Header

THE WHO

Proto-Prog • United Kingdom


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

The Who picture
The Who biography
One of the greatest of all rock and roll bands and one of the most influential of all time, The Who formed in 1964, when drummer Keith Moon left the Beachcombers and joined The Detours, who included singer Roger Daltrey, guitarist Pete Townshend, and bassist John Entwistle. The Who arrived on the scene at a crossroads in the English music scene: The Beatles were still king but were beginning to turn from the bubble gum pop of previous albums, the Merseybeat boom was fading and London was becoming the center of English music. A residency at London's famed Marquis club gave them a stage to make their impression: above all, The Who were a live band that had to be seen as well as heard. There first hit, "I Can't Explain", led to regular TV appearances and a tour with The Beatles. It also got them signed to Decca Records, where they recorded their first album, "My Generation". The album was a hit in England, reaching #5 on the charts, while the title track became an anthem of sorts for the times and still perhaps their best known song.

The Who were very original in that their arrangements were far from the normal in rock those days. Pete was more of a rhythm player who had Keith and John playing around him instead of
merely holding a beat, an influence acknowledged by the way Prog rock turned conventional rock idioms on their ear with regards to arrangement and traditional roles of the instruments. Keith's drumming was described as 'lead' drumming and John was having bass solos as early as 1965 in rock music.

Success out of the gate gave the group some measure of creative control on their next album which they lacked on the first. Pete and manager Kit Lambert had been talking about extended themes and ideas in rock and roll for some time. When The Who went into the studio for their second album in 1966 each group member was to contribute songs to help generate more revenue in royalties for the group, the group having a rather high overhead in terms of destroyed guitars and drum kits. When the others were not able to meet their quota of songs for the new album, Pete and Kit stepped in to fill the album out, and came up with what would be one of the trademarks of prog music in the future, the extended song cycle "A Quick One", which would be the title of the new album as well. It was 6 distinct song fragments tied together with a unifying theme; love, betrayal, and forgiveness. It is often called a rock opera... it could also be calle...
read more

The Who official website

THE WHO MP3, Free Download (music stream)


Open extended player in a new pop-up window | Random Playlist (50) | How to submit new MP3s

THE WHO forum topics / tours, shows & news


THE WHO forum topics Create a topic now
THE WHO tours, shows & news Post an entries now

THE WHO Videos (YouTube and more)


Showing only random 3 | Show all THE WHO videos (3) | Search and add more videos to THE WHO

