, it's still an enjoyable listen from beginning to end and certainly doesn't deserve just two stars.

5/10

I have mixed feelings about this album. I want to like it because these guys are excellent musicians, but the music seems too serious and feels kind of cold to me. It's a good album, but not a lot of fun. The tracks I like the best are "The Barbarian", a good heavy instrumental piece, "Knife Edge" another good heavy piece which also has Greg singing, and "Lucky Man", a nice soft song with Greg and the band singing and a cool synthesizer sound at the end. I like parts of "Take A Pebble", the singing and the first piano section, but the middle segment is too long and meandering. The quiet parts really take it off course and feels lost. I don't care very much at all for "The Three Fates", or "Tank", mainly because I don't like drum solos. I hope the next Emerson, Lake and Palmer album I get a chance to hear will be better for me.

This is a monsterous piece of progressive rock and of course one of those who created a style of prog that was very special. The record "Emerson, Lake & Palmer" by the gruop "Emerson, Lake & Palmer" which consisted of the organ player Keith Emerson, the bassist, guitarist and singer Greg Lake and the drummer and percussionist Carl Palmer, was released 1970 and was so fantastic significant that is is strange how three guys could do so special and powerful music.

The music on this record is creative, crazy and brilliant. It's so sophisticated and has so much high class in it. The inspiration is classical piano symphonies, heavy rock and jazz drum solos. The significant space of "Take a pebble" for example must be one of the most holy progressive pieces.

This whole album is absolutely amazing but my favourite track is "Take a pebble" where we got everything we wan't from this band, the awesome song of Grek Lake for example. But every minute of the album is marvelous. "The Barbarian" is a powerful start and the experimental "Tank" changes your head for sure. Finaly "Lucky Man" is a great end with great guitar and everything.

Most special for the band is though Emerson's organ which seems to come from another planet; such a virtuos. Sometimes a symphonic band consists of a full orchestra and does still not sound especially rich. These three men could build up a musical world of few ingredients and make a pompous and extravagant cake of it, more pretentious than ever. A milestone!

It is certainly no surprise that the debut album by this group is both a landmark and ground-breaking effort. All three musicians had pretty impressive previous group involvements, and the musical chemistry and timing of Emerson, Lake and Palmer were just right.

The ELP debut is a perfectly constructed recording; there isn't a note or beat in this record I would alter in any way, even if I could. The music therein is both technically excellent, and emotive in the same breath. Though ELP from the start were a "People's Band" that really understood who they were playing for in their audiences, the band was also an inspiration to so many professional music groups that came in their wake, from the likes of LE ORME, THE TRIP and TRIADE in Italy, to TRIUMVIRAT in Germany, the list is endless. I've always really enjoyed Greg Lake's feeling he creates in his vocals on this record, but most of all, it is the band's instrumental prowess that impresses me the most, like with The Barbarian on side one, and The Three Fates and Tank on side two. The instrumental technique displayed on all tracks is exemplary, really.

Their debut album is so well done, it is better than anything that these musicians did previously, and though they created some admirable subsequent records, this one hangs together for me the most, and has stood the test of time the most. No rock collection is complete without it. Five deserving stars.

For me ELP was always one of the most inconsistent and uneven of the great prog bands of the 70's. Their albums seemed marred and at times unfocused, blending greatness with fillers. Often these fillers appear to have been great fun recording in the studio. A great laugh for all involved but less fun for people like me, having to bear through it or skipping songs, thus breaking the spell.

Their first album, however, is interesting in many ways. First off it is sort of crude and raw, bringing forth a musical concoction based on distorted organ, heavy bass and thumping drums. One can easily see how the early phases of prog developed through the adaptation of heavy and hard rock of the late 60's, paving the way for ever more sophistication further into the decade.

Secondly I find the first album to be the most consistent. The presence of classical influences are there but first and foremost it is an album of heavy, menacing and powerful prog performed on organ, bass and drums. Magnificent! Especially since I am a great fan of the hammond organ.

The first track, The barbarian, hits you right in the face with it's distorted bass and rolls you over, feeling like you've been hit by a train. The second track is a marvellous, multi-part piece called Take a pebble. It seems to have been a live favorite and I can understand why. Very atmospheric and provides a great example of early prog's ability and willingness to expand on musical structure. Knife-edge is similar to The barbarian. It is a hard rock piece. Very heavy and certainly one of my favorites. The three fates is the track where ELP's fascination for classical music comes to the fore. It is a complex, daring piece which opens up with a majestic organ. The track Tank showcases Carl Palmer's amazing drum skills. The album closes with the ballad Lucky man. A nice song, deliverd with emotion and beauty.

All in all ELP's first album is a starting point for what is to come later on. It is quite raw but not without sophistication and wealth of music. On this album the focus and concistency is never broken. The magic is there throughout, making it, simply, their best album, although not consisting of their all time best tracks, like Tarkus for instance. A great place to start and certainly a great way to end the day.

Forty-four years after I first bought this album, I am still in love with it. In fact, with all my experience of the subsequent history of Prog Rock, the ELP debut sounds more captivating than ever. It's a moment of magical genius, when the three musicians first worked together - and the chemistry was unbelievable. I can't name another album that sounds even remotely like this one, not even from ELP. There are moments, such as the title track of 'Trilogy', or 'Toccata' from BSS, when it seems they are trying to recapture the sound of their debut album. But there is a uniqueness and coherence about the 'Emerson Lake & Palmer' album that has always set it apart. I think it's the inspired improvisation on acoustic instruments combined with a heavy yet measured use of the electric instruments. Even the much-questioned 'Lucky Man' sounds perfectly in place with its acoustic strings and Moog accompaniment.

And you should have seen 'Knife Edge' on stage in this period! Emerson vaulting over the Hammond and pulling it over... madness.

Verdict: a pinnacle in Prog Rock history.

This is the debut album from this supergroup of stellar musicians. This was to become the outlet for Keith Emerson, Greg Lake and Carl Palmer to showcase their musicianship. But, at it's peak, it was more than anything a spotlight for Emerson's spectacular keyboard playing and composing. As you listen to this album, which has been reviewed plenty of times here already, you will notice that everyone gets to shine, but the balance of the spotlight is tilted quite heavily to Emerson, which is fine. His talent has inspired countless musicians and has influenced many people to explore other avenues of music that they normally would not have explored.

This album is amazing, especially for a debut album. There is quite a mix of classically inspired rock. The mix of sounds you get here should not be too surprising because of the talent. You start off with "The Barbarian" with the full band doing their take on a Bartok composition from 1911; "Allegro Barbaro". After this somewhat bombastic instrumental where each band member shows off their talent, an epic track named "Take a Pebble" follows. This track has vocals from the amazing voice of Greg Lake. The sections where there is singing is performed by full band, but the very long instrumental break is surprisingly acoustic piano through most of it with a short break for an acoustic guitar solo and a return to the piano with drums joining in eventually. This is a very nice surprise because the sound is amazing and anyone who knows keyboards will be blown away by Emerson's playing. "Knife Edge" is another harder edged song again with full band and vocals and is very progressive. It is based on the first movement of Leo? Janáček's Sinfonietta. with a organ solo during the instrumental break that follows Bach's Allamande from the French Suite in D minor.

