PETER GABRIEL

Crossover Prog • United Kingdom


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
Peter Gabriel picture
Peter Gabriel biography
Musician, writer and video maker, Peter GABRIEL is one of the most prolific artist in the world and also one of the most loved musicians in prog-scene. He was the singer and front-man of GENESIS since 1967 to 1975, but thatīs another story...

GABRIEL started his solo career in 1977, and since then he has released 8 studio albums, 2 live albums, 3 original sound track and 3 compilations, always with the collaboration of a lot of different and great musicians and playing different musical styles. 1977 was the date of the release of Peterīs first album "Peter Gabriel 1", one year after "Peter Gabriel 2" was published, both albums has a similar sound (pop-prog-rock), and count with the production and guitars of KING CRIMSON's Robert Fripp and Tony Levin on bass, being Tony a active member of Peter's band since them. "Solisbury Hill" was the hit single of GABRIELīs first work, both albums includes classic songs that still being played on his actual shows. In 1980 two thing happens, one was the release of Peter's third album "Peter Gabriel 3", being this one the most complete work till date in the opinion of a lot of fans, and also was the found of WOMAD (World Of Music, Arts and Dance) where Peter and other members of WOMAD play a serie of festivals around the world where they mix traditional and modern music. In 1982 Peter published "Security" album, with a different sound, more electronic and also was the first time that Peter begins to use african sounds in his albums, this one was follow by the double live album "Peter Gabriel Plays Live". Two years after Peter release his first o.s.t. "Birdy" (Alan Parker film), being this one a great mix of eerie sounds ans relaxing music).

Just one year after, in 1986 "SO" is published, being this one the more know and best-sell album, with a clear pop sound with hit singles like "Sledgehammer" and "Donīt Give Up" (with the colaboration of Kate Bush on vocals) and the great "Red Rain". This album won several winners, especially for his video clips, very sofisticated for that year. Three years after Peter published his second o.s.t., Martin Scorcese's "Last Temptation Of Christ", one of the most experimental and innovative albums, with a mix of different musical styles. After this album a compilation album "Shaking The Tree Sixteen Golden Greats" was published, and in 1988 Peter was involved in some benefic concerts, like "Human Rights Now" tour for Amnisty International, with artist like STING, Tracey CHAP...
read more

Peter Gabriel official website

PETER GABRIEL MP3, Free Download (music stream)


Open extended player in a new pop-up window | Random Playlist (50) | How to submit new MP3s

PETER GABRIEL tour & shows, news & press / forum topics


PETER GABRIEL tour & shows + news & press Submit a news, events & tour
PETER GABRIEL general topics Create a new topic

PETER GABRIEL Videos (YouTube and more)


Showing only random 3 | Show all PETER GABRIEL videos (9) | Search and add more videos to PETER GABRIEL