Buy THE WHO Music


Live at LeedsLive at Leeds
Remastered · Extra tracks
Mca 1995
Audio CD$2.98
$1.35 (used)
Right Now on Ebay (logo)
Road Food - Who Guess New & Sealed Compact Disc Free Shipping USD $19.49 Buy It Now 1h 28m
The Who, The Best Of The Who: The Millennium Collection Audio CD USD $4.99 Buy It Now 1h 28m
SPICE GIRLS MAMA WHO DO YOU THINK YOU ARE 2 TRACK EU CD SINGLE IN CARD SLEEVE USD $1.54 [0 bids]
1h 28m
Who Knows Where the Time Goes by Judy Collins (CD, Apr-1988, Elektra (Label)) USD $34.99 Buy It Now 1h 29m
Civilian Fun Group Fighting All Who Rob & Plunder 1985 EQMC # 01 PUNK Sealed LP USD $10.00 Buy It Now 1h 30m
The Guess Who, Guess Who, Greatest of Audio CD USD $6.64 Buy It Now 1h 30m
The Who Are You Rock RECORD Album LP Vinyl FREE SHIP USD $9.00 Buy It Now 1h 31m
ZIGGY MARLEY Look Who's Dancing DAVID MORALES 12 INCH & CLUB & FADE PROMO DJ CD USD $24.99 [0 bids]
1h 31m
Aretha Franklin : Whos Zoomin Who CD (1990) USD $3.25 Buy It Now 1h 31m
RAY CHARLES "I WONDER WHO'S KISSING HER NOW" EX+ COND.IN Or.PIC SL. USD $3.03 Buy It Now 1h 32m
WHO, The - It's Hard - LP USD $35.93 Buy It Now 1h 35m
V5-38 Vinyl Record Album 45 Vista Annette Train Of Love Tell Me Who's The Girl! USD $37.95 Buy It Now 1h 35m
JOYCE SIMS Who's crying now CLUB/FULL LENGTH + 12" USD $3.83 Buy It Now 1h 36m
KATYDIDS The boy who's never found 12" Reprise W0065T USD $3.83 Buy It Now 1h 36m
The Best of the Guess Who VINYL LP OBI First Records FL-2031 EX red Asia IMPORT USD $94.99 Buy It Now 1h 37m
Kraven Moorehead Who Isn't? Rock 10 Tracks New And Sealed Free USA Shipping USD $6.99 Buy It Now 1h 37m
OST 007 / SPY WHO LOVED ME UNITED ARTISTS UA-LA774-H Japanese Pressing Vinyl LP USD $1.25 [2 bids]
1h 38m
Who Needs Actions When You Got Words - Plan B (2006, CD New) USD $7.55 Buy It Now 1h 38m
EX- !! Jimi Hendrix & The Who/Backtrack 4/1967 Track LP USD $23.33 Buy It Now 1h 38m
MCVICAR SOUNDTRACK OST THE WHO FILMS STARRING ROGER DALTREY LP PD-1-6284 USD $2.98 Buy It Now 1h 39m
THE WHO - PICTURES OF LILY - 7" VINYL - TRACK LABEL USD $7.78 [0 bids]
1h 39m
THEO PARRISH - Feel Free To Be Who You Need To Be - DETROIT DEEP HOUSE 12" USD $12.99 Buy It Now 1h 40m
THE FRESHMEN - Who Me? - RANDOM RAP HIP HOP 12" Man Parrish USD $11.99 Buy It Now 1h 40m
Moneen : Are We Happy With Who We Are Right Now? CD (2003) USD $3.48 Buy It Now 1h 40m
JESSE BELVIN, "Guess Who" B/W "My Girl Is Just Enough Woman For Me"--45 RPM USD $2.79 Buy It Now 1h 40m
MIKE MONDAY Can u play bass 12" PROMO Whoop WHO62 USD $3.83 Buy It Now 1h 40m
Incognito - Who Needs Love [CD New] USD $24.64 Buy It Now 1h 40m
The Who Who Are You Picture Disc Vinyl 1978 NEW Sealed Rare USD $54.99 Buy It Now 1h 41m
Dido Girl Who Got Away CD '13 (Never Played) USD $5.00 Buy It Now 1h 42m
Who - Then & Now (Sound & Vision) [CD New] USD $32.59 Buy It Now 1h 42m
THE ROYALS "THE MAN WHO WOULD BE KING" EX+ COND. USD $2.63 Buy It Now 1h 42m
Nat King Cole Capitol 45 Record #4870 EX 1962 Who's Next In Line / Dear Lonely H USD $10.00 Buy It Now 1h 42m
ERASURE - WHO NEEDS LOVE LIKE THAT - CD SINGLE - 1992 CDMUTE150 USD $1.54 [0 bids]
1h 42m
The Guess Who - No Time/These Eyes 7" USA Reissue 45 1969/70 USD $4.65 Buy It Now 1h 43m
Decca Custom record & sleeve Bravura The Man Who Hears A Different Drummer USD $7.00 Buy It Now 1h 43m
The Who Who Are You Red Vinyl 1978 NEW Sealed Rare USD $54.99 Buy It Now 1h 45m
The Spy Who Came In From The Cold LP RCA LOC-1118 KAPLAN~Vinyl VG++ USD $0.35 [0 bids]
1h 45m
TWISTA-SO SEXY CHAPTER II/Y'ALL KNOW WHO 3 EACH NEW 12" USD $7.98 Buy It Now 1h 49m
Jimmy Page Vs Albert Lee ?- Who Rocks It Better? [LP] USD $25.76 Buy It Now 1h 49m
KEITH MANIFOLD - WHO'S GONNA BRING ME LAUGHTER 7"single USD $4.67 Buy It Now 1h 50m
Vintage Vinyl Record Album The Guess Who Share the Land LP USD $4.99 [0 bids]
1h 50m
Vintage Vinyl Record Album American Woman The Guess Who USD $4.99 [0 bids]
1h 50m
RITA MARLEY - "WHO FEELS IT KNOWS IT", JAMAICAN "TUFF GONG", EXCELLENT USD $3.25 [3 bids]
1h 50m
SILVERCRUSH Who is me ACOUSTIC & UNRELEASE PROMO CD Single Buffalo Springfield USD $24.99 Buy It Now 1h 50m
The Who / Face Dances / 1981 / Warner Bros. HS-3516 / with Inner Sleeve + Lyrics USD $7.50 Buy It Now 1h 51m
1969 Jackson 5 Who's Loving You/ I Want You Back 45 Record Motown M 1157 USD $8.99 Buy It Now 1h 52m
GEORGE WILSON: Here Stands The Man Who Needs You 45 rare Soul USD $50.00 Buy It Now 1h 54m
THE WHO. SUBSTITUTE / IM A BOY / PICTURES IF LILY. 3 TRACK 12" VINYL SINGLE USD $10.89 [1 bids]
1h 54m
The Who Houston 1975 USD $30.00 [0 bids]
1h 58m
THE BROX SISTERS Tokio Blues/Who 1925 VICTOR 19631 pre-war FEMME VOCAL/Popular USD $11.99 Buy It Now 1h 58m
Red Lemon Electric Blues Band - Who Shot Billy LP NM Happy Face MMLP 1036 USD $7.00 Buy It Now 1h 58m
Ohio Players Who'd she coo?/bi-centennial 7" vinyl Mercury original outer sleeve USD $3.99 Buy It Now 1h 58m
SHIGS The Who Call Me Lightning Original 1968 45rpm VG+ USD $8.99 Buy It Now 1h 58m
THE NOLANS - WHO'S GONNA ROCK YOU 7" single USD $4.67 Buy It Now 1h 58m
THE WONDER STUFF - WHO WANTS TO BE THE DISCO KING 7" USD $4.67 Buy It Now 1h 59m
BRIAN ALEXANDER - WHO I AM NOW NEW CD USD $21.40 Buy It Now 1h 59m
The Guess Who The Best Of The Guess Who RCA Records LSPX-1004 USD $5.75 Buy It Now 1h 59m
Deep Purple Who Do We Think We Are WB LP w/Lyric Sheet Insert BS 2678 USD $5.95 Buy It Now 2h
THE WHO SIGNED FRAMED GOLD CD DISPLAY 6 USD $29.55 Buy It Now 2h
RCA 10" 78/Tex Beneke/Blues In The Night March/The One Who Gets You/E/+-N.O.S!!! USD $7.50 Buy It Now 2h
LITTLE CAESAR - Who Slammed the Door / I'm Reachin' RCA - 45rpm Popcorn USD $9.95 [0 bids]
2h
KEITH GREEN - For Him Who Has Ears To Hear (with Lyrics Sheet) USD $14.00 Buy It Now 2h
THE WHO 3 ALBUMS - ITS HARD - WHOS NEXT & MEATY BEATY BIG & BOUNCY USD $10.00 [0 bids]
2h 2m
EDDIE HILL Lovin' Spree/Who Wrote RCA VICTOR 20-5642 Country/Rockabilly BOPPER USD $9.79 Buy It Now 2h 3m
Roger Daltrey (The Who) Walking In My Sleep USA Promo 45 With Picture Sleeve USD $17.99 Buy It Now 2h 5m
BOBBY POWELL: Who Is Your Lover / I'm Not Going To Cry Over Spilled Milk 45 Sou USD $20.00 Buy It Now 2h 6m
The Who - Tommy CD Mobile Fidelity Sound Lab GOLD USD $49.00 Buy It Now 2h 7m
Brian Alexander - Who I Am Now [CD New] USD $16.34 Buy It Now 2h 8m
The Boy Who Faced His Giant 2 CD's + BONUS DVD USD $4.99 Buy It Now 2h 8m
DON GIBSON - Look Who's Blue - Excellent Con LP Record USD $12.43 Buy It Now 2h 9m
Arctic Monkeys WHO THE FUCK ARE THE ARCTIC MONKEYS? +MP3s NEW VINYL 10" EP USD $16.50 [4 bids]
2h 9m
Tony ! Toni ! Tone Who Polygram Sealed LP S USD $6.99 Buy It Now 2h 11m
Mary Hopkin - Knock Knock Who's There / International - Apple 7" 45 USD $8.22 Buy It Now 2h 11m
Madonna ?- Who's That Girl [LP] USD $21.09 Buy It Now 2h 11m
Roy Chubby Brown RARE CD WHO ARE YOU LOOKING AT USD $31.12 Buy It Now 2h 12m
The Man Who by Travis (UK) (CD, Apr-2000, Epic (USA)) USD $2.00 [0 bids]
2h 15m
TOM JONES Without Love + The Man Who Knows Too Much PARROT records 45-400945 USD $0.99 Buy It Now 2h 17m
DAVID BOWIE THE MAN WHO SOLD THE WORLD ORIGINAL ORANGE DYNAFLEX LP W/POSTER USD $249.99 Buy It Now 2h 17m
Beatles Zeppelin The Who Plus Other Vintage & Rare 45's From The 60's & 70's!!! USD $69.99 [0 bids]
2h 18m
Are We Really Happy With Who We Are Right Now? by Moneen CD FREE SHIP Punk Rock USD $3.99 Buy It Now 2h 19m
SIG - HEILS/"Sez - Who"/ "Lorelei 2"/ Booze/ Novelty Garage/VG solid/ *LISTEN* USD $29.00 [5 bids]
2h 20m
PETULA CLARK "COLOR MY WORLD/WHO AM I" 1967 LP WARNER BROS=WS-1673 USD $7.99 Buy It Now 2h 20m
STEEL WOOL NO SUGAR TONIGHT NM UNPLAYED 45 OLD STORE STOCK GUESS WHO USD $20.00 Buy It Now 2h 20m
Best of the Stones Zeppelin Hendrix Who CSN&Y Jethro Tull Live In Concert I.C. USD $65.00 Buy It Now 2h 21m
THE ZUTONS WHO KILLED THE ZUTONS SEALED CD NEW USD $7.08 Buy It Now 2h 21m
DION , Lovers Who Wander LP USD $12.00 Buy It Now 2h 21m
Roger Daltrey-The Who sealed Radio Show 08-15-1992 mint rare USD $39.99 Buy It Now 2h 23m
Jessie J - Who You Are [Platinum Edition](CD) 16 Tracks - Nr Mint - Fast Postage USD $6.21 Buy It Now 2h 24m
THE WHO - Tommy (CD, Mar-1996, MCA (USA)) BMG MCAD-10801 USD $8.27 Buy It Now 2h 24m
Shaka Who Who, Oliver Who, Good USD $3.50 Buy It Now 2h 25m
The Who Who's Next 12" vinyl LP MCA 20023 rock USD $9.99 Buy It Now 2h 26m
Who, 20th Century Masters: Millennium Collection (Eco-Friendly Packaging) Audio USD $7.99 Buy It Now 2h 30m
KELLY PRICE w/ VANESSA BELL ARMSTRONG This is who I am ADVNCE PROMO DJ CD 2006 USD $24.99 Buy It Now 2h 32m
PROMO CD MOTLEY CRUE Tears for Fears SUBLIME Toby Keith LYNYRD SKYNYRD the Who 2 USD $24.99 Buy It Now 2h 32m
THE WHO who are you CD ss co USA classic rock bonus tracks MOD oop rare L@@K USD $13.50 Buy It Now 2h 33m
Boy Who Couldn't Stop Dreaming - Club 8 (2007, CD New) 4800594407942 USD $18.83 Buy It Now 2h 37m
SANDIE SHAW UK 7" 45 w/B.E.F. ANYONE WHO HAD A HEART, 1982 on Virgin 484 USD $6.80 Buy It Now 2h 38m
Who Loves Ya Baby - Ian Prowse (2014, CD New) USD $17.68 Buy It Now 2h 38m
Let The Blind Lead Those Who Can See But Cannot Fe - 2 DISC SET - (2008, CD New) USD $27.87 Buy It Now 2h 38m
Gary Clail - Who pays the piper? UK 12" OAKENFOLD REMIX USD $9.32 Buy It Now 2h 39m
LP live at the isle of wight festival 1970 ~ USD $37.22
LP who's next ~ USD $23.45


