Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography

THE DECEMBERISTS

Prog Folk • United States


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

The Decemberists picture
The Decemberists biography
Founded in Portland, USA, in 2000

The Decemberists are a sometimes-quintet hailing from Portland, Oregon and currently signed to the Capitol Records label. While often referred to as an indie band, they have evolved over their seven years of existence into a group that delivers passionate, ambitious, and sophisticated story-centered music that both incorporates and transcends a number of styles and apparent influences. The band has established a reputation for eclectic and wildly unconventional arrangements, lively and interactive concerts, and unusual lyrical themes that sometimes border on the bizarre.

Band founder Colin MELOY was born and reared in the rustic and rugged northwestern hamlet of Helena, Montana (USA), and began his musical career as singer/songwriter for the alternative-country bands HAPPY CACTUS and TARKIO before resettling in Portland to form the DECEMBERISTS. Meloy has also toured as a solo act promoting his personal recordings of Morrissey covers, as well as a heavily folk-driven album of Shirley Collins standards.

The band's first offering was the self-released '5 Songs' in 2001, actually a six-track EP which included several songs referencing local Montana historical sites and events, as well as the whimsical ditty "My Mother Was A Chinese Trapeze Artist" written in response to pressure from his parents to abandon music for a more reliable and respected career. This was followed by their first full length album 'Castaways and Cutouts', which was packed with character sketches and period pieces with references ranging from the Nazi concentration camps of Birkenau to ghosts of stillborn infants, to homeless people in love to a mother-turned-prostitute trying to feed her children. The sympathetic glimpses of the human Struggle and unconventional instrumentation are reminiscent of bands like VIOLENT FEMMES or an unpretentious version of NEUTRAL MILK HOTEL.

Their next album 'Her Majesty the Decemberists' began a gravitation toward nautical themes possibly influenced by the band's settling in the coastal town of Portland, Oregon. In addition to what were by now becoming almost obligatory odd character sketches such as the story of a chimney sweep (a desperate wedded couple; gymnast; and a bumbling soldier) were a number of historical tales centered around the American poet Myla Goldberg, as well as the British frigate HMS Arethusa. The album also includes Meloy's passionate life-affirmation "I Was Meant for...
read more

THE DECEMBERISTS forum topics / tours, shows & news


THE DECEMBERISTS forum topics Create a topic now
THE DECEMBERISTS tours, shows & news Post an entries now

THE DECEMBERISTS Videos (YouTube and more)


Showing only random 3 | Show all THE DECEMBERISTS videos (2) | Search and add more videos to THE DECEMBERISTS

