![]() 3.19 | 147 ratings | 11% 5 stars Good, but non-essential |
Studio Album, released in 1969 Songs / Tracks Listing 1. Cirrus Minor (5:18) Search PINK FLOYD More lyrics Music tabs (tablatures)Search PINK FLOYD More tabs Line-up / Musicians- David Gilmour / guitar, vocals
LP Columbia SCX6346 (1969) and to Joren for the last updates Edit this entry |
| How to submit new MP3s
![]() | More Original recording remastered, Soundtrack Capitol (Audio CD 1996) | $7.85 $6.09 (used) |
![]() | More Soundtrack, Import EMI Europe Generic (Audio CD 2004) | $8.88 $7.89 (used) |
![]() | Soundtrack from the film MORE Columbia-EMI, Pathe Marconi, France (Vinyl ) | $29.95 (used) |
![]() | More Original recording reissued, Soundtrack Capitol (Audio Cassette 1990) | $9.99 $7.95 (used) |
![]() | More Import, Limited Edition, Original recording reissued, Original recording remastered, Soundtrack EMI Int'l (Audio CD 2001) | $34.99 $78.35 (used) |
![]() | Soundtrack From the Film More Played and Composed By the Pink Floyd EMI-BOVEMA HOLLAND COLUMBIA (Vinyl ) | $9.99 (used) |
![]() | More Import, Soundtrack Phantom Sound & Vision (Audio CD 1969) | $68.70 |
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(11%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(31%)
Good, but non-essential (37%)
Collectors/fans only (21%)
Poor. Only for completionists (1%)
Three stars for the movie and four stars for the "soundtrack".
Some progheads have problems considering this album a real Floyd album, mostly due to the OST letter. But there are a lot of real gems, some are even classic Floyd songs, and if some people are put off by this, the shorter song format and the word Soundtrack are the culprits. Do indulge as this is a real Floyd album. One of their heavier songs ever is on this one - Nile Song. Actually it is a bit of a wonder how the film does not take a better advantage of the Floyd tracks, as they are mixed in way too low in the movie. The movie plot is the downfall of a German student falling for an American woman in Paris and a sordid plunge into the world of hard drugs - as accurate a statement the movie is, it does not fit the beautiful music of the soundtrack. Most tracks are unfortunately cut before their end or interrupted by dialogue. Better stick to the album as the movie does not bring much new elements for enjoyment.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Sean Trane
(BETA) | Report this review (#8244) | Review Permalink
Posted Tuesday, February 03, 2004
Some artists are a natural for soundtracks: TANGERINE DREAM, VANGELIS and, so it would seem, PINK FLOYD. The band recorded this collection of songs and instrumentals for the Barbet Schroeder film, More (they would go on to score another of his films, released as "Obscured By Clouds"). Soundtracks are often a dicey deal, producing on command a pale imitation of an artist's original hue or indulging delusions of grandeur by dressing their sometimes humble muse in orchestral robes. Not so More, which sticks close to the plan established for their studio albums: soporific ballads, psychedelic sandstorms, and eerie instrumental noodling. It's not up to the level of A Saucerful of Secrets -- the band wasn't going to waste their best ideas on a film no one was going to see -- but it is closer to the genuine article than you would expect. The sleepy "Cirrus Minor" and its explosive followup, "The Nile Song", set the tone for the album's calculated desire to lull listeners to sleep only to rouse them with sonic overload. It's these songs and a handful of others ("Crying Song", "Green Is The Colour", "Cymbaline", "Ibiza Bar") that represent More's real achievement. Despite some interesting moments like the avant jazz duet of WRIGHT and MASON on "Up The Khyber" or the eerie journey of "Quicksilver", the instrumentals generally represent filler. Unfortunately, nothing on here aspires to an "Interstellar Overdrive" or "Careful With That Axe, Eugene." Seen as a hybrid of a studio album and a soundtrack, you'll get a better picture of what More has to offer. It's no substitute for the studio albums, but it is a nice supplement to them.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to daveconn
(BETA) | Report this review (#8239) | Review Permalink
Posted Monday, May 03, 2004
and once again, the floyd never cease to amaze. pink floyd had been moving on from the
loss of syd and had started to let gilmour prove himself. the band took a step in a new
direction by producing a soundtrack to drug film "more" but this album is a clear stepping
stone between saucerful where the band were progressing from the immature sound into
psychadelic prog rock.more also paves the way for ummagumma. there are similarities to the ummagumma studio album here. cirrus minor and grantchester meadows are rogers acoustic pieces which are quite dark and ordinary and quite similar to each other. more also experiments with guitar effects and has the biggest range of musical genres on any floyd album, including blues, tribal music, spanish acoustic pieces, trippy and psychadelic songs, and the "heavy" "nile song". very experimental and there will be parts of the album you dont like but these will be made up as there are lots of songs that will please you. this album isnt for everyone but because it is so experimental then it will suit anyones taste as there each floyd fan will get something different out of this album. shine on...
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to frenchie
(BETA) | Report this review (#8240) | Review Permalink
Posted Tuesday, May 18, 2004
This film soundtrack doccuments Pink Floyd in a hugely transitional phase. This was their
first album not to feature Syd Barrett at all, and it's pretty obvious that they were
experimenting a bit trying to find their sound. As a result, this is the most diverse album in
the group's catalogue. They're got a great psychadelic instrumental in "Main Theme", as
well as "Quicksilver" (the latter not being a very good one though) a free jazz song in "Up
the Khyber", a heavy metal song in "The Nile Song", a couple of mellow acoustic tracks
in "The Crying Song" and "Green is the Colour", as well as some distinctly Floydian sounding
tracks in "Cirrus Minor" and "Cymbaline". While many of these experiments fail, many of
them also work beautifully. "Cymbaline" remains a popular song among fans even
today, "The Nile Song" is a delightful rocker of a type that they really didn't do enough of,
and "Up the Khyber" shows that they had talents outside of rock. However, there's also
garbage like the boring "More Blues", the uselss "Party Sequence" and "Dramatic Theme",
and "Ibiza Bar", which is pretty much a more mellow reprise of "The Nile Song". This album
has enough moments to warrant giving a listen to, but not enough to make it stand up
there with the best stuff in the Pink Floyd cannon. For fans, it's without a doubt worth
checking out though.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Bryan
(BETA) | Report this review (#8248) | Review Permalink
Posted Friday, July 02, 2004
It's surprising there aren't more film soundtracks by prog bands, with their penchant for
ambient instrumentals and extended narratives. I'm sure the FLOYD boys learned a thing
or two in the process of scoring (at the very least, how to fill up an album). "More" could
very well be thought of as the third side of "Ummagumma", as the two albums were
recorded at the same time, in the same studio. Perhaps the band needed a release from
the more abstract experimentations; many of the songs here are more straightforward, if
no less diverse.
The main beneficiary from this album is the songwriting- these lyrics and structures are
already an improvement over the occasionally clumsy moments of "Saucerful". "Ibiza Bar" is
a transitional piece somewhere between Barrett-era psychedelia and the heavy,
aggresive "Nile Song", which itself sounds like nothing else in the band's discography-
although it does remarkably forsee MUDHONEY/ SCREAMING TREES- style grunge. Cirrus
Minor", "Crying Song", "Green is the Colour", and "Cymbaline" are lovely acoustic pieces,
marred slightly by strange mixing techniques. The vocals especially seem buried, although
this might just be due to a little lingering insecurity from the singers.The instrumental tracks lack some of the vision which kept much of "Ummagumma" from sounding aimless, but it's still enjoyable just to hear how good PINK FLOYD sounded even when they were just jamming. There's fun to be had even in the throwaways; fans of Gilmour's guitarwork are required to hear his unadulterated blues soloing on (of course) "More Blues" and flemenco attempt on the goofy "Spanish Piece".
Definitely not to be passed over; this is the connection between "Saucerful of Secrets" and "Meddle". The songs confirm that Syd's departure was not a crippling blow, and the instrumentals have plenty of the band's characteristic flavour. If there had been one or two more memorable songs, it would have been a classic; as it stands, it's a great snapshot of FLOYD history with many enjoyable moments.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to James Lee
(BETA) | Report this review (#8249) | Review Permalink
Posted Thursday, August 05, 2004
What an excellent soundtrack! I love More in it's entirety and even looking at the film a few
years back although dated it still managed to capture the free spirit of the late 60's in
Europe ( ibiza of all places) and the experimentation of drugs. Times have changed but
Ibiza is still renowned for drugs more in the shape of ectasy not LSD though. This
soundtrack was way ahead of it's time and speaks volumes as to why PF managed to make
such giant leaps musically within small periods of time. The album starts with ' Cirrus Minor',
a beautifully soft lazy track full of nostalgia and a cacophony of blackbirds chirping in the
background.' Nile song' is a real rocker of a number. The most poignant song on the album '
Cymbaline' has great paranoid lyrics like ' ...apprehension creeping like a tube train up your
spine...'.' Green is the colour' is also a great track. Side two is more instrumental bringing
together more spanish type themes but ' Quicksilver' really standouts the most. All in all a
very accomplished sound and I wonder why sales were never that big for this. Perhaps the
soundtrack tag had a negative impact.Highly recommended!