Buy PETER GABRIEL Music


Peter Gabriel-So-Rock CD-very good condition US $3.25 (0 bids)
1h 42m
Peter Gabriel-Revisited-Rock Cd- US $3.25 (0 bids)
1h 47m
Peter Gabriel 3 Melt LP SRM13848 1980 NM- US $1.99 (1 bids)
2h 2m
1 CENT CD: Peter Gabriel 'So' 1986 US $2.25 (5 bids)
2h 32m
GENESIS LP NURSERY CRIME CHARISMA 1972 PETER GABRIEL NR US $7.99 (1 bids)
3h 18m
Peter Gabriel by Peter Gabriel (CD, Mar-2006, Geff... US $2.99 (0 bids)
3h 29m
PETER GABRIEL BURN YOU UP BURN YOU DOWN promo only cd US $6.26 (0 bids)
3h 31m
So by Peter Gabriel CD1986 US $0.49 (1 bids)
4h 3m
Peter Gabriel - Security US $0.99 (0 bids)
4h 47m
PETER GABRIEL(GENESIS)Japan 1982 NM LP PETER GABRIEL US $17.99 »Buy it now 6h 25m
PETER GABRIEL So 1986 CD Remaster Genesis US $9.99 (0 bids)
6h 28m
Peter Gabriel Three 200g 45rpm Sealed LP US $69.99 »Buy it now 6h 31m
Peter Gabriel Two 200g 45rpm Sealed LP US $69.99 »Buy it now 6h 38m
Peter Gabriel One 200g 45rpm Sealed LP US $69.99 »Buy it now 6h 43m
Peter Gabriel Interview Picture Disc record LP NM rare US $9.99 »Buy it now 6h 48m
Peter Gabriel So 200g 45rpm Sealed LP US $69.99 »Buy it now 6h 49m
PETER GABRIEL The Barry Williams Show promo CD single US $0.01 (0 bids)
7h 45m
Peter Gabriel , Audio CD, Us US $1.00 »Buy it now 8h 5m
LEONARD COHEN Tower Of Song CD Tori Amos Peter Gabriel US $0.99 (1 bids)
8h 33m
PETER GABRIEL US $8.00 »Buy it now 9h 42m
Scratch My BackScratch My Back Deluxe Edition, Special Edition
EMI Label Services (Audio CD 2010)
$13.99
Scratch My BackScratch My Back Import
Phantom Sound & Vision (Audio CD 2010)
$39.98
Scratch My BackScratch My Back
EMI Label Services (Audio CD 2010)
$15.98
HitHit Enhanced, Original recording remastered
Geffen Records (Audio CD 2003)
$12.03
$10.27 (used)
Big Blue BallBig Blue Ball
REAL WORLD (Audio CD 2008)
$12.74
$20.07 (used)
Disney Pixar GreatestDisney Pixar Greatest Soundtrack
Walt Disney Records (Audio CD 2009)
$13.01
$8.96 (used)
The Most Relaxing Piano Album in the World...Ever!The Most Relaxing Piano Album in the World...Ever!
EMI Classics (Audio CD 2001)
$9.99
$7.96 (used)
Shall We Dance?Shall We Dance? Soundtrack
Casablanca (Audio CD 2004)
$6.73
$4.34 (used)
SoSo
Virgin (Audio CD 2002)
$99.81
$1.18 (used)
UpUp Enhanced
Interscope (Audio CD 2002)
$5.99
$2.77 (used)

More places to buy PETER GABRIEL music online Buy PETER GABRIEL & Prog Rock Digital Music online:
  • Search for PETER GABRIEL DRM-Free MP3 Downloads @ AmazonMP3 (USA Only) | AmazonMP3 (UK Only)
  • Buy your digital music at eMusic.com (worldwide)

PETER GABRIEL shows & tickets


PETER GABRIEL discography of albums and videos


Ordered by release date | Help Progarchives.com to complete the discography and add albums

PETER GABRIEL Albums (CD, Vinyl/LP, Cassette)


3.45 | 119 ratings
Peter Gabriel (1 - "Car")
1977

3.01 | 91 ratings
Peter Gabriel (2 - "Scratch")
1978

4.21 | 116 ratings
Peter Gabriel (3 - "Melt")
1980

3.93 | 96 ratings
Peter Gabriel (4 - "Security" or "Mask")
1982

2.86 | 21 ratings
Music From The Film Birdy
1985

3.83 | 102 ratings
So
1986

4.17 | 58 ratings
Passion
1989

3.62 | 68 ratings
US
1992

3.65 | 32 ratings
OVO
2000

3.51 | 18 ratings
Long Walk Home
2002

4.10 | 107 ratings
Up
2002

2.69 | 17 ratings
Big Blue Ball
2008

4.27 | 7 ratings
Scratch my back
2010

PETER GABRIEL Live Albums (CD, Vinyl/LP, Cassette)


4.14 | 38 ratings
Plays Live
1983

3.91 | 24 ratings
Secret World Live
1994

1.50 | 2 ratings
Plays Live - Highlights
2002

PETER GABRIEL Videos (DVD, Blu-ray and VHS)


3.95 | 4 ratings
P.O.V.
1990

4.35 | 35 ratings
Secret World Live
1994

4.47 | 44 ratings
Growing Up Live
2003

3.89 | 12 ratings
Play: The Videos
2004

3.61 | 10 ratings
Still Growing Up - Live And Unwrapped
2005

PETER GABRIEL Boxset & Compilations (CD, Vinyl/LP, Cassette)