Following this you get two long instrumentals. The first being a suite called "The Three Fates" which is definitely another chance for Emerson to show off, of which I have no complaint. This is one of my favorite ELP tracks and probably one of the least known. You get a very cool organ solo on the first movement, and nice piano solo on the 2nd movement, and then the piano gets joined by drums and bass for the third. This is a very progressive number that always gets my heart pounding. This also demonstrates that Emerson is not only an amazing player, but an outstanding composer also. Next is "Tank" which is a full band instrumental which spotlights Carl Palmer this time. This is another excellent instrumental with a completely different feel from the last track and a very excellent drum solo in the middle which is not stretched out to a never-ending length. Palmer shares the spotlight with Emerson not only with the instruments but with the composition also. Great stuff. The album ends with the popular Lake folk rock ballad "Lucky Man" which features his vocals and guitar and ends with Emerson on synth that was overdubbed on the end so that everyone would know (on the radio) that this is not a Lake solo. Good song, but not very indicative of the rest of their sound and I'm sure a lot of people were surprised when they heard the song on the radio, bought the album and heard something they were not expecting. But it worked for the band and made them hugely popular and that popularity continued for several years.

Anyway, this is an excellent album that introduced a lot of people to the challenging music of progressive rock. In that way, it is essential in that it helped bring a lot of rock lovers around to becoming interested in classical music and a more sophisticated style of popular music. The importance of this album in rock music can not be denied. ELP would go on to produce some other great albums and some trashy ones too, but their influence in progressive and popular music is still felt today. Essential album. 5 stars.

From the first overdriven fuzz box bass note and organ crunch on this record, you know you are listening to something new and frightening. Emerson's organ has a Jon Lord-like metallic bite, much more aggressive than his work with the Nice, and Lake's bass and Palmer's drums are taking no prisoners. Even the piano sounds pissed off. Bartok's "The Barbarian" is like a tank grinding the musical landscape under its treads, but this is not punk or grunge---this is aggressive music played by virtuosos! (Emerson has said in his autobio that lyrics and tunes were slow to come on their debut album and it sounds like he took his frustrations out on his keys)...This same violent underpinning is there in "Knife Edge", their brilliant take on Janacek's Sinfonietta, the Carl Palmer drum showcase "Tank" and the church organ workout "The Three Fates". In the middle of these tricky songs, a bit of classical piano might break out, followed by a blast of Hammond or a maniacal drum passage.

Even the piano middle section in Lake's beautiful ballad "Take A Pebble" (among the best songs he did with the band) has a driven quality. This is not Rick Wakeman's tastefully-elegant baroque piano---much as I love it as well---but keyboard-as-machine-gun. Having said that, it still retains it's beauty and the opening and closing passages are almost gentle and fragile, compared to the rest of the album. "Take A Pebble" is a song that sounds almost like a bridge between classic ELP and early King Crimson---it has that meandering Lake acoustic guitar solo in the middle that reminds me of Crimso's jazzy, meandering side (no surprise, as Lake had just come from that group). The last song, the classic hit "Lucky Man", sounds out of place on this album, a folk song among classical organ and piano work-outs, but it is possessed of a magnificent opulence, as Lake adds on multi-tracked choir vocals on the choruses, guitar solos, and that classic Keith-playing-with-the-Moog-glide-control synthesizer solo on the outro, a howl that fades into a low frequency whistle that fades into an electronic hiss. Palmer's echo-ing drums ride out the end to a masterful FM radio hit that announced to the world that there was this strange-sounding new band, ELP!

Their debut album was truly the work of a prog rock supergroup...there hadn't been a union of a top-notch keyboardist, very good bass player with a soaring, majestic voice, and top-notch drummer like this in a power trio format like this before. Groundbreaking work in my opinion. The only reason I don't give this one 5 stars is I am reserving that for Brain Salad Surgery...

Perhaps the all-time greatest prog supergroup, even if few of the bands from which these individuals came are as well-known today. Keyboard whiz Keith Emerson was an original member of the Nice, a fine outfit which bore the first fruits of Keith's classical/rock adaptations. Lead singer, bassist and sometime guitarist Greg Lake came fresh from King Crimson Mark I (best known of course for "21st Century Schizoid Man"), while young virtuosic drummer Carl Palmer was previously a member of Atomic Rooster and The Crazy World of Arthur Brown. Never let it be said that these guys were short on ambition; their second gig ever was at the Isle of Wight Festival in 1970, in front of an estimated crowd of 600,000! Not that this really set the tone for their future long-form epics?heck, they were doing "Pictures at an Exhibition" even back then. In any case, around this time they kicked off their recording legacy with their self-titled debut, released in late 1970 in the UK and early 1971 in America.

I have to say that I'm excited to be reviewing the ELP ouevre, as Keith Emerson has always been a big influence on the way I think about music. Listening to his work here and in other venues, one gets the sense of someone who truly loved music and couldn't wait to express it any way he could, and this is borne out by his mastery of the Hammond organ and grand piano, as well as his pioneering work on Moog synthesizer (eventually befriending the late Bob Moog). Add to this the mileage that he got out of different genres?greatly influenced by music from Bach to Bartok and a more than passable jazz player as well?and his keen sense of marrying harmony and melody together, and you basically have my favorite prog keyboardist. Honestly, just about anything he does is worth listening to on some level.

The first track, "The Barbarian," is as good a representation of the ELP sound as any. An adaptation of Bela Bartok's solo piano piece "Allegro barbaro," the tone is set by a grungy, distorted bass riff and the now-classic overdriven, percussive organ sound. Serious Bartok fans will notice some differences between the original and ELP's version (notably in the first 80 seconds), but remarkably, these changes take nothing away from the piece itself. The second part is a quasi-jazz piano workout underscored by Palmer's deft brushwork and lighter bass guitar work from Lake, eventually building to a crescendo. The transitions are set up wonderfully and are organic to the piece in general, especially the run up the keyboard leading into a reprise of the first part of the piece (signaled by a gong). The title "The Barbarian" is certainly apropos as well, as the track has a persistent feeling of violence and uneasiness even in the quieter moments. Overall, though, the band couldn't have picked a better opening track.

"Take a Pebble" is an immediate change of pace. Here Emerson strums the strings of the piano, a move only recently discovered by 20th-century avant-garde classical composers; Keith's use of this technique is much more accessible though. The track itself is an atmospheric, sparse ballad of Lake's which is broken up by several distinct "episodes" to stretch the track out to 12:27. After two verses, the tempo doubles for piano-based variations on the melody line before a folky, solo acoustic guitar passage that turns into a country-ish riff halfway through. (This part of the song would evolve in live performance to include a couple of Lake's own numbers.) Much of the rest of this track is given to Emerson and his signature left-hand ostinato, which turns into a jazz exercise about 8 minutes in?in fact, I always thought that Emerson should have had a co-writing credit here, solely because of this section. As great as Lake's melody and lyrics here, the instrumental sections really hold it all together and take it to another level. Dig Lake's quasi-double-tracked vocals in the last verse, as well as Emerson's quote of Bach's Invention in C Major (here transposed).

