![]() 3.73 | 87 ratings | 43% 5 stars
Excellent addition to any |
Studio Album, released in 2001 Songs / Tracks Listing 1. If I Were The Wind (and You Were The Rain) (9:23) Search PENDRAGON Not Of This World lyrics Music tabs (tablatures)Search PENDRAGON Not Of This World tabs Line-up / Musicians- Nick Barrett / guitars, vocals Total Time: 76:18 Thanks to ProgLucky for the additionand to vas-tomsk for the last updates Edit this entry |
| How to submit new MP3s
![]() | Not of This World Import, Limited Edition Inside Out (Audio CD 2004) | $18.05 $20.95 (used) |
| Not of This World (Audio CD 2004) | $52.49 |
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(43%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(22%)
Good, but non-essential (23%)
Collectors/fans only (8%)
Poor. Only for completionists (3%)
I would probably give this two-and-a-half stars, but we can't do that here. There are some good ideas here, some of which are executed well. However, the album suffers from two fatal flaws. First, as with so many European prog bands I'm listening to now (and reviewing), Pendragon lacks a good vocalist. (That said, none of their lyrics are particularly creative, so it might not matter.) Second, as another reviewer notes, much of the album sounds the same; there is too little "difference" between songs. True, there are two "themes" (lyrical and musical) that "show up" at various times. But this is not what I'm referring to. Rather, when you get to the end of the album, you truly cannot remember which song was which. Still, as noted, there are enough good ideas here - and enough good musicianship - to warrant a listen. Whether you add it to your permanent collection will depend upon how much you enjoy this type of thing. / As an side, the band description notes influences as Pink Floyd, Camel, IQ, Arena. Yes, there's a bit of Floyd, especially in the guitar work. However, I've got two comments here. First, on this album, the band "refers" to the main theme of "Heart of Lothian" (from Marillion's "Misplaced Childhood") - almost note for note - not just once, but twice. Second, I hear more Genesis influence here than anything else. In fact, just for fun, listen to this album and try to count the number of times that it "refers" (musically) to Wind & Wuthering and, even moreso, And Then There Were Three. A point for each one you catch. 10 points wins a trip to Willow Farm.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to maani
(BETA) | Report this review (#5829) | Review Permalink
Posted Monday, March 01, 2004
Not counting a numerous of live albums, compilations and best of albums, this is the first sign of life from PENDRAGON in five years. The last time was 1996 and "The Masquerade Overture" (April 1996) and "As Good As Gold" (mini album CD, October 1996). It has definitely been worth the wait. PENDRAGON is better than ever musically, especially the keyboard wizard Clive Nolan. He has a very tasteful approach: He can be both bombastic in his playing, but also quiet and mellow when it is required. They still have their unmistakable warm melodic neo-progressive sound and Nick Barrett's
compositions and lyrics are as good as always. Nick's lyrics often seem to be very emotional and personal, especially on this new album. It nice to see that the album contains only five, very long tracks. I have always loved long songs as long as it doesn't affect the overall quality of the composition. If I should raise any complaints it would be that PENDRAGON seldom surprise their audience. But on the other hand this is also their strength. Their fans always know what they'll get, and this album fulfils every fans wish, although it doesn't match "The Masquerade Overture", their finest release to date. The highlights on this album are "Not Of This World" and "A Man Of
Nomadic Traits". Two songs that have everything you could with for. As bonus tracks there are two acoustic versions of "The King Of The Castle" and "Paintbox". Both of them can also be found on the Polish compilation "The History: 1984-2000" released on Metal Mind Records last year. The inclusion here makes it less necessary to buy that compilation if you already have all the other albums. Simon Williams's cover artwork is magnificent with lots of details and the 16-page CD-booklet contains all the lyrics, paintings and photos. I should also mention the amazing production and mixing by Karl Groom (with assistant from PENDRAGON).
PENDRAGON is one of the better neo-progressive bands today and this album will probably be in the top rankings when it's time to vote for this years best releases.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Greger
(BETA) | Report this review (#5816) | Review Permalink
Posted Tuesday, March 02, 2004
Sorry for the low rate, but I'm obliged to point out the lack of originality regarding this strange band, which started his career in a remarkable way and then. They began also to "duplicate" their derivative style according to an infinite loop. At the time of the issue of "The Masquerade Overture" such derivative style was well hidden and filtered through their important experience all over the world (in the last twenty years at least). Thanks to their maturity... but nowadays this repetitive formula has become tired!! Make your own choice!!