More places to buy THE WHO music online Buy THE WHO & Prog Rock Digital Music online:
  • AmazonMP3: Search for THE WHO DRM-Free MP3 Downloads @ AmazonMP3 (USA Only) | AmazonMP3 (UK Only)

THE WHO shows & tickets


  • The Who Hits 50 on 22 Mar 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 23 Mar 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 15 Apr 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 17 Apr 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 19 Apr 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 21 Apr 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 23 Apr 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 27 Apr 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 29 Apr 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 2 May 2015
  • The Who at Sprint Center, Kansas City MO on 5 May 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 7 May 2015
  • The Who Hits 50! on 9 May 2015
  • The Who at Bridgestone Arena, Nashville on 11 May 2015
  • The Who Hits 50! on 13 May 2015
  • The Who at Nationwide Arena, Columbus on 15 May 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 17 May 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 20 May 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 22 May 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 24 May 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 26 May 2015
  • The Who Hit 50 on 30 May 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 21 Jun 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 23 Jun 2015
  • British Summer Time: The Who Hits 50 on 26 Jun 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 28 Jun 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 29 Jun 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 1 Jul 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 14 Sep 2015
  • The Who Hits 50 on 16 Sep 2015

THE WHO discography


Ordered by release date | Showing ratings (top albums) | Help Progarchives.com to complete the discography and add albums

THE WHO top albums (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

2.74 | 110 ratings
My Generation
1965
2.88 | 104 ratings
A Quick One
1966
3.52 | 150 ratings
The Who Sell Out
1967
3.99 | 370 ratings
Tommy
1969
4.36 | 397 ratings
Who's Next
1971
4.48 | 411 ratings
Quadrophenia
1973
3.48 | 129 ratings
By Numbers
1975
3.23 | 136 ratings
Who Are You
1978
2.34 | 75 ratings
Face Dances
1981
2.59 | 68 ratings
It's Hard
1982
2.88 | 56 ratings
Endless Wire
2006

THE WHO Live Albums (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

3.99 | 96 ratings
Live At Leeds
1970
4.05 | 26 ratings
The Kids Are Alright (Original Soundtrack of the Film)
1979
2.52 | 10 ratings
Who´s Last
1984
3.25 | 4 ratings
Join Together
1990
5.00 | 1 ratings
The Who Live (Golden Age serie)
1993
3.03 | 19 ratings
Live at the Isle of Wight Festival 1970
1996
2.69 | 16 ratings
BBC Sessions
2000
3.94 | 13 ratings
Live At The Royal Albert Hall
2003
4.00 | 1 ratings
Greatest Hits Live
2010
3.91 | 4 ratings
Live At Hull
2012