Onward to the next track, which is "Knife Edge," another classic in the ELP canon. It took me a while to realize that this was another classical adaptation, this time of Czech composer Leos Janacek's "Sinfonietta"?the band updates it to sound like a hard-rock riff from the 1920s or thereabouts. Sparkling instrumental work characterizes this track, and Keith's organ sounds grungier than ever (in fact this is the grittiest tone he would ever get out of the Hammond, another way of making this track stand out). Lake double-tracks his vocals again, which aren't exactly in sync with each other; somehow this adds to the humanity of the group performances. The end of the tune, with the tape slowing down to almost nothing, is another innovative touch. Great track, and a great way to close out side one. And hey, isn't that another Bach quote in the instrumental section? I believe it is!

Side two is basically the "solo" side, with each member showing off his strengths. Keith's first up with "The Three Fates," naturally divided into three parts. "Clotho" is all on pipe organ, a menacing piece that explores the different timbres of the unwieldy instrument in about 90 seconds. "Lachesis" is solo piano, and one of the best examples of Emerson's pure compositional skill and technique (wonder why he never seems to have played this live?). A brief pipe organ episode leads to "Atropos," the most avant-garde section of the piece. Here Keith overdubs three piano tracks on top of each other, accompanied only by Palmer's drums in 7/8. The entire piece is built on a whole-tone scale and eventually the "top" piano (based on the range of the keyboard) introduces a steady 16th-note triplet rhythm in 4/4 time, which will throw off the unsuspecting listener. Wild stuff.

A fuzzy, electronic crashing noise leads to "Tank," which rides a nervous riff under Keith's overdubbed Clavinets. This is another jazzy piece (like "Atropos" and the middle section of "The Barbarian") that is built on the Dorian mode, and Keith wows us with his skills yet again. After some brief sparring matches between keys and drums, the piece gives way to a fast and furious drum solo. I'll give credit where credit is due; Palmer's solo has a lot more imagination and flexibility than most ham-fisted rock drum solos of the time, and the kid was only 20 years old! However, as great as it is, it's a bit of a chore to listen to in studio (as are most drum solos, frankly). Of course Carl would build on this later on in live performances, but in any case, this is a good indication of where he was musically at that time. The end section, over a quasi-shuffle beat, introduces the instrument that would become the mainstay of Keith's rig throughout his career, the Moog synthesizer (you thought it started with "Lucky Man," huh?).

Speaking of "Lucky Man," Greg's best-selling single closes out the present album. Lake apparently wrote this when he was 12, and it shows in the fact that the make-up of the tune itself is pretty simplistic (verse, chorus, etc.). The tune is pleasant enough, I suppose (and those vocal harmonies on the chorus are fantastic), but it's so at odds with the rest of the album that I wonder why it was included. Fortunately for us (and for the financial security of the band), the song became a worldwide hit along with Keith's classic Moog solo at the end (which he hated).

If there's one specific criticism I can lay upon ELP's early work, it's that none of it really hung together as an album until, say, Pictures at an Exhibition. In spite (or because) of the variety in the material, there isn't a whole lot of continuity to it. That can be forgiven, though, because the band was still finding its feet in the early stages and that sort of thing is bound to happen. It shouldn't take away tremendously from your enjoyment of the album, anyway. Recommended for your ELP "starter kit." 4 stars out of 5.

Review Nº 15

This is my second review of an Emerson, Lake & Palmer's album. The first was their debut live album 'Welcome Back My Friends To The Show That Never Ends'. I chose review their eponymous debut studio album 'Emerson, Lake & Palmer', released in 1970, as my first studio review of them, because is my favourite studio work from the group.

The three band members came from three very well established bands, before they joined together. All of them were very talented musicians and very experienced too. Greg Lake came from a band that needs no introduction. He came from King Crimson and was one of their founder members. King Crimson are simply and undoubtedly, one of the best and most innovative progressive bands ever. He took part on their two first studio albums, 'In The Court Of The Crimson King' and 'In The Wake Of Poseidon'. Carl Palmer came from Atomic Rooster and he was also one of their founder members. Atomic Rooster is a British heavy progressive band. He has only participated on their debut eponymous studio album 'Atomic Rooster'. Finally, Keith Emerson came from The Nice and he was one of their founder members too. The Nice was a British symphonic progressive band who has combined classical, jazz, blues and rock music. Their music became the seeds of what will be the sound of Emerson, Lake & Palmer. He took part on all their four studio albums 'The Thoughts Of Emerlist Davjack', 'Ars Longa Vita Brevis', 'The Nice' and 'Elegy'.

Curiously, Emerson, Lake & Palmer could have been called HELP or Hendrix, Emerson, Lake & Palmer, if Jimi Hendrix had adhered to the project. It seems that Hendrix was tired of his own band and wanted to try something different and new. So supposedly, he expressed an interest in playing with them. However, because of scheduling conflicts, such idea couldn't be immediately held, and unfortunately, Hendrix died shortly after. However, the history was never confirmed. It even was contradicted by Lake, saying that it was just a rumour created by the press.

The front cover of the album depicts a fluttering white bird with a human ear in the bottom left corner. It was painted by Nic Dartnell and it seems that originally was for the Spirit, an American proto-prog band. It also seems that the figure man on the left of the cover is the Spirit drummer, Ed Cassidy. However, the artist denied, in an interview.

'Emerson, Lake & Palmer' has six tracks. The first track 'Barbarian', despite being attributed to the trio, is a musical arrangement of a Bela Bartok's piano piece, named 'Allegro Barbaro'. Although, the original piece be only for piano, the band rearranged the song for organ, bass and drums. This is a great aggressive track with a hard rock influence. The second track 'Take A Pebble' is a beautiful ballad by Lake, and is the lengthiest track on the album. This is a magnificent song with the powerful vocals of Lake. His singing is simply terrific, with the final line of the verses building on the legacy of King Crimson's 'Epitaph', which sounds even better. The third track 'Knife-Edge' is based on the first movement of Leos Janacek's 'Sinfonietta'. This is another great piece of music with a great showcase by all the three band members, with particular emphasis to the great bass lines. The fourth track 'The Three Fates' is an Emerson's concept piece of music, about the meaning of life, god and evil. The suite is divided into three parts. 'Clotho', an organ solo recorded at the Royal Festival Hall, 'Lachesis', a piano solo and 'Atropos', a piano trio. This is technically an excellent piece of music that showcases the rare musical talents of Emerson. The fifth track 'Tank' contains a Carl Palmer's small and beautiful solo studio drumming. Basically, the piece showcases Palmer's unique drumming style and features one of the few drum solos on a studio album. It also marks the first appearance of the Emerson's famous Moog synthesizer. The sixth track 'Lucky Man' is a ballad written by Lake for acoustic guitar, when he was a schoolboy. However, at the beginning, the song wasn't well received by Emerson and Palmer. It's a song with acoustic guitar, beautiful singing and a great synthesizer solo towards the end. It's, for me, one of the best songs ever written by Lake, and it became as one of the band's most commercial and accessible tracks.

Conclusion: 'Emerson, Lake & Palmer' is an excellent album, very fluent and very beautiful, with moody keyboards, memorable guitar lines, immaculate drumming, and above all, a great vocal work by Lake. It also still features very strong compositions and a magnificent and inspired musicianship. Emerson takes the band's music a little too strongly in his own hands on many occasions on the album. His virtuoso skills have become the defining factor on the band's music. However, fantastic musicians such as Lake and Palmer deserve certainly also a more prominent spot. Sincerely, and in my humble opinion, this album is with 'Brain Salad Surgery' the two best studio works from the group, only supplanted by their triple live album 'Welcome back My Friends To The Show That Never Ends'.