Buy THE DECEMBERISTS Music


Tain/5 Songs [Vinyl]Tain/5 Songs [Vinyl]
Jealous Butcher 2004
$22.98
$87.31 (used)
Right Now on Ebay (logo)
THE DECEMBERISTS The Hazards Of Love 2009 UK 17-track watermarked promo CD USD $6.60 Buy It Now
The Decemberists-I`Ll Be Your Girl (UK IMPORT) CD NEW USD $11.84 Buy It Now 36m 8s
The Decemberists-I Ll Be Your Girl (UK IMPORT) VINYL NEW USD $27.35 Buy It Now 36m 10s
THE DECEMBERISTS THE KING IS DEAD SEALED CD NEW 2011 USD $5.24 Buy It Now 6h 43m
We All Raise Our Voices to the Air: Live Songs 04.11.08 by The Decemberists... USD $29.49 Buy It Now 6h 47m
The Decemberists THE HAZARDS OF LOVE Gatefold CAPITOL RECORDS New Vinyl 2 LP USD $29.99 Buy It Now 7h 41m
Gang of 4, Death Cab For Cutie, Decemberists, Editors cd factory sealed USD $9.95 Buy It Now 9h 41m
DECEMBERISTS-FLORASONGS VINYL LP NEW USD $21.48 Buy It Now 9h 43m
DECEMBERISTS-LONG LIVE THE KING VINYL LP NEW USD $21.62 Buy It Now 9h 44m
Decemberists : Tain CD USD $6.98 Buy It Now 9h 58m
THE DECEMBERISTS We All Raise Our Voices To The Air CD Live 2012 2 CDS USD $7.99 Buy It Now 11h 2m
THE DECEMBERISTS - WHAT A TERRIBLE WORLD WHT A BEAUTIFUL WORLD LP EX USD $15.00 Buy It Now 11h 34m
Decemberists - I'll Be Your Girl LP NEW INDIE EXCLUSIVE USD $26.99 Buy It Now 11h 36m
Long Live the King [EP] by The Decemberists (CD,2011)NEW~ free ship US! USD $7.19 Buy It Now 11h 50m
The Decemberists - The Hazards of Love (2009 CD Indie Rock) USD $5.19 Buy It Now 16h 58m
THE DECEMBERISTS - FLORASONGS - 10" VINYL - NEW USD $32.43 Buy It Now 17h 32m
THE DECEMBERISTS - FLORASONGS - 10" VINYL - NEW USD $30.46 Buy It Now 18h
THE DECEMBERISTS - FLORASONGS - 10" VINYL - NEW USD $28.50 Buy It Now 18h 7m
DECEMBERISTS : I'LL BE YOUR GIRL (LP Vinyl) USD $32.80 Buy It Now 18h 38m
The Decemberists - The Hazards Of Love (NEW CD) USD $9.91 Buy It Now 22h 16m
The Decemberists - The Crane Wife US 2LP 2006 FOC /3* USD $25.42 Buy It Now 23h 59m
DECEMBERISTS : I'LL BE YOUR GIRL -COLOURED (LP Vinyl) USD $32.80 Buy It Now 1 day
The Decemberists - The Tain Colin Meloy Chris Walla Kill Rock Stars Indie USD $7.99 Buy It Now 1 day
THE DECEMBERISTS hand signed cd booklet ILL BE YOUR GIRL autographed colin meloy USD $26.99 Buy It Now 1 day
DECEMBERISTS, The - I'll Be Your Girl - Vinyl (LP) USD $29.37 Buy It Now 1 day
The Decemberists I'LL BE YOUR GIRL 8th Album NEW YELLOW COLORED CASSETTE TAPE USD $9.99 Buy It Now 1 day
The Crane Wife [LP] by Decemberists (The) (Vinyl, Oct-2010, Capitol/EMI Records) USD $10.00 [1 bids]
1 day
The Crane Wife by The Decemberists USD $1.78 Buy It Now 1 day
NEW LOT OF 30 CD'S: THE DECEMBERISTS - FLORASONGS (EP) NEW SEALED!! USD $19.98 Buy It Now 1 day
Black Prairie Fortune LP Decemberists USD $22.48 Buy It Now 1 day
The Decemberists - Make You Better [New Vinyl] Canada - Import USD $7.98 Buy It Now 1 day
The Decemberists - Make You Better [New Vinyl] Canada - Import USD $9.01 Buy It Now 1 day
The Decemberists Cavalry Captain ROUGH TRADE Promo CDr Single USD $19.12 [0 bids]
1 day
Decemberists - Florasongs LP [Vinyl New] 10" EP Extra Songs What A Terrible... USD $19.98 Buy It Now 1 day
DECEMBERISTS - I'll Be Your Girl LP New SEALED indie excl. colored vinyl USD $25.99 Buy It Now 1 day
The King Is Dead [Digipak] by The Decemberists (CD, Jan-2011, Consolidated Arti USD $3.99 Buy It Now 1 day
THE DECEMBERISTS | The Tain / 5 Songs EP | Blue White Vinyl | Unplayed USD $57.13 Buy It Now 1 day
The Decemberists Picaresque 2x Vinyl LP Record indie rock album!!! NEW USD $33.59 Buy It Now 1 day
The Decemberists-The Hazards of Love (UK IMPORT) CD NEW USD $9.77 Buy It Now 1 day
The Decemberists Live At Bull Moose Record Store Day Sealed CD RSD Meloy USD $15.99 Buy It Now 1 day
LOT 16 Indie Rock CDs Decemberists White Stripes Sloan Spoon Fratellis Vampire USD $10.00 [1 bids]
1 day
Colin Meloy Rare Signed Limited Edition Sings Live Vinyl LP The Decemberists COA USD $299.99 Buy It Now 1 day
The Crane Wife by The Decemberists (CD, Oct-2006, Capitol/EMI Records) USD $13.81 Buy It Now 1 day
New Crane Wife - Decemberists - Rock & Pop Music Vinyl USD $150.33 Buy It Now 1 day
The Decemberists ?- The Crane Wife Vinyl 2LP Capitol Records 2006 NEW/SEALED USD $25.96 Buy It Now 1 day
The Decemberists ?- The Hazards Of Love Vinyl 2LP Capitol Records 2009NEW/SEALED USD $29.67 Buy It Now 1 day
The Decemberists - What a Terrible World, What a Beautiful World CD NEW USD $21.39 Buy It Now 1 day
Decemberists Castaways And Cutouts 180gm vinyl LP NEW/SEALED USD $34.49 Buy It Now 2 days