THE WHO Videos (DVD, Blu-ray, VHS etc)

3.83 | 20 ratings
The Kids are Alright
1979
4.00 | 5 ratings
Who's Better, Who's Best
1988
3.58 | 10 ratings
Live at the Isle of Wight Festival
1998
4.08 | 6 ratings
Who's Next - Classic Albums
1999
3.78 | 8 ratings
Live at the Royal Albert Hall
2000
3.33 | 3 ratings
Live & Alive
2003
3.00 | 3 ratings
The Vegas Job
2006
3.15 | 9 ratings
Amazing Journey
2007
3.67 | 7 ratings
The Who at Kilburn: 1977
2008
3.33 | 8 ratings
Maximum R&B Live
2009
4.33 | 3 ratings
Live in Texas '75
2012
3.09 | 3 ratings
Quadrophenia: Live in London
2014

THE WHO Boxset & Compilations (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

2.22 | 11 ratings
Magic Bus: The Who on Tour
1968
3.30 | 20 ratings
Meaty, Beaty, Big and Bouncy
1971
3.66 | 21 ratings
Odds & Sods
1974
3.33 | 3 ratings
Who's Missing
1985
3.96 | 6 ratings
Thirty Years Of Maximum R&B
1994
3.81 | 18 ratings
My Generation - The Very Best of The Who
1996
2.18 | 3 ratings
The Who (budget compilation)
1997
4.01 | 23 ratings
The Ultimate Collection
2002
3.21 | 11 ratings
Then and Now
2004
1.75 | 6 ratings
Greatest Hits
2009
5.00 | 4 ratings
Live At Leeds 40th Anniversary Super-Deluxe Collectors' Edition
2010
4.67 | 3 ratings
Quadrophenia - The Director's Cut (Super Deluxe Limited Edition)
2011

THE WHO Official Singles, EPs, Fan Club & Promo (CD, EP/LP, MC, Digital Media Download)

2.65 | 8 ratings
I'm a Boy
1966
2.81 | 8 ratings
Happy Jack
1966
3.33 | 3 ratings
Summertime Blues
1970
2.95 | 2 ratings
Let's See Action / When I Was A Boy
1971
4.20 | 5 ratings
5.15
1973
2.95 | 2 ratings
Thirty Years Of Maximum R&B sampler
1994

THE WHO Reviews


Showing last 10 reviews only
 Tommy by WHO, THE album cover Studio Album, 1969
3.99 | 370 ratings

BUY
Tommy
The Who Proto-Prog

Review by Slartibartfast
Prog Reviewer

3 stars While I have been familiar with the music on this album for many years, I never got a copy of it, or any other The Who album for that matter. It's not that I dislike The Who, it's just that I never felt the need to have any of their albums in my collection. My brother in law was giving away some CDs recently before putting them up for sale and this was one of them. So now I have a The Who album in my collection, and if it were to be just one, this would be it.

Originally released in 1969, it can lay claim to being one of the first concept albums,. It has also been hailed as a rock opera. Musically, it is fairly proggy most of the time and for that it is a welcomed addition to my collection.

On to the problems I have with this album...

The incoherent storyline. Tommy is apparently born in 1921 but somehow winds up the 1960's and is still a kid when he would be in his '40's. Either The Who can't do math or they were on some really good drugs. The child molester. Really? Does this actually add anything to the story? The gratuitous acid queen. Really? LSD is a visual experience. Tommy is supposedly blind, or maybe he's just faking it. Like being a kid when he is still in his '40's. The operatic bits. Really? Probably the worst parts of the album musically.

I could have given this album four stars, but have to shave off a point for the stuff mentioned above.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

WARNING: Forum software upgrade in progress, login function maybe affected for some users during that time.

 Tommy by WHO, THE album cover Studio Album, 1969
3.99 | 370 ratings

BUY
Tommy
The Who Proto-Prog

Review by siLLy puPPy
Prog Reviewer

3 stars TOMMY is one of those so-called "firsts" that doesn't quite muster up the goods to fall in the category of the "bests." A rather ambitious project by THE WHO that was fairly cutting edge back in 1969 when the music world was in a creative explosion ushering all kinds of firsts like fully developed progressive rock in the form of King Crimson and East Of Eden, totally new genres like heavy metal from the likes of Black Sabbath or brilliant and creative new forms of jazz-fusion from the likes of Miles Davis but unlike their contemporaries THE WHO's first foray into the newly opened possibilities of progressive rock just doesn't seem as competent as all the others. Apparently the album was partially inspired by the teachings of Pete Townsend's spiritual guru Meher Baba who claimed to be an avatar and God in human form (seems like everyone had one after the Beatles went to an ashram in India). The story is about a boy named Tommy who is deaf, dumb and blind and his world as he goes through life. Hailed by critics at the time for being one of the first rock opera's and was in no doubt THE WHO's major breakthrough after a couple psychedelic rock albums firmly planted in the style of the late 1960s.

I have never loved TOMMY nor have I ever hated it. For me this is just one of those historical relics that marks a time in musical history as a milestone of sort but never really able to sustain itself throughout the decades that passed. The story is not a bad concept but what really keeps me from loving this album is how much of the music sounds the same track after track and segments are played way past their point of making the point. The midpoint overture cleverly titled "Underture" is the perfect example of a song that just goes on and on and on offering meager variations and has no ability to sustain my interest. I find this is true of much of this album. There are many individual tracks that are brilliant. I'm quite partial to the hits "Pinball Wizard" and "I'm Free" but there is just too much clunkiness on this album for me to get excited about. Having said all that I do like to throw this on now and again because it does mark a specific time in history and for that reason I do like this album but when I want to hear THE WHO I usually go straight for the much better releases that immediately follow. 3.5 rounded down

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

WARNING: Forum software upgrade in progress, login function maybe affected for some users during that time.