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Chris S
(BETA) | Report this review (#8250) | Review Permalink
Posted Thursday, September 02, 2004
This is a record entirely made to a movie soundtrack so don't expect great originality from
Pink Floyd's third album. The characteristic psychedelic sound have had almost vanished in
prior of calm instrumental ambiences and calm melodies (what to expect from a
soundtrack anyway?) that fit very well on the film. In fact, Pink Floyd's soundtrack is the
best the movie has to offer. We can listen some of their previous records clichés. The title track from "A Saucerful Of Secrets" appears in the sad church organ in Cirrus Minor but also in the crescendo drumming overture and subsequent psycho sounding of Up The Khyber. The album also offers the hard rocking tracks The Nile Song and Ibiza Bar; the country Green Is The Colour; and some spacey passages in Main Theme and specially QuickSilver (more again sounding like a track taken from the previous record).
The story of the film (and album) I transcribed it from IMDB: "The making of a heroin addict. Stefan, fresh from college, hitches from Germany to Paris, where he does a little breaking and entering to get some money and soon meets Estelle, a young American. Even through a friend warns him off Estelle, Stefan falls for her (she's quixotic). Although he's quickly petulant and possessive, she invites him to follow her to Ibiza for romance in the sun and sand. There Stefan meets another German, Wolf, whose connection with Estelle Stefan can't fathom. He also meets Kathy, whose relationship with Estelle is also unclear at first. What explains her disappearances and furtive behavior? And once Stefan understands, what will he do about it?"
Not an essential album of progressive rock, the more progressive sounding derivates from their previous releases. Nevertheless, it shows the idea of globalization of the psychedelic movement. Basically, for Pink Floyd's fans or great collectors.
My rate: 6/10
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to TRoTZ
(BETA) | Report this review (#8253) | Review Permalink
Posted Wednesday, December 29, 2004
After the departure of SYD BARRETT, but before the ascendency of lyrical giant ROGER
WATERS and guitar giant DAVID GILMOUR, More shows the true talents of PINK FLOYD's
most underrated musicians: RICK WRIGHT and NICK MASON (keyboards and drums
respectively). In my opinion, it was these two who helped to maintain the continuity of the
PINK FLOYD style during this transitional period, and it's a real shame they were
overshadowed later on in the band's career. The chaotic, jazzlike piece "Up the Khyber"
says it all...although there is a little bass in it as well, both WRIGHT and MASON truly
shine. RICK WRIGHT fans will appreciate the prominence of his Farfisa organ in songs such as "Cirrus Minor", "Main Theme", and "Quicksilver"; this will also give you somewhat of an idea what he was like in concert during this time period.
NICK MASON fans should enjoy the more elaborate, improvisational, sometimes Eastern drumming style he shows in songs like "Party Sequence" (foreshadowing of the intro of "Time", perhaps?), "Main Theme", and "Up the Khyber", very much in contrast to his more laid-back style in later albums.
Another interesting feature of this album is the strangely "hard" songs for PINK FLOYD, "The Nile Song" and "Ibiza Bar". Although completely different from anything else in the Pink Floyd catalogue (except maybe a vocal resemblance to Momentary Lapse's "Dogs of War"), they are very enjoyable. Another style you rarely hear, but is important to the PINK FLOYD sound, is the blues: "More Blues" is an interesting piece, although I wish the drums wouldn't start and stop the way they do.
In general, I would characterise More as a fascinating picture of the band's late 60's style. Although a soundtrack, it stands alone very well, and you will not be disappointed. All in all, I give this album three stars...maybe it isn't one of the PINK FLOYD masterpieces, but give More its fair chance--especially those of you who would like a "Rick and Nick" album.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to FloydWright
(BETA) | Report this review (#8255) | Review Permalink
Posted Tuesday, January 04, 2005
A highly under-rated and neglected PINK FLOYD album. This is good experimental stuff.
If you are a FLOYD fan, this album belongs in your collection. Although musically
experimental, Floyd is starting to settle down and one can see how Waters'
leadership is beginning to coalesce after the highly ambitious, yet disjointed "A
Saucerful of Secrets".
"More" can be divided into its two parts: 1) Original songs with vocals; and 2) Instrumental, soundtrack pieces. Surprisingly enough, especially for a soundtrack album, it's in the 'original song compositions' and not the instrumentals that FLOYD acheive new heights.
PINK FLOYD are masters at starting their albums off with a signature track/sound. 'Astronomy Domine', 'Speak To Me', 'Shine On You Crazy Diamond', 'Pigs on the Wing', 'Signs of Life' and 'Cluster One' are all classic FLOYD intros that set the mood for the album in their own way. 'Cirrus Minor' exemplifies that tradition with its atmospheric-setting tropical bird sounds, acoustic guitar intro and haunting Gilmour vocals. Don't miss Rick Wright's wonderful keyboard outro here.
'Cirrus Minor', 'The Nile Song', 'Green Is The Colour' and 'Cymbaline' are all FLOYD classics. These are the reasons you should own this album. 'Green' and 'Cymbaline' became band staples whilst they toured in the early 70's prior to their "DSOTM" success, and were often stretched into long 10+ minute improvisational pieces. FLOYD showcased the 'Azimuth Coordinator' technology during 'Cymbaline' as they manipulated and projected quad sound effects (usually footsteps) towards speakers located in the four corners of the arena.
'Green Is The Colour' shows what Gilmour could do when allowed to write his own music. Rick Wright's work on the keyboards compliment Gilmour's voice and guitar really nicely on this little tune. It is here that 'The softer side of the Pink Floyd Sound' is born. (For more info see Wright/Gilmour's later collaboration and vocal harmonies on 'Echoes' and 'Us & Them'.)
'Ibiza Bar' is a little known song that along with 'The Nile Song' show some of the earliest elements of an almost 'proto-heavy metal' sound similar to that found in GENESIS' 'The Knife'. Amazing that these FLOYD songs were written in 1969!
As for the instrumental work, some are good, and some are quite inadequate. 'More Blues', 'Main Theme' and 'Dramatic Theme' are all typical instrumental FLOYD. However, 'Up the Khyber', 'Party Sequence' and especially 'Quicksilver' are forgettable at best, and are easily seen as the soundtrack filler that they really are. 'Quicksilver' is quite possibly the worst piece of FLOYD music in existence. Yes, even worse than 'Dogs of War' (haha)
Overall, an experimental album, and the first of their big three 'soundtrack' albums. If you only own "Dark Side" and "The Wall", then skip this offering. If you are more adventurous, and enjoy more risky FLOYD, give this one a try. 3/5 stars
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Cluster One
(BETA) | Report this review (#8260) | Review Permalink
Posted Wednesday, February 23, 2005
Although I haven't seen the movie, I'm sure this music works quite well as a soundtrack for
a film that's basically about drug use among young hippies in Europe. Several tracks have
a gauzy, out-of-the-body atmosphere that almost seems to slow the passage of time. So,
this album often gets played when I'm in the mood for that kind of music late at night. Of
course, this means that the loud pieces get programmed out, but that's no big deal. I'm
not a big fan of "The Nile Song", which pre-dates punk by almost a decade. I remember
liking this album the first time I listened to it, which was sometime in the early 70's before
DSOTM came out. I think it fits in rather well with their other albums from the same period,
and would recommend it to anyone who likes the period between "Saucerful..."
and "Meddle". And don't forget the recently issued and expanded "Zabriskie Point"
soundtrack, which features several Floyd tracks that appear nowhere else (including a
song that's got a distinct country influence!). It comes from the same period as the music
from "More".
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to soundsweird
(BETA) | Report this review (#8263) | Review Permalink
Posted Tuesday, March 15, 2005
Written and recorded as a soundtrack to director Barbet Schroeder's dystopian hippie road
flick "More" (1969). On top of the various short number of movie tracks there are also a
number of great classic FLOYD songs which actually made their way into the live sets in the
late 60's and early 70's (Cymbaline, Green In The Colour and Cirrus Minor). This heavily
psychedelic-laced album explores some pretty trippy zones and mixes both soft blues rock
and psychedelic genres. In many ways this album is reminiscent of "Atom Hearted Mother".