DECEMBERISTS - I'll Be Your Girl - 8 7" Box Set COLORED AUTOGRAPHED/SIGNED LTD USD $199.99 Buy It Now 2 days
Decemberists - Hazards Of Love 2x LP Vinyl GTF NEW USD $33.99 Buy It Now 2 days
THE DECEMBERISTS "HER MAJESTY" 2003 CD - NM CONDITION USD $10.57 Buy It Now 2 days
The Decemberists - I'll Be Your Girl (NEW 12" VINYL LP) USD $33.06 Buy It Now 2 days
The Decemberists - I'll Be Your Girl (NEW CD) USD $11.89 Buy It Now 2 days
Offa Rex - Queen Of Hearts Vinyl LP Decemberists Olivia Chaney download code USD $12.00 [0 bids]
USD $16.00 Buy It Now
2 days
The Decemberists - What a Terrible World, What a Beautiful World (Audio CD) NEW USD $9.97 Buy It Now 2 days
DECEMBERISTS - I'LL BE YOUR GIRL USED - VERY GOOD CD USD $13.18 Buy It Now 2 days
Crane Wife - Decemberists LP Free Shipping! USD $29.05 Buy It Now 2 days
The Decemberists 'The Hazards Of Love' NEW CD ALBUM USD $7.86 Buy It Now 2 days
The Decemberists - rare UK live music show memorabilia gig tour concert poster USD $1.31 [0 bids]
2 days
THE DECEMBERISTS 5 Songs 2003 EP CD Hush Records BRAND NEW/SEALED USD $12.95 Buy It Now 2 days
The Decemberists, The Crane Wife, Excellent USD $6.68 Buy It Now 2 days
Decemberists BLUE GIANT Go on EDIT PROMO CD Viva Voce USD $14.24 Buy It Now 2 days
Decemberists Long Live The King 10" Sealed Vinyl 6 Tracks USD $14.99 Buy It Now 2 days
DECEMBERISTS-CRANE WIFE (UK IMPORT) VINYL LP NEW USD $140.68 Buy It Now 2 days
Decemberists-What A Terrible World (UK IMPORT) CD NEW USD $6.42 Buy It Now 2 days
DECEMBERISTS-WHAT A TERRIBLE WORLD: WHAT A BEAUTIFUL WORLD (UK IMPORT) CD NEW USD $5.84 Buy It Now 2 days
The Decemberists I'll Be Your Girl Boxset Exploded Edition USD $69.99 [1 bids]
2 days
THE DECEMBERISTS THE HAZARDS OF LOVE VINYL NM 2LP GATEFOLD USD $19.99 Buy It Now 2 days
Decemberists - Her Majesty LP NEW 180G USD $21.99 Buy It Now 2 days
The Decemberists - We All Raise Our Voices to the Air: Live Songs [New Vinyl] USD $29.50 Buy It Now 2 days
The Decemberists - Crane Wife [New Vinyl] USD $24.44 Buy It Now 2 days
THE DECEMBERISTS I'LL BE YOUR GIRL LP Blue Vinyl INDIE WITH DOWNLOAD CARD USD $29.99 Buy It Now 2 days
DECEMBERISTS - I'LL BE YOUR GIRL NEW CD USD $13.74 Buy It Now 2 days
Decemberists - King Is Dead (Vinyl Used Like New) USD $22.58 Buy It Now 2 days
THE DECEMBERISTS PICARESQUE NEWBURY COMICS CLEAR/YELLOW VINYL. LIMITED 500 2LP USD $49.99 Buy It Now 2 days
THE DECEMBERISTS - THE DECEMBERIST-THE HAZARDS OF NEW VINYL RECORD USD $30.72 Buy It Now 2 days
The Decemberists-The Hazards Of Love (UK IMPORT) VINYL NEW USD $21.66 Buy It Now 2 days
THE DECEMBERISTS-MAKE YOU BETTER (UK IMPORT) VINYL NEW USD $8.63 Buy It Now 2 days
The Decemberists-What a Terrible World, What (UK IMPORT) Vinyl / 12" Album NEW USD $26.51 Buy It Now 2 days
TIN ARMOR LIFE OF ABUNDANCE LP 2011 RARE OHIO INDIE FOLK ROCK DECEMBERISTS NM USD $3.99 Buy It Now 2 days
DECEMBERISTS, The - I'll Be Your Girl - Cassette USD $17.20 Buy It Now 2 days
Decemberists - Long Live The King [Vinyl New] USD $18.30 Buy It Now 2 days
Long Live The King - Decemberists (Vinyl New) USD $20.01 Buy It Now 2 days
Decemberists Florasongs vinyl LP NEW sealed USD $37.82 Buy It Now 3 days
The Decemberists - The Crane Wife CD NEW USD $18.24 Buy It Now 3 days
Decemberists - Long Live the King (CD) Six track EP USD $5.28 [0 bids]
3 days
The Decemberists - This Is Why We Fight (CD promo) USD $2.63 [0 bids]
3 days
The Decemberists AMELIA Jigsaw PROMO Dj CD Single 2003 USD $18.99 Buy It Now 3 days
ANNA TIVEL small believer 2017 CD Portland Jeffrey Martin folk the decemberists USD $6.95 Buy It Now 3 days
The Decemberists - Her Majesty the Decemberists [New CD] USD $14.44 Buy It Now 3 days
The Crane Wife by The Decemberists USD $5.19 Buy It Now 3 days
The Decemberists - Her Majesty the Decemberists [New CD] USD $12.90 Buy It Now 3 days
Florasongs by The Decemberists (Vinyl, Oct-2015, Capitol) USD $14.39 Buy It Now 3 days
Decemberists, The-Five Songs Ep CD NEW USD $13.67 Buy It Now 3 days
DECEMBERISTS - Tain - CD - **BRAND NEW/STILL SEALED** USD $15.95 Buy It Now 3 days
RADIO SHOW:ACOUSTIC CAFE 3/28/11 MATT COSTA FEATURE; DECEMBERISTS, ALISON KRAUSS USD $24.99 Buy It Now 3 days
The Decemberists : The Crane Wife CD USD $3.96 Buy It Now 3 days
Decemberists We All Raise Our Voices To The Air Live Songs vinyl LP NEW sealed USD $51.18 Buy It Now 3 days
The Decemberists - I'll Be Your Girl - Limited Edition, Blue Colored Vinyl, NEW USD $27.99 Buy It Now 3 days
The Decemberists - Castaways and Cutouts - Cd Rock Album 2002 USD $14.83 Buy It Now 3 days