3.97 | 24 ratings
Shaking the Tree Sixteen Golden Greats
1990

3.19 | 7 ratings
Revisited
1992

3.79 | 17 ratings
Hit
2003

PETER GABRIEL Official Singles, EPs, Fan Club & Promo (CD, Vinyl/LP, Cassette, MP3, Digital Media Download)


3.00 | 1 ratings
Solsbury Hill
1977
not rated
Modern Love
1977
not rated
D.I.Y.
1978
not rated
D.I.Y.
1978
not rated
No Self Control
1980
not rated
Games Without Frontiers
1980
not rated
Biko
1980
not rated
Solsbury Hill
1980
not rated
I Have The Touch
1982
not rated
Shock The Monkey
1982
not rated
I Don't Remember
1983

2.00 | 1 ratings
Walk Through Fire
1984

3.00 | 1 ratings
Sledgehammer
1986
not rated
Don't Give Up (w/ Kate Bush)
1986

2.00 | 3 ratings
Big Time (maxi-single)
1986
not rated
Sledgehammer - Dance mix
1986
not rated
Blood Of Eden
1986
not rated
Solsbury Hill
1986

2.91 | 2 ratings
Biko/No More Apartheid (maxi-single)
1987

4.00 | 1 ratings
Red Rain
1987
not rated
Shakin' The Tree (w/ Youssou N'Dour)
1989
not rated
Steam
1992
not rated
Digging In The Dirt
1992
not rated
Digging In The Dirt - Brown Linen Box
1992
not rated
Be Still
1993
not rated
Kiss That Frog
1993
not rated
SW Live EP
1994
not rated
While the Earth Sleeps (w/ Deep Forest)
1996
not rated
The Story Of Ovo
2000
not rated
More Than This
2002

2.00 | 2 ratings
The Barry Williams Show
2002
not rated
Burn You Up, Burn You Down
2003
not rated
Growing Up
2003
not rated
Whole Thing
2008
not rated
Down to Earth
2008

PETER GABRIEL Music Reviews


Showing last 10
 Big Blue Ball by GABRIEL, PETER album cover Studio Album, 2008
2.69 | 17 ratings

BUY
Big Blue Ball
Peter Gabriel Crossover Prog

Review by Negoba
Prog Reviewer

2 stars This is NOT a Peter Gabriel Album ? but It's Not Bad

BIG BLUE BALL is another of the Peter Gabriel's Real World projects, not a solo album by any means. As most know, Gabriel has been active in promoting world music for nearing 30 years now. In the 80's he coordinated the WOMAD festival, and his work (along with Paul Simon's) were instrumental in the world fusion surge in popularity during the 90's. Gabriel still spends most of his time recording and promoting various world artists, and this disc may have simply been a fundraiser for that effort. BIG BLUE BALL is a record of three collaborative sessions in 1991, 1992, and 1995 at Real World studios covering a huge span of musicians. Strangely, this project was not put in to finished form until 2007 for 2008 release.

There is one good Gabriel song on the album, the opener "Whole Thing." It's fairly typical of the US era, featuring plenty of world percussion along with Gabriel's big studio sound. The melodies are good, and it would have stood up as a nice album track had US had a real follow- up (which many of us would have appreciated in the mid to late 90's).

The rest of the album is a sampler of other bands and Gabriel friends. Karl Wallinger of World Party and the Waterboys actually had a large musical role in the album, and singer Joseph Arthur leads several songs. The variety is quite nice, from African voices and percussion to Middle Eastern tonalities to Celtic flavors. Some of the programming is pretty dated, with the ethno-rap "Jijy" sounding particularly dinosaur-like. Overall, this is a pleasant disc to put in on a drive, seamlessly returning to track one for a continual world beat background music. Unfortunately, none of the songs really blow me away. They are all good, but none are truly excellent aside from the world instrumentation.