 Quadrophenia: Live in London by WHO, THE album cover DVD/Video, 2014
3.09 | 3 ratings

BUY
Quadrophenia: Live in London
The Who Proto-Prog

Review by rdtprog
Special Collaborator Heavy Prog Team

3 stars I was not sure before purchasing this DVD, if I was going to enjoy a live show with the complete double album of "Quadrophenia", because it was a long time ago that I listen to this album and if I remember, I didn't enjoy all the songs. Many years later, I didn't change my mind about this, there are some really good songs, like the title track, "Dr. Jimmy", "The Rock" and "Love Reign Over Me". The other tracks are not bad for what they are, good rock songs, but not as good as some songs of their entire discography. Fortunately, the show has some of those songs as bonus performance, including "Baba O'Riley", "Who are You" and "Won't get Fooled Again"

There's a lot of projections on the screen of the band from the old days. Nice touch to have included John Entwistle with a solo of one of his performance in the song "5:15". Not only you can see him on the screen, but you can actually hear his solo. In fact, his solo sounds more alive than the bass sound of the actual player Pino Palladino, who is rarely captured by the cameras and low in the mix. Also, during "Bell Boy", Keith Moon is singing on the screen.Those projections of the old days performances are only present in the "Quadrophenia" album and not in the bonus songs at the end. We have many musicians on the stage including horn players, Simon Townsend who signs like Pete in "Dirty Jobs". Also two keyboardists, but it's mostly the piano that we hear during this show.

It is easy to rate this, can't be 2 stars because it's not only for collectors, and can't be 4 stars because, that is not a progressive rock show. So it's a good 3 stars, nothing more. But those who enjoy "Quadrophenia" will have a ball with this DVD!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

WARNING: Forum software upgrade in progress, login function maybe affected for some users during that time.

 Live at the Isle of Wight Festival by WHO, THE album cover DVD/Video, 1998
3.58 | 10 ratings

BUY
Live at the Isle of Wight Festival
The Who Proto-Prog

Review by Guillermo
Prog Reviewer

3 stars Fourteen years ago I watched on TV the film called "Message to Love" which is about the Isle of Wight Festival of 1970. That film shows not only some songs performed by some bands, but also the violence from some parts of the audience against paying for their attendance to Rock Music Festivals and also some verbal violence against some musicians like Joni Mitchell (a very unfair thing). By 1970 some of the idealism of the sixties disappeared and some parts of the audiences saw Rock Festivals as only "money making" activities for the people who created them. In the end, the promoters of this Isle of Wight Festival had to make this 1970 Rock Festival as for "free admission" due to the violence of some parts of the audience.

There were several very good bands appearing at that Festival and in that "Message to Love" film, and also other DVDs and / or CDs have been released from some complete concerts from some bands (Jethro Tull, ELP...). And also some seven years ago I watched on TV to this film from The Who playing at that Festival. They looked somewhat sober (I think) and they did not suffer the violence of the audience, who looked very happy at the time of The Who`s apperance. The band first played some of their hits plus other not very well known songs from their repertoire. They even laughed and did some jokes (particularly done by Pete Townshend and Keith Moon), making the audience laugh too. They also played an almost complete version of their rock opera titled "Tommy". It seems that being a quartet they could not reproduce all the songs from the album live, and most of the songs from the "Tommy" album have a lot of overdubs. Anyway, it was a brave attempt by the band to try to play this rock opera live during 1969-70. And I really missed some of those overdubs. The band played an almost "raw" version of that rock opera, maybe looking a bit tired of playing it live during those years.

Rock Festivals were a fad during the late sixties and early seventies. Unfortunately, the increasing violence by some parts of the audiences made them not very attractive as jobs for the musicians and not very attractive as businesses for the promoters. In the DVD from Jethro Tull from the Isle of Wight Festival from 1970 Ian Anderson talks about his dislike of this kind of Festivals.

The quality of the images and sound is very good.

There is a dedication to Keith Moon at the end of the film, showing him doing one of his very famous jokes in front of the camera.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

WARNING: Forum software upgrade in progress, login function maybe affected for some users during that time.

 The Ultimate Collection by WHO, THE album cover Boxset/Compilation, 2002
4.01 | 23 ratings

BUY
The Ultimate Collection
The Who Proto-Prog

Review by Michael678

4 stars ok.... my first official album review on here, and i was on here a few months ago on the forums, but i guess this is gonna be more of a review/rating gig only, so hello again. anyway, I have known of the Who since i was a fan of GHIII (with The Seeker on that game), and it got even futher with radio stations and what not. the inclusion of these guys as prog got me even more interested to hear if they were any proggy at all. kinda here and there, but definitely revolutionary with rock operas and programmed synthesizers (as well as the live performance). all of that is represented masterfully on this double-disc compilation which was the BIG catapult into the Who for me (thank you MP3 player, lol!) it comprises the whole history of the Who from '64-'82 (I Can't Explain to Eminence Front from "It's Hard", Endless Wire didn't peep until 2006). The booklet included here has a good essay on the same thing as well as photos and more information on the individual tracks on here. My favorite tracks here include Won't Get Fooled Again (of course), Love Reign O'er Me, and Substitute to name a few, but i love them all!! even though i have no squeeze box anywhere, i can deal with this compilation any day, proving this to be the best compilation out there. Yet, im giving 4 stars to this album because nobody's perfect (except my favorite albums ever made!!!) hopefully you guys can see me somewhere else on this type of "communication" somewhat. Prog teen, over and out.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

WARNING: Forum software upgrade in progress, login function maybe affected for some users during that time.

 Face Dances by WHO, THE album cover Studio Album, 1981
2.34 | 75 ratings

BUY
Face Dances
The Who Proto-Prog

Review by ExittheLemming
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Blurred Visionary

The thing about The Who for me, and this is sad in a way, is the amount of control that I've had to have, keeping the creative process close to my chest, making sure the other guys in the band felt they were part of the process but they really weren't. Pete Townshend

When did the Who cease to be a collaborative creative unit? Did Townshend's talent begin to eclipse that of his buddies after the successes of both Tommy and Quadrophenia vindicated his ambition, or had the rot set in even before this? As much as I admit that shorn of the textural input of Daltrey, Entwistle and Moon, those power pop 60's anthems wouldn't have sounded remotely as thrilling but they would still be great songs regardless of the means of execution. The band's enduring association with Mod culture is always overstated, as even by 1966/67 Mod had effectively abandoned it's origins in beatnik coffee bars, modern jazz, bohemian art school lifestyles and existentialism for a supplanted psychedelic hippie zeitgeist that embraced intoxication over stimulation. These precedents are seldom echoed in any of the Who's output. I've always suspected that the band's opportunistic managers Kit Lambert and Chris Stamp adopted the Mod orphan to pitch their client's act to any youthful demographic with burgeoning spending power. Teenage rebellion has never been anything more than a marketing ploy. You don't hear the sound of Italian scooters in the Who or the Kinks, (unless they're being advertised) but you do hear what amphetamines, R'n'B and working class urban modernism might resemble.