More places to buy THE DECEMBERISTS music online Buy THE DECEMBERISTS & Prog Rock Digital Music online:

THE DECEMBERISTS discography


Ordered by release date | Showing ratings (top albums) | Help Progarchives.com to complete the discography and add albums

THE DECEMBERISTS top albums (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

3.58 | 58 ratings
Castaways And Cutouts
2002
3.10 | 43 ratings
Her Majesty
2003
3.61 | 72 ratings
Picaresque
2005
3.98 | 152 ratings
The Crane Wife
2006
4.07 | 275 ratings
The Hazards Of Love
2009
2.92 | 86 ratings
The King Is Dead
2011
2.72 | 31 ratings
What A Terrible World, What A Beautiful World
2015
3.20 | 6 ratings
I'll Be Your Girl
2018

THE DECEMBERISTS Live Albums (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

3.00 | 1 ratings
Live From SoHo
2007
3.11 | 8 ratings
We All Raise Our Voices to the Air
2012

THE DECEMBERISTS Videos (DVD, Blu-ray, VHS etc)

3.88 | 5 ratings
A Practical Handbook
2007

THE DECEMBERISTS Boxset & Compilations (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

THE DECEMBERISTS Official Singles, EPs, Fan Club & Promo (CD, EP/LP, MC, Digital Media Download)

2.25 | 15 ratings
5 Songs
2001
3.76 | 21 ratings
The Tain
2004
2.06 | 6 ratings
Billy Liar
2004
3.00 | 2 ratings
16 Military Wives
2005
2.57 | 4 ratings
Picaresqueties
2005
3.00 | 2 ratings
Connect Sets
2006
2.69 | 5 ratings
Always The Bridesmaid: Vol 1
2008
2.55 | 4 ratings
Always The Bridesmaid: Vol 2
2008
3.03 | 5 ratings
Always The Bridesmaid: Vol 3
2008
2.52 | 6 ratings
Down By The Water
2010
3.91 | 8 ratings
Long Live the King
2011
2.05 | 3 ratings
Florasongs
2015