It's also very hard to give this much prog cred as it wasn't released until long after these sounds were part of common culture. Even in 1995 when the last session was recorded, listeners already would have been somewhat familiar with these sounds. (Thanks in part to Gabriel's own efforts). I got the disc used and certainly don't feel cheated, but this is a non- essential novelty. 2/5 stars.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

 Peter Gabriel (4 - Studio Album, 1982
3.93 | 96 ratings

BUY
Peter Gabriel (4 - "Security" or "Mask")
Peter Gabriel Crossover Prog

Review by fuxi
Prog Reviewer

4 stars I cannot imagine what this album sounds like to someone born after 1990, as so many of Progarchives' users are. Perhaps it smacks a little too much of the early eighties (abundant use of orchestral synths and all) and it does not even have the advantage of sounding "quaint" and "antique", like early Genesis.

But if you can reconcile yourself with its unique idiom, there are a lot of treasures to be found. Generally speaking, Gabriel continues in the (largely) experimental style that characterised his third solo album, but where PG III was dark and ominous, PG IV is life-affirming, predominantly festive, exultant even. I tend to see III as black-and-white, but IV is in vibrant multicolor.

Many of the tunes here are among the best Gabriel has written. In any retrospective box set of his work, I would definitely include "The Rhythm Of The Heat", "San Jacinto", "I Have The Touch" and "Kiss Of Life". Only two tracks turn out to be a disappointment. "The Family And The Fishing Net" purports to deal with Weighty Themes, but as a piece of music it simply doesn't stand up; and "Wallflower" is a rather bland and unconvincing ballad.

By the way, have you noticed how Gabriel keeps returning to that triumphant climax of "Supper's Ready"? We've seen the gorgeously symphonic second half of "Humdrum" on his first solo album, and now he uses a similar effect in "San Jacinto", surely one of his strongest compositions. Once a symphonic progger, always a symphonic progger; in spite of all those fashionable New Wave trappings!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

 Scratch my back by GABRIEL, PETER album cover Studio Album, 2010
4.27 | 7 ratings

BUY
Scratch my back
Peter Gabriel Crossover Prog

Review by boe_a

5 stars A VERY wonderful album indeed. There is an excellent cover of "Philadelphia" by Neil Young from the "Philadelphia" soundtrack, which Peter contributed to, so if the proposed "response" album, tentatively called "I'll Scratch Yours" does materialize, hopefully Neil will cover "Love Street". I was also happy to see him cover Randy Newman, an artist he has referenced ever since "Waiting For the Big One" on "Car". I would also like to have seen him do justice to "A Whiter Shade of Pale", since he used to cover it when he first went solo, and I also would have liked a version of "I Heard It Through The Grapevine", since he covered that as well. Still, his cover of Radiohead is wonderful (and they may cover "Wallflower" apparently), and Peter doing Elbow????...!!! This one is a keeper.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

 So by GABRIEL, PETER album cover Studio Album, 1986
3.83 | 102 ratings

BUY
So
Peter Gabriel Crossover Prog

Review by Bonnek
Prog Reviewer

4 stars After the dark claustrophobic mood and rhythm of the preceding releases, Gabriel went into an entirely different direction. The tribal beats are still present but they operate in an entirely different sonic environment. So has a lush resonance, full of rich instrumentation, funky vibes and bright and slick sounds. It's not just a pop album; it's the perfect pop album, one of the best ever.

While it isn't as unique as Security, it has equally amazing songwriting. Regardless whether it concerns melancholic anthems like Red Rain, That Voice Again, In Your Eyes and Mercy Street, or MTV hits such as Sledge Hammer and Big Time, a sentimental duet with Kate Bush or more experimental pieces like We Do What We're Told and This is the Picture; Gabriel pulls if all off with amazing easy, never faltering, never missing a beat.

He must have had one brilliant flash of inspiration after the other during this recording. Not only did he nurture every single idea that crossed his mind with the utmost care, he also managed to keep things to the point and effective. Quite an achievement given the extensive list of guest musicians that helped to flesh out the sound.

This album is a marvel of song arrangement; it's varied and lavish but it stays clear of pretentiousness. Yes it's accessible, commercial and successful. Three words that tend to sit unpleasantly with fans, but let that not scare you; it fully deserves all praise and success it ever got. 4 solid stars

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

 Music From The Film Birdy by GABRIEL, PETER album cover Studio Album, 1985
2.86 | 21 ratings

BUY
Music From The Film Birdy
Peter Gabriel Crossover Prog

Review by Bonnek
Prog Reviewer

3 stars Birdy is an 1983 soundtrack of the movie of the same name. It consists mainly of an instrumental reworking of themes and melodies of the two preceding albums, but there are also some new pieces composed for the occasion.