Overall a classic album and although I suppose is considered by most to be a soundtrack,
really represents a full fledged PINK FLOYD album for me. 100% Essential
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to loserboy
(BETA) | Report this review (#8264) | Review Permalink
Posted Friday, March 25, 2005
More of the good stuff can be found on other albums...Ambient birdsong, panned manically around the stereo "picture" creates an odd environment, and a perfect one from which to kick off a prog album. Combined with the cuckoo, and acoustic guitar/mellotron entry, we have flavours from "Saucerful..." and what would become "Ummagumma" - particularly "Grantchester Meadows", and Waters' vocals evoke a similar English pastoral theme with a dose of melancholy.
"Cirrus Minor" builds gently and texturally with a retrospective air, and is a beautiful start to an inconsistent and somewhat patchy, but hugely enjoyable proto-prog album. The jarring counter-melodies and insistent birdsong give the absorbing other-worldly ambience that the Floyd are famous for.
This is kind of spoilt by "The Nile Song", which robs the album of consistency in a single stroke. It's an enjoyable rockout - a kind of simplified "Careful With That Axe Eugene", but the stereo mix (on the original vinyl) prevents it from being as heavy as it deserves, and it's positioning is a little intrusive. In itself, however, it rocks, and Gilmour takes the opportunity for some real Spinal Tap style noodling in a rare moment of exuberance.
"Crying Song" begins with some beautiful ambience - please excuse my overuse of the word here, but it is, after all, what Floyd do best. As a song it seems remarkably unremarkable - but if you listen to the lyrics, this is a song of hope which considers more the postive outcomes rather than dwelling on the sad aspects.
"Up The Khyber" kicks off with a "Saucerful" style drum pattern, but builds nicely into a freeform jazz like medley, with fabulous, scrunchy dischords and mad panning, overlaid with some dark effects. Mysteriously, this avoids sounding completely random, and sadly, Floyd end it before it develops.
"Green Is The Colour" is a pleasant enough song - very mellow, with enjoyable guitar and piano, but the recorder is somewhat intrusive and not well played.
Likewise, "Cymbelline" is musically unremarkable, but has a nice ethnic feel thanks to the bongos, and it's worth hanging in there for the pads and keyboard lines in the closing minute or so, which are nicely engaging.
The bongos in "Party Sequence" provide a great ethnic party feel, slightly reminiscent of Comus - but it's over much too quickly, and seems irrelevant.
"Main Theme" is more like it. Enthusiastic panning on the opening Gong gives way to dischordant and haunting keyboards anticipating "Ummagumma", and the gong provides a background wash to a psychedelic bass/drum entry. Top that lot off with electronic effects and a Jarre-like melody, with flavours of Hillage (more than half a decade later!) and you're onto a psychedelic/prog winner with a mysteriously timeless feel. A wonderful piece of exploration.
"Ibiza Bar" appears to be an attempt to mirror side 1 of the original vinyl, as it is in a similar vein to "The Nile Song" - indeed, there are many similarities in the music. The mixing is better, though, and I prefer this to the latter. Fans of Kula Shaker will hear much that is familiar in the treatment of the structure here.
Continuing the mirroring of side 1, "More Blues" is a wonderfully "dubby" approach to a blues standard that I absolutely love. The only thing wrong with it is that it is MUCH too short!
"Quicksilver" is a journey into electronica par excellence, developing the "gong wash" motif in "Main Theme" and hinting at "Dark Side Of The Moon" in the atmospherics - which are haunting and even spine-chilling in places, with more nods to the studio sessions on "Ummagumma".
"Spanish Piece" is very enjoyable - check out the manic voices, and Gilmour's great Flamenco interpretation.
"Dramatic Theme" ends the album well enough, although it gives the impression of a Floyd on tickover and not at their creative height, as, for Floyd, it is remarkably uninventive and simply seems to re-use old material, without providing a sense of coherence or even ending to this album.
Possibly that's the way it's meant to be - this album providing a collage of ideas that would be worked or rejected on "Ummagumma" to the more sophisticated prog rock band that would go on to create "Animals".
In summary, some utterly superb - even masterful - moments, and far better than simply a collection filler - but by no means essential, unless you're a Floyd fan who really appreciates their early work.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Certif1ed
(BETA) | Report this review (#38627) | Review Permalink
Posted Wednesday, July 06, 2005
Experimental albums like this and Ummagumma always suffer from the bad of being
strongly underrated by the public. But one has to try to see the nuances of these
special gems, and once they are showed, the listener will sure be more pleased and
may have her/his opinion about the album changed to a more positive one. This is the first soundtrack album recorded by PINK FLOYD, it was recorded in just one week at the same year their other experimental work Ummagumma was being made. It's very different from their other OST Obscured by Clouds, which is far more rock directioned and easily enjoyable by the mainstream audience. This, on the other hand, is a much tougher listen even for floydian fans since it is more based on instrumentation variety and various musical styles are combined altogether making this the more eccletic FLOYD album. We have here mellow songs like "Cirrus Minor", "Green in the Colour" and "Cymbaline" - all classics - which are very opposite to tracks like "Ibiza Bar" and "Nile Song", the two heavy metal sisters found here and looking awfully out of place. There's also the shorts "Spanish Piece" and "Party Sequence", a light joke by Dave that works much better than "Seamus" and a drum based track with somewhat of a jungle theme respectively. Both are fine songs that don't ruin the album but on their own are quite mediocre ones. We also have blues on the obviously named "More Blues", which it's quite a nice short piece with a nice guitar flow by Dave and some jazz on "Up the Khyber" that shows Rick and Nick in the spotlight and it is based on the second part of the "Saucerful of Secrets" mini-epic. "Crying Song" is very dreamy ballad and would be an excellent follower for "Cirrus Minor", were not the incovenient appearance of "Nile Song" on the way. The other three lasting instrumentals "Main Theme", "Quicksilver" and "Dramatic Theme" are all very grossly underrated. The first one is an amazing trip through Rick's synths and my favorite song from the album. The second is a new-agey track that perhaps goes too long but can still be a nice trip as well if you listen to it with an open mind. And the third is the album's closer, which is nothing special but not bad either.
By the way, on the movie version of "Cymbaline", we have some different lyrics:
Instead of...
"Will the tightrope reach the end? Will the final couplet rhyme?" -album's lyrics
...we have...
"Standing by with a book in his hand, It's an easy word to rhyme." -movie's lyrics
And in the movie version the vocals are done by Roger Wates instead of David Gilmour.
This album has its great moments. It's a soundtrack, yes, but it deserves some attention too. Sadly this is often overlooked and not appreciated as it should be (like Atom Heart Mother). On the other hand, it is not that special and it's much inferior to its predecessor, but we have to understand that PINK FLOYD was just borning and discovering their sound, mainly because they lost Syd Barrett who was the mastermind of the band on the debut. "Saucerful of Secrets" already proved that they could make a great job on the tracks without Syd, and "More" is already quite a huge accomplishment for a soundtrack album.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Eclipse
(BETA) | Report this review (#40964) | Review Permalink
Posted Saturday, July 30, 2005
Interesting soundtrack worth checking out!Although this is far from being essential FLOYD stuff, still there are few very good moments on this album. Waters is already taking a prominent role as composer, so mellow psyche ballad "Cirrus Minor", heavy metal riff "The Nile Song", or "Cymbaline" are among his best. The first half of the album up to the "Main Theme" is actually pretty good if not yet musically structured. The last several titles are wasting time and are typical boring background music for film. There are several folky acoustic songs, some experimental jazzy improvisations and heavy guitar-driven hard rockers, almost precursors of grunge! Overall, the good album worthy for inclusion into a collection especially for FLOYD fans, but perhaps not the one to begin investigating the PINK FLOYD phenomenon with.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Seyo
(BETA) | Report this review (#46054) | Review Permalink
Posted Friday, September 09, 2005
I am a huge floyd fan so I own this and have listened to it a lot. However there is no way I
would recommend buying this or even borrowing it unless you are a completist. To be fair,
a few of the middle tracks are worth some listens. But its easy to lose interest by the
second half of the cd as its a few uninspired instrumentals.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Carl floyd fan
(BETA) | Report this review (#55006) | Review Permalink
Posted Monday, November 07, 2005
The first side of the LP is the most powerful musical entity which the band has managed to create after the leaving of SYD BARRET. Recorded singing of birds which was experimented on "Ummagumma" reach now their full potential as hypnotic album opener, and the mysterious "Cirrus Minor" emerges from it. I'm totally impressed by their use of simple effects, which create an enormous emotional load on this song. In the end, there is an echo introduced to the singing, which merges it to the raw descending organ backed up with psychedelic sound wall. The following "Nile song" is also great, a powerful rocker resembling the music of JIMI HENDRIX and CREAM. "Crying Song" makes a good contrast for this song, as it is a peaceful acoustic tune. This is followed by the chaotic "Up The Khyber", which is done in the psychedelic freeform style of "Interstellar Overdrive". Two followers "Green is The Colour" and "Cymbaline" are then more structured compositions, and "Cymbaline" is a classic song they used to have long in their concert repertoire.After this I think the album suffers a small inflation, as the following numbers weren't that interesting as the songs on the beginning of the album. But they are not terrible or anything, so I think this makes a four star album as the good parts of it are exceptional. Also as a bonus, the psychedelic album covers are wonderful!
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Eetu Pellonpää
(BETA) | Report this review (#61456) | Review Permalink
Posted Friday, December 23, 2005
Just like "Obscured By Clouds" which I had already reviewed I'll stick only to the songs
since I didn't see the sakename movie that I guess was never released comercially in
Brazil. The album itself was released here in 1973 - the same year I purchased it, and being amidst great PF works made me not to be so much impressed initially. It was tough to compare "More" with "Atom Heart Mother" or "Meddle" and tougher to be concerned about the musicianship that seemed one step behind; even the production was naturally weaker. Only years later I could appreciate better this work (and I liked it).
This album contains three great songs: 'Cymbaline', now a classic piece; 'The Nile song', a heavy and dirty song which reminds me Beatles' 'Helter Skelter' (also a classic); 'Green is the colour', a beautiful ballad. The other songs are not that powerful and they are much more amusing for real PF fans.
Final rating is good but non-essential (unless you're a Floyd fan). Total: 3.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Atkingani
(BETA) | Report this review (#61532) | Review Permalink
Posted Saturday, December 24, 2005
As a soundtrack album, it is a good album, but there are not very interesting songs in this
album. They are more like "background music" which it seems that they composed and
recorded in few days. I read in an interview that they said that it was that way and they
also said that they "earned good money for doing it". So, maybe they were not very much
interested. They simply recorded "background music". But there are some interesting
songs, like "The Nile Song", a heavy song which is the best song from this album, IMO
(despite having not very well played drums by Nick Mason, because, IMO, they lack a bit
of more power and precision) and "Cymbaline", a song they even played in some concerts
in the early `70s.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Guillermo
(BETA) | Report this review (#81782) | Review Permalink
Posted Thursday, June 22, 2006
In the whirlpool of a modest album which is though a classic shout and an hymn in the
fans' heart (Piper), of a truly extraordinary poetry (Saucerful), of
some sincere eccentricity improvisations (Ummagumma) and of a hit in
magnitude's hardness, but also in variety's deafness (Atom), this specific
album is quite trolling out, too simplistic stuff. More generally, More as
also Zabriskie Point have sup-par class, but stay far from incandescent
parfumes. The situation gets relaxing in senseless artifices: the creator effort
isn't shallow, the personal effort doesn't lose but doesn't win (much/too much)
either, preferential effort doesn't get lost out of considering pure brilliant
moments, critic effort can get to a discouragement point. The essential of the
minimalist finesse work derives from the well-known and the over-styled, of already
individual brand Pink Floyd. In positive lines, I recognize in More a fine
album, in a swift musical charge, whose peevish significance has no anti-value
aspect. Nor a contrast jinx. A little thing is to think towards the idea that More was not prepared and presented as a chronology drop or a mental caprice. Looking at all moments, Pink Floyd came with a short collection, but with a mostly present quality. At least for me. Therefore this characterization isn't at all one eased and wired of artistic values and musical frants and can convince, in essence, that caliber exists. Complying in shimmering nuances, the moment is lifting. By ways.
More is minimalist work, with full savor in short concept, perpetuated, allargando movement. Lucid, transparent cause. Characteristic, easy sense. The ease feeling in moments of clutch. The creator reason can immediately drown or, on the contrary, plant in the utter universal concept of soundtracks. A composition pointed by the scenic synchronization, imagination in no diverse text style, a song in the passion of impersonal ideas (without thinking though that the artists betrayed themselves). The miniature album is opaque, but style benefits most in the entire motivic cumuli through unity's clarity (of complete contrast, it sheds down the vane revolutionary - heard things!). I don't know the score. The musical attractiveness gives away two signs: art; chaos. Psychedelic is well suffocating, though it reflects no epic and no grandeur. The line of art and of rock, in tempest, makes just a presence act, standards falling "above" sordid. There appear moments of a slow implosion. Not a chance to say words like ambient, candid, derisorily, of low impact, but the contrast is in dynamics, the stillness move is a prime sensibility and the orphic method of playing druggy looks forward. The frame is sub dimensioned, the images are veiled, distances as frivolous perspective Difficult speech, fooled effect of forgetting, placed in the phonic clear-obscure. The most beautiful method is creating the impression of a seizing drama, in sad atmosphere of flaming smokes and poeticized precocious mind, making out of More an impressive confidence.
Lots of pieces can be brought ahead, in no abstract way whatsoever and without much tempting allure of going remarkable. Cirrus Minor is the finest most representative theme, through a soul weep and a concise spot of torpid frenzyness. The sound attracts, the lyrics sting. Nile Song is a rock "heavy surprise" that "Pow R. Toc H." fans will either abandon as an invention or approach as a fiery tempo. Aggressive, "pissed", in a totally un-elegant rage, but also vapid, color blind. Terribly catchy, still an exaggeration of rupture metaphors. I absolutely dig this song. Crying Son - bit flourish, in a nice illusion style of saying the verse. Cymbaline - ballade in which irony and the verses impulse takes you always to a more interesting conclusion. Or the chorus line is simply of an echo, perhaps even of the surfaced cold in warmth. Main Theme present the first large moment, with general mode of heavy influence, cool drum precipitation, excellence of never-ending suspense, charisma understanding type. The most energic moment of the creative lament has simple ideas in rhythmic fashion and sensation instrumental. Or in the tamped acoustic that flips out. Quicksilver, epic no.2 stays in opposition, in the emotion of so defined impression from More: tragically, loomed evolution, sedentary vanity, somber harmony, ambiguous experimental, persistent sadness. Green ends being the color.
With no epithets, More is the last attitude of the pure psychedelic Floyd. Will follow the lumpy similar miniature, will follow the self-supportive experimental and the original hinted space program rock mood.
More - poetry in slightly less known words, music in slightly less specified manners. From what I've detailed above (self-critic, on some parts I spoke too dramatically), there are valorous moments and short amazements that fully have their way. Soundtracks aren't in the main trend, neither control long enough their tempo (Zabriskie, Obscures and over!); this one remains the most indicated album. Three often pleasant stars. No extra zeal, no emotions, no dementias vision.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Ricochet
(BETA) | Report this review (#103369) | Review Permalink
Posted Sunday, December 17, 2006
Their first album without Syd and a full lenght soundtrack. It was the first album to be
produced by the band as well (exit Norman Smith).
They already did three partial soundtracks during their young career : "'Tonight! Let's
All Make Love in London", "San Francisco", as well as "The Committee" (featuring The
Crazy World Of Arthur Brown). This one included an early version of "Careful with That
Axe, Eugene". Roger would have like the Floyd to make the "Space Odyssey" soundtrack, but they were not selected. They will still create several pieces of music for some European televisions (BBC, etc.) for the coverage of the man landing on the moon (not yet its dark side though...).
I guess that if you have seen the movie (which is not my case) you could relate the music to the movie and appreciate a bit more. The influence of Waters is obvious on this record : there are only two numbers in which he was not involved "Up the Khyber" from Mason & Wright and "A Spanish Piece" from Gilmour (his first Floyd composition on his own).
The opener "Cirrus Minor" is a very spacey track and I guess a great background music for a movie (although I haven't seen it). The first part has very childish and naïve vocals but the second is almost a clone for ASOS ("Celestial Voices" part). It is one of the highlights.
"The Nile Song" is a psychedelic track that could have fit on "Piper" although the shouting vocals are a bit "too much". It was also released as a single (in continental Europe, Japan and ... New Zealand). "Crying Song" and "Green is the Colour" are accoustic ballads of no interest. "Up the Khyber" is a jazzy impro (again Mason's drumming is very similar to the one of "Set The controls..."). That will not be regarded as their greatest tune. Forget this one as well.
"Cymbaline" is the second highlight and will be one of their fave live tracks of the era. Good melody, "trip" oriented, quiet & mellow but nice song with a spacey feeling in the last third part.
"Party Sequence" last for seventy seconds, which is good news.
With "Main Theme", we have a more elaborated song. Quite remininscent of ASOS (the track) in its intro. A bit of Oriental influence (but this is not the first time in early Floyd's work) and good psyche moments make this song one of the best of this album.
"Ibiza Bar" is in the same vein as (actually almost similar) "Nile Song". As all the Floyd members have said, the influence of Syd is obvious on some of their later work. This is the kind of track which confirms this. "More Blues" is as you could have imagined a instrumental bluesy one. Press forward if you have the CD version.
"Quicksilver" could have been a part of the track "A Saucerful". Another good psychedelic moment although it sounds like a "studio improv" with little emotion or feeling. "A Spanish Piece" (sixty five seconds) is a flamenco sort of song from Gilmour. He should have waited a bit more before composing for the Floyd. We would have avoided this one. Skip it by all means. "Dramatic Theme" is a short combined effort of the band (except Mason) but is to be forgotten as soon as you've heard it. Some good tunes (but no memorable ones) and some real weak numbers. Two stars.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to ZowieZiggy
(BETA) | Report this review (#107741) | Review Permalink
Posted Wednesday, January 17, 2007
The first of two official soundtrack albums from the band [not counting Zabriskie Point] recorded in just eight 8-hour sessions. Songs are a mixture of very good like the pastoral Cirrus Minor or Cymbaline, the boring like the jazzed up psych instrumental Up The Khyber, the proto Heavy Metal thrash like The Nile Song, and ethereal psych instrumentals. Often hailed as the best of the band's film music, but in reality More doesn't hold a candle to Obscured By Clouds, unless you are more deeply moved by the purely psych soundscapes.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Joolz
(BETA) | Report this review (#107968) | Review Permalink
Posted Friday, January 19, 2007
First off, I think I am the only here who has actually seen the movie as well, and let's
just say I was thoroughly disappointed with that piece of rubbish caught on film.
However the soundtrack was an amazing musical work and it absolutely demands a
listen. Here's the review: "Cirrus Minor" kick off the album, and the chirping birds here in the parent of the chirping bird effects on "Close To The Edge". This is an excellent psychedelic, vocally captivating song. This song is the first glimpse of the Roger Waters song-writing dictatorship that will come later in the career of the Floyd. "The Nile Song" follows, and everything completely changes. "The Nile Song" is most likely the heaviest song that Pink Floyd ever released, and it surely doesn't disappoint. The lyrics tie right in with the movie, as d the ones from "Ibiza Bar" which is the sister song to this piece. One of Floyd's best ever. Worth buying the album for this song. "Crying Song" is next and it has a very tough act to follow. It's not a bad song, but the way it is placed on the album makes it seem like the original Yes line-up opening up for Dweezil Zappa. They are both great but the second pales in comparison to the first. "Crying Song" does have some very nice vocals, but not much else as there is a severe lack of substance. "Up The Khyber" is viewed by me as an intense drumming piece, which means that unless you want to hear Mason at his finest of the early days there is nothing here for you. "Green Is The Colour" is another song that could easily be considered one of my favorites. Completely on the opposite side of the spectrum from "The Nile Song" and "Ibiza Bar", this is a nice and soft acoustic ballad that is very relaxing and beautiful at the core. "Cymbaline" is the high point of the album, without a doubt. It surpasses "The Nile Song" in terms of creativity and complexity, and it will always have a warm spot in my heart as it was one of the first songs I ever learned how to play on guitar. Excellent piece of music with some of the finest vocals of the Floyd's career. The album starts to slip off of its 5-star perch after this, as "Party Sequence" and "Main Theme" breeze by shortly and unnoticed, as they contain virtually no musical aspects. "Ibiza Bar" is the sister song to "The Nile Song" and is again, some of the heaviest work released. A wonderful song, it is sadly the only listenable piece on this half of the album. "More Blues" is exactly that. More blues. Another song to skip, in my opinion. "Quicksilver" is regarded highly by everyone here and I must say although I don't like it, I really do appreciate the musicianship with all of the percussion work and it is true that it could fit in "Saucerful of Secrets". "A Spanish Piece" and "Dramatic Theme" end the album in a poor manner, with the two worst songs on the album, in my opinion.
So, what began as a perfect 5 star album became a mess of average work in the end because of a lazy second side. However, as I have already said, this is worth being bought so you can hear Floyd at their heaviest, as well as for the beautiful "Green Is The Colour" and "Cymbaline". 4 stars, an excellent diverse album.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Chris H
(BETA) | Report this review (#108255) | Review Permalink
Posted Sunday, January 21, 2007
When MORE came out, apparently Rolling Stone (the American music rag) ravaged it completely. Oh dear! When did Rolling Stone
ever sympathize with prog? Seriously, though, MORE may not be prime Pink Floyd, but it's far from forgettable. Its ghostly
instrumentals (such as "Main Theme" and "Dramatic Theme") are certainly more atmospheric than Mason and Wright's dire
contributions to UMMAGUMMA's studio part. "The Nile Song" is notable as the only Floyd song that foreshadowed Nirvana. And the
sleepy, ballad-like songs on this album have a lot of charm. You just shouldn't expect to be bowled over straightaway. Play MORE a
dozen times or so, and I bet you'll admit that "Crying Song" and "Green is the colour" are rather beautiful. The treacherously
pastoral "Cirrus Minor", with its insistent organ accompaniment, might even be one of my favourite Floyd pieces! Now be a darling
and pass the bottle of Chianti...
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to fuxi
(BETA) | Report this review (#130937) | Review Permalink
Posted Tuesday, July 31, 2007
More was Pink Floyd's first venture into scoring music for films, this one by Barbet Schroeder. Like most soundtracks, a good deal of the music was especially designed to back visual elements and thus by themselves are not a very entertaining audio experience without the video. This holds very true for More with songs having titles like Main Theme, Spanish Piece, and Dramatic Theme. However, the soundtrack isn't entirely made of tracks like this. Some of them stand out on their own, including Nile Song (the only noteworthy song that would appear on later compilations) and Cymbaline (my favorite piece on the album).There isn't anything particularly worthwhile to cause one to need this album. Many of the songs are simply ordinary to just plain boring, although this material was quite a departure from Piper at the Gates of Dawn and A Saucerful of Secrets. I'm guessing since this was a soundtrack, many have considered this not to be an "official" studio album, even though the soundtrack was exclusively Pink Floyd. Regardless of how it is classified in the grand scheme of things, it pales in comparison to the rest of the band's catalogue. Recommended for Pink Floyd fans, not worthwhile for anyone else. Two stars.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to progaardvark
(BETA) | Report this review (#132076) | Review Permalink
Posted Monday, August 06, 2007
BoreThis is an early soundtrack album by "The Pink Floyd", as they were then better known. It was the first of two films by director Barbet Schroeder they would provide music for. While their reimbursement for their efforts may seem meagre even by 1969 standards (£600), they had the good sense to retain full ownership of the rights to the music. The film was not exactly a blockbuster, and even fell foul of the censors in the UK where the sex scenes had to be cleaned up prior to gaining an 18 certificate. The album is significant in the Pink Floyd time line, as it was the first of the post Barrett releases.
The first two tracks will be familiar to most fans, as they were included in the "Relics" collection. We open with "Cirrus minor", a lovely soft song, with Waters favoured descending melody. Suddenly as the track fades, we are blown away by Pink Floyd's heaviest and loudest song ever. "The Nile song" is a superb cacophony of wailing guitars, screams and rough vocals set to a backdrop of a wall of sound.
In truth, these two songs represent the best of what of on offer here, the remaining tracks generally sounding like they were written specifically for a soundtrack. That said, this is a very diverse album, and as such does not really feel like a Pink Floyd release. There are some pretty tunes and nice sounds, but they are generally dull and uninspiring.
The song writing credits show that all but one of the seven tracks on side one are Roger Waters compositions (one, "Up the Khyber", with Nick Mason). The final track on side one "Party sequence" and all but one on the second side are band compositions, the sole exception being David Gilmour's (or Gilmore as he was credited in the film titles) "A Spanish piece". Roughly half of the tracks are instrumentals, some of which are jazzy link pieces of little substance. "Main theme" is interesting for the keyboard sounds Rick adds, as they sound very synthesiser like, but predate the commercial availability of that instrument.