THE DECEMBERISTS Reviews


Showing last 10 reviews only
 I'll Be Your Girl by DECEMBERISTS, THE album cover Studio Album, 2018
3.20 | 6 ratings

BUY
I'll Be Your Girl
The Decemberists Prog Folk

Review by waluigithewalrus

3 stars While still nowhere near the levels of their beloved "Crane Wife" and "Hazards of Love" albums, "I'll Be Your Girl" is certainly an improvement of The Decemberists preceding two albums. The warm synths that grace much of this album create a lovely sound that, while perhaps not so proggy, are definitely enjoyable. For me, the high point of this album is the roughly eight-minute "Rusalka, Rusalka/Wild Rushes," which brings back the sort of storytelling that made The Decemberists so popular to begin with. I also quite enjoyed "Severed" with its intimidating tone, though I warn that if you are a fan of America's current presidential administration, there's a good chance that you won't find the song quite as enjoyable. Also high points for me on this album are "Once In My Life," "Starwatcher," and the title track "I'll Be Your Girl." Overall, I don't necessarily think this essential to a prog collection, but I think its definitely worthwhile to have for a general music collection.
 Castaways And Cutouts by DECEMBERISTS, THE album cover Studio Album, 2002
3.58 | 58 ratings

BUY
Castaways And Cutouts
The Decemberists Prog Folk

Review by siLLy puPPy
Collaborator PSIKE, JR/F/Canterbury & Eclectic Teams

4 stars THE DECEMBERISTS began their indie rock career in Portland, Oregon and gained attention with their lyrical focus on historical incidents and folklore as well as combining the musical elements of chamber folk, indie pop, baroque pop and rock. Their style sensibilities can be traced back to the 60s British folk acts like Fairport Convention and the Fairport Convention with a healthy cross-pollination of the indie rock and newer contemporary folk acts ranging from Modest Mouse to The Postal Service and even alt-country acts such as Uncle Tupelo. The music can range from upbeat and even guitar heavy progressive pop to country tinged lush ballads. Their debut release CASTAWAYS AND CUTOUTS is a vocal led journey written by vocalist Colin Moloy's who narrates the tales of the CASTAWAYS of the world such as Spanish gypsies and Turkish prostitutes.

One of the greatest assets of THE DECEMBERISTS is the fact that their music is so diverse. While mainly led by Meloy who is the lead singer, guitarist and chief songwriter, there is also a heavy presence of keyboards by Jenny Conlee who employs ample uses of Hammond organ, accordion, rhodes piano and other synthesized effects. Also on the team is percussionist Ezra Holbrook, Nate Query on upright bass and Chris Funk who adds additional guitar parts including the pedal steel and occasional theremin. All of the these unique instruments add interesting atmospheres and crossover genre styles that give THE DECEMBERISTS their own unique sound. The differences between songs is quite pronounced. While "Grace Cathedral Hill" is more of a sorrowful tale of lament that is a lush country ballad, "The Legionnaire's Lament" is an upbeat pop rock track that utilizes distorted ska guitar techniques, energetic accordion, bass and drum interaction and a extra catchy pop hook.

CASTAWAYS AND CUTOUTS made an immediate impression and accumulated an instant fan base and the band found a unique niche that has been compared (unfairly) to Neutral Milk Hotel although as with any folk oriented bands, similarities can be heard. Although the debut is a much more stripped down affair from the second album on where the band would include more guest musicians adding a more extensive range of sounds, CASTAWAYS AND CUTOUTS focuses more on the strong songwriting and inventive genre fusion techniques led by Meloy. While not as popular as albums such as "The Crane Wife" or "The Hazards Of Love," the debut is a decent album in its own right with a stronger roots oriented feel to it. While i have to admit that Meloy's idiosyncratic vocal style that seems equidistant between country and folk with a little mopey indie rock thrown in for good measure, it ultimately has won me over and fits the mournful saddened feel of the album.

 We All Raise Our Voices to the Air by DECEMBERISTS, THE album cover Live, 2012
3.11 | 8 ratings

BUY
We All Raise Our Voices to the Air
The Decemberists Prog Folk

Review by Prog Leviathan
Prog Reviewer

3 stars Indie/folk darlings offer up a proper live album to showcase their infectious blend of playful, anachronistic, and gentlemanly rock music. The whole affair is a jaunty and lively experience, well-played and soulfully sung. However, and it's sort of a big however, the group's sound has difficulty capturing the same level of depth and texture that we hear throughout their studio work. Instead, the songs feel more riff heavy and electric than we're used to. Not necessarily a bad thing, considering that this live set-list is meant to get your toe-tapping, but in general it doesn't sweep one up as much as I would hope.