It's a mesmerizing and ambient album, with sparse instrumentation and lots of new sounds. The opening At Night only has some slow repetitive percussion and some dark dry chords on what sounds like flutes and a mellotron that was smothered under 10 blankets to muffle the sound. Brilliant. Pieces like Quiet and Alone, Slow Water, Slow Marimbas and Sketch Pad maintain a similarly gagging claustrophobic mood.

Most of the remaining tracks are derived from known songs. While they are certainly deserving, they list among the sort of things fans have more need for then anyone else. But when it comes to soundtracks this is up there with the best, Birdy is an amazing album but should be approached with an open mind. 3.5 stars

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

 Peter Gabriel (3 - Studio Album, 1980
4.21 | 116 ratings

BUY
Peter Gabriel (3 - "Melt")
Peter Gabriel Crossover Prog

Review by Bonnek
Prog Reviewer

4 stars What got into Peter? Right from the first second this album nails your head to the floor. After two directionless albums, the forceful percussive beat and weird instrumentation of Intruder is the most exciting thing Gabriel had recorded in his entire career. Regardless how good he was with Genesis, this album writes music history, almost for its entire 45 minute length.

The most remarkable innovation is the world music inspired percussion. Jerry Marotta was forbidden to use any cymbals and the resulting effect of the dry and powerful tribal rhythms is crushing. Some uncanny guitar, piano chorus effects and amazing vocals create a stunning masterpiece. Most of the album follows in the same path, combining clever songwriting with African percussion and beats. Highlights are plenty, No Self Control, Games of Frontiers and Biko are well known classics, but also the upbeat I Don't Remember and Not One Of Us never cease to amaze me. The minimalist Lead A Normal Life is very powerful, even if it just has some repetitive piano, vibes and Gabriel's distorted vocals in the background. Actually, only the awkward And Through The Wire reminds us of the albums that preceded.

While not his best in my book, this is easily Gabriel's most defining album, it's a groundbreaking experiment that is blessed with superb compositions, originality and unconventional musicianship. Prog was dead, but music was alive and kicking in 1980.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

 Peter Gabriel (1 - Studio Album, 1977
3.45 | 119 ratings

BUY
Peter Gabriel (1 - "Car")
Peter Gabriel Crossover Prog

Review by Bonnek
Prog Reviewer

2 stars Gabriel's solo career took an awkward start. I don't know what people expected, but from whatever point of view you look, be it past or present, this debut is an odd album. It was a huge step away from the prog rock of Genesis and compared to his later famous albums it's still a pretty standard art rock affair. In a way that means it's a unique item in Gabriel's career.

The compositions and vocals are adequate but never amazing. Moribund for instance is an adventurous tune, I especially like the creepy I will find out section, but the arrangement of the chorus is a bit overblown, like something Lou Reed would do in an orchestral mood. Apart from Salisbury Hill and Here Comes The Flood the album mainly consists of classic rock styled anthems and ballads that are too unremarkable to grasp my attention.

I've never found much charm in the art-rocking direction Gabriel started his solo career with. It was a field that was already occupied by superior performers such as John Cale and David Bowie. At least, this first one is a sincere and personal start of an exciting solo career and will probably sit well with people who like the 70's classic rock sound more then I do. 2.5 stars

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

 Peter Gabriel (2 - Studio Album, 1978
3.01 | 91 ratings

BUY
Peter Gabriel (2 - "Scratch")
Peter Gabriel Crossover Prog

Review by Bonnek
Prog Reviewer

2 stars On his second solo album, Gabriel goes all punk. The year was 1978 and the first generation of punk bands had already stormed over the country. Gabriel had his ears open to what was happening around him. Assisted by that other genius, Fripp, he went in a vastly more rough and harsh directions then on the debut.