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to lor68
(BETA) | Report this review (#5826) | Review Permalink
Posted Saturday, April 03, 2004
Pendragon, along with IQ and Marillion, are yet another English neo-progressive act that owe a large debt of inspiration to Genesis (and, to a lesser degree, Pink Floyd). Unlike the very good discs which I have reviewed by those bands, however, Pendragon's NOT OF THIS WORLD doesn't consistently captivate me to any prolonged extent. In struggling to assign a numerical rating to this album, I have vacillated from a low of two stars, to a high of four, and thus "strike a balance" with a mark of three stars.As the rating implies, this is a "good" CD. It is neither bad, nor great, but nonetheless warrants repeated listening. I find much of merit here: unlike some earlier reviewers, I have no problem with singer/guitarist Nick Barrett's vocals, and I think that he is a fine guitarist whose playing often favourably evokes that of Steve Hackett. Clive Nolan does an accomplished job on the keyboards, and the remainder of the group nicely fill out the overall "neo-prog" sound.
While the musicianship may be of a reliably high quality, the songwriting is rather uneven in comparison. NOT OF THIS WORLD is a concept piece, with each track flowing into the one that follows. The lyrical subject of the album is a lofty one: that of the nature of mortality, the quest for worldly enlightenment, and the hope for a higher order of existence after death. In general, the thoughtful lyrics do justice to the ambitious theme, and are delivered with passion and sensitivity, but the music is at times less than gripping, overtly bombastic, and upon occasion seems to ramble and re-hash itself. The album proper (not counting the two "bonus" songs, which are pleasant, acoustic re-workings of previous releases), at over seventy-seven minutes, would have carried more impact and immediacy if it had been condensed from its near double-album status to a shorter, more direct and focused version. Tracks such as the overblown "The Lost Children" and "And Finally" seem to be overlong merely in an attempt to be "progressive" -- almost as if the band had reasoned: "Hey, we're a serious progressive band, and serious progressive bands write long songs." Trim off the "fat" next time, Pendragon, and just give us the meat!
The "meat" here, is represented by strong efforts such as the impassioned "If I Were the Wind," the catchy "All Over Now," the title track (with a soaring instrumental opening section that is quite reminiscent of classic Genesis) and -- my favourite -- "A Man of Nomadic Traits," which is a very worthy piece of multi-textured progressive rock.
In conclusion, NOT OF THIS WORLD is a good, but somewhat overlong and uneven album -- a fine choice to practice your "track programming" skills on. It should not disappoint the band's long-term followers, and offers many passages and "vistas" of power, intelligence and beauty to those who are patient enough to accompany the band on their roundabout musical journey.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Peter
(BETA) | Report this review (#5830) | Review Permalink
Posted Monday, April 19, 2004
I said, in my review for The Masquerade Overture, it would be hard to better that one. Well, in my opinion, they just about have! Some reviewers have knocked this, saying it is directionless and a re-hash of old things. Well, I beg to disagree! It is very clever, the way it is done. Yes, it is a concept album, and that is why the songs sound 'the same' in certain areas. They are supposed to! It is a very long album, but I enjoyed every minute of it! The opener, 'If I Were The Wind' is excellent, with an absolutely brilliant guitar intro, followed by the majestic entry of a Genesis-like rhythm section. The keyboards are likewise superb here. This song is only in one part, but it does appear to split into two, the second half much quieter and keyboard dominated. Then comes 'The Dance Of The Seven Veils' which is in two parts, 'Faithless', and 'All Over Now'. Both parts are excellent and balance each other nicely. More Floydian influences here, with the girly backing vocals carrying on where they left off on 'Masquerade'. Then comes maybe the best piece, the three part 'Not Of This World' The first part opens with tremendous soaring guitar work, reminiscent of Genesis, only more powerful. Excellent driving bass and drums on this. The second part, 'Give It To Me', is short and amusing, before the third part dreamily appears, 'Green Eyed Angel' with its infectious, melodic chorus. This track takes your breath away. Then follows 'Man Of Nomadic Traits', which is officially in one part, yet seems again to split into two - a catchy verse and chorus, which is followed by a blistering guitar solo, which seems to conjure rides on magic carpets for me! Then comes the chorus again, slowing down before leading into the final track, 'World's End.' This is in two parts. The first, 'The Lost Children', starts off with a reprise of the opening track's guitar intro - excellent! Quiet and melodic, it is thoughtful and ethereal, before it picks up near the end and becomes a little raunchier. The second part, 'And Finally...', brings the other parts together, and adds some nice guitar work, before fading out. The whole album, for me, brings to mind a desert landscape, as it is intended to. This is a must, one of the best prog albums of all time. The two bonus tracks, Acoustic versions of 'Paintbox' and 'King Of The Castle' are very lovely and end the album nicely. Incidentally, I didn't comment on the bonus disc with 'Masquerade'. This has edits of 'As Good As Gold', and 'Masters Of Illusion'. Both similar, but shorter to the album versions. The 3rd track, 'Schizo', is a classic Pink Floyd track! Well, I can imagine them playing it anyway! Very nice too. The last track, 'The King Of The Castle' (The Shadow part 2), is haunting, and brings to mind immediately 'Entangled' from 'A Trick Of The Tail' by Genesis. This is the track that has its acoustic version on 'Not Of This World'. Wonderful stuff!
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to chessman
(BETA) | Report this review (#5831) | Review Permalink
Posted Sunday, April 25, 2004
If you've read some of my reviews, you've probably guessed by now that I'm sold to this band. PENDRAGON's music sways me like few others, thanks to Clive Nolan's unmistakable personal touch. And if "Not of This World" had been the band's first (or even second) effort I 'd cry out 'Genius!' at the top of my lungs. However, I'm forced to agree with some reviewers on this one: it smells a little too much of 'déjà vu'. To be fair, it does have its strong moments. For one, the intro to the first track features one of the most mind-blowing guitar intros I've ever heard. In short, it promises the world (no pun intended). As the album unfolds, however, many songs seem to drag on unnecessarily.As much as I hate to admit it, every time I hit the last part of "Dance of the Seven Veils Part 2", I invariably want to skip it and get on with the next track (this, unfortunately, also happens with a couple of others - something I never thought any PENDRAGON album would prompt me to do). Fellow reviewer Peter Rideout hit the booboo right on the nail when he said the album would have carried more impact had the band trimmed off the 'fat'. As it stands, it's still a fine CD where the musical romanticism we've come to love from PEBNDRAGON still shines through out: a 76-minute epic where all songs progress nicely and melodically, with plenty of catchy hooks and spine-tingling chords. But too many of them drag on and (sadly) are often predictable.
Todate, every new PENDRAGON release showed some upward progression, quality-wise. With "Not of This World", the band has taken a small step backwards. If you're an undaunted fan, I still think you should get this CD, if only for such fine pieces as the opener "If I Were the Wind", the 3-track suite "Not of This World" and the epic "Man of Nomadic Traits".
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Hibou
(BETA) | Report this review (#5836) | Review Permalink
Posted Wednesday, June 02, 2004
PINK FLOYD had a way of combining moody, anglo-tinted, alienated rock with gospel-
style vocals and lush or ambient spacey embellishments; after "Dark Side", they
revisited this melding from time to time, right up to "The Final Cut" and the non-Waters
era. It was such a successful combination of textures that bands still do it to this day,
some with questionable results (ARCHIVE), some with more class...like Hogarth era
MARILLION, and PENDRAGON. "If I Were the Wind" demonstrates that a stylistic
influence doesn't always equal a rip-off, as I daresay they do it better than FLOYD did
on many of their later releases.Barrett's unique tone and undisguised british phrasing take a bit of getting used to, but he generally sounds both heartfelt and dramatic in moderation, and this saves "The Dance of the Seven Veils" from pleasant mediocrity. The first movement, "Faithless" is much more pop-rock influenced; its companion piece "All Over Now" has a "Dogs"-like rhythmic guitar riff but a more contemporary 90s sound and a good sense of progression throughout.
The "Not of this World" suite has a much more modern (neo-prog, prog metal) feel, soaring nicely with blazing guitar work and warm washes of synth. The excellent drumming seems a little drowned out in the mix at times, but it is a very big sound. "Give it to Me" is a slightly poppier take on the "Money" theme, and "Green-Eyed Angel" is a more reflective, moody love song (that could have used a bit of a goose on the bum to get it moving).
"A Man of Nomadic Traits" has some uninspired lyrics, but the driving, moody pulse of the music makes for good listening. Again, it could have been trimmed a bit, and the tinkling guitar arpeggios and propulsive drums deserve to be heard better. The sweet guitar harmonies and synth washes make this a respectable neo- prog epic with more GENESIS than FLOYD influence this time.
The "World's End" dyad returns to the moody FLOYDian trappings (the first few minutes are even closer to "Hey You" than "Faithless" was) but includes also some GENESIS- inspried synth arpeggios in the more upbeat sections. "The Lost Children" makes a nice transition from a lament to a protest to an anthem, whereas "And Finally" is definitely updated FLOYD style; an interstellar crooner- smooth, sweet and warm like honey heated on a bunsen burner in a laboratory. "Momentary Lapse of Reason" should have had more moments like this.
There's also some bonus acoustic tracks; not being very familiar with the band, I can only comment on these versions. "Paintbox" has a nice nostalgic, melancholy feel- too bad those kind of pickups make acoustics sound so artificial, but strangely enough, this ends up working well with the antique harpsichord texture and solo voice of "King of the Castle". Neither song is amazing, but "King" is a nice pastoral piece.
PENDRAGON are not pioneers, but they make the most of the classic influences while incorporating choice neo-prog and metal elements. Sometimes you may want to light a fire under them, as the songs can drag or repeat a bit, but the sounds are comfortable and warm yet crystal clear. They keep the prog fire burning without simply rehashing the past, and so I give the album a lukewarm but generally positive three stars.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to James Lee
(BETA) | Report this review (#5837) | Review Permalink
Posted Saturday, June 26, 2004
Well paddedA very complete album from Pendragon, which flows seamlessly from beginning to end. The tracks are generally pretty similar, being lengthy pieces of symphonic prog. The one irritation I had with the album was I kept hearing sections which sounded very like other people's work. There are extracts which sound like Steve Howe, Enigma, etc., and one which is almost identical to a section of Barclay James Harvest's "May day" from "Octoberon". I'm not suggesting there's any sort of plagiarism going on, but I found the presence of so many similarities distracting.
None of the tracks are Pendragon classics as such, there's no "Good as gold" or "The shadow", but they are all of a high standard, and very melodic. The pace is raised slightly on "All over now", and "Give it to me", but "If I were the wind" and "A man of nomadic traits" are more indicative of the overall feel of the album. Throughout there is a symphonic sound, Clive Nolan layering keyboard after keyboard as the foundations.
While some of the tracks are nominally broken into sections, the shortest track is over 9 minutes, giving some idea of the space available to develop the themes. That space is not always exploited to the full, and the album would perhaps have been better if they had introduced more variety within each piece. The notion that they may have been thin on ideas is supported by the inclusion of two "Bonus tracks". These originally appeared on the extra disc which accompanied some copies of "The Masquerade Overture". Both are acoustic versions of tracks from that album, "King of the castle" being extracted from "The shadow".
The albums is probably best heard as a complete piece, despite the fact that the tracks do stand up OK on their own. While it is a quality offering, it would have been better if the tracks had been developed more, instead of simply being made longer.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Easy Livin
(BETA) | Report this review (#5840) | Review Permalink
Posted Friday, October 01, 2004
Let me point out that this album is the only studio work I own by Pendragon, (other then a
live one I found in the used bin) so for all you fans my comments are not prejudiced by
their earlier works. What stands out immediately is Barret's voice and guitar work. His voice
took many many plays for me to get used to. It's emotional yes, but he just can't hit or
sustain high notes, but boy oh boy he does give it a try. His guitar sounds alot like David
Gilmour's, almost too much! With those two negatives out of the way, I will say that the
music is bombastic, IQ bombastic at times (which is a good thing, given I like IQ very much)
and that falls on Nolan's keyboards which are fantastic. "Not Of This World" and "A Man Of
Nomadic Traits" are the best songs on the album for the simple fact that they compare to
IQ in structure, quick paced. The rest of the songs just plods along, with a Marrillon burst
here and there, (the beginning of the track "Not Of This World). Two notes, the two bonus
acoustic songs that close the album are sung better then any other song on the album.
(hint, hint....) and are the female harmonizing singers the same women who back-up Pink
Floyd?? It's uncanny! So, to summarize--If you are into Neo-prog, and enjoy Pink Floyd
guitar work with IQ keyboard flourishes, then this will be your cup of tea. "For complex this
is not!", replied Master Yoda.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to NJprogfan
(BETA) | Report this review (#36737) | Review Permalink
Posted Friday, June 17, 2005
I'm fairly new to Pendragon's music, but have been buying up a lot of their material from the 90's material to the
present day--including last year's Believe. Not Of This World is a worthwile disc, displaying impeccable musicianship. Barrett's vocals can be a bit grating and over indulgent at times, but the music is so good that it's thrust to the forefront. If anything, the instrumentation grabs me more than the vocals or the lyrics. Especially on the "Not Of This World" section where Clive Nolan really shines, and Barrett showcases that he's a more than capable guitarist. The musicians in Pendragon strike me as being amongst the most talented in the neo progressive genre. Peter Gee's bass seems to be muffled a lot in the mix, however.
The trait I've noticed in Pendragon's music is the music reaches upward and really whirls around. That tradition is carried on with Not Of This World (although a bit downplayed on Believe). It's very well produced and might not be as consistent as Masquerade Overture, but the musicianship is top notch.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to E-Dub
(BETA) | Report this review (#70933) | Review Permalink
Posted Thursday, March 02, 2006
One of Pendragon's best! Ok, maybe a notch or two below The Masquerade Overture, but
that's a little unfair, since you can't really compare the two. They are different
and masterpieces on their own. Actually I was quite aware if Pendragon would ever
release something the same level as Masquerade by the time it was released. It
seemed like the band got better with each release since The World. And every album
surpassed its preceder. And Not Of This World in some aspects do that. It's highly
emotional, the musicanship is even more bombastic and elaborate than Masquerade,
which does not mean it was overblown. In fact this album takes a little more getting
used to than those previous ones. But once you really get into it, you're hooked.
It's different, and yet it's the perfect follow up to one disc that did not seem to
have a match. I can't tell which song is better than the other, since they all seem
to flow in the whole concept without a fault. Actually everything here sounds like
one fantastic song with many many variations, colours and emotions. Superb! I can't
really stop hearing it once I put it on the CD player. I have to hear it all. I wish
their more recent CD Believe would surprised me as such. But I think it would be
asking too much. After more than a decade of delivering masterpieces, they'd have to
go down one day. I Hope Pendragon will produce sometihing as good as Not Of This World
next time. Highly recommended!
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Tarcisio Moura
(BETA) | Report this review (#84144) | Review Permalink
Posted Wednesday, July 19, 2006
Finally a new studio album from Pendragon. Their fans had to wait for five years to get
a follow-up to their best album so far (IMO) : "The Masquerade Overture".There won't be a revolution in style on this album of course; as you can expect. Since "The World", Pendragon produces the same type of music which involves brilliant guitar breaks, beautiful melodies and catchy songs. You'll get all these ingredients on this album.
Three very long songs build on the "suite" style will almost cover this (very) long album. But Pendragon is used to this already. So, again no surprise. It is true that this album is probably the most Genesis oriented (while they were four "Wind & Wuthering" and three "And There Were Three"). But not to such extent to call it plagiatory work.
One of my favourite song is "A Man of Nomadic Traits" as well as the suite "World's End". It holds all the Pendragon aspects that Pendragon fans love so much (and that his detactors hate so much...). A marvelously emotional Barrett on the vocals as well as on the guitar of course, not to forget the great job of Clive (but it is so obvious that it almost doesn't need to be mentioned).
Song structure is typical like of lots of Pendragon songs : easy listening, straight- forward, yet beautiful. Again, if you are looking to complex music with intricated lyrics, this album is not for you. But Pendragon will never produce such things.
There are two acoustic bonus tracks on this release (probably to annouce "Acoustically Challenged"). Although this excercise is not my favourite, I must say that Pendargon music is probably more favourable to such treatment as Arena's one for example (but they were already available on one compilation).
During the difficult nineties period, Pendragon stuck to their their melodic progressive music while most bands were heading other directions. This is to be mentioned before being criticized.
Of course, this album is not a masterpiece. Pendragon seemed to be a bit out of inspiration but it is as pleasant as 'The World" and "The Window Of Life". None of the tracks featured here is average, don't worry : this is really Pendragon as we like (or do not like). Therefore, I will aplly the same rating : four stars.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to ZowieZiggy
(BETA) | Report this review (#125660) | Review Permalink
Posted Wednesday, June 13, 2007
An often heard complaint about Pendragon (especially Pendragon of the nineties) is that all the successors of The World were more
or less the same as The World. First I want to say I always thought that was nonsense because every album was different enough
for my liking and second: even if that is the case, why bother ? I think the road Barrett and his men took in early nineties was the
right one. I think what he did in the eighties was sometimes nice, but a lot of the songs sounded almost like plain pop music and I
didn't like that stile. I even want to go that far that I think Pendragon improved with each album after The World and to me that culminated in the ultimate highlight in their carreer: Not of this World. This is an absolutely outstanding album. Besides the great compositions, it also sounds really great, so that means superb production as well. I think in this album besides (as ever) Nick Barrett now also Clive Nolan reaches his absolute apogee in his performances with Pendragon. It mainly is evident in " A Man of nomadic traits" to me the very highlight of this album and probably the best Pendragon song ever and that's particularly because of the instrumental passage in the middle of the song where both Barrett and Nolan do an unbelievable job. Really magnificent !! Almost all the other songs are far more than average too, great title track and also the catchy Dance of the seven veils (very nice in live gigs) are good examples.
So hats off for this terrific effort by Pendragon. This album is in my heart and soul. I think my avatar says it all. I can only give this 5 stars.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to progrules
(BETA) | Report this review (#146825) | Review Permalink
Posted Thursday, October 25, 2007
Crushed between the two greatest band's studio releases, "The Masquerade Overture" and "Believe", this album looks like a kind of
PENDRAGON's sabbatical. No, it's not a bad work; in fact, it's fairly audible and amusing even catchy but I'm quite sure to have
expected a bit more from this fine band or maybe I should have listened to "Not Of This World" in the correct sequence which didn't
happen and so not to sound biased I'll place myself within the correct space and time to review this album in a fair manner.Maybe I didn't get totally the amount of cheesy songs and the fact that Barrett's voice, sharp and dauntless, fits better for rock-folk- prog acts but runs senseless when venturing through romantic-balladesque sceneries. Also, PENDRAGON looks like giving one or two steps backwards while playing dated neo-prog tunes much more suitable for the mid-80s than the turn of the century. Instrumentation, even righteous, seems a bit over creating at times a choking and artificial atmosphere.
Good parts are mainly inside the songs, especially 'A man of nomadic traits', the best and proggiest song here and the dual parts of 'Dance of seven veils', being the second superior than the first. Here and there we may pick interesting segments inside other tracks, more specifically in either parts of 'World's end'. Bonus tracks, which are acoustic versions of two songs from "The Masquerade Overture", add a different perfume to the album even being a little misplaced.
In the end, a fifty-fifty work but worth to receive a upgraded rating thanks to PENDRAGON's history and so "Not Of This World" is honestly a non-essential good album.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Atkingani
(BETA) | Report this review (#156282) | Review Permalink
Posted Saturday, December 22, 2007
Somewhere in between the bombastic but engaging openers and the lovely olde Englishe sounding
acoustic bonus material this album lapses into.....repetitive bombastic and less engaging material.
The almost non stop accompanying wall of lead guitar and airy keyboards probably has something to
do with it. The self absorbed solipsistic lyrics doubtless play a role. The incessant vocal and
compositional references to 70s Genesis don't help. So after the second "Dance of the Seven veils",
pretty much everything is a repetition of what came before, either on the album or in prog history.
If Pendragon has a leg up on some of their British neo compatriots, it is that they rarely try to
infuse anything metallic into their mix, but some of the above shortcomings, and the fact that
succinctness is largely left out of their playbook, largely negate this advantage.
As mentioned, out of the gate are several beautiful songs and suites that truly vary the tempo and rise above the fray, and the stripped down acoustic songs at the end are such a breath of fresh aire in contrast to the overly busy bulk of the disk. But by and large this is a pretty mediocre effort that is very much "of this world" of neo prog. 2.5 stars rounded down.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to kenethlevine
(BETA) | Report this review (#159914) | Review Permalink
Posted Saturday, January 26, 2008
The best Pendragon album I've heard...In my opinion, "Not of this World" clearly surpases the previous "The Masquerade Overture"... Maybe not in originality and sound. But in passion, lyrics and in feeling, Nick Barrett managed to surpase the previous and a bit overrated work.
The style is similar than the previous Pendragon albums form the 90's... Maybe it's more guitar oriented, having the Clive Nolan's keyboards less protagonism than "The Masquerade Overture". The album is also mellower than the previous one, offering a lot of slow passages, where Nick Barrett draws marvellous melodies with his electric and the now very habitual acoustic guitars, always with Nolan's keys in the background.
The albums open with an slow, dramatic and emotional piece called If I were the Wind, wich is not the best of the disc, but a good opening... After that, we have the Dance of the Seven Veils, a track that clearly represents the style of this album, more dinamic and with longer progressions (although they are not always appropiate...) than the previous band's efforths. Then Not of this World comes, wich is in my opinion the best long track Pendragon has ever made, with a lot of changes and intensity... After this jewel, comes A Man With Nomadic Trates, in a style similar than Dance of the Seven Veils, but even better, because here we have the best Clive Nolan's work in the album. At the end, World's End comes, wich repeat some melodies of the title track in a decadent and sad style, very appropiate to close the disc, in a similar way of the start of it.
So the scheme of the album, if you've read the last part of my review, is circular! Songs 1 and 5 are similar: a bit sad and dramatic, appropiate to open and close the work. Songs 2 and 4 are also equivalent, with a similar duration and style. The marvellous Song 3, the central piece of the album, it stands alone, being the more complex, complete and representative of "Not of this World".
After that, I have to say than the album is not perfect... Except 2 or maybe 3 songs, the rest of them has some flaws, with a pair of dull moments. I find interesting the slower and acoustic direction this album has, but sometimes I miss a bit more energy. Nevertheless, some slow pieces like Green Eyed Angel are just pefect, and for me, Nick Barrett's voice is more appropiated to sing this kind of songs, than the rockier ones.
Best Tracks: Dance of the Seven Veils, Not of this World and A Man of Nomadic Trates.
Conclusion: having not heard the last two Pendragon albums, "Not of this World" is my favourite from them. It's more inspired than their previous efforths, it has better lyrics in my opinion, and it's structure is ingenious and very catchy. It's a pity the pair of boring moments this album has, specially at the end of the last song, although they are not any impediment to enjoy this exccellent addition to any prog music collection.
My rating: ****
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to The Crow
(BETA) | Report this review (#221880) | Review Permalink
Posted Saturday, June 20, 2009
Sometimes, you hear something and know that's it's A class, the masterpiece and you're
gonna give it 5 star rating, no matter the cost. And you'll defend this decision, until someone
(with really good arguments, facts and big in size, strong in stubbornness) prove
something that can change my mind. And I'm afraid that even after all this martyrdom, result
will be that I'll still love Not of This World.Wonderful cover art, in fact, this was first Pendragon album I get myself to, so I can't compare. Even now, this is everything I need (for now), no need to explore more, because on this album, there are Ideas, hidden thing which will appear after numerous listening, one after another. As I know now, these covers are typical for Pend. (isn't this name something from Arthur legend ? I'm not so skilled in it - yes, it is, father of King Arthur), but this one is somewhat important for me. My dear girlfriend was kissed by muse one night and drawn me and her in style of this picture, on a meadow like scenery, sitting and looking to the sun. Funny thing is that most of music I listen regularly is connected with certain game, during which I listen this music. When listening to NoTW, I imagine myself playing San Andreas (Las Venturas, hotel with pirate ship, trying to take down as much pedestrians as possible, while shooting on helicopters with M16. There is natural cover, something like fence from brick wall, which separates sidewalk from my position. Well, bullets and Pendragon, what a combination). Weird, but true (I mean strange, but true, as is sung in lyrics)
In my 130 reviews history, I had to admit few times for certain thing. That I was listening one track over and over again, until I was satisfied by it. And that would be All Over Now part. Even I am not used to like this kind of keyboards, Arena and Pendragon are exceptions, there I like it. Probably some kind of connection here. So let's start with If I Were the Wind. Sounds is typical for neo prog, I'm not afraid to call it archetypal for this genre, with one exception, acoustic guitar here. Vocals fits here perfectly, Nick Barrett is doing a lot and is giving a lot of emotions in it. And to this fantasy story is more then good suited, I can't imagine this music without him. Similar style of singing is even in Arena music, where singers changes regularly. Oh, when talking about Arena, I have to mention Clive Nolan. He's skilled keyboardist of modern age, I suppose he has his hands (four h's in a row) in a lot of Pendragon/Arena music.
5(+) for a work of true art, which is pleasure to listen, have all ingredients which I admire in this kind of prog and, which is the biggest surprise, everything works perfectly. And oh, of course, my girl. She felt instantly in love with this one, same as myself.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Marty McFly
(BETA) | Report this review (#239049) | Review Permalink
Posted Sunday, September 13, 2009
This is a neo- prog master piece.
I remember when Pendragon made a turn in their style of prog. rock with "The World "
I said ..."what a beatiful piece of neo prog" ...because before they were a mix of
art,symph. and neo progrock.
But here In Not OfThis....they honoured the name of t
... (read more)
Report this review (#126538) | Posted by robbob | Friday, June 22, 2007 | Review Permanlink
I got a copy of this as soon as it was released....... nearly six years ago now.
It takes a special album to still be in my most played list so long after release!