Prog is my Ferrari. Jem Godfrey (Frost*)

This was one of the first prog albums I bought, the first ELP album I ever heard, and the only ELP album I can stand to still listen to, although I'll admit it's years since I'd heard it before today. Generally speaking I think ELP went on to embody most of the worst traits of progressive rock, but that would be later. This is the most restrained ELP would ever sound.

'Take a Pebble' is the highlight for me, and the main theme would not have been out of place on a King Crimson album at this time. Very melodic, and I've never heard anything from Emerson to top the work he does here. Sometimes less is a whole lot more. Nothing else on this album grabs me nearly as much, but it's all listenable. 'The Three Fates' comes the closest to that later pompous ELP sound that I really don't enjoy, but I don't mind it here. I've always felt that this one track in particular was a huge influence on the progressive rock that would come out of Italy in the years following this. I could have done without the drum solo on 'Tank'. I don't mind well-written pop music, but 'Lucky Man' does not fit that bill for me. The moog solo, although probably quite remarkable at the time, in hindsight feels really out of place on what was otherwise a very conventional song.

Emerson Lake & Palmer was formed by a keyboardist Keith Emerson, who departed from The Nice, Greg Lake, a bass player of King Crimson and Carl Palmer, who previously had played with Atomic Rooster and The Crazy World Of Arthur Brown. Needless to say, ELP have become synonymous with the term "prog rock" being one of the best known bands in the genre. What really is a proof of the "chemistry" between the musicians of the supergroup is that they released their debut slightly over half a year after meeting. This was intended as a collaborative recording session work, but ELP couldn't part their ways with just that. So, that's how the band was formed.

Emerson Lake & Palmer have a distinctive style of their own that blends jazz approach to classical music. This is best visible on their variations on themes by Bela Bartok ("Barbarian") or Leos Janacek and J. S. Bach (both on "Knife Edge"). Their music is characterized by unbelievable amounts of vigour, energy as well as musical intelligence. The great late Keith Emerson is the wizard of keyboards and a phenomenal composer. Greg Lake's unmistakable tear-bringing vocals has become one of audience's favorites. In addition, Lake is a proficient bassist capable of moody grooves. Carl Palmer is an excellent drummer with great playing dynamics. Enough said, the musicianship of this debut album is outstanding.

Emerson Lake & Palmer consists of six tracks. The band seems to have organized the time perfectly. This work goes from English renaissance folk ballads like "Lucky Man", through Emerson's triple-movement suite "Three Fates" or jazzy improvisation over classical quotes on "Knife Edge" to almost proto-metal opening on "Barbarian". The variety is great, because it does not show the common inconsistence that many debuts have with too much of a variety. At times, the music loses itself and becomes a bit repetative and sterile, which is a shame.

All in all, this is a classic prog album, so it's obviously a much needed addition to every collection of the genre's fan. This work majestically represents the early years of symphonic rock subgenre as well as progressive rock in general and despite being slightly flawed here and there, it is highly recommended, Many amazing and unforgettable moments! Four stars!

The Carousel Ballroom, a San Francisco-based music venue that mainly held blues performers such as B.B. King and other African American jazz artists in the 1960s, found itself under the control of a musical conglomerate composed of bands like the Grateful Dead, Jefferson Airplane, among others in 1968. These bands intended the venue to be a socio-musical experiment to attract audiences in the San Fran/Haight-Ashbury area. Needless to say, the idea wasn't too successful. Former promoter, Bill Graham, took the reigns in '68, hoping to achieve some success similarly with the hall. However the seating capacity of the hall was lackluster at best, and was not nearly grandiose enough to attract the atrophying community surrounding it. In New York City, Graham owned a similar auditorium by the name of Fillmore East which he had acquired not four months earlier. Deciding to seek a better location, the newly-born Fillmore West was born less than a mile away from the original Carousel Ballroom's location.

Fillmore West would go on to host a variety of performances, such as Californian regulars the Grateful Dead, as well as Santana, Quicksilver Messenger Service, etc. It should be noted that this performance hall came at a very special time, one known to birth many prolific rock bands all across Europe and North America -- the late '60's. Taking place well into what was colloquially referred to as the Psychedelic Era, rock bands of the time were keen on trekking the globe on large extensive tours, where droves of audiences happened to follow them wherever they went. One of the younger of these acts was King Crimson, who, in December of 1969, co-headlined concerts at Fillmore West with London-based jazz rockers The Nice, a band apart of a similar progressive mindset as Crimson. It was there that keyboardist Keith Emerson from The Nice and bassist Greg Lake from King Crimson met and struck up a quick and steadfast friendship. As their series of performances came to a close, Emerson and Lake were already discussing the prospect of forming a new group. The one musician the band the two needed was a drummer, and after a series of unsuccessful tryouts and careful consideration, the band decided on Carl Palmer, known for his work in both The Crazy World of Arthur Brown and Atomic Rooster. The trio was now set in stone, and a debut album was set in motion. Lake, similarly to how he had in King Crimson, acted as producer, began collecting songs performed previously in the band's gigs, and began executing them in the studio format. Thus, in November 1970, the band's self-titled studio work was born.

Emerson Lake & Palmer, and by that I do mean the album, is perhaps the purest form of skill, intelligence, and understanding of zeitgeist the band ever cared to show. With a 6-track runtime (par for the course for any semi- self-conscious progressive rock band in 1970), the album doesn't exude any overbearing smugness that the band would come to be criticized for. From beginning to end the album is very poignant musically, aside from hitting a few snags and some inopportune times. Starting with the crunching proto-metallic surge of 'The Barbarian', a rock arrangement of ethnomusicologist Béla Bartók's 'Allegro barbaro', ELP manages to pack a big punch in a short amount of time. Unlike many latter releases, ELP's debut does not contain huge quasi-orchestral suites, instead opting for simply semi-lengthy tracks. The majority of the tracks tend to be a mix of clear songwriting and extensive jams. This is clear from the second track, the epic 'Take a Pebble'. Also clear is a certain dichotomy that only got more pronounced as the band aged; because the band is comprised of only 3 admittedly skilled musicians, each member makes what is almost a silent effort to outdo each-other in terms of unabashed bravado. This especially rings true for Keith Emerson, who not only has a luxuriously no-holds-barred piano solo what seems like every 3 minutes, but also permeates the rest of the album with a multitude of synthesized soundscapes that, with multiple listens, can get extremely grating. This relationship between the band members also can create unenjoyable pandemonium, which it seems the band is blissfully unaware is in fact unenjoyable, especially on songs like 'The Three Fates' (said pandemonium occurring funnily enough directly after one of Emerson's solos). This is all prone to subjectivity though, as the band still manages to hit some rather great points. The heavy riffs that the band occasionally pumps out like on the aforementioned 'The Barbarian' and 'Knife-Edge' are much in the vein of Greg Lake's parent band Atomic Rooster, and are thus very well received. 'Tank' may pleasure me with a bias -- as a drummer and a certain fan of Greg Lakes work I'm easily enraptured by a drum solo from the man coincided with some bouncy synth. 'Lucky Man' seems to hold a certain amount of bad blood with prog-fans, however I personally found myself rather warm towards the track's cheesy qualities, not to mention I'm a sucker for some good vocal harmonies.