Over the years Roger Daltrey has come to sound increasingly uncomfortable at inhabiting what are some very unflattering alter egos from the troubled Pete psyche. Townshend has therefore often had to provide material for two distinct appetites of his target audience i.e. the experimental and confessional material for his solo albums and the more accessible but simplistic rawk fare for the legions of archly conservative Who fans. (who, by 1980 included the singer, the bass player and the drummer alas)

By the time the band convened to record Face Dances their individual orbits were at least on similar trajectories e.g. Jones, Entwistle and Townshend all had serious marital difficulties and were quaffing prodigious amounts of booze. To add lighter fluid to an already heavily combustible cocktail, Pete was also indulging in harder drugs (cocaine and heroin) Roger, by way of complete contrast, has always been strenuously 'clean' and was basking in the recent success of his role in the McVicar movie. (as the reformed armed robber now celebrated for his obtaining a degree in Sociology, like you need one to tell you stealing is wrong? go figure and gallery owners everywhere, give my regards to Jimmy Boyle's mutilated victims)

Pete's entire songbook is tantamount to the world's catchiest ever identity crisis. Teased and bullied mercilessly on account of his awkward adolescent gait and huge nose by playground sadists in childhood Acton, Townshend was inevitably a case book study in dealing with oppression and searching for belonging. He was a reluctant mod, a very unconvincing hippie, a meticulously unkempt punk and the oldest new romantic luvvie to ever frequent the Heroes and Embassy Clubs in London. What's rather ironic is that Townshend at this time was completely besotted with the Clash as embodying his holy grail of a sexy and politicized rock band who wrote and played great rock'n'roll while confronting pressing social concerns. It is clearly Townshend and NOT Joe Strummer who would have been best equipped to bring this nascent vision to reality. The reasons being that Pete does not suffer from the romanticized nostalgia for a past that never occurred in the first place that so afflicted Strummer, and he is a pragmatist at heart, a realist who cannot hide behind political rhetoric or empty agit prop. Townshend was a hoi polloi who eventually rubbed padded shoulders with the indolent elite: Strummer was the public schoolboy son of a diplomat who posed around with proles and considered the troops who manned the barricades of Northern Ireland as representative of nothing more significant than a 'photo opportunity'

You Better You Bet - 'Just' a pop song but a cracker for all that and such is the confidence of the writing that it survives a rather speculative and unwittingly comedic Daltrey reading.

I showed up late one night with a neon light for a visa But knowing I'm so eager to fight can't make letting me in any easier I know I been wearing crazy clothes and I look pretty crappy sometimes But my body feels so good and I still sing a razor line every time.

It seems clear that such dissolution expressed so unflinchingly in this song is completely alien to the singer.

Don't Let Go The Coat - Pete always cast a keen eye on the youthful competition throughout his long career and here we see his take on the contemporaneous 'jangle' indie pop phenomenon perhaps best epitomized by the LA's There She Goes. A beautiful and hauntingly powerful song that Roger pitches perfectly with just a hint of remorseful regret in his lower register.

It's easy to be sad when you lack a partner But how would I react to a broken heart now? It ain't really true rock 'n' roll unless I'm Hanging onto you and when I hold it next time

The rather unusual title was probably inspired by an oft repeated phrase sourced from Townshend's acknowledged spiritual guru Meher Baba:

and help us all to hold fast to Baba's daaman [hem of his coat] till the very end.

Cache Cache - Consumed with a sudden wish to give up music forever and live as a tramp in Switzerland, Pete decided to seek out the brown bears that live in cages in the hills above the city of Berne armed only with a bottle of brandy, his wallet and passport for company, Mercifully he found none, but this very endearing and strange song resulted which if nothing else, testifies to the faintly disturbing impulses that can afflict those with unlimited resources and impunity. The author was discovered unconscious in one of the bear pits and subsequently flown to Austria to perform a concert with the Who that evening. The cringe-worthy 'Spinal Tap' element to all this will not be lost on you I'm sure. Once again there is ample evidence that despite his excellent singing, Daltrey has very little clue about the motivation that prompted such spontaneous idiocy from Pete:

I got used to behaving very badly. Once I was so completely out of my brain that I actually humiliated the band in public. We were playing at the Rainbow in London -- this was early '81 and I kept stopping songs and making speeches to the audience. I kept playing long, drawn-out guitar solos of distorted, bad notes. I'd alter the act, making up songs as I went along. And I knew it was London, and I knew that everybody's friends and family were there, and I deliberately picked that day to f.u.c.k up the show. I just ceased to care. I threw my dignity away Pete Townshend

The Quiet One - Given that producer Bill Szymczyk (pronounced B.I.L.L) worked with the Eagles and was suggested by Pete's friend Joe Walsh for this album, it is perhaps not that surprising to report that this Entwistle tune sounds like erm... a Joe Walsh tune. John is on record stating that it was designed to replace My Wife in the Who's live set which he had grown tired of singing. I bet he wearied of this mediocre effort far quicker.

Did you Steal My Money? - We can forgive both the irony of this number being inspired by the Police (the band) and the very large debt it owes to the melodic seed of On Broadway. It's an unusual number for the Who but it works surprisingly well thanks to Pete's accusatory backing vocal that sits in a very pleasing contrast to Roger's more placatory lead vocal. The developmental sections are sufficiently inspired to warrant an entirely fresh writing credit anyway. Quite possibly the only song lyric that conspires to rhyme 'brasso' with 'ass.h.o.l.e'. trivia fans. The demo version on Townshend's Scoop 3 is also well worth hearing. As to the the shady events that inspired this tale, Pete merely states:

The true story behind this doesn't make anyone look good -- especially me. It is not the time to tell it.

How Can You Do It Alone? - A weighty and brooding descending intro provides the camouflage for a lighter and tightly swung verse to emerge that depicts the shame of thwarted desires being uncovered for potentially unfavorable judgement. These run the gamut of flashing on the underground, stealing porn mags and erm, showering with your girlfriend? The short synth driven martial interlude is unexpected but delightful as it leads very satisfactorily back into a verse to fade ending where 'sprightly' and 'creepy' somehow lock flirtatious hands and traipse off down the street inextricably entwined. Why any of this works defies all conventional musical wisdom as the verses centre unequivocally on D major while the intro and bridge begin with a clashing and contrary D minor? File under 'exceptions that prove the rule'

Daily Records - A belter and one of my favourite Who tracks ever. Similarly to Did You Steal My Money? notice how Townshend uses the harmony backing vocals to refreshingly original effect i.e. their wordless gaucheness adds to the feeling of befuddled alienation expressed in the lyric:

I look at baggy suits and leather capped with puke, I look at Richmond married couples denim look I watch my kids grow up and ridicule the bunch but When you are eleven the whole world's out to lunch

Pete's skiffle past is betrayed by an exhilarating guitar break where his command of rapid banjo finger-picking technique is deployed on 6 string electric. Kenney Jones drumming is particularly good on this and it's a shame that his very invisibility makes him one of the few top drummers capable of seamlessly replacing Keith Moon while receiving scant credit or censure for same. A simple and salutary song about how the best intoxication and anti aging tonic to be had anywhere is that fueled by pure, uncut and undistilled music fresh from the source.

You - Another Entwistle original but it's driven by such a tight arsed little riff that must be one of the stingiest ever committed to tape post big bang. Things do perk up thereafter as we transition into a clanking pedal point groove under 'A' which if nothing else, is an exercise in how far you can take this standard issue rock device without resorting to quasi oriental inflected modulations a la Fancy, See My Friends, Tomorrow Never Knows etc. Wisely, John resists such temptation as he's in way over his head in that company. It ain't bad, but I've never yet felt compelled to reach for the 'repeat' button on its cessation. Faintly cack-handed misogyny to boot?

You, your wasting my life, You can't lose what you've already lost Your arms are open but your legs are crossed

Another Tricky Day - Almost self consciously nostalgic for a simpler and more naive past, with trademark windmill power-chords punctuating the Ox's effortless but always muscular anchor and Bundrick's playful jesting piano. Very strong ascending melody that reaches its memorable summit thus:

(Just gotta get used to it) We all get it in the end (Just gotta get used to it) We go down and we come up again (Just gotta get used to it) You irritate me my friend (This is no social crisis) This is you having fun (No crisis) Getting burned by the sun (This is true) This is no social crisis Just another tricky day for you

You can't help but feel there are those amongst us in positions of great privilege, wealth and cultural standing who suffer from both a slice of self-loathing and that strange jealously of ordinary people with ordinary everyday concerns? Regardless, like so much on Face Dances, it succeeds because the writing is strong enough to withstand the lukewarm reception afforded by the band to Pete's original demos and the complete dearth of empathy from a singer who would have very little common ground with the hellish demi-monde inhabited by his songwriter

This just leaves the token doggie bag of tidbits that proliferate on reissued CDs these days. Word to the wise label execs everywhere: free s.h.i.t. is still overpriced.

Somebody Saved Me is an interesting draft that was given its definitive reading on Pete's brilliant solo album All the Best Cowboys have Chinese Eyes. Listening to this earlier version, it seems to inhabit harmonic territory similar to that retraced by Lloyd Cole's Are You Ready to Be Heartbroken? a couple of years hence. I Like Nightmares is good fun but is ruined by Pete's transparently rat a.r.s.e.d. delivery with uncharacteristic dithering over whether he wanted it punchy New Wave or country parody. It's In You sounds like something even the Stones would have rejected from one of their uniformly wretched 80's albums. There are also bundled a couple of live versions of How Can You Do It Alone? and The Quiet One which are decent but strictly for completists only.

Face Dances is an unjustly neglected album in my book as I consider it stronger than the more highly regarded It's Hard that followed. Although not 'proggy' in any conventional sense, of some interest to PA visitors has to be Rabbit Bundrick's keyboards which in the absence of the usual swathes of Townshend guitar, provide much of the internal detail and flesh out the arrangements accordingly. He does this quite brilliantly and his playing is borderline ornate in places with a choice in sounds and textures exemplary throughout. Bundrick is the rabbit that Townshend pulled out of the hat. It also seems clear that by circa 1974 the Who only existed in any meaningful form solely to perform the music of Pete Townshend. They ceased to be a 'real' interactive band long before then.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

WARNING: Forum software upgrade in progress, login function maybe affected for some users during that time.

 The Kids are Alright by WHO, THE album cover DVD/Video, 1979
3.83 | 20 ratings

BUY
The Kids are Alright
The Who Proto-Prog

Review by Guillermo
Prog Reviewer

4 stars I went to a now defunct cinema in my city to watch this film in July or August 1979. At that time, I was 14 years old, and I was on school holidays then. I also went at that time to watch some Rock films ("Woodstock", "Let It Be" and others) in other cinemas. It was a time when Rock concerts in my city were not seen with "good eyes" by the goverment, and Rock movies were rarely shown in cinemas and for a short time only (fortunately this changed by the late eighties). At that time I also was starting to collect Rock music records and learning about Rock and Prog Rock bands. So, I went to that old cinema to watch this film, with a lot of "teenager enthusiasm". I liked the film a lot, so some days later I went to watch the film again.I think that even some years later I went to another cinema to watch the film again, and finally, in 2000 a Cultural TV channel in my city broadcasted the film for the first time on TV. So, now, my opinion about this film is not as favourale as the first time I watched to it, but, anyway, I still consider it as a good documentary about the history of this band done before Keith Moon`s death. It has some flaws: the clips are not shown in a chronological order. There is not really a narration of their history. So, it is more a visual documentary, with funny scenes and interviews, some TV appearances, and some songs played in concert, like in the Monterey and Woodstock Festivals and in other venues, some promotional films for songs like "Happy Jack", etc. Maybe the most interesting things in this film are the scenes of the band filmed during their last concert with Keith Moon which were filmed in May 1978, and also the scenes filmed during the recording of their "Who Are You" album during late 1977 and mid 1978. Humour also appears a lot in this film due to funny interviews with the members of the band, particularly with Keith Moon and Pete Townshed. Roger Daltrey and John Entwistle appear less time speaking in the film (a thing both of them didn`t like very much from this film, and they also said that they considered the film as "amateur"). As time has passed, I can see more clearly now these flaws, and it is very clear that Jeff Stein, the Director of the film, really was an amateur film maker then, being really a fan of the band who proposed to them to do this film. Another flaw (which I hope that it was repaired when preparing the film to be released on DVD) is that most songs are in a higher speed in the original film (a thing that didn`t happen in the soundtrack album of the same name).So, this film, while still been very good, is like a "collage" of unrelated scenes edited one after the other. Anyway, it still is very entertaining and funny. I hope one day to watch to the DVD version of this film.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

WARNING: Forum software upgrade in progress, login function maybe affected for some users during that time.