While the move to left is surely worth some praise, the result leaves much to be desired. Clearly this wasn't the kind of stuff he felt really comfortably with, there are a number of pleasant songs such as On The Air and DIY but they don't measure up to the more adventurous and angry stuff Peter Hammill released in the same year. Mother of Violence is like a lost song from Nursery Crime. It fits awkwardly after the vehemence that preceded but it's a nice tender song.

It's quite hard to make out what the purpose was behind of the remainder of the tracks, most of them sound like weak filler tracks and leftovers. Only the more experimental tracks like White Shadow and Exposure (which also features on Fripp's solo album of that title) are interesting but hardly a compelling listen.

I can not imagine how this album was received back in '78. Maybe the only purpose was to release something that was as remote from prog as possible, something that nobody would have minded had it been good. But really, it's hard to see this as more then a collection of uninspired song writing. 2.5 stars

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

 Peter Gabriel (2 - Studio Album, 1978
3.01 | 91 ratings

BUY
Peter Gabriel (2 - "Scratch")
Peter Gabriel Crossover Prog

Review by TGM: Orb
Prog Reviewer

2 stars Review 2 in a while, Peter Gabriel II

Peter Gabriel II is a spectacular effort to alienate listeners old and new. The series of problems that are the production (Fripp's rather idiosyncratic approach to the material here doesn't really do a good job of emphasising strengths and leaves the busier songs feeling messy), the vocals (Gabriel's voice is always under the same effect in this one, which makes it rather difficult for him to actually express most of the songs very well), the lyrics (now, Gabriel's lyrics past and future were excellent. Here he seems to be on the verge of moving to the more direct approach he'd adopt in the future but with neither the interest nor the powerful central images he so excels with) are mildly redeemed by the quality of a few of the album's better numbers and the sort of cumulative power that all these idiosyncrasies build over a listen. Worth picking up if you're a serious Gabriel fan and have the acknowledged classics; it has grown on me, given time, but in a sort of sideways direction that baffles and bemuses as much as it entertains.

On The Air is one of the album's little highlights, introducing Fripp's production by a little sensitive needling with the synthesiser breaking under the hard guitar/bass riff (some great little embellishments by Levin here). Gabriel's vocals add little more than a general angry buzzing interchanged with some slightly contorted theatricals, thankfully obscuring the rather misfired lyrics. Fripp's solo is rather neat (if a bit undermixed). On the other hand, DIY, the album's second hard rock number is equally dim but not quite so winning... there's an oddly decent version on Plays Live... here only Levin's bass really comes across very strongly and the vocals sound like they've been sung from inside a well-padded box.

Thankfully, that's really the only song that's a bit bland to sit through, and compensated for by the gorgeous Mother Of Violence (an icy little duet between acoustic guitar and piano... something I'm usually not a fan of, but it works here... and Fripp adds his yearning electrics over the top and a couple of interesting insect humming bookends), probably the only song on this one that a Gabriel fan really needs to hear and arguably his most winning acoustic piece.

Thereupon, the album's on its up... possibly the most satisfying section with the quirky bass-driven pop song Wonderful Way In A One-Way World and the thumping orientally-flavoured rocker White Shadow (with some truly superb multi-part riffs, one hell of a Fripp solo and a bit of an unhelpful synth-based introduction). Indigo opens the shorter still side two... a rather inoffensive little piano number seemingly adding a slightly more personal touch to the album's rather thin commentary on commercialism that clumps into a clunky chorus/break then suddenly explodes back in with an unanticipated emotional grip ('All right, I'm giving up the fight/I didn't know when I'd be a stranger again in my own land'). Eventually, it works out as a relatively satisfying piece with some cool side-melodies (listen out for the background guitar and synths... they're not exactly pointed out by the production. Animal Magic is possibly the closest to conventionally catchy the album gets... a slightly odd rock-and-roll inspired piece with Levin in the foreground and some snarly Gabriel vocals, great aggressive guitar, a comparatively convincing lyric. A highlight.

And yes, Exposure is the Gabriel/Fripp collaboration at its most extreme. A hypnotic rhythm, typically entrancing Frippertronics (i.e. a series of guitar loops designed to kill airplay), the first really effective use of Marotta's thick drum style and Gabriel just drawing out every possible idea, syllable and quality of the word 'exposure' before freaking out at the end. It's really something to observe. Levin's bass is also a blast. I'm sure many, many people will be rightly concerned by this; I think it's fantastic.