Upon release, this album was hailed as a mighty fine one, and it's not hard to see why. Right out of the gate Emerson, Lake & Palmer is passionate and alight with unbridled genius. ELP now had a tight grasp on the attention of the outside world, and nearly everything was set up in anticipation for the band's next big hit.

Great Debut.

The first album by ELP is one of their strongest, although both Trilogy and Brain Salad Surgery are better. But after those two, their first remains one of their most solid. Beginning with the great "The Barbarian", the album set the tone for not only the 70s (it came out near the beginning of the decade) but also virtuoso progressive rock with Emerson's quirky Romanesque organ. The second track "Take a Pebble" is the best track on the album, a nuanced and lovely Greg Lake song that would become a live highlight. Emerson's piano work is wonderful here. "Knife-Edge" mixes Emerson's organ skills with Lake's edgy singing. The suite "The Three Fates" is not quite as successful, extending Emerson's peculiar compositional style over three movements named after each of fate in the classic story. "Tank" is similar to this, highlighting Palmer's drumming, while the closer, "Lucky Man" became a very well-known radio hit, despite not sounding much like the rest of the album. The formula set here would have worked well on subsequent albums, but alas ELP was to experiment, which is good but can lead to mistakes, which ELP would seem to be prone to at times through their career. I actually give this album 7.9 out of 10 on my 10-point scale, which is at the bottom of the range for 4 PA stars. It just creeps in.

After an onslaught of Dream Theater reviews that honestly left me burnt out on everything to do with the band for the time being, I decided to just stop with them for the time being and move onto a band that I have extremely mixed opinions on, Emerson, Lake and Palmer. Overall, I find the band to have a very particular sound to them unlike much other prog at the time, with much more on the nose classical influence to the point of reimagining various classical pieces, an extreme focus on keyboards and drums, and an all around more energetic, chaotic, jam focused sound to them. Out of all the classic prog bands, this is easily one of the most pompous and excessive of them all, only issue being that it only works some of the time, an issue present through every one of their albums. Their debut is definitely their most restrained work by an extremely wide margin, but even here, there is still a lot of time dedicated to simply showing off the incredible talent of the band members, rather than on making enjoyable music. Both Keith Emerson and Carl Palmer are extremely skilled at their respective instruments, and Greg Lake is one of my favourite vocalists, but the music itself is quite a mixed bag, with a lot of it sounding like more work could have been done in order to polish things significantly.

Despite the band largely providing its riffs and melody through the keyboards, The Barbarian kicks off the album with a sludgy guitar tone, before increasing in speed, starting off slowly before the beat evolves into a gallop. I love the way everything cuts out in order for the frenetic drumming and tense piano playing to come in, providing the mental image of being chased, at least to me. I love the intensity of this song, and it's without a doubt one of my favourite songs on the album, and is at the very least, what I'd consider to be the most perfect. Take A Pebble is a very different affair however, starting off very strongly, highly reminiscient of the earlier King Crimson ballads such as the first couple of minutes of Moonchild, with similarly amazing vocals and an overall powerful beauty to it. The issue here is that a lot of the middle instrumental section feels very unecessary, being quite dull with what I consider to be fairly unappealing country - blues section that feels as if it comes out of nowhere and lasts far too long. In a way, I guess I can compare it to Moonchild, both starting out excellently before devolving into pure boredom, with any magic the song contained being drained away. Knife Edge proves to fare far better, being a pleasant, bluesy song with much more restraint placed upon it, with nothing getting too out of hand, and some really great concepts explored, especially the baroque section, which is simply to die for. The song feels a bit stilted in placed, but is definitely enjoyable.

The Three Fates feels like the polar opposite of Knife Edge, with it sounding like the band just decided to abandon all restraint and see how much punishment their instruments could take before they broke. What is created from this is a wonderfully chaotic instrumental that switches between mildly dull to downright awesome, the latter being much more prominent in the third movement of the song, and at the very least, it's simply more proof that Keith Emerson is incredible on his respecitve instruments (if it was somehow not already extremely obvious from everything else here), but once again, the song could have used a bit of trimming. Tank is definitely an interesting song, having some of the greatest instrumental interplay that the band has ever composed in my opinion, with an amazing driving energy behind it. The issue here is that once again, the excessive, pompous side of the band ends up getting the better of it in the form of a 2 minute drum solo which becomes almost painfully dull by the end. I honestly want a version of this song with a shortened version of the drum solo, as this would otherwise be one of my absolute favourite songs by the band if not for how much the energy is ruined. Lucky Man is definitely a beautiful track and one that I can quite easily see how it became the most popular, well known song by the band, as it's peacful, melodic, and absolutely beautiful. There is nowhere near the same amount of chaos and intensity as previous songs, but does close off in a way that sums up the whole album very well, with a poorly conceived moog solo that disrupts the beauty, although the song is still incredible despite this.

Overall, while 5 of the 6 songs on this album are good overall (Take A Pebble, not so much), almost all of them are flawed in the same general way, with the exception of The Barbarian. Each of them could have used further editing and polishing to make for some really great listening, as the songs all have incredible potential in one way or another. As it stands though, while I do really enjoy listening to this album, I often end up becoming mildly irritated at the many flaws it has, which is definitely enough for me to knock this down to 3 stars. I'd highly recommend this album to those who enjoy heavily classical influenced music and also can get behind a lot of excess. This is definitely their most restrained album of their peak material, which is honestly a good thing in certain respects when looking at some of their later efforts where they allowed their pretentiousness to go unchecked.

Best songs: The Barbarian, Knife Edge, Lucky Man

Weakest songs: Take A Pebble

Verdict: Highly technical, complex muwsic that has a habit of becoming too overtly complex for its own good. Songs can both have moments of genius, and moments of ill conceived noodling, but for the most part, it's an entertaining album overall, albeit very flawed in certain respects.

After finishing the Nice experience, Keith Emerson joins the great drummer Carl Palmer, the excellent singer and bassist Greg Lake, and founds Emerson, Lake & Palmer, a group that since the name highlights the three singularities of the artists who are part of it, and who there will be some three soloists playing together. Their first Lp, definitely one of the most important in the history of symphonic progressive rock, is qualitatively controversial, let's see why.

1) "The Barbarian". First instrumental song inspired by Bartok's Allegro Barbaric, it starts as a heavy metal piece, then Emerson gives vent to his virtuosity, and Palmer tends to overdoing, then comes a piece played by the piano more adhering to Bartok's original, then the heavy metal sound returns for the ending, that is too pompous. Beautiful reimagining, never monotonous, just a little repetitive and bombastic in some passages. Rating 7.5/8.

2) "Take A Pebble". Acoustic ballad written by Lake, with country inflections, where Lake sings up to 2'30''; then comes a long instrumental piece of very nice pastoral atmosphere, dictated by Lake's guitar; then at about 6'30' is Emerson's piano to lead, joined by Palmer's drums towards 8'30'. At that point the song becomes prolish and jazzy. Lake's voice returns at 11'20'' and restores balance. It's the best piece on the album, the one and only masterpiece. Rating 8.5.

3) "Knife-Edge". Hard-rock song, with a good aggressive beginning, quotes Janacek with the organ in the instrumental part. Repetetive in the ending. Good but not excellent. Rating 7+.

End of Side A.

Side B begins with a mini-suite in three movements: "The Three Fates", written by Emerson. A solemn beginning with the organ, then the piano arrives and the song improves; finally Palmer arrives, the song becomes jazzy and pedantic, too percussive and obsessively repetitive. It's a piece with some good ideas, especially in the middle, but overall it is not quite successful, the listening isn't very pleasent. Rating 6.5.

"Tank" is another instrumental track led by Emerson and Palmer, more unpredictable than the previous one but also more spoiled by the style exercises played by Palmer and Emerson: decidedly the weakest piece (euphemism) of the album, which with the last two tracks has dropped dramatically in quality after the promising start (the first two songs). Ratin 5+.

With "Lucky Man" fortunately Lake brings the music back to more relaxed atmospheres. Simple and linear piece, less beautiful than the second, progressive only in the arrangement. Emerson buns in the ending. Rating 7+.

Qualitatively, this Lp is a long way from the masterpiece: this album can keep up with the best of 1970 only for the first two pieces, then otherwise it's mediocre. Rating 7+ (average 7,08); Three poor stars. If there weren't the first two pieces, it would take two stars.

A classical keyboardist, a folk-rock vocalist, and a jazz fusion drummer walk into a bar... Whether or not you fancy this to be a setup for a joke or an interesting premise for a musical project says a lot about your taste in music and whether Emerson, Lake, and Palmer's eponymous debut record has anything to offer you.

In 2020, fusion projects of this sort are a dime a dozen. But in 1970, there was genuine novelty in the makeup of this super group. With their debut record, ELP successfully captures their varied influences, abilities, and all- around eclecticism. Most importantly, the record demonstrated that such a musical endeavor could eschew gimmicks and make interesting music.

The album's flaw is that it still manages to feel like a proof-of-concept demo or EP rather than a cohesive record. Each band member is given "their moment" to shine but their powers are not quite threaded together. This is most strongly felt in the final three tracks of the record, "Lucky Man" especially. Sure, the vocal harmonies in the chorus of that song are goosebump inducing, but sorrowfully out of place on the record.

I will never understand how this absolute masterpiece and cornerstone of prog rock is far below top 50 here on PA (at the time of writing it is located on possition 83!), while I consider it one of the ultimate prog records of all time by some of the founding fathers and masters of the genre. Absolute must. Emerson's work here immediately places him on top of my prog keyboard wizards list. His piano/organ/synth play is extremely skillful, imaginative, sometimes touchingly beautiful, sometimes solemn and grandiose and yet pasionate and furious where it needs to be. Lake's voice sounds as beautiful as ever, his bass punches and guitar ornaments add to the richness of the soundpalette and provide very tasteful details. Compositions are very strong. Some are tight and smart rocking punches ("Barbarian") some are minisuites containing several parts ("Take a pebble", "Three fates"). There is no weak point here. Thankfuly there are no dubiously funny and forced honky-tonk songs on this album yet. So the overall sound is very cohesive and Emerson-dominated. Only the last song - the famous ballad "Lucky man" brings a bit different mood to reduce the intensity of previous tracks. It's often overlooked how smart the drumming is in this one. May it serve as a friendly reminder of the quality of Palmer's craft

One of the most defining exponents of progressive rock was Emerson, Lake & Palmer, a British supergroup from the 1970s known for its elaborate stage antics and its distinctive sound. In combining melodies and structures from classical music with rock & roll energy and instrumentation, they successfully brought together the European and North-American traditions of Western music and created a completely unique kind of music.

Keith Emerson, the band's driving force who was nicknamed the Hendrix of the Hammond organ, originally rose to fame as keyboard player of The Nice, which can be seen as a "proto-ELP" of sorts. It was an innovative rock band characterized by the prevalence of Emerson's keyboards and his bizarre antics on stage. Live performances of The Nice contained lengthy, virtuosic organ solos in which Emerson would stab knives into his instrument to hold down notes, or jump over his organ to play Bach's Toccata & Fugue in D Minor? while standing behind his instrument.

While The Nice's sound already contained a prototype of the rock/jazz/classical fusion that would become ELP's trademark, Emerson envisioned a far more ambitious project and left the band in 1970 before forming a new group with singer/guitarist Greg Lake and drummer Carl Palmer. Greg Lake had been an unknown until he provided lead vocals and bass guitar for King Crimson's widely acclaimed 1969 debut album In The Court Of The Crimson King. His unique voice contributed to the celestial atmosphere of that album and would become a staple in ELP's sound. Carl Palmer on the other hand had previously made a name for himself as drummer in Arthur Brown's band, and later in the hard rock band Atomic Rooster. Aside from his skills at beating the hell out of his drum kit, he would also become known for his extensive arsenal of additional percussion, including a set of timpanis, tubular bells, two giant gongs and a bell that he could play with his mouth. The trio quickly acquired a record contract and kick-started their career by firing three cannons on stage at the Isle Of Wight Festival in August, 1970. Two months later, they released their first, eponymous, album, with which they wanted to smack their audience in the face and show them all that they were capable of at once. The album starts off right away with an example of the kind of rock/classical fusion the band would become known for: "The Barbarian". It's a cover of Béla Bartók's "Allegro Barbaro" which is a piano solo piece, but you know you're in for something of an entirely different nature when you first hear the ominous fuzzy bass notes that open the album. Bartók's original piece has been transformed into a roaring apocalyptic tune, dominated by Emerson's furious organ barrage that more than compensates for the absence of guitars, before giving way to the relatively quiet piano-driven midsection, which follows the original more closely. But the tension keeps building up until the introduction is reprised again, and afterwards the song ends with a "call-and-answer" duel between the screaming organ and Palmer's impeccable drum blasts.

Too rough for you? Don't worry, cause the boys try to create a number of different moods on this album, and the next song couldn't be more different from its predecessor. "Take A Pebble" starts off as a beautiful piano ballad on which Greg Lake gets to shine with his heavenly vocals. However, the song is extended to no less than twelve minutes with some acoustic guitar plucking by Lake and a prolonged piano improvisation from Emerson. This might be one of the best showcases of Emerson's amazing keyboard talent: for several minutes, he plays the same eight-note ostinato with his left hand while playing masterful licks with his right hand, seamlessly varying between classically influenced chops and typically jazzy note sequences.

"Knife-Edge" is much more straight-forward, as it actually has a verse-chorus-verse-chorus-bridge-chorus structure (more or less). The instrumentation is also much closer to conventional rock music, despite the fact that Emerson's organ is once again the dominant instrument. The main melody is borrowed from Janáček's Sinfonietta, but it's presented in such a way that it becomes its own thing entirely. It rocks!

Now, while the first three tracks perfectly capture the trio's strength as a group, the next three tracks are rather meant to display the individual talents of each musician. If you're an Emerson fan, you're in luck because he's the only band member who's present on the first two parts of "The Three Fates". This starts off as a purely classical composition, beginning with an introduction on organ before moving to another beautiful piano passage, less ethereal than the one on "Take A Pebble", but more complex and engaging. While the piece shows influence from composers such as Chopin and Ravel, Emerson refrains from directly quoting other compositions, plus he again incorporates chromatic jazz scales to avoid it sounding too derivative. Then, in the final part, Lake and Palmer finally join in to bring the piece to a chaotic ending.