 Live at the Royal Albert Hall by WHO, THE album cover DVD/Video, 2000
3.78 | 8 ratings

BUY
Live at the Royal Albert Hall
The Who Proto-Prog

Review by Guillermo
Prog Reviewer

4 stars This concert video was recorded in November 2000 during a benefit concert, with The Who playing the songs with some guests in some songs. It is one of the last recorded appearances of John Entwistle (who died in June 2002) with the band, and it includes an excellent bass guitar solo section by him. This concert video is very good as shows the band playing very well, with a lot of energy. Particularly, the inclusion of Zak Starkey as drummer since 1996 improved the band a lot since Keith Moon`s death and in my opinion he has been the most adequate drummer for the band`s music style, playing in a similar way like Moon did with the band (he was in fact given some drums lessons during his childhood by Moon himself). The sound and images are very good, and it is maybe one of the best concerts I have seen from the band wiithout Keith Moon.The inclusion of John Bundrick as keyboard player also improved the band`s playing during the concerts. So, I think that this line-up of the band (Daltrey, Entwistle, Townshend, Starkey and Bundrick) was the best line-up since the death of Moon. The inclusion of guests in some songs was a good idea, bringing some variety to the playing of some songs. Their performances are good in general.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

WARNING: Forum software upgrade in progress, login function maybe affected for some users during that time.

 The Who at Kilburn: 1977 by WHO, THE album cover DVD/Video, 2008
3.67 | 7 ratings

BUY
The Who at Kilburn: 1977
The Who Proto-Prog

Review by Guillermo
Prog Reviewer

4 stars I knew about this Kilburn concert (the first DVD in this package) because I read about it in a book about The Who written by journalist Chris Welch. This concert was done and filmed with the aim to include some footage from it in "The Kids Are Alright" documentary film which was also done during that period (1977-78) by Jeff Stein. But unfortunately, the members of the band were not very satisfied with their performances in that concert (particularly Peter Townshend, who even shows some dislike from the band`s playing during the concert). At the same time, maybe it was a good idea to not release this video until recently because the modern technology which is available now maybe helped a lot to improve the sound and image of this concert video which is very good. But, I think that at the same time the band had at that time some real reasons to not include footage from this concert (apart from two very brief scenes when the band was not playing) in "The Kids Are Alright" film: they sound like they didn`t rehearse enough. Particularly Keith Moon`s playing shows some "doubts" in some places, like he really was having a hard time remembering how to play some songs. Also, his playing began showing the effects of the excesses in his lifestyle and the lack of practicing. In fact, this was the bands`first concert since mid 1976, and Moon was living in the U.S. then until the band called him to return to England to record the "Who Are You" album in late 1977. Another reason to not release this concert video in the seventies maybe was that they were a bit drunk while playing (I can see it!). But the performances of most songs are good, sometimes noisy and chaotic. Anyway, this is a very good concert video which shows the band playing with a lot of energy. They even played a bit of the "Who Are You" album title song in a somewhat improvised form (as I mentioned above, they were recording the "Who Are You" album then until mid 1978). To replace the live footage from the Kilburn concert in the "The Kids Are Alright" film, they played and filmed another concert in May 1978 at a film studio inviting (like in the Kilburn concert) some fans. The "The Kids Are Alright" film is a good film but most of the songs included in the original film (including the songs which were filmed in May 1978) suffer from a bit of high speed in their appearance and sound, and also for this reason the release of this Kilburn footage is much better than that film mostly in the presentation of the live performances. The performance of "My Wife" was the only live recording from the Kilburn concert which the band released in the "The Kids Are Alright" album, but in a bit edited form and with a different sound mixing (but i wasn`t included in that film). Even with all the flaws the Kilburn concert was much better than some of the later concerts which the band played after Moon died (particularly during their "Farewell Tour" in 1982).

The second DVD from this package shows the band playing the "Tommy" rock opera live almost in its entirety in 1969. It seems that some songs were not played for some reason, and the band plays it very well but obviosuly lacking the keyboards and horns which were recorded in the original studio album. The quality of this footage is not very good, sometimes dark, and it lacks in some places the images of the band filmed live and instead they show some still photos from the concert to replace the missing footage. Not as good as the Kilburn concert, but it was a good idea to include this footage in this DVD package as "Bonus Material".

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

WARNING: Forum software upgrade in progress, login function maybe affected for some users during that time.

 The Who at Kilburn: 1977 by WHO, THE album cover DVD/Video, 2008
3.67 | 7 ratings

BUY
The Who at Kilburn: 1977
The Who Proto-Prog

Review by Ivan_Melgar_M
Special Collaborator Symphonic Prog Specialist

4 stars THE WHO in a bad night were far better than 90% of the bands in their best day

I honestly can't understand the critics to this video, that's what THE WHO was...A force of nature that couldn't be stopped, if you want to see a polished clean 1977 show, buy a CAPTAIN & TENILLE concert, but if you want to see a band giving 110% of them even if not in shape and amazing material, this video is a must have.

Luckily I waited until the deluxe edition was released in Blu-Ray, because apart from the regular 1969 at the London Coliseum version, you get an extra bonus, the first-ever live recording of the rock opera Tommy featuring: "A Quick One While He's Away", "Overture", "It's a Boy ", "1921", "Amazing Journey," "Christmas," "Acid Queen," "Pinball Wizard," "Do You Think It's Alright," "Fiddle About", "Tommy Can You Hear Me?", "There's a Doctor", "Go to the Mirror", "Smash the Mirror", "Miracle Cure", "Sally Simpson", "Tommy's Holiday Camp", "I'm Free", "We're Not Gonna Take It."

I agree with Finnforest's comments about weak songs in the Kilburn concert like the infamous version of "Who are You", but "Baba O'Riley" "Behind Blue Eyes" and "Pinball Wizard" are as exciting as usual, and of course the hilarious version of "Tommy's Holyday Camp" with Keith singing completely out of key. So yes it has lows, but the whole concert is a collector's item that no WHO fan should avoid.

The image has been digitally restored (A few minutes are lost because of the rewinding of the 16 mms camera), the sound is great (avoid the dull Dolby Digital 5.1 mix, because the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and PCM 2.0 with boosted vocals are both excellent), so it's a piece of musical history in very good condition that every fan must get.

Ah, almost forgot the rating.........4 solid stars.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

WARNING: Forum software upgrade in progress, login function maybe affected for some users during that time.

Thanks to micky for the artist addition.

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — the ultimate jazz music virtual community | MetalMusicArchives.com — the ultimate metal music virtual community


Server processing time: 1.37 seconds