The songs emphasize the newly released King is Dead, with some dabbling primarily from Picaresque and Crane Wife; effective selections overall, though if you're looking for something as sensitive or artistic as you heard on Hazards of Love, you won't hear it. We All Raise Our Voices to the Air has a crowd-pleasing, festival feel, and is more concerned with creating a fun concert experience than it is with reveling in the antique and finely crafted sound that the band produces in the studio.

Definitely check it out if you're interested in seeing a slightly heavier side of a legitimately good indie/folk band.

Setlist: 3 - Instrumental Performances: 3 - Stage/Energy: 3 - Live Experience: 3

 Florasongs by DECEMBERISTS, THE album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2015
2.05 | 3 ratings

BUY
Florasongs
The Decemberists Prog Folk

Review by Neu!mann
Prog Reviewer

2 stars You might have thought his long sabbatical after recording "The King is Dead" would have given Colin Meloy enough time to recharge his creative batteries. That hope was quickly spoiled by the release of "What a Terrible World, What a Beautiful World" in 2015: an album sounding like the flotsam of earlier, unrealized projects, exhumed from the bottom drawer of Meloy's songwriting cabinet.

Predictably, this modest collection of leftovers from the same studio sessions appeared shortly afterward: in effect an EP of outtakes from an album of outtakes. If nothing else, the five songs here marked a full-circle retreat to the unremarkable Indie Rock of the "5 Songs" EP from 2001, in retrospect hardly a Decemberists classic but at least showing some of the youthful aspirations missing from the band's current efforts.

After fifteen years of escalating success the group now sounds a bit jaded, content to rest on their wilting laurels. "Riverswim" is a pretty song, once again mining the same vein of faux-Americana exploited for "The King is Dead" a half-decade earlier. "Fits and Starts" presents another plagiarized R.E.M.-style rocker, one of many already dotting the Decemberist landscape. There's even a song titled "Stateside", by coincidence (or maybe not) a bookend reflection of the "5 Songs" ballad "Oceanside".

Even the signature vocal tremolo of Meloy, so distinctive when he's singing about 'brickbats and Bowery toughs', is fast becoming a tiresome affectation. The Decemberists certainly deserve all the acclaim their music has earned them in the past. But with the eclecticism long gone, and with Meloy complacently treading very shallow water, it might be time to admit his band's best years are behind them.

 What A Terrible World, What A Beautiful World by DECEMBERISTS, THE album cover Studio Album, 2015
2.72 | 31 ratings

BUY
What A Terrible World, What A Beautiful World
The Decemberists Prog Folk

Review by Neu!mann
Prog Reviewer

2 stars The first Decemberists album after a four-year recess continued in the same, mainstream direction as "The King is Dead", to the dismay of anyone who, like me, first discovered the group through their ambitious "The Hazards of Love" project in 2009. Since then the band has retooled its idiosyncratic style in pursuit of a more commercial muse, playing shorter songs with fewer eccentricities, explicitly tailored for lower common denominator NPR airplay.

There's nothing wrong with that. When properly motivated, Colin Meloy can still write incredibly well-crafted pop songs ("Make You Better") and lovely acoustic ballads ("Lake Song", and is that a Mellotron I hear over the chorus?). But the material here sounds oddly disengaged, lacking even the lightweight thread of backwoods Americana that held the "King" album loosely together.

"We had to change some", Meloy insists at the start of the album, in a narcissistic ditty transparently named "The Singer Addresses His Audience". The author denies any autobiographical bias, but I don't believe it: he's too smart not to realize the song plays like a slap in the face to longtime fans who treasured the band's originality. We get it, Colin: you've outgrown that trademark antique Victorian charm and tongue-in-cheek narrative whimsy. Change is good, but not when you're defending your weakest album to date (and still performing "The Mariner's Revenge Song" on stage).