"Tank" puts Palmer in the spotlight, but it's sadly not as interesting as what came before. The focus of the song is his drum solo, which he uses in part to show off his aforementioned percussion set, but for the most part it's just an erratic collection of kicks and snares without much rhyme or reason. The song was mainly meant for live performances where the effect could indeed be impressive, and its inclusion on this album would be rather pointless if it weren't for the catchy, jazzy clavinet and synth solos that bookend it and turn it into a memorable composition in its own right.

Finally, "Lucky Man" is an acoustic folksy song written by Lake when he was twelve years old. It's probably the most normal song on the album. Emerson doesn't show up at all until the last minute when he throws in a solo with the undiluted square wave oscillator of his newly acquired Moog Synthesizer. It doesn't fit with the rest of the song at all but it gives a pretty hilarious effect. "Lucky Man" was the band's first single and its most well-known song to this day, which is unfortunate because it does not represent the band's style very well. I even happened to hear it on the radio the day after Keith Emerson's death in 2016, and the station was nice enough to cut out the synth solo in its entirety, thus completely removing his contribution to the song. Maybe it was meant to be symbolic?...

In all, the album as a whole feels a little unfocused, but the individual songs are just so strong. All of these weird rhythms and song structures will probably take some time to get used to, and I realize that many may shake their head at the prospect of listening to a twelve-minute song (look out, by the way: "Take A Pebble" is far from the longest track ELP ever recorded?), but if you allow it to sink in you can't help but be enthralled by it in the end. At the very least you have to acknowledge the talent and the ambition of the musicians and songwriters at work.

'Emerson, Lake & Palmer' was certainly the start of something beautiful. The newly-formed prog supergroup, combining the forces of Greg Lake from King Crimson, Keith Emerson from The Nice and Carl Palmer from Atomic Rooster, was set to champion the up-and-coming genre with their adventurous sounds and the classical crossover direction that was strongly influenced by their keyboard maestro. This first album by the trio was released in November of 1970 on the Island label, and was produced by their own Greg Lake.

At this point, this is a seriously important album both for the band, and for the whole movement, massively influential and groundbreaking, the insane playing of Keith Emerson was what truly sets ELP apart from many of their peers. Writing rock arrangements for classical pieces, amongst some hard rock-influenced numbers, and occasional acoustic moments, the band already displayed an original and recognizable sound with their very first release.

Some absolutely fantastic compositions on this self-titled debut, amongst them we have to mention the opening track 'The Barbarian', based on Bela Bartok's 'Allegro barbaro' - a beautiful and energetic rendition by the band, with everyone playing masterfully, the haunting 'Knife-Edge', that is the band's first tread on some hard rock ground, with the prevailing manic Hammond organ, and the enormous and menacing instrumental 'The Three Fates' - this is absolutely Emerson going crazy and displaying his full potential on the keys. 'Take a Pebble' is another very good composition, maybe a bit aloof in the middle section, eventually slightly prolonged, but nonetheless memorable and touching. 'Lucky Man' has to be one of the all-time most recognizable songs of ELP, a highlight of Greg Lake's charming writing. 'Tank', however, has some pretty ridiculous sounds that have hardly aged well; it must be noted though, that it is a mood that is often copied by other bands, some in the 80s and some 21st century collectives.

All in all, this record is extremely influential, very menacing, and pretty impressive. It is hardly, however, a perfect album. It has its wacky moments, which you sometimes get with prog rock, but it also has some of the most excellent material that this musical genre has ever offered. The artwork is iconic, the band are playing their hearts out, and all this contributes to making Emerson, Lake & Palmer's self-titled debut a must-listen!

Not much can be said about this album that hasn't already on the site. One of the really strong debut albums in prog, especially for earlier-era prog. Some of it I could do without- the lengthy "Three Fates", along with overplayed "Lucky Man". The latter of which really just doesn't fit on this record. Seems like a single tacked on for sales reasons. "The Three Fates" doesn't do much for me, primarily because I"m not a big fan of extended key pieces, but to top it off it is incredibly harsh and shrill sounding, and forces me to turn down the volume on every listen. With the weak spots out of the way, there is a lot of good and great material to speak on. The record gets off to an ambitious start with "the Barbarian" an absolutely colossal sounding track. To me this sounds like some "proto-doom metal" and it really kicks ass to start an album. "Take a Pebble" brings the intensity down a notch, but doesn't sacrifice quality. This track adds a lot of texture and sets a ton for what turns out to be quite an eclectic album. "Knife-Edge" is another heavier, doomy track that closes out the perfect First Side of the record. This song features some of my favorite vocal work from Lake. I've always loved his basic and subtle rhyming, it just fits the song. Side 2 features "Tank", another intense song showcasing the skills of Carl Palmer, one of my favorite prog drummers. There are some really adventurous moments on this song and it all sounds great on the early Cotillion pressings. Anyways, yup, a really great start for the ELP guys back in 1970/71, but in only a number of months, they would outdo their debut effort.

Rating: 8.5/10

Review #105

To talk about EMERSON, LAKE & PALMER is to talk about one of the most important and transcendental groups in Rock history. This supergroup got a very loyal cult of followers from around the world, their first albums were part of the most solid foundations on which Progressive Rock was built. They were only three guys playing the most aggressive buy yet sophisticated experimental rock pieces and becoming an undeniable legend of music.

Their first album was called simply "Emerson, Lake & Palmer", which included six songs through which the homonymous band showed what it had to offer. They made a tremendous performance at the festival of the Isle of Wight in 1970, legend has that they were talking to Jimi HENDRIX to consolidate an even more fantastic supergroup that would be called HELP, but since HENDRIX died on September 18, 1970, this project never reached to see the light. It is well known where these three musicians came out from but I'll mention just as a reference: Keith EMERSON (keyboards) came from THE NICE, Greg LAKE (bass, vocals, and acoustic guitar) came from KING CRIMSON and Carl PALMER (drums) came from ATOMIC ROOSTER.

The opening track of the album is an instrumental aggressive piece called "The barbarian", in here we can start to understand what the sound of EMERSON, LAKE & PALMER was like: the absence of guitar doesn't affect the rawness of the song; the organ and bass lead the piece while the powerful drums of PALMER give the extra punch the song needs, as an opening track is explosive and catchy, I feel almost obligated to listen to the entire album knowing they did such a great introduction.

As a second song, we have "Take a Pebble", my personal favorite track in the album and also the longest composition contains; here we recognize the voice of Greg LAKE from his recordings with KING CRIMSON and actually, this song has some moments that made it sound like a part of "In the court of the Crimson King" but, Keith EMERSON gave it a very unique touch notoriously different from what Ian MCDONALD used to play. Also, the middle section contains a very beautiful soft acoustic guitar line that teaches us the habilities of Greg LAKE in this instrument, since he didn't have a lot of opportunities to play it in KING CRIMSON.

"Knife-edge" is a very intense rock song that has become one of the most famous pieces of EMERSON, LAKE & PALMER; an old-time favorite in their live performances with a very unique and powerful organ riff (I don't know if it is correct to call it a riff since it was not played with a guitar) that collides with the precise drums.

"The three fates" is an amazing piano and organ performance composed by Keith EMERSON and divided into three sub-tracks: "Clotho (Royal Festival Hall Organ)", "Lachesis (Piano solo)" and "Atropos (Piano Trio)" in which we can appreciate the amazing talent Keith EMERSON had on his instrument, changing from an almost classical piece to a very complex and aggressive Experimental Rock song reaching the end.

"Tank" is another instrumental song in which now we can hear a very nice drum solo by Carl PALMER, drum solos were very common in those days: almost all the rock bands of the era had at least one song that includes a drum solo (LED ZEPPELIN's "Moby Dick", BLACK SABBATH's "Rat salad" and IRON BUTTERFLY's "In-a-gadda-da-vida" are my favorites), the song ends with a very concise organ line accompanied by a strong bass figure.

"Lucky man" is absolutely beautiful, it's a rock ballad led by the acoustic guitar of LAKE but with the presence of EMERSON's organ and PALMER's drums that give the song a very unique relaxing Hard Rock atmosphere. This song is maybe the most famous that came from this record.

Absolutely essential, the debut of one of the most important bands in Progressive Rock was a great example of how good an album could get with few musicians and not a lot of unorthodox instruments as long as the quality of the compositions and the talent of the musicians is as high as these.

SONG RATING: The barbarian, 5 Take a Pebble, 5 Knife-edge, 5 The three fates, 5 Tank, 4 Lucky man, 5

AVERAGE: 4.83

PERCENTAGE: 96.67

ALBUM RATING: 5 stars

I ranked this album #38 on my TOP 100 favorite Progressive Rock albums of all time.

ELP's debut is an excellent album but in recent years I have developed mixed feelings about it. The opening track 'The Barbarian" is a great opener and a good indicator of where they were heading. It is largely an original composition with the first and third section comprising a great fuzz base intro and dramatic Hammond organ melody and sandwiched between on piano is a re-working of Bartok's famous "Allegro Barbaro". It might be sacrilegious to say this, but I actually enjoy ELP's strident version more than the slightly pensive tone of the original. A great driving Prog Rocker. My problem with the album starts with the next track "Take a Pebble". The main song section is absolutely gorgeous and right away Keith Emerson's decision to find a "proper" singer in Greg Lake absolutely pays off with the singer's superb tenor. The piano section which follows is also quite beautiful but the whole song drifts off into a fairly pedestrian pseudo Bluegrass acoustic guitar improvisation followed by yet another piano solo before finally the song section reprises. For me, however much I admire the instrumental prowess on display here, the song would have been so more effective as a simple four minute plus ballad even incorporating a piano interval but at twelve and a half minutes, it is just so bloated. The first side's closing track "Knife's Edge" incorporates the beginning of Janacek's "Sinfonietta' and compresses it into a five minutes Prog Rocker with vocals instead of the trumpets. It is quite a clever exercise but I always find the song a little dare I say cheesy in its execution. The opening track on side two, "The Three Fates" is clearly Keith's baby. It is strongly reminiscent of the sort of experimental music he was exploring with his previous band The Nice. He combines Church organ, Hammond Organ and of course his beloved piano into a Classical/Rock hybrid which unfortunately comes across as a bit of a meandering mess. The second track "Tank" is more focused with its strident melody similar to what the band would produce with Tarkus and incorporates a fairly sophisticated drum solo. It is a pretty decent track but I always felt it was a bit underdeveloped especially the closing couple of minutes which is dominated by Emerson's rather atonal moog solo. Greg Lake's beautiful "Lucky Man" closes the album and is probably the best known song on it. Unlike the somewhat sprawling "Take A Pebble" this track is very concise and boasts another early example of the moog synthesiser at the end which seems to be at odds with the song's bucolic tone but somehow I cannot imagine the song without it. Overall I would say that while this album is fairly assured, better was to come especially with the very next album-Tarkus. A great way to start.

4 stars

ELP's debut album is one of the most influential in prog history. In contrast to Crimson's "In the Court of the Crimson King," it features some of the greatest sheer instrumentalism and tenacity of all time. With all three members, Keith Emerson (Keys), Greg Lake (Guitar, Bass, Vocals), and Carl Palmer (Drums) coming from classic prog bands themselves, they formed the first true prog supergroup.

"The Barbarian" starts the album with the very Emersonian organ and distorted guitars from Lake paired with constant drum rolls and fills from Palmer. About halfway through the song, Keith goes into an extended piano section that goes back into the main riff to end the song in a dramatic fashion. "Take a Pebble" is the first song on the album to reveal Greg Lake's beautiful voice and also the longest, clocking in at over 12:00 minutes. The song comes into a few jazzy swing sections with intricate brushes on the drums from Palmer and enters into a very long acoustic section. The song is not bad, but feels a little too long and gets repetitive.

"Knife-Edge" is one of my favorite songs on the album if not my favorite. Greg Lakes' bass work coupled with the doom metal vocals creates a unique atmosphere that seamlessly shifts from dark sections to upbeat organ licks from Emerson. Although not the longest song on the album, "The Three Fates" is the true epic of the album. With 3 movements, (Clotho, Lachesis, and Atropos) based on the ancient Greek myth of the three fates, the song spans countless sections in only 7 minutes which is quite short for prog. It begins with one of the most iconic organ openings in prog and includes some of the best piano work in the entire genre. As much as I would have loved to see the other bandmates featured more in the song the last 2 minutes make up for it with Palmer and Lake joining Emerson in on the action. Wonderful track and another highlight on the album.

"Tank" is a very interesting song with Emerson on Clavichord and Moog. It includes a 4-minute drum solo from Palmer. As much as I love the instrumentalism on the album this has to be my least favorite song on the album because it feels never ending and structureless. The closer "Lucky Man" is an acoustic guitar ballad from Lake, very different from the rest of the album. It was also one of the band's biggest hits. I love this song despite it not featuring Emerson as much, and it has a very nice guitar solo from Lake as well.

This album is so amazing, and I feel like it could have easily been 5 stars if the band had featured Lake more and cut down some of the instrumental sections. Emerson proves his sheer versatility on this album and would only improve it on their sophomore album. An absolute landmark of prog, recommended for everyone.

Taking modern classical music as their main source of inspiration and adding elements and nuances of their own, Emerson, Lake & Palmer debut with a solid album, with the trio's surnames as title, backed by their previous successful experiences (Greg Lake's participation as singer and bassist in the fundamental "In the Court of the Crimson King" by King Crimson in 1969 is very notorious).

Virtuosos almost on the verge of a nervous breakdown, it is, however, the brilliant multi-keyboardist Keith Emerson the main protagonist of most of the pieces, both in the adaptations of classical music (the instrumental and over- saturated "The Barbarian" and the demanding "Knife-Edge"), as well as in those of their own label (the extensive and restful "Take a Pebble", surely on the podium of the best of the album), or the also instrumental and jazzy "The Three Fates" and "Tank", in both cases with the impeccable percussion of the remarkable Carl Palmer.

The mole of the album was exposed when Lake, with his grave and serene tone of voice, describes an unfortunate story in the imperishable and beautiful ballad "Lucky Man". Created by the singer and bassist in his early teens and included at the last minute on the album, it unexpectedly became for EL&P one of their most representative songs, and the moog at the end of the song, an Emerson improvisation that remained as is after only one take, in one of the most celebrated passages of their discography.

Emerson, Lake &Palmer developed their own particular style until becoming one of the great icons of the genre without any transitional albums, placing themselves at the top of the progressive Olympus with their 1970 album of the same name, something that they would confirm with their later works.

Excellent

4/4.5 stars