Flotsam And Jetsam continues in the slightly more experimental vein with a neat vocal yawning and some Marotta/Levin intensity. Almost a shame that Gabriel's boxed-in vocal and the rather persistent but superfluous piano cut away any power I think the song could have achieved. As it is, only the cutesy solo at the end really touches.

Perspective; the padded box is back in vogue for another piano rock song. Don't really feel there's much content in the basic song, though the sax, guitar and so forth are fun and it gives an opportunity for the band's musicianship to blow away suitably. Passable for what it is but really not doing anything interesting. And if you're sort of entertained enough by this point, Home Sweet Home sort of unifies the whole thing in a typically odd and fascinatin' moral 'dilemma' (dilemma isn't the word...let's try quandary?). It's a sort of piano ballad with half a million ambient touches (organ, harmonies, guitar, little rhythm section additions) fluctuating in the background.

Peter Gabriel II is not the finest 42.3 minutes of a very fine musician (and backed by a number of very fine musicians) but, at the same time is mostly enjoyable, has a couple of standouts and a couple of flumps. A fans mostly rating... 2 stars

Rating: Two stars, 9/15 (I have an odd scale, to be honest... 14/15 will usually be a 5, 12/13 will earn a 4. Thereafter it all gets a bit abstract... Favourite track: Mother Of Violence

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

 So by GABRIEL, PETER album cover Studio Album, 1986
3.83 | 102 ratings

BUY
So
Peter Gabriel Crossover Prog

Review by TGM: Orb
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Review #1 in a while, So, Peter Gabriel

So what? It's always slightly annoying when the closest thing to a cheap pun doesn't really fit your opinions (the other one I've always wanted to use was PG tips... I blame a childhood deprived of the fourth series of Blackadder for this terrible sense of humour)... this then makes you write things like reviews. Still, Peter Gabriel's fifth 'real' studio album was his first real mainstream hit, and understandably so: it's a great album, has half a dozen songs that could reasonably have been hit singles (and four of which were, I think) and yet has enough odd and atmospheric stuff, innovation and idiosyncrasy to appeal to long-time fans and smug critics. And it's pretty much flawlessly produced (frankly, I'm amazed that Gabriel's production with Daniel Lanois managed to actually improve on this for Us)... every sound has effect, without ever seeming to crowd the songs.

I suppose there is some 'dumbing down' from the startling structures and raw atmosphere of PG IV (we don't hit anything quite as daring as Lay Your Hands On Me or Rhythm Of The Heat) and the lyrics have also lost some of their mystical grip... I guess Gabriel's new directness leans on his voice the central idea generally being strong enough to sort of spread its mood to the fairly haphazard phrases supporting it and on So, that's not always the case. However, there's also a lot of bigging up on So... the ambience is far more consistent and less naked than on IV, which makes for a more satisfying unity: the 'pop' sensibilities feels linked to the experimental sensibilities. And, most of all, Gabriel's confidence and the tightness of the band(s) is phenomenal... there's really no sense that Gabriel is ever holding back here, which makes even the songs which don't really have much to say oddly moving and the ones which do devastating.

From the opening of Red Rain we are hit by this confidence: it's big, bombastic, catchy, interesting and, most of all, punchy music. The inversion of the grandiose crushing waves of drumming (Stewart Copeland adds some fantastic hi-hat work to Jerry Marotta's clattering drums) and searing vocals descending to the sad showers of piano over a lonely voice at the end. Perhaps could have been cut down, but I can't really think of any moments which don't have something I'd miss. The quality of the synths and treated percussion is only improved from IV and it's overall a superb opener, though I'm not perhaps as keen on it as others here. The confidence hits even harder in the slowly building Sledgehammer, which you've probably heard... a rolling funky song with a seriously awesome bit funky bass/guitar riff, blaring horns and a lead vocal and lyric so infectiously fun that it maybe clouds just how good the music behind it is... the flawless incorporation of the bizarre flute intro into the main song, the little organ melody rolling in at the end, the cool overdub harmony on sledge. While this is an undeniably 'pop' song and probably Gabriel's most notorious hit, I still don't think I've heard anything quite like it.

Contrasting to these two is the lush atmospherically underlined duet Don't Give Up. The matching of Gabriel's increasingly searching and strained vocals meeting Kate Bush's astoundingly sweet and soft replies is just perfect and the idea of the lyrics is here really moving. Credit for the piece's effect goes also to Richard Tee's crisp piano, Levin's smooth, funky, vaguely tragic stick-work and Manu Katche's immensely tasteful percussion. Just incredible.

That Voice Again is the one piece of the album that stands out as not really being particularly great. It's not especially bad, but the melodies just don't strike through, and the contrast of the moments of general shiny threat and the bright shiny chorus feels rather too clunky. And the lyrics just aren't very effective for me. There are a few features I really like... Levin's basswork (and I find it hard to criticise the drumming either), the incredible 'listen to the wind' vocal answer, the rather dark conclusion, but as a whole piece it just doesn't really satisfy.

In Your Eyes simply blows away any doubts left over from the previous piece... I have to admit I probably made myself like the first chorus by sheer force of will... not that I ever particularly disliked it, but I felt that it didn't really match up to the heartbreaking opening. There are very few openings that compare to the way Gabriel introduces 'Love... I get so lost... some-times...' over the rising piano and percussion pairing... and then the way it comes back later is even more powerful. And the chorus keeps building power, too... if I find it a little too light initially, when Levin's bass, Youssou N'dour's backing vocals, the extra drums and the synths come in it moves from heart-wrenching to heavenly.

And Mercy Street: understated and mired in sadness. The cold, lost lead vocals contrast with soft, strange harmonies (my favourite vocals by Gabriel, ever). The percussion is as unobtrusive as any continual rhythm could be, blending in with a whistling sound and the bass (Larry Klein's) has a power over the heart here that I've never really associated with that instrument. And the 'solos' (synthesiser and treated sax) are matchingly soft, sad and unobtrusive. Words really fail to describe this piece (while we're on it, the words of the piece are very striking, 'nowhere in the corridors of pale green and grey/nowhere in the suburbs in the cold light of day/there in the midst of it so alive and so alone/words support like bone').

Big Time flows astonishingly well from this utter immersion, snapping straight out with its awesome basslines (I mean, Levin is usually awesome but here he's just on fire... I guess that's the collaboration with Jerry Marotta on the 'drumstick bass' sound), thunking percussion and Gabriel's deliciously ironic 'HI THERE'. A sharp narcissistic mockery of narcissism, with some hilarious lyrics, the snappy Big Time is really not all that much like Sledgehammer if you actually listen to it rather than assuming that any song with occasional gospel backing and some horns will be the same. Loadsa fun. We Do What We're Told is barest piece on the album with freakily singular vocals, and a virtually purely atmospheric backing with the melody stuck more into the percussion than anything else. Hits a distinctly creepy mood.

This Is The Picture, a duet with Laurie Anderson is something completely different again, catchy as any of the more overtly 'accessible' songs and with a delicious sort of interplay between the two singers' slightly gravellier voices and (again, Gabriel's vocals are incredible) their more soulful seconds. As the lyrics go, it's excellent nonsense that really gives an opportunity for the vocals to move around into a lot of different oddity. And the little synth melody and cool bass part are just perfect. Great way to end an album (or at least the remaster?).

So, four stars. I love everything except That Voice Again, though I guess I'm slightly colder to the still superb Red Rain than the remainder of the material. There's a lot to commend So for, and I think it's comfortably Gabriel's most unified effort to that point, even if it's not my favourite. As for the whole pop/prog/SELLLLOUT debate... I really think the possibilities of (very commercially successful) pop music are much wider than people sometimes think, and here Gabriel has demonstrated that with an album of music that can't really be categorised single-mindedly as pop, prog, rock or world. So is an album you should probably have, if only to bear witness to that.

Rating: Four Stars... virtually essential but not quite perfect. Favourite Track: Mercy Street

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Thanks to ProgLucky for the artist addition. and to MIcky for the last updates

Copyright Đ Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | GeoIP Services by MaxMind