Ironically, "The Singer Addresses..." is by far the album's strongest track: a thrilling return to form, at least musically. Elsewhere the songs too often go in one ear and out the other, and thankfully too: "Easy Come, Easy Go", as Meloy sings in the (almost) catchy rocker of the same name. That old-thyme American folk sound from "The King is Dead" resurfaces in "Carolina Low" and "Better Not Wake the Baby" (what was that you said about needing to change, Colin..?) And the band hits rock bottom in the twin nadirs of "Cavalry Captain" and "Philomena", the former sounding not unlike the worst of '80s Phil Collins (but with pithier lyrics), and the latter a fluffy pop nonentity with atypically smarmy lyrics unworthy of the pen that wrote "The Crane Wife".

Let's hope such a unique songwriter, who describes himself (in "Lake Song") as being at one time "seventeen and terminally fey", soon grows tired of career-building and reconnects with the buoyant spirit of his wayward youth.

 Picaresque by DECEMBERISTS, THE album cover Studio Album, 2005
3.61 | 72 ratings

BUY
Picaresque
The Decemberists Prog Folk

Review by Prog Leviathan
Prog Reviewer

3 stars This third album by the Decemberists sees the indi-rock darlings escalating the bombast and artistry of their nuanced, hand-crafted songs and stories. The result is a strong show of the band's unique sound and identity that shows progression from their previous two works, and feels like a warm up for the two excellent albums that follow. Taken by itself, Picaresque is an album of stand alone songs that sometimes captivate, sometimes romance, sometimes poke fun at, and sometimes miss the mark, making for a good but not essential prog-folk experience.

The opener "Infanta" is a huge, bombastic, and upbeat attention grabber with a Spanish flair. It's pretty good, and may be a prog fan's highlight of the album. However, it's hardly representative of what follows. "We Both Go Down Together" is a sing-songy tune with an abundance of Meloy vocals and violin counter melody. A good example of a song that has a few moments of appeal but doesn't quite work as intended. We're given songs that are playful and charming, melancholic and sorrowful, and even ambitious balladry like "Bagman's Gambit". This song is another good example of a mixed bag; the composition has numerous dynamic shifts and nuance, but doesn't have the emotional "umph" to resonate. "Mariner's Revenge Song" is better, thanks to its reliance on acoustics and occasional moments of intensity. Ironically, the excellent instrumental performances and nuanced vocals of later albums haven't quite developed yet, but the album retains a strong sense of presence and fun despite this.

For me Picaresque is at its best at its most extreme: very ambitious and "forte," or very acoustic and sensitive. There is too much middling to make this more than a 3-star prog folk release. Those curious about the band should check out the much better albums that follow first, and temper expectations if working backwards.

Songwriting: 3 - Instrumental Performances: 2 - Lyrics/Vocals: 2 - Style/Emotion/Replay: 3

 The King Is Dead by DECEMBERISTS, THE album cover Studio Album, 2011
2.92 | 86 ratings

BUY
The King Is Dead
The Decemberists Prog Folk

Review by Prog Leviathan
Prog Reviewer

3 stars The King is Dead is the Decemberists celebrating their indie/folk stylings more than their prog-folk artistry. This really shouldn't be surprising, considering that at the time of this album's release, 3 of the band's 5 records were more indie than prog. However, it's also not surprising that the Prog Archives average reviews shows that we as a group favor those 2 albums that lean more towards prog than indie. The King is Dead isn't the follow-up that some of us wanted after the excellent Hazards of Love, but it is an enjoyable example of the Decemberist's thoughtful blend of rock and folk.

In fact, the King is Dead is probably the best example of the band's "total package" to date. It's heavy parts are heavier; it's softer parts are more tender; the vocals sound more experienced; and the instrumental moments are very well executed. The band plays with a more electric sound then they have in the past, with fewer antique and acoustic instruments in the mix. Query's bass stands out as being more prevalent throughout, as does the vocals of Meloy, which come across as more mature and steadier. None of the songs cut as deeply or as powerfully as we heard in Hazards, but this is a different kind of album. It's a mix of mostly mid-tempo tunes that stand well alone or when taken in as a group.

The songwriting and tone doesn't even tip-toe into "progressive" territory, but that doesn't make the King is Dead bad, just good but not essential. Recommended right behind the more artistic Crane Wife and Hazards of Love.

Songwriting: 3 - Instrumental Performances: 3 - Lyrics/Vocals: 3 - Style/Emotion/Replay: 4

 Her Majesty by DECEMBERISTS, THE album cover Studio Album, 2003
3.10 | 43 ratings

BUY
Her Majesty
The Decemberists Prog Folk

Review by Prog Leviathan
Prog Reviewer

2 stars The Decemberists are known for their sort of antique, hand-crafted brand of folk/prog, and while Her Majesty definitely has a style and tone consistent with the group's other albums, this one lacks the creative spark to grab hold of the listener and leave much of an impression by its conclusion.