In all, not a Pink Floyd album to get excited about. If you have "Relics", you have the best of what's on offer here anyway.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Easy Livin
(BETA) | Report this review (#133219) | Review Permalink
Posted Wednesday, August 15, 2007
PINK FLOYD's first OST album, 'More' is inconsequential, typical of the immediate post-BARRETT period in indulging in
soundscapes bereft of musical merit.'More' is a very slight album, a quickly-generated filler between 'proper' PINK FLOYD studio album releases, with little of merit to recommend it. In the first two tracks, however, there is more substance than either the previous studio album or the one to follow. 'Cirrus Minor' is a gentle opener, comprising an interesting and sadly under-exploited chord progression, leading in to an enormously heavy GILMOUR-guitar-driven 'Nile Song'. The contrast could not be greater. This raises interest, only for the album to drift away into a sequence of largely indistinguishable soundtrack noodling.
Again, an album for completionists, with the first two tracks and the 'Crying Song' lifting it to two stars.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to russellk
(BETA) | Report this review (#149619) | Review Permalink
Posted Thursday, November 08, 2007
I really liked their other soundtrack record "Obscured By Clouds" but i like this one even "more".Haha.I think one of the problems a
lot of people have with this is the variety of musical styles employed.Personally i really like the diversity.This is the first PINK FLOYD
album without Syd participating in.
"Cirrus Minor" features mono toned vocals as the sounds of birds chirping can be heard throughout.Acoustic guitar and synth-like
sounds wash in and out before some excellent organ replaces the vocals 3 minutes in. "Nice Song" is a real rocker, and the complete
opposite of the first song.It's loud with yelling vocals.Gilmour fires off some blistering melodies. "Crying Song" is a mellow track that
i'm not too fond of. "Up The Khyber" opens with drums that build as piano joins in.The organ comes in before 1 1/2 minutes.I love
this track because it has such a jazz flavour to it. "Green Is The Colour" features strummed acoustic guitar and fragile vocals.Flute-
like melodies come and go.Piano after 2 minutes.Nice song. "Cymbaline" is another mellow song with light drums,piano and guitar
leading the instrumentally.I really like the vocals on the chorus as they soar.Some cool vocal melodies before some fantastic
sounding organ comes in late. "Party Sequence" has an Middle Eastern flavour with the relentless percussion and flute-like
sounds. "Main Theme" is great, with the waves of spacey sounds and the dark sounding organ.Drums arrive after a minute, followed
by keys a minute after that.Excellent track. "Ibiza Bar" is similar to "Nice Song" but not quite as aggressive.I really like the "not so
loud" parts a lot.Gilmour rips it up with some raw sounding melodies. "More Blues" has some blues styled guitar throughout.The drums
come and go. "Quicksilver" is an experimental song not unlike their "Saucerful Of Secrets" song from the previous album of the same
name.It opens with strange sounds as a dark and haunting atmosphere takes over.Organ 3 minutes in.This could have been
on "Heresie" it's so dark and slow moving. "Spanish Piece" is exactly that,spanish guitar with someone speaking. "Dramatic Theme" is
all about the percussion and crying guitar sounds.
I can understand why a lot of people feel this is one of FLOYD's worst records.There are arguments to be made for that,but i can
also see why some feel this is one of their best albums.This record excites me because of some of the styles of music they play that i
really like.It actually took me a while to get used to "Nice Song" because it comes off as being so loud compared to the rest,but i
really appreciate it now.If variety is the spice of life,then this is one spicy record.Enjoy.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to sinkadotentree
(BETA) | Report this review (#152159) | Review Permalink
Posted Wednesday, November 21, 2007
I have always held this 'Official Sound-Track' in high regard. It's definately not one of Floyd's best, though aptly displays the band's
willingness to experiment (as most early Floyd albums do) and offers some great contrasts - being music to a film, the songs cover
many different styles and moods. Film soundtracks seem to allow certain freedoms to the musicians recording them, of course,
that's within the confines of what is featured in the film and its script - infinite possibilities through creative brainstorming can yield
some fairly original work, as opposed to a band's, perhaps, more focused approach to an album proper (not to say that proper
albums aren't as experimental), it's just that the inspiration is totally different and can present the composer(s) with something of a
challenge, one that connects the audio with the visual successfully. Now (after that rather (wishful) philosophical observation) onto
the songs. Opening with twittering bird-song, 'Cirrus Minor' takes us on a tranquil journey through softly sung verses backed with acoustic guitars and subtle organ washes, only to finish with an almost hymn-like passage where keyboardist Rick Wright immerses himself in a day-dream on his Farfisa organ. A very beautiful song for sure. 'The Nile Song' is quite a heavy song, heavy for Floyd, and heavy for the time, too. It's built on a repeating riff, which constantly ascends after each verse, searing acid-guitar from David Gilmour being the highlight, his harsh vocal delivery not. 'The Crying Song' is again a soft, acoustic song with some tinkling vibes and a brief electric guitar solo at the end. Pleasantly mysterious. 'Up The Khyber' is an avant-garde, psychedelic track with a great drum rhythm from Nick Mason which carries Wright's angular piano notes into the very trippy organ solo which ends the piece. Great stuff !! 'Green Is The Colour' is a live classic (always segued into Careful With that Axe, Eugene), but here remains a largely acoustic song with soft, falsetto vocals from Gilmour, some playful piccolo and more piano and organ work. 'Cymbaline' is another classic, especially live, sung by Dave and really has a great groove to it, with quite hypnotic Farfisa work - a trait that dominates this album, and a sound I admire a lot. 'Party Sequence' is a little hand percussion arrangement with piccolo soloing.
Second side features the dynamic, spacey 'Main Theme', a tune which conjures up images of intrigue and mystery, a great bass-line from Roger Waters, some spacious lead guitaring and melodic organ lines. 'Ibiza Bar' is very similar to 'The Nile Song', without the ascending verses. 'More Blues' is a simple 12 bar instrumental tune, but the occasional interjections of Mason's drumming makes it a little more interesting. 'Quicksilver' is the long track, its purpose being atmospheric (almost KRAUTROCK) and, although many find this piece meandering and pointless, I believe it reflects PF's unique approach to experimenting - given that it features just shimmering (aah, I didn't want to use that word) organ and a good dose of (possibly) Waters hitting his gong, it sounds 'full' and is quality space-music. 'A Spanish Piece' is a brief song with flamenco-styled guitaring, seldom heard in Floyd ('High Hopes' middle section comes to mind), and some Spanish accented mumbling. 'Dramatic Theme' is a variation of 'Main Theme' with a 'brighter' sound. Great drumming from Mason. 4.5 stars.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Tom Ozric
(BETA) | Report this review (#152778) | Review Permalink
Posted Monday, November 26, 2007
No more please...Seemingly the one hiccup of early Floyd, this album was basically thrown together and it definitely sounds like it. There's even rumor that some of the band members themselves want it omitted from their discography. This one finds the band at a weird stage in life, being that this is the first album done entirely without Mr. Barrett at the helm forcing the other members to step up like their last album (the great Saucerful of Secrets). The album is not entirely without merit, but it does lose the audience's attention after about the first side. There's some repeated material (this is likely due to the fact that it's a soundtrack), some very boring material, but some good material as well. After this album it's a surprise that the next soundtrack that they would do would actually be very very good.
As previously stated, the first side is actually quite good. Cirrus Minor opens the album gracefully in a very Floydian manner while The Nile Song quickly pushes it out of the way and proceeds to rock for a bit, showcasing Gilmour as a good hard rock vocalist, albeit for only a minute. Up The Khyber is fairly forgettable, but that's okay because the A side is about to close on a very high note. Green Is The Color is actually a fairly fantastic song, as is Cymbaline. Both fairly odd for the Floyd being that they are fairly modest in structure and has a fairly basic layout. They're performed quite well, however, and that makes them very good songs able to compete with some of Floyd's classics.
The B side is where it all goes to hell on this one. There's no tracks really worth mentioning since they're all mostly quiet, instrumental and they all run together (in a bad way) to make some kind of song-stew that's not really that great. Ibiza Bar is basically a repeat of The Nile Song, or maybe it's just part II of the song, but either way it's fairly weird to listen to the same song twice. Quicksilver is the longest song on the album (and has, arguably, the coolest title), but once again it's fairly unremarkable and doesn't really go anywhere, unlike Floyd's usual inspired instrumental tunes. Maybe there's some great moments on Side B, but since it's hard to keep the attention span going over these tunes they're likely going to be missed.
Ending statement!
A blip in the Floyd's career. Best avoided, but since side A actually borders on excellent it's still recommend it to fans and collectors. Everyone else should just try and find the better tracks on a compilation. 2 stars. There's so much better stuff under every category of Floyd's music.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to King By-Tor
(BETA) | Report this review (#159787) | Review Permalink
Posted Friday, January 25, 2008
Effective soundtrack by my favourite band - Pink Floyd! The first album without the involvement of the previous leader of
the band - Syd Barrett is definitely little weaker than both of two albums before it - The Piper at the Gates of Dawn and A
Saucerful of Secrets (one of my favourite). These are troubled times for Pink Floyd because of the quit of Syd Barrett
related with mental problems,but even though Pink Floyd are better than thousands of bands. Their unique style is again
wonderful combined with experimentation. The structure of the album is different,but it's normal for a soundtrack. There are
a couple of superb songs and variety of genres from hard rock to blues,and of course psychedelic and progressive rock.4
stars.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to poslednijat_colobar
(BETA) | Report this review (#185115) | Review Permalink
Posted Thursday, October 09, 2008
A short break for some film work Stylistically, and over-generalizing of course, there are fans who think "the good Pink Floyd" started with the Meddle album. And, in lesser numbers but just as passionate, there are some fans who would say "the good Floyd" ended with the release of Meddle. Ok, so a third group exists, those like myself who pretty much love all of the Floyd albums, in my case I enjoy all of the legitimate albums released through "The Final Cut." Although I sympathize with the fans of the early work particularly, because it is disheartening to read the disrespectful and occasionally ignorant comments of listeners and band members alike regarding the early work. For the albums from the debut Piper through Atom Heart Mother represent a truly amazing body of work-they are the true essence of the experimental, progressive Pink Floyd. The Floyd that still dabbled and searched, the Floyd who were willing to work as a four person unit (with pleasure) and try things very unsafe to their brand name. Beginning with the mediocre Meddle album (their weakest proper album until AMLoR) and throughout the '70s the brand name would take over a bit and the truly avant-garde moments would become rare, even while the music itself became more palatable to the accumulating fans and thus more commercially successful. Ironically, as the fan base was swelling in the 70s, music writers were beginning to mourn the loss of the experimental/progressive Floyd as they became stadium rock-a fact not lost on Waters as he melted down during the Animals tour. As a listener I find the early work as important and enjoyable as the later work but in a different way. It was the Floyd at their most "interstellar" to pick an appropriate adjective and there's nothing wrong with that! The biggest mistake made is by those who don't consider this early work progressive but write it off as psychedelic musings only-it most surely was progressive music. The band members scoffed at the label of "British Psychedelia" by '69 and considered themselves serious musicians, not pop personalities. While common knowledge loves to credit Crimson with everything short of man's creation, the Floyd were right there with them regardless of the label you wish to apply.
In the Spring of '69 the Floyd very quickly recorded the music for the Barbet Schroeder film "More." Schroeder was a fan of the band and wanted their music in his counterculture film about the misadventures of a young couple. He was looking for more than just standard background soundtrack and wanted songs that integrated into and out of the actual scenes, music the characters would be listening to or encountering. The band were shown the film which was already completed and agreed to the rather high-pressure project, which they later knocked but admitted the experience was useful in building their working skills. Schroeder was stunned with the speed at which the Floyd were able to generate the ideas and get them recorded-the band members themselves were not interested in abandoning rock and roll but saw the practice of making film music as a potential gig to fall back on if they failed in their main quest. Remember, at this point the full potential of the group was far from certain, many thought they would collapse without Barrett's songwriting talents. The film came out in May of '69 and did not do well but the Floyd's soundtrack actually did crack the top 10 shortly thereafter. Even in this early period between Saucerful and Ummagumma it was Roger who was beginning to morph into the leader of the group. "I took responsibility in the Floyd because nobody else seemed to want to do it" he stated. "They'd no f___ing idea what the band was for." As '69 moved on they would now begin a period of live activity that would see them reach their experimental height attempting some fairly crazy live sound histrionics.
Like much of their early catalog, "More" has become far more interesting to me now that I've grown as a listener beyond the more easier-listening 70s albums. Once your brain has every note of WYWH and DSotM committed to memory you almost don't need to play them any more. The prog portion of your brain still likes Floyd of course but sends you cravings to start listening to their more challenging material. It is in this phase of life where the beauty of a daydream like "More" can be appreciated in the way that today's predictable corporate prog cannot. Subtle ideas casually played with and dropped, atmosphere, and a general disenchantment for the ways of the world?.the last no doubt an element of the film itself. It all uncoils to draw the listener into a hazy state where the band's still-developing talents take full advantage. Not every idea had to be this all-inclusive song which followed a formula to satisfy the fan?rather the band could simply indulge themselves and drop an idea as quickly as they picked it up. Some reviewers call this approach "fragmented" and perhaps that is valid, but it could also be thrilling-the idea that not every album of music had to be this quantifiable product. The 60s and early 70s provide many examples of what rock music lost as expectations changed among fans, labels, and musicians. Beginning with bird sounds "Cirrus Minor" sounds a bit like "Granchester Meadows" and Roger confirms the track is based on little bits of Cambridge memory. A truly haunting piece of music with the stark vocals and thin acoustic guitar draped in Wright's ceremonious, beautiful background. Rick and Nick were every bit the full contributors at this time which lends the sound extra intimacy. Along with Cirrus the album features early stellar highlights "Crying Song," "Green is the Colour," and "Cymbaline." (I have read a claim or two that Barrett's recorded playing was used in Crying Song but I've never seen anything confirming that and believe it to be false.) Crying Song features a pleasant if cheeky vocal by Roger and a nice guitar lead by Dave, both of which have that certain Floyd familiarity to them?if you listen close I believe you hear the earliest typical sounding Floydisms throughout More. Roger's lyrical growth process was slow but there are a few lines that hint at things to come. (Years later he would bristle at Rick's interview comments from this period playing down the importance of lyrics, another example of diverging views quite early in the game.) Green and Cymbaline were often performed live in much greater length, both songs here are sadly brief but have the most joyous, intoxicating effect to them. Many fans have commented that More is one of the best stoner albums around but among the Floyd's many talents were the ability to simulate a drug experience by the nature of their sound-with no chemicals needed. Often throughout More there is a catatonic, hazy feeling that envelops the listening, perfectly coaxed along by those laid back vocals, Wright's loose piano tinkling here and there, and Mason's drumming which can sound like the flailing of a drowning man. This same feeling permeates their second "daydream" album of soundtrack music, the lovely and equally overlooked "Obscured by Clouds" from a few years later. The duds here in my view are the heavier throwaways "Nile Song" and "Ibiza Bar" which find the band out of their element and unconvincing. Much of the rest of the album consist of occasionally interesting, occasionally quite patchy instrumental work that sounds more like typical soundtrack work while hinting at where they would go on the next project "Ummagumma." Not perfect, but interesting and enjoyable in the context.
"More" is certainly no masterpiece but at least half of the album is truly beautiful stuff and for an album made in just over a week, it is nothing to be ashamed of. Be sure to get the '95 remaster here for improved sound, as well as a booklet full of gorgeous stills from the film, including some provocative shots of the lovely actress Mimsy Farmer. Not an essential album but recommended for all Floyd fans who wish to experience the bridge albums that connected their best pre-Dark Side works Piper and Atom Heart Mother.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Finnforest
(BETA) | Report this review (#219189) | Review Permalink
Posted Sunday, May 31, 2009
More is the third full-length studio album by UK progressive/ psychadelic rock act
Pink Floyd. The album is a soundtrack to the film More by Barbet
Schroeder. More was recorded at Pye Studios in London during March of
1969 and released through EMI on the 27th of July 1969. The album was produced by
the band themselves.The music is a mix of mellow folky pop/ rock songs, hard rock songs and some experimental psychadelic songs. The two hard rock songs Nile Song and Ibiza Bar brings much needed variation into an otherwise mellow, atmospheric and phychadelic album IMO. The former is a classic in my ears. I enjoy the mellow ballad type folk songs too but as always with the early psychadelic songs by the band, I´m not overthrilled. Songs like Main Theme and Quicksilver are a bit too repetitive and stoned for my taste.
The production is a bit muddy but charming and enjoyable.
More is one of my least favorite albums by Pink Floyd but it´s still a good album with many enjoyable moments fully deserving a 3.5 star rating ( I guess it says something about the extremely high standard of the rest of the bands discography that the rating is so high).
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to UMUR
(BETA) | Report this review (#226623) | Review Permalink
Posted Tuesday, July 14, 2009
I've always liked More very much. Of course it's true that a lot of the tracks are rather plain rock
songs and ballads (but so is Wish you were and everybody seems to like that one).The tracks on More actually fit together very well and create a consistently dreamy and captivating mood throughout the album. Next to that general vibe there are some really strong cuts here as well: the dazzling Cirrus Minor and the entrancing instrumentals Main Theme and Dramatic Theme which are vintage Pink Floyd and rate among their best output from the 60's. Even the hard rocking blues of Nile Song is very enjoyable and a welcome change to the seriousness of regular Pink Floyd songs.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Send comments to Bonnek
(BETA) | Report this review (#236830) | Review Permalink
Posted Thursday, September 03, 2009
More is one of my alltime favourites. It is by no means their best effort, but it still resonates as
a well crafted movie soundtrack that is 10 times better than the picture itself, which fits the
hippie stereotype like a well oiled thermometer up your bum. Stick with the music, if you want an
ad
... (read more)
Report this review (#250944) | Posted by Guldbamsen | Monday, November 16, 2009 | Review Permanlink
I am not a big fan of earlier PF works. This soundtrack isn't something special as well. In fact,
you can feel, that it is soundrack all the time: it's a collection of songs, very different in style,
often with strange ending, with some heavy psyhedelic ( and not very musical) pieces in
betwee
... (read more)
Report this review (#248228) | Posted by snobb | Thursday, November 05, 2009 | Review Permanlink
Ater 140 reviews everything was said about More and its low status in the Pink Floyd body of work,
right?
Well, I believe I can add another perspective to this judgement.
To evaluate "More" in its own terms you must listen to the boolegs from the 1969-1971 period,
specially 1969 when the inf
... (read more)
Report this review (#230870) | Posted by moodyxadi | Monday, August 10, 2009 | Review Permanlink
SIMPLICITY is the key word to this album. It has nothing of the ambitious, dramatic sound Floyd is
famous for. This distinction is certainly due to the fact that this is a soundtrack, and not a
regular studio album. Therefore, More has a different, particular feel, yet with an immediately
recogni
... (read more)
Report this review (#225993) | Posted by bfmuller | Saturday, July 11, 2009 | Review Permanlink
I say 3 stars for More. Good, but non-essential.
In fact, the album isn't that progressive. It is in some parts, but it really has a varied sound. It
can go from really slow stoner kind've rock, to hard rock, to simple ballads, to funky and
experimental instrumentals. It's nowhere near a class
... (read more)
Report this review (#197421) | Posted by HammerOfPink | Monday, January 05, 2009 | Review Permanlink
This is a period of Pink Floyd when they've lost the psychedelic impulse, and they are not yet
progressive enough. They are in between.
And thus, most songs are dull and forgottable, they can only serve as a soundtrack. The better ones
are: Cirrus Minor and Crying song show a bit of Waters' later
... (read more)
Report this review (#179494) | Posted by klvin | Wednesday, August 13, 2008 | Review Permanlink
Pink Floyd - More: 50%
This is early Pink Floyd not at their best, but working their way there. On this album Pink Floyd displays more of their
psychedelic side as they no longer have Syd Barret. You can hear hints of what is to come in later albums through it. As I
listened to it I noticed
... (read more)
Report this review (#177055) | Posted by Onslaught | Thursday, July 17, 2008 | Review Permanlink
Pink Floyd's soundtrack from the Barbet Schroeder movie 'More' (a masterpiece) is one of their best
albums ever, and one of their strangest - because it's not a real album, but a soundtrack, of course. Here,
you can hear a pre-grunge song (The Nile Song), a hard-rocker (Ibiza Bar, performed by G
... (read more)
Report this review (#164819) | Posted by Zardoz | Monday, March 24, 2008 | Review Permanlink
This is an highly underrated album. The first side of Meddle, the second of Atom Heart Mother and the
whole of Obscured by Clouds just can't compete. Here you get a good range of styles like the Bucolic
(Cirrus Minor), Hard Rock (The Nile Song, Ibiza Bar), Modern Jazz (Up the Khyber), Pop tunes
... (read more)
Report this review (#163039) | Posted by strayfromatlantis | Sunday, March 02, 2008 | Review Permanlink
Floyd did this album as an unofficial soundtrack for the french movie More, and as a result, the material is a little patchy.
This is easily the most inconsistent album in Floyd's discography (even a momentary lapse and Division bell are consistent:
consistently bad). There are a few songs worth m
... (read more)
Report this review (#154508) | Posted by The Ace Face | Thursday, December 06, 2007 | Review Permanlink
The first band I had completed an official discography for (back in the days when I did that kind of thing) was Pink Floyd. The
reason for this is that this is really the first band that so intrigued me that I needed to scoop up everything they had produced. I
must admit, it has been a number
... (read more)
Report this review (#150991) | Posted by LARKSTONGUE | Thursday, November 15, 2007 | Review Permanlink
Many people consider to a this disc that has a lack and that only is for collectors, but I
consider that it is an excellent piece of work of the band, the first disc in where no longer
appears the today legend Syd BARRETT, the clear influence of the same one in this disc
notices and at moments
... (read more)
Report this review (#111575) | Posted by Shelket | Saturday, February 10, 2007 | Review Permanlink
Did you watch the film? It's not very good. But the soundtrack is listenable. Strange
thing. Floyd recorded only two studio albums, and some dude wants them on a film
soundtrack. There are very good songs here like Cymbaline, good songs like Nile Song,
funny songs like A Spaish Piece, and film mo
... (read more)
Report this review (#109161) | Posted by Deepslumber | Saturday, January 27, 2007 | Review Permanlink
I want more More!
4.5 stars- Favorite of the first three albums.
More is Pink Floyd's first album since Syd has left and we see a new band full of ideas
and indiviuality. With plenty of expectations from fans of both the remaining members
as well as Syd, Pink Floyd set out to do what they
... (read more)
Report this review (#80729) | Posted by Rust | Thursday, June 08, 2006 | Review Permanlink
a sadly disjointed album. But that can be tolerated, as I said in the "Momentary Lapse of
Reason" review, you can't expect the music to stay the same if you lose the leading band
member. For that, the album can't be taken to harshly.
Reviewing this album 35 years and many albums later, thi
... (read more)
Report this review (#79121) | Posted by echoes2112 | Tuesday, May 23, 2006 | Review Permanlink
I own all of PF's albums as does most muscis enthusiasts and I can't believe there are
reviewers out there giving this album any less than 4 stars. From the first song to the last
it is an amazing album. It may not be as ground breaking or apocalyptic as Dark Side, Wish
You Were Here, or Meddl
... (read more)
Report this review (#77958) | Posted by LouLoo | Friday, May 12, 2006 | Review Permanlink
If someone decided to listen to all the Floyd albums in a row I would recommend
blasting 'The Nile Song' on full volume between albums just to make sure you are still
alive. Of course most people that will listen to More won't like 'The Nile Song' since
it's too energetic for the average stone
... (read more)
Report this review (#62539) | Posted by | Saturday, December 31, 2005 | Review Permanlink
It's hard for me to review this album, because I didn't like it when I bought it sometime
in 1997, and now I want to listen to some of the new stuff I have, and not to come back
to this album. Another thing I have to say - I haven't seen the movie, so I can only
review the music as an album an
... (read more)
Report this review (#60388) | Posted by Baza | Thursday, December 15, 2005 | Review Permanlink
This is about as un-floyd as the band gets. By this I mean this sounds nothing like
any of the floyd periods ( Barret, "REAL FLOYD", Post-Waters). Considering they
had one weeks time they did OK, for such a rushed schedule. But the songs are
mostly bad. It sounds a bit like Saucerful of Secret
... (read more)
Report this review (#56781) | Posted by Howard the Duck | Thursday, November 17, 2005 | Review Permanlink
The first thing you have to remember is that this is a film soundtrack and not a normal
album release for the Pink Floyd. Nick Mason was in his prime at this stage in the band's
career. On this album he uses pounding bass and snare, tom-toms, bongos, jazz
rhythms and hypnotic tribal beats. Dav
... (read more)
Report this review (#55661) | Posted by Marquês_Prög | Wednesday, November 09, 2005 | Review Permanlink
You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.
As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.
You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).
Copyright © Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise
| GeoIP Services by MaxMind