This is a story of touching emotion, of fears, and sadnesses and human betrayals, it is real and full of
passion, there is no "fil
... (read more)
Report this review (#103201) | Posted by Wilcey | Friday, December 15, 2006 | Review Permanlink
Hmm, not quite sure with this album, on one hand it is brilliant, coherent and it rocks; on
the other there are some annoying traits that begin to needle after a while, almost as if it
were being amplified...
Firstly the good stuff - Excellent muscianship is displayed by all, The longer piece
... (read more)
Report this review (#91835) | Posted by huge | Sunday, September 24, 2006 | Review Permanlink
I am a new fan of this group and learning slowly their music I thought The Masquerade
Overture, as many people say, is the best album...
This was until I bought Not of this world....F A N T A S T I C !
There is not one single weak song.
All music is really excellent with good atmosphere from
... (read more)
Report this review (#84062) | Posted by luc4fun | Tuesday, July 18, 2006 | Review Permanlink
I love this CD. I don't think there is a bad track on it! Right from the opening song to
the end the songs just flow in and out of each other with some recurring tunes. The
tunes themselves have interesting themes/stories with no swearing in the lyrics (I am
no prude by the way), and the bookl
... (read more)
Report this review (#62052) | Posted by | Wednesday, December 28, 2005 | Review Permanlink
Not of this World is a fairly big letdown after the near-perfection of The Masquerade
Overture, and on first glance, and perhaps even on first listen, one may wonder why.
All of the ingredients that go into the classic Pendragon formula are there: searing
guitar solos, bombastic synths, Barret
... (read more)
Report this review (#62046) | Posted by stonebeard | Wednesday, December 28, 2005 | Review Permanlink
I would easily rate this as a 4.50/5.00 album.
The two things that I do not understand are
complaints over NICK BARRETT's voice and the lack of innovation/complexity in this
album. BARRETT's voice on this album is the most emotionally intense that it has ever
been. And IMO, this is at least as
... (read more)
Report this review (#44727) | Posted by | Monday, August 29, 2005 | Review Permanlink
Excellent: the best of Pendragon is here. Just hear the title track! This is the conclussion of
a work that started with "The window of life" and ends here. You can hear it as a
conceptual album, the tale of creation; or just as a compilation of songs. Both sound well!
... (read more)
Report this review (#5842) | Posted by | Monday, March 14, 2005 | Review Permanlink
There is only one negative I can find in this album. Nick Barrett's voice. I have no
other PENDRAGON CD's, mainly because they're hard to find in the U.S. but also due to
the fact that Mr. Barrett's voice causes me to lose concentration on the music. After
a few spins (getting used to Barrett's s
... (read more)
Report this review (#5841) | Posted by Trafficdogg | Thursday, February 03, 2005 | Review Permanlink
Much overrated band, since there is no musical development in comparison to former
albums. Great musicianship, I admit, but songs lack focus and sharpness. Too naive, and
too pompous for it's own sake. Also there's too much emphasis on Nick Barrett's vocal and
guitar melodies. This makes it so
... (read more)
Report this review (#5839) | Posted by PROGCOM | Tuesday, August 03, 2004 | Review Permanlink
After a long time not searched for and listned to Prog- or Symp rock music, I was pleased to read some articals about groups I never heard of. After reading, I starded to listen to that unknown music. So I found the music of Pendragon. After I heard it, it was for me the music I want to hear. Someti
... (read more)
Report this review (#5828) | Posted by It's Me | Monday, May 03, 2004 | Review Permanlink
This record is the great Pendragon`s rock opus. The songs has a impressive dramatic and
apassionate voice and lyrics by Nick Barret. Besides the music has a agressive and
melodical game of keyboards and drumming. The guitars are wonderful in the Pendragon`s
history. In my opinion really the be
... (read more)
Report this review (#5844) | Posted by Queno | Thursday, March 11, 2004 | Review Permanlink
it's not so bad as the others say really, it's just good album but without any very exciting point, good solid work. I don't think Masquerade success will be repeated ever again, Not Of This World is too long in my opinion and sometimes boring but for really many good moments it's worth of listening
... (read more)
Report this review (#5817) | Posted by l-s-d | Thursday, March 11, 2004 | Review Permanlink
If you're a Pendragon fan, you already own it; if you're just a neo-prog fan looking for a good album, then you're better off with Masquerade Overture, or picking up the newest I.Q. or Jadis disc if this sound is your cup of tea. Both are better choices than this; a plodding album without even the
... (read more)
Report this review (#5825) | Posted by | Wednesday, February 25, 2004 | Review Permanlink
You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Copyright © Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise
| GeoIP Services by MaxMind