It's hard exactly to pinpoint what holds Her Majesty back. Maybe its the song writing, which lose depth and creativity as the album goes on. Maybe its Meloy's very exposed vocals, and comparatively uninspired vocals. We just aren't given that much to catch our interest, as song after song goes by in a folksy, twangy mish-mash of acoustic sounds. The whole album sounds sort of like B-sides, or unfinished works in need of a sharper production and edit for impact.

Still, the bands's playing is good overall, giving us some interesting tones that emerge from an otherwise bland entry from the otherwise engaging band. One for the fans.

Songwriting: 2 - Instrumental Performances: 3 - Lyrics/Vocals: 2 - Style/Emotion/Replay: 2

 Castaways And Cutouts by DECEMBERISTS, THE album cover Studio Album, 2002
3.58 | 58 ratings

BUY
Castaways And Cutouts
The Decemberists Prog Folk

Review by Prog Leviathan
Prog Reviewer

3 stars While I would normally take steps to turn off or avoid quirky indie artists, there is a dreamy and antique charm to the Decemberists that I enjoy very much. In this, their debut, they offer us a variety of artful, densly arranged, and emotional music that tickles the fancy on many different levels. While it doesn't always connect with me on a personal or intellectual level, their sound here is very soulful and soothing.

There are two things one will hear right away on Castaways and Cutouts: the first are the layers of acoustic instruments played with a sort of old-time feel. This is probably the trademark of the Decemberist's sound, and it's great. It's played in a very warm and anachronistic tone that is half tongue-in-cheek, and half crafts-person. The second is the distinctive voice of Meloy, which are smoothly crooned in sort of a nasally drone that is surprisingly enjoyable. His lyrics are surprisingly good, having numerous literate references and playful rhymes that take you to unexpected places.

While not their best album so far, Castaways and Cutouts is recommended for those seeking a mellow sound to add to their prog collection.

Songwriting: 3 - Instrumental Performances: 4 - Lyrics/Vocals: 3 - Style/Emotion/Replay: 4

 What A Terrible World, What A Beautiful World by DECEMBERISTS, THE album cover Studio Album, 2015
2.72 | 31 ratings

BUY
What A Terrible World, What A Beautiful World
The Decemberists Prog Folk

Review by FunkyM

3 stars Ah, The Decemberists. A few years ago they were darlings of the progressive folk genre, having released the very good The Crane Wife and the utterly fantastic The Hazards of Love. However, many were unhappy with their move towards the Americana pop/rock style on The King is Dead.

Now, in 2015, the band returns with a new release sporting the lengthy title What a Terrible World, What a Beautiful World and they seem to be aware of the discontent from some over changing up their sound. The opening number, "The Singer Addresses His Audience" is a very plain statement from the band to those fans who have become critical of them that the change was necessary. That the band couldn't remain musically stagnant is understandable and admirable. Bands should not aspire to become creative stagnant, after all.

However, the band's response is somewhat betrayed by the fact that, on the whole, What a Terrible World, What a Beautiful World is a bit of a retreat in terms of The Decemberists' musical direction. The album moves the band towards their pre-Crane Wife sound mixed with a bit of The King is Dead whilst going for a slightly more "polished" (read: commercially viable) indie rock direction.

That is not meant to slag the band or this release off. I think What a Terrible World, What a Beautiful World is a terrific album just as I also thought The King is Dead was a terrific album.

However, I must be honest - this is not a "prog" album. Many songs, like "Cavalry Captain" and the first single, "Make You Better", are enjoyably melodic pop/rock tracks and the band is very talented at making this kind of music. If you are looking for progressive folk/rock though, you will not find it here.

That said, I do think that this album will appeal to both fans of the band and to some fans of progressive rock because the songwriting remains clever with a strong emphasis on melody.

So I do recommend the album, despite the change in direction with the band's sound. Some may be disappointed because it's not a prog album, but despite that, believe it or not, the music is still good.

Highlights: "Cavalry Captain", "Make You Better", "Till The Water's All Gone", "Carolina Low", "A Beginning Song"

Thanks to ClemofNazareth for the artist addition. and to Quinino for the last updates

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives